Sort of. She feels it worse in some ways because she's battered from all directions by what people THINK. Enough that she has to disengage and flee multiple times.
As a legilimencer child, she might have grown up to be a very accomodating and pliant individual, doing everything to please people around her. Like an extreme social mimicry, backed by literal empathy and mind-reading. Her isolation, for all it's downsides, ensured that she has a strong personality.

Hazel could only mull over silently something
looks like a wrong word ordering

When McGonagall had said before they were all split up into their houses and that they would be earning points,

A weaving type of tool might work for transfiguration? Weaving the magic into shape, unspooling the nature of one thing only to rethread it into another.
That reads like transmutation/alchemy - changing a thing permanently, by intricately rearranging and transmuting it's components. Transfiguration is usually depicted as enforcing your ideas and concepts (i.e. replacing a table with a pig despite not knowing a pig's makeup in detail). It is also reversible. I always thought of transfiguration as of making a solid illusion that behaves according to your wishes, and superimposing it over the object in question. A paintbrush would be a very appropriate tool for this task.
 
Last edited:
Oh! I wonder if there are Taboo spells on spoken words relating to Druidism and other 'darker' magics. A few hit squads of Unspeakables with full reign would explain these oddities.
Nah, the ignorance of wizards regarding the Druids has a much more mundane explanation.
If I recall correctly the Great Hall get's the colors of the winning house for the last meal of the school year, and also bragging rights.

More than one story (usually by an American author) has pointed out that this seems, lackluster considering the amount of effort it takes to keep said points and how everyone acts about it.

I'm not sure how the Brits who's school system was the basis for the 4 Houses see it mind you. They might find it perfectly ordinary.
I feel a little bit attacked :cry:

Honestly, I'm fine with the concept of house points. Humans are wired to identify with a group and then view other groups in an us-versus-them mentality. Just look at all the people who get way too up in arms whenever someone insults their favorite sports team. House points for a bit of bragging rights, yeah it's fine. Whatever.

The reason I have Hazel specifically not getting them is both because she is very independent and sees herself as an outsider and because she has a much more basic sense of priorities. Her main driving needs are primitive: How do I get food to eat? Where do I find shelter? How do I not get killed/eaten by something?

Bragging rights just don't fit in that list.
first, Sally-Anne's reaction to the word "cleansed" has me adding two and two and coming up with a solution of MURDER. Or at the very least I have a sinking feeling that Grievous Bodily Harm[tm] may need to be inflicted upon somebody within the Perkes' family circle
Ironically I mentioned on the FFN version not to try reading too much into Sally Anne's fears at the moment. I maybe should have said so here as well.

I will say that nothing like what you're imagining has happened to Sally Anne. It is just something she and her parents are worried about.
Second, Peeves himself might be more eldritch than first blush, and is vulnerable to getting shanked like a bitch. Which is useful information and will no doubt have interesting repercussions down the line
Heh heh :evil: I thought it was nice to give Hazel an option/ability that basically no one else in Hogwarts has.
....ok I have a question, why didn't she try to use the staff in transfiguration? Shouldn't that be her go to tool for anything she hasn't figured out a slicker method for? There's a lot of weight placed on that staff, why isn't she trying to leverage it?
1) She knows her staff is important, but she hasn't figured out how to use it.

2) It wouldn't matter even if she did try it because that isn't what her staff does anyway.
Also, quick question: is Hazel's magic actually different from witches/wizards at a base level, or is it the same but she just learned to use it differently due to being self-taught and then assumed that means she's not really a witch? I've been assuming the latter, but I'm curious if there's been any WoG on the topic.
She doesn't have nonhuman magic. She's fully human (at the moment :evil: ). She just uses it in a very different way.

Lily could use magic similar to Hazel's AND could do wizard magic. They aren't inherently incompatible.
 
She doesn't have nonhuman magic. She's fully human (at the moment :evil: ). She just uses it in a very different way.

Lily could use magic similar to Hazel's AND could do wizard magic. They aren't inherently incompatible.
Not quite what I was asking. What I meant was, are witch/wizard magic and druid magic actually just the same thing expressed through different mechanisms? Or are they, as Hazel believes, entirely separate types of magic? Basically, is Hazel's 'druid' magic something any witch/wizard could do if they put the effort in to learn (meaning it's just an undiscovered or no longer used expression of witch/wizard magic), or does it require a specific magic talent or heritage or something?
 
Lily could use magic similar to Hazel's AND could do wizard magic. They aren't inherently incompatible.

AHA! Spoilers. I thought Druids vs Wizards was just a cultural/knowledge thing, and the whole "my parents were Druids" thing was just childish thinking.

___

A good tool for transfiguration (and Conjuration/Vanishing) would be a stage-wizards sheet of clothing. But that's probably a very advanced idea/image. And Hazel probably never ever saw a stage-wizard perform.
 
AHA! Spoilers. I thought Druids vs Wizards was just a cultural/knowledge thing, and the whole "my parents were Druids" thing was just childish thinking.
That's not really a spoiler. Hazel already knows Lily could do both types of magic. And she knows that her dad wasn't a Druid. She still thinks that her and Lily's ANCESTORS were.
Not quite what I was asking. What I meant was, are witch/wizard magic and druid magic actually just the same thing expressed through different mechanisms? Or are they, as Hazel believes, entirely separate types of magic? Basically, is Hazel's 'druid' magic something any witch/wizard could do if they put the effort in to learn (meaning it's just an undiscovered or no longer used expression of witch/wizard magic), or does it require a specific magic talent or heritage or something?
They are both styles/traditions of human magic, just structured completely differently.
 
That's not really a spoiler. Hazel already knows Lily could do both types of magic. And she knows that her dad wasn't a Druid. She still thinks that her and Lily's ANCESTORS were.

They are both styles/traditions of human magic, just structured completely differently.
So basically it uses the same power source, but draws on it via different mechanisms? In other words, it's a difference in technique rather than anything inherent?
 
I will say that nothing like what you're imagining has happened to Sally Anne. It is just something she and her parents are worried about.
Ah, okay. Always was bad at math. :)

1) She knows her staff is important, but she hasn't figured out how to use it.

2) It wouldn't matter even if she did try it because that isn't what her staff does anyway.
What her staff does:


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OqCTq3EeDcY
 
Given how much of an emphasis has been placed on the Hufflepuff prefects making sure none of the first years get lost on their way to lessons, I can only expect that they'll be staging a frantic search of the whole castle once they realise they've accidentally locked the mute, (to their eyes) magicless girl out of the house. Meanwhile, Hazel is quite happily exploring Hogwarts in search of secrets and a quiet nook to fall asleep in.
 
You Hogwarts teachers are very different from common fanfiction depictions of them. Flitwick and McGonagall in your story are close minded and practical sorts. They don't think about abstract theory Their teaching is formulaic. They're good at their wizardry but they're not scholars. It fits Rowling Wizard's World very well. They reflect the values of their society.

What does her staff do though? I gotta know!
It's good for growing plants and to give blessings.

The question is, how long until she finds the Room of Requirements? And what knowledge will she find within?
The Room of Requirement can wait. The House Elves are a much closer and they know magic to teleport through annoying House Door. Visit the House Elves, Hazel. They can fix her shabby wardrobe and soft mattress. Maybe they can help her with Transfiguration too.
Given how much of an emphasis has been placed on the Hufflepuff prefects making sure none of the first years get lost on their way to lessons, I can only expect that they'll be staging a frantic search of the whole castle once they realise they've accidentally locked the mute, (to their eyes) magicless girl out of the house. Meanwhile, Hazel is quite happily exploring Hogwarts in search of secrets and a quiet nook to fall asleep in.
If Sally doesn't tell them they won't notice before the next morning. She left after they entered the common room.
 
if only because Professor Quirrell was starting them off on theory in a similar by more focused vein as Professor Flitwick.
but? more focused
When she could not longer see Professor Snape, she breathed a quiet sigh of relief.
no longer
Flitwick's the only one I can see diving into the underpinnings of an unorthodox casting style like that, but will he reach out enough if Hazel herself doesn't?
First he'd have to know it's happening and I sadly can't see her doing it out in the open enough for it to reach him.
Also, Dumbledore would probably want to take part in such a project, even though he is probably too busy to do more than review her progress every once in a while.
Finally, I can't see her trying to resustrure her whole magic around words. Or at least it's gonna take her a lot to want to do it because that would make her magic style closer to wand-waver magic and right now, well... She doesn't have a high opinion of wand wavers.
 
Back
Top