[Mafia] Scarlet Hand Finale

He claims to have a kill.
If it's just that, and he'll be a vanilla after he uses it, then it doesn't make sense to kill him if he's just gonna make the kill tonight and end up a vanilla. So they might not do it. As it stands we should probably wait to lynch meso for one night. @mesonoxian I'd ask you to reveal your kill flavor so we can tell your kill apart. We don't really gain anything from lynching them today.
 
Well well well. Nice shooting, @ondine. Extension is lucky too, at least for me - I'm gonna have to leave for a bit now but at least I won't be missing EoD.

Yes, at this point I do believe all value is gone from it.

My power was town tracker.

From the fact that you didn't reveal earlier I assume you didn't find anything of value N1?
Flavor seems to match the kill flavor for Nictis. Do people agree?

Nah, Nictis's kill flavor was green. ondine's was white, though, so that's some evidence of her having died to a Soul. Maybe NANOOK got to take a shot after all?
 
If it's just that, and he'll be a vanilla after he uses it, then it doesn't make sense to kill him if he's just gonna make the kill tonight and end up a vanilla. So they might not do it. As it stands we should probably wait to lynch meso for one night. @mesonoxian I'd ask you to reveal your kill flavor so we can tell your kill apart. We don't really gain anything from lynching them today.
He already did.
 
Hi, I will attempt to blitz through this game so that I am a functioning member of whatever faction I am (have not looked at the PM yet). So uh be gentle, I've read basically just Cyric's posts, before replacing in. :V
 
Also for the record I would still bee reeling over this as Town, so you aren't vindicated at all because I'm scum. Really shitty play and I will maintain that until the end of time.

The Mafia gods fucking have it out for me

Chill dude. We'll chat about it in the post game and there were very legitimate issues with this play from ondine. And no, I'm not saying that due to my alignment, this was objectively bad play due to how ondine handled it in regards to rushing and her reasoning/arguments being muddled.

Don't get angry and make the thread toxic though. It isn't worth it.
 
Chill dude. We'll chat about it in the post game and there were very legitimate issues with this play from ondine. And no, I'm not saying that due to my alignment, this was objectively bad play due to how ondine handled it in regards to rushing and her reasoning/arguments being muddled.

Don't get angry and make the thread toxic though. It isn't worth it.
I'm just overly irritated about this and general history playing here right now. I'm done posting anyways so I'll take time to cool off.
 
Quick question has my position made any claims that I should be aware of at this time? Because they are totally true, and I agree with them in full, now what are they?
 
So I was right. They did have a magic user! Anyhow, good job ondine.

Also, ComiTurtle, good luck! :D
 
I actually did find something of value night 1. I tracked pawn, he didn't move, and then I didn't think he was acting like a vanilla. It wasn't enough on its own to get me to lynch him, but it's the reason I started looking at his posts more closely, which did end up in me lynching him.
 
I actually did find something of value night 1. I tracked pawn, he didn't move, and then I didn't think he was acting like a vanilla. It wasn't enough on its own to get me to lynch him, but it's the reason I started looking at his posts more closely, which did end up in me lynching him.

...

QT, when I say life is getting in the way of posting I mean it. My activity isn't a indicator of power role or alignment for me.
 
If we're playing to all the Hero tropes there should be 5 scum, so 3 left? Does that fit the player count?

So the 5 man band is more a mythological trope, I'd assume more likely we're in DnD tropes, which is a 4-man band (Thief, Warrior, Priest, Magic-User). Though both are reasonable numbers in a 19 player game 5 pushes towards less likely 3rd party roles, but I'm not sure how to rate the living past death thing that townies have (do scum have that too?).
 
...

QT, when I say life is getting in the way of posting I mean it. My activity isn't a indicator of power role or alignment for me.
No, that wasn't it. You're active as a power role to, and as scum; I should know, I've been scum with you before.

Rather, what happened was:
1. I noticed you didn't move
2. You weren't giving me vanilla signals
3. I went through your posts, and determined that i was pretty sure you were scum.
4. I backfilled post count into my reasons, because I was still not telling what my power role was.
 
So the 5 man band is more a mythological trope, I'd assume more likely we're in DnD tropes, which is a 4-man band (Thief, Warrior, Priest, Magic-User). Though both are reasonable numbers in a 19 player game 5 pushes towards less likely 3rd party roles, but I'm not sure how to rate the living past death thing that townies have (do scum have that too?).
Yes they do, Pawn and Rosen are dead Scum.
 
Okay, does -Rosen dying change feelings on Meso or me? I'm pretty unconvinced scum would go that far to drive a lynch for town on Meso, so it's got me looking a lot more generously than I was before there.

Happery being subbed also counters most any read there I think. It was just a player having a hard time engaging which is sad and I hope @happery wasn't too burned by the pressure on that, which leaves 1K, Underling and Deathvon of the inactive players of which I'm suspicious.

Meanwhile, I'm more suspect of @Tykan than I was before.


Hi, I will attempt to blitz through this game so that I am a functioning member of whatever faction I am (have not looked at the PM yet). So uh be gentle, I've read basically just Cyric's posts, before replacing in. :V
Is the color green? I'm happy to help explain for you in-thread if it is!
 
Back
Top