Day 1 Elimination was on 99Lies: hailcapital, LDJ, Young Pyromancer, CoolCatmanC, RoachTV, Cyricubed, OriginalName, Scia
Day 1 YP voters at end: Snickers4444, Shadell, A Bunch of Atoms/Usili, 99Lies, Nictis, Legend of Ruina
Those not on either major wagon or not voting: Zaealix, Draxy, ComiTurtle
Well, for starters, I feel extremely confident that at least one scum was on YP! Additionally, as you can see by the number of YP voters who have died relative to the 99L voters who have died, clearly we are being retaliated against.
More seriously, starting with the D1 vote. Hail and Roach are town. Cyri has a dayvig claim to sort out that I think kinda precludes strong focused looks there. I know I'm town, and discussing me wouldn't be that helpful anyway if you're leaning a different way.
That leaves LDJ, YP, CCC, Ori and Scia on 99L and Usili on YP
LDJ: Made a few odd pushes that strike me as maybe mechanical or maybe a bit scummy still (as I said in my
last read of LDJ).
their vote on 99L has no justification.
Previously said "vibes" on 99L, Roach and me, but I know all 3 are town. Then Hail voted for 99L and LDJ jumped on that wagon. This reeks of opportunism tbh. If YP flips scum, LDJ is looking pretty bad. D2, LDJ said that
they were in a rush and hadn't been able to do more. I'm just not super happy about an experienced player having a read and not voting it, then voting it as soon as someone else does. OTOH, the fight with Nictis D2 is pretty exonerating.
YP has the cleanest reason for voting 99L, it's naked self-preservation. There's a lot to go over wrt YP and the kinda boggling claim about Nictis redirecting YP onto Nictis when Nictis has powers that scream Witch/scum to me is... odd, but I'm not inclined to clear YP because of the Nictis interactions, specifically, associating YP wagons with the cult theorizing feels like a good way to somewhat inadvertently discredit them. At the moment, I'm honestly not sure how I read YP, but I do kinda want to flip them just because it would make a lot of other reads (LDJ and Scia) make a lot more sense. Sadly, that's not a great reason to vote atm.
CCC: Very high noise to signal ratio. OTOH, correctly got sus on the Zaealix prime thing skimming through the memeposting.
262 catches my eye there in reading a bit odd and warranting pressure if YP isn't town.
Their argument for voting 99L strikes me as bad, but they overall feel like a new player. The Zaealix Prime interactions with Draxy make me suspect Draxy a bit though.
Ori: I anticipate this reread will take me the longest, so going to defer until earlier tomorrow if that's okay because I am tired and it is late.
@Scia: Honestly hasn't done much. Has inserted vote counts and memed today to get post count up, but is mostly flying under the radar.
445 feels like playing, but otherwise I'm not seeing much to like in Scia's play. Also, I'll stand by much of what I said in my last read on Scia.
here and
here. I think there's a lot scummy to go on, but it feels like a bit of a weird story and I'd like more data to reconcile things.
Usili: Swapped in this Day and this Day has been dead, so Usili clearly murdered the Day phase and must be scum! More seriously, hasn't really done anything besides hitting exactly the minimum post-count. Swapped in to a dead slot, with Atoms having 8 posts total, 1 of which was pregame and several of which were contentless.
250 is the exception, with a few other posts that are mostly NAI (jumping on YP's issue with the rolecards and vanillas). Not terrible for a post, but also the bare minimum to contribute and only 1 day. Considering they soon subbed out, I'm not inclined to credit that either way really.
[x] Vote Scia