I favor one of two extremes, though I'm not yet sure which one. Gotta get my head on straight about the risk, and also maybe be sober.
[ ] Who Walked Away
[ ] Forebear's Blade - Iron Maelstrom
This is mostly for the sake of letting Hunger be a big damn hero again, or at least a back damn side-kick. Not a bad combat improvement, particularly in mass combat, but a bit light on the intelligence. Yes, it leaves open the question of how we'll save the civilians, but it does set us up with a plucky squad that could rise to the occasion (somehow?). Also there's the whole 'Hunger is not nice' thing. We didn't exactly come in here with mercy and forgiveness at hand, in fact the only thing he's holding is the Forebear's blade.
I would quite like to actually meet a Fairbright, for a number of reasons. I like straightforward good guy heroes of the sort that they purport to be. I want to see how their power functions, beyond some sort of shiny burny thing. I like waifus. I'm optimistic that Hunger can get something good out of a famous heroic bloodline.
For the disorganized rescue of civlians: Gisena can sort the wheat from the chaff in regards to Soul Evocations, and Hunger can provide buffs to the useful ones to try and get effective help from the populace. Like find weak teleporting man, boost him, use him to facilitate escape. No guarantees in this plan, lots of variables.
We can Cut and then with Verchlengorge's help, probably breach the borders, allowing for greater mass exodus.
Perhaps Gisena can selectively nullify, or even not-selectively nullify the vast distance between the entrance to the temple and the entrance to the inner temple, making walking out much more practical. We're not really interested in leaving this place intact.
[ ] Larissa of House Alynne
[ ] Hero-Defeating Stance
[ ] Fierce Quickening
Just sword gud and lead a much more contemporary rebellion. Ultimately just discontent nobility grasping for more. I like the success odds compared to anything without Alynne and Hero-Defeating, but I'll keep my eyes peeled for superior suggestions. This is my more traditional and cowardly route of trying not to get pasted by immortal kung-fu lich guys. The improvement in stats, rank, and matchups is pretty good, and the support from our blushing backer makes a pretty honest attack actually plausible, if still dangerous. No worries about evacuation, it's handled.
It does lack much of the hopefulness of the other set I'm looking at, but needs must. Tactics for fighting are similar to the other option, just broadly better in every way. Buffs are a bit less prevalent, but that's easily made up for by the superior forces in play, and Hunger's own greater power. Knowing more about what we're up against is also pretty damn big.
It does beg the question of what we're doing with these guys after we take their ring. Just letting Gisena ruin Larissa's dream and walk away? They're going to lose out on power massively if we don't find a way to keep supporting their Soul Evocations, either with power taken from the dominated ring or by having a party member (let's be honest, it would be Gisena) wield the Azure Ring.
Either way, they're not going to just disappear, and as an aspiring high-Rank, Hunger needs PR.