While there's a lot about this group you're curious about, plenty of it things that can be asked between intermittent Makouha, Mazio, and Ma.... whatever that third person's doing. You stopped paying attention after a while.
There's one, however, that comes to mind as a fairly important thing.
"So... Rise-san, right?" You direct your question up at the abyss above you, fairly certain that the person you're addressing will be able to figure out that you're talking to her.
(What is it?)
"Since when can you use telepathy?" You're pretty sure she couldn't do that the last time you saw her, and that wasn't even a month ago!
(It's been... um... four months since I got Himiko now? Yeah, something like that.)
That doesn't make any sense. There's no way she could have had a Persona for so long unless...
...Time travel. Of course there's time travel involved, why not? Sure, your own situation is something of an open secret these days, at least in the sense that you're not really trying to hide anything from your friends and more never mentioning it unless it's actually relevant, but you'd thought that would cut down on these kinds of incidences, at least that you have to experience.
"...What year are you from?" You're sort of hoping that you're wrong, but it's the only thing that makes sense.
(What... year?)
"It's 2011," The boy with silver hair says. "...Is it different for you?"
Okay. Weird people from the future. You're aware that that sentence could also be used to describe you, but this is a different kind of weirdness entirely. You could make categories of this sort of stuff, and the only things you'd have in common with these people would probably be 'have a Persona' and 'from a future.' You don't even know if you're from the same future yet, or if they come from the world you're making, or maybe even a third possible future that you aren't going to get to see happening after you've interacted with it.
...Yes, you're aware that you've maybe gotten a bit too far into Futaba's reading suggestions. The point still stands.
"We're from 2009." And you're aware of a version of 2016 that's out there somewhere, though you aren't quite sure what ended up happening to it. Given what you remember, it was probably nothing good.
The boy pauses. "...Would you like some lottery numbers?" As if you'd be old enough to take advantage of them. Sure, wherever in the year they come from, there's a decent enough chance that Mitsuru-san might be able to, but there's pretty much no chance that you'd ever see her gambling.
(Since when do you pay attention to those?)
"Since I figured that, if this was what my life was going to be, why wouldn't time travel be a thing?" He makes it sound surprisingly reasonable.
"Senpai, no diving through portals to the past. Rise-san, don't encourage him. Our situation is tenuous enough as it is." Says the person who is clearly having the most fun here.
"Come on, Naoto, it'd be fun."
"Yes, until you reach the logical ramifications of such an act: homelessness, technical lack of legal identity... If you had a valid credit card, you could probably be charged with credit fraud, as well."
(...Is it really fraud if it's money you earned either way?) Rise asks, sounding more curious than anything else.
"It doesn't matter. We're not trying it." The next attack to come from the little blue Persona is another white explosion that engulfs much of the sea of cards. Through the sea, you can see the regal Shadow facing off against your friends. She doesn't seem to be doing that well- she looks more desperate than anything else. You suppose, given what your friends are like, that this was only to be expected.
"You could also go back to your younger body," You point out. "Time travel can work that way." That's what happened with you, after all, and as much as you want to deny it, it's impossible to say for sure that such a thing hasn't happened with Elizabeth. It honestly raises less questions than it answers, though the questions it raises are honestly bigger than the ones it answers.
You're also aware that bringing it up will probably lead you to have to have extended interactions with her, and that's something you're not quite ready for yet.
(I guess...) There's a pause. (...How did we get to this topic?)
"Either you guys went back in time, or my friends and I came forward." And it's impossible to tell which one. "Or maybe we didn't end up in either of our times. Maybe we're not in time at all." It sounds silly when you say it, but... actually, thinking about it, it makes a surprising amount of sense. It feels right, at least, even if you could never explain it to someone else.
There are now multiple odd looks sent your way. From the people you ended up fighting beside, a prickling feeling in your mind that you think is Rise trying and failing to voice her confusion in a coherent answer... and from Margaret, who stands off to the side to watch the rest of the battle, having apparently decided only to interfere to the point of getting you in the room.
Naoto is the first one whose confusion is given a voice. "Why would you think that?"
[ ] Point out how nothing here seems wholly real.
[ ] Point out that apparently you're the first one here to realize time travel was involved in this at all.
[ ] Point out that it's honestly not much weirder than anything else you've had to deal with.
[ ] "...I don't know."