Who do you want Jacob to be? Someone who wanders and tastes the different flavours and textures of life, or someone who defines himself via comparison to other people?

This choice is not in anyway defining in any 'total' sense, but it is a step in a direction. What person are you aiming for Jacob to be in terms of how he approaches life?

I'm not sure I quite agree with that assessment, yes that's definitely a flavour of what the choices mean, but it's only a small part.

[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
Last edited:
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
I'm not sure I quite agree with that assessment, yes that's definitely a flavour of what the choices mean, but it's only a small part.
Fair enough, I have the impression that the lens I am promoting is the one that most accurately perceives the QM's intent.

How do you see it/why do you see it that way?


show yourself to us, with words. let your perspective- your personhood, shine
 
Really glad that the random encounter turned to be a social event.

[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.

Fair enough, I have the impression that the lens I am promoting is the one that most accurately perceives the QM's intent.

How do you see it/why do you see it that way?

I see it as Jacob potentially wanting to have shared journey with another person and whilst you're right that the journey in part revolves around comparisons to other people, it revolves more heavily around learning magical skills, every opponent would be a new puzzle in this mind set. The skills Jacob learns would become the tools he uses to solve that puzzle.

Maybe i'm explaining myself incorrectly. Hmmm.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
I see it as Jacob potentially wanting to have shared journey with another person and whilst you're right that the journey in part revolves around comparisons to other people, it revolves more heavily around learning magical skills, every opponent would be a new puzzle in this mind set. The skills Jacob learns would become the tools he uses to solve that puzzle
Idk, the quote seems like the thing Jacob is about to say, and I don't really want to say,' This is the Road to the Top.' Seems incendiary and it's also not our goal. It's Tracy's goal, and we would be aping her. At least the second option, is Jacob firmly deciding this is a fine activity, but not something he's aspiring to be the best at.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.

This choice is not in anyway defining in any 'total' sense, but it is a step in a direction. What person are you aiming for Jacob to be in terms of how he approaches life?

I can't speak for everyone but for me it's this: Jacob found something he enjoyed where he didn't expect to find it. Should this now turn into a full-on interest/hobby or is this a passing thing that fades in an hour? Since I'm not interested in playing someone who's interested only in magical archeology, my answer is obvious.
 
I think it would be nice if Jacob explored dueling through somebody else's persuit. Kindof supporting role, and very hufflepuff of him if it helps Melina the hufflepuff to win the tournament.

Maybe winning the tournament was the friends Jacob made along the way?

It is also nice to not be the very best in everything, which is what I like about the MC. He has a very introspective maybe... view of the world.

[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
I can't speak for everyone but for me it's this: Jacob found something he enjoyed where he didn't expect to find it. Should this now turn into a full-on interest/hobby or is this a passing thing that fades in an hour? Since I'm not interested in playing someone who's interested only in magical archeology, my answer is obvious.
I'm focused on the "desire to win" part. It just holds negative appeal to me. The social scene where he hangs out with his yearmates was lovely in terms of 'new thing he did not expect to enjoy'
 
I can't speak for everyone but for me it's this: Jacob found something he enjoyed where he didn't expect to find it. Should this now turn into a full-on interest/hobby or is this a passing thing that fades in an hour? Since I'm not interested in playing someone who's interested only in magical archeology, my answer is obvious.
The purpose of the vote seems to be whether or not Dueling captures Jacob's attention. You've also got the scale wrong as this is not a binary choice. The scale is more like: a fad, an active hobby, and Jacob's full attention.
 
Didn't have time to comment on the last chapter so I'll do it now.
Crouching down for a more secure hold on your lean mare, you closed your eyes. You let yourself go again, a process that came more natural to you with every passing moon. Holding your breath for a few moments, before breathing out again calmed your mind. In the darkness, you let go of everything you were; this body was not that of Basques anymore, the woman who had seen twenty full cycles of seasons, the daughter of Edurne, he who had conquered the winter. When you opened your eyes – you were a wolf.
Definitely hope to have something like this in the future. Would probably require some insane Legilimency & Occlumency investment though so I will be a while. But being able to have a familiar of some sort and see through their eyes and feel their thoughts sounds all sorts of useful.

This was the last night for the Land of Primus.

You were all going to die here on this hill.

When your oldest brother spoke, you almost didn't register it: "Prepare sticks and stones."

Antes was still pale, there were dark shadows under his eyes that you had rarely seen even in the hardest of battles. When he spoke the next words, his voice didn't waver. In the end it was true, that he was the greatest of the children. He could take decisions, that the rest of you could not.

"Wake the elderly and children and arm them."
This doesn't sound like it will be a happy story either. Glad we didn't overburden Jacob this month, sounds like the Book has given him enough stress.

"It is often those that grew up without fear that ask questions like this. They are not wrong, far from it, Miss Pennyfeather, but a wizard's culture is coined by mistrust and doubt. For most of our history have we balanced our role in the world, until we yanked off the bridge to the mundane and put ourselves at the top of the magical world. A wizard always fears to climb the latter back down again, as he has grown rich and powerful at the top of it."

There was a learning in here, that you couldn't quite grasp yet.
This is the best Binns I have ever read. When he gets excited about a subject he can share some insightful commentary. I also like how you didn't go for what most people would consider the obvious solution, which would be to 'raise Goblins up'. Binn's said that you could do that, but that in doing so Wizards would also lose their supremacy and that there are costs in either scenario. Truly a great teacher in that he is trying to get his students to think.

Intellect Training, DC 40 → 1D100 → 27(27)Failure!
Sad, but not unexpected. I honestly think we shouldn't really try to train Attributes that need a DC 40 to pass. To much chance to waste an action. Thoughts on this? Should we switch to training the lower rated attributes and stick to level-ups to raise this attribute now? Or should we give it one more shot? Personally, it is too close to a 50-50 chance for me to put an action on it.

You stayed together for an hour, eating and talking of random things. While it was clear that this was not something that would happen regularly, as in most of them had other core groups of friends in their day to day life, you still enjoyed the evening.

For a moment you felt at peace even in this large group, because you realized … something like this could be quite nice actually.
Glad Jacob had time to bond with his year mates. He needed it after the week he has had. It also shows his fellow Ravenclaws that he isn't that distant. ..well maybe he is, but that he doesn't bite if you approach him.

New Spell Research, Protego (Deep Understanding) – DADA. Stronger version of the Shield Charm. Protego is a term applied to several varieties of charms. They create a magical barrier to deflect physical entities and spells, in order to protect a certain person or area. Conjurations may sometimes rebound directly off it back towards the caster or in other cases, may ricochet off in other directions or dissipate as soon as they hit the shield. Requires DADA Skill of A, gives a +15 to defending rolls. DC: 150
Nice. Glad we got it down. Though I don't think we will finish it this year. Our basic defense is good enough for now. If we tackle the other spells on our list then we can see where we are at then and if we have the time for it later on in the year then I say go for it. I would rank this after the Patronus in priority though.

Regarding the vote, for me it is between 2 or 3. Tracey seems open to having a friendly rivalry, and I would like to oblige her. Our relationship with her is unlike any other one we have with a fellow classmate and I would like to cultivate it further.

[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.

Edit: Changed to this. BeepSmile convinced me. I like their reasoning.
 
Last edited:
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.

That said, I would not mind option 3 either. Ambition should not be exclusive to Slytherins. If Jacob must feel competitive about something, better dueling than Quidditch.
 
[X] "This is the Road to the Top" – Tracey's goal seems to be clear. She wants to rise in ranks, however long it takes her. Her fierceness inspires you as well; this is something you can do. You will aim to win the dueling tournament at the end of this year, however farfetched that goal is. Because this feels like something that could be a lot of fun.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
Sad, but not unexpected. I honestly think we shouldn't really try to train Attributes that need a DC 40 to pass. To much chance to waste an action. Thoughts on this? Should we switch to training the lower rated attributes and stick to level-ups to raise this attribute now? Or should we give it one more shot? Personally, it is too close to a 50-50 chance for me to put an action on it.

I feel we shouldn't be afraid of attribute training failure. Yes it's sad that the action is essentially wasted but if we want to be great it's going to be something we have to suck up. At least to the point where we have stats at the 6-7 range. Garunted success for the lower attributes is nice but it's also slightly less meaningful. Ultimately I'd love to train our stats to 6-7 before we put level up points into them.

Two attributes at 6 means we could level up and push them both to 7, that opens up getting skill 12 in all skills that use those two attributes and with Int and creativity that opens enough options up that we could feasibly aim for skill 15 in charms or DADA by the end of this school year for instance. My ideal scenario is that come the next level up we've a stat at 7 and can drop two level up stats into it to get the stat to 9. I'd probably choose int for this. it should easily be possible to train constitution and Empathy to 4 before then as well.

AS we're likely to be two turns away from a level up I think it's okay to risk attribute training failure.
 
Last edited:
The reasoning I have for the third option is that I think it's fine for Jacob to have more than one passion. And that having a passion for dueling can lead to spells to better protect ourselves during more dangerous investigations/adventures.
 
[X] "You guide the way." - You like dueling, clearly, but you don't have any aspiration to it. While trying your very best may be a bit much, you will invest some brain matter into developing your skills to further improve. But this is not an overly important matter to you in the end.
 
I'm leaning this way right now. The wording for 2 makes says that dueling isn't an overly important matter and I tend to disagree. I think dueling is important in the HP setting for a variety of reasons. Being able to competently defend yourself is the mark of a good wizard, imm. While it isn't everything a wizard should be, I do think that putting effort into it isn't bad. Option 2 basically says that we don't think dueling is important in the end. But being good at defense can open doors that would otherwise be closed to us. A wizard that is capable of defending themselves is more independent and can consequentially do more things. They are more likely to be successful at exploring dangerous places for one. So I'm inclined to vote option 3 because to me, a wizard that can duel is one that can defend themselves, and the world in dangerous. Also, Jacob says he thinks it could be fun. This was a little rambley of me looking back at it.

In the end, almost all the great Wizards and Witches were at least competent duelist. Own own Head of House had a great dueling career. While it isn't something that I believe is necessary to build our identity around, I do think that being a good duelist gives us more options. It will likely make some of our more dangerous Cases and Explorations easier so I'm inclined to vote for it.

I'm about confused with your argument here. I agree with everything up to the underlined statements, but the following logic doesn't fit. We don't need to do option 3 for Jacob to learn self-defense. We're already doing that by learning spells and reviewing past knowledge. Heck, several prior plans had Jacob attempting to learn new spells specifically for the purposes of staying challenging for our fellow members in dueling club.

Then there is the latter statement based on how Jacob doesn't need to build his identity around dueling. However, Option 3 is the one where Jacob's feels the strongest regarding duels. In a very real way, option 3 makes dueling part of his identity whereas Option 2 is more inline with the stated desire to limit dueling as a facet of our personality and not a full part.

edit:nvm the section I quoted is no longer there.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top