Even after the reboot, I'm still trapped in the wrong anime!

[Yzarc]

[X] Darkness
[X] a club

 

[ChildishChimera]

[X] Wood
Wood is underutilized and gets almost no love
[X] a yo-yo?
Show them the power of mans most unexpected weapon

 

[RookDeSuit]

[X] Thunder
[X] a club

 

[Driliviel]

[x] Darkness
[x] a blade

 

[White Lantern]

[X] Darkness
[X] a club

Yeeeesssd

 

[J.I.M.S]

[X] Darkness
[X] Your fists



I like the idea of a really swole trainer. Perhaps pillar man posing, having a Armstrong sparkle to their face, and bitter pill training (painful training montage) with their partner who makes magical girls mistake them for bad guys.

 

[James Birdsong]

[X] Water
[X] a yo-yo?

 

[Raphael]

[X] Darkness
[X] a yo-yo?

 

[Cornix Argentus]

[X] Wood

[X] a yo-yo?

 

[WildCardFool]

[X] Darkness
[X] Your fists

The answer here is to clearly be as anti-magical girl as possible. Not like, hating magical girls, but just in standing out. I know nowadays lots of magical girls use their fists, but still, for the most part this runs against the grain. And Darkness but not like... DARKNESS y'know?

 

[Valkyrien]

I don't really care about the element I just want us to have a yo-yo

 

[Ashmaker]

[X] Light
[X] Moon
[X] Fate
[X] Wind
[X] Earth
[X] Wood
[X] Fire
[X] Water
[X] Metal

By your powers combined, I am Captain Exalted reference!

More seriously, are write-ins for elements and weapons allowed, @Thozmp?

[X] a club
[X] a sling
[X] a yo-yo?

I'll have to give it some more thought, but right now I'd be happy with any of these. Club could let us join the school baseball club and sling or yo-yo are rarely seen.

 

[Enmascarado]

[x] Metal

[X] a yo-yo?

Ok hear me out, have you ever hear of a show called: Beyblade?

 

[SpacePaladin]

[X] Metal
[X] a club

Let's bring down the hammer

 

[Kanata.EXE]

[X] Darkness
[X] Your fists

So... Mon and Kamen won.

... Are we in Kamen Rider Ryuki? Kamen Rider Ryuki is a combination of tokusatsu and mon genre. Though, the monster is not loyal and they will eat you.

 

[Silor]

[X] Wind
[X] Metal
[X] Thunder

[X] a yo-yo?

 

[Enmascarado]

... Are we in Kamen Rider Ryuki? Kamen Rider Ryuki is a combination of tokusatsu and mon genre. Though, the monster is not loyal and they will eat you.

Click to shrink...

The mon/kamen setting is from where the MC originates.

Right now they're in Magical Girl land.

 

[llat-2]

[X] Metal
[X] Your fists

 

[Paloneia]

[X] Darkness
[X] a club

 

[Verdom]

[X] Metal
[X] a yo-yo?

@Thozmp is the write-in acceptable?
Edit1- changed vote from [X] Beyblade to [] a yo-yo? due to getting vetoed by qm

 

[GoDisDEaD]

[x] Darkness
[x] a blade

 

[Pi In The Sky]

[X] Thunder
[X] Your fists

Only trust your fists and your mon.

 

[drexal15]

[X] Darkness
[X] Your fists

 

[Enmascarado]

You guys realize that if the MC ends with darkness powers, they will probably become the edgy mysterious character that the main magical girl wants to redeem, right?

I'm just saying.

 

[Fluffy_serpent]

[x] Darkness
[x] a blade