Yes,Red Sun is dumb for the sake of having what is effectively a Stalinist superman punching it out ideologically with President Luthor.(I hope you remember who won there)
He said it was just a normal famine soner.
The comic has Supes keeping everything socialist and like all socialists otl never trying to transition to communism while somehow the whole world just joins an increasingly dystopian USSR ignoring plausibility and Luthor somehow allows that to happen.
Not necessarily,he could probably make planned economy work with Kryptonian tech but the effect would be very similar.
Why would the capitalist powers attack Russia beyond the propaganda.
Because the existence of any form of socialism, especially at that developed a stage, presents an existential threat to capitalism due to its global nature.
1-If humanity is that evil then it deserved to die.
1. No
If you need opresion to stop the capitalists from oppressing you then what is the point.
The point is achiveing global communism. That's not possible so long as the bourgeoisie exist as a class. Once global socialism has been achieved the bourgeoisie as a class will become impossible, as the means of production are out of their hands, and the transitionary state, no longer having a function, shall wither away
The party under Vanguardism literally is at best bourgeoisie(They literally exist as a clear ruling class unlike the capitalists that just exhort uniqual influence on the government).
But what about the alien capitalist that could invade any day now and internal dissent from the eternal revisionists/traitor/reactionary.
Well we don't exactly know what Supermans vision of what actual communism is. Just because we live in a capitalistic society today, doesn't mean its what the founding fathers would've wanted. So it isn't what Lenin wanted, but what Superman wants after blowing Stalins brains out.
If it involves any level of centralized planning Superman will STILL have to answer "How many X do Y people need?". And that's a question that's nearly impossible to answer on a broad level. Using my prior example, Plates, let's say the government makes the reasonable assumption of dishes being washed at least once a day and plans for 5 plates per person to account for dishes being washed at different times. What happens when an individual is unusually clumsy and regularly breaks plates?
"realistic"+"communist"+"Superman"
It's hard when most of the thread doesn't understand the basics of communism, something there supposedly planning to write about
We know the basics of communism. We disagree about the priority levels a Paragon would have.
I don't see how establishing worldwide communism isn't priority #1 for any idealistic communist leader
Because being imperialist doesn't mesh with actually wanting to achieve communism.
