Empyrean [Elden Ring/Destiny]

There's additional subtext to what happened with Ranni, Godwyn, and the rest of the family in this story. I'm not going to simp for Ranni, here or in canon, but here I tried to give her... perhaps more personal motives, let's say.
Maybe, but everything about her questline and story really just ticks some negative boxes for me. Mainly because her questline IS just mindless, thankless simping. 'T'was by the Fate I read in the stars my wishes were fulfilled.' Meanwhile I'm here wondering when my name got changed to Fate.
 
I haven't been up to speed on Destiny's story for some years, so before I read the info post on Glass, I just assumed these
Well, last I heard, Thermidor still has that Tablet of Ruin we nabbed from the High Coven, but there should still be more of the damn things out there somewhere.
Even the Anthem Anatheme can't no-sell death like that. It can create a semblance of a dead person, but it can't bring them back. Silver was real clear on that, when Lex asked her to bring Cayde back.
were canon things I hadn't heard about.
 
Prediction: Rather than stealing away Death, Queen Marika instead implemented something that prevents individuals from dying. Like a sort of safety net that catches their souls before the souls dissipate. Maybe Queen Marika was given this item by a different Outer God, maybe it was a remnant artefact that she discovered on her own, or maybe she created it wholesale. But it seems far easier to make something that stops one from fully dying than to change fundamental nature of death itself.
Unfortunately, this is canonically incorrect. The Rune of Death was literally being kept by Maliketh, which we see when we fight him, and we see it after we beat him. It's also made pretty explicit that it was Marika who made the call to seal away Destined Death using Maliketh, not the Fingers, and not the Greater Will. Frankly, the Greater Will itself seems pretty lax about what the current god and their Elden Lord decide to do, assuming that the various endings where you become Elden Lord all have the approval of the Greater Will at least.

Also, changing the subject, WRT Ranni I'll point out that it's very unclear how much culpability she actually has for the Night of the Black Knives, seeing as the Black Knife Assassins work for Marika, and that it was Marika who decided to shatter the Elden Ring (which caused like 99.9% of all the other problems besides Godwyn dying). And also that Gideon Ofnir (THE ALL-KNOWING) pretty heavily implies that the current state of the Lands Between, where everything is a nightmare hellscape and Tarnished are fighting endlessly to gain power and become Elden Lord, is actually what Marika wanted all along. Which, if true, recontextualizes everything, such that it's really more accurate to say that Ranni mostly just wanted out from under the Two Fingers and the Greater Will, and Marika used this desire in order to orchestrate the Shattering. Which of course raises the question "But why tho" which is never explained because From Software never gives straight answers and complete information. So really, if someone decides they want Ranni to be an evil mastermind that's certainly possible within the established lore, and if they decide they want Ranni to be a revolutionary who wants to create a more egalitarian system without any need for gods or Elden Lords that's also completely possible within the established lore.
 
I haven't been up to speed on Destiny's story for some years, so before I read the info post on Glass, I just assumed these


were canon things I hadn't heard about.
Those parts are from the AU background set up for this fic.
Well, the Tablet of Ruin is canon. It's the artifact the player claims during the Light Blade strike.
Unfortunately, this is canonically incorrect.
I think the original post was speculating as to how the crossover might create AU elements. Obviously I can't be completely canon-compliant with Elden Ring if I'm going to put it within a Destiny context, although you might be surprised how close I can get.
 
I think destined death is one of those things where noone really knows what the deal with it and the stuff surrounding it is, so if you're gonna fuck around with things you might as well fuck around with that.
 
Malenia and Radahn fought over the motion of the Cosmos
...I'm not sure where you got that, to be quite honest.
If we're talking theories, I like the one where she was looking for Miquella. Conveniently, Mohg's seat of power is directly under Caelid.

leaving the Lands Between to figure things out without even the vague hope of an Elden Lord to eventually fix things.
Except that her premise is that an Elden Lord cannot fix things. The only 'good' that Marika did was making 'peace' through crushing all resistance in the name of the Greater Will, for instance - something which notably involved a lot of genocide. All they do is provide the opportunity for the gods to battle it out to put their own puppet on the proverbial throne, claim the Elden Ring (or presumably destroy it, in the case of the Frenzied Flame) and enforce their own version of order - the Greater Will's may be more 'benevolent'-seeming than some, but it still attracts the attention of the others. Removing the ability to so cleanly edit the world's metaphysics then theoretically removes a great deal of that impetus - it's a thin hope, but the possibility exists that their attention will start to pull away.
 
it's a thin hope, but the possibility exists that their attention will start to pull away.
In canon, this is exactly the greater good that Ranni purports to serve. And I intend to keep that core of her character here. The heart of my worldbuilding and character development surrounding her has been fleshing out how she came to those conclusions. One of the biggest unanswered questions for me in Ranni's canon questline is exactly that: what was the inciting incident for her rebellion? I don't think she's selflessly doing all this to give the Lands Between a chance at freedom. She's too much her father's daughter for that.
 
Unfortunately, this is canonically incorrect.
Luckily, we're not dealing with canon, and thus are free to imagine what's different in this universe.
I think the original post was speculating as to how the crossover might create AU elements. Obviously I can't be completely canon-compliant with Elden Ring if I'm going to put it within a Destiny context, although you might be surprised how close I can get.
Basically this, yeah.
 
Last edited:
4. Small Kindness
Many thanks to @Keltoi, @DemiRapscallion, and @BinaryApotheosis for betareading and fact-checking.

-x-x-x-

Small Kindness

-x-x-x-​

"Damn, this thing packs a hell of a punch!"

"Of course it does, Sara. But we've got dozens of guns that pack a punch."

"Not like this, Barrett. Hot
damn, not like this."

-x-x-x-​

I don't dream of the Crypt again. I don't dream at all. But I also don't get much sleep.

I'm woken only a couple hours after sunset by a sudden jolt of Arc energy. I think shouting "Dammit!" and trying to slap Winchester out of the air is a completely appropriate response.

He disagrees. "Cut that out," he snaps, voice low as he darts away from my flailing hand. "Get up and come with me."

I shake the last of the sleep from my head and glance to the side. Melina is still lying on the grass, hair still spread over the rolled-up hood of her cloak, almost luminous in the light of the Grace beside her and the Erdtree above. I stand quietly. "What is it, Chester?"

He doesn't answer, just starts floating away. I follow. We walk down the hill, away from the mausoleum, heading away from the Erdtree in the distance, back in the direction of the Lonestar. We don't get nearly that far before I hear something that has me freezing in place.

"Was that—"

"Yes," Winchester says darkly. "Come on."

I'm tenser as I follow him now. The sound continues, one voice joining with others. A dozen of them, maybe more.

We crest the hill and it takes me a second to understand what I'm seeing. There's burned corpses, crucified on wooden stakes, lining a vague trail down by the shore of a lake to my left. Some of them are even glowing slightly, like coals in the night, as if the fire had never gone out after they were burned alive.

Then I realize that the sound I've been hearing is coming from the corpses. The burned and crucified corpses are screaming in agony.

"What the fuck," I whisper.

Winchester doesn't answer. He just settles over my shoulder, flaps rotating slightly.

What the hell had Melina said? The spirit remains, longing for release. It finds that release, eventually, when it is returned to the roots of the Erdtree.

"Holy shit," I whisper. "They're being suspended off the ground. They're being kept away from the roots."

"Looks that way," says Winchester.

It's only when I almost slip on a patch of loose gravel that I realize I've started to walk down the hill to the nearest crucifix. I come to a stop just in front of it, staring up at the remains of a body which, somehow, still screams despite being little more than charcoal.

Quiet hoofbeats approach me, and I hear Melina dismount from Torrent. "The traditional punishment for those who committed the most heinous of crimes," she says softly, "was to be wrapped in a crown of briars and banished from the southern heartlands into the forbidden north, or to be cast away entirely beyond the Fog as a Tarnished. But ever since the discovery of the Blood Star and the development of thorn sorceries, this practice has begun to replace the old briar crowns."

"I'm gonna need an explanation of those things," I say, not looking at her, "but not now." I draw Quickfang and strike at the heavy wooden stake. It takes a couple blows to carve through the stake—Quickfang is light, meant to slip through armor and tear through flesh, not do the work of a saw—but before too long, I bring the crucifix down. It falls, but when the corpse hits the ground it keeps screaming. "You said that the spirit will be set free if we return it to the roots of the Erdtree?"

"Yes," says Melina. "There may be a place to perform Erdtree burial somewhere within the catacombs beneath the Hero's Grave here—" she gestures up at the mausoleum on the hill "—but I know not what manner of defenders might be within."

"Defenders?"

"Erdtree burial sites are carefully controlled," says Melina. "Especially now. Those which are not defended by stone watchdogs and other constructed defenders have often been taken up as residences by Those Who Live in Death, who spread their corruption through the roots."

More goddamn proper nouns I've got no idea about. "And what happens," I ask, "if 'Those Who Live in Death' have corrupted the roots here? Or what happens if they do later?"

She looks… really, really sad. Not the abstract sorrow of knowing something horrible is happening to people you don't know, but the real, present grief of having a personal connection to someone involved. "Then they will take any who have not been fully reclaimed by the Erdtree," she says. "And they will transform them into more of their kind."

"What are Those Who Live in Death?"

"It is not entirely known," says Melina softly. "Whatever they are, they only appeared after the Night of the Black Knives, when Godwyn the Golden was assassinated. They are soulless creatures to whom death is empowering. A living thing which dies ceases to move, until it is either restored by Grace or returned to the Erdtree. But for Those Who Live in Death, one may scatter their bones and they will simply reform them in seconds. To destroy them, the entire skeleton must be crushed—and even then, the dust carries the spreading rot of their Deathroot."

I stare at her for a minute. Then I look at Winchester. "Vex Risen," I say.

"You shut up," he grunts. "I can't even sleep and that's gonna give me nightmares."

I shake my head, turning back to the poor burned carcass on the ground. "Well, we can't leave them like this," I say. "And I don't want to risk them getting turned into a contagious zombie monster."

"There's another option," says Winchester quietly.

Something in his tone makes me pause, and that pause is all it takes for me to follow his logic. "Tell me you didn't keep it."

"Of course I kept it. You think a Weapon of Sorrow is gonna let itself get lost in data corruption? If I'd left it in the vault to decay it'd just find some way to turn up outside of our control."

I hate it, but he's right. I grit my nickel-alloy teeth. "I thought Ghosts were supposed to stop their Guardians from playing with shit like that."

"When the hell did I give you the impression I was a good Ghost?" Winchester asks, and boy oh boy is there a lot going unsaid in the spaces between those words.

"This time, it is I who is lost in this conversation," Melina says softly. "What are you discussing?"

I look down at the screaming corpse at my feet. Exomind bodies are damn good at simulating humanity—they have to be, or we'd be getting weekly resets—but they're not perfect. If they were, I'm pretty sure I'd be swallowing back bile. "Give me the damn gun."

The Dead Man's Tale disappears from my back. In its place is a more smaller, more compact gun. It's made of lighter materials, but somehow it's almost heavy enough to make me stagger. I reach over my shoulder and pull out the Osteo Striga.

"We should've purified this months ago," I say.

"Dunno if that poor bastard would agree," says Winchester softly. "Don't think Lumina could do what needs to be done today."

I grimace and bring my eye to the gun's sights. I rest my shaking finger on the trigger. It's warm to the touch. I can feel its eagerness, its hunger. I take aim at the corpse's emaciated head, then close my eyes.

I pull the trigger.

The corpse lets out one final, agonized scream, then falls mercifully silent. When I open my eyes, it's already decayed into Hive miasma and soulfire.

There's a sharp intake of breath beside me. "What… is that?" Melina asks.

Fuck. Almost involuntarily, my hands tighten around the gun between them. Don't you dare try and corrupt her, I think at it, willing it to understand me. She wouldn't even know how to use you. You may only be a small part of my arsenal, one I'm reluctant to use, but you're better off there than stuck with her.

I'm never sure whether I'm imagining it when some of the almost-sentient weapons in my arsenal respond to me. If D.A.R.C.I. says something to Lex, they know she's really talking. Back before she passed it to Grant, the Whisper was always quick to let Silver know when it wanted something. But the Osteo Striga isn't sentient. Not really. It's a Weapon of Sorrow—the Sword-Logic manifested in the form of a weapon. It's no more sentient than the law of gravity.

But even gravity can be said to have a singular desire. It wants to bring things together. And Osteo Striga wants to feed.

So I don't know if I'm imagining it when I feel Osteo Striga shiver under my hands. I don't know whether I'm imagining the psychic pulse of satisfaction that runs through me. But for once I hope I'm not.

I turn to Melina. "This is a Weapon of Sorrow," I say. "It can set these people free."

"How?" she asks.

I grimace. "By consuming their souls," I say. "The Weapons of Sorrow are some of the only things in the universe that can permanently kill a Guardian like me. If we don't know whether the Erdtree roots are safe for these people… then this is our best option."

Melina nods slowly, looking at the gun in my hands with dread and awe. "I agree," she says. Then she looks back up at me. "You are kinder than I expected," she says softly. "Kinder than most in these lands. Kinder than I, certainly."

"Don't sell yourself short, sweetheart."

"I did not for a moment consider cutting these wretches down and offering them Erdtree burial. It did not so much as occur to me. Their plight did not even enter my mind." She turns and looks out over the long line of crucified bodies. "Will you do this to every crucifix in Limgrave?" she asks.

"I…" Part of me wants to say yes. No one deserves this. I remember Crow's disgust over the treatment of the Hive prisoners we took back in Operation Elbrus, all those years ago. Of course, those bastards hadn't actually been in constant tortuous agony, but Crow had believed they were. It's taken me a while to forgive him for almost bringing down our hard-won alliance with Caiatl in a single reckless move, but I get it.

I've put a few demons of my own out of their misery.

But… I turn and look up at the Erdtree. I think about that gravitational anomaly, sealing this world off from my friends and allies. I think about the tiny slice of the Lands Between I've already seen.

There have never been enough Guardians to protect everyone. We can't afford to let ourselves get tunnel vision. We can't focus on the problem in front of us—even if it is a really big problem—to the point that we lose sight of the wider context.

That way lies obsession. It's happened to hundreds of us, many of whom I knew personally. It happened to Rezyl Azzir. It happened to Toland. It happened to Jana-14.

It happened to Sara.

"No," I say heavily, holstering the Striga. "I'll free those we pass on our route. But there's too much to do for me to spend weeks going all over Limgrave looking for crucifixes. I need to get my radio repaired and signal my fireteam. And I promised to take you to the Erdtree, didn't I?"

She looks at me for a long moment, then nods. "One day," she says softly, "These poor creatures will all be laid to rest. By one course or by another."

"One day," I agree hollowly. "I don't think I'm gonna be getting any more sleep tonight. You good to go?"

"I am well enough to travel, yes."

"Then I'm gonna need Always On Time, Chester."

We head north. The Erdtree Sentinel I killed yesterday was patrolling a stretch of road between the mausoleum and what looks like the remains of a chapel. There's several more crucified bodies hanging up along the path, and I give each one a double-tap to the head as we pass. Striga is joyful in my hands. I just feel sick.

By the time we reach the crumbling church, the sun has started to rise. I glance inside the stone archway—if there was ever a door there, it's rotted away by now—and see what looks like firelight on the inside. I brake, and Torrent slows to a halt beside me.

"What is it?" Melina asks me.

"Someone's in there," I say."

She follows my gaze. "Ah, a wandering merchant," she says. "In the days before the Shattering, theirs was an oft-reviled people. As a result, their lives have changed perhaps less than nearly any others', though I imagine they often have fewer clients than they once did."

"Chester, you ever figure out what to do with those 'runes' we supposedly got from that big gold guy?"

"I mean, I scanned while you were sleeping, and they should be harmless," says Winchester. "But what to do with them? No idea."

"Maybe he can explain it to us," I say. "After all, probably in his interests to make sure we know how to give him money." I dismount from Always On Time and step through the high arch into the ruined church. Melina follows, but doesn't dismount from Torrent until she's close to the Site of Grace in the center of the room. I give that thing a wide berth. No Crypt visions today, thanks."

"Hm," says the merchant as I draw near. His voice is raspy, like he hasn't had a drop of water in it in days. "Well, you are an unfamiliar face, and no mistake."

"Getting that a lot," I say, sitting down at his campfire across from him.

The man has some kind of musical instrument in his lap. It has a bow like a violin, but its hairs are woven between the two threads strung across the rest of the instrument's wooden body. The bow is tipped with that looks like an open hand, cast in silver. The guy's wearing the brightest clothes I've seen so far—a warm-looking, bright red coat and cap, and a matching fur cloak with a thick white collar. There's also a red scarf wrapped around his mouth.

"I can only imagine," says the merchant, with what sounds like a sincere chuckle. "Well, steel-faced stranger, I am Kalé, purveyor of fine goods."

"Barrett-12, Guardian. Just call me Barrett."

"A pleasure, Barrett," says Kalé. "It's always a joy to meet people who would rather talk than try to separate my head from my shoulders. All too uncommon, these days."

"I'm gathering that," I say. "Sounds like things aren't going so well in the Lands Between lately."

"You could say that." Kalé's eyes, I notice, aren't any normal color. Nor are they gold like Melina's, which is what I'd thought at first. Instead, they're a sickly yellow. "But despite everything, there are still occasionally travelers in need of supplies. Perhaps I can furnish you?"

"Well, I was hoping you could help me with that, actually," I say. "I've gotten myself a fair number of Runes—killed the Erdtree Sentinel who was patrolling outside, if you saw him."

"Ah, I noticed that he had vanished," says Kalé. "You have my gratitude. I was worried he would notice me here and decide to rid the world of one more wretched merchant."

"Glad he didn't," I say, though I have to wonder what the hell kind of history is there for a people identified only as merchants to be hunted down like that. Is it an ethnic thing, or something else? "But unfortunately, I've got no idea how to use those Runes. So how about you explain to me how I can use them to buy something, and I'll repay you by making sure I do?"

"A generous exchange," says Kalé, sounding amused, "as I suspect you'll discover in a mere moment. How many Runes do you have?"

"Don't know."

"Don't you?"

I blink, and suddenly realize that whatever those paracausal specks that passed to me from the Erdtree Sentinel were, I'm aware of them. Only vaguely, and only when I look, but I know they're there. And I know how many there are without even having to count. "Three thousand, two hundred," I say. "What the hell?"

He smiles slightly under his scarf, visible in the wrinkling around his eyes. "Well, I'd recommend you pick up my crafting kit. It'll help you put together whatever you might need from supplies you can scavenge all over the Lands Between. I have some manuscripts detailing recipes, as well."

"Sure. How much for the kit?"

"Three hundred Runes. Then five hundred for two manuscripts I received from a nomadic warrior several years ago, and a thousand for a cookbook compiled by a missionary of the Golden Order in the years before the Shattering."

"Just the kit, for now," I say. "Let me guess, I just…"

I will three hundred of my motes of paracausal energy to pass into Kalé's possession. They oblige, and he reaches into a sack beside him and pulls out a small purse, full of needles, spools of thread, chisels, scalpels, and various other tools. "There you are, then," he says. "I have other wares, if you would like them. Some information and advice, as well."

"What sort of advice?"

"Two pieces of useful information have passed into my hands recently," says Kalé. "Two hundred runes apiece. The first concerns an object you may find useful—a Flask of Wonderous Physick. The second concerns a set of ruins nearby, and what is contained within."

"Where are those ruins?"

"To the east, just across the river."

I consider. "I'm not headed in that direction right now," I say. "And if this Flask involves drinking some kind of potion, well, I'm not sure it'd do much for me."

"I suppose that's sensible." Kalé doesn't seem too disappointed by my refusal. "I have armor, ammunition, and a few various other oddments. But I'll be here if you decide to return at a later date, as well."

"Fair enough." I stand up. "Thank you, Kalé. I appreciate it. It's nice to meet a friendly face."

"I could say the same thing, Barrett."

I turn to Melina, then blink. "Where's Torrent?"

She glances behind her, seeming surprised at the absence of her Spectral Steed. She looks around, and then smiles. I follow her gaze. Torrent is nuzzling at a crumbling wall, about chest-high, to my right. He almost seems like he's looking for something.

"Is he hungry?" I ask Melina.

"Unlikely," she says. "Given that there are rowa bushes aplenty all over Limgrave. No, more likely he has noticed some unusual scent." She walks over and mounts the creature gracefully. "Now then," she says. "Do we make for Castle Stormveil?"

"Lead the way."
 
Liking this. Liking this plenty. I am ignorant of destiny's lore in an absolute, but Elden Ring i know intimately and i liked how you are portraying the Characters of the Lands Between.

Keep it up!
 
Liking this. Liking this plenty. I am ignorant of destiny's lore in an absolute, but Elden Ring i know intimately and i liked how you are portraying the Characters of the Lands Between.

Keep it up!
For a catch up on Destiny Lore I recommend Mynameisbyf on YouTube he has a lot of videos starting from the very beginning of destinies timeline all the way up till recent events during this season
 
5. The Gate of Storms
Many thanks to @Keltoi, @DemiRapscallion, and @BinaryApotheosis for betareading and fact-checking.

-x-x-x-

The Gate of Storms

-x-x-x-​

"Ah. Sister."

"Hello, Brother. Might I ask you a question?"

"If you must."

"There's no need to be unkind, Godwyn. Greetings, Lady Melina."

"Greetings, Lord Fortissax. Brother, I asked my tutors when the lands north of the city were barred, and why. He bade me ask you."

"Ah. I had them barred."

"Why?"

"That overly curious young demigods would not uncover secrets that better remain buried."


-x-x-x-​

We slow to a halt as we clear the treeline at the crest of a small hill. The woods behind us were patrolled by soldiers wearing padded armor emblazoned with red and green heraldry. Soldiers in the employ of Godrick the Grafted, apparently.

There's a small complex of ruins ahead of us that might once have been a hamlet, though only stone foundations remain. But to the left is a massive stone gate that looks more well-maintained. The portcullis is raised, though, and part of me suspects it's stuck that way. The patrols I see marching back and forth in the ruins out front certainly don't seem like they want to let just anyone traipse on by.

"What am I looking at?" I ask Melina.

She shakes her head. "If this village had a name before the Shattering, I do not know it," she says. "The Gate of Storms is one of the few ways up the cliffs from lower Limgrave onto the Stormhill. Castle Stormveil is built at the summit of the Stormhill."

I look past the sheer stone cliffs and point. "Is that part of the castle?"

Melina follows my finger. "No," she says. "That is the Divine Tower of Limgrave. In the days before the Shattering, a bridge connected the tower to the castle so that its ruler might go to consult with the Two Fingers at its summit. But that bridge has been broken, and I rather doubt the Fingers survived. Many sets of Fingers were killed when the demigods went to war."

"Why?"

"I know not. I was not free to investigate at the time. Some say that the demigods themselves slew the Fingers to prevent them selecting any upstart as an Empyrean rival. Others claim that the Shattering itself killed the Fingers, for their connection to the Elden Ring is what sustained them. I cannot say whether either story is truth."

"Huh." I shrug. I have bigger fish to fry than questioning the details of how a group of paracausal grippers died centuries ago. "Gate looks heavily defended," I observe.

"Yes," Melina agreed. She leans forward on Torrent's back, frowning at the gate with narrowed eyes. "It is likely that there are more defenders in the canyon behind the gate, as well." She looks over at me. "There are other ways onto the Stormhill, if you would prefer.

"How far out of the way?" I ask. Daylight is weird here—the Erdtree fucks with the lighting in ways I don't expect, making morning and evening less dark than I feel like they should be—but the sun's a bit past noon already. This planet's day-night cycle is a little shorter than Earth standard, but not by enough that I'm tempted to force Melina and Torrent out of their circadian rhythm. I can work with shorter days and nights, I've done it before.

"We would have to cross the Murkwater," Melina says. "There are spiritsprings on the eastern side that Torrent can use to ascend the hill."

I frown. "Will those work with my sparrow?"

Melina's face falls slightly. "I do not know," she says, "but it will not matter. You can ride Torrent, and I will follow."

"How?"

Her lips thin. She visibly debates with herself about how to answer. So, I raise a hand. "Don't worry about it," I say. I remember now—she offered me Torrent at the beginning, told me she had her own way to keep up. But she clearly doesn't actually like taking that option, whatever it is. "There's no need to go that far out of the way, anyway. We can just take the gate."

"Are you certain?" she asks.

"I want to try talking to the soldiers anyway," I say. "I know you said they probably wouldn't listen to a word I said before trying to gut me, but I wouldn't feel right going after Godrick if I hadn't at least tried, you know?"

She considers me with an unreadable look in her golden eye. "I suppose I understand," she says. "It has been a terribly long time since any in the Lands Between had the luxury of such principles, Barrett."

"I'm a Guardian of the Last City," I say, swing my leg over the Always On Time and standing up. "Principles ain't a luxury for me. They're the wall and the people behind it. Stay back here, I'll come get you when it's safe."

"…Thank you," she says, with visible reluctance. It's odd—she vanished the moment the fight against the Sentinel started yesterday, but she doesn't seem to like staying out of fights.

"Do you want to come with?" I ask.

"I fear I would not be able to offer any assistance," she says. "No, it is best you face them alone. As frustrating as my current state is, it is one I must come to terms with."

"Your current state?"

"Go, Barrett," she says. "We can speak more later."

I shrug and start on down the hill.

She's keeping secrets from you, Winchester says from the safety of my localized hammerspace.

No shit, I answer.

That don't bother you?

Some,
I admit. But not enough to want to burn the only damn bridge I've built on this planet. We'll keep our eyes open. It'll be fine.

Winchester doesn't give any more answer than a grunt.

Once I've crossed about half the distance to the ruins, one of the soldiers finally spots me. I raise a hand when I see the man start, looking in my directions. "Hey there!" I call. "I'm—"

The man raises a trumpet to his lips and blows, cutting me off. Every other soldier in the ruins, whether they're hanging out around a campfire or patrolling around one of the massive carriages, jumps to attention. It takes some of them a minute to figure out where the trumpeter was looking, but eventually they all spot me. And once they do, every damn one of them draws their weapon and charges.

I sigh. This ain't looking good.

No shit,
Winchester says dryly.

I don't draw my weapon until the first guy reaches me. "I'm not—" I try to say, but he doesn't even slow before swinging his sword at my head. I channel the light around me, thinning the air the way Aparajita-4 taught me all those years ago, throwing myself backwards and rolling, the air offering as little resistance as vacuum. I roll back to my feet. "I just want—"

He swings again, and, well… I'm a Guardian, not a pacifist.

I channel Solar Light into a weighted knife. It coalesces in my right hand, warm as a hearth and hot as napalm. I parry the blade, then swing mine into the soldier's chest. He lets out a choked, guttural scream, then falls. But as he does, I notice something.

That wasn't a totally human sound. The guy's skin is grey. And, mostly hidden by his helm, his eyes are bloodshot, with irises that are unnaturally black. I… don't think these people are completely human anymore. And I say anymore deliberately.

There's nothing that can be as inhumane as something that was once human.

A couple of wolves are charging me now. Guess these soldiers must have domesticated them. But they've got nothing on war beasts.

I throw the knife at the first. It buries it in the beast's skull. By the time the other reaches me, I've pulled out the Dead Man's Tale. Two shots to the head are plenty to put the wolf down.

Then I turn the gun on the people behind them. The half-dozen or so soldiers go down in three headshots apiece. The last one gets wise enough to start zig-zagging, but I've been training in the Crucible for centuries. It doesn't help him.

There's a guy in heavier armor behind them. He starts hiding behind his big shield when he sees what my gun is doing to his men, advancing at me slowly with his spear extended towards me. I fire a couple experimental shots at the shield, but the bullets ping off it with hardly any impact. If they even dent it, I can't see it from this distance.

It's a damn heavy piece of work, wider and thicker than the shields Hive Knights sometimes carry. And I'm talking objectively wider and thicker—relative to the guy holding it, who's a good three feet shorter than a Knight morph, it's comically oversized. But the guy doesn't seem to be struggling with it hardly at all. I mean, obviously he's moving a little slowly, but that's mostly because he's half-crouched behind the shield, not because the shield itself is so heavy.

I put away the Dead Man's Tale. I briefly consider asking Winchester for a fusion rifle or grenade launcher, or something else that might get through the shield or disintegrate the guy behind it. But the thing is, without our ship's engram decoder, my ammo is limited to what Winchester can fabricate from the materials we can salvage.

Kinetic ammo—or even the liquid ammo of my simpler Omolon weapons—is easy. Winchester could probably fab a full mag of bullets for the Striga from a handful of dirt. But for more advanced stuff? Grenades, charged ammo for my directed energy weapons, or RPGs for my rocket launchers? Those will take resources I'm not even sure we can find planetside. Once we get that debris field down here it'll be possible, but once we get that debris field down here I'll have a distress call out anyway.

So instead of burning limited resources on one guy with a metal barn door strapped to his arm, I call on the Light. Flames lick up my arm as a grenade coalesces in my hand. I throw it. The Solar Grenade blossoms into life around the man and his shield. He screams, stumbling, then falls. A moment later, he falls silent as he cooks in his armor.

I grimace as the scent of burning human flesh reaches my synthetic olfactory receptors. Most of the time, I'm glad that DER forced Clovis Bray to make us Exos simulate most human functionality. But it's times like this that I wish we could have some kind of toggle for some of our senses.

I turn around and fall back to where Melina is watching me astride Torrent. "Most impressive," she says.

"Thanks," I say. "Guess you were right. Will they just… linger? Like the poor bastards on the crosses?"

"Only very briefly," Melina says. "They are not being kept from the earth, and so the earth can reclaim them. Their road back to the roots of the Erdtree will be longer than some, but they will find their way back, just the same."

"That's good." I hadn't been looking forward to pulling out the Striga again. "What's up with their skin?"

"Their skin?" Melina asks. "Ah—were they grey of flesh?"

"With black eyes, yeah."

"It something I have only seen a few times before," she says. "I suspect it is more common now. The dark eyes are a marker of those who have lost the Grace of Gold. The graying skin occurs after someone remains so afflicted for long enough. It usually takes years." She grimaces. "I imagine, after all these years of constant warfare, most of the armies of all the demigods must have greyed, decaying flesh by now."

"Is that how that works?" I ask. "Does trauma lead to the loss of Grace?"

"The process is poorly-understood," Melina says. "But it is most common in those who lose a sense of purpose and hope. The First Elden Lord, Godfrey, lost his Grace after he ran short of lands to conquer. In the days before the Shattering, it was more common in soldiers than in other professions."

"Damn," Winchester grunts, popping out of my hammerspace. "A paracausal punishment for depression. That's fucked."

"Agreed," I say. Then I shrug. "Once we get the fireteam back together, we can start looking into fixing things."

"You have said such things a few times now," Melina says. "There are more warriors like you, then? Once you have escaped the barrier Radahn has placed upon the stars, will they wish to involve themselves in the wars ravaging these lands?"

"Can't promise anything for everyone else," I say, "but I became a Guardian because I wanted to give people a safe place to live. There's people here, and it doesn't sound like they've got one. So even if I leave, I think I'll probably come back before too long."

She smiles. It sends something swooping in my stomach. "I am pleased to hear that," she says. "If you would not object, I would hear something of your homeland, Barrett. A place defended by men like you must be a goodly place."

"It's getting there," I say. I point at the gate. "Let's get through there and up onto the Stormhill. You told me about the Lands Between when we made camp last night. I'll return the favor when we make camp tonight."

Unfortunately, getting through the Gate of Storms ain't that easy.

With the ruins' garrison dealt with, Melina and I ride down to a Site of Grace just outside the gate. Then we take cover behind the gate and poke our heads around the corner to get a look at what's on the other side. It doesn't look good.

There's multiple layers of barricades blocking the narrow path up the canyon. I can only see a couple of soldiers, mostly armed with crossbows, but I'm willing to bet there's more, taking advantage of the dim lighting and abundant cover to keep hidden.

Speaking of the dim lighting, there's what looks like a massive, crumbling chunk of ancient masonry wedged across the walls of the canyon, forming a bridge across the gap above us and throwing the whole path in shadow. And there's something up on top of that bridge. I duck back behind cover and look at Melina. "Above the path. Tell me that's a statue."

She looks again, and when she looks back at me, her expression is grim. "I'm afraid not," she says. "That looks to be a troll."

"Great," I say. "Big fella."

"Yes. He is not likely to be as much a threat as the Erdtree Sentinel you fought yesterday, however."

"Really?" I ask. "He looks bigger than that guy was. Maybe not if you include the horse."

"Trolls are large, but they are also slow," Melina says. "And those in this part of the world largely lack advanced training in warfare or magic. Before the Shattering, many trolls were used as little more than beasts of burden. I would guess that the one here was freed by Godrick in exchange for his service."

"Beasts of burden? These trolls are intelligent, right?"

"Enough to speak. I was once told that they were markedly less intelligent than men, but I could not say whether this is so."

Intelligent beasts of burden. Don't like that. I'm starting to get the feeling that this world wasn't exactly sunshine and roses even before the Shattering.

"Those barricades didn't look all that sturdy," Winchester says. "We might be able to bust right through them if we hit 'em with Always On Time."

I look at him. "We sure there's a clear path? I don't want to get pinned against a locked gate with that whole garrison behind us."

"I could check," he offers.

"Absolutely fuckin' not. We have no idea what kind of paracausal shit they have in play. I'm not risking you going like Sundance did."

He grunts, and I get the feeling that if he had a face, it'd be grimacing. "Fair enough. So what—you wanna kill everything in the path?"

"Not really," I admit. It's not like I enjoy killing people, even if they seem to have lost some of what makes them people. It was easier, once, and I don't want to go back to that.

"Could try invisibility," my Ghost suggests.

"I'm not Lex. Can't chain smoke bombs long enough to keep both me and Melina invisible the whole way through that." I consider. "Maybe combine strategies, though. Try and dash through, then use a smoke bomb to get us out if things get hairy?"

"I have my own way of escape if things grow violent," Melina says. "You need not concern yourself with my safety, Barrett."

"You don't seem to like that way of escape, though, sweetheart," I tell her.

She flushes slightly, as if she didn't expect me to notice. "Nonetheless. If it is a choice between my comfort and your life, the choice should be obvious."

Which is fair. "Fine, sounds good." I mount back up on Always On Time, and Melina pulls herself up onto Torrent's back. "Follow me," I tell her, "and holler if something goes wrong."

"I will," she promises.

That said, I turn the sparrow towards the gate and gun it.

Fortunately, there is a clear path. Mostly clear, anyway. Unfortunately, the last barricade is reinforced. After busting through half a dozen of the things already, I don't notice how much sturdier it is until my sparrow hits it dead-on. The barricade comes apart—but a bit of wood reinforced with iron flies into my engine, and my ride comes apart too. Always On Time explodes under me, tearing through my shields and ripping gashes through the plating of my legs. I go flying and hit the ground hard.

"Barrett!" Melina screams, slowing Torrent.

I wave her on. "Go! I'll catch up."

She hesitates, so I palm a smoke bomb and toss it on the ground beside where I've fallen. The vaporized Void Light hisses as it forms a haze around me, I see my own hands fade from view.

She blinks at where I've disappeared, then sets her face and leans into Torrent. The spectral steed gallops onward, leaving me, the wreck of my sparrow, at least a dozen soldiers, and a troll, which has jumped down onto the path and is jogging up the hill after us.

Nice driving, Winchester says caustically.

Shut your flaps, I tell him. The Light's already knitted my legs back together, enough to stand up at least, so I pull myself to my feet. A couple of soldiers—the ones who had been behind that reinforced barricade—are trying to figure out where I went, but the rest of the force seems to be headed up the hill after Melina.

Hate to break it to you, bud, says Winchester, but I don't have the resources to re-fab that sparrow from scratch. We need to salvage the wreck.

I sigh and draw Quickfang. Figures.

The soldiers go down fast. A hit from the Void-charged sword is enough break their shields if they have them, and another cuts them down. I take a few hits from their crossbows, but I pull the bolts out and heal up by the time the troll reaches me. I get my first good look at him and…

…I don't actually know what I'm looking at. The big guy looks like a giant scoop got ripped out of his torso. It almost looks like something's embedded in his exposed guts, like a slab of stone, held inside by his entrails. Sounds fucked, but in this lighting that's what it looks like. He tries to slam his fist down into the ground on me, but I roll to the side.

I take stock once I'm back on my feet. Most of the soldiers are dead now, and the four that aren't are still halfway down the hill aiming at me with crossbows. The troll's the only thing still trying to engage me in CQC, so I roll between his legs, sheathing Quickfang and pulling out the Dead Man's Tale. I aim from the hip and fire off four shots. The surviving crossbowmen go down.

I roll out of the way of the troll's foot as he tries to step on me, then hit him a couple times in the dome with DMT. He flinches, but takes the shots like a champ, trying to backhand me away. I jump over his hand, switching weapons in midair to my First In, Last Out, and hit him with that.

My FILO was designed to take out a Titan in the Crucible in the middle of his Super. If it hits the radiolarian core, it can take out a Vex Hydra with one slug. The troll, poor bastard, doesn't stand a chance.

By the time he's finished falling to the ground—it takes a while, with how big he is—Winchester is already halfway back to the wreck of Always On Time. "I'm not gonna be able to rebuild this thing that many times," he warns me. "Not without our decoder."

"I know," I say.

"So be fuckin' careful with it, then," he snaps.

"I will. No more crazy charges without seeing the course in advance. Promise."

Winchester just grunts as he finishes decompiling the wreck. "It'll take me a few hours to reconstruct it," he says. "You're gonna have to run to catch up with the girl."

"Fine," I say as he disappears into my hammerspace.

There's a pack of wolves on the road just as I come out of the canyon, but I go invisible and slip by them without much trouble. Nice thing about paracausal invisibility like we Lightbearers use is that it muffles all of the senses, not just sight. If I'd been using an Eliksni cloak, like the one we used to hide the Lonestar, they'd have been able to smell me just fine. Even so, I see one of the wolves sniff the air as I pass it. Invisibility is never completely perfect.

I pass them by, and then pass a tiny glowing sapling on the side of the road. Looks like a miniature Erdtree. Gotta ask Melina about it when I catch up. It takes a few minutes before I see what looks like a small, dilapidated cottage up ahead. As I get closer, I see that Torrent is out front, munching on a berry bush. The spectral steed looks up as I get close. His eyes have rectangular pupils, like a goat's. Probably some evolutionary significance to that, but I ain't a Warlock. I give the animal a nod, and I swear he nods back as I duck into the shack.

The walls have mostly rotted away, but the roof is still mostly held up by four supports at the corners. Melina is there, her hood up as she sits beside another Site of Grace. There's another girl, wearing a hooded cloak that looks like it's made of red velvet. They both look up as I come in, but the new face looks back down again a moment later.

"You made it," Melina says. "I was somewhat worried. There were far more soldiers there than at the ruins."

"Nothin' I can't handle." I nod at the girl in red. "Who's this?"

Melina glances over. "We have not spoken much. She says her name is Roderika."

"Hm." Did she really come in here, get the girl's name, and then just sit down in silence? Huh. First giving Varré a fake name, then barely talking with Kalé, and now this. I'm starting to think Melina has hangups about talking to people. I approach Roderika. "Hey. I'm Barrett."

She looks up at me. "Are you a man?" she asks. Her hair's blond, and her eyes are blue. Her skin is very pale, to the point that a faint redness in her cheeks, probably from the cold wind, stands out sharply against the rest of her face.

"Yeah, last I checked. An Exo, which is why I look," I rap my knuckles against the metal of my cheek, "like this."

She nods slowly. "I suppose you've nothing to fear from grafting, then," she says, looking away.

I sit down across from her. "People have mentioned that a fellow named Godrick the Grafted rules this territory," I say. "But nobody's actually explained what that means."

"It happened to my companions," Roderika says softly. "Everyone who crossed the sea with me. Their arms, their legs, even their heads. Taken, and grafted to the spider."

It takes me a second to even guess at what she means, and once I do the image in my head is almost too grotesque to imagine. "You mean… their body parts were attached to this 'spider'?"

"Aye. They say if you're grafted by the spider, you become a chrysalid. I'm sure it'll happen to me before long." She hugs herself with shaking arms. "I should've just gotten it over with then, with my men. But I—I was too much of a craven to do it. I wasn't ready. I'm still not ready."

"Hey. There's no shame in wanting to live."

"But this way, I'm all alone," she says. "I want to be like everyone else. To become a chrysalid. But it's scary."

"Fear is the mind's way of warning us. Telling us that we need to be careful. That we might be making a mistake. Sometimes we need to push through it, but sometimes…" I shake my head. "I don't think your men would want you to suffer their fate. I think they'd want you to survive."

She sighs. "I don't know what to do, if not to become a chrysalid. I'm alone now. What can I do alone?"

"Everyone's alone. Find someone to be alone together with."

She frowns. Meets my eyes. "How?"

I shrug. "Where were you headed before? Why'd you come to the Lands Between in the first place?"

"Same reason as any other Tarnished, I suppose. My men hoped I'd become Elden Lord. Much good that did them."

"Well, I promised her—" I jerk my thumb back at Melina, who's sitting silent and watching us "—that I'd get her to the base of the Erdtree. You're welcome to tag along." I glance back at Melina. "She is welcome, right?"

Melina considers me in silence for a long moment before she nods. The hesitation is long enough for me to regret not at least consulting her before offering a space in my little fireteam.

But it doesn't matter. Roderika shakes her head. "I'm too scared even to leave my ward," she whispers. "No, I can't climb to the Erdtree. Not like this."

"All right," I say, standing. I offer her my hand. "I'm Barrett, anyway. Let me know if I can help you."

Hesitantly, she takes my hand. "Thank you for your kind words, Barrett," she says.

I return to the Site of Grace and Melina. "You all right?" I ask her softly.

"Well enough," she answers.

"Sorry I didn't talk to you before—"

"There is no need to apologize." Melina cuts me off. "I cannot fight with you. It is only fit that you should have the right to seek out companions who can."

"That wasn't why I offered to travel with her. Or with you, for that matter. I'm a Hunter, I'm used to ranging out on my own. But it's better with friends, even if I'm fighting alone."

She considers that for a moment. Under her hood, I see her one eye reflecting the irregular light of the Site of Grace. Then she looks at me. "You said you would tell me something of your homeland," she says. "Are you still willing?"

"Of course, sweetheart. What do you want to know?"

"What does it mean to be a Guardian?"

I let out a breath. "Well now, starting with the big questions."

"Can you not tell me?"

"It'll take a bit to explain."

Melina gestures at the sun, sinking low in the sky. "I believe we have time."

"Guess we do."
 
Last edited:
LORE DUMP TIIIIIIME!

but seriously, this is some good stuff. Keep up the good work feeding that muse of yours.
 
6. Philosopher
Many thanks to @Keltoi, @DemiRapscallion, and @BinaryApotheosis for betareading and fact-checking.

-x-x-x-

Philosopher

-x-x-x-​

"Where were you?"

"Whoa! You startled me, Barrett."

"Sorry. But I expected you back hours ago. Everything all right?"

"Everything's fine! You worry too much."


-x-x-x-​

"I guess this must be how you felt," I say, my eyes going to the glowing Erdtree in the distance. "It's hard to know where to start. Especially since I have nothing to point to and say 'that's what I'm talking about.' You could at least just gesture vaguely at the Erdtree."

"Before you continue," Melina shoots a glance at Roderika. The girl doesn't seem to be paying attention to us, but I know how hard it is not to hear a conversation happening just a few meters away when there's nothing else to take your attention. "Are you sure you do not wish to have this conversation elsewhere?"

I shrug. "I'm not gonna tell you anything that's all that secret. If you think there's a danger to people spreading rumors about me, I guess I don't mind having this conversation on the other side of the road or something."

She considers me, then Roderika. "No," she says slowly. "I suspect rumor of you will already be spreading with Varré and Kalé. If you do not fear spreading what you share, I see no reason to be concerned."

"All right." I pause for a minute, gather my thoughts. "I guess I need to start by defining a term. You've probably heard me and Chester talking about paracausality."

"Yes. I gather it is a word for magic?"

"Not wrong, but it's more complicated than that. I don't rightly know how you define magic—what makes a phenomenon magical, as opposed to just unexplained. Paracausality, there's a pretty clear definition. Something that's paracausal is anything that can violate the principle of cause and effect."

Melina breathes in sharply. "You reject the Law of Causality."

I look at her. "Don't think I didn't hear them capital letters. Causality is a thing here? More than just the way things work?"

"It is one of the two principles of the Golden Order that defined Queen Marika's world." Melina's voice is soft, and she's staring at me with something… hard to define in her eye. She doesn't look afraid or even displeased. If anything, she looks warily intrigued. "The Fundamentalists defined the Golden Order as being comprised of the Laws of Causality—that cause should follow effect, and that effects should branch forth from causes like the limbs of the Erdtree—and of Regression—that all things, from men to beasts to inert stone, seek to return to their roots, to the places and things from which they came."

"For you were made from dust, and to dust you shall return." Winchester's voice is considering. "That's from a pre-Golden Age religious text Arch lent me a few years ago. Interesting."

It is interesting. It might be nothing, but I haven't forgotten that we still don't know how humans got onto this world in the first place. If some paracausal being—a Disciple, or a god, or even something neutral like an Ahamkara—scooped a bunch of humans off Earth and dropped them here a thousand years or more ago, it would make sense that maybe some fragments of Earth's religions survived. Especially given their language seems to have hardly drifted.

"Well, cause and effect still matter," I allow. "I mean, if I punch someone in the face, they're still gonna want to punch me back. Me being paracausal doesn't change that. But it does allow me to do things like—like create fire without fuel, or jump without my feet touching the ground, or harness the potential energy of a black hole without swallowing half the planet. And from what little I've seen, all of your magic is also paracausal."

"Those Runes you've been picking up every time you kill something," Winchester says. "They're lossless encoded information without any receptacle for that information to be encoded into. Like engrams without glimmer."

"There you go," I say, nodding at him. "And the debris field Radahn suspended above the planet—first of all, it's invisible until you get into the planet's gravity well, and second of all, they don't obey the causal laws of gravity and momentum at all. So whatever magic he used to hang them there is also paracausal."

"Yet the stars hang in their place because of his magic," Melina says. "Is that not causation?"

"Sure. But it doesn't obey the underlying physical principles of how causation is supposed to work. Without paracausality, effects have predictable causes. If a stone monolith crumbles, it's because some force broke it. If you know enough about the world, you can figure out what that force was—gravity, tension, whatever. Paracausality breaks that. If I snap my fingers, the only physical forces that should causally have been created are the pressure between my thumb and finger, and then the impact of my finger against my palm. But I can snap my fingers and make the stone monolith crumble. Cause and effect, yes, but breaking the underlying principles of why the cause creates the effect. Make sense?"

"I suppose so," Melina says. "But how do you know that you are violating the underlying principles of the world, rather than merely harnessing those you do not yet understand?"

I grin at her. "I have got to introduce you to Parvati once I get in touch with her. There are two reasons why I know paracausality is real. First, Warlocks have done experiments—I don't understand most of them, but they managed to use the Light to get particles to disobey the underlying principles of quantum mechanics, the most foundational facts of the causal universe. Second, there's paracausal effects that are a hell of a lot more impressive than just breaking a hunk of rock."

"What sort of effects?"

"Well, that's where the story starts. I won't bore you with the billions of years of subjective history before humans and Guardians ever came along. For us, the story starts a little less than two thousand years ago, when a shape appeared in our solar system. At first, human astronomers thought it was a comet or asteroid, but it didn't obey the laws of gravity. The first time humans stepped foot on a world other than Earth, it was to catch up with it when it reached Mars. It turned out to be a machine—a white sphere probably about as big across as the Erdtree is tall. We called it the Traveler, and it had come to change our world.

"That was our first exposure to paracausality, and it was the start of our Golden Age. Human lifespan tripled. We started to gain access to paracausal principles—basic and predictable ones, sure, but still paracausal. We learned to refine electrical currents into stable Arc energy, to clarify heat into Solar energy, to harness the nuclear forces into Void energy. We started colonizing the other worlds in the Sol system almost as fast as the Traveler terraformed them. The Golden Age lasted almost seven hundred years." My smile, almost nostalgic for a time my eyes had seen that I'd never remember, twists. "It ended in a matter of days."

"You were attacked," Melina says softly.

"We call it the Collapse," I say. "The Traveler was being chased. Some people had dreams about it, apparently, but no one really knew. Not until it was too late. It had enemies—well, one enemy, though we didn't know that until much, much later. It called itself the Witness, and its Disciples came to try and destroy the Traveler, and our whole civilization with it. Turns out, the Traveler had gone to thousands, maybe tens or hundreds of thousands of systems before us and been chased away by the Witness and its Black Fleet every time. The civilizations it left behind were laid to waste. Every time before Sol, it left when the Black Fleet caught up with it. But at Sol, something changed.

"I still don't fully know what happened. Only two or three people are still alive who do, and none of them are telling. But for whatever reason, the Traveler stood its ground and fought off the Black Fleet. It went dormant after that, but not before giving humanity one last gift." I nod to Winchester, hovering near the Site of Grace. "The Ghosts."

"We were created knowing what we were for," Winchester says. "We'd been sent out to find the dead, and resurrect them. When we scan a body—or even just a grave, if it's been long enough—we get a… feeling for the person they were before they died. Nothing about their history, just a sense for who they were. When we find someone who feels compatible with us, we funnel our Light into them. It reconstructs the body and breathes life into it, but wipes away any memories of the life before they died."

"And Chester found me," I continue. "That was centuries ago—just a few decades into what we call the City Age, after the Last City had been built under where the Traveler came to rest. Lot's changed since then, especially recently." I summon a Solar knife and idly flip it between my fingers, trying to figure out how to continue the story from there. "We Guardians see it as our duty to defend the City from its enemies. That includes gods like the Witness, and more mundane—causal—enemies like the Cabal and Vex."

"And what are those?" Melina asks.

"There were four general groups of aliens that started harassing the survivors after the Collapse. There were the Cabal, an interstellar empire trying to expand into the system. The Vex, an ancient network of machines that can sort of travel through time by simulating the past and future with near-perfect accuracy. The Eliksni, a race chosen by the Traveler before humanity that was chasing after it after their own Collapse—they called it the Whirlwind. And the Hive. They were probably the most dangerous, because unlike the others, they were paracausal, just like Guardians. They worshipped the Witness, followed it to Sol and wanted to drive us to extinction because, to them, that was the moral thing to do."

"And you prosecuted this war on four fronts?" Melina asks. "With only a single city remaining to your people, you held against these ancient empires and horrors?"

I grin. "A single Guardian is more dangerous than damn near anything any of those groups can put on the field. A few things could compete. Some of the oldest Cabal commanders and Eliksni Kells. Vex Axis Minds. The Hive gods. But yeah, against their armies? We held."

"Then this 'Light' you wield must be powerful indeed," Melina says. "Precisely what is it?"

"Complicated answer," I say. "Short and simple version is that the Light is a paracausal force that underlies the universe. Guardians can wield it to fuel our abilities. Typically, we filter it down to one of three aspects that are easier to work with than raw Light: Solar, Arc, and Void. Each of those is complicated, too, but again, basics.

"The simplest version of the elements that every Kinderguardian learns is that Solar is fire, Arc is electricity or lightning, and Void is gravity and fields. It's more complicated than that, especially in the case of Void, but them's the basics. Myself, I'm a Gunslinger by training, which is a way of using Solar Light mostly. I've trained as an Arc-specialized Bladedancer in the past, too, but that was a long time ago. I can use all of the elements, but I'm most comfortable with Solar. In the past few years, Guardians have started using the Darkness, too, but I've never had the knack for it."

"Darkness?" Melina sounds startled more than curious. "You wield the magic of your enemies, then?"

"When we need to." I force myself to call on the cold depths buried inside me. Crystal creeps up my hand, freezing my burning knife solid. "We learned to use the Darkness alongside the Light a few years back. I've never used it as much. There're two aspects of the Dark that I know how to use, like the three aspects of Light. This one's Stasis—ice, basically, if you don't care about the philosophy. The other one's Strand, and it's… harder to explain. Threads and connection." I flex my fingers, shattering the crystal, then spread them to reveal a cat's cradle of green threads between them.

"I see," Melina says, her eye on the green lattice. Then her gaze turns to my face. "Each of these, then, is akin to a different school of magic? To my mind, it seems to resemble the distinction between the draconic incantations and those of the Erdtree, or the crystal and night sorceries."

"Dunno if I can speak to that," I say. "Are those different schools philosophically different, or just separate collections of spells?"

"Both, as a rule," Melina says. "Though not always. The incantations of most Erdtree scholars share their root philosophy with those of the Fundamentalists, but the understanding of the Fundamentalists is deeper and their incantations are therefore different."

"Sounds similar, then."

She considers me. I meet her eyes, flickering in the irregular light of the Site of Grace. Outside the little shack, rain has started to fall, pattering on the grassy turf like a billion tiny footfalls.

"I confess, Barrett," Melina says, "I did not take you for a philosopher."

"Sometimes philosophy is a matter of life and death for a Guardian," I tell her, thinking of Ahamkara, Weapons of Sorrow, and the Osmium Gods.

"Indeed." Melina turns her gaze back on the Site of Grace. She's silent for a long moment before speaking again. "I am sorry that you have been sundered from your people," she says. "From the city you defend. But I confess, I am glad that you have arrived here."

"I've hardly done anything yet," I point out.

"But you have shown yourself capable," she says. "And, more importantly, sincere. There are hundreds, perhaps thousands of Tarnished scattered throughout the Lands Between. There are hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of humans, demi-humans, and other thinking beings living in these lands. And yet none of them attempted to fell those crucifixes. Not one sought to show mercy to those condemned to linger, denied the peace of Erdtree burial. Not even me."

"In fairness, no one else has a Weapon of Sorrow on this planet," I point out. "At least, I sure hope they don't."

"They could still have cut the wretches down," Melina said. "Even merely allowing them to touch the ground would eventually set them free. Burying them would have been faster still. But none did so."

"You can't know that no one is doing that," I say. "It's a big continent."

"And yet I never saw any try to relieve that pain while I wandered with Torrent, seeking one who might help to relieve my own burdens." She meets my gaze. "I may not understand every aspect of your tale, but I suspect this is the heart of your creed. That you do not turn away, you do not allow yourself to be distracted from the pain of those who have no recourse or relief. Not even by your own pain."

If I had blood and skin instead of Clarified radiolaria and plating, I'd be flushing by now. "We do our best," I say. "A Guardian who doesn't try to protect people isn't a Guardian at all, just another Risen."

"I only hope that your determination will hold," she says. "At least until our pact is concluded and you leave this world. And that, when you do, you do not forget the plight of the innocent here entirely."

"Never." I sit back. "You got any other questions?"

"Not for now," she says. "Though I am sure we both have much to learn of one another. But for now, we should rest—assuming you yet intend to assault Castle Stormveil on the morrow?"

"There's no way we're getting Godrick to give up his Great Rune without a fight, right?"

"Not only will he never willingly surrender his Great Rune," Melina says softly, "I suspect that, once you have seen the inside of his castle, you will not wish him to. You were affronted by the site of crucified criminals. But their fate is far kinder than that which Godrick inflicts upon many within his domain."

I grimace. "Like Roderika's companions?"

"Indeed," Melina says. "Rest, Barrett, and brace yourself. Tomorrow, you will face the Grafted."

I frown. "You won't be joining me?"

She grimaces. "Torrent will not fit in most of Stormveil," she says. "The corridors are too narrow, the ceilings too low, the floors too weak. And I… cannot move about on my own, without Torrent to anchor me."

"Okay," I say. "Don't worry about it. Are there Sites of Grace inside the castle?"

"I suspect so, though I have never entered Stormveil myself."

"Then I'll stop by those whenever I can, and we'll make sure we stay on the same page." I grin at her. "It'll be all right, Melina."

She lets out a breath. "I pray you are correct," she says.

We don't talk much after that before turning in for the night. It's easy to let the drizzle outside lull me to sleep.
 
Last edited:
There are two reasons why I know paracausality is real. First, Warlocks have done experiments—I don't understand most of them, but they managed to use the Light to get particles to disobey the underlying principles of quantum mechanics, the most foundational facts of the causal universe.
I imagine that Melina probably isn't super convinced by "these guys you've never heard of did some stuff I don't understand and proved that it breaks some rules you haven't heard of" but is like "let's just be polite and nod or else we could probably go back and forth on this all day"
 
I imagine that Melina probably isn't super convinced by "these guys you've never heard of did some stuff I don't understand and proved that it breaks some rules you haven't heard of" but is like "let's just be polite and nod or else we could probably go back and forth on this all day"
I suspect she basically equated it to some of the most learned about the Golden Order doing experiments which proved that the Golden Order allows things to happen which the world before it disallowed... But she also likely thought that it wasn't of the 'these laws are the only thing which allows everything to exist and they are being broken'. Because that's probably something like...

Maybe taking the Rune of Death which has been removed (and broken?) then tying the fragments of said Rune into the pre-existing laws which the Golden Order overrules in such a way the full effect of the Rune of Death is made a part of them which only fails to work if it is constantly being actively fought by the Golden Order. And said Rune can not be removed like it was from the Golden Order.

One is spectacular but pretty mundane for people of that skill. The other is 'how the fuck is that possible, it's NOT yet it HAPPENED, WTF?'
 
This is a very funny statement. It's absolutely wild to think of how Destiny's lore has developed, that the Vex are considered 'mundane.'
Vex are the absolute peak of mundane(causal) enemies in lore to the point that in a universe without Light and/or Dark(and other stuff derived from them) they would have been the Final Shape.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top