fdsafdsafasdfdas
Arkievyes
- Location
- why should I
because "edit oh i missed a page, ighore all that"
because "edit oh i missed a page, ighore all that"
The only part of that I need to ignore is the vote. The rest of it was well thought out and insightful. I appreciate the criticism and I'll go ahead and give a couple of points for the excellent analysis/nitpicks.______________________
at this point with few votes and us not knowing enough about how this story is going to work to actually choose anything yet(that'll change once you get into the swing)you should just write what you want to/what makes sense to keep it moving. if you don't do something you risk this dying on you and I like this. quests always have this problem with a slow start too. need readers to be active, need to be active to get readers.
this is why I don't like quests, the authors always seem trapped by them. too dependent on readers choosing something the author can/wants to work with, never understood their point really. from the small bits existing you seem to write this well enough you don't really need us for inspiration so it can't be that...?
and then theres the transparency issue all quests have. I mean so far most of the votes are people who keep copy/pasting the magic thing even though you say in the comments that we can't actually do that.(quests seem to run into bandwagon problems fairly readily) blake would know what was possible so we're mostly just introducing user error and a bit of out of context knowledge to skew things.
(or for an example from another angle: how the first choice had us totally blind to what it meant and felt left to random guessing beyond what that would be from our character(for example I thought we were choosing our companions not ourself(and picked evan+greeneyes over rose) and the bonzi..how would we know that meant a guardian alt continuity blake?(i'd have guessed it'd throw us in with that hostile book girl before figuring that. part of a batch of bogymen)
why would the fallen accidentally succeed in summoning us? i'd have guessed adapts either way and expected the symbolism involved to just change their reactions to it actually working.) not a criticism on you so much as on the system in general
(and the other problem...hopefully you get the right handful of starting readers or they'll badger you into something dumb(usually involving convoluted shipping and turning every single character into a lesbian harem regardless of plot, personality, species, gender, or established orientation) which either leads to author abandonment or is desperately accepted to keep the story alive. luckily you managed to avoid being infested for now )
________________________________________________
honestly it ...seems really dumb of epoch to not explain shit and ask you to fight just now...he seems to have read some version of pact somewhere? too many of blakes fights played for keeps to just tell him "we're under attack" and throw him into it blind.
I'd pick interference since blake doesn't know enough to do anything else and have it end well. (then again thats never stopped him before...especially towards the end. but hes not stupid and the blitz choice risks flanderizing him, he's been careful too.)
nothing to write in for that other than maybe demanding additional info along the way...but i don't want to get this story bogged down in another choice so soon.
[X] Run interference. Epoch can get his Circle out, if you provide the opportunity. Stay with Tarfeather and Ariel. Distract the opposition and prevent them from stopping Epoch.
_______________________
and to help with the other votes:
if you go with charge in I'd take evan for the escape talentsbut leave greeneyes since she doesn't really have good non lethal options by the point her acid skin gets mentionedstrike that, it specifically says that would go badly in her description. we'll just have to ask her to stay back and only fight when she has to(speaking of which somebody had better mention something about the machete of ruin we're just casually asked for being a problem) and your clarification post has them telling us they don't want to kill the wards. but out of context knowledge says that firebird master guy is there and skitters been popping pigeons before they could explode which could go badly for....everyone. :/ better leave him here
for sneaking...how exactly does going in through the roof or basement even work physically? we don't fly or teleport. and why would approaching from the back help? its not like they're expecting reinforcements from a specific place or they'd be attacking there too. that option's sub choices just confuse me
_______________
WE know that but 'we' don't. the adapts might but nobody thought to tell us that and they seem to assume we're better at this than them and will follow our lead.
EDIT
oh, nevermind then. somehow i missed a page. just ignore all that
Prize-wise, you each get to ask one question that I promise - to the best of my ability - to answer truthfully. (As the technical winner, @devas gets to ask two.)
They stole it.
Wasn't Maggie Holt a huge bestseller in canon Worm? I remember it being described as Worm's Harry Potter.
In this Quest, it's fairly popular, but too dark (and wordy of the stilted) to be Harry Potter popular.It's mentioned in canon, people discuss it, but we don't have any real idea of popularity, other than one of the wards (Vista?) reading it.
So it could be some niche title. It's probable it's the Harry Potter equivalent or close to it, although it didn't get a (mentioned) movie and that would imply it wasn't as much of a popular work as HP.
Prize-wise, you each get to ask one question that I promise - to the best of my ability - to answer truthfully.
This would require the shards to quantify magic first. Which is... Well. If they could do that then the cycle wouldn't really be a thing.*actually, this is more me begging you to not make Magic a special snowflake Precog-proofing spackle, like I've seen far, far too many fics do.
Seriously, why everybody and their Mother thinks that neutering Contessa & Ziz and busting open Dinah's skull (and, in especially egregious versions, Lisa's) is a good mystifies me.
Why waste a chance to figure out the implications of things? Bah.
This would require the shards to quantify magic first. Which is... Well. If they could do that then the cycle wouldn't really be a thing.
Is Magic an Out of Context Problem? In a way, yes. They've never run into Pact-verse Magic.I don't actually know what I should ask.
Mainly because I don't know what has already been established and I'm afraid of retreading known ground.
Also, I'm somewhat unfamiliar with Pact (although I'm keeping up with Twig-which I heartily recommend-and on the second to last arc of Worm).
I guess for now I'll ask one of my question: is Magic an Out of Context Problem for Entities, Precog and so on*? If not so, meaning Magic has already been encountered and understood by Entities, are there any powers which interact with it directly (i.e. Power-on-Magic interaction instead of Magic-on-Power interaction, which we already know can happen).
*actually, this is more me begging you to not make Magic a special snowflake Precog-proofing spackle, like I've seen far, far too many fics do.
Seriously, why everybody and their Mother thinks that neutering Contessa & Ziz and busting open Dinah's skull (and, in especially egregious versions, Lisa's) is a good mystifies me.
Why waste a chance to figure out the implications of things? Bah.
I'll try to answer this a bit more in-depth later (I'm currently experiencing computer difficulties - this is on my mobile) but... yes and no.I've thought of what to ask for my second question!
(And I've gone through the whole thread (thank god it's still short-ish) and checked that it hadn't been asked yet)
Is Myrddin a wizard? By that I mean, do groups aside from the Adepts already know magic, and might there be magic users (or beast, or incarnations) around masquerading as capes?
It would be fun if Skitter had inadvertently kicked the ass of an actual dragon, at the start of her career.
I do. As I will be watching this quest for the indefinite future, I'll be happy to tally for you when necessary.
Thank you. I will keep that in mind for the future.I do. As I will be watching this quest for the indefinite future, I'll be happy to tally for you when necessary.
yeah, I couldn't think of anything good so was defaulting to hoarding.
We should eat Hero's ghost. Well...eat may be the wrong word here. We should make an deal with his ghost. Power for (eventually) getting rid of the Endbringers.
Wildbow's second fic. Not...his best work, given that it kept getting bogged down in "It gets worse" and "Escaped by the skin of our teeth".