I didn't say they had Minotaurs, I said they had Ogre's and Troll's which had tough skin.
And then pointed out that the only example of "Tough Skin" we had on a magical creature was with the Minotaur. And just what it's skin was shown to be capable of standing up to.
Sorry if I wasn't clear enough.
That is worse Vaermina. That is like saying, I heard that boiling water and magma are both hot. Then I heard that magma is hot enough to instantly char someone. So hot water and hot magma both instantly char someone who touches them.
I can also describe both a 6'2" man and a 12' Ogre as big. That does not mean that the man is as tall as the ogre.
I can describe salsa and H2SO4 (sulfiric acid) as acidic. That does not mean that both will eat through flesh in minutes.
Do you see where your assumptions are a problem?
Edit: I actually use the "ad absurdem" argument to disprove things. As I show above, what you were doing was trying to use an "ad absurdem" argument as proof of truth.
Last edited: