Secret Santa Short Story Contest

Joke aside, I do hope we can all have fun here with this event, and while this is a contest that is connected to our prompts... you could always write something that is inspired by the prompt actually!
Like lets say you got a "Wedding" based prompt... you could always simply be inspired by the idea and spin off of it and make something original if you don't want to work on a fandom work right?

This is supposed to be fun, so some wiggle room in case you get a prompt you really don't want to exactly work with feels like a good step forward right?
I'll approach whichever prompt I get in good faith, just thought I'd make my feelings on the matter known.
 
Rules Update: No Fandom-Specific Prompts
Semi-agreed. I'll still be participating myself, as I think plenty of these prompts are fun, but I really do not like how very fandom-specific a couple of the submitted ones are and I really hope I don't end up getting randomly assigned one of the fandomy prompts.
As much as I hate to be a Grinch, the guy above me is somewhat right. (Edit: the guy two posts above me) There are some prompts where I feel like some people just want to read a fanfic without actually writing it.

I still encourage everyone to participate, though! I really like some of the prompts I've seen so far! Special mention goes to my old friend Realm and that one about the timeless dragon.
I agree about the fandom-specific prompts, but I wasn't planning on letting it get in the way too much. If I don't know the fandom or characters I'll just get creative with them and the concept, and if someone was hoping for a fanfic they won't get exactly that.
Wait, shit? I haven't been looking at prompts for Secret Santa reasons; I thought it was heavily implied they shouldn't be fandom specific?

Ugh. I don't think I could write for a fandom I wasn't a fan of. Or at least vaguely acquainted with.
I wasn't gonna say anything but yeah, I'm not thrilled about the fandom prompts either. Seems kind of inconsiderate to potentially make someone dig through fandom wikis just to know what their supposed to be writing about if they want to participate properly.
I've been looking at the prompts (because it doesn't ruin the fun for me), and there are a few fandom ones posted that are for fandoms I know literally nothing about, I thought the deal with writing prompts was to create something that others could easily leap off of to create something- fanfic prompts sort of just don't do that. I wrote my prompt to have a lot of directions for whoever writes it to take it in, I thought that leaving them open ended was how writing prompts are supposed to work.
I would almost even like to request that fandom-specific prompts be disregarded for the purposes of this event? I feel like I'm making too big of an ask with that, but at the same time – I want to try and create a fun bit of fiction using a prompt, I don't want to write your fucking fanfiction for you!!!!

Taking into consideration the feedback here, and having honestly not considered that people would submit prompts set in a particular setting or the issues that might cause, I think this raises a pertinent issue. Whilst of course I love the enthusiasm from those who submitted fandom-specific prompts, I agree that it may make things a bit hard for other participants who receive those prompts and have no familiarity with the setting in question. This is worth amending the rules, I think.

Shortly I will edit the OP to make things clear, and PM the participants who submitted fandom-specific prompts and give them the opportunity to submit or edit in a new one. Apologies for the disruption everyone!
 
Last edited:
Kitsune_Obsessed's prompt
I wanna write something for someone for Christmas! I don't check SV much, so I'll probably need a DM when it's my time to write, or for someone to come bug me on discord. Here's a prompt so I can participate!
A fluffy Kitsune playing in the snow. Preferably cute, heartwarming, and Christmas themed.
 
Rakashua's prompt
You've Prompted me to act...

"It's been over 20,000 years since they locked you in your lunar prison after you attempted to devour the pantheon and the rest of creation along with it. You nearly succeeded, and in the end they could only imprison, not destroy you. Well, you've had a long time to think about it and, if you read the weave correctly, there isn't even a deity in the current pantheon who knows you exist. The chains are weak, and unlike these new gods and goddesses, you do not need followers to believe in you for your power, ancient abomination that you are. But have you learned your lesson? Will you break from your horrible purpose and choose a different path, a new life? Or bring destruction and chaos one final time? The choice is yours... Fenrir..."
 
Last edited:
Dr Heaven M.D.'s prompt
A lineage of historic figures, both villanous and heroic, greets the youngest member of the family, making the nation wait anxiously for the reveal of which side the child will take. Years later, they've taken a third option. It's kind of a lateral move.
 
Last edited:
Tempest Warden's prompt
Eh, I think I'll actually give a shot at trying one of these. Hopefully this works.

A story that comes full circle with events beginning and ending at the same location, a stranger calling out to the protagonist and speaking with them under a lone illuminated light pole as snow fell. After the Protagonist story comes full circle they take the place of the stranger at the end and have a similar conversation they had in the beginning with a different lone individual they call out to in the snow and while standing under the illuminated light pole. A major mid point in the story the protagonist goes through a location invoking the liminal space aesthetics.

Include a animal such as a fox, wolf, or lynx in some manor whether its just a theme, image, or physical animal etc. Alongside the involvement of a grandfather clock in some manner. Though both of these can be considered as optional.

A possible sense of the protagonist being alone but not really, the protagonist encountering characters they may or may not already know. Possibly include encounter(s) with the protagonists Family/Friends/Co-workers/classmates or whatever other group that may be chosen that the protagonist is apart of. Depending on what age is chosen for the protagonist whether their a kid to an adult, but the main thing would be those they encounter at the light pole being the same age range as the protagonist.



Suppose would involve having to check somewhere like wikipedia to get an ideal of what I mean by Liminal space (aesthetic)
 
Taking into consideration the feedback here, and having honestly not considered that people would submit prompts set in a particular setting or the issues that might cause, I think this raises a pertinent issue. Whilst of course I love the enthusiasm from those who submitted fandom-specific prompts, I agree that it may make things a bit hard for other participants who receive those prompts and have no familiarity with the setting in question. This is worth amending the rules, I think.

Shortly I will edit the OP to make things clear, and PM the participants who submitted fandom-specific prompts and give them the opportunity to submit or edit in a new one. Apologies for the disruption everyone!
I hope this is an appropriate place to ask.

I'm wondering if we can use a "fandom setting" if it fits the prompt? I have no specific plans at the moment but I do keep wanting to do some fanfic stuff.
 
Information: Actual Rules Clarification
I hope this is an appropriate place to ask.

I'm wondering if we can use a "fandom setting" if it fits the prompt? I have no specific plans at the moment but I do keep wanting to do some fanfic stuff.

actual rules clarification Someone else asked me this in PMs so it's actually really good timing that you asked here, as I wanted to clarify it in-thread where it's visible.

My ruling on this is that a fictional setting or fandom for your story, I.E. the short story you write based on the prompt you are randomly assigned, is absolutely fine. The rationale behind banning them for prompts is entirely based on the fact that it could make prompts inaccessible for someone unfamiliar with a given setting. By contrast, if it's just someone writing their short story entry, then by definition whatever helps them write it it is all to the good. Beyond respecting site rules, we have no desire to meddle.


Now that being said, I think that you are quite right to say that any fandom you bring in should ideally flow organically from the prompt and not feel shoehorned in. That's not a rules question, because there's no way to legibly adjudicate that, it's more of a good writing question? There's a world of difference between getting the prompt "You are cursed into becoming a living snowman and have only 24 hours to break your curse or melt." and deciding to cross it with Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, versus something like "You are a scientist cursed by their own invention, but for one day on Christmas you revisit memories of home and happier times." and making it about Bruce Banner, Victor Frankenstein, or so on. If that makes any sense?

Even then, I think it may be something of a high risk strategy, and it may be better to go with fictional conceits from media but with the serial numbers filed off, so to speak. For example you can easily write a story about Superman, and have people realise it's about Superman, without necessarily explicitly putting Superman in your story. The advantage there is that it can help the story to feel like more of a pure exploration of those ideas and themes, rather than like, being so bogged down in the specific lore and established characters of a given setting. Especially when you have only a short story to work with, this can be an advantage.

But everything other than the first paragraph here are essentially just my personal Hot Takes about how you might use other fictional settings in your stories. (This will to some degree be reflected in the judging but there will be at least two other people on the panel.) There a lot of SVers here who've submitted some great prompts, including some really experienced authors, so you might want to ask the opinions of other participants and start a discussion.


EDIT: I've stuck the actual rules bit in an info box just to make it clearer what is my personal writing advice, versus what is actually contest rules.
 
Last edited:
Zerohour's prompt
Sure I could use something to motivate me

A Witch and a Wizard have their traditional Christmas dinner together, all while trying to avoid the conversation they've avoided asking each other for years: Would you give up your magic for me?

(Concept is that magic must be their first and only priority. Anything less will slowly weaken them, though they will retain any knowledge that they have. They can choose each other, but neither wants the other to pay that price)
 
The mixing and matching of the prompts will only happen tomorrow, right?
I took a scare with 43 new notifications on this thread.

Submissions officially close at Midnight (GMT) tonight and realistically, probably I would hope for all the prompts to have gone out to their Secret Santas by like, tomorrow evening?

We are going to be doing something along the lines of putting everyone's names into a column of a Google Spreadsheet, copy-pasting it, then randomising the rows of the second column, and use that for assigning, then actually writing and sending the forty-odd PMs.
 
Best of luck to all writers. May you enjoy the story you (hopefully) get.
 
Back
Top