Remove ads

A Harry Potter Quest: He who was not

Reader mode
Varder said:
There's Barty Crouch Jr. still. Plus it's not like Voldemort needed Harry for resurrection, he needed the blood of his enemy. Harry was chosen purely because Voldemort wanted to use him to bypass his mother's defense.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
What could happen from this is that, without Peter, Barry would have to help voldemort full time and wouldn't be able to impersonate moody.
Which would prevent him from putting Harry's name into the goblet.
Unless he tells Snape to do it because of double agent things
 
Am I going mad here or is there something wrong with the timeturner logic? There was one timeturner. Peter grabbed it from Hermione and is using it for its plans. He still has that one. We got a timeturner from Lupin and used it to go back to the past to send Lupin to the future so we could grab it. But that is a selfcontained loop. Where does it connect with the "original" timeturner? Are we going to have to grab Peter's timeturner and swap it with the one Lupin currently has?
 
Last edited:
[X] Magic Sense II – You remember feeling the magic of your brothers. There was warmth and familiarity. Underneath your senses there had been something else, waiting to wake. Your ability is starting to take form and get more sensitive. You sense more magic than before around you; it is like a vibrant sensation that fills the surroundings.
 
[X] Magic Sense II – You remember feeling the magic of your brothers. There was warmth and familiarity. Underneath your senses there had been something else, waiting to wake. Your ability is starting to take form and get more sensitive. You sense more magic than before around you; it is like a vibrant sensation that fills the surroundings.

Where exactly is the Shack? Because if it is in the outskirts of Hogsmeade then it is very likely that we can't use it to track Peter.
I doubt he is going to run towards the castle.
 
[X] Magic Sense II – You remember feeling the magic of your brothers. There was warmth and familiarity. Underneath your senses there had been something else, waiting to wake. Your ability is starting to take form and get more sensitive. You sense more magic than before around you; it is like a vibrant sensation that fills the surroundings.
 
[X] Spongify (Deep Understanding) - Transfiguration. The Softening Charm is a spell that softens a target area or object, making it rubbery and bouncy. Rare is someone with your understanding over the spell, you can hit large spaced at once, making your surroundings your domain. With good timing, you can even make attacks bounce back on the attacker. +5 to Defence Rolls.

I like utility spells and environmental control.
 
Joker13 said:
What could happen from this is that, without Peter, Barry would have to help voldemort full time and wouldn't be able to impersonate moody.
Which would prevent him from putting Harry's name into the goblet.
Unless he tells Snape to do it because of double agent things
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

I mean, yes? That's what I meant. Barty won't impersonate Moody and Harry will be safe (probably), but it won't stop the resurrection ritual because Harry is not needed for it.

[X] Spongify (Deep Understanding) - Transfiguration. The Softening Charm is a spell that softens a target area or object, making it rubbery and bouncy. Rare is someone with your understanding over the spell, you can hit large spaced at once, making your surroundings your domain. With good timing, you can even make attacks bounce back on the attacker. +5 to Defence Rolls.

I don't see why we'd get an upgrade for our Magic sense, we didn't do any sensing. We just used the Map.
 
Last edited:
[X] Magic Sense II – You remember feeling the magic of your brothers. There was warmth and familiarity. Underneath your senses there had been something else, waiting to wake. Your ability is starting to take form and get more sensitive. You sense more magic than before around you; it is like a vibrant sensation that fills the surroundings.

So now Harry can be called "Furry" as a nickname, I'm sure no one will take advantage of this golden opportunity...
 
Curing lycanthropy would be doable as a long term side project.
I think people want to get better at potions anyways.
 
Dutch said:
Am I going mad here or is there something wrong with the timeturner logic? There was one timeturner. Peter grabbed it from Hermione and is using it for its plans. He still has that one. We got a timeturner from Lupin and used it to go back to the past to send Lupin to the future so we could grab it. But that is a selfcontained loop. Where does it connect with the "original" timeturner? Are we going to have to grab Peter's timeturner and swap it with the one Lupin currently has?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I said something similar in an earlier post. But after more though I have come to a conclusion!
The time turner used on lupin doesn't actually exist…. It can't get out of the time loop, plus at no point in time was a time turner introduced into that situation. We got a time turner from past lupin to use on future lupin. But at no point do we have something leading into the time turning existing.
The point of a time turner is that there is only the original one existing time turner at any point in non turned time. A person uses a time turner, they go back in time, do whatever they plan on doing. They then wait and eventually they get past the point where the original them used the time turner and time is no longer turnt, leaving only the original time turner actively existing.
So unless there is a second time turner in play I think we have an issue. But I'm done thinking about this hopefully the next chapter clears things up.
Maybe the reason pettigrew disappeared is because he screwed up the time turner and he just went poof….

I do also think people are vastly underestimating the trouble of curing a werewolf…..
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm, I wonder if its possible to imbue something, like a ring/necklace, with the homorphus charm and as long as the werewolf is wearing it, they don't take a trip on the wild side.

(bring idea up with Nicholas)
 
Well, this result is why one voted to keep the children safe and unbitten as the priority.

One can only imagine Professor Snape's thoughts about the situation. On the one hand, Potter is the scion of his old nemesis. On the other, Potter is also the child of Evans, whom he loved. Combined with the not unjustified thoughts about werewolves, considering that Professor Snape almost died as a student thanks to the illustrious Black, well, it must be a complicated morass.
 
I mean. A cure should somehow be somehow possible, even if it's very hard. If Wolfsbane can stop a transformation and Homorphus can temporarily revert it, then we can assume that whatever dark magic that causes the disease can be suppressed/blocked. And if it can be suppressed than it could possibly be removed.
 
Raikazin said:
I don't think lupin is getting out of this one. I hate that since he was entirely set up on this one.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Depending on what you mean by getting out of this one...

If you mean that he will be prosecuted legally, then I seriously doubt it... He took all the precautions required by law, it was Pettigrew the one who sabotaged his efforts and actively threw him away to the students, and no serious tribunal would prosecute him... He is even more innocent than one affected by the Imperious curse.

But if you refer to him mentally he is totally going to be crushed, he has just cursed the son of one of his only friends, even if it was set up by a third party and not a result of him being negligent in any way, shape, or form he is going to be devastated... And if Harry forgives him (Which I am pretty sure that once the truth is revealed he will) he would feel even worse...
 
Regardless, Lupin's time amongst the Hogwarts staff ends here. With one student being bitten, no matter the circumstances, the risk to the student body is too great. One could make an argument that the wise and noble Headmaster should never have hired a lycanthrope in the first place.
 
Last edited:
[X] Magic Sense II – You remember feeling the magic of your brothers. There was warmth and familiarity. Underneath your senses there had been something else, waiting to wake. Your ability is starting to take form and get more sensitive. You sense more magic than before around you; it is like a vibrant sensation that fills the surroundings.
 
Welp the time loop is fucked. Unless we steal the time turner from peter and swap the one lipin has before he fights us. Since
Jacob gets time turner from lupin —> goes back in time and uses that time turner to send lupin back in time. —> jacob gets time turner from lupin.
So the only way for this to be stable is getting another time turner and swaping the one lupin has before we even fight him.
E: seems i wasnt the only one with that idea
E2: this is the path of the timeturner im thinking. Hermione —> petegrew —> dumbledoor —> lupin —> jacob —> lupin —> dumbledoor.

I'm putting dumbledoor as a skilled grown up to deal with a werwolf with the goal of swaping the time turners to properly close the loop.
 
Last edited:
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top