[x] Save the girl. A hero always saves everyone!
I'm wondering if the "Shiny" option would simply make us back into the overlord? Note that it doesn't say that "This isn't right" or something along those lines. It's saying "this isn't you". In this case, what isn't us? Someone who's compassionate, and cares for others? Somebody who would answer a cry for help? I absolutely disagree with the shiny, simply because of what effect it may have - if it'd undo the good that the character that learned, the person that could befriend a hero and overcome his nature, I absolutely won't agree to it.