Each Star is a Point of Light-A Destiny/Mass Effect Fusion

I still just love how the Warlocks settle funding disputes with knife fights and big bro was surprised little sis went for the throat! As a big brother myself I can attest how decietful younger sisters can be, Blue shell throwing, Oddjob using harlot.

So does Ashley have her actual family or an adopted one?
 
Book 3: Chapter 6: Tomorrow Comes Today Pt 2
Chapter 6: Tomorrow Comes Today Pt 2


Tali felt a subtle sense of vertigo as the elevator lurched to a stop. The air filled with the sound of metal screeching and Tali could not help but wince at the noise. Keelah, she thought, you think the Guardians would take time to grease the gears. As the door squealed open, Tali glared at the autumn sun. Whatever good mood she'd had earlier in the morning had disappeared with Samantha Williams.

After the screaming had stopped, a consequence owed more to an aching throat than to a lack of fear, Samantha had calmed down enough for Ashley to assure her that Tali was in no way a dangerous and uncaring force of death like it seemed every alien in Sol was and offer her a place at the table. Any conversation after that was spent in awkward silence punctuated by Ashley's futile attempts at conversation. Samantha remained tightlipped with eyes fixed on the kitchen table whenever they didn't crawl towards the corners to peer at Tali. After twenty minutes, she decided she'd had enough and excused herself.

She slammed the door behind her as she left, something she felt guilty over immediately. Ashley had been nothing but wonderful. She wasn't mad at her. She was barely mad at Samantha. She was just mad. Mad and frustrated.

A flash of soft blue light came from the corner of her eye and the Ghost floated by her head.

"Look," it said in a facsimile of a woman's voice, "if you want to talk about what just happened there I can…"

Tali ignored her and walked forward. Hopefully the hunk of junk would take a hint and…

"OH, THAT FUCKING TEARS IT!"

Tali felt something the size of a handball slam into the back of her head hard enough to knock her off of her feet. She rolled onto her back and reached for her sidearm only to be hit on the side of the head, the blow hard enough for hairline cracks to form in her mask but not cause a breach. She fell onto her side and a small flash of light came from her belt. It faded quickly, taking her pistol with it. She looked up to see the Ghost glaring down at her with death in its eye. Tali felt a freezing cold sensation enter into her chest.

"You bigoted, close minded, hypocrite!" it shouted at her. "I decided to use the kid gloves cause of the whole "forced exile of your people" bullshit. But I am done. So done. What will it take for you to realize that I am not the thing you need to worry about right now!"

Tali glared. "You fake anger well. But all you are is wires."

The Ghost faked a calming breath. "Traveler, give me strength. Okay, looks like any sign of compassion on my part is just plain incomprehensible to you. I'm plastic, wires, and a small bit of Light for spice. So let's talk in a language you understand."

The Ghost glared at her. "I am a Ghost. The Ghost that raised your ungrateful ass from the dead. That means I am bound to you. As much as you are to me. So if you don't believe I can actually care about someone then maybe you can trust my sense of logic." It drew closer to Tali's face. "I am stuck with you. You fall then I'm alone at best and dead at worst. So…" A beam of light shot out from the drone's eye and a soft glow enveloped Tali's mask. After a moment, it stopped and the crack had disappeared without a trace. "I will take care of you. Help channel your Light. Heal your wounds. Bring you back. In exchange, you protect me and keep every pirate, butcher, and miscellaneous psycho from hollowing out my shell with a rusty blade." The glare faded into a flat gaze. "Deal?"

Tali stared at it. The logic the machine operated under made sense. She'd heard that it was rare for a Ghost to find a second Guardian after the loss of one and that would mean the drone would be defenseless without her. Its self-interest would demand that she remain healthy and whole.

She glared at it. "Deal."

"Good," the Ghost said as it transmatted Tali's pistol into her hand. "Now we can actually get to work." A flash of light and the Ghost returned to its usual place in her suit's system.

Tali, for her part picked herself up and brushed herself off. As she did so she reflected on the new status quo that had just been forged. She didn't like it but it would work until she could figure out something, anything, else. Everything in place, she made her way towards the Pheonix Pillars HQ.

-----

Sir Peresvet-13 kept his eye on the girl from his hiding spot. Hunters liked to think they held the monopoly on stealth among the Guardian classes but you didn't survive as long as he had by running into the middle of an enemy formation shouting all the time.

No matter how fun that was.

Staring at the spot where he'd seen the confrontation between Ghost and Guardian, he felt relief enter him. He hadn't been enthused at the assignment of the kinder to his Order but he was nothing if not a loyal Titan and he'd do his duty to the Tower come hell or high water. Her stubborn paranoia regarding Artificial Intelligence had left him in despair. But now…

"Maybe she can be taught."
*****

I am sorry that not only is this snippet late but that it is also so short. I'm just having a lot of trouble writing this chapter and I am more convinced than ever that I'm going to need to split this chapter up when the time comes. I also might need to expand Liara's storyline in this but I'm not sure how so I'd take constructive criticism on how I would do so.

Anyway, this isn't the last snippet from this chapter. There's a really critical scene or two coming up that again I don't know where to put them so they're going in this chapter for now. Anyway, I hope to see you guys next week.
 
Sooo... who's for sticking Tali and Cayde in a broom closet for an hour or two and seeing if her opinion on AI not having feelings changes? For science...
 
Sooo... who's for sticking Tali and Cayde in a broom closet for an hour or two and seeing if her opinion on AI not having feelings changes? For science...

Cayde would be dead several times over. Then I suspect Tali will die.

And if her attitude doesn't improve soon it might be permanently.

It wouldn't improve her opinions on Ghosts and Exos at all.
 
And if her attitude doesn't improve soon it might be permanently.
Honestly when compared to canon ME2 Tali it's surprising how immature she is here. That one (if you went impartial paragon) actually got along with Legion (of course after having him/it at gunpoint). Then again that Tali went through things that this version never went through (like saving the galaxy and having years of experience leading others) so they are basically two different people.
 
Keep in mind that Tali is literally a teenager right now (I think).

Late teens to early twenties. Tali was 24 in the first Mass Effect, and had been on her Pilgrimage for a while, and i'm willing to bet that this take place a bit before her appearance in that alley.
 
Okay, I have to get something off my chest.

How exactly is Tali's view of AIs unjustified? Her opinions aren't irrational paranoia by Mass Effect standards, they're proven scientific fact. ME AIs don't have emotions under normal circumstances, and every AI in the entire series is either amoral, uninterested in any sort of working relationship with organics, or outright hostile. The only AI in the entire original ME trilogy that isn't one of these to start is EDI, and she's built with a combination of an existing AI seed and Reaper tech that's so far more advanced than anything in existence that it might as well be magic. The Geth aren't hostile until the Heretics come around, but they also aren't interested in dealing with organics and aren't capable of comprehending organic behaviors or emotions. To the point that they have to run social experiments on unknowing and unwilling participants just to try to figure out some semblance of understanding of organic irrationality. Hell, Legion is so baffled by feeling emotions that he literally cannot process having them at first.

Meanwhile the Destiny humans have an incredibly skewed view of AIs. The Exos were created during the Golden Age with technology just handed to them by the Traveler, letting them skip all of the intervening steps in having to develop artificial intelligence and just automatically giving them AIs that are fully capable of having a normal emotional range and behaving like organics, something the ME races can't do because they don't have a glowing ball of space magic and wisdom to give them things. They have to struggle through learning how to make AIs work through trial and frequent error. Errors that almost always end with a hostile AI that needs to be stopped, further reinforcing the idea that AIs will never work without becoming hostile. Additionally, Ghosts are created straight from the Traveler's Light and powered by space magic that humans trust religiously. It's unfair to be mad at Tali for not liking or trusting them when all of humanity's good fortune with AIs comes from the giant glowing ball of space magic that gave them all of their super powers and technology. Guardians, the people who are constantly badgering her over this, are far from unbiased because they exist because of the Traveler and all knowledge of it comes from fragments of Golden Age data and what the Ghosts tell them, which is hardly an unbiased source. Even if we as readers (or players of the games) know the Traveler and the Ghosts and the Exos doesn't have ulterior motives and are trustworthy and friendly, Tali doesn't, and she's being badgered to accept that on blind faith and then treated like the bad guy when she doesn't.

Every time Tali shows up, this story starts committing the worst sin a crossover can: it goes out of its way to make one side look worse than the other.
 
Last edited:
Tali's view aside, what about the rest the exploration crew? How are they taking not just the AIs but the whole Space God hanging over their heads and all the crazy magic?
 
Tali's view aside, what about the rest the exploration crew? How are they taking not just the AIs but the whole Space God hanging over their heads and all the crazy magic?

Also a good question. I don't think we've seen anyone from the Citadel crew other than Tali, Garrus, and Liara (who are Guardians and doing exclusively Destiny/Guardian related things) since they arrived at the City. It feels like all of the ME elements and characters are being ignored to focus exclusively on Destiny stuff.
 
Quick thing I just wanted to mention kamenhero25 but the thing with AI isn't exactly true, there used to be AI's living on the Citadel with the other species. However after the Morning War where the Geth fought to protect themselves from genocide the Council had C-Sec kill them all so... yeah.
 
They were new, peaceful AIs trying to argue for survival, the Council killed them, and they covered it up to kept the comfortable 'evil robot' belief going.

As for Tali, I think a good idea for the story would be to have her note, out loud, that the Quarian view on AI is like the City's view on aliens, made through painful experiences. But if one of those has the potential to not always be true, then just maybe...
 
Quick thing I just wanted to mention kamenhero25 but the thing with AI isn't exactly true, there used to be AI's living on the Citadel with the other species. However after the Morning War where the Geth fought to protect themselves from genocide the Council had C-Sec kill them all so... yeah.


To be fair, I've only played the Citadel DLC once and didn't remember that. Additionally, this brings up the fact that you're applying knowledge that we only have as outside viewers and assuming that it's common knowledge, when it's clearly not. Even taking this into account, there's no way in hell Tali actually knows this happened or is true. So as far as she knows, AIs are entirely hostile, and with what happened to her people, she has plenty of evidence to support her beliefs.

They were new, peaceful AIs trying to argue for survival, the Council killed them, and they covered it up to kept the comfortable 'evil robot' belief going.

As for Tali, I think a good idea for the story would be to have her note, out loud, that the Quarian view on AI is like the City's view on aliens, made through painful experiences. But if one of those has the potential to not always be true, then just maybe...

This. If the narrative wasn't actively supporting the City characters and treating Tali like she's wrong, I wouldn't be bringing it up. It makes sense of the humans/Exos to not share Tali's views and to think she's being paranoid. If it was restrained to only being in-character for them, then it's simply character conflict. But the narrative itself is supporting them and framing it like Tali needs to learn a lesson, while being completely tone-deaf to the fact that her views on AIs are no different to the City's views on aliens, but acting like she's wrong and they're not.
 
Last edited:
Quick thing I just wanted to mention kamenhero25 but the thing with AI isn't exactly true, there used to be AI's living on the Citadel with the other species. However after the Morning War where the Geth fought to protect themselves from genocide the Council had C-Sec kill them all so... yeah.

That event has been forgotten by all thanks to the Council. That's why we learn about it in the vault.
 
Okay, I have to get something off my chest.

How exactly is Tali's view of AIs unjustified? Her opinions aren't irrational paranoia by Mass Effect standards, they're proven scientific fact. ME AIs don't have emotions under normal circumstances, and every AI in the entire series is either amoral, uninterested in any sort of working relationship with organics, or outright hostile. The only AI in the entire original ME trilogy that isn't one of these to start is EDI, and she's built with a combination of an existing AI seed and Reaper tech that's so far more advanced than anything in existence that it might as well be magic. The Geth aren't hostile until the Heretics come around, but they also aren't interested in dealing with organics and aren't capable of comprehending organic behaviors or emotions. To the point that they have to run social experiments on unknowing and unwilling participants just to try to figure out some semblance of understanding of organic irrationality. Hell, Legion is so baffled by feeling emotions that he literally cannot process having them at first.

Meanwhile the Destiny humans have an incredibly skewed view of AIs. The Exos were created during the Golden Age with technology just handed to them by the Traveler, letting them skip all of the intervening steps in having to develop artificial intelligence and just automatically giving them AIs that are fully capable of having a normal emotional range and behaving like organics, something the ME races can't do because they don't have a glowing ball of space magic and wisdom to give them things. They have to struggle through learning how to make AIs work through trial and frequent error. Errors that almost always end with a hostile AI that needs to be stopped, further reinforcing the idea that AIs will never work without becoming hostile. Additionally, Ghosts are created straight from the Traveler's Light and powered by space magic that humans trust religiously. It's unfair to be mad at Tali for not liking or trusting them when all of humanity's good fortune with AIs comes from the giant glowing ball of space magic that gave them all of their super powers and technology. Guardians, the people who are constantly badgering her over this, are far from unbiased because they exist because of the Traveler and all knowledge of it comes from fragments of Golden Age data and what the Ghosts tell them, which is hardly an unbiased source. Even if we as readers (or players of the games) know the Traveler and the Ghosts and the Exos doesn't have ulterior motives and are trustworthy and friendly, Tali doesn't, and she's being badgered to accept that on blind faith and then treated like the bad guy when she doesn't.

Every time Tali shows up, this story starts committing the worst sin a crossover can: it goes out of its way to make one side look worse than the other.

I'm going to start with saying you're right in so far that the way I've been writing the story has been guilty of putting too much on Tali. Now we disagree on the details (I.E the role of the Traveler in AI development and why exactly the City accepts synthetics so easily. The way the Citadel treats AI and how I think its merely a symptom of a much larger problem) but overall the effect on the story is the same. It becomes annoying and imbalanced.

My only real defense so far is that I didn't mean for it to become so one-sided. I actually am trying to paint the the City-dwellers (Guardians included) as xenophobic assholes (but not so much as to make them Hate Sinks or otherwise make them irredeemable) and the whole thing as a morass of prejudice and bullshit that needs to be overcome by both sides so that they all can become stronger. But I'm trying to do it subtly (Matrix Dragon mentioned Tali pointing out the hypocrisy which is out of character and, I think, lazy) and with actual effort on the character's parts.

Now when it comes to Tali and her Ghost I don't think I'm being that bad. The fact of the matter is that Tali's life is linked to her Ghost now and that's something that while horrifying to her can't really be changed. The lesson isn't a simple "bigotry is bad" (especially since Tali still isn't fully admitting defeat here and I have very specific plans for the chain of events that lead her to accepting her Ghost and giving her the name Chatika vas Paus) in this case its more "don't let your prejudices fuck with the thing you need to live".

Now most of the problems come from the fact that, as I've been saying, this whole chapter has been incredibly difficult for me to write and I used my prerogative as a writer in the middle of a first draft to say, "Fuck it, I just want it on the page. I'll fix the goddamn thing later." This is a big reason why I use the forum as my first draft repository, it allows you all to show me these fuck ups before I become locked into them. Which brings me to the next problem.


Also a good question. I don't think we've seen anyone from the Citadel crew other than Tali, Garrus, and Liara (who are Guardians and doing exclusively Destiny/Guardian related things) since they arrived at the City. It feels like all of the ME elements and characters are being ignored to focus exclusively on Destiny stuff.

You know how people say it's a feature not a bug? This isn't that. It's more like a bug that I knew was going to be there and I decided to roll with it as much as possible. Now, that's not to say I didn't make changes. I realized that something like this might happen and I made radical alterations to the story beyond Book 3 to eliminate it. But I figured Book 3 could tank the flaw for a number of reasons. One was a matter of themes. I didn't name Welcome to the Jungle just for the classic rock reference, although that was a nice bonus. It's a story about three people brought into a weird place (having already been altered by it) and learning how to adapt to it. Part of that is trying to figure out where they stand in it as individuals. Its why Tali, Liara, and Garrus are away from each other through this first part of it.

Another issue is one of pacing. Small spoilers in bound, Welcome to the Jungle takes place in a period of 5-6 days. There's not a lot of room for the crew in there. At least, the OC crew. I have plans for Wrex (Why wouldn't I? It's Wrex.) but I considered the OC crew's screentime as a necessary casualty (although once I hit Book 4 I intend to write a canon omake series about their experiences in the City).

The third reason is that I really wanted to put the spotlight on the City. Now, I love Destiny's lore, I wouldn't be writing this if I didn't, but it has big flaws. One of those is how little it deals with the City. Oh, it's there and we learn a little about its history like the Concordant Coup or the multiple battles that have been fought to keep it standing but it never becomes a living place that we care about. Cause in canon Destiny the City is a friggin mcguffin.

Its important as an excuse for the player to shoot shit or as a source of hope in the lore but it doesn't matter to the story beyond that. We don't get acquainted with its culture except for small scraps like the Day of the Lost or the Dawning (which in turn are usually used to find more reasons to shoot shit) and we never really get to know the people who live there who aren't part of the Tower. A lot of the worldbuilding in this Book is stuff I've been pulling out of my head because the City might as well be empty in the canon lore.

But for Destiny to work as a story then the City has to matter. The reader has to care about it and the people who call it home. Enough to be invested in its continued survival and prosperity. So that's really what I'm trying to do with Book 3.

To solve these issues, I've decided to

1. Take a week off writing. This has been a bad week for me and work was a huge pain in the ass to the point that I was forced to work during my weekend. So nothing this week.

2. Work on my other fic for a week or two. Cleanse my brain of Each Star for a bit so I can come back to it fresh.

3. Rewrite this last chapter. One of the good things that came out of all of this is that I really started to think about how I could fix some of the problems you brought up and I figured out how I could do it and make the story better. So when we come back I won't be posting the next chapter. I'll instead post a reworked Tomorrow Comes Today.

So that's the plan. In other news, still looking for betas for the second draft of Books 1 and 2. Annoyed that I keep bringing it up? So am I! So volunteer today!
 
My only real defense so far is that I didn't mean for it to become so one-sided. I actually am trying to paint the the City-dwellers (Guardians included) as xenophobic assholes (but not so much as to make them Hate Sinks or otherwise make them irredeemable) and the whole thing as a morass of prejudice and bullshit that needs to be overcome by both sides so that they all can become stronger. But I'm trying to do it subtly (Matrix Dragon mentioned Tali pointing out the hypocrisy which is out of character and, I think, lazy) and with actual effort on the character's parts.

I think a major issue with this is that we're not inside their heads. We see Tali's inner thoughts all the time, along with the other protagonists, but not the people around them. By using the third person limited view (third person narrative, only describing what that character knows), you've inadvertently set up a situation where Tali's the only one being ragged on. Every time she's in a room with an Exo (I know that's an exaggeration, but you get my meaning), there's an inner monologue about not trusting them. But we never see anyone else having the same thoughts about her because we never see anyone else's thoughts in the same depth. And it seems that in your efforts to not make them too openly xenophobic, you've gone too far in the other direction. Without there being moments of open xenophobia, you've inadvertently turned them into bigger hypocrites who will dig up other people's prejudices, but bury their own and act high and mighty about it. Frankly, having them be more openly assholes to the aliens would make them less hate-able because then the narrative is being fair to both sides instead of being tilted toward the City.

I think that having a chapter that's literally nothing but Tali's issues is a big part of it. Burying the City's xenophobia in the middle of other things while having Tali's issues being the sole focus of a section makes it look like you're harping on Tali's problems far more than you're intending to. My suggestion for the re-write would be to make it significantly longer and give her more to do during it. Let the argument with her Ghost be a single scene in a larger story so the narrative is giving her fair treatment and showing what else is going on in her life and her positives, not being a single scene of nothing but getting chewed out for her flaws.

After you're break of course. Have a good rest from what you're working on.
 
Last edited:
Final Post and Summary
Okay, I'm going to start this off by saying I wanted to have this post up in July but between a brief stint with depression that I'm just pulling myself out of, difficulties with writing, and my usual issues with procrastination it took til almost a year since my last post to do this. My apologies.

So, anyway, it should shock no one that I'm declaring Each Star to be dead. Now, it was something I was struggling with for awhile. On the one hand I didn't want to disappoint people wanting to see the story continue but I also found more and more reasons I kept wanting to stop writing it and move onto something else.

For one thing, I was falling out of love with the Destiny franchise. I had high hopes for Bungie's progression of the story when Destiny 2 came out but as time went on and the lore developed and Destiny 2 kept getting involved in controversy I just fell out of it. I don't like the direction Bungie has taken the story (CoS was underwhelming, Warmind made me roll my eyes, and Forsaken fixed nothing). There were other reasons too.

The biggest reason is probably the simply fact that the story (as stories do) grew in the telling but it didn't just grow. It became so massive I realized it would take the better part of a decade to finish and, frankly, I did not want to work on this that long. I had other ideas I wanted to pursue and the sheer amount of labor finishing this would have taken (even after I sliced no less than six books out because they were essentially Destiny novelizations with ME characters) was more than I could give.

There were other reasons. Work on the second draft of the first two books pretty much stalled due to lack of beta-ing interest. I started having doubts about what I was writing. So on and so forth.

Frankly, if I could do it again I might get rid of the first couple of books and get to what I now see as the center of the fic (as in the pole it would have spun around), the Hive War. I also might have given Shepard more to do on her own. In hindsight, I see her as a bit static compared to others. But it is what it is.

Now, I bet you're asking why it took me almost a year to simply announce the end of the fic. Well, I didn't just want to leave you all twisting in the wind so I have collated and collected all of my notes and wrote them out. It was supposed to be just around 2k-4k words but...

It grew.

It grew a lot.

So, it is in this post that I present the collected notes of Each Star is a Point of Light (separated into spoilers for easy viewing). Now, the notes get less detailed as we go along because there was a bunch of stuff I hadn't planned down to detail. After Book 8 I stopped having them in books because at that point I hand't organized them into a larger narrative structure and so they are sperated by character arc. In spite of that, I hope you all enjoy it anyway.

Well, let's get on with the show.

The revised version of "Tomorrow Comes Today" opens with Liara working on her lecture alongside the two assistants of (doctor) from the omake "I Shall Report All of the Things I've Seen Though I Know I Will Not Be Believed" (an effort on my part to include the crew of the Long-Sight in this Book) they talk for a bit about all the strange things they've come to see in the City to be interrupted by Scheherazade coming to see Liara. She invites Liara out to tea, the first step to her becoming Liara's primary love interest.

The two assistants smile awkwardly during the whole thing as Liara remains oblivious of Sadie's romantic interest. As they both leave the two assistants talk about what they've just seen. (The turian) admits some disgust regarding the idea of dating a synthetic while (the asari) says to keep an open mind. The scene ends with the (turian) joking that she just wants to learn if asari can bond with Exo.

Liara and Sadie arrive at the tea house Saide frequents (a small Iranian place that looks a bit like something out of the middle ages due to a bunch of cultural City stuff I'll probably write about in a small lore-essay soon) only for the owner to (with as much respect as he can muster since Sadie's a friend/Guardian) that he won't serve aliens. It's only by Sadie pulling the "I'm a fucking Guardian" card that they manage to get a seat. Sadie is mortified but Liara (whose maintained an admirable amount of composure) says its fine.

Sadie is confused by this and Liara explains about her history as an asari "pureblood" and that she actually finds the obvious scorn of the City-dwellers to be a breath of fresh air compared to the poisoned smiles of her fellow asari. Sadie comes away with a new respect for Liara and Liara feels closer to Sadie, seeds firmly planted for a further relationship to bloom.

Tali's storyline continues much the same though a finished version of Tomorrow Comes Today ends with Tali growing tired of her treatment at the hands of Kristofor and striking him across the face. This is considered the challenge for a duel in Titan circles and it ends with Tali and Kristofor twirling around each other at the top of the Wall. It's a tough fight but Tali wins, a feat which earns her the respect of the Phoenix Pillars, with many claps on the back and even a small party thrown in her honor after the work shift is over. It is during the party that Tali is asked a very important question.

Why hasn't she taken her suit off, yet?

The story returns to Garrus, Shepard, and Samuel as they rush across the City trying to get to Chora's Den. On the way Shepard explains Jack's deal. Jack, in the Destiny verse, is a Channeler, someone with the ability to channel Light without being a Guardian. Now, a Channeler can only channel Light in small and specific ways and Shepard compares Jack's Light to a small spark in contrast to a Guardian's raging inferno. Jack's channeling takes the form of random visions that show her some form of information (sometimes the future sometimes not) that will benefit her or the people around her.

This is not such a good thing as it sounds as Jack's Destiny background is full of as much abuse as her Mass Effect background and it was only when Shepard guided her to the City that Jack began to go from violent wastelander (Jack's love of Mad Max came from somewhere) to den mother to the City's orphans.

Anyway, they get to Chora's Den in time to discover some of Fist's thugs attacking a woman dressed as a bartender. They intervene and the woman reveals that she's an undercover cop who was investigating Fist on suspicion of drug trafficking only to discover something much bigger, Fist being part of Elias Kellam's smuggling of alien and Golden Age artifacts. Knowing this was what Jack was guiding them to, the team jumps on the opportunity and call into Police HQ for a warrant, a process made easier by both Guardian involvement and the fact that Fist's men just tried to murder a cop.

As the sun sets on the City, the three Guardians bust into the Den. They find the place ready for them but no one actually expected Guardians (they thought they would send just normal cops) so they tear through them quickly (mostly non lethally with John Reese/ Shaheen Shaw levels of kneecapping) they find that they were distracted just long enough for Fist to escape out the back. Shepard calms a frustrated Garrus down by telling him she called a friend as an insurance policy. The scene switches to Fist running through the back alleys only to run headlong into a certain krogan mercenary.

They get Fist into an interrogation room, Samuel doing his best to convince him to talk. Garrus grouses about the fact that he can't go in there to break his legs and him and Shepard get into a small fight, continuing Each Star's adaptation of Garrus' canon storyline. It's interrupted by Wrex showing up. Shepard gives him a bag of glimmer with a promise of further payment if he sticks around. She sees trouble on the horizon and Wrex's gun could help. Wrex says yes, in part to keep Garrus out of trouble; in part because he needs work (the Vanguard have been reluctant to give him work for some reason).

The interrogation takes a while so they go back to the Tower to regroup and report in. There, Shepard finds Tali standing on the ledge of the Tower a foot out over the edge before bringing it back in. Shepard asks what she's doing and Tali says she's working up the courage to jump. Shepard nods like this is an everyday thing (because Guardian) while Tali laughs the laugh of the sane man trapped in the land of the mad. Shepard asks her what's wrong.

Tali explains that she wants to be free of her suit. Shepard presses (not quite getting it) and Tali explains. She was informed that Guardians don't get sick but due to Tali's rather cynical view of the universe and the quarians' place within it she didn't think that included her. Now that she's been confronted by the idea her fear of death and unrelenting craving to be free of her suit are warring within her. So she wants to test her immortality. Shepard gives her a speech about the pursuit of even the most forlorn of hope being a Guardian trait before climbing onto the ledge with her. They clasp hands and step off the ledge together.

They both revive on the balcony and Shepard takes in the City for a moment only to hear a faint hiss behind her. Her mouth drops open as she sees Tali. She's bald (her hair closely shaved to her scalp) and looks a little hollow eyed and gaunt from the lack of direct sunlight but there is the beginnings of beauty there and Shepard is a little bit surprised. Overall, this whole scene is a milestone in Tali and Shepard's relationship (being the moment Shepard began to see Tali as something more than a kid) and Tali's character development (this and the duel being the two moments where she began to shed two aspects of her old identity that made her life miserable: "to be forced endure prejudice and abuse demurely" and to be "forced into a suit and cut off of most tactile sensations".)

Garrus stands nearby, hidden around a corner, having miraculously not been seen by a veteran Hunter but overhearing the conversation.

Samuel calls in and says that he's got something. He tells them that Fist admitted to smuggling something in.T hree people from outside the Walls. Three people who he handed off to Ain (the murdered Titan). He doesn't know anything about the crate in the warehouse but the fact that he smuggled people in who have something to do with the murder of a Titan is enough to get a warrant for Kelham, although he needs time to prepare. Shepard and Garrus agree to come down there after they swing by Liara's lecture.

The whole crew has gathered to give Liara morale support and the conference starts well only for Garrus to get suspicious when he sees someone run away from the conference room during a quick intermission. He investigates to find a strange device hidden under the chair of one of the leading Warlocks attending the lecture. He is unsure of its purpose until he sees a countdown timer on it.

It's a bomb.

It is only with the assistance of the gathered Warlocks that the team is able to disarm it in time. The team takes the bomb, Liara in tow because her lecture was ruined and she is PISSED, to Ikora to have it examined. Kelham is apprehended and, faced with a lot of bad shit being linked to his involvement, he fesses up to having something, he didn't ask what cause he's not stupid, smuggled in from Venus. He's not sure who paid for the job as it was done through deniable channels. The mention of Venus causes something to click in Kaidan's head and he calls up Ikora who confirms his fears.

Kelham smuggled Vex technology into the City.

Worse, as they discover when Ikora calls them back for a briefing with OWL Sector (Hi, Mordin!), they're Vex Timeline Bombs with the ability to remove any caught in the blast radius from the timeline. Everyone freaks out at this (especially the aliens cause they didn't even know the Vex were a thing). Liara despairs that this plan might have been meant to kill the crew only to be interrupted by esteemed Warlock, Jack Harper. Otherwise known as the Illusive Man (although Ashley calls him Uncle Jack).

He drops another Vex Timeline Bomb on Ikora's desk. He found it in a meeting room in the Lawson Industries Headquarters that he'd been known to frequent. Whatever this is, it's not aimed at the aliens. Vex technology turns the conversation towards Osiris but Jack waves it off. Osiris has shown little care for the City since he's left and this isn't his style besides.

They say they can figure it out later, they need to figure out where the rest of the bombs are. Samuel meets up with them and they begin to comb the City. Garrus and Samuel get a garbled message over their Ghosts only to discover that the message has been jammed in some way. Some decryption and they find it's a 911 call from a small clinic in the Paris District. Thinking this has "weird coincidence" written all over it they decide to investigate.

They find a hostage situation inside. Garrus, Samuel, and Shepard (who showed up right after them) arrive and plan to infiltrate the place. There a familiar scene occurs with Garrus taking a risky shot to save a certain Dr. Michel from three gunmen.

Wait, is one of them wearing a cloa…oh no.

Michel is unharmed but Garrus gets his ass beat only to be saved by a timely trick of his Ghost and Big Damn Heroes Samuel and Shepard. Both of whom are pissed by the risk he took (a changed version of Garrus' introduction scene where Paragon!Shepard rips into him for risking Michel's life). It ends in a huge fight which ultimately ends with a humbled Garrus when Shepard takes him aside tells him he's not a mercenary or even a cop anymore. He's a Guardian. Which means he must act beyond reproach (well, mostly) as the City's people revere Guardians and Shepard can't stand the idea of letting them down.

The sequence ends with Garrus talking to his Ghost about what transpired, thanking her for saving his life, and giving her a name. Solana, after his sister.

Garrus' report completes the puzzle. Harper reveals that the Guardians, who were probably the three people Fist smuggled in, are Concordant agents, exiled after Lysander's Coup. The aliens ask what this means and we get an exposition dump.

The Concordant was founded early in the City Age by a small cabal of people that wanted an aggressive strategy to reclaim the Golden Age and ensure the City's safety. However, Lysander ended up creating a cult of personality (either accidently or on purpose depending on the history book) and it ended up being an avenue to enforce his personal agenda on the city. However, he always faced tons of pushback and political stonewalling even though he ran the third largest Faction in the City.

It all came to a head after the Battle of Twilight Gap. The districts the Fallen broke into had been full of Concordant voters and a lot of Concordant allied Guardians died defending the Walls. He got a bunch of guns together and drew up plans to overthrow the Speaker and the Consensus. But a group of Concordant members were appalled and they informed on him, stopping the coup before it really had time to get started (although there was some fighting in the streets). These people are known as the Twenty Righteous Men and became honored throughout the City, although there are those who have always been suspicious of them and their motives. Lysander and many of his followers were arrested, a bunch of Concordant Guardians and voters walked away from the Faction in disgust, and those that didn't chose exile.

There were three members of the Twenty Righteous Men at Liara's lecture and one was in Michel's clinic. Lysander's goal is clear. Remove the Twenty Righteous Men from the timeline and alter history so that Lysander's coup succeeds.

The Vanguard Heads outright say the plan is fucking ridiculous and a sign of Lysander's madness but that doesn't mean it won't play merry hell with the time/space continuum and cause Traveler knows how much damage. The Heads swear to have the full force of the Guardians, the Hidden, and Cayde's network of informants to chase the Concordant Guardians to the ground before they can succeed.

They team gets ready to leave only to notice Ashley isn't there. They look for her and Garrus and Tali find her in a graveyard near her home, desperately looking for a Timeline bomb. We get another exposition dump as Ashley explains her backstory.

Ashley's grandfather was a general in the City's militia and a high ranking member of the Concordant. He had had a flawless career until, during post-Twilight Gap cleanup operations with the Reef, he and Petra Venj ordered the bombing of a Devils position that ended up killing a bunch of Guardians, ruining both of their careers.

It was while in house arrest that he learned about the Concordant Coup. Being disgusted at the idea of overthrowing the City's legal government, General Williams escaped his house and made his way to the Tower. Unfortunately, he got caught up during the early stages of the fighting and by the time he got to the Tower the coup was pretty much over. There was a heavy skepticism over his true loyalties and many thought he'd only turned once the Coup went against the Concordant (untrue). He was discharged from the Militia and from there and things go on much like in Mass Effect canon. The Williams family lives in disgrace, Grandpa Williams dies in obscurity (pretty young by City standards too at the age of 75), and Ashley has been forced to fight for every scrap of status and respect she's ever earned.

This in part explains her increased closeness to Tali as, while they are not cruel to her, other Titans tend to keep her at arm's length due to this and having another outcast among the Titans makes her feel better.

Harper is revealed to have been eavesdropping and his relationship with Ashley and the Concordant is cleared up. Harper is an ex-Concordant member and one of the Twenty Righteous Men. Not only that, but he and General Williams were friends as well as colleagues. When everything went down Harper did what he could for the Williams family but he was dealing with suspicion himself since there were holes in his story regarding the coup and he'd been particularly close to Lysander but he became a close friend of the family to the point that Ashley and her sisters know him as Uncle Jack.

Jack and Tali's encouragement fills Ashley with new determination and everyone swears that one way or another the Concordant will be stopped. That's when they get the call that the Concordant Guardians have been spotted skulking near Representative Gallard's place. Bad news because Gallard is one of the Twenty Righteous Men (the only Concordant representative to remain in politics after the Coup).

This part's not all that planned out so I'll just say it ends with Gallard putting himself in extreme danger to assist the Guardians and they earn his respect. We also see behind the politician mask Gallard wears when we see that each accusation of traitor he gets ( a lot considering he's in politics) actually cuts incredibly deeply as he was one of Lysander's true believers and his act of treason shattered Gallard's heart into a thousand pieces. The whole scene ends with Gallard being loaded into an ambulance admitting he's a god awful judge of character (as in he was wrong to not only trust Lysander but to mistrust the Crew) and that he'll do what he can to change minds regarding the aliens in his district. The crew take the victory and head back to the Tower to rest up and regroup.

The Vanguard gives the team good news as the Hidden, Cayde's informants, and other Guardians have stopped numerous time-bombings and have no less than six Timeline Bombs in custody. Ikora presents the findings of her Hidden that reveals that the Concordant insurgents only have two bombs left. There's a moment of celebration but Zavala tells them that the danger hasn't passed.

His foresight is proven when a message is piped directly into the Tower. On the screen, Titan Matthews (that asshole who killed Garrus in Chapter 1) warns the Vanguard that they've wired one of the last two timeline bombs in a Residential District somewhere in the City. He warns everyone that if they try to interfere any further with their plans had better get ready for a bunch of innocent people to be erased from the timeline.

The whole damn Tower goes into panic mode as they try to deal with this and figure out what the hell the Concordant's planning to do with the last bomb. Everybody realizes that the anniversary of the Concordant Coup is being held at the Concordant's old Tower (the one used as a Crucible map) the next day (an event that would have been mentioned in the background numerous times) and a bunch of the Twenty Righteous Men tend to be there. Now, Harper, Gallard, and all the ones saved by the team won't be there but that's still around 15 (or 14 I've lost track) members and between them and the huge amount of people there and it's a disaster in the making.

They make a plan though. Samuel and Fireteam Cerberus (accompanied by Wrex just in case) will go hunt down the bomb while the main team track down the Concordant Fireteam.

This was a part that wasn't scripted out that well but it ends with the enemy escaping and the story segueing into the opening (in a chapter appropriately titled "…Where We Came In?"). Before the moment they crash though, Garrus realizes he's done all this before. The scene pauses around him and (taking a bit of a leap of faith) steps out of the car into midair. He doesn't fall though. He looks up and he finds himself in a dark void punctuated by distant points of Light that look like stars.

He blinks and he finds himself staring at a setting sun on the horizon. Besides him someone asks if he finds it beautiful. Garrus turns his head to see the Speaker.

Garrus asks what the hell is going on and Speaker explains. Garrus must have been killed recently and is having a vision now that he's beyond the veil. The Speaker also has the ability to see beyond the veil in his dreams which is how he got the job although there's little rhyme or reason for how he does it (to make it clear he's not communing with the Traveler here. "I never said it spoke to me" is in full play here). We then get some quick exposition as Thanatonautics enter into the story. Garrus wonders why he's being shown things he's already seen mixed with stuff he wasn't there for. The Speaker asks if the things he's seen had an effect on him.

Garrus realizes that they do. His growing bond with Shepard (which is beginning to bloom into romantic feelings but Garrus isn't fully cognizant of this yet), Tali and Liara seizing their futures on this alien world, the lessons he's learned. He's begun to see the City not just as a place to be while he waits to go back to Citadel Space. It's beginning to be his home.

The Speaker gives him a nod and some words of encouragement and Garrus wakes up on the hood of Samuel's squad car (remember in the revised Chapter 1 I would have changed it so Matthew threw Garrus off the tower). Samuel and the secondary team found the bomb and disarmed it and came to backup the others. They saw Garrus' corpse falling off the tower and caught him with their car. Together they head up for a final showdown with the Concordant Fireteam

We hit another point that's not scripted out that well but it the final fight proceeds with all of the Alien Guardians unlocking the full power of their Supers (symbolizing their trials under fire turning them into true Guardians) and ends with Garrus killing Matthews with a fully realized Golden Gun.

We enter the denouement. Any surviving members of the Concordant Fireteam (the Vanguard issued a kill order essentially meaning "if you get a shot at their Ghosts, take it" and I never figured out which ones bit it) are put into cryo-freezing. Everybody is given honors and the Alien Guardians are given a fast track to Full Guardian status. Wrex's effectiveness against the Concordant earns him "honorary Guardian" status, the first in history to do so (this in and of itself is a compromise with Zavala who will not allow mercenaries in Guardian operations but will let Ikora and Cayde strong arm him giving someone Guardian privileges).

Speaking of Zavala, he personally apologizes to the Alien Guardians for his vote back during Book 2 and commends their honor. Now, people in the thread tended to come down hard on Zavala (fair enough) but, in my opinion, Zavala isn't some stubborn prick. He's willing to eat crow when shown he's wrong and we have evidence of this in canon.

Finally, Shepard is finally commended for guiding the aliens and the nomads to the City and she is rewarded with her Armor Exotic, the Shinobu's Vow. The Book ends with everybody going out to eat. Garrus realizes he might be falling a little in love with Shepard and deigns to keep his mouth shut for the sake of Tali and its revealed that Wrex has been living with Lord Shaxx (a running gag across the book is people wondering where Wrex has been living and him not answering) beginning the saga of Wrex, Crucible Commentator and Beloved Grumpy Grandpa to All Guardians (who lovingly refer to the krogan as Ol' Deathless).

The Book ends with the newly christened Fireteam Normandy having a small makeshift party at Shepard's place (where we learn that Shepard's apartment is (design wise) the same one as she had in Mass Effect 3: Citadel) with the City celebrating the courage and heroism of Fireteam Citadel and the prospect of a bright future for our heroes.

But not quite, we see Ja'far-11 (who's been seen conferring with Ikora all throughout the book) exit his jumpship on the fiery steel surface of Mercury. He is met by three Titans, each of them wearing golden armor covered in sun related imagery. He asks to be taken to Osiris. The three refuse and tell him he'd better leave Mercury only to be interrupted by a voice coming over their comms that say he's been expected.

He's guided into an armed citadel filled with members of the Cult of Osiris and Sunbreakers (although the Sunbreakers have been with Osiris so long that they themselves are starting to take on a cultish vibe). There Ja'far meets with Brother Vance and a little bit is revealed. Ja'Far was once an apprentice to Brother Vance before the Exile of Osiris and stayed with the City rather than follow his mentor (the only one of Vance's apprentices to do so).

Ja'Far for his part is a loyal City Guardian…and a member of the Hidden. Because of his link to Vance he was chosen among the Hidden to be a sort of quasi-ambassador between Osiris and the City to be sent when they need something from him or just whenever they need to talk to him (something they don't necessarily like doing but sometimes their hands are tied). This is all done clandestinely of course. Ikora does this without Zavala's knowledge (she thinks Cayde knows but keeps his mouth shut) and doesn't want to deal with the fallout of him finding out.

They get into a small debate on the merits of the City vs. Osiris with Ja'Far being suspicious of the blind faith Osiris' followers have while Vance mocks the City's political and military apparatus which he believes is stagnating and will eventually collapse under the weight of the Darkness' onslaught.

Their argument is interrupted by Ja'Far being welcomed into a small lab containing Osiris himself doing some research. Osiris welcomes him and asks what the City wants with him today. Ja'Far takes a Timeline bomb from his bag and presses the detonation button.

Nothing happens.

Ja'Far asks Osiris just what the hell he was thinking.

At this point everything becomes clear. Osiris has agents within the City that keep him apprised of what's going on. When he heard about the aliens he knew Lysander (a xenophobe) would blow his top. Osiris took the opportunity and reached out to Lysander for the opportunity to "take revenge and ensure this monstrosity does not occur".

Ja'Far is confused by this and Osiris states that Lysander is an easy individual to manipulate if you know what he's about, especially when his ego is taken into account. He's also a little bit of a Sauron–figure in that he thinks people are as shitty and cynical as he is. While it did occur to Lysander that Osiris was just using him he probably thought he could turn it to his advantage.

Osiris explains that he helped Lysander draw up the plans for his bombing spree only to give him fake bombs. Ja'Far explodes at Osiris. All of this was a con? What for? Does he have any idea how many people could have gotten hurt? A Guardian was ki-

Ain Magdy (the Guardian "murdered" by the Concordant) walks through the door and gives his report to Osiris. He's been a member of the Cult the whole time (they were the ones who found him after his Ghost found him and they've all but raised him) and was sent into the City as an agent. He killed himself to draw attention to the Concordant Fireteam and spread the shards of dead Ghosts he'd collected to make it look like it stuck. Agents of the Cult snuck him out afterwards.

Ja'Far glares at Osiris and asks what was all this for.

Osiris puts down his tools (he's been working this whole time not even looking at Ja'Far) and tells Ja'Far of a vision he's had. A year or two before all of this Osiris was performing thanatonautic rituals when he had a vision of three stars crashing down to Earth. These three (although there is a fourth one not as bright as the others) would join with three stars that sprang from the Earth. Together they would banish the Darkness that had encroached upon the City. Then they would rise into the sky and Osiris beheld that they would be joined by a massive army of stars marching through the cosmos destroying Darkness everywhere they went.

He realized that each star was a Guardian.

Osiris figured out that the aliens were the three falling stars that initiated his vision. Everything he's set into motion is to ensure that the aliens would come to be not just accepted but respected among the City and thus be in a position to initiate the next stages of his prophecy.

Ja'Far shakes his head and leaves the citadel. He calls Ikora as he enters his jumpship and begins his report as Book 3 comes to a close.

With this Book we get the show on the road. From now on, the Hive War is front and center with the occasional flashback to explain the events between Books 3 and 4. Now except for a few set piece moments, I didn't plan out this bit a bunch (I was more focused on Book 5 and this and Book 6 ended up getting a bit of the short shrift with the exception of important subplots) but there are key points I'll note.

On Vulcara (the actual planet in the Victian System that the War takes place on. Something that was fixed in the second draft.), the plan that ends up coming out is that Garrus will help the turians hold out while Shepard heads out to tell the wider turian military (gathering in a nearby system) what's going on while getting them together with the Host that will support their reclamation of the planet.

Meanwhile on Aswe, Liara and Tali are able to kill the Hive Princess that cornered them at the end of Book 2. The asari are exuberant before Liara tells them that you need to do very specific things to permanently kill Ascendant Hive and that while Thizna is gone for now she'll probably be back.

It gets foggy at this point and I had a lot of ideas struggling together so I'll make this quick. The asari find out about the invasion in Victian and Liara susses out that while Savathun is invading the Republics, Xivu Arath is invading the Hierarchy. She suspects it to be a competition to see who will be the new Taken King. Whoever completes their genocide first will be crowned and then use the accumulated power from two genocides to march on the City. She also suspects that the turians and asari were targeted specifically to get back at Garrus and Liara for killing Oryx. Tali asks about the quarians and Liara tells her that they'll probably be the Hive's "victory lap" to be cleaned up after the extermination of the asari and turians.

On Vulcara, Garrus helps repel more Hive assaults (increasingly common as Xivu Arath has discovered Guardians on the planet) and remembers the death of Crota which delivers us into my adaptation of Crota's End which I will detail at a later date. When he snaps back, turian sensors detect a huge Hive force coming their way that they doubt they can overcome. Garrus prays that Shepard can make it through and get back in time. Liara and Tali find themselves in much the same situation as Savathun schemes her way past asari defenses.

The story on Aswe is a more psychological one as Liara and Tali are forced to confront how they've changed since they've left. This part of the story is vague in my head. Liara fights for her sanity while Tali is forced to come to terms that she has little in common with her fellow quarians. The latter comes to a head when one of them notice that Tali has surrounded herself with fully functional AIs. This triggers a huge argument, with a few quarians (members of Korris vas Qwib-Qwib's faction) backing her up but most turning against her. The scene ends with Tali sitting by herself in the dark, possibly going into a flashback (detailed at a later date) regarding how Tali started getting over her prejudices.

The situation turns dire on both worlds as Savathun finally tricks her way past asari defenses and Xivu Arath decides to stop screwing around and starts a full assault on the last turian stronghold. All seems lost until strange music lights up every single comm channel. Long story short, the contingent of 500 stole a Cabal dreadnought (disarmed the self-destruct just in time too) that is about to be backed up by a massive turian fleet. Cabal drop pods containing Guardian fireteams along with turian shuttles reinforce the defenses and attack the Hive behind their own lines.

On Aswe, the weaker asari fleet along with 500 Guardian jump ships have trouble until Liara comes up with a plan to cause a meteor shower that peppers Hive positions and allow Guardian and asari ships to slip through.

The hive assaults are fought off as hundreds of Guardians and millions of normal troops flood onto both worlds. A final epilogue scene taking place a week after the Landing sees Fedorian, walk into a room swarming with Warlocks and turian engineers. The head of this collaborative walks up to him and tells him it should be ready but this is the first time they've used this kind of equipment since it was recovered from Golden Age ruins. Fedorian says he understands before stepping onto a large circular platform. In front of him appears the images of the Vanguard Heads and the Speaker.

The Hive War has begun.

This Book is a bit different from others. Instead of a single narrative, it's a collection of short stories describing incidents from the War, some including canon characters, some featuring only OC's. So we'll do this in pieces.

The Deep-Downers:

As the War on Victian wages on, the turians find themselves forced to deal with an avenue of war they've never dealt with before: The Underground. In the months since the invasion began, the Hive have dug thousands of miles worth of tunnels under the surface of the planet and much of the war now hinges on claiming, destroying, and fortifying strategically important chokepoints and lairs. Now, a Hive nest has been located in the heart of a nearby mountain ready to pump out thousands upon thousands of Thralls.

There is only one option; infiltrate the nest and purify it with fire.

A small team of turian saboteurs (including POV character Fabius) and Guardians enter the Underground with a newly developed WMD: a Solar bomb the size of a torpedo. The group has some difficulty working together. The turians don't like the Mildly Military nature of the Guardians while the Guardians wish these anal-retentive mortals would let them work the way they like and- Traveler's Light! Why can't you guys be more like Vakarian? (Something a lot of turians all over the planet are getting real sick of hearing from Guardian mouths.)

These tensions mount as they face increasing opposition from Hive forces and they almost come to blows though they are ultimately stopped by the sacrifice of a Guardian's Ghost to stop a Hive Wizard from destroying the bomb. In a brief moment of mourning the turians learn that each member of Fireteam Carbonari has been fighting since Six Fronts (or almost four-hundred years). In this moment the turians begin to understand the Guardians. To a Guardian, duty isn't about proper protocol or eternal discipline. It's about keeping hope alive and Darkness held back through a war that looks like it may well never end. In this moment, strife is traded for brotherhood and they forge onwards to their objective.

Casualties only grow higher however and by the end only three turians and one Warlock (Garibaldi-17, head of Fireteam Carbonari) make it to the laying chamber, where the head of a Wizard's Coven lays her eggs. The Wizard appears and newly matured thralls pour through the halls of the nest. During the fight, the trigger mechanism for the bomb is broken. The Warlock tells the turians to make a break for it. Fabius refuses but is convinced to go. The Hierarchy still needs him.

Besides, someone needs to remember the final battle of Fireteam Carbonari.

The turians escape as Garibaldi initiates Radiance and floods the room with Solar grenades causing the bomb to detonate. Ethereal fire sweeps through the tunnels of the mountain incinerating everything inside. The turians barely make it out before a pillar of orange flame erupts into the sky behind them. Before long, it eases into something akin to a large bonfire.

Fabius stares as Solar Energy flows into the sky as it seeps from every cave entrance, tunnel opening, and earthen crack and swears to never forget Fireteam Carbonari.

Warlord:

The chapter opens with a shuttle landing on Tuchanka. We see four figures walk out of the shuttle all of them covered in cloaks. A krogan warband find them and take them prisoner. They deliver the strangers to their Clan Leader, Urdnot Wreav. Wreav does his typical grandstanding and boasting and orders the outworlders to death only for the lead to remove his cloak.

It's Wrex (who was suspiciously absent from Book 4) and he's come to take his clan back. Wreav laughs in his face as he hears his brother's challenge for a duel. He has no krantt worthy of the name how could he expect to win a duel? Wrex says he could kill any krantt of Wreav's on his own but that he has brought some decent fighters. The other three members of the party remove their cloaks to reveal Lord Shaxx (here to support his bromantic partner and fellow Crucible commentator), Saladin (who respects Wrex and is paying a favor he owes Shaxx) and Arcite 99-40 (they needed a fourth guy and most of the Guardians are busy).

The resulting battle makes up the rest of the chapter as while Saladin and Shaxx make short work of their opponents Wrex insists on taking on Wreav by himself. It's a symbolic act as Wrex knows to make his vision a reality he must defeat his brother in a "fair" fight. As this happens he remembers a conversation he had with Shepard and the rest of the team before they left to stop the Hive.

You see, Wrex in canon felt annoyed when Shepard tried to compare the First Contact War with the situation the krogan were facing. In "Each Star" though, he can't shrug off the comparisons so easily. Mankind in Destiny is staring down the extinction barrel much like the krogan are. The difference as Wrex has come to see it is that the humans haven't given up. That in their darkest hour they have decided to fight for their future.

Using their example for inspiration, Wrex declares that he'll fight for the future of the krogan as long as he draws breath and with a last burst of strength defeats Wreav. Returning to the Urdnot camp, Wrex declares to the clan and any other krogan listening that he's running Urdnot now and that if anyone wants glory they'd better get some ships together and make sure their guns are ready.

They're heading to Aswe to fight a threat even greater than the Rachni.

It's Quiet Out Here:

This chapter opens in a peaceful field of alien!wheat with a certain Matriarch Aethyta looking for someone. She stops and stares at an asari standing peacefully listening to the wind and calls out, "Nezzy!" Benezia doesn't hear her and we slip into a flashback. Aetheyta is nursing a hangover on Ilium as she listens to a report on the continuing search for the Long-Sight. It's revealed that it wasn't Benezia pulling strings that got Liara onto the expedition (which is what Liara thought) it was Aethyta doing so against Benezia's wishes.

Aethyta contemplates her daughter's fate when she hears someone knocking on her apartment door. It's Shiala and Aethyta wonders if this is part of some punishment Benezia is planning for her but Shiala says she doesn't even know she's here. Aethyta asks what she wants then.

She wants Aethyta to come back to Thessia with her. Aethtya quirks an eyebrow and Shiala tells her that the Liara's disappearance has destroyed Benezia. She's blown a lot of her political capital making sure the searches for the Long-Sight keep up (and even then they're on the verge of being called off and the crew declared lost), she barely eats, and she doesn't sleep for days at a time. Overall, she paints the image of a woman breaking down in grief.

Aethyta asks what she expects her to do. They've been divorced for almost a century it's not like she can help. Shiala admits that it's a long shot but nobody on the T'Soni estate can help. They've only ever known her as their untouchable leader and now that the image she's always projected towards them has broken down they have no idea what to do. Aethyta, despite everything, is the one being in the galaxy who knows Benezia the person best and not only that shares in her grief.

Aethyta scoffs and chases Shiala out but her remaining feelings for Benezia win out and she heads down to Thessia.

She finds the mansion Benezia lives in clean (thanks to the staff) but with misery all but painted on the walls. The summer soldiers of Benezia's retinue have left for greener pastures and only Shiala and the other truly loyal members are left and even then all they can do is shake their heads and shrug. Aethyta tries to speak to Benezia only to find her near mute. A sense of despair filling her, Aethtya wanders the mansion only to find herself in Liara's room.

Aethyta comes to a realization and tells the entourage and staff to pack everything up and get ready to move. She's come to the conclusion that living in the same house where she raised Liara for a century is only contributing to her depression and that a change of environment is necessary if she's going to climb out of it. When questioned where she plans on taking them, Aethyta remembers a small estate Benezia owns on a small agricultural colony where they spent the early years of their marriage.

From there the story goes into a montage of snippets as Aethyta begins the long, slow battle to save Benezia from despair. One that hits a climax when Benezia, after a year of mourning in silence, finally lets loose her resentment and anger at Aethyta for Liara's disappearance. Aethyta fires back and it turns into a huge row that ends with both asari weeping in each other's arms which then transitions into…

Well, let's call it "grief-fueled intimacy".

Aethyta wakes up alone but finds Benezia sitting on the veranda looking better than she has in ages. Aethyta sits next to her and they begin to talk. A montage occurs of Benezia recovering and the two of them resurrecting their relationship.

The flashback ends as Benezia turns around and sees Aethyta. They both return to the mansion arm in arm. Once inside, Benezia goes to check on something. While she is gone, Shiala takes Aethyta aside and gives her important news.

Benezia and Aethyta have been paying attention to the War on Aswe. Now, due to the chaos of the war, military censorship, and the fact that both of them are out of the political game at the moment (although Benezia is considering returning to it) they both don't know much. Which is why this is the first Aethyta has heard of an asari claiming to be Liara on Aswe helping lead the war effort.

To say Aethyta is dumbfounded is an understatement. After years with no news, she had lost all hope. Caution overrides excitement. It might be someone using Liara's name and if Benezia gets her hopes up... Shiala and Aethyta decide to head to Aswe and check it out for themselves.

The next scene opens with Aethyta talking to Benezia over comm, telling her that she's going to "check on her daughter". Aethyta of course means Liara but Benezia thinks she's talking about her other daughter (the one with the hanar) who Benezia actually gets along with pretty well and asks Aethyta to say hello for her.

The chapter ends with Aethyta and Shiala boarding the military transport that will take them to Aswe.

Other Tales: Those are the most fleshed out stories of Book 5. There were a bunch of others nowhere near as developed. Among them:

· The Bogatyr: Peresvet-13 and the rest of the Phoenix Pillars have come to Aswe to support Tali. Together they prepare to engage with a major Hive force led by one of the best Knights in Savathun's army. The battle is rough and Peresvet sacrifices himself to protect Tali.

· Tali'Zorah's Vigil: Tali and the rest of the Phoenix Pillars declare a Vigil for Peresvet (A Vigil is a Guardian tradition where a deceased Guardians comrades and admirers sally out on a revenge campaign to kill as many enemies [in this case Hive] as possible in their memory). The main thrust is Tali's grieving for an exo she realized she'd been closer to than her own father.

· Hold the Line and I Am the Wall: Two stories centering around Captain Kirrahe. He gives his life on Aswe to hold a defensive position only to rise again as the first Salarian Guardian (a Sentinel).

· Sparks of Light: A small group of newly arisen Alien Guardians try to cope with their new existences and (in a few cases) amnesia. One of these is Sidonus, risen as a Hunter, and the story contains his first meeting with Garrus.

· New Eyes: Saren shows up on Victian looking for his brother, Desolas, who disappeared when the base he was commanding from got overrun by Hive. He wanders the front doing his job, searching his brother out, and being his smug asshole self along the way. Ultimately he finds his brother wandering around the area where his base was but his jubilation at his brother's survival turns to distress quickly. For above his brother's shoulder is a Ghost and the look in his eyes is that of a stranger.

· Hey, Brother: Solana and Garrus are reunited when her division is assigned to the Victian Campaign. The reunion is complicated not only by the battle waging around them but Garrus' missing memories (some of which included incredibly meaningful moments in their relationship), a death and resurrection in front of her eyes, Garrus' discovery of their mother's illness and death, and this weird little drone using her name serve to make it far more complicated than she expected.

· When Last I Saw You and A Hand to Save the Sinking: Two stories revolving around Liara, the people in her life, and her slow slip into Darkness. The first is the story of Aethyta's reunion with her daughter but beyond the central idea I hadn't planned it out. The latter is more plotted out. When Scheherazade-10 (at this point Liara's girlfriend of two-and-a-half years) arrives at Aswe she's horrified by Liara's following Toland's path which leads to a huge fight and Scheherazade, Aethyta, and Tali banding together to try and pull Liara from the brink. It ends with an intervention and Liara promising that she'll hand over Toland's notes and her copy of the Book of Sorrows once they push the Hive off planet.

· Stranded: Adrian Victus and his squad become trapped behind enemy lines. They are almost overrun when they are saved by a group of Sparrow-specialist Guardians called Fireteam Mongol.

· Wasteland: A silent Titan finds a little asari girl in the wreckage of a city on Aswe. Together they must navigate the wasteland that Aswe has become to get the girl onto one of the last refugee transports out.

Let's just say I back loaded this book a lot. Damn near everything planned for it was in the last third or so. So, to make it quick, the war has turned heavily against the forces of the Light as Savathun has hatched and accomplished a brilliant scheme that has fatally undermined the asari defenses and Xivu Arath has personally engaged enemy forces and has personally slaughtered a million turian soldiers and more than a few Guardians.

Garrus and Shepard (along with a small army of Guardians) head out to personally face down the God-Knight. Garrus leading the charge, the Guardians rush forward to distract Xivu-Arath while Shepard sneaks in with her sword (she was rewarded with Bolt Caster for helping slay Oryx). Xivu-Arath pretty much walks through them and sinks her blade into Garrus. As the list fade from his eyes Xivu Arath looks up and sees Shepard, tears in her eyes and overflowing with rage. The Knight-God gazes upon Shepard's blade and recognizes a piece of Willbreaker.

Xivu Arath flashes back to her forging the blade as a gift for Oryx. Using it, she challenges her brother to a duel as a challenge to his throne. Oryx, of course, breaks her over his knee. Tears come to Xivu Arath's eyes, a smile on her face, as her brother takes her gift from her corpse. The Taken King has taken sword and betrayal as they were. Symbols of her love for her brother.

Such is the way of the Hive.

But now, the blade that was the proof of a sister's love is now in the hands of one of the ones that killed her sibling. So it is that both swordswomen meet in the middle of a desolate battlefield. Each one overflowing with rage and the need for revenge.

Meanwhile, on Aswe, the remnant of Citadel forces are in the last fortified location on the planet and are scrambling to figure out what to do. They still have their presence in space and all of the civilians were carted off long ago but their ground forces have been destroyed. Tensions get high and it looks like some are about to snap when Liara proposes an idea. She outright says it won't save Aswe and it may well kill them all but it will save the Asari and (Goddess and Light willing) the Galaxy. The heads of the Defense sigh to themselves and ask what the plan is.

The plan is to use Paracausal methods to cause a dark matter reaction in the heart of the Aswe's star that will destroy the Aswe System and take out most if not all of Savathun's fleet.

Arguments break out but in the face of Savathun's victory they find there's no choice. If they don't stop Savathun here then the Hive will spill out into the rest of the Republics drunk on the power they have received from the slaughter on Aswe. If Aswe has to be removed from the Galaxy map to stop it then so be it.

After much difficulty, they get enough Dark Matter and Paracausal material to put into a ship and launch it at the star while Citadel/Guardian forces launch a mix assault/fighting retreat. Liara, Kaidan, Tali, and Ashley board the ship to make sure the Hive can't take the ship. The plan works up until the team is semi overrun. They repel the Hive (for the moment) but find that due to damage in the ship's navigation systems somebody is going to need to stay behind and guide the ship to its destination.

Long story, Ashley locks everybody, including her Ghost, in a shuttle, programs it to get them the hell out of the system and begins a one-woman defense of the ship from Hive (and Taken). She ultimately succeeds at the cost of her own life and Savathun and her fleet are destroyed as most of the Citadel forces make it out.

Back in Victian, Shepard is beginning to lose against Xivu Arath. She is a skilled swordswoman but with no fireteam behind her back she can't outfight the God-Knight. Finally, Xivu Arath is able to disarm Shepard (possibly taking an arm as she does so). All Shepard can do at this point is glare Xivu Arath down as the sister of Oryx raises her sword.

Garrus wakes up in the sea of stars he perceived when he first died in the Cosmodrome all those years ago. He recognizes it immediately and wonders how he never remembered the place when he went back. A voice tells him he was not meant to remember as a figure that takes the form of various turians Garrus has known in his life appears before him.

Long story short, all the stars surrounding Garrus are the spirits of Turian religion (with the smallest being the souls of individual turians waiting to be welcomed into the larger gestalt of true spirits) and the supernova on the horizon being the spirit of the turian people as a whole. The Spirit explains that the Traveler is not the only purveyor of the Light in the universe and that the spirits themselves are beings of Light although their purpose is fundamentally different. While the Traveler made the decision to uplift and enlighten various species, the Spirits have always felt that their purpose was to inspire the turian people to greater and greater heights while keeping their true presence and power beyond the Veil.

But the time for that has passed, the war with the Darkness has reached distant shores and now mere inspiration is not enough. Now, they cannot perform the wide range of miracles that the Traveler can. They simply aren't made to do those things. But they can channel their own form of Light through a Guardian. It is for this reason that they spared Garrus from Final Death.

The Spirit holds out its hand as it takes the form of Garrus' mother. A Golden Gun manifests, held out grip first for Garrus to take. As Garrus takes the gun the Spirit gives Garrus a single commandment.

To show these invaders the strength of the Children of Palaven.

Back in the world of the living, Shepard is disarmed (possibly literally) and glares final defiance in Xivu Arath's direction as she prepares the coup de grace only to be interrupted by an eruption of sunlight on the horizon. Shepard smiles and Xivu Arath balks as they see a Garrus overflowing with Spirit-Light aiming his Golden Gun at the God-Knight.

His first pull of the trigger fires a beam of Solar fire visible from miles around which forces the sister of Oryx to her knees. The second shot disintegrates her body. For the final shot, Garrus points it at the sky and fires. In orbit, Citadel ships witness a beam of light shoot out from the planet, slicing through multiple Hive ships.

The knowledge of the defeat of their god causes the Hive ships to not only bug out but begin firing at each other as according to Hive custom. There are still numerous Hive forces on Vulcara but those can be dealt with by a low intensity cleanup campaign (albeit one that will take half a decade at least).

The epilogue takes place on a large military starbase halfway between the two fronts where Guardian and Citadel forces either escaping from Aswe or leaving Victian. A lot of character work is done. The Aswe team sits despondent about the death of Ashley (an event which takes the shine of victory off the Victian team) but elsewhere there are celebrations.

Even though the loss of Aswe is felt among many, the fact of their victory against an implacable enemy has filled everyone with a sense of hope. Humans, exos, turians, asari, and many more mingle amidst the halls of the station. Over the comms, there is an announcement of a more formal alliance between The Last City and the Citadel (The Last City cannot actually be admitted to the Citadel polity due to complications regarding the status of AIs and the Treaty of Firaxen so this was a compromise that worked for everybody).

The final scene takes place as a massive superintelligence awakens as its herald calls to it.

The superintelligence takes stock of the situation before asking, "What is it, Nazara?"

Nazara answers, "Oryx is dead."

The superintelligence immediate begins to fire on all cylinders, the endless corridors of its mind on fire with excitement. How many harvests have been lost to the beasts of the Hive. How long had they been forced into frustrating stalemate with Oryx and his hordes. The superintelligence calls out to the head of its forces. The one it calls Leviathan.

They discuss the new situation. Not only has Oryx fallen but they have found the Traveler after losing track of it a four or five harvests back. Leviathan says they must take advantage of the new state of affairs to finish the Hive once and for all while Nazara tries to ensure the harvest goes as planned. It's been working hard to make sure it goes smoothly even with the unforeseen complications from the last harvest.

The suprtintelligence thinks on it and comes to a decision. There is a chance to remove two of the greatest threats to its plans and it won't see it wasted. It declares that they may need to sacrifice a harvest for the sake of innumerable harvests in the future. A silence comes at the end of this statement. The Harvest is the closest thing to sacred these beings understand but the greater good they follow demands the loss of the crop in this case.

Nazara speaks up. It has an army preparing for conflict but it may be turned to a different enemy. Better yet, it reveals a small bio-mechanical bundle of what looks like muscle. It is primitive and near useless in their eyes but they can use it to clear the board in preparation for the cleansing of this crop. Leviathan gives Nazara permission to move forward but to keep them apprised of the situation before going back to its own slumber.

Soon, the superintelligence is alone. It remembers staring at the grand inevitability of extinction and despairing at finding an answer only to find a voice in the dark. The voice that guided it to the answer. There is a new surge of resolve. It is inevitable that the universe will be cut into and smashed until it has achieved its perfect shape.

And the shape that shall emerge will be that of the Reapers.

Here there would have been a mini-Book made up of multiple lighter plotlines to break up the intense Hive arc and the emotional drama of the next arc. A few days after the defeat of the Hive the station lights up with celebration, performances, and works of art created by Guardians. This confuses the Citadel residents (mostly soldiers from Aswe and Vulcara who are waiting for their orders along with politicians, journalists, and others who've come to observe the galactic new guys. It is then reveal that the Speaker has declared three days of mourning and two weeks of celebration. The first for the Guardians lost in the fighting and the last in celebration of victory.

The period of mourning has just ended.

But it doesn't end with partying as the Vanguard has told Guardians with backgrounds in the arts (ranging from painting to theatre to film studies) to set up performances and galleries to introduce the Citadel to human (and awoken and exo) culture. Such stories include:

· Shaxx and Wrex set up a Crucible tournament in Citadel space.

· Solana is flabbergasted when she enters to see a room of Guardians and Citadel normals making a ruckus watching the spectacle. She becomes even more flabbergasted when she realizes her brother is playing. Smash cut to her drunk in her under armor and screaming, "That's my fucking brother!" as Garrus pulls off his eleventh head shot of the match. A cough behind her and she sees her father, freshly arrived from Palaven to see his children.

· The emotionally fraught reunion between Garrus and his father. Made even more awkward when Garrus introduces his girlfriends.

· Tali trying her best to cope with Ashley's death culminating with her wearing Ashley's Titan Mark in the Crucible tournament (a way to honor a fallen comrade as whatever victories Tali wins while wearing it are considered Ashley's).

· Liara trying to pull herself back together after Book of Sorrows induced madness.

· The reunion between Liara and Benezia.

· Liara going on a movie date with Sadie that's unfortunately intruded on by her parents.

· Garrus running across the station in vain to stop his father and Solana from seeing the Rocky Horror Picture Show.

· A huge dance party in which Tali and Garrus dance while Shepard sings.

· An adaptation of Hamilton that's been altered to fit City history.

· Guardian Modern Art.

· Tali being called home to the Fleet culminating in the next scene.

"Tali steps into the room to see it lined with Titans with Zavala at their head. The Titans salute as they pass by and she realizes that this is a good bye ceremony. She keeps her composure until Zavala hands her a canister full of cytoconstuctors, the nanotech robots that make Spinmetal and repair Guardian armor in mid-combat. At this, Tali feels tears enter her eyes as she realizes that this is a gift of technology to the Fleet. A technology that would save countless quarian lives as it would allow their suits to repair themselves immediately after a breach and allow Tali to return to the Fleet in honor. She hugs Zavala (who humorously panics as he does not know how to handle honest affection) before she turns and waves to her fellow Titans and tells them thank you."

· A final goodbye scene where everybody meets up. Guardians of all ages and stripes weep as they say goodbye to Wrex who's going home to Tuchanka. This sadness is multiplied by the remnants of Fireteam Normandy saying goodbye to Tali. Tali tries to break up with Shepard and Garrus but they say no that they can make long distance work and Tali, touched by their devotion to her, agrees.

· The strange silence that haunts the people who call the station home after the celebration ends and everyone goes home. The feeling of emptiness as an epoch making moment passes over the horizon.

This Book focuses on the aftermath of the altered status quo that comes from the end of the First Hive Invasion and First Contact between the City and the Citadel proper. There were a lot of different arcs running through it but the only ones that really coalesced in my mind were Fireteam Citadel's. Garrus was the least of them involving his altered relationship with his sister and father (his sister's division being assigned to help defend the City and his father having emigrated to be close to his children). These relationships (along with Garrus' relationships with Tali, Shepard, and Samuel-8) would form the emotional core while Garrus, his father, and Samuel worked together to hunt down a serial killer. Also, Sidonus meets up with Garrus again and becomes his apprentice.

Liara's storyline would have focused on the effects of her slipping so close to the dark. This does not lack consequence as Liara's physical health was impacted and she experiences withdrawal like symptoms along with night terrors as the Book proceeds. Liara's parents convince her to come back to Asari space with them. Liara refuses at first but Sadie, Ikora, and Liara's Ghost convince her that she needs peace and quiet. Liara leaves with her parents and Sadie. What follows is a story regarding the recovery of Liara's family and of Liara herself. It ends in bittersweet tears as Ikora calls Liara back to Earth to join the Hidden. Benezia tries and fails to convince her daughter to remain with her and deciding to return to Earth. Aethyta decides to follow her and send reports back to Benezia to help with her peace of mind.

The final and most planned out story is Tali's return to the Fleet. While Tali tries to keep her spirits up and the quarian people embrace her as a hero the situation degrades as the radical changes in Tali's outlook and character serve to isolate her from her fellows. The situation is only worsened by her already poor relationship with her father degrading even further. In Each Star, Tali has a much lower threshold for dealing with bullshit than in canon ME so when her father, Rael'Zorah, tries to pull his "what we do we do for the Fleet" spiel on her after she returns she tells him off.

This disrespect of her well-regarded father only serves to isolate her further but she finds some solace in her new friendship with Kal'Reegar, who realizes early on what he's dealing with and offers her the comradery of a fellow soldier. These relationships are made more complex as Admiral Koris Vas Qwib-Qwib becomes a distant ally as he pushes for closer ties to the City as he believes that if the quarians can learn how the humans integrated synthetic citizens into their society then they can finally make peace with the Geth.

While there is resistance to this, of course, the whole situation is more complicated. Thanks to Tali, the quarians actually have a lot of respect in the City, certainly far more than anywhere else in the galaxy. Between Dead Orbit's constant need for engineers and the relative lack of discrimination (although each quarian is warned to "be polite" around synthetic citizens) the City has the potential to become a hub of Pilgrimage activity. This serves to make Tali's position even tenser as she's drawn more and more into Fleet politics.

It all comes to a head when a Guardian operating in deep space flags the Fleet as they need to resupply, it gets through because of Tali. Turns out it's a member of the Phoenix Pillars. During his visit, Rael overhears discussion of what Tali wants to do with her house (which Tali would have gotten along with her deed name, Star-Dancer, in side stories). This revelation breaks Rael's mind as it tears away one of the grand delusions of Rael's life.

Ok, now to do some explanation of how I interpret Rael'Zorah.

Rael'Zorah is an admired soldier, a respected admiral, a mechanical genius, and a shitty father. Now, he's not abusive or criminally neglectful but he has always been distant with Tali in a way that wasn't great for his daughter. But Rael honestly believed everything he did was for her future. He says that he will not stop until he's built a house for Tali on Rannoch and I think that's his justification. All the neglect, the lack of understanding her, the pressure she's always felt about living up to him. It will all be forgiven once she sees that house.

But she already has a house. On a world that's not Rannoch. It's not just a dashing of Rael's subconscious dream of redemption and reconciliation it's also the sign of an unhealable breach between Tali and her people. Now, I play it pretty subtle (Rael is not conscious of much of this) but at this point Rael actually becomes subtly hateful of the City for what he sees as stealing his daughter from him (never mind that much of Tali's loyalty to the City is from it being the place where she found actual love and acceptance).

This leads to disaster eventually, as Rael stumbles into his storyline from Mass Effect 2. Now, I never quite figured out what Rael did but it was either going to be steal Vex parts from Sol or capture wayward Ghosts for vivisection (possibly a fusion of the two). Either way, Tali is forced to storm the Aleri by herself to save her father. Thankfully, she's actually on the Fleet when the Aleri goes dark this time so she actually finds him alive.

The treason trial following this is critical if only because Rael's actions have pissed the Vanguard off. Rael knows this and pleads guilty and is sentenced to exile. But while the Admirals have everyone together they tell Tali they have a job for her. Part of it is needing to get her out of the shadow of her father's crimes for a while but a part of it is Tali's recapture of the Aleri has made everyone aware that they have been either ostracizing or politically courting someone who has the ability to kill everybody in the Fleet with little trouble. So they tell Tali to return to the City.

As the Quarian Ambassador.

Tali all but leaps for joy as the ends the conflict she's felt the whole Book by allowing both to return to Earth but serve her people in some capacity. Kal'Reegar decides to come along as an "ambassadorial bodyguard" which Tali accepts as the sign of friendship that it is. Rael also comes with her as she feels the need to make sure he's not left on some random world to die and is sure that with her word the City will give him sanctuary (although he'll probably be given stink-eye for the rest of his life). With that, Tali gets on a ship to return to the City and the Book closes.

The Book begins as Tali and her entourage return to the City with great fanfare (something that shocks the assembled quarians is how celebrated her return is with Reegar in awe and Rael sinking further into horrified depression). She gives them a quick tour of the Tower, where she is greeted by the Vanguard as both a returning comrade and the new Quarian Ambassador (she is also tackle hugged by her Garrus and Shepard). The tour is cut off however when Saladin comes and takes Tali to a secluded corner and tells her to meet with him and a group of other Guardians in the next few days.

She spends a few days getting Kal and Rael used to the City and getting them set up in her house before meeting up with Saladin. There at a meeting that includes her, Edi-3, Shiro-4, Kirrahe, and three OC Guardians I never bothered to flesh out, Saladin tells them that he's been getting reports of Fallen activity near the old Iron Temple and…

Okay, you all get that this is my version of Rise of Iron.

Now, there are lots of differences. For one thing, it's not a single Young Wolf that becomes the core of a new generation of Iron Lords it's a six-man team and Shiro-4 (because he deserves it dammit). Kal and Rael serve as important supporting cast with a small subplot about Reegar fighting a SIVA infestation in his suit and barely making it out of the incident unscathed and Rael trying to rebuild his life, mental state, and relationship with his daughter in a world that weirds him out at best and terrifies him at worst.

The other big differences is antagonists, because the Splicers are not the only servants SIVA has. The old Iron Lords have been sent forth from SIVA's heart to wage war on those who contained it the first time with the Young Wolves barely forcing them back at the Iron Temple. The corrupted Iron Lords and the Young Wolves clash all throughout the book culminating in the last battle in SIVA's foundry where Tali fights Perun one on one while an alliance of Young Wolves, other Guardians, turian troops, and two quarians in way over their heads fight across the Plaguelands.

Tali strikes down Perun and in her last moments the old Iron Lady smiles and thanks her opponent for freeing her from SIVA's slavery before entrusting the future of the City to her.

Now, while Tali deals with the situation on Earth, Garrus, Shepard, Liara, and Sidonus (in his capacity as Garrus' apprentice) start investigating the disappearance of Citadel trade and patrol ships between Earth and the Moon. At the heart of the mystery they find the House of Exiles. Once a band of outcasts and misfits, they have become an elite fighting force under the direction of a leader they simply call the Bloodied One.

The Bloodied One's presence is increasingly felt as they track the missing ships to a deep Golden Age space facility the Exiles have turned into a makeshift dockyard. There they find the ships, the crews (taken as slaves to help refit the ships into pirate vessels and teach the Fallen how to operate Mass Effect technology), and some Fallen communiques about how the Bloodied One will lead them to a new age of freedom and strength. The team assaults the base and while they succeed in causing grievous casualties and rescuing the slaves they fail to capture the ships before the Fallen get them away from the base. Worse, Sidonus disappeared while trying to infiltrate one of the ships.

The mystery gets more tense as Garrus is forced to add "save my apprentice" to his list of objectives but they finally home in on the Bloodied One's personal HQ. What seems like a perfect Raid is soon turned onto a nightmare as the Bloodied One reveals himself.

It's Vrothrir, who has worked tirelessly throughout the years to take his revenge upon The City in general and Garrus in particular. A vengeance that begins with Garrus forcing to watch over vid screens as he kills a captured and Ghostless Sidonus. That's not the end of it though. Through his interrogation of captured Citadel engineers he's discovered how to interact with the Mass Relay. Between this new knowledge and his captured ships, Vrothrir can take his fleet and leave Sol entirely and introduce the Fallen's brutal brand of piracy into Citadel Space. This culminates in a no holds barred knife/fistfight between the two that ends with Vrothrir wounded but escaping while Garrus screams to the sky in frustration.

The team reports back and Dead Orbit with some help from the Turian Navy blockade the Relay as best they can which is a complicated prospect because of the Darkness lurking at the edge of the system. The holes these complications cause give Vrothrir his chance and a small skirmish occurs. The team flies their Jumpships into a loading dock of a captured Turian warship which they re-capture and use to fire on the Fallen fleet A:TLA-style.

Ultimatley, Vrothrir and the Exiles escape but with less than half of their fleet intact.

At this point we hit the epilogue. In the heart of the Iron Temple, surrounded by her new fireteam and her family (both biological and emotional), Tali is given a blade and a new hood (purple as usual but the patterns and lines crisscrossing it are silver and gold in color) and proclaimed an Iron Lady. The ceremony continues on and while Garrus tries to keep a happy face, Vrothrir haunts his thoughts. Shepard and some of the others try to cheer him up by telling him he escaped with so few ships and forces that he can't be much of a threat. Garrus only stares into the shadows of the Temple, a mix of foreboding and rage filling his thoughts.

The scene switches to six months later, and a Krogan is brought to the feet of a certain Fallen. The Krogan's name is Cetatog Khur, a major leader within the Blood Pack. He lifts his head and sees a dark assembly room crowded with not only Fallen but krogan and vorcha. At the front of the room, Vrothrir begins to speak.

He speaks of power, glory, and riches. That he can offer these things to those who follow him and serve faithfully. To those that don't…

He takes a blade and buries it where Khir's headplate meets his skull. It is a chilling scene with Khir's screaming fading into sobs before turning to silence entirely. Even the krogan, so used to bloodshed and cruelty blanch at the sight and a few even vomit in disgust and terror.

As Khir's mutilated corpse hits the ground and Vrothrir tosses his headplate into the crowd. He raises his hands above his head and continues his speech and at the end he says these words.

"No longer House of Exiles or Blood Pack are we. Not divided between eliksni, krogan, or vorcha. Now we are one! Now we are the HOUSE. OF. BLOOD!"

And as one Fallen, vorcha, and the most bloodthirsty krogan begin to chant.

"All hail, Vrothrir. Blood-Kell."

In the background of everything that's happening, the Citadel Council (along with military advisors from all the Citadel Races) have been working with the Vanguard to experiment with various ways Guardians can better work with Citadel forces. Among these experiments is the idea of a special ops taskforce comprised of Spectres and Guardians working hand in hand. While the project is imperiled by Spectre pragmatism clashing with Guardian honor, it ultimately sees success. To best facilitate the needs of such a taskforce, some old turian frigate schematics are dusted off and altered to incorporate Paracausal technology.

The new ship, when it's finished, will be named in the honor of the legendary first multi-species fireteam and be known as the Normandy. I wasn't sure whether anyone in the main party was going to be a member although in hindsight I think this was the only way to advance Shepard's personal arc.

Garrus' storyline becomes dominated by his hunt for Vrothrir and his personal war against the newly christened House of Blood, which has gone on to become one of the most dangerous merc groups in the Galaxy to the point that the Chained Sword (a turian/batarian group that exists because the Blue Suns were never founded by Zaeed in this universe) and Eclipse have been pulling back from their conflicts with them.

The story pretty much becomes Moby Dick with Garrus doing his best to play Ahab. As such two conflicts play out. The blood-soaked vendetta between Garrus and Vrothrir and the struggle by Garrus' friends to save his soul from his rage.

Ultimately, Garrus is brought back from the brink and Vrothrir dies under circumstances I never bothered to map out (possible involving the Kell of Kells).

Tali's future arcs would essentially begin as she was performing Guardian ops in deep space. In the middle of a firefight, she would be assisted by an unseen sniper that would reveal themselves to be Legion, wearing Guardian paraphernalia instead of N7 armor. After a tense standoff, Legion informs that the Geth Consensus would like to propose an alliance to deal with "a threat to Rannoch". To say Tali is suspicious is an understatement but she goes along anyway due to a mix of curiosity and the hope that this might do something regarding the quarian situation.

Tali arrives at Rannoch and meets with a small geth strike team that she is assumes is there to betray her but in truth are there to "show her to the truth". After this, they lead her to a small isolated valley to a sight which leads to Tali falling to her knees in despair and crying out a heartfelt apology to the sacred homeworld.

For the sight she sees is a valley overtaken by SIVA.

The True Geth then explain to Tali about the split between True and Heretic geth and how the True faction was fine with going on without them until the Heretics came back to Rannoch enhanced with SIVA and with the apparent goal to subsume not only the True Geth but the whole planet in the name of their god as the first step of a war upon the whole galaxy (this being the first point of the story when the Reapers really start coming into play).

What comes next is a political lead up into another war arc as an alliance of quarians, Iron Lords, regular Guardians, and True Geth fight to push the SIVA Geth off of the planet. Ending with the geth and quarians making peace and the beginning of a process to resettle Rannoch.

Liara's story is heavily influcenced by her canon storyline. With Liara abandoning "researching eldritch lore" field in exchange for becoming a handler of the newly expanded Hidden, essentially operating as Ikora's lieutenant. Her duties pretty much boil down to what she did as an info broker during canon ME.

This does eventually turn into a conflict with the Shadow Broker but whereas Liara's conflict with the Broker was a personal quest for vengeance in canon, in Each Star it would have been a full scale shadow war between the Broker and Ikora Rey with the Hidden as her army. This mixed with basic ideas for Liara's evolving relationship with her parents and loved ones (along with some adventure archeology) would have made up the bulk of Liara's storylines.

Saren's story was one I was a little proud of for how I was able to blend canon ME with Destiny ideas. It would begin with Saren keeping a close eye on the newly-risen Desolas as he trained in the City. Now, Saren would start off as his usual asshole self but he would actually begin to improve through his relationship with his brother. See, Saren's brother is essentially a newborn since he remembers nothing of his old life. Between that newborn naivete and the fact that he's being trained by the Guardians, a society that believes in honor and fighting for others, he becomes something of an idealist.

So Saren starts playing at being a better person than he is for the sake of not seeing a look of disappointment in his brother's eyes. And then the act starts becoming the truth.

Saren starts going with his brother on ops (a right afforded to him by his Spectre status which eventually sees him and Desolas join Taskforce Daybreak). He starts spending time with him in the City. He starts spending time with his friends. He actually starts becoming a better person. In this version of events, Saren actually becomes friends with Shepard.

But on the other side, Saren is being more and more exposed new kinds of threats. Paracausal threats. As his storyline continues, Saren actually begins to despair at the ability of the Citadel races to actually fight back. This comes to a head when Saren and Desolas find a dying Guardian while doing bounties talking about "a dark instrument that could doom the galaxy." A situation that gets more complicated as they find that whatever it is can grant someone's heart's desire. The quest leads them to Vex labyrinths, to Cabal installations, to Hive catacombs and with each new struggle Saren's fear for the future grows.

It comes to a head in an ancient temple on Venus, untouched by the Vex. There, the brothers find a strange orb which thrums almost like a heartbeat. Desolas prepares to destroy the orb only for Saren to level a pistol at the back of his brother's head and fire. He takes the orb and runs.

Desolas is brought back (Saren loves his brother so wouldn't perma-kill him) but Saren is already gone and Desolas' jumpship is missing. Saren becomes a fugitive much as in canon and Desolas swears to stop whatever plans his brother has. Ikora tells him that he will need that determination in days to come.

She's figured out what he stole.

Meanwhile, in a hidden corner of the Sol System, Saren watches as the Orb cracks and opens in his hand. A large worm emerges from the egg and looks up at him.

"Hello," the last Ahamkara says, "Oh, Father Mine."

Okay, something that was going to happen in the flashbacks was that we were going to see Fireteam Cerberus help Fireteam Normandy fight the King's Fall raid and kill Oryx. The part most pertaining to this was that Eris Morn was going to give Jack "Illusive Man" Harper the Touch Of Malice. This ends up having bad consequences as it eventually makes the Illusive Man Fall into the Dark, taking Kai Leng (already kind of a prick) and Petrovsky (too loyal for his own good) with him. Jacob and Miranda leave when they figure out what's happening. Things happen and Jack Harper becomes the new Ruler of the Taken and becomes a major antagonist for the last few books of the fic.

This arc would have been the absolute finale of the fic. Once all other ideas were exhausted and all other conflicts completed, the Reapers would have marched on Sol. It essentially would have been my version of the Destiny 2 plot ultimately ending with the Reapers retreating in the face of a newly-awakened Traveler. The cast would stand before a recovering city as the sun rose and that's where we would have ended it.

Now, that's not it. Not by a long shot. There was a ton of other stuff but none of those ideas were developed enough for full write ups here. So for the next month or so, I declare the thread open for questions. What was I planning for particular characters? What were certain storylines I wanted to do? I particuarly welcome questions about wolrldbuilding cause I had so many ideas about the Destiny universe that I didn't have a chance to use.

Besides that, its done. I am currently in the middle the opening chapters of a new project that I hope to start posting by mid February. I hope a bunch of you decide to look in on that. I'd love to have you.

I'll see you all later.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to hear that a great story is dead on the tail end of Bungie declaring they would make their own fate, but it is great to see what might have been. Hopefully we can see similar care to world building in future projects and who knows, prehaps a return of our Guardian trio in one form or another.

Because with Tali's story, I just wanted to see one scene in the meeting with her father's "the needs of the many" speech. For her to calmly remover her mask, look her father in the eye and just say one word:

"Horseshit."
 
There are so few good Destiny fics. I'm sorry to see you go.
Good luck with your future projects.
 
I'm sad to see this finally die, but I'm glad it got some closure. Based on your notes, you had some great stuff in the pipe, if maybe a tad over ambitious. Good luck on your next project, I'll be keeping an eye out for it.



Also, any intention of continuing that Life is Strange/Changing fic?
 
I will say that you certainly planned ambitiously, and it would have been great to see it all in prose, but I understand the feeling of burnout.

Good luck on your future projects!
 
Sad news to hear. Especially after the good news that was Bungie departing from Activision with Destiny in their hands.

I'll hold on to the faith that you will return to this at one point. Who knows? Maybe Destiny 3 will inspire you to take this up again.
 
I'm sorry to see this story dead, especially with how interesting all of the outlining is. But I completely understand the struggle with burnout and depression.
 
All of it, just all of it.

My god, it's beautiful. Absolutely, breath takingly, beautiful.

The part that really stood out to me were the Reapers for the sheer clever welding of their goals to Destiny's canon. Becoming in a way both the perfect take on the Hives crazy and a absolute rejection of it. Yes the universe will have its perfect shape, but that shape shall be made of all the shapes that came before and after it. Mind blowingly awesome and made all the better cause I can actually see that working. Though if you had written this out I'd of advised you have the Reapers do absolutely everything in their power to still preserve what they could. Adhering to the idea that if the perfect shape can only be made out of all the others, then they actually need all the others. Including what they can save of this harvest.

Next is the House of Bloods ending. Specifically how you mentioned the Blood Kell's death might involve the Kell of Kells, who is looking to be Variks. I can see him arriving after its all been said and done to deliver a verdict on Vrothrir along the lines of:

"A Kell?

No.

You are no Kell. I am Kell.

The Kell of Kells.

You are merely... Fallen."

And then he snaps his neck or something.

Lastly there's Saren. His becoming a better person only to end up with a Ahamkara is a tragedy, but one that also had me burst out laughing when I read it. It's just such a perfect fit that he ends up with a wish dragon that may or may not be evil. That will or will not drive him to become the villain he was in canon ME.

All in all, thank you MagicMan. For both the story and sharing how you saw it ending.

Each Star will forever remain one of my all time favorites.
 
Back
Top