Magical Girl Raising Project Mafia Game
- Thread starter Andelevion
- Start date
- Mafia
-
- Tags
- fun times ahead mafia murder
Actually, with so many claims of innocence, allow me a crazy theory:
LDJ had a different color. Now we know the name means nothign and the color means something different.
What if LDJ was maf with Nanimani and JBJ was maf with BunnyLord? And stupidly took a hit from each other first night?
LDJ had a different color. Now we know the name means nothign and the color means something different.
What if LDJ was maf with Nanimani and JBJ was maf with BunnyLord? And stupidly took a hit from each other first night?
- Location
- The Surface Of A Hostile Planet
What's the "witch's" color? If it's the same as ours then that tone of purple is the "survivor" color.
- Location
- Central Standard Time
Or it's our mason color.
Other games have had separate mason colors.
Anon was first to declare a color with the color of Innocence.
@BunnyLord
Your power please. No way you're powerless in this giant mess.
- Location
- The Surface Of A Hostile Planet
True. Witch even has her own color in Town of Salem, IIRC.
On the other hand, if color is all the information we have, I sure hope that the color coding is at least good at carrying information, and each little slightly different group having a seperate color would go against that.
-CURRENT STATE OF GIANT MESS-
Me - ???
Anon - Redirect someone to another
Nanimani - Investigator, black or white
MrEgret - Roleblocker
Mortifer - Looker
Pawn Lelouch - One day self-guard, one day recharge
BunnyLord - ???
Redshirt Army - Plunder items for abiltiies
AlphaDelta - Silence
Bahn - Medium
Assembler - Protector
Me - ???
Anon - Redirect someone to another
Nanimani - Investigator, black or white
MrEgret - Roleblocker
Mortifer - Looker
Pawn Lelouch - One day self-guard, one day recharge
BunnyLord - ???
Redshirt Army - Plunder items for abiltiies
AlphaDelta - Silence
Bahn - Medium
Assembler - Protector
- Location
- The Surface Of A Hostile Planet
Yeah, BunnyLord obviously has an ability.
And I obviously have one as well, even if I don't need to declare it to save myself.
@Anon̦̦
At the very least, there's a quick way to see if my theory about two small maf groups is true. Especially since the more I look at my list, the more I ponder.
How about taking Nanimani and forcing him to 'watch' BunnyLord? If he's a killer or not, we'll see it.
The more I think about it, the more I find Nani's story strange... I mean, it all seems we havw powers related to our appearances and powers. Why not Nani? fishy as fuck.
I sure as hell no longer trust LDJ's color as innocent either. Meaning... there may not have been a lyncher after all. Especially if we have a pair of survivors.
[X] BunnyLord
Speak.
I sure as hell no longer trust LDJ's color as innocent either. Meaning... there may not have been a lyncher after all. Especially if we have a pair of survivors.
[X] BunnyLord
Speak.
@Mortifer
I suppose I may as well reveal my ability after BunnyLord speak... Would you mind watching me come next night? We can get @Assembler to protect you too, if he agree.
I'll definitely be a possible target once I reveal. You'll see why.
I suppose I may as well reveal my ability after BunnyLord speak... Would you mind watching me come next night? We can get @Assembler to protect you too, if he agree.
I'll definitely be a possible target once I reveal. You'll see why.
Mortifer
Embrace your inner lunatic. Fun times guaranteed.
- Location
- Under a rock.
I haven't picked my watch target just yet so unless a better pick comes along I'll agree to that in exchange for knowing your deepest darkest secret
Of course, considering BunnyLord, it will probably be after you wake up next. But I think you'll agree about me being a juicy target once I reveal.I haven't picked my watch target just yet so unless a better pick comes along I'll agree to that in exchange for knowing your deepest darkest secret
At anyr ate, if we get organized for tonight? Either the kill will be redirected and nullified... But in the event it pass? it will severely limit who could have done it.
On a side note, the 'Why do Megaolix believe in a crazy two teams of 2 mafs idea'.
Well, already, with three mason teams, it's no exactly a standard. But you know, now that our pair of survivors came out, we could now fully confirm that we are indeed all Magical Girls. But the colors matter. They matter a lot.
1 team of survivor, I can believe. Two teams of Masons on top of it and then mafia? Less so. But you know if I'm completely wrong here, then a 3-man team is hiding fucking well.
But the cleaner or whatever similar power died somehow. There's no reason to not have TPK's body vanish to murder any credibility I would have had.
And LDJ's color... Well, something is afoot. First night, either LDJ of JBJ was the cleaner. That's what I believe. We can never confirm because JBJ's body was vanished.
Nani was right to believe 3 masons was odd. So why not go up to 4? 1 neutral, 1 town, 2 mafs. Teams of two mafs may seem underpwoered a bit, but do take into account our survivor team's powers can easily be taken for hostile activity. Anon could have been taken as hostile given power. Tankdrop could have done lot of collateral damage with his power if he wasn't lynched first.
And Nani... you story doesn't hold up. I can believe you visited LDJ that first night. I'm having a harder time to believe you didn't believe GB was the tracker. And that you and 2 others killers all picked that in one night. Not only that, but that you stated your power was not related to you and your appearance... It smells. It smells a lot.
And if I have to doubt LDJ being innocent, then your claim that you found him Innocent comes into question. That Redshirt could not steal your power also add to the doubts.
@Mortifer
Would I be wrong assuming your power is used with a book? Mine myself is an umbrella. Fitting for I, Twirling Drip.
Well, already, with three mason teams, it's no exactly a standard. But you know, now that our pair of survivors came out, we could now fully confirm that we are indeed all Magical Girls. But the colors matter. They matter a lot.
1 team of survivor, I can believe. Two teams of Masons on top of it and then mafia? Less so. But you know if I'm completely wrong here, then a 3-man team is hiding fucking well.
But the cleaner or whatever similar power died somehow. There's no reason to not have TPK's body vanish to murder any credibility I would have had.
And LDJ's color... Well, something is afoot. First night, either LDJ of JBJ was the cleaner. That's what I believe. We can never confirm because JBJ's body was vanished.
Nani was right to believe 3 masons was odd. So why not go up to 4? 1 neutral, 1 town, 2 mafs. Teams of two mafs may seem underpwoered a bit, but do take into account our survivor team's powers can easily be taken for hostile activity. Anon could have been taken as hostile given power. Tankdrop could have done lot of collateral damage with his power if he wasn't lynched first.
And Nani... you story doesn't hold up. I can believe you visited LDJ that first night. I'm having a harder time to believe you didn't believe GB was the tracker. And that you and 2 others killers all picked that in one night. Not only that, but that you stated your power was not related to you and your appearance... It smells. It smells a lot.
And if I have to doubt LDJ being innocent, then your claim that you found him Innocent comes into question. That Redshirt could not steal your power also add to the doubts.
@Mortifer
Would I be wrong assuming your power is used with a book? Mine myself is an umbrella. Fitting for I, Twirling Drip.
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
And now for an effortpost.
Hey, guess what I was gonna do to the people that didn't unvote? Exactly what I did. Investigated those left alive. Well, two of the three, since they all survived, but I've only had two nights.
But yeah, remember that whole thing going on, with me wanting people voting for a pink mg on the block? You really think I'd have enough confidence to point that out if my name wasn't the same?
Like, why do you think I'm allied with LDJ? Me starting the bandwagon around people voting for Anon was one of the big reasons he revealed his role. Sure, you can say it's fake, but he wouldn't have had to come up with that if it wasn't for my antagonizing. The attention in that day is probably why he got ganked. I know you think I'm an idiot, Mega, but I'm not that stupid.
*Shrugs* My power really can't be verified, and I understand why you're suspicious. I would be too, if I were you. But there's no other sheriff, and I'm telling the truth about my role.
If we're on lylo, killing me loses us the game.
Redirect me at someone. Heck, make it the same person Assembler protects. Sure, maf will probably attack them too, given it's way too easy to frame, but I can at least tell you whether they're innocent or guilty. Yeah, I'm fully aware that if they're innocent, I'm probably going up, but again, I'm not lying. I'll tell the truth, whether you believe me or not.
I mean, I couldn't just say "Yes, I know some are innocent, some aren't because of my role", could I?
This was, in fact, the truth.
(Not sure if I got these in order, honestly. I did a lot of jumping around with the search function.)
Hey, guess what I was gonna do to the people that didn't unvote? Exactly what I did. Investigated those left alive. Well, two of the three, since they all survived, but I've only had two nights.
But yeah, remember that whole thing going on, with me wanting people voting for a pink mg on the block? You really think I'd have enough confidence to point that out if my name wasn't the same?
Like, why do you think I'm allied with LDJ? Me starting the bandwagon around people voting for Anon was one of the big reasons he revealed his role. Sure, you can say it's fake, but he wouldn't have had to come up with that if it wasn't for my antagonizing. The attention in that day is probably why he got ganked. I know you think I'm an idiot, Mega, but I'm not that stupid.
Hey look, an investigator concerned over a doc.
Should be self-explanatory.
More just telling the truth.I'm [Clawer Pawer], as you can probably tell by looking at the costume. Fun fact: Neither clawing nor pawing are mentioned anywhere in my PM except the name. Even the power bears no relation.
I think you can gather why I'd be worried about this?
It feels like a got a bit blatant here, but since no one picked it up, I guess not?
*Shrugs* My power really can't be verified, and I understand why you're suspicious. I would be too, if I were you. But there's no other sheriff, and I'm telling the truth about my role.
If we're on lylo, killing me loses us the game.
Redirect me at someone. Heck, make it the same person Assembler protects. Sure, maf will probably attack them too, given it's way too easy to frame, but I can at least tell you whether they're innocent or guilty. Yeah, I'm fully aware that if they're innocent, I'm probably going up, but again, I'm not lying. I'll tell the truth, whether you believe me or not.
Well, there is the fact that you're a Mafia veteran here, Nanimani. And I very much know myself that one of the first thing being agreed on in a mafia team is 'Don't agree with each other'.
Still, that I still have some doubts is why I go after @BunnyLord first.
Well, I suppose that for safety, I could always ask Anon to direct you at people like Assembler or Bahn (that Assembler would protect just in case), but I'm not sure how Mortifer would appreciate a night plan that leaves him defenseless.
Still, that I still have some doubts is why I go after @BunnyLord first.
Well, I suppose that for safety, I could always ask Anon to direct you at people like Assembler or Bahn (that Assembler would protect just in case), but I'm not sure how Mortifer would appreciate a night plan that leaves him defenseless.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
We could have Anon direct Bunnylord towards me, have Assembler give the vest to Mortifer, have Nanimani agree to visit me, and have Mortifer watch me again tonight. That way if there is only one kill tonight we know who one of the killers is and with Mortifer watching me we would know if Nanimani actually did visit me that night.
Doing this would allow us to figure out who is the killer is without worrying about the bait getting killed (since Assembler's vest only blocks one shot) while stilll protecting Mortifer. This still leaves us with 50-50 odds on figuring out who the killer is unless we lynch Bunnylord or Nanimani today but it's arguably the safest plan we can have. Speaking of that this seems like the right decision to me and we can modify the plan if we lynch one of them today to be simpler.
[X] Bunnylord
Doing this would allow us to figure out who is the killer is without worrying about the bait getting killed (since Assembler's vest only blocks one shot) while stilll protecting Mortifer. This still leaves us with 50-50 odds on figuring out who the killer is unless we lynch Bunnylord or Nanimani today but it's arguably the safest plan we can have. Speaking of that this seems like the right decision to me and we can modify the plan if we lynch one of them today to be simpler.
[X] Bunnylord
Once I reveal my role, you'll see why I want Mortifer watching me. But yes, that was the idea. Besides, if we lynch Bunny and Nani is redirected on you... Well, even if you don't catch wind that you were attacked because you were hiding, a lack of killing will look very bad for Nani.
That you said so yourself, however, makes me wonder if we should simply direct Nani on Assembler directly to vet that team if Nani happen to be legit.
Anyway, if BunnyLord refuse to speak, I'll simply wait for Mortifer ot be up before revealing my role.
Well, at this rate, we'll be lynching BunnyLord and we'll be asking you to direct Nanimani to either Pawn Lelouch or Assembler to check if Nani is actually a killer.
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
I'm honestly not sure myself. Currently in Florida, following a three hour plane ride and an effortpost, and not really wanting to work too hard right now.
I'll go investigate who people think I should, but I'm not really... Huh. If there're two two-man maf teams and a Neutral Mason, doesn't that mean Town doesn't have a majority? Even if we get the right person, I'm kinda scared of how it's happening. Depends on if JBJ was maf or not, I'd say.
- Location
- Central Standard Time
Either way, it doesn't matter.
It could be that the individual team has to have majority and not have the other scum team survive. That's pretty standard.