Magical Girl Raising Project Mafia Game

What's your opinion of the game so far?


  • Total voters
    27
Why those three specifically? I don't believe we have anything tying Bunnylord to them...?
Hum. Good point. If Bunny wasn't in a group, that'd mean Bahn was lying as well, but if he is, not much effort to "confirm" that. Would be pretty funny if Bunny was the SK and Bahn was the maf faking a Medium's powers, but that has absolutely no place in serious talk and is just me fantasizing to myself.

This doesn't actually change my conclusion vis a vis "Too many Masons, someone's lying", though.
 
Hum. Good point. If Bunny wasn't in a group, that'd mean Bahn was lying as well, but if he is, not much effort to "confirm" that. Would be pretty funny if Bunny was the SK and Bahn was the maf faking a Medium's powers, but that has absolutely no place in serious talk and is just me fantasizing to myself.

This doesn't actually change my conclusion vis a vis "Too many Masons, someone's lying", though.
Unless you're teh SK and Egret, Pawn and Mortifer are mafia anyway. And Andelevion expected more kills amongst pairs.

@Redshirt Army
By the way, the 'no more puzzle' apply to you. I gave a theory about your ability, but what the heck does your item detection ability actually do?
 
My power is unverifiable until I act to allow verification. I have not done so yet. I'm not going to reveal who I used my ability on as they are unable to verify today.

TPK flipping innocent was unexpected, and invalidated my plans for the night.

...I just want to get back to sleeping in peace. I'd also like my cousin to survive.

I have my priorities straight.


And Andelevion expected more kills amongst pairs.
Wait, what?
@Redshirt Army
By the way, the 'no more puzzle' apply to you. I gave a theory about your ability, but what the heck does your item detection ability actually do?
It gives the names of the [Item] that the target has, or [No Item] otherwise.

For example, it would be able to verify Assembler's Vest claim, as that is an item.

 
The fuck is that even useful for?

...Unless Killers have no Power symbolized in an item.
Nah; that would just make it a refluffed Investigator, I think.
...I just want to get back to sleeping in peace. I'd also like my cousin to survive.

I have my priorities straight.
"While I can sympathize with wanting to preserve the lives of your loved ones, I must ask: is your cousin liable to lash out at others? In this game, that could mean life or death, yes?"
 
"While I can sympathize with wanting to preserve the lives of your loved ones, I must ask: is your cousin liable to lash out at others? In this game, that could mean life or death, yes?"
Nope.

Neither of us have any intent to kill, just to eliminate those who would keep us from surviving together.
 
My power is unverifiable until I act to allow verification. I have not done so yet. I'm not going to reveal who I used my ability on as they are unable to verify today.
Nope. We DON'T have more time. If we lynch another innocent today and two more inncoents die at night, we fall to 8. If Mafia are 3 and there's indeed a SK, it's pretty much over for town.
 
Nope. We DON'T have more time. If we lynch another innocent today and two more inncoents die at night, we fall to 8. If Mafia are 3 and there's indeed a SK, it's pretty much over for town.
Well, it is literally impossible for verification until tomorrow, because of the way I applied my ability. Bad planning on my part :/

And this is very awkward, since I dug myself into this. Oops.


For everyone who is not the GM, Redshirt Army, and the person who I targeted, you will find out what happened N2 once this is over and laugh. Seriously. This is hilarious if you are in the know.


Person I targeted N2:
By any chance, do you have a close friend, or a relative that can verify me? Nobody has said anything yet, but I'd like to make sure.
 
"My name is [January], or at least it was, until I got pressured into revealing my role in this death game and then the people responsible for KILLING ME decided not to TAKE RESPONSIBILITY and protect me at night!"

I sigh and glance around at my... messy body. "Fucking morons. My teenage daughter has more sense than you lot. 'Let's let the woman with the tracking ability die because we left her unguarded'. Pah."
 
Well, it is literally impossible for verification until tomorrow, because of the way I applied my ability. Bad planning on my part :/

And this is very awkward, since I dug myself into this. Oops.


For everyone who is not the GM, Redshirt Army, and the person who I targeted, you will find out what happened N2 once this is over and laugh. Seriously. This is hilarious if you are in the know.


Person I targeted N2:
By any chance, do you have a close friend, or a relative that can verify me? Nobody has said anything yet, but I'd like to make sure.
Yes, you've stated it's impossible to verify, we know.

It's also impossible to verify my ability unless I actually catch someone guilty with it. Doesn't stop me from telling people when I think it'd help.
 
I'm honestly not sure what role would require a night of prep time, is easily vertifiable, and specifically works well with an investigator.
 
I'm honestly not sure what role would require a night of prep time, is easily vertifiable, and specifically works well with an investigator.

Cards fully on the table.

My ability isn't just to investigate [Items] - it's to steal them, gaining the ability to use them. Me and AlphaDelta are both [Magical Girls] (yes, in that color) with the Survivor wincon.

AlphaDelta's ability is to prevent his target from speaking about a certain topic, silencing them for one day. He used this ability on the person I was going to rob yesterday, to prevent them from speaking about the night events that occured to them yesterday.

As a result, the person he used his ability on is literally incapable of verifying. Hoist by his own petard indeed.
 
Cards fully on the table.

My ability isn't just to investigate [Items] - it's to steal them, gaining the ability to use them. Me and AlphaDelta are both [Magical Girls] (yes, in that color) with the Survivor wincon.

AlphaDelta's ability is to prevent his target from speaking about a certain topic, silencing them for one day. He used this ability on the person I was going to rob yesterday, to prevent them from speaking about the night events that occured to them yesterday.

As a result, the person he used his ability on is literally incapable of verifying. Hoist by his own petard indeed.
I'm honestly not sure what role would require a night of prep time, is easily vertifiable, and specifically works well with an investigator.

The hilarious part?

@Megaolix is the one who I quieted.

*Yawn*

Now, if you'll excuse me, it's time for my nap.

Zzzzzzzzz
 
Fun how you don't step into the Mafia accusation here.

Mainly because of the fact that I can't prove myself until someone investigates me because I can't visit anyone else or gather information that can be verified. I was hoping that TPK or one of the other investigative roles would check me N2 but TPK was killed and Nanimani was investigating TPK that night.

There's also the fact that it's a lot harder to pin down a mafia member than a SK because there is only one SK to three mafia. If a person is confirmed to have not killed one night then they are confirmed to not be the SK if there was two kills that night. It's not the same for the mafia because generally all three members have a kill they can use and other abilities along with that.

This means they can switch out who is killing based on what ability would be useful to use that night and how much heat any particular member has which makes it harder to clear people so I didn't really talk about that. I thought I had the SK spot narrowed down not the mafia ones. Even that isn't as concrete as I thought because with the reveal of there being three mason pairs Bahn and Bunnylord are more suspicious than before because the odds of one of the mason groups having a liar is high.

We heard you about the SK, but how about more about yourself?

Already said what I can do. I choose to use my power and any night that I activate that power I'm immune to getting night killed. However, since I'm a pretty new magical girl doing that tires me out and I can't do it the following night. *Sees AlphaDelta's and Redshirt army's posts* Huh, that explains why I have the town color and wincon. I was wondering about that.
 
I saw you looking. Get over there and speak out already.

I just woke up and this is the first post I've made on the forum since getting up, give me time to be actually able to think properly before you make me talk, I haven't even had breakfast or coffee yet
 
Cards fully on the table.

My ability isn't just to investigate [Items] - it's to steal them, gaining the ability to use them. Me and AlphaDelta are both [Magical Girls] (yes, in that color) with the Survivor wincon.

AlphaDelta's ability is to prevent his target from speaking about a certain topic, silencing them for one day. He used this ability on the person I was going to rob yesterday, to prevent them from speaking about the night events that occured to them yesterday.

As a result, the person he used his ability on is literally incapable of verifying. Hoist by his own petard indeed.
Ah, third parties. Okay, I can believe that.
Unvote AlphaDelta
At any rate...
Yeah, targets are growing few, ain't they?
[X] Vote Mortifer
 
Ah, third parties. Okay, I can believe that.
Unvote AlphaDelta
At any rate...
Yeah, targets are growing few, ain't they?
[X] Vote Mortifer

Okay, I've got some bread next to me, time to talk.

I really don't want to talk about my power, for three reasons, but I'm on the sus list right now so I'll talk, I guess.

But let's try introductions, then?

Hi, I'm Seelie. I like fairy tales. All sorts, from Little Red Riding Hood, to the myths about fairies of the two courts in which I get my Magical Girl names. I like stories. Stories are great.

I might like them a little too much, to be honest, because my power lets me watch your stories unfold. I'll explain more, but yes, I'm an investigative-ish role.

See, I didn't want to reveal this for three reasons, remember? First is that my power's already really close to someone elses power. TPK's power allowed them to watch someone, and see who they visit. Mine's the mirror of that. I observe your destiny and see who visits you that night. After TPK revealed, I didn't want to, in case people got suspicious of the overlap. Well, they're suspicious now anyway, so...

Well, point is, TPK also bleeds into the second reason I didn't want to reveal. I'm the Lookout. I see who visits who. If I pick the right person, I basically know who's responsible for a kill. That's devastating if I get lucky. TPK had a similar power, and SK and Maf both killed them last night.

So yeah good luck have fun I look forward to being dead next night phase :V

Oh, and I can hear you already, asking for verification. That's the problem. I can't. I've picked wrong and nobody I've watched has been visited. That's why I didn't want to reveal yet from the start, though the other two reasons came to me later. I wanted to be able to confirm it with valuable information. Night 1, I tried to watch Nanimani, got redirected to Redshirt, and nobody else visited. Night 2, I watch Pawn Lelouch, nobody visits them.

So yep. That's me. A Magical Girl who likes her fairy tales and wants to see this one unfold, but who hasn't been able to play a part in it yet. I don't have any useful information to come out with, but I should be able to verify my role if I get lucky with my pick tonight. Assuming you guys trust this answer enough to let me make it that far.
 
Sorry about the silence but I got my eyes dilated yesterday so it took a bit of time for them to clear up enough to be able to read properly today.

With the information thats been gathered I think I've figured out who the SK is or at least who has the best odds of being them.

Anon - Confirmed power use N1 and N2 so can't be the SK.
Assembler - Roleblocked on N1 so can't be the SK.
Megaolix - Confirmed to have stayed indoors N1 so can't be the SK.
Mortifer - Redirected by Anon N1 so can't be the SK.
MrEgret - Confirmed power use N1 so can't be the SK.
Redshirt Army - Redirected by Anon N2 so can't be the SK.

Alphadelta - Claims his power is actively detrimental to town and didn't use it. However, there is no proof of this because if you aren't going to use your power then what's the point in hiding it? The lack of knowledge of this detrimental power coupled with no information on your night actions basically makes you a ghost compared to the other players because even Nanimani revealed their night actions even though they seem fairly incriminating.
Bahn - Confirmed to be on a team with Assembler but has only given information that is obvious or already stated. Possible SK like in one of the idol games but unlikely.
Bunnylord - Confirmed to have been on a team with JBJ by Bahn and his own words. Possible SK like in one of the idol games but unlikely.
Nanimani - Claims investigator but both of their investigative targets are dead. I'd say that this is the SK but Redshirt didn't find anything incriminating item wise N2 and the fact that Nanimani admitted to investigating both of those targets lowers my suspicions.
Pawn Lelouch - Frankly I can't prove myself until someone investigates me so I'm stuck on this list for now.

So the most suspect player here is Alphadelta with me, Bahn, Bunnylord, and Nanimani being the other potential SK players with all of the other players cleared.

Alphadelta > Nanimani > Pawn Lelouch > Bahn = Bunnylord (Pretty much cleared but not 100%)

Alrighty-roo.
So the thing here is that obviously, I believe myself. I can understand why you wouldn't, which is why I'll quote all the hints I dropped... probably tomorrow, as it's getting late, but I have to eliminate myself from the list.
We can assume the SK isn't colluding with anyone, so we can wipe away those who claimed masons which were confirmed. Crossing out them and me from the list...
Pawn Lelouch - Frankly I can't prove myself until someone investigates me so I'm stuck on this list for now.
Like, unless we've got an idol game thing going on, there's only really one person it could be.
Mind, the fact that they're the one who brought it up in the first place makes me think I'm gonna wake up to five votes on me, but it's the only thing that makes sense from my perspective.
 
Back
Top