Even after the reboot, I'm still trapped in the wrong anime!

Not all mon anime involve, catching all them all, do they?
I don't remember digimon involving acquiring more digimon for example.

I'm trying to steer away from this idea, because I don't think that capturing the girls is a good idea.
The solution is obvious, to combine the mon anime with the sentai/kamen one and so each monster of the week that attacks the girls will become an upgrade for our protagonist once it's defeated! :V
 
[x] Mystery Anime
Protagonist-kun is an amazing detective
I'm gonna have to ask you to change your vote. No detective Protag.
Question: If we pick a mon protagonist and throw him into a magical girl anime, does catching magical girls make it count as a harem anime?
chances are it's not really going to involve catching mons. I'm just using it as a short hand for non-human-sophant partner. So, no there will be no catching of magical girls. I might do Monsters of the Week though.
Question 2: If we pick an isekai protagonist and put him in slice of life, does that mean he just survives being hit by Truck-kun?
If, for some reason you want an Isekai protag, then he'd be hit by a truck and inserted into the voted setting. He'll likely be surprised at how it seems just like he's last life, and it'll probably do to some celestial bureaucratic mistake, and that's gonna have consequences.
 
Giving it until the hour is up. Seeing where we are now.
Adhoc vote count started by Thozmp on Jan 2, 2021 at 6:21 PM, finished with 83 posts and 61 votes.

Currently looks like we are definitely in a Magical Girl anime. And almost a tie between Mon and Sentai, which would have been interesting.
 
Last edited:
You wouldn't be. You would have distinctly non-human mons, and there wouldn't be any reason to try and capture magical girls, provided capturing mons is even a thing. You are not going to be from pokegirl world.
I get the feeling that's why 20% of people voted for Mons. The Pokegirl world thing.
 
I get the feeling that's why 20% of people voted for Mons. The Pokegirl world thing.
... Should I let them know? I feel like I should let them know.

@SoixanteZio
@LonelyWolf999
@ziizo
@LordPanther14
@beowolf
@crowbar
@Chaosbrain
@SpacePaladin
@Raphael
@Fluffy_serpent
@The Lone badger
@WallFlower
@RookDeSuit
@Ashmaker

Just in case you got the wrong idea, you aren't going to be from a pokegirl world. There would be no in-character reason to be throwing/using capture devices on random strangely dressed girls. I'll extend the voting a bit in case you want to change your votes.
 
What? No! I was thinking something like regular digimon or SMT/Devil Summoner.

Now aiming at the monster of the week or the cute animal mascot, that I could see being possible.
 
Last edited:
Adhoc vote count started by Chaosbrain on Jan 2, 2021 at 6:52 PM, finished with 89 posts and 61 votes.


So it looks like right now Magical Girl world is locked in, but it's split between Mon and Sentai/Kamen Rider for the world we are from.
 
Last edited:
So no looking for monsters like Newt Scamander or A monster hunter protagonist?
Those are still possibilities. You just won't be throwing pokeballs at magical girls. In character there would be no incentives to do so.
Edit: Though Monster hunter protag would be more something if Mon and Adventure tied.
 
Last edited:
Just in case you got the wrong idea, you aren't going to be from a pokegirl world. There would be no in-character reason to be throwing/using capture devices on random strangely dressed girls. I'll extend the voting a bit in case you want to change your votes.

My expectations for the Mon vote was That is supposed to be a sort of Zacht bell thing except that our Mon has an horrible sense of direction and ended in the wrong world with the both of us searching for the other contestants of the Mon battle Royale without success.

I didn't vote for the magical girl world and if capturing them was possible I would have probably dropped the quest.
 
My expectations for the Mon vote was That is supposed to be a sort of Zacht bell thing except that our Mon has an horrible sense of direction and ended in the wrong world with the both of us searching for the other contestants of the Mon battle Royale without success.
This is also a possibility, though this is closer to a Mon/Competition tie.

I didn't vote for the magical girl world and if capturing them was possible I would have probably dropped the quest.
I felt I needed to state it clearly (especially to those who voted for the Mon category) because I kept seeing the throwing pokeballs at magical girls thing crop up and felt I should stamp it out before it propagates.
 
I felt I needed to state it clearly (especially to those who voted for the Mon category) because I kept seeing the throwing pokeballs at magical girls thing crop up and felt I should stamp it out before it propagates
I have zero interest in that. I want to see both the initial failure of the mon taming process to work on the monsters of the week, and then for it to actually succeed and start turning them into something that is as overpowered compared to the local enemies as trained pokemon are to their wild counterparts.
 
Back
Top