So what are the odds Sayaka's wish will be for us to notice/fall in love with her?
No idea, but I think it's a bit too fast since we have no idea if Kyousuke will be relevant in this story or not.

[x] Tell them
-[x] I come from the future to hunt the Devil.
-[x] I don't remember much beyond that.
-[x] Ask Kyuubey what does he mean with his magic not being typical.
 
...

[x] The Questing Beast
[x] Ask Kyuubey what does he mean your power is not typical.
 
Last edited:
Would Madoka make a contract to try and keep us safe if she found out we're her little brother?
Because if so, I can't help but reinforce that her discovering our identity could be added to a list i have titled 'Shit that means bad shenanigans are about to commence'
 
Would Madoka make a contract to try and keep us safe if she found out we're her little brother?
Because if so, I can't help but reinforce that her discovering our identity could be added to a list i have titled 'Shit that means bad shenanigans are about to commence'
Would not put it past her.
 
Would Madoka make a contract to try and keep us safe if she found out we're her little brother?
Because if so, I can't help but reinforce that her discovering our identity could be added to a list i have titled 'Shit that means bad shenanigans are about to commence'
That's a given, also she would not take it well to know that her younger brother will suffer in the future.
 
Yeah, Lets not reveal that. If she contracts, we have one of two problems incoming:
a) Kreimhild Gretchen
b) Homucifer, who is pissed off that we let Madoka contract.

Alternatively, I could be 100% wrong and there will be absolutely no negative repurcussions for this at all.
 
[X] Tell them...
-[X] EVERYTHING.

Breaking down and babbling out everything is very IC, and should help drive home the weight of what's going on here. If you've ever heard the beginning to "Rosetta Stoned" by Tool, that's a good guideline for the kind of tone I'm thinking of: too freaked out and terrified to possibly be lying.
 
Okay, I'm changing my vote to

[x] Tell them…
- [x] That you're from the future
- [x] That you made a deal of power
- [x] That you're hunting the Devil
- [x] That you can't remember much else
[x] Ask Kyuubey what does he mean your power is not typical.

We need to know as much as we can about our powers if we have to confront Homura in the future.

@Gardener
Again, we don't want our sister to have a freak out when we start acting like a mad man.

Edit: Thanks for the heads up Sayaka.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm changing my vote to

[x] The Questing Beast minus Tell them we are Madoka's brother.
And as an additional.
[x] Ask Kyuubey what does he mean your power is not typical.

We need to know as much as we can about our powers if we have to confront Homura in the future.
y'know, it would probably be better to just post your vote in full than do... that.
 
[x] Tell them…
-[x] That you're from the future.
-[x] That you're Tatsuya Kaname.
-[x] That you made a deal for power.
-[x] That you're hunting the Devil.
-[x] That you can't remember much else.
 
[x] Tell them…
-[x] That you're from the future.
-[x] That your Madoka's brother.
-[x] That you made a deal for power.
-[x] That you're hunting the Devil.
-[x] That you can't remember much else.
 
I refuse to make actions I don't like IC or OOC in the interests of "not metagaming".
Revealing who we are and our connection to Madoka (any of it) is one of those actions.

Honestly, revealing that connection is one of our best cards. No one trusts Homura because she's a complete outsider with uncomfortable truths. We really only benefit, save for the possibility of a Madoka contract, but if Homura can neutralize that with "I came here to protect you" then so can we.
 
[X] Tell them…
-[X] That you can't remember.

I still want to be the mysterious guy Totallynot!Archer.
 
Honestly, revealing that connection is one of our best cards. No one trusts Homura because she's a complete outsider with uncomfortable truths. We really only benefit, save for the possibility of a Madoka contract, but if Homura can neutralize that with "I came here to protect you" then so can we.
We will have to be careful to not create a Temporal Paradox with our younger us.
 
Back
Top