Many thanks to @DemiRapscallion and @BinaryApotheosis for betareading and fact-checking.
-x-x-x-
Simple Answers
-x-x-x-
"Thou summonedst me, mother?"
"I did, Daughter. Art thou prepared for thy meeting with the Fingers?"
"As prepared as I might be, not knowing what I ought to expect."
"Art thou afraid?"
"Afraid? Nay. Nervous, perhaps."
"'Tis understandable. Dost thou hope to be named Empyrean?"
"Nay. My siblings are Empyreans enough for these lands. Methinks I should prefer to be a more ordinary demigod."
"…"
"Mother?"
"…Thy humility doth thee credit, Daughter."
-x-x-x-
The sun's set by the time we slip out of Stormveil's front gate. I poke my head in the gatehouse, but the gatekeeper—Gostoc, I think his name was?—seems to have abandoned his post. Under the circumstances, I can't say I blame him.
We make camp at the Site of Grace on the hill leading up to the castle, where Rogier and I fought Margit… Traveler, was that just this morning? Or did an entire night go by while we were exploring that I didn't notice? It wouldn't be the first time, especially since I left Sol—different solar cycles make it hard to keep track of the days. I was on a planet just a month and a half ago—Earth reckoning, to be clear—that had days that were only half an Earth hour long. It was rotating so fast it was hard to even land on.
The big lion lays down with its chin on its paws beside me while we bed down for the night. Trinovar takes off his armor to sleep—underneath it he's wearing a padded black gambeson, and under that he's in a shirt and trousers that might have been pretty fancy at one point, but by now look like they've seen better days. His face is solidly built—square-jawed, with cropped golden hair and a bit of stubble on his chin. His eyes are pale blue, but flicker faintly golden in the Erdtree's light.
I keep the first watch. Rogier takes over for me after that, and Trinovar takes the last watch before morning. Melina apologizes, but points out that she can't shake us awake if something happens. Which is a fair point, even if it clearly hurts her to have to make it.
Over breakfast the next morning—Rogier and Trinovar both have some rations with them, and they share them with the big cat while Melina feeds Torrent what looks like raisins—we talk.
"We have a mount now," says Trinovar, gesturing to the lion while it savages a helping of some sort of pemmican. "And it might, perhaps, be capable of carrying two of us."
"I'm heavier than the average human," I say. "And so are you, with your armor. Two of Rogier, sure. But if it's Rogier and one of us, I'm not so sure."
Trinovar nods. "This is entirely possible," he agrees.
"One of you could ride Torrent," Melina says.
"Nope," I say. I look the lion up and down. "Trinovar, does it have a name?"
"Not one that I have heard," says the Crucible Knight. "I doubt it, to tell you true. Godrick seldom interacted with the creature, to my knowledge, and never with the sort of kindness thou hast shown it."
I glance under the lion's tail. "Him."
"As thou sayest."
I consider the big cat, which is playing with a small boulder, beating it back and forth between its powerful paws. "I think I'll call you Rufus," I decide.
Rufus looks up at me, blinking his big, yellow eyes. I ruffle his mane, then turn back to the group. "I say we head down to that encampment the mercenaries told us about yesterday. Hopefully they'll have a horse we can buy off them. If not, we can figure something else out there. Part of me still wants to go back north once we're across the river, hit that village the mercenaries mentioned—Summonwater, I think they called it."
"To do battle with the Mariner?" Rogier asks.
"I don't plan on shooting first," I say. "But you can bet your britches I'll shoot last."
Trinovar chuckles as he affixes his helmet. "Summonwater is very near the border with Caelid," he says. "It is on our way in any case."
"Then that's the plan," I say. "We'll head down the hill, meet the mercenaries, try to buy a horse off them. Once we have another horse—whether we get it from there or elsewhere—we'll cross the river and head north to Summonwater. From there, east to Caelid."
"And then southeast to Castle Redmane," finishes Rogier. "To do battle with your second Shardbearer."
"Assuming Radahn won't listen to reason," I interject.
"A safe assumption," Melina says. Knowing what I do about her now, the small frown on her face looks unbearably sad.
We start down the hill. A pack of wolves scatters as we approach, especially after Rufus lets out a roar in their direction. The Gate of Storms isn't
quite unmanned—there's still a few soldiers camped in the shadow of the large towers, but they make like the wolves and run when they see us. Can't say I blame them.
"So," I say once we're through the gate, the old village's ruins laid out in front of us. "Any idea where that encampment is?"
"Perhaps there?" Melina says, pointing at a small copse of trees north of the road. "I see smoke rising."
I squint.
Maybe I can see what she's talking about? It's fuzzy and indistinct in the daylight. I hadn't even noticed it, and even if I had I'd have assumed it was fog. "You have damn good eyes, sweetheart," I say. "Uh. Eye, I mean. Sorry."
She chuckles. "I am not offended. But that is likely some sort of encampment, though I cannot say whether it is the one the Kaiden mercenaries mentioned to us."
"Worth investigating," I say. "Come on."
We follow the road through the ruins, then turn left, heading for the trees. Now that we're a little closer, I can see the smoke Melina pointed out clearly. It's not coming from the trees, actually, but from a small, fortified encampment behind them, built in the shadow of another of those big chunks of fallen masonry that I've seen scattered around.
All of a sudden, I make the connection between the vision I had in the shadow of the Divine Tower and the chunks of marble I've seen all over the Lands Between. They're chunks of the city in the sky—the city that the golden star hit on its way to the Erdtree. Farum Azula. It didn't make sense that they're all over the place, regardless of whether they resemble any of the ruins around them or if there even
are ruins around them. I've been letting it slide because I've got bigger things to worry about, but this… this makes sense.
And although it's far from confirmation of anything about my death-visions, it's a good sign. It means that whatever's trying to contact me through my impromptu thanatonautics is at least offering
some kind of explanation for some of the things I'm seeing that don't make any sense. Whether that explanation is
true, well, too early to say.
As we approach the encampment, a shout goes up. A moment later, a man in the same armor as the mercenaries we encountered yesterday rides out of the wooden gate. A heavy, curved sword, five feet long if it's an inch, is hanging from one hand while the other grips the reins of his charger. He gallops towards us, raising his sword, but when he gets about halfway he suddenly tugs the reins and turns slightly to bring his horse to a sudden stop. I'm not sure whether it's because he saw whatever marker the Rune of Binding leaves on me, or because he saw all of us reaching for our weapons.
"Shardbearer!" he calls, sounding wary. His head turns, taking us all in—Trinovar with his sword half-raised, Rogier with his staff glowing, me with my rifle cocked, and Rufus with his hackles up. Melina's the only one of us who doesn't look squared for a fight. "So it is true, then. Lord Godrick is dead."
"Yep," I say. "We ran into a couple of Kaidens up the hill. We were wondering if we could talk to a Captain… Ivan?"
"Ivar," Winchester corrects, popping into being over my shoulder.
"Ivar," I continue, "about buying a horse?"
The man considers me for a long moment. His face is mostly hidden by the cloth mask under his helmet, but his black eyes glitter in the late morning sunlight. "I am Lieutenant Sigurd," he says. "One of our band's only two remaining horsemen. Captain Ivar shall not be parted from his steed, and I'll not part from mine without his approval."
"Then can we talk to him?" I ask.
"Wait here," he says, then turns his horse and canters back into the encampment.
So wait we do. I lean back against a tree, folding my arms across my chest. After a moment, Melina spurs Torrent over to me, until she looms over me from his saddle.
"Something wrong?" I ask her.
"No," she says. "Though I confess, I am concerned that these mercenaries would command a Shardbearer to wait like an errand-boy."
I grimace. "Better that than the alternative. I've got this Great Rune because I need to it do what I have to. I'm not a demigod, not in contention for the Elden Ring, and don't want to be. I don't need their worship."
"Perhaps not," says Melina, "but surely you are owed their respect?"
"Maybe. Doesn't really bother me."
"I can see that." She looks down at me with an unreadable expression in her face. "Why not?"
"Hm?"
"I have never known someone of your power not to crave respect. Not to feel it is owed to him, nor to resent it when he feels it is withheld. Your outlook on the world is wholly different from the warriors and magicians I have known. In the abstract, I understand that it is because your home, and your history, are so different from my own. But I would like to understand the details. What is it that made Barrett-12 so much more humble than any hero or knight of the Lands Between?"
I consider the question. "Don't think there's a simple answer to that. It's my whole life. You're asking me to point out why I am who I am. I can't give you an answer that's any shorter than the centuries that made me into that person."
She hums softly. "I suppose not," she says. "That should, perhaps, be an end to such questions."
"Should?"
"I still wish to understand," she murmurs. "Everyone is the product of all the years of their lives. But not everyone fascinates me as you do, Barrett."
"Aw, shucks, sweetheart. You're gonna make me blush." I say it like a joke, but only because Exos can't blush to begin with. If we could, I think I would be.
To my surprise, though, she actually
does. Just a little. "I—that is not my intent. I merely…" She hesitates. The silence between us stretches, punctuated by the rustle of the wind in the trees. I notice that Rogier and Trinovar are giving us some space, talking between themselves a couple dozen paces away. "My mind circles endlessly back to a certain hypothetical," she says finally. "I cannot help but wonder what the world would look like if you had arrived a few centuries sooner. If you had been there when I was small. If my family could have met you—have learned from your example, as I feel I already am. If you had been there the night I was…"
She trails off, but I have a sick feeling that I know where that sentence was going. "I'm sorry I wasn't," I say quietly. "I don't know the story, Melina, and I'm not going to pry. But I wish I could have been here to help. To prevent whatever happened."
"Even if it was necessary?" Melina asks, voice soft and tired. "Even if my blackened bones protected the world for a few years longer?"
"Did you volunteer?"
"No. Perhaps I should have."
"Absolutely not," I say firmly. "A world that would burn a girl alive just to keep itself going a little longer is one that doesn't deserve to keep spinning."
"And yet there are innocents in these lands," Melina counters. "Children who have never known any world but the chaos of the Shattering. Parents whose only crime was ignorance or impotence. What right have I to bemoan my lot, if my sacrifice gave them their lives?"
"Doesn't seem like their lives have been all that delivered to me," I say. "I'm not saying that this world deserves to be
purged. Not at all. I'm saying that there has to have been a better way."
"Why should there be?" Melina asks. "The world is not kind."
"The world isn't a person. It's as kind as we are—and as cruel."
"Do you really believe it to be that simple?"
Yes, is the honest answer, but there's an edge to her voice. I don't want to make her feel like I'm trivializing her sacrifice, or questioning the story she's told herself about why it was necessary. So I take a step back. "I don't know what the world looked like when that happened to you," I say after taking a moment to think. "It's possible that, by that point, there really
wasn't anything better to be done. Maybe by that point things had gone too far for too long, and there weren't any good options left. I'm not a kinderguardian anymore, I know that sometimes things just don't work out. But the thing about those sorts of bad situations is that they were always set in motion a long time ago. No one ever takes just one step and finds them in a situation where all their choices are bad. It always takes more than one mistake, whether on the part of one person or the whole society.
"Maybe what happened to you really was necessary. Maybe there was no better choice. But if that's the case, that doesn't mean we have to settle for that. All it means is that we can start building a world,
now, where that kind of choice
isn't necessary anymore."
"How?" she whispers.
I reach up and put my hand on Torrent's mane, just a couple inches below her own hands on his reins. It's the closest I can come to touching her without passing straight through. "That's the question," I say. "If there's a simple answer, then anyone who knows it ain't telling." I remember the Speaker and his sermons about the Traveler's silence.
The best voices… "My best guess, so far, is that if we just keep asking, and keep being kind to each other, that it'll work itself out eventually."
"I wish I had your faith."
"Faith ain't a thing you have, sweetheart. It's a choice you make. Hope is where we plant our flag."
She looks down at me, eye slightly wide, lips slightly parted. "Barrett—"
"Shardbearer!" The voice snaps out from the entrance to the camp. I glance over to see two men riding out towards us. One is Sigurd, the other is a slightly taller man in similar armor, though his has blue trim along the edges. "I am Captain Ivar, leader of this warband. I am told you wish to purchase a horse from us."
"If you're willing to part with one," I say, pulling my hand away from Torrent and standing up. Rogier and Trinovar approach, apparently deciding that she and I don't need privacy for haggling. "If not, I'd be grateful for a hint on who might be."
"If you make war on the soldiers of Lord Godrick," Ivar says, "some of his few remaining cavalry are even now escorting a carriage south along the eastern shore of the lake. But they'll not be keen to sell."
"I'm not keen to go killing people for their horses," I say. "I've got runes, if you want to trade for them."
Ivar's silent for a minute, looking us all up and down. "I'll not part with Fafnir," he says finally, patting his horse's neck. "But I shan't forbid Sigurd from trading with you if he so wishes. That is his affair, and he may set the price he chooses."
"Gullfax is fine horseflesh," says Sigurd. "But we return northward soon, and runes will serve us better on the road than a horse when so much of the band lacks mounts. I'll part with him for twenty thousand runes. No less."
Trinovar snorts audibly.
"That a bad deal?" I ask him. "Never bought a horse with runes before."
"If this horse were the mount of Queen Marika herself and the hero of a hundred campaigns, it might be worth such a price," he says.
I take stock. I do
have twenty thousand runes—that's about the haul I got from Godrick, besides his Great Rune. But after that I'll be down to about five thousand left. Which is probably fine—I haven't needed them for much—but there's no sense burning resources if I don't need to.
"Gullfax is the finest stock of the hardy north," Sigurd says sharply. "A finer steed you'll not find anywhere south of Altus."
"And yet we could take a horse a scant two hours' walk from here with the escort for that carriage," Trinovar counters. "Even if it is a lesser beast that we would find, it is scarcely
twenty thousand runes lesser. Ten thousand." He glances at me. "If I have leave to negotiate for you, Barrett."
"Of course," I say. "And thanks."
They haggle for a while, but eventually they settle on fifteen thousand. I hand over the runes the same way I did to Kalé a few nights ago, and Sigurd dismounts and passes me the reins. "Treat her well," he says. "She's borne me these many years, and she'll bear you many more if you care for her."
"Of course," I promise. "But I think—Rogier, you want the horse?"
"Happily," he says, taking the reins from me. "I'll have to find some way to repay you for all you've done for me, Barrett."
"Don't worry about it. Small price to pay for speeding up our whole trip." I turn to Rufus. "You don't mind carrying Trinovar, do you?" I'm tempted to put the Crucible Knight on my Sparrow and ride the temperamental—and traumatized—lion myself. But it'd take a while to train Trinovar in the controls, and there's a serious risk of him crashing and burning through our very limited resources to repair it.
The lion chuffs and shakes out his mane.
"Good boy." I turn to the Kaidens. "Thanks for doing business. We'll get out of your hair. Chester, bring out Always On Time, would you?"
A few minutes later, the four of us are off. We cross the bridge to the east, speeding past a small encampment of soldiers who are still scrambling for their gear when we leave them in the dust. The main road turns south on the other side of the bridge, but following Rogier's lead we turn north, following a terribly-maintained dirt road that's so overgrown with grass that it's barely there anymore. The road curves around as it descends a hill, turning further towards the east. As it passes under a massive archway of Farum Azula's fallen masonry, I hear a voice calling from above us.
"Hello! Whoever goes there, could you aid us?"
I kick my sparrow to a stop, and that's when the ambush hits.
More than a dozen small fellas appear in puffs of gray smoke with a shill war cry. They look…
almost human, but shorter, with faces that more resemble an ape's or a dog's. All of them are carrying crude clubs or blunt swords. They charge at us, flailing their weapons.
I leap off of Always On Time, already reaching for a gun. At this range… "Chester, Death Adder!" I snap out, and Winchester responds in a heartbeat. The submachine gun comes up, and bolts of Solar energy pour out like water from a hose. The creatures' war cries turn into shrieks of terror, then pain. Then silence.
I stare at the corpses, riddled with holes, as Rogier and Trinovar dismount beside me. "Well," says Trinovar slowly. "That was… impressive."
"They barely even had armor," I say. "Why the hell would they attack us? They had to see we were harder targets than they could manage."
"Many demi-humans have been driven every bit as mad as any human by the violence of these days," says Rogier. "They may not have had the mental fortitude to realize they were outmatched.
For a moment, the demi-human corpses vanish, and I'm staring at a field of slaughtered Eliksni wearing the violet colors of House Dusk. Then Cabal, in the tattered armor of the Red Legion remnants. Then Hive, in the spiked carapace of the Lucent Brood.
Is demi-human even the name of their species? Or is it a slur, a slur that's so common that people have forgotten it even is one? Am I calling my enemies
Fallen again?
I turn away. "Let's go see who was calling us."