For your Streaming/Patreon/Original Fiction Needs
So, to make sure everyone knows (and though I know it might be a bit annoying to have it always present) I'm sticky-ing this post with...pretty much all the info. If the sticky-situation annoys folks, I'll get around to removing it after a week circa. By that time, everyone who might have missed any of the 'info' will have been filled in, and the new recruits-ahem, cultist-ahem, readers will eventually learn it through osmosis.

Streaming:


Offer me a coffee or something:

Patreon:
Patreon
Ko-Fi:
Ko-Fi

Original Fiction Links:
Amazon.
www.amazon.com

Alberto Catellani: books, biography, latest update

Follow Alberto Catellani and explore their bibliography from Amazon.com's Alberto Catellani Author Page.
Smashwords.
www.smashwords.com

Alberto Catellani

Draft2Digital (multiple book libraries)

Find me on Discord:

Unisciti al server di Discord Shadenight123Chat!

Dai un'occhiata alla community di Shadenight123Chat su Discord: spassatela con altri 171 membri e goditi la chat vocale e testuale gratuita.
Twitter:
Facebook:
www.facebook.com

Shadenight123

Shadenight123. 74 likes. Shadenight123 facebook page, because why the hell not.
 
Last edited:
It is a different game with casual mode on, but it is still a good game. I don't like using it, but I'm really glad that it comes with one. I've got a sibling who only plays casual mode, but we both love the game and talking about the characters.
And that's completely fair, I just use casual mode exclusively because I'm a salty sport who does not like losing units to stuff that feels unfair and don't want to just reboot the stage to try again.
 
3) the empire is the bad guy because of the shadow organization
You can join the Empire; they become less evil and Rhea goes absolutely insane because you refused to kill someone just because she ordered it. Thing is Edelgard was always going to turn on the shadow organization but she had to work with them initially. Byleth joins her and she losses the need to work with the shadow organization and she also ditches the less acceptable crap they would have otherwise used.
 
Last edited:
You can join the Empire; they become less evil and Rhea goes absolutely insane because you refused to kill someone just because she ordered it. Thing is Edelgard was always going to turn on the shadow organization but she had to work with them initially. Byleth joins her and she losses the need to work with the shadow organization and she also ditches the less acceptable crap they would have otherwise used.
....I mean..... yeah, she did have that plan, but ah............ yeah, she is not a good planner...
 
Shade Emblem: Hunger Eternal Part Three [Fire Emblem:Three Houses]
AN: As there are actual spoilers for the Fire Emblem Three Houses in the following chapter, don't read it if you don't want them.

Shade Emblem: Hunger Eternal Part Three [Fire Emblem: Three Houses]


The pleasant and fresh air of the mountains soon left the place to the tranquility of the hills. I enjoyed my quiet moments of contemplation, my delight at the sights, and my capability to just sleep like a log and wake up when I felt like it.

My first day of relax and vacation passed with me happily taking a stroll through nature. On my second day, I reached a small thicket with a crystal clear pond and sat down, taking a deep breath as I cracked my neck a bit, the tension in my body loosening up.

"It feels like the Arthurian myth," I muttered under my breath. "The blade that hides within the lake."

The waters of the lake remained placid. The only ripples being mine as I quietly swam into the cold waters, reaching for the center before taking a plunge and staring at the darkness within.

Don't cry, we'll be fine. The darkness will protect us.

My arms moved the water behind me as I reached deeper; the lake wasn't that deep, but where I was headed was its deepest point.

We must lick our wounds. We must prepare ourselves. We must kindle our hatred, but not let it consume us.

A large, pyramidal object was standing at the very bottom of the lake in question. On one of its sides, a hand-shaped print remained. An old system to identify the user. Agarthan. Crafted under strict orders of secrecy, placed there decades ago by a willful mind devoted to one purpose alone.

Humans are not our enemies. Fodlans are not our enemies. The Nabateans are. The Gods are. We will kill. We will butcher. We will devour. Any who fall prey to the power, shall by our hatred be subsumed.

My palm pushed against the hand-print. The small pyramid beeped in the underwater lake, and then it trembled. I grabbed hold of its edges, held my breath, and as the floating devices functioned, we soon rose to the surface of the lake itself.

I gasped for air, letting it fill and burn my lungs.

We face dragons. We face monsters of might and magic, and their slaves twisted by their falsehoods. We shall become as gods, so that we may cast the gods down. And if the new gods shall become as the old, then they too shall be cast down.

I began to swim, pushing the small pyramid towards the shore. Once I reached it, I dragged it a bit further ashore, and the placed my hand against the hand-print again. This time, dark blue lines started to thrum, and the pyramid sides opened up like a delicate iron flower revealing their contents. There was a brief moment of silence, as I gazed into its contents.

We shall know no mercy. We are the remnants of our civilization. We are the guardians of the true history of the world. Until the last Nabatean dies, we shall know not freedom. Just as they condemned us all to die, we shall condemn them all. Let this cycle of hate, this vengeance, burn into our souls.

The weapon was small. It was a weapon of a more refined era. It was a product of humanity. It was the final arbiter of equality. Kings, Gods, Heroes, a strike to the head would wound them; it would kill them. It was the final equalizer. The ability to kill others, that was what determined equality in a world of might and magic.

When all are equally capable of dying, that is when true freedom is achieved.

I took a deep breath. Humanity had sought freedom. The Agarthan had sought freedom from the yoke of a Goddess. No Gods, no Kings, only humans. Did the Goddess have to die? Yes. The difference between a Tyrant and a Merciful King seldom depends merely on which side of the bed they wake up that particular morning.

Absolute power, in the hands of a single individual, is always a recipe for death and destruction. The chosen of the Goddess, for every kind one, how many were unkind? For every protector, how many were tyrants?

There was no way of knowing anymore. History had burned. The past had been destroyed. The present was a lie. The future would be born of the spilled blood.

I holstered the dagger. Perhaps a Nabatean might recognize it for what it was, or a fellow Agarthan. I wiped the water off my brow, and rubbed my hair to remove the last traces of water.

The rest of the contents of the cache were either small vitamin supplements and a mixture of first aid kits and drugs, designed in case of a special operative stuck in enemy territory, or small, honey-bathed portions of food. Nothing had spoiled. I glanced at the change of clothes within the cache, and closed my eyes.

The fiber that composed those clothes was three times as resistant as the Fodlan equivalent. There was a time where the Fodlans fought with the same intensity as us, a time when they were evolving to become like us. Then, the surviving Nabateans choked on their evolution. They choked on their intelligence. They made them sheep, braindead fanatics to a religion that held no other purpose but to keep them down, to direct the world into a path chosen by a monster.

Was that the truth?

Was that a lie?

There was no way for me to know.

I was merely a human, thrust in a world where history was broken.

The clothes fit. As I wore them, I stared at the symbols etched upon them. A black drop, with a silver eye surrounded by splitting branches. Military symbol, worn in battles to recognize active military personnel. It would be a crime to go without it.

The past was gone. No tribunal would sentence the likes of me for removing those.

The humanity that remained was regressed; the technology, the knowledge, the everything...

I wiped my face, the weight of the dead a soul crushing experience I had gone through more than once in my past, but still present to that day.

The final item in the cache, a mask.

"Are you God, that you get to decide who lives or dies?" I muttered, grabbing hold of the mask with both of my hands, lifting it up, staring at its contours. "Are you the judge, the jury and the executioner?" I whispered, faintly tracing the details of the flowery motifs that were etched upon it.

"Are you a wraith of the past, a vengeful spirit with justice as its purpose, or revenge?" I whispered further. I was talking to myself. I was talking to the past. I was talking to the dead. "Or are we merely human, with crushed hopes, and nightmares in place of dreams?" I chuckled. "Let us go," I stared up at the sky. The beautiful sky that was forbidden to those who still hid beneath, in the darkness, with fear and hatred their nourishment and strength.

I would free them from the chains of hatred. I would shatter the choking hold of the unwanted Gods.

"We have purpose," I murmured. "But truly, it is a wicked one."

---

"Three days," Byleth's voice was unwavering as always. Jertal knew she was taking it heavily, her expression ever so briefly shadowed by a hint of emotion. He had never seen her cry, but even he had to admit that when it came to emotions, his daughter showed them more whenever Shade was mentioned.

On one hand, he reckoned it was a youthful crush. On the other, he was probably the motherly figure in her life. The thought of Sitri briefly brought a fleeting shadow of sorrow in his own mind, but as he looked into Byleth's face, he could see her own face.

"Yes," he said, "Rhea doesn't want me to help you," he added, "You need to be careful around her. Shade said he'd help, but he managed to wriggle out three days of vacation for himself in the meantime."

Byleth's face remained unfaltering. "Three days."

"I said one, he said a week," Jeralt hastily added, "I wriggled him down to three."

Byleth's crestfallen expression was a pout, a small one.

"It's not going to be that bad," Jeralt said. "We've all gotten too used to his cooking. Some time weaned off it might do us all some good. Gonna help lose some weight-"

"...am I fat?" Byleth asked.

Jeralt had no answer to give, thus he gave none. "I hope you're handling your students well," he said instead. "How is it?"

Byleth nodded, "The Black Eagles, they are...with problems."

"Are they going to be up to the task? I know you'll handle it egregiously, but they're young and it will be their first time in a battle," Jeralt remarked.

Byleth crossed her arms in front of her chest, her expression unreadable, but it was usually the case with his daughter's muted emotions. She was way better than before though; Shade excelled not just in cooking, but also in dragging out from Byleth more and more emotions. Sometimes, he wondered if it was luck that made them cross each other's paths decades before.

"Oh Goddess gracious, that's a kid. You're bringing a kid with you on the battlefield. Good reasons or not, do you even know how to properly feed them? Name's Shade. Tough, wonderfully brilliant mercenary who shines light in the dark. Cause I'm brilliant-don't you groan at that! I bring my humor wherever I go. I'm a great cook, a great logistic officer, and most importantly...don't ever put me on a horse. I forget the word 'Retreat' if you do that. And the horse tends to die. I don't know why. Just, no horses."

Other times, especially when his men got accustomed to his cooking, he wondered if it wasn't just bad luck. Which brought him to the sad reality he had to notify his men that there wouldn't be any of Shade's cooking for the next few days.

"I'll teach them well," Byleth said. "Shade is going to lead your company?"

"Yes," Jeralt nodded, "But the church of Seiros has offered a battalion of mercenaries and some of their knights too, so you can lead either-"

Byleth nodded. "He'll make food for all of us?"

Jeralt sighed, louder still. "You'll have to ask him that. It's up to a battalion's leader to handle the supplies for their own men."

"He'll make food for all of us," Byleth affirmed.

"Byleth," Jeralt muttered, but then shook his head. "Bring it up to him, but bring your own supplies."

She nodded, looking ever so slightly more pleased than before.

Maybe Shade was right with some of his daughter's nicknames. The next step, though, would be the hardest.

"Well, Captain Shade is gone for three days, so you know what this means people!" one of the soldiers exclaimed.

"We're all going to starve?"

"We'll have to pun ten times harder to make up for his absence?"

"We must start a hunting party and bring him back?"

"We must make a peaceful protest with signs? No mercenary action, without food satisfaction?"

Jeralt simply massaged his face with the palm of his hand. What had Shade done to his mercenaries. Why had he not realized sooner. And how long until his company returned to accepting the natural order of things?

He really needed to keep a stricter eye on his men, and count the horses. He really didn't want anyone to get strange ideas.

---

My return to the monastery happened without much fanfare, and late at night. I yawned as I waved at a couple of knights of Seiros in charge of guarding the gates into the fortress-church. I was pulling a small hand-drawn cart with some supplies on it.

Mostly coffee beans, admittedly. "Got some special supplies for cooking," I said. "Couldn't manage to get back earlier in the day. I can wait outside until dawn if you prefer-"

"And miss preparing breakfast? I think not," one of the guards grumbled, "Captain Shade-" he was one of Jeralt's mercenary. "These three days were hell. Please don't leave us ever again."

I snickered, "Oh, you big babies. I'm sure you'd all cook delicious meals if only you tried."

"But why waste time learning how to cook, when we can have you cook?" the mercenary retorted, before giving the order to open the gate just enough to let me in with my supplies, not even bothering to check if what I was bringing in was coffee or some other manner of food.

It was coffee. For the most part.

I slept long enough to get some of the tiredness out of my limbs, and then reached for the kitchens to resume my post.

I was mostly done with the first batch of freshly baked honey bread and coffee, when a presence entered the kitchens.

"Oh, Devourer-of-breakfasts," I said with a grin, "Missed me?"

Byleth simply nodded, and extended a hand.

"What makes you think I found some candy out there?" I mused, before filching from inside one of my pockets a small sugar-filled, honey glazed, sugar-sprinkled, and wrapped in a small piece of cloth, candy. "Here you go," I said, "Am I forgiven?"

She popped it into her mouth, suckling on it before giving a quiet nod. "Jeralt told me," she said, "You'll be in charge of his company."

"Yeah," I said, "The armored division. I'm going to leave the Flankers to a support role. Canyon fighting-if they're smart enough to use the terrain to their advantage, it's going to be a gruesome inch-by-inch fight."

Byleth turned thoughtful, "Morale's gonna be the most important thing then," she said.

I nodded, "True enough. They'll be fighting for their lives. We'll be fighting to kill them."

"Motivation will be important," Byleth insisted.

I blinked at that, "Yeah. Have you prepared a speech or something?"

Byleth shook her head. "Food is important in motivating people."

"Uh, well, yes," I said, "That's why Jeralt's company has the highest morale of them all, I would hazard. That, and my charming personality. You want some pointers on-"

"Cook for us too," Byleth said.

"That's...I mean, that's a tall order. Jeralt's men are already a lot to handle. I can't handle two more battalions on top of that, even with the flankers helping me out in the cooking department-" I said, quietly glancing at the oven where the honey was starting to caramelize on the bread buns.

"Cook for me, then," Byleth said.

"No," I said. "If I cannot cook for the men, I will not cook for the officers," I softly added.

"The students," Byleth said then, "It's their first battle."

I sighed, "That much, I can do. But I want it to be clear; it's because they're students and they're going to be killing for the first time. Not because they're officers."

Byleth nodded. "It's my first battle as a professor too-"

"Byleth," I flatly said, "No."

"You are being mean."

"I am being honest with the soldiers," I remarked, "Treat them as you would your own sons, and they'll follow you into the depths of hell itself-" I whispered, "Rest and eat only after they have, and they shall stand by your side even in the most desperate of situations. That's what being a leader is like."

Byleth quietly looked on as I proceeded to pull the bread buns out of the oven. I could see the corner of her mouth showcase a single droplet of saliva. One of her hands nearly moved, but she then stopped it, and shook her head.

"I see," she said simply enough. "Leadership...is different from being a soldier."

"It is the weight of responsibility," I acquiesced. I glanced away. "Their lives are in your hands. They live, or die, by your commands and your mistakes. Just as much as your enemy's commands, and their mistakes, will determine their fate."

We are the horse riders of Agarth. We plunge our lances in the hearts of the evil Nabateans. We show no mercy to our enemies. Ride, my brethren! Ride and laugh at death's maws! Let evil be murdered, so that we may stand triumphant!

"Never forget that, Byleth," I whispered, "For every single one that dies for you, you owe the world a human life."

Even Hard-To-Read could see there was a slight bitterness on my face. "I'll make sure they all live."

"Don't make a promise that you may not get to keep," I retorted. "It will hurt you harder, when you fail to do so."

She shook her head, and then grabbed eight of the still cooling honeybuns. "I'll bring these to my students," she said.

"Oh? Not taking one for yourself too?"

She smiled, "If any remain afterwards."

I snickered at that, "Then, here," I said, grabbing one and placing it on the bundle together with her eight, "I don't actually like these sweet things, but I make them for the others. So, have mine."

She walked away with a happy skip to her step.

The smile slipped away from my face.

There is no justice to be found on a battlefield. No enemy is ever evil or good.

There is only the blood of the dead. There are only the cries of the wounded, the rasps of the dying, and the smell of death.

Yet, we must continue on this path.


I glanced at the buns that remained, cooled enough that I could start piling them up to one another and prepare another batch.

For it is the only path we know how to walk, us remnants of the past humans.

Us, vengeful wraiths of a long-forgotten civilization.

Us, demons with an eternal hunger for justice.
 
Meanwhile, much later in the game (plot spoilers, obviously):

Jeralt: *gets murdered by an Agarthan*

Byleth: ;_;

Shade: Ah, now I have a valid reason to turn against the Agarthans. Jolly good, then.

/because after awhile
//I'm sure that even Shade gets tired of being on Team "ALL GODS MUST DIE"
///or Team "DOWN WITH THE FILTHY MONARCHS"
////or Team "HUMANITY, HOORAH"
/////gotta spice it up!
 
I'm pretty sure that those were definitely the bad guys that were in the wrong and not the other way around...

AN: More 'Spoilers' follow.

You know, that's where there's something interesting worthy of exploring. Are the sins of a whole 'civilization' the same as the sins of the entire population?

I mean, the way the wiki/lore says it, the Agarthan wanted power and started warmongering because they had the highest level of technology, and thus wished to conquer everything. The Goddess (who was not a human, and one could argue had no business with human activities) intervened, and stopped them from conquering the world; then went to sleep to recover. When she did, the survivors of Agarth used a third-party to kill her as revenge for being forced to retreat underground.

Imagine the government of your country deciding a war against another country: are you, as a citizen of that country, guilty of that warmongering?

Are you, as a non-combatant, someone who should rightfully suffer for your leaders' sins? To never see the sky again, because sometime before a guy in charge said "Let us conquer this world" and 'aliens' stopped your country from achieving just that?

The folks that survived underground did so for countless decades, even centuries; there was a sizeable population that survived thus. There had to be men, women and children.

The Agarthan might have started the war, but there is a time where the retaliation to an aggression becomes, itself, a crime. You can most certainly defeat an enemy country, make them pay reparations, and go on with your life. But reaching the point where you condemn them to survive by escaping underground? How firm was the retaliation strike? How cruel the attacks?

That's what makes it an interesting and thought-provoking thing to explore and write about.

Of course, this is mere speculation from wiki-delving and walkthrough watching. If there's some extended lore that instead says that the Agarthian are cardboard-cut two-dimensional villains without any justifiable reasons for wanting the world to die except for "kek lol, we wanted to rule but aliens said no" then by all means, I am wrong.

(And I can live with it :V)
 
Um, well. That is certainly an interpretation of the Agarthans. Honestly, with the amount of information we're given about them it may even be correct. However, I always viewed it as the Agarthans being much much fewer in number. Considering they even had Nemesis in storage, their life extension and preservation methods made me think they were the remnants of the original Agarthans. More specifically, they were the extremist military remnants. I assumed that any civilian Agarthans that disagreed with their government would have dispersed and mingled with the Fodlan population long ago. Those that were left are what I assume to be the Mengele/Nazi/Supremacist subset that thinks horrific experimentation on children and wars of extermination are just methods to get what you want in life. For individuals like Kronya, I assumed that they wouldn't be beyond the kidnaping and brainwashing of children to bolster their numbers, considering the stuff they get up to in the game.

Bold choice to make the conflict more morally gray, but the material really works against you here. Way more than your She-ra work did.

Edit: Seriously, I'm curious as to the sort of Olympic-level mental gymnastics that ShadeSI will need to pull of to justify (to his character, at least) the horrific sort of child experimentation that the Agarthans get up to. I was not making hyperbole when comparing them to Mengele.
 
Last edited:
The idea of course isn't to 'whitewash' the actual crimes of the dark slitherers. (As the text already hinted, Agarth-Shade belongs to a more moderate faction). The reprehensibility of those acts isn't going to be questioned; but the fact that there are 'humans/citizens' amidst the Agarthan who just want to see the sky again is instead the moderate faction path. (Destroying the shackles of hatred, it means taking down Thales and co) yet, the church too must go.
At least, that was the idea. :V
 
I just know that the moment you saw they were a human faction fighting Alien Gods, and that their very name was "Those Who Slither in the Dark" you dove right in without reading the contract. So now you're stuck fighting an ancient conspiracy and feeding an emotionally stunted child while keeping her and her cute students as alive as possible. All this because of your snek fetish. :p
 
Yeah you've lost me, there really isn't any room for moral ambiguity here.
I mean, the way the wiki/lore says it, the Agarthan wanted power and started warmongering because they had the highest level of technology, and thus wished to conquer everything. The Goddess (who was not a human, and one could argue had no business with human activities) intervened, and stopped them from conquering the world; then went to sleep to recover. When she did, the survivors of Agarth used a third-party to kill her as revenge for being forced to retreat underground
Alternatively the Agarthans took advantage of the technology that they only had thanks to the Goddess to try and conquer the world, Sothis, an individual acknowledged and looked up to by every other nation in the world, stopped them and undid all the damage they'd done. Plus as far as I'm aware nobody forced them to go underground, they did that by themselves
The Agarthan might have started the war, but there is a time where the retaliation to an aggression becomes, itself, a crime. You can most certainly defeat an enemy country, make them pay reparations, and go on with your life. But reaching the point where you condemn them to survive by escaping underground? How firm was the retaliation strike? How cruel the attacks?
Again they chose to do that and any moral superiority they theoretically might have been able to claim ended at Zanado
The idea of course isn't to 'whitewash' the actual crimes of the dark slitherers. (As the text already hinted, Agarth-Shade belongs to a more moderate faction). The reprehensibility of those acts isn't going to be questioned; but the fact that there are 'humans/citizens' amidst the Agarthan who just want to see the sky again is instead the moderate faction path. (Destroying the shackles of hatred, it means taking down Thales and co) yet, the church too must go.
At least, that was the idea. :V
They literally could have left whenever they wanted to, even if the Nabateans did force them down there they've been dead for centuries, nobody knows who the Agarthans are and the god they hate so much is already dead

They're at best a bunch of petty assholes who can't accept that the war ended a long time ago
 
Being a Dragonborn in Fodlan would be heaven. So many dragon souls, neatly packaged, ready to slurp up.

A scaly all-you-can-eat buffet.
 
Last edited:
Never really played 3H myself, but if this fic is so different to the source material, then just we can just treat it as AU or something
 
Never really played 3H myself, but if this fic is so different to the source material, then just we can just treat it as AU or something
Agree, for the sake of Shade's internal drama of burning down the path of the story.
Writing is a creative field, some might argue that he should have put AU sign or something at the start, but just enjoy what madness he cooked up, shall we?
 
Ah, well, I don't understand shit! It's like Halo 5's Forerunners all over again!

Except it's medieval... with aliens... And magic... oof.
 
Last edited:
Shade Emblem: Hunger Eternal Part Four [Fire Emblem: Three Houses]
Shade Emblem: Hunger Eternal Part Four [Fire Emblem: Three Houses]

One could never predict how a fight could go. Even with all the tools at one's disposal, the element of chance, of luck, could play a pivotal role in altering drastically the events at hand.

"Jeralt," I muttered, "Do you have a moment?"

We would depart for the Red Canyon the next day. The students of the Black Eagles were as ready as Byleth could have made them. I, on the other hand, was restless. You could argue a lot about facing your own demons, but in the end, if said demons were weak, then they weren't demons to begin with.

Jeralt nodded, and as I closed the door of his office behind me, I neared the window. Outside, the sun was setting, and the night was coming out with its brilliant stars.

"You found something out," Jeralt said.

"I have," I acquiesced. "Promise you won't rush head-first into a confrontation, though?"

Jeralt took a small breath, "Can't promise you that."

"The Archbishop...she is not what she seems," I said. "She's...not human."

Jeralt frowned, "She has lived for a long time, but I suspected it was the power of her Crest, or the will of the Goddess. If she's not human, what is she?"

"There...was a conflict," I muttered, "a long time ago. Between the power hungry Agarthans, who could bring down from the very heavens death and devastation, and the Nabateans, who wished to guide humanity to prosperity, by keeping a tight leash on their desires." I chuckled. "There is no way for me to know who was right, or who was wrong. But mistakes were made back then. A lot of them. And...everyone paid the price. The Nabateans were slaughtered to a near-last. The Agarthans were banished beneath the ground. There, their hatred festered."

I looked away from the window. "A civilization...it's not a monolith. The will of a King is seldom the will of its peasants. There are factions, in the Empire, in the Kingdom, in the Alliance...even in this monastery," I pointed out, "The Agarthans...some did horrifying things. Terrible things." I shook my head. "Unquestionably evil things. There is no justification for them, for those crimes."

I clasped my fingers tightly around my arms, "But humans did horrifying things too; Nabateans did horrifying things. Everyone did horrible things. Yet, even so...things are coming to a head once more. This cycle of vengeance, of hatred-it's festered to once more the point of rupture. To break it, something must be done."

"So she's...Agarthan?" Jeralt asked.

"No, she's Nabatean," I said with a chuckle, "But it doesn't matter what she is," I added, "like it doesn't matter what I am." He looked at me, and my smile remained bitter, "what matters is what we choose to do next. There are...people, amidst the surviving Agarthans, who just wish to return to see the sky. To live once more amidst humanity, in peace, but...under a clear sky. However, they're afraid of further retaliation. The war against the Nabateans...it was never officially pronounced over."

"She's the leader of the Church of Seiros," Jeralt said, "what these people...what your people fear-" he had caught up. He was quick on the uptake. "Is that she would have them branded as enemies, to be hunted down and killed?"

"Precisely," I said, "And because of that fear, they will not stop supporting a different faction within the Agarthans. The extremists. Those who seek to reconquer Fodlan, to kill all the Nabateans, to slaughter all enemies and that treat those 'inferior humans' who chose to stay on the surface as nothing more than beasts...or expendable pawns." I grimaced.

"Why did you come forward now, Shade?" Jeralt asked. "Of all times, of all things?"

I chuckled, "Whether you would have believed my tale or not was one thing that kept me from telling you this, but there was also shame, and fear." I said, "But the extremists amidst my people, they are readying to move. I do not know where they are, or how many-I do not know the full extent of their plans, but I know they possess great power. Great enough that there was no way of stopping them. Yet, if the Archbishop is willing to forgive, if she's willing to move forward...then those amidst my people who feel the same way can still be saved."

Jeralt said nothing. He just remained silent, taking in my words, letting their weight settle in. He grimaced. "If war is coming, my company will need more men. But I'll need to know more. I hope you weren't planning on going to sleep anytime soon, Shade, because I won't let you go until you've answered everything you can."

I quietly nodded. "I wouldn't have it any other way."

Not once, did he doubt my words. Not once, did I feel the need to lie to him.

That was what friendship was, in the end.

---

I yawned for the umpteenth time as Jeralt's company marched in formation with me at its head. Jeralt usually stood on a horse to guide them. I instead held a banner in the nook of my arm and wore a form-fitting chainmail with metal gauntlets and a kettle helmet.

I could see Byleth walking in front of her own battalion, composed of the Seiros' own mercenaries, while she had given command of the proper Knight-forces to Edelgard herself.

The rest of the Black Eagles' students were keeping to a tightly-knit formation. There was one figure amidst them that held a spear, and who wasn't an original member of their troop to begin with. Apparently, he had asked and obtained to join their house out of sheer respect for Byleth's qualities.

I had little doubts about what qualities he had seen that he liked, but he was a young man, and Byleth more than capable of handling him.

If anything, I pitied the fool who'd end up having to cook for the rest of their lives for that hungry black hole in human form.

As if my unspoken thoughts had been spoken aloud, I noticed Byleth staring in my direction. I grinned and gave her a small wave of the hand, which she returned without her expression ever changing.

We'd soon reach Zanado, the Red Canyon. The place where the blood of the Nabateans had run the thickest by the hands of Nemesis. It was a quiet moment of reflection. The order to destroy the children of the Goddess had come from the Agarthans, and Nemesis, a human, had obeyed it. Had we returned to the surface back then, what would have changed?

Would we have been hunted down? We chose the darkness, and perhaps in so doing when the tides of war turned again, we remained safe. It was ironic to find safety in darkness, and yet dream and wish for the light.

My thoughts returned to the situation at hand, and the canyons' sides encroaching upon us. If the brigands had any scouts, they'd know of our arrival and take proper countermeasures.

On one hand, sending our own scouts to engage theirs would have been a better option; on the other we didn't have anyone I'd consider good for scouting. Leonie would have been excellent, but she didn't belong to the Black Eagle's house, and what we had was pretty much heavily armored troops. Too noise and slow to prevent a scout from running back to their masters.

There had been a bridge we had passed with relative ease; the bandits there had rushed back to reinforce the others once they had noticed just how many of us there were. This meant, however, that it was going to be that much harder to break through later on.

The brigands, quite predictably, stopped us at yet another chokehold. There was quite a good number of them; this had to be one hell of a bandit-rich region. Remarkably, we got the short end of the stick due to being the most experienced and heavily armored of them all.

"Pressure them here, we will detour; there's a side passage," Byleth ordered, and I gave her a thumb-up as she rushed past. "Edelgard, provide support!"

"Yes, professor!" the future imperial princess said, a large ax in her hands.

With a dreadful sigh, I slammed the banner on the ground by my side and pulled free my own ax from my back. "Company!" I bellowed. "Advance slow and steady!"

"Horrah!" they bellowed.

We didn't rush in; the enemy's lances were firmly set, and while a frontal assault might have been suicidal with horses, the heavy armor we had and the sharpness of our swords wouldn't have won us the day if we didn't walk as close as possible to the weapons' sharp blades to start hacking away at them.

Spears were an excellent tool of defense if the soldiers advancing ended up pushed forth by their comrades behind them, or if they didn't have shields to swat the spears away. Further, the brigands weren't divided in rows, but simply all bundled together.

Shoulder to shoulder worked great for formations, but a spear-formation needed depth.

They lacked that depth.

This meant that when we crushed through the first row of spears, it was a matter of locking weapons with them and the push-of-war began. My ax was held with both hands, its sharp edge thrust rather than swung due to the tight confines.

The white-haired figure of Edelgard didn't care about space, then again she was holding her large ax one-handed, which spoke volumes of her actual arm strength. Her hands briefly flashed with the arcane symbols for magic, and a billowing gust of fire slammed into a nearby spearman, who shrieked in pain before she swiftly cut his head off.

She had not hesitated.

She knew what killing meant.

My body crouched ever so slightly, finding further purchase against the ground, and then with a bellowing roar I pushed forward, bringing my ax back and then swinging it downwards. It sliced through armor and flesh; it cleaved the enemy, and I pushed through, the gap in the defenses temporary, but important.

The pommel of my ax slammed into the enemy on the right's stomach, the sharp edge deflected a blow from the left. My allies behind me pushed into the opened fold. My kettle helmet rang from a deflected blow. I gritted my teeth, and pushed over the dead body.

If you show fear, you will freeze. If you freeze, they will take your life. Do not hesitate! Do not know fear!

My muscles burned ever so as I noticed a few of the brigands start to break back. The position was unattainable for them; without any form of further support, they had to move back. This didn't sit well with me.

At the very least, a few archers should have been expected.

As if on cue, to prove my thoughts correct, a volley of arrows started to descend on us from a nearby ridge; the archers must have waited until their own troops had started to retreat in order to begin their own attacks. "Shields up!" I yelled, "Girl! Move back!" I snarled next, moving back and crouching behind the raised shields of my own men.

Once the first volley was done with, the brigands reformed. This time they were a mixed-arms company, with ax-wielders and lancers.

Well, whoever had taught them tactics had done a great job. These guys wouldn't collapse easily.

"S-Sir," one of the nearby soldiers gasped, stumbled, and then fell on the ground. An arrow stuck against his side, the wound not that deadly. Not unless the arrow was poisoned.

Damn them.

Damn them all to hell.

"Their arrows are poisoned!" I bellowed. "Shields up high and advance! Do not break formation!"

Under the threat of a death, with the enemies in front, we had no choice but to keep our nerve as we advanced. "Girl! Can you blast that ridge with some more fire!?"

"I-Yes!" Edelgard said. As soon as she said that, and a sphere of fire left an arcane circle to slam against the stony ridge, the terrain detonated in clouds of dirt and loose rocks. We charged in the time it took for the dust to settle down, swatting away spears and encountering actually armed resistance in the ax-wielders. Yet, at this time, their and ours formations broke as we ended up in makeshift duels against one another.

Human lives flowed out of hacked limbs, grievous injuries, and unnoticed daggers plunging right and left. Magic sometimes flashed, arrows tentative and hesitant, landed and struck friend and foe alike.

It was a carnage for the enemy more than for us, but we had still lost some lives. It was inevitable in any battle; it was common. Regardless of how much you could train your own men, the enemy would do the same. Regardless of how great your tactics, the enemy would think the same of theirs.

In the fights between men, even the most excellent of plans would still have casualties.

"I have a name," I heard the white-haired girl remark as we began to rush for the path up to the ridge itself.

"And it's a long one," I retorted. "In battle, I don't have the time for that. Eddie'll do."

"Ed-Eddie!?"

"Hurry it up, men!" I barked behind me, "let us avenge our dead comrades!"

"I am the Imperial Princess-"

"Eddie, get your men to move to protect our rear," I said instead, hurrying further up. "Hopefully, Billy's handling it on her end."

"...you call the professor Billy?"

"I call her so many nicknames she's lost count," I added dryly, before hastily jumping to the side as an arrow sailed past me, landing against the ground. The archers knew we were climbing up for them, so they had decided to come down to face us. "This is gonna be a slog; do you have some extra fire in you?"

Edelgard's hands gripped her ax, even as she muttered the arcane formula for more fire. "More than enough."

"Good."

We cleared the ridge of archers and their backup just in time to watch Byleth's own troops break through from the west, the woman in question holding on to a severed head by its hair, with the remaining bandits running away while throwing their weapons down.

"Ah," I said, "She went straight for their leader."

I sighed and cracked my neck. "You fought well," I added, glancing at Edelgard. "It wasn't your first time, was it?"

"It was not," she answered, flatly. Was she angry about the nickname? It was a great nickname.

We rejoined forces with Byleth and her students, and as she showed off the bandits' leader head to me, I simply arched an eyebrow. Then again, Jeralt had asked me to keep an eye out on Byleth's back, and she had most aptly ditched me to go fight on her own, so...

I reckoned, in her own way, this was her teenage rebellion phase. 'Look at me, father. My back is untouched by backstabbers! See? Nothing to worry about! Now return Shade to his cooking duties.'

I could clearly imagine her thinking that, even as I ended up opening a burlap sack just so she could dump the head inside of it.

"Thank you for leading us, professor. I guess there was no way we'd lose to such a familiar foe," Edelgard remarked, having in the meantime moved to rejoin the rest of her house. "In any case..." she glanced around, "Something about this canyon feels inexplicably strange."

It was probably the blood. Or the ghosts. Or the sins, crawling on my back.

Or Byleth's grumbling stomach. Though that one was merely in my imagination and not in reality. Yet its deadly presence to all of food-kind could not be discounted.

Once we returned to the monastery, Jeralt might have an answer for me. Or he might have decided to do things his way. Or any variation of those thereof.

I had given him trust, just as he had extended trust to me in turn.

Without trust, there could be no compromise, no attempt at improving the situation, and no better tomorrow.

The cycle of violence would be broken, if necessary...

...but what do you mean, Jeralt, I'm supposed to prepare a tea party for the archbishop!?
 
Umm... there exist other countries/continents in 3H, right? So why couldn't those Agarthans just flee somewhere where the church doesn't have power if they wished to return to the surface so badly?
Wait... why didn't they just do that in canon and take over some neighboring power instead?
 
Wait... why didn't they just do that in canon and take over some neighboring power instead?

Because like all cartoon villains in media, they think the sunk cost fallacy is something that you eat.

For an explanation that makes more sense in-universe, perhaps their war with Seiros resulted in the destruction of much of their infrastructure and knowledge on how to construct that infrastructure. They likely were left with Shambala, a few javelins of light, and not much else. Perhaps their time since then was spent reacquiring old knowledge and building up a power base. This would make some sense considering they were the ones to gift the elites with crests, but are shown in universe to still be conducting human experimentation in order to add another crest by the time canon rolls around.

Another thought to consider is that crests seem to largely only exist in Fodlan (and are hard to breed, so would likely disappear in a generation or two), and with the Agarthans obsession with them, they likely would stay solely for that.

Like I mentioned in an earlier post, my headcanon and what I believe canon implies is that very few Agarthans are left, and those that are would be either the original remnants that are having their life prolonged with dark magitek (dark crest-tek?), or those inducted and brainwashed from the outlying Fodlan population. In short, I don't really consider them a people in the sense of an ethnic group, their population size doesn't really feel large enough for it. I'd think there would only be around a hundred at most, no more since the life prolonging would likely need a crest stone and after Zanado, those would be in short and limited supply. They always seemed more like an immortal terrorist cell cut off from the main civilization if that makes sense?
 
Last edited:
So basically this version of the Agarthans are all idiots right? After all in the hundreds of years since the war none of them thought "let's just go somewhere else" or "we could just go up to the surface whenever we want, there's like three Nabateans left and they can't even tell if someones an Agarthan when they're literally right in front of them for years"
 
Back
Top