Capitalism ho! Let's Read Kengan Asura

Chapter 201 - Parting
The fight is over, and the results are up on the Dome's massive screens for all to see. Mikazuchi Rei lost, Kuroki Gensai won. And with that, the tournament spins its wheels for a little while as preparations are made to begin the next match, leaving the audience to their own devices. And in this interstitial moment, a curious emotion. Melancholy. We dip into the heaving sea of humanity filling the dome's seats, and find some of the musing on what a shame it is, that it seemed like an interesting fighter was going to take his place in the Kengan Matches. Mikazuchi's done for, they say. Every fighter of Kurayoshi's that has lost a match goes missing. Every single one. What a terrifying woman she is.

Well, I guess that explains how hard the panels at the end of the last chapter were trying to push a sense of omen.

That said, as we move to the next page, the scene suggests something else. Rino knelt on the ground, Rei cradled in her arms and gently bleeding onto the floor. She looks down at him with a fairly complicated expression, the face of someone who reflexively hides their feelings encountering feelings that defy being hidden. When she finally speaks, it almost feels apologetic, an attempt to justify what happened to herself.

She supposes it was her environment, the world she grew up in, but whatever caused it she could never overcome a revulsion toward what she calls "unnatural death." What does that mean? Well, we don't get a direct explanation, but the context I think gives a pretty clear image of the broad idea. As a Kengan Association member, she knew she had to endure it. She believes her father caused it, his rampant murder in service of his goals. And when her fighters lost their first match, she ordered them to quit. With her dumb, dumb magic hypo-boobs or whatever. She didn't want them to die.

Leaving aside the manga's utter refusal to just drop the stupidest element of Kurayoshi's character, the meaning of "unnatural death" here is quite simple. It's deaths caused as a result of Kengan Association business. Both in the backroom dealings, and in the most basic course of its operations. One could even read it as guilt, inherited along with the fabulous, bloodstained wealth that doubtless sped her along her path to prominence in the association. She doesn't have it in her to leave this life, but at the same time the idea of anyone dying on her behalf apparently terrifies her so much she'll all but inflict ego death on them anyway to ensure they live on. And yeah, on that note, this is an amusingly fucked up thing to learn in the course of a moment that's clearly supposed to humanise her? Like, these men probably know what they're about, the Kengan Matches aren't shy about their nature. But she takes the decision out of their hands anyway, for the sake of her own comfort and peace of mind. Not even firing them and leaving them to their own devices, no, she has to reach into their skull with her horny-based mind control and lobotomise their will to fight. If the scene were more honest about how fucked up this is, I'd honestly be saying this as a point of praise, it's genuinely appropriate as the foible of a CEO in this vein. The sense of entitlement to make decisions for other people's lives, all tangled up in her own neuroses and partially-formed sense of ethical discomfort. Sandro doesn't seem to have absorbed the idea that maybe it's not a good thing for CEOs to have such unilateral control of people's lives, alas.

Oh, incidentally, remember how Kurayoshi and Hayami seemed to have a preexisting relationship, and we spent a little time musing on what form that might have taken? Yeah, this page confirms it's a father and daughter relationship, the panel where Kurayoshi talks about her murderous father features what's very obviously Hayami's silhouette, complete with the man's characteristic melted eyelid. So yeah, we all know what shit he gets up to trying to secure his position in the association. I'm sure Sandro would like it if we assumed Kurayoshi cut ties with him entirely and got where she is entirely via her bootstraps, but…come on. We all know that's not how this works.

Anyway, Rino seems to lament how things have gone, and begins to muse on what might have happened if she hadn't "put my chains on you", which…could mean the pheromone order specifically or pulling him into her orbit more generally. I'm not sure. It could honestly be either, each would fit Rei's response that it's not her fault, and it was his decision to swear off killing. Maybe it's both, and the characters themselves aren't sure, the ideas blending together in the match's emotional fallout. I kind of doubt that though, Sandro hasn't really shown any capacity for that kind of nuance.

In any case, Rei insists that it was his decision to swear off killing, which ultimately is true. Even if he did it for Rino, as she notes, he had a life he could have gone back to. He chose to abandon that life, to try and become closer to her. But then we hit the part of this whole section that I find…strange. And which implies some quite unsettling things underlying Kengan Asura's perspective on masculinity, and sense of values.

Rei says that his thought process was too shallow. To fight without killing is his goal, but as he exists right now his martial art is stuck in limbo between these two ends. He refuses to take a life, but his new Raishin style is too messy and incomplete to save one either. He has to change, he says as he lifts himself out of Kurayoshi's lap and stares into the opposing wall. His back to her. She reaches out one more time, telling him she knows he can do it, and if there's any way she can help…just let her know.

She looks at him with the same sort of numb smile as before. Because he doesn't turn back to look at her. His thoughts don't even acknowledge her.

There's only one face in his mind right now.



This is, in Kengan Asura's estimation, what it means to be a Seeker of Strength, I suppose. And forgive my reach, but there's a significant part of me that feels it reflects poorly on the manga that in what it clearly feels is the ultimate expression of masculinity…there's no space for love. That intimacy is a distraction from the purity of male endeavour. That's rather sad, I think.

Now, don't get me wrong. I've said many times before that becoming the best in the world at something takes a certain kind of monomania, a certain kind of madness, to be able to focus on and dedicate yourself to a skill like that. But a partner is also a valuable source of support. Practical, yes, in terms of having someone to deal with the day to day business of financial support, food and whatnot. But also evidently emotional, in keeping a person centered, socialised, healthy, propping them up when things are hard, encouraging them through a wall, just being there on a regular basis. The human heart is a complicated flower, even a relatively robust one has a cocktail of needs. And, well, ultimately even the most utterly psychotic martial artist cannot be training 100% of the day, even ignoring the need to eat and sleep. Rest, at some point, is mandatory or your body will take the decision out of your hands. And that rest time is an excellent opportunity to cuddle your significant other. Just maybe take a shower first.

And let's not leave the gender angle to this unsaid, as well. This isn't the first time I've seen a manga characterise a passion, a drive of this kind as a uniquely male property that women cannot properly comprehend. Only with the additional, deeply unpleasant implication that they cannot even support a man through his goals, no, she can only ever be a distraction. The classical gender binary roaring through the room like a harley davidson made of frozen piss. Men act, women are acted upon, men have dreams and ambition, women simply exist in the banal moment, men resist temptation, women are temptation.

It was not just in the moment that Rei had to abandon all attachments and annihilate the world around him to pursue victory. Kengan Asura says that he must sever himself from Kurayoshi entirely, or the Siren will forever deny him the victory he seeks.

What a sour fucking cherry to top the last match's cake. But then I suppose that cake had a layer of rancid salad dressing in the middle anyway, so it's just carrying on the theme.

Thankfully, the manga is moving on, and so shall we. From the dour atmosphere of the Mikazuchi entry corridor to the Kuroki entry corridor, we find Rihito standing in wait for his unconsenting master. What took you so long out there? He asks. Did something happen between you? Kuroki brushes it off, claiming that Rihito of all people was overthinking it.

Rihito. Overthinking something. I'm not sure the man has ever had a complete thought in his life, let alone overdone one.

Anyway, Kuroki insists he just needed a warmup. In the Kaiwan style, foresight is called Motionlessness, and it's been a solid while since he's ever had to use it to fight someone. Which is credit to Rei, because Setsuna didn't make him use it. Kuroki wanted to make sure that he hadn't gotten rusty with the technique. Nothing personal to it at all.


Hello? Rihito? I think he's dissociating.​

The man cannot fucking help himself. He's like a cat, I swear, the slightest suggestion of emotional connection and he's like "no, what, nothing of the sort, you're dumb, shut up." It's almost like Kuroki is parodying the thesis of the chapter's first scene, he is lying through his fucking teeth to seem more stoic and isolationist than he really is. What he really is being kind of a softie for a promising kid with lots of room to grow. Here is the peak, a man in whom martial arts is embodied like a kami within a shintai, and he is incapable of not forming emotional connections at every opportunity. He can't even meet Takakaze's eyes, look at him glancing off to the left like a big fat liar. If his pants were any more on fire he'd achieve liftoff through the explosive propulsion.

Fortunately for the embodiment of martial arts, his CEO doesn't bother pushing the point, so he's saved having to scramble for further defenses. One more win down. Motorhead Motors has kind of languished in the mid-range of the Association, but they've made it to the semi-finals.

Right, he notes, to the greatest trial the tournament can offer.


We pivot once again, because the quarter finals have one match left to go. Katahara Metsudo welcomes Nogi to his private box, expressing gladness that he could make it, with a wry and amused cast to his eyes. With a singsong lilt he dryly asks Nogi to go easy on him now that they're competing directly, and the man calls that out for the gag that it is. Jokes out of the way, Katahara does have actual points to make though. Little late to comment on it, really, but Nogi is taking a massive risk. Remember the caveat for calling an Annihilation tournament? It's been like 180 chapters, so I don't blame you if you've forgotten. If he doesn't win, Nogi Corp gets dissolved. All Nogi's assets thrown away, just to stand on even ground with Katahara Metsudo for a moment. I'd call it arrogance, but by all indications Metsudo has walked the walk for the better part of a century now. Nogi isn't phased, though. He hasn't thrown his assets away as long as he wins, and, well. He's only even with Metsudo for now. He'll surpass him soon enough. It's solid banter and Katahara agrees, finding it quite funny. He has him there!


Very few things get under a CEO's skin in this manga. It's a whole thing, their sheer, focused manliness deflects bullets or some bullshit. But Katahara has been consistently framed as exceptional, and so it goes here, looming in the panel like a wraith. Something's been bugging him since the instant Nogi called for the tournament. Nogi's not a risk taker, he's a sound investor who runs the risk profile down to the very nub of its being when at all possible, Katahara knows as much from watching Nogi do business. And yet, here he is, making the highest risk play possible within the financial establishment. Why the sudden change of heart? This prompted Katahara to do a little digging, and he figured in the process that Nogi must have learned the same thing he did. Nogi cuts him off, telling him that-pffff, sorry, gimme a second. Ahem. Telling Metsudo that a newcomer like him would never understand. Nogi will win this tournament at any cost for his ancestor's desire.

I won't lie, it's very funny to see Nogi frame himself as the established, norm-defining old guard and crusty, ancient old Katahara as the clueless upstart. The both of them are part of a calcified system, neither can be putting on airs.

But yeah, who's the him that Nogi learned about? Well, Katahara muses on how that man probably hasn't even dreamed…


Plot twist! We have yet to get any sense of what this actually means, but the implications are pretty wild. This disposable little office drone, for a few heady days the axis around which the financial establishment of japan turns. But, for now, this is where this ends. The manga doesn't linger on it, simply leaving the mystery to stew as Yamashita yells at Ohma not to go too hard as the younger man steps into the ring. Why is he there? To spar with Hatsumi. The audience is baffled, one fighter helping another warm up is, if not unprecedented, highly irregular. Even when the fighters are close, they note that the companies usually put a stop to it. Which tracks, the only thing capitalists hate more than making even the slightest contribution to their competition is not having ironclad control over every asset they can reach. Anyway, the sparring isn't even really sparring, it's a super light warmup so far and the fighters note as much with a little confusion. Kaneda suggests Ohma is simulating the Fang's strikes, but Mokichi points out the sheer difference in frame between Ohma and the Fang would kind of render that pointless. Maybe it's just a warmup after all? Chiba doesn't think so. Hatsumi wouldn't do anything like this with no specific point, and if we asked Nogi he might well respond that Hatsumi wouldn't put that much effort in without enough of a payoff.

Back down in the ring, Yamashita is musing on how badly Ohma and Hatsumi used to get along, and on something Hatsumi said just before. Dipping back into a flashback, we see Hatsumi prod the tiger a little, blithely asking about that time Agito kicked Ohma so hard he bounced off the ceiling. And, to everyone's surprise, Ohma agrees equally blithely. That is indeed a thing that happened. Hatsumi is completely nonplussed, he'd been expecting a blowup, and Ohma shrugs it off as just stating facts. They banter back and forth a bit more, and Hatsumi muses on the changes, apparently having only just now noticed the emergence of Chill Ohma. But then, I supposed they haven't really interacted since before the tournament. Still, an Ohma this stable? Hatsumi can use that, he reckons. He then offers Ohma the chance to team up to beat the Fang. What does that mean? Well, find out next week. End chapter.

See you all next time, as Hatsumi's act completes, and we see what the Floating Cloud can do where the God of War failed.
 
Last edited:

You can hear the whistling sound of the wind as it goes into one ear and out the other.

sigh. This plotline, right. Not a big favorite of mine, for reasons that we've already discussed before. We'll get to it in time.

This is, in Kengan Asura's estimation, what it means to be a Seeker of Strength, I suppose. And forgive my reach, but there's a significant part of me that feels it reflects poorly on the manga that in what it clearly feels is the ultimate expression of masculinity…there's no space for love. That intimacy is a distraction from the purity of male endeavour.
It's a sad inevitability of the battle shonen genre as a whole, I think. This childish approach to intimacy that ends up resulting in so many characte dynamics that feel romantic but can never be. Both for guys and for women, to be honest; even when they're given the role of supposed romantic interest, there's always this distance, and invariably they'll be treated as a distraction even if just for the sake of a joke. It's rare that one of them gets to stick around or become involved with the main character at all these days, and conversely, it's led to an archetype of character who is in a relationship, is an early strong opponent, but eventually gets left by the wayside as the characters grow in power. There's probably a whole thesis that could be written about the consequences and implications of this lonely masculinity outlook in stories like these, though I don't think i'm the person who'd be able to write it.
 
Leaving aside the manga's utter refusal to just drop the stupidest element of Kurayoshi's character, the meaning of "unnatural death" here is quite simple. It's deaths caused as a result of Kengan Association business. Both in the backroom dealings, and in the most basic course of its operations. One could even read it as guilt, inherited along with the fabulous, bloodstained wealth that doubtless sped her along her path to prominence in the association. She doesn't have it in her to leave this life, but at the same time the idea of anyone dying on her behalf apparently terrifies her so much she'll all but inflict ego death on them anyway to ensure they live on. And yeah, on that note, this is an amusingly fucked up thing to learn in the course of a moment that's clearly supposed to humanise her? Like, these men probably know what they're about, the Kengan Matches aren't shy about their nature. But she takes the decision out of their hands anyway, for the sake of her own comfort and peace of mind. Not even firing them and leaving them to their own devices, no, she has to reach into their skull with her horny-based mind control and lobotomise their will to fight. If the scene were more honest about how fucked up this is, I'd honestly be saying this as a point of praise, it's genuinely appropriate as the foible of a CEO in this vein. The sense of entitlement to make decisions for other people's lives, all tangled up in her own neuroses and partially-formed sense of ethical discomfort. Sandro doesn't seem to have absorbed the idea that maybe it's not a good thing for CEOs to have such unilateral control of people's lives, alas.
I get the sense that Sandrovich didn't realize how little he had to say about his premise of HYPERCAPITALIST CORPORATE DEATHMATCHES until it was too late to change the premise.

If he was trying to say something here, it could be pretty potent! Rino Kurayoshi decides she personally wouldn't like it if her fighters were killed in the course of battle, and how does she respond? She keeps throwing them into the meatgrinder, but when it looks like they might be ground, she pulls them out and throws them away. Not only that, she prevents them from pursuing their obvious passion in fighting or utilizing the skill they've developed for it over their lives.

How many fighters in this tournament do you think have a college degree, or other marketable skills, or a work history that isn't martial arts plus maybe a part-time job? Probably just the two doctors in the freakshow corner. How many have hobbies beyond honing their craft? More than two, but not many. Probably, Rino's other fighters were much the same, just less proficient or talented or whatever. You don't get to the top tier of Kengan Association fighters if you have a life outside of fighting.

This could be an interesting plot point. Rino Kurayoshi thinks she's acting out of compassion, but it's a short-sighted, selfish compassion. You could argue that letting the fighters fight as they desire would be compassionate, or that not participating in Kengan Association fights would be, but Rino chose a path that combines the worst of both worlds. People get maimed and potentially killed in fights, but at their lowest moment, Rino strips her fighters of the one thing that makes that danger worthwhile to them.

...of course, that's the ideal Kengan Asura. The real Kengan Asura has Rino strip the fighters' ability to fight not with economic influence, but with feminine brainwashing. So the message would be less "Isn't it terrible that CEOs so casually abuse their economic influence over the proletariat?" than "Isn't it terrible that so casually abuse their boobs' influence over men?"


Anyways, while I'm complaining about how Kengan Asura handles women in general and Rino Kurayoshi in specific, isn't it kinda screwy that the manga all but states that an emotional connection with Rino holds Rei back from his full potential, then immediately chides Kuroki for thinking he should avoid forming an emotional connection with his two (male) not-pupils?
I'm not saying Sandrovich is definitely doing this on purpose, I'm just saying I have no idea what else he thought he was doing.
 
While I can't speculate further on what the Rei and Rino thing is supposed to be beyond what's already been said, Omega still has him in her employ (although she's seemingly refusing to use him for matches, or at least the first big tournament), he's still upholding his non-killing oath out of his love for her and he's noted to have made leaps and bounds in progress. So I don't think it's supposed to be a complete condemnation of their relationship or a statement he needs to cut her out of his life, but what it's supposed to be I have no fucking clue.
 
While I can't speculate further on what the Rei and Rino thing is supposed to be beyond what's already been said, Omega still has him in her employ (although she's seemingly refusing to use him for matches, or at least the first big tournament), he's still upholding his non-killing oath out of his love for her and he's noted to have made leaps and bounds in progress. So I don't think it's supposed to be a complete condemnation of their relationship or a statement he needs to cut her out of his life, but what it's supposed to be I have no fucking clue.
It'd be nice if the answer turned out to be "hey the mind control thing is actually sorta fucked and we shouldn't involve it in our relationship" but my expectations of Omega are low enough to scrape rock bottom.
 
While I can't speculate further on what the Rei and Rino thing is supposed to be beyond what's already been said, Omega still has him in her employ (although she's seemingly refusing to use him for matches, or at least the first big tournament), he's still upholding his non-killing oath out of his love for her and he's noted to have made leaps and bounds in progress. So I don't think it's supposed to be a complete condemnation of their relationship or a statement he needs to cut her out of his life, but what it's supposed to be I have no fucking clue.
I'm like 90% sure that's either a retcon or Sandro walking back this writing decision, because the tone of the scene here is pretty unambiguous that their relationship is doomed. Now, whether Sandro meant for it to come off like it does in my reading of the scene is easily debateable, Sandro very rarely intentionally goes in for a serious thematic statement, but I am fairly confident in my read.

Also, for the purposes of this Let's Read I'm mostly ignoring that Omega exists, except when I think it's funny. This is more because I haven't actually bothered to keep up with Omega than any specific exercise of principles. :V
 
This is, in Kengan Asura's estimation, what it means to be a Seeker of Strength, I suppose. And forgive my reach, but there's a significant part of me that feels it reflects poorly on the manga that in what it clearly feels is the ultimate expression of masculinity…there's no space for love. That intimacy is a distraction from the purity of male endeavour. That's rather sad, I think.

Now, don't get me wrong. I've said many times before that becoming the best in the world at something takes a certain kind of monomania, a certain kind of madness, to be able to focus on and dedicate yourself to a skill like that. But a partner is also a valuable source of support. Practical, yes, in terms of having someone to deal with the day to day business of financial support, food and whatnot. But also evidently emotional, in keeping a person centered, socialised, healthy, propping them up when things are hard, encouraging them through a wall, just being there on a regular basis. The human heart is a complicated flower, even a relatively robust one has a cocktail of needs. And, well, ultimately even the most utterly psychotic martial artist cannot be training 100% of the day, even ignoring the need to eat and sleep. Rest, at some point, is mandatory or your body will take the decision out of your hands. And that rest time is an excellent opportunity to cuddle your significant other. Just maybe take a shower first.
There's a particular parallel I'm going to raise here to a common science fiction and fantasy trope about how living in tough environments produces fantastic warriors.. Here's a series of essays on the topic. I'm sure most people in this thread will have seen some variation of it before. The Fremen in Dune are tough because their culture expects them to survive in harsh conditions, Spartans in 300 needing to fight wolves as children making them able to fight better, Warhammer and it's many many death worlds all of which produce amazing warriors.

Tough lives make tougher warriors as a simple consequence of the fact they have faced more difficulties.

I think there's even an element of truth to it in some contexts. The Fremen know how to survive and thrive in an incredibly hostile environment and are simply used to doing so. Fighting them on the sands or anywhere remotely similar seems like a truly awful idea. But it doesn't end there. The Fremen are generally an elite force anywhere they go in the galaxy and in a stand up fight rout and defeat well drilled and heavily equipped soldiers.

Because what makes the Fremen strong, in the way Dune sees them is that they are entirely without decadence. Other less pure warriors gain wealth and power which eventually corrupts and prevents them from being truly effective. The only way to avoid this is to live a life of deprivation and thus avoid the material distractions which would disrupt their warrior spirit and thus weaken them.

While not identical a lot of the same notes exist in Kengan. It understands a relationship, especially a romantic relationship, fundamentally as something unessecary to the life of a Seeker and thus inherently detracting from it. Kengan just inherently imagines a fighter who takes breaks, or doesn't cut off everything but this one part of their, as inherently weaker.

Except not really because Kengan is able to overcome this mindset when its a certain kind of relationship. Kuroki, after all, entered this tournament as a personal favor to his friend not for the money. Clearly it's okay for fighters to have some friends. Adam and Cosmo can be Just Training Buddies in Omega and it doesn't hold them back.

It's only a man being emotionally open with a woman which Kengan takes aim at as a weakness. There is an implicit statement here that this is a level of relationship that no other can match. Loving a woman is inherently so much more powerful then any level of friendship. It must be stronger then the pseudo-fatherhood Yamashita has found with Ohma. Companionship is fine, friendship is fine, but romantic love is inherently deeper and more powerful and becomes a weakness.

And I really do hate that as a statement. It does a disservice to both friendship and love.

Edit: Hopefully this post reads less like the ramblings of a lunatic to the reader then the writer.
 
Also, for the purposes of this Let's Read I'm mostly ignoring that Omega exists, except when I think it's funny. This is more because I haven't actually bothered to keep up with Omega than any specific exercise of principles. :V
If anyone wants an update on what's going on in Omega that won't spoil shit for any pre-sharkjump bits of the franchise: We just got a cliffhanger of Ohma#3 - the one with the mustache - getting ambushed by two additional, previously unmentioned, Ohma-clones. One's cosplaying Ken's look in the newest Street Fighter and the other has a chinstrap and a manbun.
 
Once Manic is done with Kengan Asura, Omega readers should recommend choice Omega chapters for them to read and react to. It sounds like reading the absurd bits out of context is the ideal Kengan Omega experience.
 
Chapter 202 - Time New
As we left off last time, Ohma was being offered a chance to team up against the Fang of Metsudo. And, evidently, he agreed. We saw him begin to lightly spar with Hatsumi in the ring, as the time between matches proceeded. Now, he begins to strip the "lightly" from that sentence. Bit by bit he accelerates, his arms and legs becoming indistinct blurs to the audience, until some of them notice something odd.



Before Kaneda can explain what's going on, that teeny tiny afterimage makes it clear. Hatsumi is refining his dodges down to the barest nub of their being, compressing his defense down to the absolute minimum distance travelled. And what a very Hatsumi Sen mode of combat. Which isn't to say this isn't a highly traditional notion, in martial arts historically, wider martial arts fiction and battle manga specifically the concept of Eliminating Unnecessary Motion is almost ubiquitous. And it's a very intuitive idea, I think? From multiple angles, too. Fighting is exhausting, the less you have to move the longer your stamina will last. Fighting is fast and mean, with victory and defeat separated by microsecond delays between thought and action, smaller movements happen quicker and give your opponent less space to act or recover from offence. A lot of martial arts benefit from a firm, planted stance, and so enjoy when you don't have to make large motions to defend yourself. The benefits are many to begin with, and are all the more appealing to a man as notoriously lazy as Hatsumi Sen.

Anyway, it's been noted in the past that Hatsumi is an inconsistent fighter, prone to wild swings in motivation and focus. Something Hatsumi is as aware of as anyone else, even if he's usually very lackadaisical about it. Not so today. Today he gets as much visual hype as anyone else in the funning, spending a panel an ominous black shadow lit by bright eyes and a roiling pillar of aura. And just to make sure the point is driven home, Ohma muses on how he's almost going full speed now, and still can't touch him. The process is complete. Hatsumi thanks Ohma for getting him into Top Gear.

The funny thing is, Ohma doesn't react with any kind of awe, just a blank look and an exasperated sigh before he wishes Hatsumi luck and advises him to try not to die. For a moment very clearly trying to stoke up some heat for Hatsumi it's pretty dismissive, but as much as anything this specific part of the moment is a character beat for Ohma. Highlighted when he returns to Yamashita, who expresses surprise that Ohma would help out Hatsumi. One of Yamashita's formative memories in this whole scenario, after all, was Ohma spotting Hatsumi and immediately devolving into a feral dog. And, well.



Well, nice of the manga to acknowledge the similarity finally, I guess. Was this actually the idea way back when? Honestly, I don't know. Sandro doesn't generally show much capacity for long term planning, and this isn't exactly a central plot beat to the match. If I had to guess, I think it's more him realising what he did incidentally and incorporating it into the characterisation of those involved. It's a writing trick I'm fond of as well, in all honesty. A good author should be willing to adjust when they have a new, better idea, I think.

And speaking of Hatsumi and his laziness, he gives the other end of the arena an exasperated look, and whines that "you" didn't have to actually show up.


Agito doesn't look like sunshine and roses at the best of times, but it certainly looks like he's keyed up for this one.

Up in Metsudo's personal box, the man himself notes who it is that's come out in his name. Which is a very strange reaction to have, since it implies he didn't actually know who it was going to be. Nogi says as much, and Metsudo shamelessly agrees. He didn't. He doesn't believe it makes a difference, and I suppose that's fair. Anyone who can beat the current Fang would be worth that kind of faith. And as we dip down into the entry corridor, while Agito looks entirely untouched, his opponent is covered in bruises. Which isn't to say Omori Masamuchi, the one of Metsudo's personal guards without a mask, looks in a bad way. He's got a bust lip and aforesaid bruises, but his hair is still immaculately coiffed and he's happily puffing away on a cigar as he muses on what a pain the current Fang is. That said, he goes on to say some of the issues he had with Agito have been resolved, and just as planned he's even stronger. Takayama isn't so sure thought. By another school of thought he could be said to be weaker. Whatever's changed could be for better or worse, they won't know until the match is done. In the end, he thinks they'd be better off with Omori in his place. Which is an odd, interesting sentiment, highlighting the mystery of what has actually changed with the Fang. He's had his instabilities, but in the end he's still been a juggernaut. A leading candidate to win the whole thing, without a doubt. But the way these two are talking, the issue with Agito runs more deep than the hissyfit he threw over having to use something as petty as "tactics" or "strategy" against Gaolang.

In the end, while that question is left hanging, Omori has a more specific point. He's not very good at handling people like Hatsumi. Is he talking about the Soft Martial Arts? Or Hatsumi being an annoying prick? Who can say, I can believe either. Maybe both. Hatsumi greets Agito with a jaunty salute as the Fang stares wordlessly back at him and Sayaka and Jerry go off on a little screed about just what a gigachad the Fang is. A height difference of over 20cm and a weight gap of over 40 kilograms isn't the biggest the tournament has seen…but it is a significant difference, and we all know that Kengan Asura respects those. It's part of why Agito is as unstoppable as he is, he could be said to be the perfect build for combat. Tall enough to have potent reach and have long, thick bones across which to string astonishing arrays of muscle, without being so huge and lumbering that he's easy to give a runaround and exhaust. And this is something the other fighters have a lot of characterful commentary to offer on too, as the fighters separate to take their positions. Raian, gormless brute that he is, immediately claims the fang's win is obvious. Wakatsuki has a little more faith in Hatsumi, which fits given he's the only person other than the Fang to beat him. Okubo offers a technical insight, noting Hatsumi's strongest soft toolset, his Aikido, as his best chance and that the Fang will keep his distance if he's smart. Kuroki broadly refuses to make a firm guess, there's no telling before the fight happens, and Gaolang zeroes in on the gap in striking ability. Hanafusa reiterates the physiological gap, Chiba points out that Hatsumi's obviously aware of that gap and wonders how he can turn it around.

Himuro believes it can't be overturned. That's what makes him the Fang of Metsudo. A god among fighters.

And Sayaka would seem to agree, amusingly, framing the faceoff as between the Emperor of the Kengan Association taking his "rightful place" in the semifinals or the Dark Horse Floating Cloud changing history. On the bright side, Hatsumi clearly doesn't take offense, and would appreciate some more advantages. He can't see any lingering damage from the second round, and silently admonishes Gaolang for not making any injuries stick.

Then, at last, the referee steps in. Cheetah Hattori and his magnificent name, here to officiate the last match he's going to be involved in for the tournament. A part of him is sad for this, ap art of him does want to be there to referee the semifinals and finals. But he's sure this will be the best match of the tournament, and he couldn't ask for a higher honour than to see it up close. He looks the part too, grin shaky and rivulets of sweat running down his brow.


It all feels oddly perfunctory to me, I'll be honest. Especially compared to the buildup to Agito's match with Gaolang. And it's not like Sandro isn't obviously trying to build heat, either, but it's just not landing for me. For a character given as much attention as he has, and as clearly framed as a big hitter as he is, Hatsumi doesn't really excite.

Will this match change that? Can he turn around the audience's expectations, and the clear betting odds against him? What has changed about Agito that puts those closest to him in such disagreement whether he's stronger or weaker?

See you all next time for a lot of answers.
 
And speaking of Hatsumi and his laziness, he gives the other end of the arena an exasperated look, and whines that "you" didn't have to actually show up.

Agito doesn't look like sunshine and roses at the best of times, but it certainly looks like he's keyed up for this one.
Man looks like he's made of steel and shitting bricks at the same time.

I like the art, but the vibes of this match and the commentary have me giggling and looking for Funny Stuff.
 
Ah yes, The Chapter Where We Raise Heat For Hatsumi.
It's too bad he's been so mild for so long. He never once struck me as an actual threat to the narrative structure of the story, which said that the Fang was the antagonist.

One thing I'll note, however, is that Ohma is actually getting powerscaled by this chapter. The sparring with Hatsumi shows, theoretically, where Ohma is in terms of centered mind and physical capability, even if he wasn't going all out. By taking that information with Hatsumi, we can see how the Fang measures up to those same combat capabilities, and thus get a sense of where Ohma and the Fang measure up to each other in the broadest sense. It's actually quite a clever turn of narrative, and not super obvious right away.

I'd praise it more, but attempting to use Hatsumi Sen of all people for this makes it come through a little flat, because we can't adequately scale Hatsumi due to the variable nature of his own capabilities.
 
This fight does not excite me. It feels... perfunctoary. Sandro does his best trying to add heat to it, but going into it this is clearly the weakest of the quarterfinals starting up.
 
I mentioned it back in the second round, but Hatsumi going into this fight with two gimmick fights behind him and no time for us to see how he works on a real match does serious harm to his character. Dude is meant to be one of the tournament favorites and the guy Nogi staked his whole plan on, and yet he cannot feel like a threat at all.
 
This match.

I'll have things to say about this match, once it's done. I feel it fulfills an interesting but questionable purpose in the story.

But I also think Sandro genuinely believes Hatsumi Sen has more hype than he actually does.

We were introduced to Hatsumi Sen as the guy who lost fifteen matches, which is an outrageous number by Kengan Association standards; that guy should be a total chump. Then the twist is that all fifteen losses were because he wasn't in the ring at the appointed time, making his "actual" record zero losses, but marking him as one of the more mercurial and unreliable fighters in the tournament, but one with an incredible upper ceiling.

Then each match is Hatsumi sort of like, "unlocking" each level of his power by getting his head into "the game." We're meant to believe that this guy is already one of the best of the best, on the same tier as Agito, but he needs a long and drawn-out process of getting fed lesser fighters before he can shake the rust off. The problem is that... For one thing, Sandro doesn't put in the work to make us believe that? We don't get a scene in which Awakened Aikido Hatsumi Sen just Clouds over some super-powerful guy to make it clear that this is it, he's peaked. The closest is that little warm-up at the start with Omah and it's just kinda limp.

And another factor is that Agito Kanoh opened the Tournament being pitted against Okubo Naoya, an absolute powerhouse, and then went straight off that warm-up into a match with Kaolong, one of the hypest man on earth and one of the coolest matches in the entire manga. The Fang gets put up against genuinely terrifying forces of nature right off the gate. While Hatsumi... Well, I chose my words carefully when I said he had to be fed lesser fighters before he could shed the rust off. Hatsumi's path through the tournament is a carefully calibrated escalation against at first a total chump, then a guy who is genuinely dangerous but because of an insane gimmick, and then - oh shit is he already fighting the Fang!? Wait, isn't there a missing step?

Nope, there isn't. Hatsumi gets fed two jobbers so he can get his head in the game and then he's up against The Guy, He Himself and we're meant to believe he's on par. There's a missing gap here - Hatsumi needed a third fight. One against a genuine contender, in which Hatsumi dominates and lets us see what it means for the Cloud to be in "peak condition" and we have proper heat.

And there was an opportunity for that: during the munity mini-arc. Except then we just get a gag of Hatsumi running away because he won't get into any fight he can avoid.

And I think the reason the whole edifice is creaking like this is that... Sandro just thinks the concept of the "guy who is a top contender but too lazy and rusty so he has to get back into the groove" carries enough inherent hype that he doesn't need to put in extra work making it stick. Hatsumi has gotten enough focus, backstory, and comedy beats, and was introduced early enough, and in such an important position (Nogi's own fighter!), that it's clear he's supposed to be a massive fucking deal, but the writer thinks we're already invested in the idea of Hatsumi's hidden power level and already believe he's a match for the Fang just based on vague pronouncements.

In other words... Kure Raian isn't Kengan Ashura's "Potential Man."

Hatsumi Sen is.
 
Last edited:
It all feels oddly perfunctory to me, I'll be honest. Especially compared to the buildup to Agito's match with Gaolang. And it's not like Sandro isn't obviously trying to build heat, either, but it's just not landing for me. For a character given as much attention as he has, and as clearly framed as a big hitter as he is, Hatsumi doesn't really excite.
Part of the problem, I think, is that we're three rounds into a tournament arc. We've been through this song and dance with these two characters two times already, and they've both gotten more than their share of focus (Hatsumi due to his connection to Nogi, Agito because he's The Fang of Metsudo). Especially since there's just...not a lot going on in this fight.

Hatsumi and Agito are relatively static characters. Cosmo is a prodigy who's close to realizing his full potential, Muteba gets one last shot at being the mercenary with weird senses, Rei is putting his love to the test.

But Hatsumi and Agito? They were both mysterious at first, top dogs in this pack, and the early fights gave us glimpses of what they were capable of. That's a compelling hook for a character in a typical tournament arc...but you can't stretch it as long as you can some of the other competitors' bits. We can see Cosmo coming into his own as a fighter over several fights, but we can only learn what Hatsumi's deal is once.

And unless I've forgotten something...this fight is just a fight.
Like, with Cosmo/Ohma there's concerns over both fighters' condition, and that stuff about Cosmo discovering a new trick, his talent crashing against Ohma's skills that he's practiced for years. Muteba/Wakatsuki is a clash between Muteba's pragmatic war-fighting versus a pinnacle of martial arts. Rei/Kuroki is...kind of a second "young talent versus honed skill" fight, but from a different angle, with the new trick Rei pulls out being connected to his relationship with Rino rather than a talent he's figured out how to use.

Can this fight pose or answer any question except "Which of these two dudes can beat the other one up"? And no spoilers, but as other people have articulated, the deck is not stacked in Hatsumi's favor. If he beats the renowned FANG OF METSUDO after the two gimmick fights failed to establish his abilities, it would feel arbitrary. "The Floating Cloud lives up to the hype for once? Oh, okay. I hope Kuroki kuro-kicks his ass."


Hatsumi needed a third fight. One against a genuine contender, in which Hatsumi dominates and lets us see what it means for the Cloud to be in "peak condition" and we have proper heat.

And there was an opportunity for that: during the munity mini-arc. Except then we just get a gag of Hatsumi running away because he won't get into any fight he can avoid.
The other problem is that the mutiny mini-arc was kind of a wet fart. Most of the antagonists were just...not at the level of Kengan Association headliners. Maybe if we restructured the mini-arc so that there were actual contenders in there, maybe Julius or Okubo or some of the Kure Clan assassins. Hatsumi Sen getting cornered by a gang of B-tier Kures and fighting them off, then fighting against Raian or someone, would be a great way to build Hatsumi's heat!

Unfortunately, that would require the mutiny arc to be good in at least one way.
 
Before Kaneda can explain what's going on, that teeny tiny afterimage makes it clear. Hatsumi is refining his dodges down to the barest nub of their being, compressing his defense down to the absolute minimum distance travelled. And what a very Hatsumi Sen mode of combat. Which isn't to say this isn't a highly traditional notion, in martial arts historically, wider martial arts fiction and battle manga specifically the concept of Eliminating Unnecessary Motion is almost ubiquitous. And it's a very intuitive idea, I think? From multiple angles, too. Fighting is exhausting, the less you have to move the longer your stamina will last. Fighting is fast and mean, with victory and defeat separated by microsecond delays between thought and action, smaller movements happen quicker and give your opponent less space to act or recover from offence. A lot of martial arts benefit from a firm, planted stance, and so enjoy when you don't have to make large motions to defend yourself. The benefits are many to begin with, and are all the more appealing to a man as notoriously lazy as Hatsumi Sen.

I can't speak for the traditional martial arts perspective but this is a HUGE deal in boxing and kickboxing, although the idea there is more "Make them miss, make them pay."

Because the one time someone's defenses are sure to be down are when they've launched a strike and haven't retracted back into their guard yet, many many MANY knockouts happen in that situation, but to capitalize on that moment of vulnerability you have to be able to reach out and smack the person attacking, which isn't going to be feasible if your dodge (slip, duck, whatever) is a huge movement that takes you way off in a direction.

So ideally you want that movement to be as slight as possible, whether a punch or kick misses by an inch or by a mile it still misses, and then you punish them before they can get their defenses back in place.
 
Back
Top