Even Further Beyond [Complete]

[X] Justice

ugh fuck, i know i'm flip flopping like a madman here. i just can't decide between following bonedaddy's wishes or turning them into the slaves of a resurrected diagram nation and their ex-servants. you really can't gloat if they're incoherent from pain and gloating is one of life's great pleasures

"hey, autumn, what were you calling weebshit again? it was so long ago for me since i'm only 18 but i'm sure it feels like yesterday to you. how do you feel about it now? still think it's disgusting?"

"hey winter, bet you wish you'd went with zang kong's idea, huh? if you'd managed to put aside your petty, selfish, stupid grudge, maybe you wouldn't be spending eternity as my footrest. how unfortunate for you."

"hey spring, how're you feeling? i'm sure you're grateful to me for giving you a chance to help the people of the world directly as my personal janitor. it's okay, no need to thank me, i was just so inpsired by your compassion to the people of the world; so empathetic that you were fine with the cycle of ages and planned on murdering me. i heard about the fated love you guys had planned, aren't you glad you're going to spend the rest of eternity with me (cleaning up my mistakes)?"

just being maximally shitty and smug. it'll be great.
 
ugh fuck, i know i'm flip flopping like a madman here. i just can't decide between following bonedaddy's wishes or turning them into the slaves of a resurrected diagram nation and their ex-servants. you really can't gloat if they're incoherent from pain and gloating is one of life's great pleasures
Oh man, that's true. If there's only one or two more updates left, then an epilogue of rubbing it in their faces would be more entertaining than just listening to their screams.
 
Oh man, that's true. If there's only one or two more updates left, then an epilogue of rubbing it in their faces would be more entertaining than just listening to their screams.

This would be so much easier if we knew what we could buy with BP during the epilogue. If, for example, the Logos or the Praxis was on offer, I'd condemn them to bonedaddy's tender mercies in a heartbeat. But if it's just improvements to other people's lives, I couldn't give less of a fuck.

[X] Vengeance

probably gonna flop around a few more times unless there's some decisive factor revealed.
 
This would be so much easier if we knew what we could buy with BP during the epilogue. If, for example, the Logos or the Praxis was on offer, I'd condemn them to bonedaddy's tender mercies in a heartbeat. But if it's just improvements to other people's lives, I couldn't give less of a fuck.

[X] Vengeance

probably gonna flop around a few more times unless there's some decisive factor revealed.
We know we can spend BPs on IA, at the very least, so that's a thing.
 
I'm pretty sure that all the BP we gain from Vengeance - and more - won't allow us to switch tracks from the disappointing and bitter "triumph" we will set up for ourselves this way.
All we need do is stop escalating and not make artifacts.

I don't know how many arguments I can construct for this, honestly. I mean, 7 Beyond Points is a bounty equal to our wildest dreams. I could just repeat '7 BP' over and over again, at the top of my digital lungs, but it's really just rhetorical gravy, the cherry on top of the option. A better epilogue is neat, don't get me wrong, but that's not what ultimately matters.

I participate in these quests to give a shit, because good stories lift our hearts up out of the dust. They make us care, and conjure from words on a screen images of more interesting worlds. The strongest emotional beat in the entire quest, for me, was A Throne of Stars. There was this ancient lich, a creature from a different Age, one of the last remnants of a ruined world. Sustained by hate, he nevertheless entrusted his vengeance to a child, and gave his life to arm the boy with the incarnation of everything he'd lost. An act of selflessness from a monster, the old passing the torch to the new.

It was beautiful, and it was melancholy. For the first time, I got a sense of the scope. The spells of the Diagram were named for their inventors, and there were stories behind each of them. This was a world with a history. A palimpsest - not of the Nameless One - but of creation itself, the slate wiped clean over and over again, entire civilizations erased until the legend faded to myth and the sheer horror of it all passed beyond comprehension. I began to give a shit.

So now, at the end, I care more about fulfilling Baenlixnaire's wishes than I do about the suffering of the most evil entities in the setting. I want to honor the spirit of the compact we made with our mentor and not just make a half-hearted gesture in that direction, faltering at the final juncture when instead we could complete the arc of Nameless' character.
Beautifully said, Orm! This certainly cements my decision to choose Vengeance.
 
Last edited:
This is in large part a characterisation vote, and I don't like setting the precedent that we're happy to commit atrocities if it will slightly improve the success of someone we like. Frankly, it reminds me of the appalling nepotism shown in Xianxia novels - it's okay to do awful things to other people, if it slightly helps someone you have a connection to.

Hell, Baenlixnaire didn't even really like us. We were using each other to get what we wanted - it was a business transaction we were literally bound to the terms of, not a selfless sacrifice. We'll be resurrecting him anyway, he can find something new to do.
 
This is in large part a characterisation vote, and I don't like setting the precedent that we're happy to commit atrocities if it will slightly improve the success of someone we like. Frankly, it reminds me of the appalling nepotism shown in Xianxia novels - it's okay to do awful things to other people, if it slightly helps someone you have a connection to.

Hell, Baenlixnaire didn't even really like us. We were using each other to get what we wanted - it was a business transaction we were literally bound to the terms of, not a selfless sacrifice. We'll be resurrecting him anyway, he can find something new to do.
No, we are willing to let Baen do his thing because everyone involved deserves it.

Like, I would legit vote for this if we had no BP rewarded to us. And being able to EFB our good end is very much something I'm looking for.
 
No, we are willing to let Baen do his thing because everyone involved deserves it.

Like, I would legit vote for this if we had no BP rewarded to us. And being able to EFB our good end is very much something I'm looking for.
They by definition do not deserve it - that's what Justice doles out, an eye for an eye. Vengeance is escalating far beyond that, purely because Baen hated the Fates so much.
 
[x] Vengeance

My kneejerk reaction was to pick justice but...nah.

This is what Nameless has geen gunning for this entire time, what bone daddy sacrificed his life and yet more important things for, the culmination of the story. Let's make it as glorious and terrible as possible.
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Deathbybunnies on Aug 2, 2019 at 9:56 AM, finished with 125 posts and 52 votes.
 
They by definition do not deserve it - that's what Justice doles out, an eye for an eye. Vengeance is escalating far beyond that, purely because Baen hated the Fates so much.
They very much deserve the Lich they played with. Its the very definition of reaping their just reward.

Just as Bean has deserved his own happy ending after all this suffering.
 
They very much deserve the Lich they played with. Its the very definition of reaping their just reward.
No, it's not. There's an ironic feeling to it, sure, but that's not what they deserve. People don't deserve to have terrible things happen all out of proportion to their misdeeds just because one of their victims gets to do it.
 
They very much deserve the Lich they played with. Its the very definition of reaping their just reward.

Just as Bean has deserved his own happy ending after all this suffering.

Are we seriously going to forget about our Mentor's own crimes? He was a genocidal maniac like all the liches before him.

The Diagram Empire made humans the only species left in the world outside of the elves.

And that wasn't because of a lack of trying.

To be honest, he deserved what he got. The only people here with an argument for innocence are the past Overlords.

And only because they were force into it under extreme durance.
 
Are we seriously going to forget about our Mentor's own crimes? He was a genocidal maniac like all the liches before him.

The Diagram Empire made humans the only species left in the world outside of the elves.

And that wasn't because of a lack of trying.

To be honest, he deserved what he got. The only people here with an argument for innocence are the past Overlords.

And only because they were force into it under extreme durance.
.. Because magic they were given explicitly thrived on genociding other magic users.

Guess who designed said magic?

They created spiteful Lich to act as a doll in their little play. They can now have him.
 
.. Because magic they were given explicitly thrived on genociding other magic users.

Guess who designed said magic?

They created spiteful Lich to act as a doll in their little play. They can now have him.
Giving people the retribution they actually deserve is literally the definition of Justice. You're not describing that, you're describing a vengeful ironic punishment. It's not right, it's just satisfying. You can vote for Vengeance because you want that satisfaction, but don't pretend it's secretly the real Justice option, because it's not.
 
Are we seriously going to forget about our Mentor's own crimes? He was a genocidal maniac like all the liches before him.

The Diagram Empire made humans the only species left in the world outside of the elves.

And that wasn't because of a lack of trying.

To be honest, he deserved what he got. The only people here with an argument for innocence are the past Overlords.

And only because they were force into it under extreme durance.
They designed magic systems which ensured amorality would be rewarded. Diagram magic supported and encouraged genocide. Cultivation encourages amoral growth, the Endless Sky being the logical conclusion. I wouldn't be surprised to discover many more magic systems along these lines of "Conduct heinous acts for power or be the victim of such acts". If Banelixnaier was not the way he was and did not participate in genocides, there would be another Banelixnaier who would have done the same.

They also made to annihilate all other Divinities who could have stopped them from doing so.
 
Last edited:
Giving people the retribution they actually deserve is literally the definition of Justice. You're not describing that, you're describing a vengeful ironic punishment. It's not right, it's just satisfying. You can vote for Vengeance because you want that satisfaction, but don't pretend it's secretly the real Justice option, because it's not.
No, I am voting for it because I don't give a shit about Fates, and as such have no reason to save them from mess they themselves created.
 
Personally, I'm of the impression you should just fucking kill them, but that's a non-starter with the BP bounty.
 
.. Because magic they were given explicitly thrived on genociding other magic users.

Guess who designed said magic?

They created spiteful Lich to act as a doll in their little play. They can now have him.
They designed magic systems which ensured amorality would be rewarded. Diagram magic supported and encouraged genocide. Cultivation encourages amoral growth, the Endless Sky being the logical conclusion. I wouldn't be surprised to discover many more magic systems along these lines of "Conduct heinous acts for power or be the victim of such acts".

And?

No, seriously. How does that change the situation? Our Mentor was still responsible for his actions. They could have, you know, just not have killed everyone and then conducted henious experiments to grow their power even more.

As much as some people may want to believe otherwise, the maker of a tool holds little to no responsability as to how it's used.
 
Last edited:
And?

No, seriously. How does that change the situation? Our mentos was still responsible for his actions. They could have, you know, just not have killed everyone and than conducted henious experiments to grow thir power even more.

As much as some people may whant to believe otherwise, the maker of a tool holds little to no responsability as to how it's used.
Hypothetically, if a terrorist was freely provided nuclear weapons, is the provider of the nuclear weapons free of blame when it is used to blow up a city? What if the provider provided nukes in proportion to it's use?
 
*Baenlixnaire will be proud to call you his student.

What else needs to be said?

[X] Vengeance

If they didn't want this, they shouldn't have left a remnant of the Age they destroyed, mourning for all the glories they lost and plotting the Fate's demise for five thousand plus years. That's just common sense.

Yeah, they don't deserve this, but fuck them.

However, I wouldn't mind Justice winning, so I'm not super invested in this vote. It's rare to feel like this in Rihaku quest, so I'm going to savor it.

Personally, I'm of the impression you should just fucking kill them, but that's a non-starter with the BP bounty.

Hey, if they spend every waking moment filled with pain beyond imagining, they will hardly be able to play against us, will they?
 
Back
Top