SAPR: Volume 2

Chapter 31 - The Climb
The Climb​



"Sunset!" Skystar waved one hand in the air as she approached down the street, her heels clicking on the paving stones. "Sunset!" she cried again, a bright smile upon her face as she drew near. "Fancy running into you here!"

"It's a smaller city than it seems, I suppose," Sunset replied.

Skystar laughed more than the comment warranted. "I'm so glad to run into you here; it means that I get to give you this myself." She held out a flier from a box of fliers tucked under her arm.

Sunset glanced over Skystar's shoulder; she could see that the street was filled with people handing out such fliers to anyone who was passing in the street, or at least trying to; not everyone took one, but most people did, and most even glanced at them before stuffing them into their pockets or bags.

Sunset did likewise, taking the flier out of Skystar's hand and looking down to see what it said. "Shakstspur in the Park?"

Skystar nodded eagerly. "The Vytal Festival is a celebration of culture, and since Vale is hosting, I thought, well, what could be better than celebrating the greatest writer in Valish history? So we're reviving the Second Richardiad right here in Winchester Park, the way they used to do theatre in the old days. You should come! You should bring your team! I've sat in on a couple of the rehearsals, and while I don't understand all of the language, some of it is hilarious, and other times, it's-" Skystar's words abruptly stopped tumbling out of her mouth as she caught sight of Blake, standing at the back of the quartet of young huntresses – and Twilight – just visible between Rainbow and Twilight who were, in turn, standing just a little behind Sunset.

The smile faded from Skystar's face, replaced by a look that was very like fear. No, there was no 'very like' about it; she was afraid.

And it didn't take a genius to work out what she was afraid of.

"So, um," Skystar stammered. "I, um, I should go. Have a nice day." She turned on her high heels and began to walk away as fast as they would carry her – she wasn't as nimble in them as Pyrrha, to say the least.

Blake sighed and half-turned away from the others, clutching at the metal band around her left arm with her right hand as her head bowed towards the ground.

Sunset exhaled from out between her teeth. "Skystar, wait!" she called out, running after the First Councillor's daughter. She supposed that it didn't really matter whether or not Skystar Aris held any ill will towards Blake or not, but it stuck in her craw that Skystar should consider Cardin Winchester to be a paragon of morality and the epitome of all that a huntsman should be while regarding Blake as some sort of depraved and dangerous criminal. It might not be strictly speaking backwards, but it was wrong, wrong enough that she was going to get an itch on the scars on her palm unless she did something about it.

The flier crumpled in Sunset's hand as she dashed down the street.

Thankfully, as unsteadily as Skystar was moving, it didn't take Sunset long to catch up with her. "Skystar!" she repeated.

Skystar's lip trembled with uncertainty, and although she seemed to be trying her best to ignore Sunset as the latter jogged by her side, she couldn't help but keep glancing Sunset's way.

Sunset quickened her pace, getting out in front of Skystar and planting herself squarely in the path of the Amity Princess. Skystar stopped, a squeaking sound passing between her lips, as she clutched at her box of fliers as though they would protect her.

She was wearing seashell bracelets on her wrists, Sunset noted idly and somewhat absurdly in the circumstances; it didn't matter, but it was weird. Couldn't the First Councillor's daughter afford real jewels?

Couldn't her boyfriend afford some real jewels?

"Skystar," she said, for the third or fourth time. "Blake isn't an enemy, and she isn't dangerous. "She's-"

"I know what she is," Skystar said quickly. "My mother told me… the truth, not what they told the news. She told me what she really is. She told me to stay away from her."

Sunset sighed. "Of course she did," she murmured. "Your mother," she added, maintaining a calm tone of voice through some little effort of will, "is just trying to keep you safe, but Blake doesn't deserve to be treated like a pariah."

"But she… she's-"

"A brave and devoted huntress," Sunset finished, "who has done more than anyone else to keep Vale safe from the White Fang."

Skystar stared at her warily. "Mother says she's dangerous."

"What's your mother doing to protect Vale?" Sunset snapped. "Beyond inviting an Atlesian fleet to do the job that she can't? Blake has just done more to protect Vale than all the cops in this town, which isn't that surprising, because most of them are on the take!" That reminds me, I should check if Blake has told anybody about that. In the immediate aftermath of the fight with Adam – in the aftermath of seeing that brand upon his face – the words that had passed between Adam and Torchwick had been driven out of her mind by other, seemingly more important concerns, but her anger at Skystar's attitude had recalled them to the forefront of her mind.

If Blake hasn't done it already, we really need to let… somebody know what Torchwick said about that.

"That… that was her?" Skystar asked. "Is she the one who caught Torchwick?"

"We caught Torchwick," Sunset corrected her. "But Blake was there."

Skystar blinked. "The news last night didn't mention that."

"No, I'll bet they didn't," Sunset replied.

"But why would a terrorist-"

"She's not a terrorist," Sunset insisted. "She… she was, I'll admit, and so would she; but she's not one any more. She's not that person anymore. She's not perfect, believe me, but she's not someone that you should be afraid of." She ventured a smile. "Not unless she asks you for a favour, then get ready to be plunged into a world of trouble."

"Then why does Mother think she's dangerous?" Skystar demanded. "Why does Cardy say that she shouldn't be allowed at Beacon?"

"Really?" Sunset replied. "Cardy says that? Does Cardy say that he's done anything about that?" Maybe I won't need Cinder's help to find out who graffitied our door after all.

"What do you mean?"

"I mean… don't worry about it," Sunset said, because getting into the issue of what sort of man Cardin Winchester really was would distract from the real issue. "The point is that Blake… Blake isn't perfect, but she is worth far more than those who hiss at her the loudest."

"Then why…?" Skystar hesitated. "I don't know."

Sunset snorted and stepped out of the way. "All I ask," she said, "is that when your plays go off without a hitch, and everything else, you ask yourself who is responsible for that. I guarantee that Blake will be amongst them." She won't let herself not be involved.

Skystar stood still, and for a moment, Sunset thought that she might say something, but she didn't; she hastened away, glancing at Sunset and looking over her shoulder as she went, but going all the same.

Sunset watched her go, her back to the others as they joined her.

"How did that go?" Twilight asked.

Sunset shrugged. "Who can say, really?"

"You didn't have to do that," Blake murmured. "It doesn't really matter what she thinks of me."

"Yes," Sunset declared, rounding on her. "It does."

Blake didn't meet Sunset's eyes. "I don't do this for recognition," she said. "Or for the good opinions of those I protect."

"But you do protect them," Rainbow said, a touch of sharpness in her voice. "So they should appreciate you for it."

Blake managed to raise a slight smirk upon her face. "'I turned up at the theatre, as sober as can be,'" she murmured. "'They found a drunk civilian room, but not a seat for me.'"

"'I next went to a public house, to get a pint of beer,'" Twilight said. "'The barman looked at me and said, "We serve no soldiers here."'" She paused. "I'm a little surprised you know Bramley, given the… the, um-"

"The fact that he was egregiously racist?" Blake suggested.

Twilight winced. "In the context of his time-"

"He was still a racist," Blake insisted. "And treating the people of the past like they were an indivisible mass of bigotry does a disservice to those who fought against prejudice and oppression."

"Yeah, well, you'd know all about judging people as one big blob, wouldn't you?" Rainbow asked.

Blake's cheeks reddened a little with embarrassment, and she did not reply; what could she have said, even if she had wished to reply?

"Anyway," Rainbow went on, folding her arms across her chest, "are you two going to stand there making me feel stupid because I don't read as many books as you, or are you going to explain?"

"It's a poem," Sunset answered. "Part of one, at last; an old Atlesian-"

"Mantle," Twilight corrected. "Bramley was writing not long after the Great War, before Atlas had supplanted Mantle as the heart of the kingdom."

"That particular poem is about soldiers," Blake said, "and the treatment shown to them back home. The ill-treatment. Or are you going to tell me that Atlas has moved on since then?"

"Yes," Rainbow said at once. Then she hesitated, squirming for a moment. "Well, some of the time. Mantle… yeah, okay, I can see that happening in Mantle today because Mantle sucks."

"That's a bit of a sweeping generalisation, don't you think?" Twilight asked.

"Can you think of someone getting thrown out of a bar for being in uniform anywhere but Mantle?" Rainbow replied.

"Well…" Twilight trailed off, at least for a few seconds. "I think it varies across the kingdom, really. Mantle… a lot of people resent the military because they resent Atlas and the way that Mantle has declined, as they see it, under Atlesian rule. On the other hand, you've got Canterlot, which is very heavily associated with the Combat School, and Crystal City, where the R&D test beds are, and I think in both places, you'd find soldiers are pretty popular."

"And in Atlas?" Blake asked.

"In Atlas, everyone knows someone in the service or knows someone who does," Rainbow declared. "In Atlas, they know who keeps them safe. People round here should do the same."

"It's not like I'm wearing a Defence Force uniform," Blake murmured.

"No, you've actually accomplished something," Sunset pointed.

"Sunset!" Twilight squawked reproachfully.

"What?" Sunset cried. "We've accomplished more than the cops or the soldiers."

"Than the Valish soldiers," Rainbow corrected.

"Whatever," Sunset said dismissively. "The point is that Blake deserves a little respect. We all deserve some respect."

Rainbow nodded. "No argument here."

"Well, this isn't Atlas," Blake replied. "It's not the idealised Atlas that exists in your heads-"

"I don't have an idealised version of Atlas in my head." Sunset protested.

"Then you're the only one here who doesn't," Blake said quickly. "This isn't even the real Atlas. This is Vale, and I'm-"

"An Atlesian soldier," Rainbow finished for her.

Blake raised one eyebrow. "That's not exactly how I would describe my position."

"Oh, come on!" Rainbow said. "Haven't you had fun working with us?"

"I'm not sure 'fun' is quite the word I'd use," Blake said softly.

"Then what would you call it?"

Blake was silent for a moment. "Twilight, where are we going? There's no point us just standing here all day."

"Right," Twilight said, a touch of nervous laughter in her voice. "Now, um, where is it? Um." She got out her scroll, her fingers fumbling just a little bit as she opened the device, bringing up a map of Vale. She typed a name into the search bar on the top right-hand corner. "Ah! Here we are!" she cried, as a point on the map became marked with a red dot. "Bibliophiles' Paradise."

"Not exactly a humble name," Sunset observed.

A sigh fell from Blake's lips. "These booksellers just can't help themselves, I suppose. They have to make grandiose claims for themselves."

Sunset's brow furrowed. "You're thinking about Tukson?"

Blake nodded solemnly. "I haven't been to see him."

"You've been pretty busy," Sunset pointed out.

"I should have made time."

"We've got time now," Rainbow pointed out. "Twi, can we put off the bookshop until after we've swung by the hospital?"

"Of course," Twilight said brightly. "Do you know which hospital it is?"

"Lancaster Memorial," Blake answered.

"He might have been discharged," Rainbow suggested, as Twilight typed the name into her search bar. "It has been a while."

"I suppose," Blake conceded. "But if he isn't there, they might know where he went."

"Why don't you just call him?" Sunset asked.

Blake looked at Sunset, and her ears pricked up with embarrassment as her face froze in a look of wide-eyed mortification. Blake continued to stare.

Sunset felt a smile spread across her face. "You hadn't thought of that, had you?"

"I…" Blake faltered, turning away from Sunset as she got her scroll out. She said nothing to anyone as she started to thumb through her contacts.

Sunset exchanged a glance with Rainbow over Blake's shoulder.

"Don't sweat it," Rainbow told her. "Twilight forgets the obvious stuff sometimes, too."

"Rainbow Dash!" Twilight squeaked.

"It's one of the many reasons why I love you," Rainbow assured her with a pat on the shoulder.

"Huh," Blake muttered.

Sunset took a step closer to her. "What?"

"Tukson's number has been disconnected," Blake whispered. "But… why?"

None of the other three girls said anything.

"Well, we won't get any answers here," Twilight said with a touch of faux cheer entering into her voice. "We might as well swing by the hospital. I know where to go; it's this way."

She led the way, a pace or two out in front of the others, giving them someone to follow, even if they weren't following any great distance. Rainbow and Sunset both hung back with Blake, whose steps dragged just a little bit as she followed Twilight with a subdued, shuffling gait.

"If anything had happened to him, they would have told you," Sunset assured her.

"Would they?" Blake replied, glancing up at the girl on her right. "I'm not his family; I'm just… an old comrade from a past that he keeps secret and for good reason. Why would anybody bother to tell me anything?"

"The General would have told you," Rainbow insisted.

"Would General Ironwood even bother to find out?"

"General Ironwood assigned the guards to protect the guy in hospital; they'd tell him if he… if he died there," Rainbow replied. "And he'd pass that on. He wouldn't sit on it and leave you in the dark."

Blake was quiet for a moment. "I suppose he'd want to give me cause and motivation to fight back against the White Fang."

"As if you don't have that already," Sunset muttered.

"He'd tell you because it's the right thing to do," Rainbow corrected Blake.

"And Atlas always does the right thing?"

"Once they've tried everything else," Sunset said.

"Very funny," Rainbow said. "We may not always do the right thing, but we don't ever try and do the wrong thing. We just… make mistakes, like everyone else." Rainbow put her arm around Blake's shoulder. "But if you come to Atlas with me, you'll get it."

Blake glanced at the huntress to her left. She snorted.

"What?" Rainbow demanded. "You think I'm joking? I'm serious! Once we've saved Vale from the White Fang and given Skystar the breathing space to hold a totally awesome Vytal Festival, then-"

"The terms of my agreement with Atlas will be complete," Blake said. "I'll be free." She looked at Rainbow again. "Unless you mean to change the agreement on me?"

"Of course not," Rainbow replied, her tone rising to mild outrage. "That's not how Atlas does things; that's not how I do things. I gave you my word that we were going to keep you in until this White Fang thing was done, and then we'd let you go, and I never, ever go back on my word." She was quiet for a moment. "What I'm saying is, that when all that is done, we'll be shipping back to Atlas, and I think you should come with us."

Blake stared at her.

Rainbow blinked. "What?"

"I'm waiting for the punchline," Blake said dryly.

Rainbow rolled her eyes. "Come on, Blake, there is no punchline!"

"You're serious?" Blake demanded. "You're not kidding?"

"Of course I'm not kidding; why would I be kidding about this?" Rainbow asked.

"Because it's Atlas?" Blake suggested.

"Because Blake already has a spot here at Beacon," Sunset added. "Why would she need to transfer?"

"Because you'd fit right in at Atlas," Rainbow insisted. "You're smart, serious, committed; if you could learn to do as you're told, you'd be the model Atlas student. You're much more of a model student than I am." She paused. "And besides, what are you going to do here at Beacon? Are you going to steal Sunset's bed for the next four years? Are you going to be the fifth wheel for Team Sapphire the entire time you're here at Beacon?"

"You're welcome to stay for as long as you want," Sunset told her. "No one minds having an honorary member."

Blake's brow furrowed. "Perhaps, with a little more time, my team will-"

"What?" Rainbow demanded. "Are you hoping that they'll come round? Forgive you? You could do so much better than them! Lyra has no business being a huntress, Bon Bon isn't much better, and Sky Lark is a sack of flour; transfer to Atlas, repeat your first year, get yourself a cool red aiguillette on your uniform and get yourself three tough northern flowers to have your back."

"'Northern flowers'?" Sunset repeated incredulously.

Rainbow shrugged. "It's something Ciel says. Flowers of the North is what we are, if you listen to her for long enough."

"'Up, through snow and cold and heart of winter,'" Blake whispered. "'Rise up, and bloom in glory.'"

"Exactly," Rainbow said. "The point is that we're tough; we can survive the winter, so we can survive anything. And I think that you could survive it too. I guarantee you'll make team leader there too; in fact, I'll mentor you to make sure you do."

"You'll mentor me?" Blake repeated.

"Okay, that sounds a little formal; I just mean I'll teach you what General Ironwood looks for in a leader," Rainbow explained. "Although you've probably got it all already; you just need to show that you can step up to the responsibility."

"I don't know," Blake murmured. "I wasn't such a great leader last time."

"You were lying to your teammates the last time; that won't be a problem in Atlas," Rainbow declared. "Come on! I'm talking about access to all the most advanced toys; I'm talking about high-tech training facilities; in fact, I'm talking about high-tech everything facilities at the best-funded school in Remnant; I'm talking about air support on tap. What's not to love?"

"I'm a faunus," Blake pointed out.

"And what am I?"

"An ugly fish," Sunset answered.

"You're different," Blake said, ignoring Sunset.

"Oh, yes, let's go back to the days of you thinking that I'm a sellout for serving Atlas," Rainbow muttered.

Blake's cheeks reddened. "I didn't mean it like that. I just meant… you have connections to General Ironwood; you're protected from what it's really like in Atlas for ordinary faunus."

"Neon doesn't have pull with the General, and she makes it work," Rainbow said. "And she's not the only one either. Besides, you could have pull if you wanted."

Blake frowned. "What do you mean?"

"I mean, we're working directly for General Ironwood himself," Rainbow explained patiently. "He reads my reports, and I'm going to write good things about you tonight after we're done. I think he's going to like what he reads. General Ironwood recognises talent when he sees it, and… and when he sees talent worth nurturing, he doesn't give a damn whether they're a faunus or not."

"Neither does Beacon," Sunset insisted. "You could ask Ruby or Pyrrha or Jaune, and they'd all tell you that none of them mind you rooming with us; none of them would mind you staying on as a member of our team; you've even got your name on the wall now." She paused. "Did you actually want to come to Beacon for a reason, or was it just that you were in Vale at the time?"

"I…" Blake trailed off for a moment. "I wanted to train as… I wanted to… it sounds stupid."

"Maybe," Sunset allowed, with some idea of what she was about to say, "but you have to say it anyway."

Blake snorted. "I wanted to see if it was possible for someone like me to become a hero, at the school that produces heroes."

"You think Atlas doesn't turn out heroes?" Rainbow demanded.

"Not of the same calibre," Sunset informed her in a tone whose blitheness was entirely feigned. "Listen, Blake, I know that things at Beacon aren't going entirely as you planned when you came here, but they're going okay, aren't they?"

"At Atlas, you'll have a place to belong."

"You have a place to belong right here at Beacon, with Team Sapphire."

"Teams are four members, and you'll be leader of a team if you stick with me and come to Atlas."

"At Atlas, you'll be pushed into a mold-"

"Oh, come on, even you can't actually believe that!" Rainbow snapped.

"At Beacon, you're free to become whoever you want to be."

"That's true of Atlas too, but we've got airships as well."

"Oh, for goodness sake!" Twilight cried, rounding on all three of them. "Blake isn't a toy for you to fight over or a prize for one of you to claim from the other."

"That isn't why we're arguing," Rainbow said defensively.

"Although it would be nice to win," Sunset muttered.

Twilight glared at her.

"I'm kidding!" Sunset cried. "I'm… ninety percent kidding."

Twilight folded her arms. "Don't you think that Blake should be free to make this decision for herself?"

"I'm just letting her know that she's got options," Rainbow insisted. "And maybe offering some encouragement one way."

"Just like I was just encouraging her to go a different way," Sunset said.

"I think you've both encouraged Blake quite enough," Twilight declared. "Don't you agree, Blake?"

"I, uh, thanks, Twilight," Blake murmured. She looked at Rainbow Dash. "Why does this matter so much to you? Why do you want this?"

Rainbow stared blankly back at her. "What do you mean?"

"I mean why are you trying to… to recruit me?" Blake asked. "Why does it matter whether I come back to Atlas or not? Maybe I would like it there, maybe… I'll admit that you've been nicer than I was expecting you to be. Maybe I'd even fit in there. But why do you want it? Why don't you just fly away and leave me behind?"

Rainbow didn't say anything for a moment or two. "Because… because I like you," she said. "And because… because you don't want to be a hero. Not like that statue in the courtyard, anyway; Atlas makes heroes too, but it's a different kind of hero, and I think that's the kind of hero that you want to be: a part of something bigger than yourself, something more than just you standing out in the field alone. I think… I think you're made of the right stuff. I think you could have the Mettle, if you came to Atlas and saw what we're all about."

"The Mettle?" Blake repeated.

"It's… how do I explain it?" Rainbow asked. "It's a… it's like a semblance that we all share, but it's not like a power or anything-"

"So it's nothing like a semblance?" Sunset mocked.

"Shut up. I'm trying my best," Rainbow snapped. "The Mettle of the North is our fighting spirit: it binds the forces of Atlas together; it's our will to defend the kingdom and keep our people safe; it gives us the determination to keep fighting and see things through to the end, no matter the odds. More than the guns and the bombs and the ships, the Mettle is why we win." She scratched the back of her head. "Ciel explains it better than I can; even the General can put it into better words than me."

"It sounds… to be perfectly honest, it sounds appealing, although I'm not entirely sure how it differs from ordinary courage or determination," Blake murmured.

"Our own courage can falter," Rainbow said. "Our determination can reach its limit, but the Mettle never runs out."

"Do you really believe that?" Blake asked.

Rainbow took a few seconds to reply. "It helps to be able to tell yourself that, when it feels as though you've got no courage left," she said softly.

Blake's ears drooped. "I… I see." She looked away from Rainbow Dash. "I never would have thought about coming to Atlas if you hadn't mentioned the idea," she confessed, "but now that you have mentioned it… I don't know. Sunset's right; I wanted to come to Beacon for a reason, but… I can see that in Atlas… I don't know."

"You should tell her the other reason," Twilight said.

"I thought you said I'd encouraged her enough?" Rainbow replied.

"You have," Twilight told her, "but you might as well be completely honest."

"Honest?" Blake repeated. "Honest about what?"

Rainbow licked her lips. "It would be nice," she admitted, "to have more faunus working their way up in Atlas. We're not going to change things by holding rallies like your parents; we're not going to change things by setting off bombs like the White Fang; the way we're going to change things is if faunus like you and me can climb our way to the top of places like the military. Once we get our hands on the levers of power, then we can pull on them."

"That's generally what you do with levers," Blake observed.

"Exactly," Rainbow said. "And when we pull, things can really change for the faunus! That's my plan, anyway, and Twilight says that it's a good one."

"I think it's the best possible choice," Twilight said, "and, please, believe me when I say that I'm not just saying that as a human anxious to preserve my own privileges. Although you won't have to take my word for it, because I'm going to show you at some point today."

"I'll do it alone if I have to," Rainbow said, "but it would be better with company."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. She was genuinely surprised to hear Rainbow talking that way. "In all the years that I knew you at Combat School," she said, "you never once gave any sign that you thought this way."

"I never made any secret that I wanted to climb all the way to the top."

"I thought that was because you had a huge ego."

Rainbow grinned. "Well, there's that too. But I can have selfless motives as well. Besides, it's not like we were close back then, so why is it so surprising that you didn't know my secrets?"

"It's surprising that you were able to keep it secret," Sunset commented.

"Why did you have to keep it secret?" Blake asked.

"You know," Rainbow said, with a shrug of her shoulder. "Some people… they might not like the sound of it. It might sound like infiltration or something."

"Don't you think the fact that you have to think that way is a possible indicator that… that something isn't right in Atlas?" Blake suggested. "That there are powerful forces, entrenched interests that are opposed to granting us real equality?"

"There are powerful forces opposed to humans being alive," Rainbow said. "Just because a battle's hard doesn't mean it isn't worth fighting."

"There are some who wouldn't see what you're planning to do as fighting."

"Yeah, but the people who would say that are the ones who go around hurting kids, so they can bite me," Rainbow replied sharply.

"All the same… " Blake murmured.

"It seems a little naïve," Sunset said. "How do you know that they'll even let you get to the top, let alone change anything once you get there?"

"I don't know they will," Rainbow conceded, "but I don't know they won't either. And while I think I can, I have to try." She pumped her fist. "And if anyone tries to stop me, I'll smash all obstacles in my path and do it anyway!"

Blake chuckled. "Maybe you're right," she said. "Maybe it is the best way; you're right that the other ways that have been tried… didn't work out so well. But at the same time… I don't know." She glanced at Sunset, who thought that she was referring as much to the idea of going to Atlas as she was to Rainbow's hidden ambitions. "I just… don't know."
 
Chapter 32 - A Misplaced Word
A Misplaced Word​



The title of the book was Prison Journals by Rudi Antonio. It was a large volume, well-preserved despite its age, with a handsome black cover – evoking something of a feeling of a jail – and the title and author's name picked out in gold letters. Blake had never heard of the book or author before, but as her eyes lingered upon the words 'with a new introduction by Sienna Khan' picked out in the same gold as the title near the bottom of the cover, she knew that at least somebody had.

Blake knew that her erstwhile mistress had been a historian before joining her parents in devoting themselves fully to the cause of the White Fang; in quiet moments, when she was in a restive mood, Sienna would occasionally reminisce about her time in what she described as the gerontocracy of academia, enduring the racism of tenured professors old enough to remember when faunus had been slaves; Blake sometimes thought that Sienna Khan must have been exaggerating about that. It was a part of Sienna's past that was not a mystery to her, and yet, this was the first time that she had ever held a book in her hands that dated from her time as an academic; everything that she had read from the High Leader had been written later, after she had committed herself first to politics and then to violent struggle. The fact that this tome in her hands predated all of that dated the book, or at least this edition; it must have been from quite some time ago for anything Sienna Khan had to say about it to be 'new.'

As she sat in the lounge of the skydock, waiting for a Skybus headed for Beacon, Blake wasn't sure what she wanted to read more: the book itself or the introduction by her former leader.

I wonder what she sounded like, back in those days.

"You're staring at that book as though you'd like to set it on fire with your mind," Twilight observed as she settled down on the grey padded chair next to Blake.

Blake looked up – to where Sunset and Rainbow were engaged in animated conversation on the other side of the aisle – and then beside her into Twilight's face. "I'm sure that someone has a semblance that would let them do that," Blake observed, "but-"

"But that would be an awful way to treat an old book, so I hope they wouldn't use it," Twilight replied.

Blake managed a slight smile. "It would be a pretty poor way to treat a gift, too."

"All the same," Twilight said, "is everything okay?"

Blake showed her the book cover, her finger hovering near the point about an introduction from Sienna Khan.

Twilight frowned. "Sienna Khan; does that mean something to you?"

Blake's eyebrows rose. "She's the leader of the White Fang."

Twilight gasped. Her mouth formed an O of surprise. "Really?"

Blake nodded. "You really didn't know that?"

Twilight shook her head. "The White Fang are quite the mystery."

Or humans just don't care to discover the truth, Blake thought, but that was possibly a little unfair and certainly rather unkind; the White Fang as a political group had become a marginal force long before her father stepped down and retired to Menagerie, and since assuming the role of High Leader, Sienna had done nothing to elevate her public profile. 'The cause is what matters, not my reputation,' she had been wont to say, before adding wryly that if nobody knew who she was, then it was harder for Atlas to order her assassination.

Adam, of course, had disagreed, both in the matter of holding his fame as the Sword of the Faunus of great import to himself and also in relishing in the notoriety that he enjoyed amongst their enemies, the terror that he inspired across all four kingdoms.

Of course, Adam never had any fear of death, at least none that he would allow even Blake to see.

"I'm a little surprised," she said, "that you haven't pumped me for information yet."

"What do you think you still know?" Twilight asked. "I mean, no offence, but you're a defector; the moment you left they would have moved their safehouses, changed their passwords, taken precautions against you… against you…"

"Against me deciding to betray my cause," Blake murmured.

Twilight's eyes were wide with concern as she reached out and placed a hand upon Blake's arm. "You didn't betray anyone until you were betrayed by the White Fang first; you kept all of their secrets until you were exposed."

"I went down to the docks before I was exposed," Blake pointed out.

Twilight hesitated. "True," she said. "But even so, you kept their secrets. And… all the more reason for them to take precautions about you leaking any information; the fact remains, any specifics you know are probably worthless now."

"Yet I'm not worthless to you," Blake replied.

"You're much more than a source of intelligence to us," Twilight assured her.

"Hmm," Blake murmured. "I'm…" she trailed off, her eyes flickering to Rainbow Dash across the aisle. "What am I to her?"

"A friend," Twilight said. "It's a great place to be." She smiled. "Nowhere safer, I guarantee it."

"I didn't exactly come to Beacon looking for safety," Blake informed her, "and I don't think that I'd go back there looking for safety, either."

"No, I suppose you didn't," Twilight said. She pushed her glasses back up her nose. "It's entirely your decision, obviously, but Rainbow wouldn't be asking you to come to Atlas if she didn't want you there, and she wouldn't ask if she didn't think it would be good for you. Rainbow… Rainbow thinks you need a cause."

Blake snorted. "Rainbow might be right," she admitted. "Of course, if Ruby were here, then she'd say that, for a huntress, serving humanity is the cause."

"I'm sure it is," Twilight agreed. "But a lonely one for most huntresses."

"And in Atlas, you're never alone?" Blake asked wryly.

Twilight chuckled. "If you really want more of the sales pitch, you should go over and talk to Rainbow Dash. I'm just explaining why she wants you, and maybe… maybe telling you not to dismiss the idea out of hand. And not to dismiss Rainbow's ideas out of hand, either."

Blake raised the book. "Is that what this is about?"

"He was a Mistralian faunus," Twilight explained. "He was elected to the Mistral Council, not too long after the Great War, but he was arrested and imprisoned for… for the rest of his life. And while he was in prison, he wrote."

"About what?"

"Everything, as I understand it," Twilight said. "Philosophy, history, politics… he advocated for a march through institutions as a solution to the question of how to obtain equal rights for the faunus." She paused. "It was an approach that… fell out of fashion compared to more activist ways of… attacking the problem."

"Literally," Blake muttered.

"I got it for you," Twilight went on, "because I wanted you to see that Rainbow isn't just being naïve, or making excuses for her loyalty to Atlas; incredibly intelligent faunus have thought deeply about these issues and come to the same conclusions."

"Has Rainbow read this?" Blake asked.

Twilight couldn't quite stop herself from smiling. "No," she said. "I love Rainbow Dash, but I'm not sure she'd have the patience to get through this."

"But you introduced her to the ideas?"

Twilight shook her head. "Not until after she'd already had them. She came up with the basics all on her own."

Blake's eyebrows rose. "Really?"

Twilight nodded. "The way I remember, we were lying awake one night, and Rainbow had been staring up at the ceiling for a little bit when she said 'You know, Twi, if we had some faunus senior officers, I bet things would be a lot better for all the faunus.'"

"Somehow, I suspect that's a simplification of the arguments in here," Blake said dryly.

"Oh, of course, but it's a start, don't you think?"

"I suppose so," Blake conceded, "but it's still a start that I don't know if I want to be a part of."

"I can understand that," Twilight said. "We're still asking you to take a great deal about Atlas on trust, with only a handful of people to really illustrate what the kingdom is like. And that's after all the trouble you had with Rainbow Dash earlier in the year."

"I've forgiven her for that," Blake said, "but it did demonstrate to me the problem of making rash judgements and assuming groups to be heterogeneous. If I take you as the average of what Atlas is like, then I'd be making the same mistake from a different perspective."

"Well, there are a lot more Atlas students around than just Team Rosepetal now," Twilight said. "So you could get to know a lot more, different Atlas students if you wanted to?" She smiled. "Of course, you'd have to be actively considering Rainbow's offer for there to be any point to that."

Blake didn't reply. Was she considering it? Ought she to be considering it? It seemed absurd that she was even contemplating a move like this. This was Atlas they were talking about: Atlas the cruel, Atlas the relentless, Atlas the city from which the blood of faunus dripped down upon the earth. Atlas of the SDC, Atlas of the military, Atlas that was all the evil in the world, the great enemy of faunus rights and of all faunus kind.

And yet, she was – almost in spite of herself – actually considering it. A part of her rebelled against the fact, but when Blake looked inside herself, she couldn't deny the fact that she really was thinking about it.

Not because of the toys or the technology but because… because Rainbow was right about one thing: Blake did need a cause. It wasn't enough for her to just fight to survive; she didn't fight for her own glory like Sunset, she couldn't devote herself to some – no offence – vague idea of service to humanity like Ruby or Pyrrha. She needed to be working towards something, something important, something that mattered, something that she could look at and say 'yes, I did that.'

I helped with that, Blake mentally corrected herself. It was arrogant to assume that she could or needed to do everything on her own.

But it was an arrogance that had a hold on her, like a leech with its teeth in her skin. She couldn't seem to shake it off.

Atlas was attractive for that reason, after she'd been shown that not all Atlesians were terrible people and that faunus could lead reasonable lives there. Some of them at least.

But still… it was Atlas. A place she still knew little about.

She didn't know. She just didn't know. She'd wanted to go to Beacon; she hadn't just chosen it because it was in the same kingdom as she was or even because Vale enjoyed a reputation for tolerance. She'd chosen it because it was the best, and she'd hoped that it would make her the best version of herself.

In spite of what had happened, did she really want to forsake that? To turn her back on it, and all for what? For northern dreams? For a promise of something that might never materialise? For the enthusiasm of a true believer?

And if she had to spend the next four years – or however long was left once the Atlesians were through with her – as an honorary member of Team SAPR, well… there were worse fates.

If Blake might be permitted, in the privacy of her own head, to use an animal metaphor: the collar didn't chafe as much as she'd been worried it might, but that didn't mean that she wanted to go back to the kennel.

Not definitely, at least; not yet.

"I'm sorry that we couldn't find anything out about Tukson," Twilight said softly.

Blake pursed her lips together. At the hospital, she had learned that Tukson had been recently discharged, but they had not been able to tell her – either because they didn't know or because they weren't authorised to tell Blake – where he had been discharged to; they had swung by the shop to find the place boarded up, with a sign stating that it was closed with no indication when – or if – it would ever reopen. And of course, his scroll had been disconnected.

It had occurred to Blake that he might have been spirited away into witness protection for his own safety; if that was the case, then she wished him all the best… but she wished that she'd gotten the chance to say goodbye.

She sighed. "At least they told me that he walked out of hospital on his own two feet," she said. "At least I know that he's okay."

Twilight nodded, if only slightly. "You know, I'm sure that if I talked to General, then he could find out-"

"No," Blake said. "That's kind of you to offer, but you don't have to do that."

"It's no trouble, really," Twilight said.

"It's probably for the best if I don't know," Blake replied. "Nobody's supposed to know, isn't that how it works? And besides, even if I did know… I couldn't go and see him, or I'd risk drawing attention to him."

"But don't you want to see him again?"

"That doesn't mean that he needs to see me again," Blake said. "I brought Tukson nothing but trouble; in the end, I even brought Adam to his door. It's best that… I hope he's happy, wherever he is."

The doors into the skydock lounge slid open, and Ruby and Penny both came bouncing through, accompanied by Ciel.

XxXxX​

Twilight had actually gotten Sunset two books, one of which was a little bigger than the other. The first, and larger of the two, was called Prophet Narratives: Choosing and Power in the Religions of Remnant; it had a very striking cover depicting a woman in blue robes getting smote on the breast by a bolt of lightning hurled from out of a cloud – hurled by who, it didn't say. It was not a new illustration – a look at the back revealed it to be a painting by someone Sunset had never heard of, but then she'd never heard of any of this until Twilight had brought it up to her. The book had no author, since it was a collection of traditional stories, but was noted as being collected by one Oswald Oakenshaft; Sunset had never heard of him either, but a quick look at the back of the book had provided her with a limited degree of enlightenment: not much was known about the man except that he had enjoyed a sinecure from the crown of Vale in the time of King Athelstan Whitebeard, two or three generations before the Great War, and he had used the income to spend his life apparently pulling together this book, considering he had no other accomplishments to his name.

The current edition – or the edition that she was holding in her hands, at least – had been published by a small press somewhere in Vale; Sunset doubted that many copies had been produced.

The same press had also published the other book that Sunset was holding in her hands: Red Queens, a book that had neither author nor collector identified but which Twilight had insisted had to be read in conjunction with the prophet book; they formed, according to her, two halves of a narrative of decline and fall, a statement which she claimed would make sense once Sunset had done the reading.

Sunset didn't blame her for being cryptic; she had asked for reading material, not a story; she wanted to be free to make her own judgements about what she was reading – and take notes – without Twilight's interpretation getting in the way.

After all, Twilight only hoped and believed that magic existed – or had until she had learned Sunset's secret; Sunset knew full well that magic existed and understood a fair bit about how it worked, so it was likely she would pick up on things that Twilight had missed.

She hoped so, anyway; it might be that all magic in Remnant was as alien to her as Ruby's silver eyes – something Sunset hadn't quite had the nerve to mention to Twilight, if only because she wasn't sure that Ruby or Pyrrha would appreciate her giving out Ruby's secret to just anybody – but she doubted it. Twilight's description of her magical rescuer sounded very much like the sort of thing that an alicorn could have done; although, if all wielders of magic in Remnant were on par with alicorns, then Sunset might be in a bit of trouble if she ever met one.

And if they existed, then she did mean to meet one, if only to find out where they got their power from.

"Prophets, huh?" Rainbow asked from where she sat down next to Sunset in the lounge of the skydock. They were having to wait a little bit for a Skybus to arrive. "Twilight told you that she believes in…"

"Magic?" Sunset suggested.

"Mhm," Rainbow murmured. "Do you believe it?"

Does the eagle believe that it can fly? "Yes," Sunset said. "It surprised me when Twilight told me you don't."

"Why?"

"Because she's supposed to be your friend."

"Twilight is my friend," Rainbow replied loudly. "It doesn't mean that I have to think everything that she thinks, believe everything that she believes."

"You're also friends with Pinkie Pie," Sunset pointed out.

"Yeah, and you show me one thing in one of those books that sounds anything like what Pinkie can do, and I'll agree with you it's magic," Rainbow challenged her. "Twilight says that you can look back in these old stories and see that there are lots of things that keep coming around over and over again. And she's right; they are all full of the same stuff."

"You've read them?" Sunset asked in astonishment.

Rainbow nodded. "The Red Queen book is pretty cool, full of heroes and villains and fights… although I did have to get Twilight to tell me what half the words meant. But the fact that a lot of the same stuff keeps coming up doesn't mean that it's true; it just means that the people who came up with this stuff didn't have a lot of ideas of their own."

"What makes you so sure?"

"Because if there really are people who have amazing powers like that, then where are they?" Rainbow demanded. "Twilight thinks that they're still out there, but where? I've never seen them."

"Twilight has," Sunset pointed out.

"Twilight thinks that she has," Rainbow replied. "Did she tell you she took a pretty bad bang on the head?"

"She told me that she was in a car crash," Sunset answered.

Rainbow leaned forward in her seat. "Listen, I am beyond glad that Twilight survived that, and I don't pretend to know what happened on the road that day, but I know that a flying woman with white hair didn't come out of nowhere and kill all the grimm by shooting lightning out of her hands."

"Again, why so sure?"

"Because, again, why did she only do it once?" Rainbow demanded. "I love Twilight, but why did she get to be saved when nobody else does? Why come out for one person and not for others?"

"Twilight says there are others," Sunset replied.

"A few, but that doesn't change my point," Rainbow insisted. "If there are people out there with… with magic powers, then why don't they use them? It's game time, come on, get off the bench."

"Maybe they're afraid of being discovered?" Sunset suggested, thinking about Pyrrha's nervousness around Ruby's eyes and what would happen to Ruby if the secret of those eyes became widespread.

"So they'd rather let people die, come on!" Rainbow snapped. "What is this, a gloomy superhero movie?"

"This is nobody's story but ours," Sunset declared, clenching one hand into a fist. "But not everyone can be Ruby or Pyrrha or even you for that matter. Just because someone has power is no guarantee that they'll be minded to use it for the greater good. Or even to use it at all. Some people just don't have the guts for the fight. Some people aren't suited for it. Would you want Fluttershy out on the front lines just because she had magic?"

"Don't be ridiculous," Rainbow said instantly. "But if Fluttershy did have power like that, she wouldn't just hide in a hole so that nobody knew existed. She'd… I don't know exactly what she'd do because I don't know what her magic would do, but she'd do something, even if it was just like magically healing animals or something."

Sunset shrugged. "Like I said, not everyone has that kind of spirit."

"But no one has it?" Rainbow replied. "Nobody, out of all the people who have ever had these special powers, nobody has wanted to do anything with them? Everyone who's ever had them has been too afraid of being found out to ever show their powers? I don't buy it. I don't buy that people are like that. I just… I don't buy it."

Sunset could see Rainbow's point. She knew that the Atlesian girl was wrong – there was at least one form of magic in the world that had not come from Equestria – but at the same time, that very wrongness proved Rainbow Dash partly right, because Summer Rose had used her powers; she had not been more afraid of her gift being discovered than of the cost of not using them.

But at the same time, Summer had not been discovered; her silver eyes remained, for the most part, a secret.

"Maybe they have used their gift, but… subtly," Sunset suggested. "In ways that didn't attract attention."

"Or maybe it's all a great story but one that doesn't mean anything," Rainbow said. "Why do you want to believe in this so much?"

"Why do you want to steal Blake so much?"

Rainbow's eyes narrowed. "I'm not stealing Blake; who would I even be stealing her from?" Rainbow answered her own question a moment later. "It's you, isn't it?"

Sunset brushed her trousers idly with one hand. "I have no idea what you're talking about," she said quietly, looking somewhere else.

Rainbow snorted. "I really do think Blake would do great in Atlas. I really believe she'd be better off there than here."

"You think everyone would be better off at Atlas."

"I don't think you'd be better off at Atlas; you couldn't cut it."

"What do you mean I 'couldn't cut it'?"

"You don't have the discipline," Rainbow explained.

"You think that Blake has discipline?" Sunset asked, her eyes boggling.

"I think she could have, which is more than I could say about you," Rainbow replied. She folded her arms across her chest, even as she crossed one leg over the other knee. "Do you honestly think that being an ordinary huntress will be enough for someone like Blake?"

"You say that like there's some shame in being an ordinary huntress," Sunset muttered.

"No, I didn't," Rainbow said sharply. "What I mean is… huntsmen and huntresses from the other kingdoms defend the status quad-"

"Quo."

"Huh?"

"Status quo, not status quad."

"Whatever," Rainbow said. "The point is that they defend it. They defend the kingdoms, they defend villages, they defend whoever pays them, and that's fine, but there's no way that that will be enough for Blake. Blake wants to change the world, and she'll be able to do that as an Atlesian officer."

"How much world-changing does the average Atlesian officer get up to?" Sunset asked.

"Well… not much, on average," Rainbow admitted. "But Blake's not going to be an average officer; she already knows General Ironwood, and she's got time to get to know him even better, see what a good man he is, how trustworthy he is." She paused. "I'd put my life in his hands a hundred times over before I'd do the same for your Professor Ozpin."

Sunset snorted. "I actually agree with you on that, and I've never even met your general."

"You don't trust the headmaster?"

"Neither do you."

"Yeah, but he's your headmaster; if you don't have any faith in the guy, then what are you still doing here?"

"I have faith in myself and my team. I don't need to believe in Professor Ozpin or his reputation," Sunset insisted. "He knows more than he lets on. He plays games with us."

"You got that right," Rainbow muttered. "He knew about Blake all along; he knew everything. Just because it all worked out in the end doesn't mean that… I mean…"

"Yes," Sunset agreed. "I know exactly what you mean." She fell silent, albeit only very briefly. "I suppose that I'd like to believe it," she said, after a moment, "because I'd like to believe that there's some wonder left in what is kind of a grim world."

"I wouldn't like to believe that everyone who's ever lucked into power put themselves ahead of everyone else," Rainbow replied.

"And I wouldn't like to lose Blake," Sunset admitted. "Not even to another team, certainly not to Atlas, but we don't always get what we want, do we?"

"I don't know. I think I've gotten pretty lucky that way," Rainbow said, with exaggerated mock casualness.

Sunset huffed. "Of course you have."

The doors into the Skydock slid open, and Ruby and Penny bounced in excitedly, chattering to one another so quickly that their words became lost in a blur as they spoke over one another; Sunset wondered how they could possibly understand what the other was saying.

Ciel followed a couple of steps behind, moving at a more controlled and graceful pace.

"And that bit when Lady Jaye rescued the Councillors like wam-bam!"

"And then Roadblock took out Kobra Commander's airship with a single shot to the engine!"

"That was an impressive piece of marksmanship," Ciel agreed. She was the first to notice Sunset and the others. "Good afternoon, everyone."

"Hey, Ciel," Rainbow said, grinning. "Ruby, Penny."

"Greetings, everyone!" Penny said, waving enthusiastically. "Ruby and Ciel and I just got back from seeing the best movie ever!"

"Let's not be hyperbolic," Ciel murmured.

"Yeah, it was pretty great, but it still would have been better if we could have gotten to see Grimm 3," Ruby said.

"You like the Grimm series?" Rainbow demanded. "The second movie made the Atlesian soldiers out to be totally incompetent."

"They weren't incompetent; they were just caught by surprise," Ruby replied.

"When the grimm attacked in the reactor complex, half of them shot one another!"

"Calm down, for goodness' sake; it's just a movie," Sunset said.

"It's bad enough that everyone thinks that we're a bunch of robots, but everytime we're not, we're absolutely useless," Rainbow griped. "It's really annoying."

"I feel your pain," Sunset remarked dryly.

"What movie did you actually go and see?" Twilight said pointedly, glancing at Rainbow from over the top of her spectacles.

"Real Atlesian Hero: Retaliation," Penny announced.

"There, you see," Twilight said. "A nice action movie with no Atlesian incompetence in sight."

"Unless you count the fact that the entire Council had been replaced by Kobra agents and nobody noticed," Ciel pointed out.

Twilight sighed. "This is why I only take you to watch cartoons with me," she told Rainbow Dash.

"But it was rather enjoyable nonsense," Ciel added, "and Penny had a good time."

"I certainly did!" Penny cried. "It was so exciting, and it all seemed so real, and Ruby Roundhouse is so cool!"

"Yeah, she is pretty cool," Rainbow agreed. "It's a shame they couldn't get her to play Daring Do; she'd have been great at it."

"I thought Chestnut Magnifico did a pretty good job," Twilight said.

"She didn't have the physicality," Rainbow argued.

"Ruby Roundhouse has arms like mine," Twilight pointed out.

"Yeah, but she moves like she knows what she's doing," Rainbow said. "Chestnut doesn't quite have that."

"What are you talking about?" Penny asked.

"Daring Do, Penny; we'll have to show you those films some time," Rainbow said.

"But didn't you just say you didn't like the actress?" Penny asked.

Rainbow shook her head. "She wasn't bad; I just think that it could have been better. Still, classic films based on great books; they just… could have done with someone… someone with muscles like Pyrrha."

"Pyrrha would be a terrible actress," Sunset said.

"What makes you say that?" Penny asked. "She's really pretty, and she knows how to make fights look epic!"

"True and true, but I don't think she could act," Sunset explained.

"She has spent half her life in the public eye," Ciel pointed out. "Some might call that a performance far more demanding than short bursts on a film set."

"That may be so," Blake allowed, "but judging by the way that she feels about that performance, it's probably safe to say that she wouldn't enjoy acting."

"And hence, she wouldn't be good at it," Sunset declared.

"Oh, hello, everyone," Pyrrha said as she and Jaune walked into the lounge. Both of them had their arms full with brown paper bags, out of which various groceries were starting to protrude into view.

"Pyrrha!" Penny cried. "We were just talking about you!"

"Penny," Ciel said softly, as she crossed the lounge to sit down next to Rainbow Dash. "That is not something one says."

"Not even if it's true?" Penny asked.

"Especially not if it's true," Ciel informed her.

"That only holds if you're saying stuff behind somebody's back," Sunset countered. To Pyrrha, who was looking a little apprehensive, she added, "We were just pondering whether you'd be a good actress."

"We agree you have the looks for it," Blake murmured.

Pyrrha let out a little nervous laugh as her cheeks reddened. "Well, that… that's very kind of you, but I'm afraid that I've no desire to pretend to be someone I'm not."

"Haven't you done that already?" Blake asked. "Isn't tournament fighting just performing in front of a crowd?"

"More than I would like," Pyrrha conceded, "but there is an undeniable element of skill to it as well, and besides, I've given up tournament fighting."

Penny sighed dreamily. "I wonder what it's like to be a star, to know that hundreds of thousands of people are going to rush to see you."

"Are they seeing them or seeing the characters they play?" Pyrrha asked.

"It's the stars, isn't it?" Jaune said. "I mean, that's why they get paid the big lien, right?"

"You would think," Ciel observed, "but many industry insiders believe that the era of the traditional movie star is coming to an end as audiences narrow their attention to a few tentpole franchises based on well-known intellectual properties."

Everyone stared at her.

Ciel looked at them. "What?" she asked evenly.

Twilight cleared her throat. "Anyway," she said, "Pyrrha, Jaune, where have you guys come from?"

"Shopping, by the looks of it," Sunset said.

Jaune laughed. "Yeah, we did pick up a few things on our way back, but only after we'd gotten back from the ice rink."

Sunset's ears pricked up. "'The ice rink'?"

"As it turns out," Pyrrha said, "Jaune is very graceful."

Ruby grinned. "So you guys finally went on your first date?"

Pyrrha chuckled, "I suppose we did, yes. It was…" – she glanced at Jaune, a soft smile playing across her face – "wonderful. For me, anyway; I'm not sure how much fun I was to watch flailing about on the ice."

"I don't know, that sounds like it could have been fun," Sunset said.

"You weren't that bad, Pyrrha," Jaune assured her. "You did pretty well for your first time."

"That was because I was using my semblance to adjust the movements of my skates," Pyrrha confessed. "Not something I'm particularly proud of, but I didn't want to embarrass myself too much on, well, on our first date."

"But you did have a good time, right?" Jaune asked solicitously.

"Oh, of course," Pyrrha assured him, as she sat down next to Sunset. "You were quite the sight to see. Every day, you reveal more and more talents."

Jaune took a seat beside her. "Our town, the place where I grew up, sits between a forest and a lake; it's beautiful, the water is practically silver. In the summer, you can fish in it, but in the winter, it freezes over most years, and that's when we go skating on it."

"I see," Pyrrha said fondly. "You've certainly learned well there; I don't think I'll ever be as good as you."

"I'm glad you two had a good time," Sunset said, "but I don't get why you went shopping afterwards."

"Jaune's going to teach me how to cook," Pyrrha explained.

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "Okay, but why?"

The groceries in the brown bags in Pyrrha's arms rustled a little as she shrugged her shoulders. "I think that I should probably learn how to take care of myself if I don't want to rely on my mother and my family."

"You say that like you've been cut off," Sunset said.

"I know that I haven't been," Pyrrha acknowledged, "but as I was saying to Jaune, it feels a little disingenuous to simply carry on as though nothing has happened between us."

"Or you could just call her and put all of this behind you?" Sunset suggested.

Pyrrha sighed. "Please, let's not have this conversation again, Sunset," she begged. "Besides, what brought you into Vale?"

"Book shopping," Sunset replied. "Twilight brought Blake and I some presents."

"That sounds very kind of you, Twilight," Pyrrha said.

"Just a few things I thought might interest them," Twilight responded sheepishly.

Pyrrha leaned over slightly to get a better look at the books resting on Sunset's lap. "What are they about, if you don't mind me asking?"

"Magic."

Ruby gasped. "You mean like my silver eyes?"

Rainbow's ears twitched. "What's this about Ruby's eyes?"

Sunset twisted around in her seat. "I don't suppose that I could say 'nothing' and you'd believe me?"

"No," Rainbow said. "I really wouldn't."

Twilight frowned. "'Silver eyes'? What are you talking about?"

"You don't know?" Sunset asked. The one kind of magic that we know for sure existed, and you've never heard of it?

"No," Twilight replied. "That's why I asked what Ruby was talking about?" She glanced at her. "Do you… do you have magic too?"

"'Too'?" Rainbow repeated. "Twi, what is this 'too'? Did you find some proof of-?"

"You know what, this is not really a conversation to have in a skydock lounge while we wait for a ride home," Sunset said quickly.

"Is it a conversation to have at all?" Pyrrha murmured. "Ruby, you don't have to say anything."

"I don't mind," Ruby said quietly. "I trust Team Rosepetal, and Blake; I mean, we're all friends here, right?"

Pyrrha nodded gently. "If this is what you want," she said.

"How about this?" Jaune said. "We go back to Beacon, I'll make dinner – I'll show Pyrrha how to make dinner – and then we can all meet up in our dorm room tonight and talk about all of this stuff. All nine of us. And we can celebrate a successful mission at the same time."

"Do you want to celebrate a successful mission?" Pyrrha asked, a touch of anxiety creeping into her voice.

Jaune hesitated, but only briefly. "Yeah," he said. "Yeah, I do. Even if it didn't go perfectly, we still got the bad guy, and we all made it back in one piece, and it feels like something worth celebrating."

"If we're going to celebrate, then Sun should be there too," Blake pointed out.

"True, but…" Sunset trailed off, unsure of how to wonder aloud if she trusted Sun with Ruby's secrets, still less with her own. "Can he keep his mouth shut?"

Blake's face assumed a pensive expression. "I… think so," she said. "He wouldn't deliberately betray anyone's secrets, and… I'm not sure who it could accidentally slip out to at the moment."

Sunset looked at Ruby. "It's your call."

"I trust Sun," Ruby said quietly.

Sunset leaned back in her seat. "Then it looks like we're having a room party."
 
Chapter 33 - Green Eyes
Green Eyes​



Sunset's scroll rang. She pulled it out of her jacket pocket and opened it up. The caller ID read 'Lady Nikos.'

Even though she hadn't answered the call yet, the knowledge of who was calling was enough to make Sunset get off Blake's bed and rise to her feet on reflex.

Blake was the only other person in the dorm room with her; everyone else – on Team SAPR at least – was being either a hindrance or a help in the making of dinner, but Sunset had never cooked for herself in her entire life, and unlike Pyrrha, she had no intention of starting now. Blake seemed to feel the same way, because as Sunset's scroll buzzed and vibrated in her hand, the princess of Menagerie was able to take a step towards her and crane her head to see who it was.

One black eyebrow rose. "'Lady Nikos'?" she asked.

"It's Pyrrha's mother," Sunset said, as though it ought to have been obvious. It ought to have been obvious.

Blake's other eyebrow rose to join the first.

"What?" Sunset demanded.

"You have Pyrrha's mother down in your caller ID as 'Lady Nikos,'" Blake observed.

"She's the rightful Empress of Mistral; she deserves a little respect," Sunset explained tersely.

If Blake's eyebrows climbed much higher, they were going to disappear completely under her bangs; they were halfway to hidden already. "'The rightful Empress'?" she repeated, disbelief suffusing her tone.

Sunset rolled her eyes. "If you want to debate my monarchism, then that's fine, I'll go some rhetorical rounds with you about it, but can you let me take this call first before my lady starts to think me insolent?"

"Well, we wouldn't want that, would we?" Blake muttered, not bothering to hide her sarcasm as she turned upon her high-heels and stalked casually out of the dorm room, shutting the door gently behind her.

Sunset tapped the green icon to accept the call. Instantly, the stern, stony face of Lady Nikos appeared on the screen.

Sunset cleared her throat. "I would wish my lady a good evening, save that I fear in Mistral it is already night; I would not expect you to call so late."

"And I do not wish to inconvenience you by calling too early, Miss Shimmer," Lady Nikos replied.

Sunset inclined her head. "My lady's courtesy is appreciated but unnecessary; to speak with you is never burdensome."

The corners of Lady Nikos' lips twitched upwards ever so slightly. "There is a fine line, Miss Shimmer, between courtesy and toadying. The latter does not become you."

"I hope humility becomes me at least a little, my lady, but I take your point and beg your pardon," Sunset declared. "However, I speak true when I say that you could have called at a more convenient hour; I have not been preoccupied with anything important."

"You did not have classes today?"

Sunset hesitated for a moment. "We did not, my lady," she admitted. "We have-"

"Your mission was not completely free of mishap, then, necessitating some time to recuperate," Lady Nikos observed.

Now it was Sunset's turn to raise her eyebrows curiously. "You… the word of our mission has spread as far as Mistral?"

"Roman Torchwick, the terror of Vale, has been apprehended by Pyrrha Nikos," Lady Nikos said. "Did you think that this news would not reach as far as Mistral?"

Of course she gets all the credit. "Pyrrha has done deeds worthy of a hero," Sunset agreed diplomatically, "but the rest of us were… able to be of some assistance."

Lady Nikos chuckled. "Your efforts to be humble are unnecessary, Miss Shimmer; you may be honest with me."

"Then honestly, my lady, I say that Pyrrha has done great things," Sunset said. "She destroyed an Atlesian war machine single-handed."

"You mean with her semblance?" Lady Nikos asked.

"Yes, my lady."

Lady Nikos' brow, already wrinkled with age, acquired a few more wrinkles out of concern. "Has she begun to use it so recklessly, so frivolously?"

"I am not sure that it can be called either frivolous or reckless to use a semblance such as Pyrrha has been blessed with when confronted with a titan made of metal, my lady," Sunset suggested.

Lady Nikos snorted. "Against some Atlesian toy, I would have hoped that Pyrrha's native skill would have sufficed, or is the valour of Mistral fallen so far?"

"Say rather that Atlesian science has advanced so far, my lady, for these particular toys were far from child's play to deal with," Sunset insisted. "It took myself, Ruby, and some of our Atlesian allies to deal with one, while Pyrrha destroyed another, as I have told you, by herself."

"At what cost?" Lady Nikos asked.

Sunset blinked. "I hope my lady does not think me too dull-witted when I say I do not take your meaning."

"How many people now know of her semblance?" Lady Nikos asked, in a tone that did not quite become a demand but hovered upon the border of it like an army poised to invade.

Ah, now I understand. "Pyrrha's own teammates and the students of an Atlesian team, Team Rosepetal."

"You have mentioned Atlesians twice now," Lady Nikos observed. "I understand it is quite unusual for any training mission to require two teams of students."

Sunset mulled over her options. She could either say that to attempt the capture of Roman Torchwick was no small thing and that the school authorities had thought it wise to be cautious, or she could tell something a little closer to the official lie. She chuckled in what she hoped was a self-deprecating manner. "In point of fact, my lady, our mission was never to apprehend, or even to attempt the apprehension, of Roman Torchwick and his confederates; our mission was to protect a working crew making repairs to the rail line. When that was done, we found ourselves in the town of Cold Harbour, where we also found our Atlesian friends of Team Rosepetal and decided to travel back to Beacon together. We were both fortunate and unfortunate to be waylaid upon the journey."

"Indeed," Lady Nikos said. "There are things you are not telling me, Miss Shimmer."

"What makes my lady say so?"

"Because I am not an idiot, Miss Shimmer," Lady Nikos said, her voice acquiring an edge of sharpness. "However, I trust your judgement in this matter, that you would not place Pyrrha in unnecessary danger."

Sunset bowed her head once more. "I am grateful for my lady's faith."

"I am not so sure I trust either your or Pyrrha's judgement in the matter of her semblance; does she use it openly now?"

"No, my lady, at least not in the sparring ring."

"But in the field?" Lady Nikos pressed.

"Upon occasion, yes," Sunset conceded.

"Pyrrha's semblance is her hidden weapon," Lady Nikos declared. "A concealed dagger that her enemies know not of. It should not be thrown around in grand displays where Atlesians can see it."

"Team Rosepetal are to be trusted, if any are," Sunset said.

"Trust is not the issue," Lady Nikos said. "Today's allies may become tomorrow's enemies when the Vytal Festival begins. It is said that General Ironwood's students have good mettle in them, for all that their headmaster is rather too in love with metal. Pyrrha may have need of her semblance to overcome them."

"With…" Sunset trailed off, thinking better of saying 'with all due respect.' "My lady, I fear that Pyrrha aims at other things besides a crowning glory."

"Did it take a great deal of effort for you not to say 'higher things,' Miss Shimmer?"

"No, my lady. I confess a Vytal crown glimmers yet in my imagination."

"But not in Pyrrha's?"

"I am not sure that she would not welcome it, but she does not esteem it the greatest prize to be won at Beacon."

"No, that would be the detestable Mister Arc, I suppose."

"I think it would be to do some act of great benefit to Remnant, such as she – as we – have done in our capture of Torchwick," Sunset replied. "My lady, if I might advise you, if you were to reconcile yourself to Jaune, it would ease the path of reconciliation with Pyrrha."

"They are still together, then?"

"If I may venture to say, my lady, they make a handsome pair." Sunset paused. "If I may venture yet further to the cliff's edge, Pyrrha will never reconcile with you if you are obstinate in this."

Lady Nikos was silent for a moment. "Would she speak to me if I were to accept him, such as he is, and unworthy as he is?"

"In matters of the heart, my lady, I do not know that it is wise to talk of worth."

"Would she speak to me, Miss Shimmer?"

Sunset hesitated. "I fear she requires a little longer yet, my lady. I have urged her, more than once, but she… she, too, is obstinate."

"Then I will continue to rely on you, Miss Shimmer," Lady Nikos said. "Please encourage her to limit the use of her semblance, especially in the presence of outsiders."

"I will… mention it, my lady."

"Much obliged to you, Miss Shimmer," Lady Nikos said. She took pause a while. "And how are you?"

"I am well and content, my lady."

"You may speak honestly," Lady Nikos urged. "Especially since you have already admitted to me that your mission required some rest afterwards."

Sunset sighed involuntarily. "Jaune… took a man's life," she said.

Lady Nikos was as still as any of the images of her ancestors that filled the garden of her great estate. "I cannot say I like the young man, but nevertheless, I would not wish that upon him," she confessed. "It is a hard thing to do, and a hard thing, too, to comfort afterwards him who has done it."

How many times did your husband return from the field in need of such comfort? Sunset wondered but did not ask, for it was not her place to do so. "I endeavoured to point him in the direction of one who could offer him more than comfort, and now…" She wasn't sure if she ought to tell Lady Nikos that Jaune was getting therapy from Professor Goodwitch; some people had old-fashioned ideas about weakness, and Lady Nikos was nothing if not old fashioned.

"I see," Lady Nikos said, her voice quiet. "I am glad that the task of comforting him does not fall on Pyrrha alone. And yourself?"

It was all that Sunset could do not to touch her wound. "I… took an injury, my lady."

Lady Nikos' green eyes narrowed. "I hope that my faith in you is not already being proven to be misplaced."

Perhaps she ought to have taken that badly, but it made Sunset smile, at least a little. Even if it did have something of a grimace in it. "I… allowed myself to be struck, my lady."

"For what purpose did you engage in such lunacy?"

"He – Adam Taurus, of the White Fang – has a sword through which he can absorb attacks without coming to harm," Sunset explained. "I needed to bury his sword in something so that I could hit him without him being able to negate my assault."

"And you thought your own flesh was the most suitable sheath for his blade?" Lady Nikos asked, a note of incredulity making her voice tremble. "Are you still in your wits?"

"Perhaps not, where Adam Taurus is concerned," Sunset admitted. "But it would have been worth it, had I managed to kill him."

"Why? Who is he to you?"

"He almost killed Ruby at the docks," Sunset declared. "Now he has almost killed me. I do not mean that he should almost kill Pyrrha."

"Ah, so it is revenge, I see," Lady Nikos observed. "That is a duty strongly to be felt, indeed, and worthy of your courteous manner and courtly upbringing."

"A rather unique reaction, if I may say, my lady."

Lady Nikos snorted. "I do not say that it will bring you happiness or contentment; I have never had cause to seek bloody vengeance myself, but many are the tales we tell of it in Mistral, and whatever comfort it brings to the avenger seems cold at best. But nevertheless, it… I will not say it must be sought, but I will say that it speaks well of you that you seek after it. But if I may offer you a word of caution, Miss Shimmer?"

"I will receive it gladly, my lady."

"As I say, we tell many stories of revenge in Mistral," Lady Nikos said. "As oft as not, they lead the avenger to their grave. I would not have you be amongst their number."

Sunset blinked rapidly. "Your concern…" She trailed off, and when she spoke again a little of her affect had fallen away. "I am touched, my lady," she said quietly. "I swear that I do not intend to die in this endeavour."

"I believe that you do not," Lady Nikos agreed, "and so I trust that you will choose your path with wisdom, tempering the wrath of Pyrrha's namesake with the prudence of Penelope. I put my faith in you, Miss Shimmer."

"And I will be worthy of it, my lady."

"And now I leave you to your evening," Lady Nikos said. "Goodnight, Miss Shimmer."

"Goodnight and farewell, my lady," Sunset replied as Lady Nikos hung up the call.

Sunset sighed once more as she folded up her scroll and put it back in her pocket, and as she did so, she looked up and saw Pyrrha standing in the doorway, looking at her with green eyes wider than usual.

Sunset felt a coldness in her stomach and a dryness in her throat. "How… how much did you hear of that?"

Pyrrha walked inside and closed the door behind her. "Enough," she said softly. "My mother trusts you a great deal."

Sunset didn't reply. Silence had fallen between the two of them like a rockslide closing up the mouth of a cave. She turned away from Pyrrha and wandered down the room towards the far wall, the wall where they had carved their initials on their first night at Beacon. Sunset held out her hand, and her stuffed unicorn flew into it. She grabbed it by the waist and squeezed it a little bit, glancing down at the glassy eyes and the eternally happy expression.

It was probably inevitable that they should reach this point; Sunset's decision to take Lady Nikos' money, to take her sword, to take her part and urge Pyrrha to reconcile with her mother… yes, she should have seen this coming.

Am I the Cadance here?

I hope not.

No, I'm not, because Celestia and I were happy before that interloper came into my life and ruined everything.

Yeah, keep telling yourself that.

Or rather, don't, because this isn't about me. This is about Pyrrha.


Sunset turned around, her grip on the stuffed unicorn loosening just a little. "So," she said, with a slight sigh in her voice. "Are we going to do this now?"

Pyrrha hesitated. "Do… do we have to?"

"If the alternative is you brooding on how much you dislike me, then I'd rather we have a row and get it over with," Sunset muttered.

"I don't want to fight, Sunset," Pyrrha said gently, "and I don't dislike you, far from it." She looked away, her eyes turning down towards her scarlet sash, the sash with which both of her gloved hands began to fiddle idly. "It… it might be easier if I did dislike you. My mother… she has approved of people before whom I did not like."

"The man she wants you to marry?" Sunset guessed.

"Yes, Turnus is one such," Pyrrha said. She frowned, marring her flawless skin with a momentary wrinkle. "Wants?"

"Hmm?"

"You used the present tense."

"And you were listening," Sunset pointed out. "You don't need me to tell you what she said."

"I didn't hear everything," Pyrrha replied.

"Right," Sunset said softly. "Sorry. She is… still not entirely reconciled to Jaune, I fear."

"I see," Pyrrha whispered. Once more, she fell silent for a little while, her fingers continuing to play with the red sash. "As I said… as I was saying… it might be easier if I disliked you, but… but I don't. Do you have any idea how hard it is knowing that your mother prefers your best friend to you?"

Sunset's eyebrows rose in spite of themselves. Her tail straightened out a little behind her. "I'm your best friend?"

"Of course," Pyrrha murmured. "Who else would it be?"

"Jaune?" Sunset suggested.

"I love Jaune," Pyrrha replied. "But… anyway, the point is that I'm very fond of you, and that… it means I can't just dismiss my mother's affection for you as evidence of her poor judgement, or at least of a judgement that is incompatible with my own." She began to walk towards the window, until she was standing side on to Sunset, presenting her profile to her team leader as she leaned upon the windowsill. "A judgement that shines on you as… as it has never shone on me."

"That's not my fault," Sunset said quietly.

"No," Pyrrha agreed. "But it is your nature. Though your name is Sunset, I sometimes think you are more like the rising sun, to which all the flowers turn and open up their petals." A little melancholy laugh escaped her lips. "Perhaps I ought to thank you for leaving me Jaune."

"You give yourself far too little credit," Sunset declared. "Someone like Jaune could never love someone like me." After all, I loved someone just like him once, and I lost him.

"You're too kind."

"I'm honest, when I have cause to be."

"My mother would call herself honest too, but her honesty is not so kind," Pyrrha replied. "She… she has never told me that she trusted me, the way that she put her trust in you." Pyrrha sat down upon the window seat. "She has not armed me with one of the heirlooms of our house."

"Soteria?" Sunset asked.

Pyrrha nodded, although she still didn't look at Sunset.

Sunset passed the stuffed unicorn from one hand to another. "Is it…? I didn't think it was that big a deal."

"You know that it was carried for my great-great grandfather at the Battle of the Four Sovereigns?"

"By a retainer," Sunset countered. "It's not like it's your great-great grandfather's sword that I'm carrying around slung across my back. Your mother gave me a bodyguard's blade; there was a message there that I didn't need to be a genius to see. At least, that is what I read into it. I think that is all that there should be read into it."

"Yes," Pyrrha said, "it is a bodyguard's blade. But it is a blade that was carried for the last Emperor in the last battle of the last war that Mistral waged as a great empire. With that sword, Achates cut down the Captain of the King's Guard and his standard bearer before he aimed his stroke at the Last King himself. That sword may not have been wielded by any of my ancestors, but it has a history as storied and as noble as any in the possession of the House of Nikos. And my mother armed you with it."

"To protect you, in the last resort," Sunset insisted. "Not that you need it, but…"

"Even so," Pyrrha murmured. "She armed you with it."

"Do you want the sword?" Sunset asked. "Because…" She trailed off, because of course it wasn't as simple as just giving Pyrrha the sword if she wanted it. The black blade had been given to Sunset by the Lady Nikos, the head of the family, bestowed upon her, Sunset, to wield, to give good account, to honour as best she could with further deeds to add to its story that was already so heroic. If she simply gave it away, like a common trinket, she would be saying that she esteemed this great gift little and valued the friendship of Lady Nikos as being of little account. She was not willing to do that, not even for Pyrrha's sake.

And to be fair, I don't think Pyrrha would ask me to be so discourteous.

"It's the principle, isn't it?" Sunset said.

Pyrrha nodded. "You understand what honour is done to you with such a weapon?"

"I do now," Sunset replied. "Your mother… when she gave me the blade, she told me that it had been wielded in the Battle of the Four Sovereigns… and that Achates had fought against the Last King… I suppose she told me enough that I can hardly say I didn't understand the import. She did not tell me who Achates had slain first, but… perhaps that hardly seemed relevant."

"Indeed," Pyrrha said. "Miló and Akoúo̱ are excellent weapons, and I would not trade them for any blade out of our family vault, but… I know that this isn't your fault, and I ask you to forgive me, but… I hope you can understand that it isn't always easy to look at you and see the daughter that my mother would rather have had."

Sunset winced. Her ears drooped down towards her hair, and her tail drooped too, hanging listless down behind her. She threw away the stuffed unicorn, guiding it with telekinesis down onto the camp bed. "That," she began, her voice a little hoarse, "that is-"

"Don't say it isn't true after you've just told me that you're honest."

"I said I'm sometimes honest," Sunset reminded her. "But honestly, I think that you exaggerate."

"Do I?" Pyrrha asked. "She gives you a sword out of our family's treasury-"

"A retainer's sword, for all its honour."

"She gives you a stipend."

"For dust and armour and other necessities; it's not as though she's written me a blank cheque," Sunset replied. "I'm a better fighter because of the things I can buy thanks to your mother."

"Don't you think that Ruby and Jaune might also be better fighters if my mother were to offer them her financial support?" Pyrrha asked.

Sunset felt that was a question which, far from behind rhetorical, deserved to be taken seriously. She folded her arms across her chest. "Ruby… Ruby doesn't really need dust, although she could use dust rounds, I suppose. Jaune… he could afford some better armour instead of that amateur dramatics stuff he's got on at the moment, I suppose. Could he use dust in his sword?"

Pyrrha nodded. "He could infuse the blade, as you've done with Soteria," she said.

"You could buy dust for him if he can't afford it himself," Sunset pointed out. "Is he too poor to buy dust?"

"I… don't know," Pyrrha admitted. "I haven't… I don't want to pry into his finances, in case… I'm worried that, with me being… would he take offence if I asked him how much-?"

"No," Sunset said. "I doubt that there's much that you could do that would offend Jaune, and I'm pretty sure that asking about money wouldn't be one of them. Not the way you're likely to ask, anyway." She ventured a grin.

To her relief, Pyrrha smiled back. "That's good to hear," she acknowledged. "But the point is that my mother-"

"Isn't invested in the prowess of the team, just in me," Sunset finished.

"Exactly," Pyrrha said. She looked out of the window once more, to where the sky without was beginning to grow dark. "And the worst part is… I can see why she prefers you. You're ambitious, confident-"

"Overconfident, at times."

"Proud."

"Prickly."

"There is no need for you to be so humble," Pyrrha said. "The truth is, you are everything she would have wished for in an heir."

"More fool her then, when she has you to be her heir," Sunset replied. "Not only as skilled as a hero of old but as gracious as a princess to boot and as learned as a master of lore. I… I have a fire in my belly that you lack, maybe-"

"I don't think there's any 'maybe' about it, do you?" Pyrrha asked.

"But that is only because I want the things that you were born heir to," Sunset insisted. "You don't need to hunt after those things because you have them already: the glory, the reputation, the fame. All the things that I am ambitious for, you already possess, so why should you be ambitious?"

"My mother would have me be ambitious for further fame and other glories," Pyrrha said, "but that is not what I desire."

"Then why get so hung up that she favours one who does desire those things?" Sunset demanded.

"Well, when you put it like that, it sounds rather silly," Pyrrha admitted. She got up and walked towards Sunset – and her own bed. "I'm sorry, Sunset."

"You don't need to apologise," Sunset assured her. "I get it."

Pyrrha tilted her head ever so slightly. "You do?"

Sunset nodded. "There was a girl, in my teacher's house," she explained. "She arrived not long before… the final break between us. She was pretty – beautiful, even – graceful and gracious, kind and considerate, beloved by everyone who had cause to come into contact with her." Sunset grinned. "You remind me of her, except that you're also a great warrior on top of all that."

A faint blush rose to Pyrrha's cheeks. "Stop it, Sunset; you're just trying to embarrass me."

"No, I'm trying to say that… she was everything that was expected of someone in our exalted position, everything that I was not," Sunset said. "I hated her."

"I don't hate you," Pyrrha said.

"No, because you're a better person than I am," Sunset replied. "I… I don't want you to start hating me. So if… if there's anything that I can do-"

"No," Pyrrha said quickly. "I mean… I'm aware that this might make it seem as though I'm complaining for the sake of it, but I don't want you to give up my mother's money, or Soteria. It wouldn't be right for me to ask that of you merely for the sake of my own… concerns."

"Then what do you want?" Sunset asked.

Pyrrha sat down on her bed. "I don't know," she admitted, with a nervous laugh. "I suppose… I think… I don't know. Perhaps I just wanted to let you know how I feel."

Sunset took a couple of steps towards her and sat down next to Pyrrha on the bed. "I can understand that," she murmured. She reached out and gently took hold of one of Pyrrha's hands. "I… I'm sorry."

"You don't have to-"

"Yes, I do," Sunset said. "My relationship with your mother… I should have thought about how it would make you feel." She paused. "I would offer to swear an oath to her as a retainer, but I fear my pride would not bear it."

Pyrrha snorted. "No, I doubt it would. And besides, what kind of friend would I be if I demanded that you humble yourself like that to make me feel better?"

"What kind of friend have I been to make you feel like this?"

"I'm fine," Pyrrha said.

"Clearly not."

"…no," Pyrrha conceded, after a moment. "But I… I can bear it. After all, I am the one who has turned my back upon my mother; what right do I have to complain that you have her trust and I do not? And I have Jaune, I have… I have so many things to be thankful for, it would churlish to obsess too much over this one thing." She hesitated. "I will try to remember that in future." Pyrrha glanced at Sunset. "Will you remind me of it, if I forget?"

"Remind you not to be upset at me? Yeah, I think I can do that," Sunset agreed. She smirked. "I'll also remind you to call your mother."

Pyrrha sighed. "Not now, Sunset."
 
Chapter 34 - To A Successful Mission
To A Successful Mission​



"Sunset," Ruby cried. "What are you eating?"

Sunset blinked in surprise and ostentatiously studied the two slices of bread in her hand. "It's a sandwich," she announced flatly.

"It's got nothing in it!" Ruby complained.

"Don't be ridiculous; it's got watercress and celery in it."

"'Watercress and celery'!" Ruby repeated, her tone aghast. "That's not a sandwich filling; that… that's nothing. You're eating an air sandwich!"

Sunset rolled her eyes and ignored Ruby's opinion on her diet as she bit into the sandwich; the celery had a satisfying crunch as her teeth drove through the slices.

"I'm not altogether sure of Ruby's motives for speaking out," Twilight said softly, "but she does have a point. Did you know that celery is one of the only foods which consumes more energy to eat than you get back from consuming it?"

Sunset looked at her. "So… you're saying that I'm losing weight by sitting here and eating this?"

"No," Twilight said. "If you were only eating celery, that might be true, but bread definitely does not follow the same rule."

"Pity," Sunset commented dryly.

Rainbow snorted. "Concerned about your figure?"

Sunset raised one eyebrow in her direction. "Who wouldn't want to look this good?"

"Get some muscle on your arms like me and Pyrrha, and then we can talk about looking good," Rainbow bragged.

"You think you look better than me?" Sunset asked. She chuckled to herself as she took another bite out of her sandwich. "Dream on."

"What, you think you've got something that I don't?"

"I think that I've had a steady relationship and you haven't," Sunset said. And I didn't get Flash on my winning personality.

Rainbow shook her head vigorously from side to side as she dug into her grilled cheese and meatball toastie. "I," she declared, oblivious to the little bit of grilled cheese and meatball sauce dangling down the corner of her lip, "could get anyone I wanted to."

"Oh yeah?" Sunset asked.

"Yeah," Rainbow replied, as Twilight dabbed at the corner of her lip with a napkin.

"Go on, then."

Rainbow hesitated for a moment. "I… don't want to," she said as Sunset jeered at her.

"You are both idiots," Blake muttered.

"Yeah, I mean, who eats celery without peanut butter?" Sun asked.

"I do," Sunset said. "Does anyone have a problem with that?"

"I don't have a problem," Sun replied. "I just think it's weird."

Sunset rolled her eyes and focussed on finishing off the remains of her sandwich.

In spite of the discussion, the tone in the dorm room was affable, friendly, and comfortable; in fact, it was only in that comfortable atmosphere that you could say the things that had been flying between Rainbow and Sunset without worrying about the kind of offence that would leave scars. She wouldn't have brought up Flash in front of people she didn't trust, for fear that they would use it against her; it would have been very easy for Rainbow to have pointed out that her long-term relationship ended in failure and social humiliation. But she didn't, because there was a difference between banter and being a jackass, and they all knew each other well enough to stay on the right side of said line.

Mostly. Nobody really knew Sun that well, or not as well as they knew one another, but he was Blake's boyfriend, and he had been on the train mission, and it would have been its own kind of jackassery to have excluded him just because he was a relative newcomer to the group.

Plus, the word was that his own team hadn't taken kindly to him sneaking off to be with Blake, so it might possibly have been extra harsh to have excluded him from tonight.

And, again, he had been on the train mission, and as much as a part of tonight was about sharing secrets, it was also about celebrating an operation which, for all its flaws, had been a great success when taken in the round. It would have been churlish not to have included in their victory feast someone who had been there when they gained the victory.

The room was crowded, but not oppressively so; there was enough room for everybody: Sunset and Blake knelt cross-legged on Blake's bed, that had been Sunset's bed until she so generously gave it up; Sun sat on the floor beside the bed, his head almost but not quite in Blake's lap; Pyrrha and Jaune sat side by side upon the window seat; while Ciel sat on Pyrrha's bed in a fashion like a lady riding side-saddle upon a horse; Rainbow, Twilight, Ruby, and Penny sat on the floor, in two pairs on either side of the door; Ruby and Penny were closer to the bathroom, Rainbow and Twilight to the far wall where their initials were carved.

This disposition meant that there was space on the floor for the food and mostly room to reach it when you wanted more; the plates were paper, which combined with the food on offer to lend a festival air to proceedings as people moved back and forth across the room to refill plates that became progressively greasier and greasier until they became unusable and had to be exchanged for something else.

The levels of cooking ability across the two teams – and Sun – varied considerably: Jaune could add 'good cook' to his ever-growing list of talents to balance out his inexperience as a huntsman; Ruby had an old family cookie recipe, which was no less an old family recipe for having apparently originated with her mother; Blake knew a few things about how to cook and serve fish which had the carnivores amongst the company in raptures; Twilight had apologised that her cakes were not as good as Pinkie's, but not as good as Pinkie's was a high bar to fall short of; Pyrrha was inexperienced but eager to learn; on the other hand, Sunset had never cooked before and had no intention of starting now, and she had seen what happened the last time Rainbow tried to bake and was grateful that she hadn't tried again.

It had to be said that a lot of the food didn't particularly appeal to Sunset's palate – the chicken pieces with that seasoning on some of it and that coating on the rest, the tuna in that pungent sauce, the meatball toasties, the sausage rolls – they all left her cold, and so, she left them well alone. But her friends were aware enough of her tastes that she was not devoid of things to eat besides the controversial watercress and celery sandwiches: there were cucumber sandwiches too, but there was homemade slaw, jacket potatoes, beans, macaroni, cookies, and cakes.

Yes, there was quite enough that Sunset didn't feel as though she was missing out by not eating of the flesh of another living creature.

"So," Blake began, "did anyone else in here know that Sunset was a monarchist?"

"You want to talk about this now?" Sunset demanded.

Blake shrugged. "We're all here."

Rainbow swallowed. "I didn't know that," she said, "but now that you've said it, it doesn't surprise me."

"Is that a good thing or a bad thing?" Penny asked.

"It… isn't really good or bad, I think," Ruby ventured. "It's just… a little weird."

"It is a little bad," Pyrrha sighed, her face beginning to redden, "if this is going where I think it may be going."

"Where is it going?" Twilight said. "What do you mean by 'a monarchist'?"

"She called Pyrrha's mother 'the rightful Empress of Mistral,'" Blake said.

"Which she is," Sunset insisted.

"No," Pyrrha murmured. "No, she isn't."

"The Emperor of Mistral laid down his crown at the end of the Great War, as did the King of Mantle and the Queen of Vacuo," Ciel pointed out.

"The crown as a thing of gold, adorned with jewels, may be removed," Sunset allowed. "It may be thrown away or melted down or laid at the feet of a greater conquering sovereign, but the crown, the weight of majesty of state, the royal rights and duties are not so lightly put aside." Snatch Princess Celestia's crown from off her head, tear the heavy necklace from around her throat, hurl her golden slippers into the fire, yet she will remain Princess Celestia. For a throne exists not only upon a dais in a palace, a crown is not just a gleaming diadem; throne and crown alike are forged and fashioned in the hearts of little ponies everywhere who accept – nay, who embrace – the princess as their sovereign.

And so it is in Remnant also. Though the race be changed, that remains the same.


"Are they not?" Ciel inquired. "It seems to me that the three kings did both, for none ruled in Mistral, Mantle, or Vacuo thereafter; they had not only laid aside their ornaments but their burdens too."

"Let's not pretend that they did it voluntarily," Sunset replied. "They were forced to do by the King of Vale-"

"The King gave up his crown, too," Pyrrha reminded Sunset. "Having established peace amongst all four nations and set up a system that would preserve that peace, he laid down his own crown and authority both and retired to the newly founded Beacon Academy."

"Really?" Jaune said. "The King of Vale lived here?"

Pyrrha's tone was fond as she said, "Jaune, he was the first Headmaster of the school. Doctor Oobleck covered that last semester."

"Right," Jaune said. "Thank you… for reminding me." He laughed nervously. "No wonder I didn't do so well on that test."

"Yes, the King retired from the affairs of state and contented himself with the affairs of running the academy," Sunset said, "while the four kingdoms were given over to lesser men."

"Do you have to phrase it like that?" Blake asked.

Sunset looked at her. "That Mistralian historian you and Pyrrha have read described the period after the Great War as the world moving from a theatre of giants to a pantomime of dwarfs."

"Yes, he did," Blake said, "but that doesn't mean I have to agree with him, and I don't have to like hearing you say it. It sounds… wrong."

"So the reason you wanted to talk about it is to convince me that I was wrong?" Sunset asked.

"You are wrong!" Blake insisted. "You can't just talk about 'lesser' people as though you're somehow different from the rest of them. You can't just declare yourself better than everyone else-"

"Too late for that," Rainbow muttered.

"I'm being serious!" Blake cried. "Pyrrha, I mean no offence, but your ancestor was a slaver. He kept my people as slaves. Why should someone like that, why should any one person, be allowed to rule over others, to make decisions that affect their lives and deaths? Why should so much power be bestowed upon someone who hasn't earned it?"

"Because they do earn it, or they should," Sunset said. "I admit that some of the kings and queens of the four kingdoms might have been a little less than perfect, but the ideal monarchy is so much grander and more glorious than even the ideal republic."

"That's because it is an ideal," Blake said. "It doesn't exist."

"Ideals can exist," Ciel declared. "Atlas is an ideal, a dream that we have conjured amongst the clouds and, with toil and hardship, made that dream a reality."

"You might be working towards it," Blake allowed, "but I'm not sure you're there quite yet."

"Okay, you want an example of a thing that exists?" Sunset demanded. "Pyrrha."

"Please don't bring me into this," Pyrrha groaned.

"Pyrrha is training to become a huntress," Sunset said. "Pyrrha is training so that she can defend her people; Pyrrha has defended her people against the karkadann when no other would."

"That's not very fair, Sunset; no one else could," Ruby corrected. "Because they were all away. Not that you weren't really brave, Pyrrha-"

"Believe me, Ruby, I quite understand what you're saying."

"Pyrrha behaved as the scion of a royal line ought," Sunset asserted. "Meanwhile, what did the Councillors of Mistral do?"

"They asked Pyrrha to handle it," Jaune said. "Do you think they should have gone out and fought it themselves?"

"Not necessarily, but come on, look at First Councillor Aris," Sunset said. "She's in power because she talks a good game and knows how to make lavish promises, but Ruby says that she starved the provinces of huntsmen for the longest time, and then when the White Fang started prowling around the city, she has done absolutely nothing to stop it. We in this room have done more to keep Vale safe than those who lead it."

"That's our job," Ruby said. "Or at least it's the job that we're training for."

"What is everybody talking about?" Penny asked. "I'm lost."

"That makes two of us," Sun admitted.

"Sunset doesn't think that ordinary people should be able to decide who gets to be in charge," Rainbow explained. "She's wrong."

"Am I?" Sunset asked.

"Yes," Rainbow insisted. "Robyn Hill has never been elected to the Council; instead, we have people like Cadance and the General, good people, smart people. I'd rather have that than some motorbike racer be in charge just because of who his parents were. I know the system seems like it's set up so that anyone can be successful, but real quality always finds a way to rise to the top."

"I must confess that I am less sanguine about the political wisdom of the body politic," Ciel said, "but in the interest of general harmony perhaps we ought to change the subject."

"Oh, thank goodness for that," Pyrrha groaned.

"I'm sorry, Pyrrha, I just…" Sunset trailed off. "I'm sorry. But I think what I think."

"And what you think is…" Blake began.

Sunset frowned at her. "Go on."

Blake shook her head. "No."

"Go on," Sunset insisted.

"Nobody wants to talk about this any more. I'm sorry for bringing it up," Blake replied. "I should have known that it would spoil the mood."

Silence descended in the dorm room.

Rainbow's look passed through discomfort, travelled across guilt very swiftly, and then entered mischievous territory. "You know, the real reason Sunset doesn't like voting comes down to the time she was voted 'Biggest Meanie' in the Combat School yearbook."

Ruby snorted. "'Biggest Meanie'? You had a category for 'Biggest Meanie'?"

"No, it wasn't a real category," Sunset hissed, "but that didn't stop everyone from voting for me anyway. Every year."

"What's a yearbook?" Penny asked.

"It's a book produced every year by Combat Schools," Twilight explained. "Everyone has their picture inside, individually and with their class, and there are details about some of the clubs and sports teams; the upperclassmen get to answer to a few questions about their plans for the future, and all your friends sign the book so you can remember them after you graduate-"

"That all sounds wonderful."

"And everyone votes for their fellow students to win superlative categories," Twilight carried on. "Like 'Best Smile' or 'Class Clown' or 'Greatest and Powerfulest.'"

"Or 'Biggest Meanie,'" Sunset muttered.

"That last one doesn't sound very nice," Penny said.

"It wasn't," Sunset growled.

"You kind of deserved it," Rainbow reminded her.

"Not every year, I didn't," Sunset snapped. "Not to mention, Flash and I ought to have been a shoo-in for Cutest Couple, but instead… you know, I can't even remember who won Cutest Couple, they were that forgettable."

"Oh, get over it," Rainbow told her. "Everyone knows those awards don't really mean anything."

"Easy for you to say," Sunset said. "You six got voted Best Friends every single year, and you were voted Most Likely to Succeed in your last year at Canterlot."

Rainbow's smile was unspeakably, unbearably smug.

Sunset glanced at Pyrrha. "I bet you were voted Most Likely to Succeed when you graduated Sanctum, weren't you? No, Most Likely to Succeed and Best All Around."

Pyrrha mumbled something so quiet that Sunset, even with two extra ears, couldn't make it out.

"What was that?" Sunset asked.

Pyrrha's face was flushed bright red. "And… Best Smile," she confessed.

Sunset snorted. "Well, I won't say that I can't see it."

"Twilight got that one," Rainbow said, putting one arm around Twilight's shoulders.

"I still feel like that's really unfair," Twilight murmured. "Rarity should have won that, or Pinkie."

"Nah, if you only focus on the smile, I can see that one too," Sunset said.

"Besides, Pinkie won Class Clown, and Rarity was voted Best Dressed and Best Hair, so it's not like either of them really missed out," Rainbow assured her.

"All of this sounds kinda rough on anyone who didn't get the votes, or who got the wrong votes," Sun said. "It's making me glad I didn't go to combat school."

"At any school other than Canterlot, you would have been a shoo-in for Class Clown," Rainbow informed him.

"Is there not a difference between funny and foolish?" Ciel asked.

"Sometimes, sure," Rainbow agreed. "But sometimes, stupid can be funny."

"I bet you won something," Sunset said. "Let me see… your close quarters aren't good enough for Best All Around… Beauty and Brains."

Ciel pursed her lips together. "As it happens, I was voted Most Unique. I'm still not certain it was intended as a compliment."

"So you didn't go to combat school either, Sun?" Jaune asked.

"Nah," Sun replied. "I just picked up a few things growing up in Vacuo."

"What do you mean, either?" Rainbow said. "You didn't go to combat school?"

Jaune froze for a moment, with the look of someone who had forgotten that not everybody in the room knew his secret. "Well, funny story…" he began.

They ate, they talked, they laughed, and when they had eaten their fill the bin in the corner of the room was full to overflowing, and there were quite a few dishes in the kitchenette sink waiting for somebody to apply some elbow grease – and that person would probably be Sunset, given her lack of contribution so far – once they were done talking.

Right now, however, they had some information to share.

"So," Sunset said, clapping her hands together. "We've come to the serious bit."

"For a while," Rainbow said, her tone subdued.

Sunset shrugged at that. It implied an end to the serious mood that she was not certain would come before evening's end. She licked her lips and glanced at Ruby where she sat on the floor next to Penny. "Where shall we begin?" she murmured, as much to herself as to anyone else. "Where shall we begin?"

"Magic is real, and Sunset's got it!" The words burst out of Twilight's mouth like water gushing through a hole in a dam.

Silence descended on the dorm room. Pyrrha, Jaune, and Ruby – to whom this was not new – waited expectantly for any reaction from the Rosepetals, Blake, and Sun, to whom this was new.

Twilight laughed nervously. "Sorry," she said. "I just couldn't hold it in any longer."

Rainbow Dash blinked rapidly. "It… it's real? Like real? All of that stuff-"

"Yes!" Twilight cried triumphantly. "All of it is real, I was right, and you owe me an apology for implying that I was crazy!"

"I never implied that you were crazy!"

"You told me that people see things after they hit their heads!"

"That's a concussion, not craziness!"

"It didn't feel that way," Twilight said, quietly and with a touch of sullenness.

"I didn't… sorry," Rainbow said. "I wasn't trying to make you feel bad, I just… didn't believe you."

"I know."

"But you were right?" Rainbow asked. She looked at Sunset. "Twilight was right. It's all true?"

"I don't know about all of it," Sunset said. "I'm not even sure what all of it is – that's why Twilight got me those books – but magic does exist, and I have some."

"I don't understand," Penny said. "What do you mean when you say 'magic'?"

"That's what I'd like to know too," Blake declared, her tone wary. Her ears were pricked up sharply above her head, long and straight like arrowheads. "What do you mean? What are you talking about?"

"In some ways, 'magic' is a lazy catch-all term, for things currently beyond our scientific understanding," Twilight declared.

"My magic is not beyond scientific understanding; it's simply beyond scientific knowledge," Sunset corrected her. In this world, anyway. In Equestrian terms, Twilight's definition of magic as a kind of dark matter was wholly inaccurate, although she could see how it worked in Remnant. "And it's going to stay that way," she added, sweeping her gaze across the room and all its occupants before she focussed on Blake. "Have you never thought that my semblance was strangely wide-ranging?"

Blake's brow furrowed. "Some semblances are more versatile than others. My clones can be combined with dust to produce a variety of different effects; it's just not obvious because I don't have access to dust. You might say that Weiss' glyphs are strangely wide-ranging, but that doesn't make it magic."

"No," Sunset allowed. "But I don't have a semblance."

She wouldn't have thought that it would be possible for Blake's ears to stick up any higher on top of her head than they already were, but somehow, they managed it anyway. "You… you don't have a semblance?"

"It's magic," Sunset said. "I've been passing it off as my semblance. Which, incidentally, is a possible answer to your question, Dash: they have been using their abilities; you just didn't notice."

"Why…?" Blake began, but no other words followed the first, at least not straight away. "I'm sorry, Sunset, but why should… ? How can…?"

"You don't believe me?" Sunset suggested.

"I don't want to call you a liar," Blake said delicately, "but… it's a lot to take in."

"Would it help if I turned that chicken piece into a frog?" Sunset asked.

Blake's eyes widened. "You can do that?"

"It seems to be her favourite method of demonstration," Jaune observed.

"Whatever happened to the last frog?" asked Pyrrha.

"I let it out," Ruby explained. "It didn't seem right to keep it cooped up in here."

"It would have turned back into an orange if you'd left it alone," Sunset said.

"Oh."

Penny stood up, leaning forwards eagerly. "I'd like to see you turn something into a frog."

"I am uncertain that would be sanitary in the presence of food," Ciel said, "and this is not a children's party." She paused. "For my own part, I believe that you can do it; there is no demonstration necessary."

"You believe her?" Twilight asked. "You believe that magic exists?"

"The world is full of extraordinary things, some of which can appear… inexplicable," Ciel murmured. She clasped her hands together on her knee. "My mother once told me a story of a… it was after the conclusion of a particularly harrowing mission. She was flying a Skyray through the teeth of a snowstorm at night, having lost contact with all other members of her flight; one engine was out of action, communications were down, she was carrying six wounded men in need of medical attention, but she had lost contact with her home cruiser. No situation ever seemed more hopeless. And then… then she saw a light. A single light, as though a star had pierced the clouds but closer, so close to her airship, moving as though it were trying to guide her. My mother did not know what this light was, but she was out of options but not out of hope, and so, she followed this light, this guiding star, trailing it as it twisted and turned, keeping it ever before her until… until it disappeared, to be replaced a few seconds by the myriad lights of the Ardent, welcoming her home.

"There was no air traffic detected beside my mother's airship, no communications were received, and yet, something had guided her to safety. Just because the light cannot be explained does not mean that there was no light. There are more things in heaven and earth that we can dream of… or have yet dreamt of at least. We must have faith that all things will be revealed to us at need and that there is purpose to those things which we do not understand. If you say that you have magic and that that which you have led us to believe is your semblance is, in fact, said magic, then I believe you."

"I suppose you have no reason to lie about it," Blake said. "Or should I say, that you have no reason to stop lying, after having lied about it for some time already. But I still have questions."

"You and me both." Rainbow leaned back against the wall of the dorm room. "So the reason why you appeared to have gotten so much stronger since coming to Beacon compared to the way you sucked in combat school, that's because you decided to cut loose with your magic?"

Sunset nodded. "I was hiding my light under a bushel before." She grinned. "I'm not doing that any more, as you'll find out if we ever meet in the sparring ring."

Rainbow waved that off without responding to it. "Okay, so why hide in the first place?"

"Because I didn't want to get poked and prodded by scientists to try and find out how magic works and how they can duplicate it."

"But what if we could duplicate it?" Rainbow asked. "Maybe Twilight could figure out a way to copy it, to give it to everyone-"

"It doesn't work that way."

"How do you know, you haven't tried?"

"Because I know," Sunset insisted. "I know how my own powers work. They aren't something that I… my magic is an extension of myself, like my aura, almost. You can't just replicate it, and even if you got close, then it wouldn't be my magic, because other people aren't me. The power would change to fit them, their personality, their aptitudes and natures. You can't clone me." Her eyes narrowed. "Unless you've got secret Atlesian cloning tech that you're not telling anyone about?"

"Don't be ridiculous; we're not working on anything like that," Twilight said. "And if we were, I certainly wouldn't admit it," she added under her breath. "Anywayyy," she went on, drawing out the word a little more than was strictly necessary, "while you're probably right, I wouldn't mind taking a look at you with a couple of instruments."

"Hmm, let's think about that," Sunset murmured.

"Can you at least answer the questions you didn't get the chance to answer on the train because of Adam attacking?"

"Uh, yeah, okay, why not?"

"Have you always had these powers?"

"Yes," Sunset said. "I was born with them."

"Can you do anything with them that you haven't shown yet?"

"Yes," Sunset replied again, "but nothing useful in combat."

"Turning things into other things could be pretty useful in combat," Rainbow pointed out. "In fact, if you can do that, why do you waste time shooting laser beams?"

"Because aura blocks my magic," Sunset explained. "I could turn an inanimate object into a frog, but I couldn't turn you into a frog so long as your aura was up. I'd need to break your aura first, and at that point, I'd have won the fight anyway."

"How about weapons?"

"Weapons are conduits for aura."

"I know that," Rainbow replied sharply. "But not when nobody is holding onto them."

Sunset's mouth opened just a little, but no words came out. That didn't just happen. It was not possible that Rainbow Dash knew more about the way that Sunset's magic could be used in battle than Sunset herself.

I suppose General Ironwood likes her for a reason.

"Is it linked to your aura in any way?" Twilight asked, leaning forward expectantly.

"No, I've had my magic since before I unlocked my aura," Sunset said. Since before I knew what aura was. "It's like aura in that it's unique to me, but it's not connected."

"Do you know why you have it?" Blake inquired, her voice soft. "I mean, out of all the people in the world, why were you born with this… unique gift?"

"How do we know it's unique?" Jaune asked.

Blake frowned. "Because Sunset-"

"Is the only person willing to tell us about it," Jaune said.

"Hmm," Blake murmured. "That's… a good point."

"She's not unique," Twilight insisted. "There are reports of unexplained phenomena like the one that Ciel's mother described happening all over Remnant, and I think that magic… for want of a better name, is the cause."

"Perhaps, but it still doesn't answer my question," Blake pointed out.

"No," Sunset said. "But that… is my secret to keep."

Blake held Sunset's gaze for a moment, before she nodded. "Of course. The limits of your honesty are for you to set, not us."

"That's very understanding of you."

"It would be a little hypocritical of me to be anything else, don't you think?" Blake replied.

"I don't understand," Penny said. "What does this mean?"

"It doesn't mean anything," Sunset said. "I'm still me. I just… my abilities come from a slightly different place."

"I wouldn't say that it doesn't mean anything," Rainbow said. "It means Twilight was right all along, for one thing."

"And if Sunset exists, then that means there could be more out there," Twilight added.

"If they don't want to be found, you shouldn't look for them," Blake said. "Sun, how are you taking this? You've been very quiet."

Sun shrugged. "It's like Sunset said: it doesn't mean anything."

"You weren't supposed to agree with me!" Sunset snapped.

"It's like Ciel said: it's a big world, and there's a lot of stuff happening in it," Sun added. "It's cool for you, I guess, but… you know?"

"No," Sunset said. "I don't know, but apparently, neither do you." She rolled her eyes. "Anyway, in response to Blake's question, there isn't any need to go looking very far for others with magic, because there's someone else with magic sitting right here in this room."

Ruby leapt to her feet, striking a pose with two fingers held in front of her right eye, while with her other hand she held her cape around her as though she was trying to hide in it.

Penny gasped. "Ruby! You have magic too!"

"Yep!" Ruby announced proudly.

"Can you turn something into a frog?"

"No," Ruby admitted, deflating a little. "I… the truth is I don't really know what I can do. Or how I can do it."

"Twilight," Sunset said. "All the research that you've been doing into magic, and you never came across the idea of Silver Eyes?"

Twilight shook her head.

"What about 'The Warrior in the Woods'?" Jaune asked. "What about the tale of the Dragon and the Two Sons?"

"The warrior in 'The Warrior in the Woods' never actually does anything that can be described as magic," Twilight replied. "Her silver eyes are remarked on as a feature of beauty, not as a weapon. And… I've never heard of that other one."

"I can lend you the book, if you like," Pyrrha suggested.

"Ruby's eyes are of course notable for the uniqueness of their colour," Ciel said, "but you suggest that there is more to it than that?"

Ruby nodded. "My mom kept a diary; in it, she talks about using her silver eyes to zap grimm, to turn them to stone or burn them or things like that. She called it magic."

"We didn't believe it either," Jaune admitted, "until Sunset told us that she had magic too, then it started to seem a lot more plausible. If one kind of magic exists, then why not more?"

"Does Yang know about this?" Blake asked.

"About my eyes, yes," Ruby said, "but not about Sunset."

"Can you use this power?" asked Twilight.

Ruby's face fell a little. "No," she confessed. "In her diary, my mom says that it's activated by feelings of love, but… she doesn't really explain what that means, and Sunset's magic is too different from mine for her to be able to help. And Sunset doesn't want me to talk to Professor Ozpin about it-"

"Don't say it like that, Ruby; it makes it sound like I don't have good reasons," protested Sunset.

"Well, you kind of… don't," Jaune said.

"I have excellent reasons, thank you very much," Sunset declared. "I don't trust him."

"We know, you've said, repeatedly," Rainbow muttered.

"Professor Ozpin knows about the power of your eyes?" Ciel asked. "To be clear?"

"Yeah," Ruby confirmed. "He helped my mom learn to master them."

"That explains why he let you into Beacon early," Rainbow muttered.

Ruby went on, "That's why I could ask him for help if someone trusted him a little more."

"Well, I don't trust him, and you shouldn't trust him either," Sunset insisted.

"I am inclined to agree," Ciel said.

Pyrrha looked at Ciel in astonishment. "Excuse me?"

"Ruby, how effective are the Silver Eyes you speak of? Does your mother's diary offer any indication?"

"Pretty strong, I think," Ruby replied. "She used them to take out whole bunches of grimm, even if it did leave her pretty weak afterwards."

Ciel's face was creased by a frown. "The Headmaster of Beacon, a man sworn to defend the Kingdom of Vale, has knowledge of a powerful weapon against the grimm and sits on knowledge and weapon both. He could approach Ruby and offer his services, in spite of Sunset's disapproval, if wished to do so. Why does he not?"

"Perhaps he has some concern for Ruby as more than just a weapon," Pyrrha suggested, a touch of acid corroding the tone of her voice.

"That is no reason to keep what he knows a secret," Ciel said. "We should inform General Ironwood."

"No," Rainbow said. "We're not going to do that."

Ciel's eyebrows rose. "Is there a good reason why not?"

"Because that's not why they asked us here," Rainbow declared, getting to her feet. "Ruby and Sunset are telling us these things because they trust us, and so, we're not going to turn around and run our mouths about their secrets, not even to the General. Some things just aren't ours to tell."

Ciel hesitated for a moment, before she gave a curt nod of the head. "Very well. I understand and will keep all your confidences."

"Besides," Ruby said, "in my case, there's not much to tell, since I can't get my eyes to work."

"Perhaps I could help with that?" Twilight suggested. "I understand that Sunset is wary of being examined, but it might be that I can find a scientific explanation for your magic that will enable me to unlock your access to it."

"Really?" Ruby asked. "Do you think so?"

"It can't hurt to try, right?"

"I don't know, Twi," Rainbow said. "Remember that time you tried to scientifically analyse Pinkie?"

"The bruises wore off eventually."

"'Bruises'?" Pyrrha asked anxiously.

"Twilight had the bruises, not Pinkie," Rainbow explained quickly.

Ruby nodded after a moment of what looked like thought. "I guess it couldn't hurt," she murmured. "Sure, if you think you can help, then why not?"

"Great!" Twilight cried.

"I'm a robot," Penny announced.

Everyone looked at her.

"You know, since we're all sharing secrets," Penny said.

There was a moment of silence before the room – most of the room – collapsed into laughter.

"Thank you, Penny," Pyrrha said. "That was… I think we all needed that."

"Penny," Ciel began. "Miss Belladonna and Mister Wukong-"

"It's done now, Ciel," Rainbow said. "I'll explain to General Ironwood what happened. Kind of. In a way that doesn't say anything about Ruby or Sunset."

"Will you get into trouble?" Penny asked anxiously.

"Maybe," Rainbow admitted. "But it was worth it this once."

"And now everyone knows, we don't have to worry about it being a secret any more," said Ruby.

"You thought it was a secret," Sunset murmured. "I'd worked that out weeks ago."

"You did not!" Ruby declared.

Rainbow bent down and picked up her cup off the floor, raising it towards the ceiling. "Here's to us," she said, "and to a successful mission."

"To a successful mission!"
 
Chapter 35 - Her First Debriefing
Her First Debriefing​



"Are you frowning at me?" Sunset asked.

Blake hadn't realised that she was frowning, and she stopped as soon as she realised. "Sorry," she said. "I just… I can understand why General Ironwood might want to see me, but not why he'd ask you to come up here." The two of them stood in the corridor outside of General Ironwood's office aboard the Valiant. Or rather, Blake stood; Sunset slouched against the wall like a sack of flour. Blake suspected that she was doing it on purpose in order to demonstrate that she wasn't a part of General Ironwood's military and wouldn't be bound by its discipline.

It was the same reason that Sunset had her hands thrust into her pockets.

If Blake had been more determined to remain a mere ancillary of the Atlesian forces, then she might have been tempted to join her, if she had given Rainbow Dash a firm 'no' when the idea of transferring to Atlas, then maybe… but she had not given a firm 'no' for the good reason that she hadn't made her mind up yet. And so, she assumed a somewhat military bearing, back straight and hands by her sides, even if she wasn't actually standing to attention.

Shall I stay or shall I go? Rainbow's offer… it was a tempting one, not so much for the material advantages as for what you might call the spiritual ones. To be a part of something bigger than herself, bigger than just a four-man team – or a five-man team, even – to be a part of something large and powerful… something like the White Fang, but better.

But she'd been here before. The White Fang had seemed like the 'something better' not so very long ago. She had sat at the feet of Sienna Khan and listened to her talk about the need for justice and the need to take extreme measures in order to obtain that justice, and she had believed her, as she found herself starting to believe Rainbow and the others when they talked about how great and glorious Atlas was. She had a habit of getting swept away by the appeal of a cause when sold by someone passionate and convinced of its righteousness, and Rainbow Dash was certainly that.

Rainbow… Rainbow reminded her a little of Adam at times; they were both brave, each ferocious in battle, both utterly committed to the cause to which they had dedicated their lives, both able to sell that cause to others. To Blake. Of course, Rainbow Dash wasn't cruel, or at least, Blake hadn't seen her be cruel, and she had watched carefully.

She wasn't sure how much that lack of cruelty was the doing of Twilight and Rainbow's other friends and how much was simply the fact that Rainbow had more humanity than Adam. Were people born cruel or kind, or were they fashioned into one or the other by the circumstances in which they lived their lives? A philosophical debate which had eluded the greatest minds in Remnant, there was no chance that she would be able to solve it now while she waited for General Ironwood to see her.

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "Are you saying it's surprising that General Ironwood should want to speak to me?"

"No, I… you know what I meant," Blake said, with a slight huff in her voice.

Sunset snorted. "Yes. I do. Do you enjoy this?"

"'Enjoy this'?"

"Being summoned into the presence of the commanding general himself?" Sunset explained. "Does your heart thrill to the great honour that is done to you?"

"You sound much more like a Mistralian than an Atlesian sometimes," Blake pointed out.

"Thanks," Sunset said, a slight smile playing across her face. "I prefer Mistral to Atlas."

"They both have equally poor reputations when it comes to faunus rights," Blake pointed out.

Sunset sucked in a breath, and her tone acquired an edge of mockery as she said, "Ooh, do you suggest that Atlas might be a little bit racist? Rainbow would be horrified to hear it."

Blake gave her a flat look. "Rainbow isn't blind… not completely blind to the state of Atlas; she just… believes that it can be improved."

"And you?" Sunset asked. "Do you believe that it can be improved?"

"I don't know," Blake admitted. "I've never actually been to Atlas."

"Perhaps you should rectify that before you move there permanently," Sunset suggested.

"I haven't made up my mind to do that yet," Blake informed her. But all the same, it wasn't a bad idea; it was a little ridiculous that she was even considering transferring to a school in a kingdom that she'd never actually visited. Dash told her one story of Atlas, Ilia had told another; only with her own eyes could she actually judge whose account was closer to the truth. Only by going there could she see if it was really the kind of place she would want to live.

Maybe during the vacation, before the Vytal Festival starts.

Not that it matters, since I won't be competing in the Vytal Festival.
Blake was pretty sure there was no option for a team to compete with five members.

The point was, visiting Atlas might not be a bad idea. In fact, it was a very good idea.

"You changed the subject," Blake pointed out.

"Did I? When?"

"When I pointed out that Mistral's reputation on faunus rights was pretty poor."

"I didn't see any sign of that when I was there," Sunset replied.

"Might that be because you spent all of your time with aristocrats?" Blake suggested. "Perhaps if you had descended the slopes into the lower city, then you might have had a different experience."

"Why would I want to do that when I could associate with aristocrats instead?" Sunset asked.

Blake chuckled, but she also couldn't help but roll her eyes. "I'm just saying that the Mistralian upper class-"

"Are not perfect, lest you think I believe otherwise," Sunset said. "Far from it, in fact."

"I'm glad to hear you recognise that," Blake murmured, "but they are also not the entire city, still less the kingdom. Mistral is a lot more than Pyrrha and her class."

"You've spent some time in the lower environs, I presume?"

Blake nodded. "For a while, with the White Fang."

"How was it?"

"Poor," Blake said. "Prey to criminals of every kind. The White Fang in Mistral spends more time protecting faunus neighbourhoods from gangs than it does trying to advance the cause of faunus rights." She paused. "How was the peak?"

"Pompous, arrogant, full of themselves," Sunset said.

"That doesn't surprise me," Blake murmured. "Sunset?"

"Hmm?"

"You've known Rainbow Dash for some time, haven't you?"

"That depends how you define 'known,'" Sunset replied.

"Has she…?" Blake blinked. "Has she ever been cruel? Have you ever seen her be cruel?"

"She was an ass to me, does that count?" Sunset asked.

Blake stared at her flatly.

"Oh, I see, we're having a serious conversation now," Sunset muttered, coughing into one hand. "I… no, I can't say that I did ever see that. I wasn't close to her, you understand, but she was so loud that it was hard to ignore her. So… no. I never saw her be cruel to anyone. She wasn't as kind as Twilight or Fluttershy, but she was never cruel."

Blake suppressed the sigh of relief she wanted to let out. "I see."

"Why do you ask?"

Blake didn't reply. In fact, she looked away from Sunset to make clear just to what extent she didn't want to reply.

"She's not Adam," Sunset declared. "Rainbow has her faults, but she's not him."

Blake glanced at her. "How did you know?"

"I'm very perceptive," Sunset said, a slight grin playing across her face.

Blake snorted. "Thank you."

"Don't go to Atlas," Sunset said.

Blake couldn't help but smile. "You really don't want me to go, do you?"

"No, I don't," Sunset said. "I want you to stay here."

"Why?"

"Because… because we'll have more fun together," Sunset said. "More than you'll have in Atlas. Rainbow Dash… you'll be better off here in Beacon."

Before Blake could reply that she was not entirely convinced of that, the door into General Ironwood's office opened, and the yeoman stepped out into the corridor. "General Ironwood will see you now."

Sunset allowed Blake to go in first, and she stepped into General Ironwood's austere office. She heard Sunset's footsteps echo on the deck behind her.

The General had his back turned to them, looking out of the window at his fleet and at the city that they protected. Blake couldn't help but wonder if he genuinely liked the view or if this was some kind of power play by not showing them his face.

Or, perhaps, he just didn't want them to see his expression.

It was probably not the latter, since he turned to face them both as soon as the door slid shut behind them.

"Miss Belladonna, Miss Shimmer," he said. "Thank you both for coming."

"It's our pleasure, sir," Sunset said, softly but without hostility.

"I asked you both here because I've finished reading Rainbow Dash's report upon your recent mission," General Ironwood announced, explaining the matter which had puzzled them outside – at least in part. He began to walk around his desk. "Miss Shimmer, I hope you'll forgive me if I keep this brief: thank you, for protecting Twilight from that bastard."

Blake's ears pricked up. She supposed that she hadn't known General Ironwood long enough to be surprised by him swearing, but at the same time… she was surprised. Whether she had any right to be was another matter. There was nobody in the room who could have suggested whether she did or not.

Blake didn't miss the way that Sunset's hand twitched towards the wound on her stomach. "Thank you, sir," Sunset said. "I wish you could be thanking me for taking him out of the picture."

Blake sucked in her breath but held her peace. It wasn't her place to speak right now, especially not about this.

"Believe me, after the damage that he's wreaked over the years, I wish that too," General Ironwood admitted, "but I'm well aware of what a tough nut he is to crack, and I can't fault you for not finishing the job. From Rainbow's report, it seems you did the best you could in the circumstances."

Sunset's eyebrows rose a little. "Sir, you might be the first person who hasn't called me a fool for doing what I did."

"Sometimes, we have no choice but to throw our bodies into the firing line," General Ironwood declared. "If only because we have nothing else to put in the way. I'm sure that those who remonstrate with you for your actions do so out of concern for your safety, but if they keep it up, perhaps you ought to remind them all that you're a huntress-in-training: putting yourself in harm's way is what you signed up for."

"But Twilight didn't," Sunset said. "Did she, General?"

General Ironwood stared down at the Beacon student for a moment. "No, Miss Shimmer, she did not. I take it you're aware of exactly what Penny is?"

"Yes, sir. I was the last of my team to find out," – Sunset couldn't quite keep the irritation out of her voice as she said that – "but I'm aware. It… explains a lot."

"And as an outsider," General Ironwood said, "how does it make you feel? Knowing that we have built… someone like Penny."

Sunset was silent for a moment, considering her response. "It's a magnificent feat of engineering you've pulled off," she said. "It borders on… magical."

General Ironwood raised one eyebrow curiously. "You've been talking to Twilight, I see."

"Yes, sir."

"Your appreciation of the efforts of the Polendina brothers is noted," General Ironwood said, "but what I meant was what you thought of the ethics of it. Does it alarm you that we can create Penny?"

"No, sir," Sunset said. "No offence to Penny, but for all that she's a technological marvel, I'd still say Rainbow Dash is more reliable. I don't think she's going to replace us any time soon. I know that she's new, but if we never did anything new because it might seem strange to people, then we would never advance, would we?"

"No, I suppose we wouldn't," General Ironwood conceded. "And you are correct; Twilight is not a huntress-in-training. She's a scientist, here to monitor Penny during this, her field testing."

"It can't have been an easy decision for you to send her out into the field," Sunset guessed. "She matters to you, doesn't she General?"

"The life of every single boy and girl in my academy, every single man and woman under my command, matters to me, Miss Shimmer," General Ironwood declared. "But you're right: Twilight is dear to me. Which is why I'm grateful to you, for keeping her safe. Thank you, Miss Shimmer."

Sunset understood that she was being dismissed. She bowed her head. "Thank you, sir. Your praise is the highest reward I could expect for my service."

General Ironwood folded his arms. "I'm sure that there are some in Mistral or Vale who would appreciate such flattery, but not in this office."

Sunset smiled. "Can't blame a girl for trying, sir." She bowed again, from the waist this time, although not deeply so, and stepped backwards out of the room. The door opened behind her and then closed in front of her face.

"If I may, sir," Blake murmured, "why did you send Twilight out into the field?"

General Ironwood was silent. "Someone had to go," he said. "Doctor Polendina didn't believe that Penny was ready to go out into the field at all, but the prospect of another year's delay on top of all the money, time, and resources sunk into her development… the Council was growing impatient and, I admit, so was I."

He turned away from Blake and began to walk back towards the window with its panoramic view of Vale. He did not reach the window, however, but stopped and looked down at his desk, at the photographs that Blake couldn't see. "I championed the Penny project. I selected it to go forward out of several funding submissions from some of the top minds in Atlas. Having a member of Doctor Polendina's lab team – someone young enough to pass as a student alongside Penny – accompany her in case any issues arose was the compromise that enabled us to get things moving. There were only really two candidates, Twilight volunteered, and she had a lot to recommend her over the other girl I could have sent. In the end, I didn't have much choice."

Blake's eyes narrowed just a little. "Sunset thought that you'd assigned Rainbow Dash to Penny's team in order to protect Penny, but it was actually to protect Twilight, wasn't it, sir?"

General Ironwood looked up at her. "It was to protect both of them," he said. "Twilight, yes, but also Penny if her performance was not everything that we expected of her. If Doctor Polendina was correct, if Penny turned out not to be ready, then I knew that Dash – with Soleil's help – would bring them home."

"You think a great deal of her, don't you, sir?" Blake said. "Not just a lot for a faunus, but a lot, period."

General Ironwood looked up at her. "I trust her completely."

"Why, sir?" Blake asked. "If I may?"

General Ironwood looked into Blake's eyes for a moment. "Why don't you ask Dash herself, Miss Belladonna, see if she'll tell you?"

In other words, she might be willing to tell me, but you're not, not yet. "That's fair enough, sir."

General Ironwood nodded. "So, how was your first mission with the Atlesian forces?"

"It… was not what I expected, sir," Blake admitted, "but at the same time, it confirmed some of my worries about working with Atlas."

"Oh? Such as?"

"On the flight to Cold Harbour, Rainbow thought it was necessary to warn me that the base commander-"

"Might not mind their manners," General Ironwood finished for her. "I'm afraid that's something every faunus student learns." He paused. "How was it?"

"There was no problem, sir," Blake said. "Captain Blackberry was extraordinarily helpful and sympathetic to the faunus in and around the town. But that isn't really the point. The point is that it could have been so much worse, that even Rainbow Dash, who is incredibly loyal to Atlas and its ideals, thought that it might be worse."

"I won't deny that there are a few fossils in the high command who haven't moved with the times," General Ironwood confessed. "I have hope that the new generation of rising stars will be more tolerant."

"If I may speak freely sir, you have more hope in the new generation to be free of prejudice than I do," Blake said, thinking of Cardin and those like him. She frowned. "General Ironwood, are you… aware of Rainbow's plans?"

"Do I know that she means to rise to take my place one day and use the power of this office to improve the condition of the faunus? Of course I do," General Ironwood said. "She asked me if I thought it was feasible."

Blake's eyebrows rose. "And did you?"

"Yes," General Ironwood said. "Are you aware, Miss Belladonna, that I hold two seats on the Atlas council?"

"No, sir, I wasn't."

"One in my position as Commanding General and another as Headmaster of Atlas Academy," General Ironwood explained. "The two seats don't have to be combined, and haven't always, but imagine what a faunus holding both or even one of those seats would be able to accomplish."

"Will it happen, sir?"

"It will take a lot of work on Dash's part," General Ironwood allowed, "but I don't know anyone more willing to work hard for something she believes in than Rainbow Dash."

Blake felt a twinge of envy for Rainbow Dash. "She's lucky to have someone who believes in her."

"Dash has plenty of people who believe in her," General Ironwood replied. "I'm fortunate to have someone I can believe in."

"Do you know that she's asked me to transfer to Atlas?"

General Ironwood looked into Blake's eyes. "No," he said. "I didn't. Although, having read Rainbow Dash's report, I can understand why."

"I didn't really do anything, sir."

"You assisted in the capture of Roman Torchwick; that's not nothing."

"Others did a lot more than I did, sir."

"Everyone plays their part in battle, and a part being less dramatic makes it no less notable," General Ironwood informed her. He clasped his arms behind his back. "Atlas Academy does not usually accept transfer students, but with your grades and combat experience alongside our forces, I'm sure that an exception could be made in your case."

"Aren't you the one that gets to decide if an exception is made, sir?"

"I am, so you should trust my confidence," General Ironwood informed her. "If, that is, you want to transfer."

Blake glanced down at the deck. There was a dent in the floor, and she couldn't work out how it had gotten there. "I don't know, sir."

General Ironwood sat down behind his desk. "I suppose Dash has already given you the sales pitch?"

Blake smiled. "Yes, General, she has."

General Ironwood nodded. "Your feelings about possible racism among the senior staff aside, what was it like fighting with Team Rosepetal?"

"It was a different style than the one taught at Beacon," Blake said. "I'm not ready to call it better on the basis of one mission. And I'm certainly not ready to judge Atlas on the basis of one team."

"If you would like to accompany other teams on training missions as they come up, that can be arranged," General Ironwood suggested.

"I… yes, sir, thank you," Blake said. "I'd also like to visit Atlas during the vacation."

"That depends on the threat posed by the White Fang at the end of the semester," General Ironwood said, "but in principle, I've no objection to that either. You are considering it, then?"

"Yes, sir," Blake admitted. "I am."

"May I ask why?" General Ironwood inquired. "You don't seem like the kind of student who would be excited by high tech gadgets or the ability to call in fire support."

"Does that make me a poor fit for your academy, General?"

"No," General Ironwood denied. "Although it means you may have something to learn when it comes to adapting to our philosophy." The general took pause for a moment. "We don't train Heroes at Atlas Academy, Miss Belladonna. Every student who passes through the halls of my school is a hero in my eyes, but we do not train Heroes. Do you understand the distinction?"

"Do you mean someone who fights alone, for their own glory?"

"Alone, or with only a handful of chosen companions like some knight or warrior prince of old," General Ironwood corrected. "If your ambition is to roam the dark places of the world with only your own strength – or the strength of the handful you trust to stand by your side – to preserve you, then I wish you luck, but Atlas Academy isn't for you. At Atlas, there are no soloists, only instruments in a grand orchestra. Scales on a leviathan."

"So I understand, sir, and honestly… that's what appeals to me. The chance to be a part of something bigger than myself… if only I could be sure that it was something good as well."

General Ironwood said, "I consider this great creation of ours to be not only good but great, and I hope that Dash would say the same, but I don't expect you to take either of our words for it."

"No, sir. This is something… I have to decide for myself." I owe it to myself not to make another mistake in choosing a cause to fight for.

"That's fair enough, Miss Belladonna," General Ironwood said. "When you do decide, just let me know."

"Yes, sir. General, has Roman Torchwick said anything yet regarding the plans of the White Fang? Or anything else?"

"No, he's not talking," General Ironwood said. "A few more days in solitary, and I hope that will change."

"And if it does-"

General Ironwood smiled slightly. "You'll be one of the first to know, Miss Belladonna."

"Thank you, sir."
 
Chapter 36 - Science and Magic
Science and Magic​



"So," Twilight asked, "how was the General?"

Sunset leaned back in her chair. "He thanked me for saving your life," she said. "His gratitude was effusive."

Twilight looked around from the machine that she had been examining. "Really?"

"No," Sunset conceded. "But it would have if he weren't such a block of stone, I'm sure."

Twilight frowned behind her glasses. "General Ironwood is not a block of stone," she snapped. "In any sense."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "Okay, Twilight, I didn't mean anything by it."

Team SAPR's garage was a little crowded. Each team was assigned a garage to store any vehicles that they might have – Yang's bike, Flash's car, Sunset's motorcycle – and wished to bring onto campus with them. The garages were bare and uninviting things, plain grey breeze block that offered no meaningful heat insulation and were pretty depressing to look at to boot, not to mention not terribly well-lit, but they were a little isolated from the rest of the campus, and they were large enough to accommodate the possibility – rare, admittedly, but still present – of a team having multiple vehicles that they wished to keep in one place. Which meant, since Team SAPR had only Sunset's idiosyncratic beauty of a bike, there was plenty of space in the quiet, secluded place for Twilight to run her little science experiment.

Sunset, Ruby, and Penny each sat in the garage upon old swivel chairs, worn out and not particularly comfortable, that Sunset had found by the skips at the back of the dorms; someone hadn't wanted them any more, but they were good for one more use, and that was all – hopefully – that they would need for this.

They were sat around an advanced Atlesian aura monitoring device, a tall, sleek, white machine that looked far too modern and clean to belong in this rather dark and slightly dinghy space, let alone sharing it with Sunset's hybrid motorcycle. A screen, displaying a lot of data relating to aura, sat above what Sunset thought to be a holoprojector, although it was not currently projecting anything. A series of black cables ran from the machine to the battery pack and to Ruby, Sunset, and Penny, who were all hooked up to the machine via black, plastic feeling monitors wrapped around their uncovered forearms.

Another machine in the same white, pristine, slender Atlesian mode was monitoring their brain activity, with three lines, running horizontally and rippling up and down on the screen. Finer cables led to it from the nodes attached to the sides of the temples of the three huntresses.

A third machine, to which Ruby and Sunset were also hooked up, this time via their other arms, monitored vital signs.

Sunset had to admit, the fact that that was considered necessary was a little concerning.

Jaune stood not too far away from Twilight and her machines, making a light scuffling sound with his feet as he twitched from one foot to the other. He might have a part to play in all of this, if Twilight decided that a stimulus to the aura was just what the scientist ordered. Pyrrha stood still and silent near the garage door, mostly visible for the reflection of the dim garage lights upon her gilded armour. Ciel stood next to Penny, one hand upon her shoulder, her blue eyes darting from Sunset to Ruby and then back again.

The door was shut. They were encased within.

Twilight turned away from Sunset, looking at her aura monitoring device, or seeming to. "I'm sorry," she said. "I just… people talk about General Ironwood like… it isn't fair, the things that they say. But you didn't mean it, and I shouldn't have reacted as though you did."

Sunset snorted. "It's mutual, then."

"Hmm?" Twilight asked.

"You care about him," Sunset explained. "The same way he cares about you."

"Oh," Twilight said. "Um, yes, I… of course I do. General Ironwood is… to be honest, I can't imagine our forces without him. I know, intellectually, that there must have been a time before him – in fact, I can tell you the name of his predecessor – but at the same time, and at the same time as I know that he won't always be around, that there will be a day when someone else will take his place… I can't really imagine that day coming."

"Not even if Rainbow Dash was the one taking his place?" Sunset asked.

Twilight blinked. "That… would require me to be able to imagine what Rainbow Dash will be like when she's older, and I just… is it weird that I can't do that? Not just with Rainbow, with anyone really? I can't imagine us grown up."

"And yet, it will happen to all of you nonetheless," Sunset murmured. "Except for you, Penny," she added, glancing past Ruby to where the newly-revealed robot sat on the far side of the garage. "You'll… do you have a plan for what you're going to do about that?"

"Do I need a plan for what I'm going to do about that?" Penny asked.

"Someone should have one," Sunset replied. "You don't really look seventeen now; it'll be really noticeable when everyone else is twenty-one, and you still look about fifteen."

"Some people stay looking young," Ruby pointed out. "Dad and Uncle Qrow haven't aged a day since they were at Beacon."

"I'm sure that's what they'd like you to believe."

"No, it's really true; I've seen pictures," Ruby insisted. She paused for a moment. "They haven't changed their clothes since then either."

"That's… a choice," Sunset muttered. "I take it, then, that the answer is that you don't have a plan for how to fake the appearance of getting older."

"No," Twilight said softly. "It… hasn't come up."

"Is that because Penny will be able to tell everybody the truth by then?" Ruby suggested.

"Do you think I should?" Penny asked, her tone wavering between eagerness and wariness. "I mean, what if… what if people find out what I really am and… they don't like me?"

Pyrrha took a step forward, coming a little more into the light than she had been before. "We like you just fine, Penny," she pointed out. "Finding out your truth didn't change one bit how we feel about you."

"You're not most people," Sunset said under her breath.

Ciel must have caught her words, because she said, "Indeed, as gratifying as your acceptance of Penny has been… it cannot be counted on to be universally replicated. We must take into account the possibility that there will be adverse reactions to Penny's nature. Which is why her secret ought not to be shared more widely than it already has been."

"You don't trust us to hold our tongues?" Sunset asked.

Ciel sighed. "I wish that nothing had been said to Mister Wukong. There is a certain fecklessness about him that makes him hard to trust."

"Feckless?" Sunset repeated. "There's nothing feckless about Sun. Stupid, sure, but not feckless."

"He has repeatedly abandoned his team-"

"Because they don't matter to him, and why should they?" Sunset demanded.

"Because they're his team?" Ruby reminded her.

"And he's found something that matters to him more than they do: Blake," Sunset declared.

"Your tone suggests you find virtue in that," Ciel said. "I confess, I cannot see it."

"When a man loves a woman," Sunset said, her voice adopting a certain haughty air, "he puts her at the very centre of his life and world." She twisted around in her seat to affix Jaune with a piercing look. "Devoting himself to her and sacrificing all his pleasures to her happiness. Otherwise, he is merely playing with her affection, and it is cruel beyond words to use a maiden's heart so."

"What are you glaring at me for?" Jaune asked nervously.

"I'm just exercising my neck muscles," Sunset said casually, looking away from him once she was sure that he had gotten the point. For all his faults, she found that she kind of liked Sun; he wasn't likely to treat Blake the way that Flash had treated her.

"I've never heard anything like that before," Ruby said.

"Then hearken to my wisdom, Ruby," Sunset said. "You need someone older and wiser telling you what to do."

"I like a good singalong more than probably anyone here," Twilight interjected, "but please tell me you're not about to start singing 'Sixteen Going On Seventeen' from Edelweiss."

"Of course not," Sunset snapped. "That guy was a complete jackass."

"In any case, no offence to Sunset-"

"But you're about to insult me."

"-but Ruby, I wouldn't necessarily take Sunset's words on the subject of relationships too much to heart."

"I suppose that she should take your advice instead," Sunset muttered. Listen to Twilight long enough, Ruby, and she'll teach you how to get Jaune away from Pyrrha. She could accept the fact that Twilight had not intentionally set out to steal Sunset's boyfriend, but at the same time, that kind of made it even worse; Twilight hadn't set out to do it, but nevertheless, she had accomplished precisely that. She didn't need to try; she was just so pretty, so sweet, so nice that men fell over themselves to ask her out. "How's Timber Spruce?" She took a slightly wicked glee in the way that Twilight's face flushed.

"He, um, I mean we, uh… it, uh, didn't work out," Twilight muttered. "Long distance, it was fun, but we didn't really, you know. I mean it's not like he was a bad guy or anything-"

"Perhaps we should focus on the reason we are here," Ciel suggested pointedly and with something of a glare in Sunset's direction. "Then we can all escape this rather dismal place."

You're no fun at all, are you?

Twilight, on the other hand, seemed to find Ciel's intervention rather gratifying. "Thank you, Ciel. That's an excellent idea." She coughed into her hand. "Ahem. Thank you… both of you," she added, in a tone that suggested she was a little less thankful for Sunset's presence than she might have been, "for coming. And thank you, Penny, for agreeing to be our control."

"I thought you were in control?" Penny said.

"I did too," Ruby agreed.

"A control, sometimes known as a control group, is a scientific term," Twilight explained. "It refers to the… the normal element in an experiment. By looking at Penny's aura, I can see if there are any abnormalities in yours or Sunset's auras that might be caused by your magic."

"But my aura isn't normal," Penny pointed out. "Not like yours or Ciel's."

"It's true that your aura is, as yet, unformed," Twilight conceded, "and in some ways, it might have been better to use Ciel as the control, but… well, to be honest, after I told everyone that I needed this equipment in order to run some checks on you, Penny, it makes me feel a little less dishonest if I run a couple of checks on you." She laughed nervously.

"'Unformed'?" Ruby murmured. "What do you mean, Penny's aura is unformed?"

"I mean… it's probably best if I show you," Twilight replied. "In fact, I will show you, because this is really cool. At least, I think it is anyway. As you might be able to guess from the presence of this technology and the fact that, well, Penny exists, we in the Defence Advanced Research Commission – pronounced 'dark' – have begun investigating aura from a purely scientific standpoint, stripping away the mysticism with which many past generations imbued it."

"Is that possible?" Pyrrha asked. "We're talking about the reflections of our souls, Twilight; how can that be stripped of… of reverence? And why would you want to?"

Twilight glanced at her. "I understand that aura is a wonderful thing-"

"Aura is far more than just wonderful," Pyrrha murmured. "Aura is… aura is a gift; a shield of light to guard us against the darkness and to enable us to fight against them."

"A gift from whom?" Twilight countered.

Pyrrha was silent for a moment. "That," she admitted, "I do not know."

"That ignorance does not disprove her point," Ciel declared. "The fact remains that aura is our link to the heavenly, to something more than human."

"Can that really be true, when aura is something that all humans have the potential to access?" Twilight asked.

It was clear from the way that she bit her lip that Ciel was not happy about that answer, yet nevertheless, she did not reply, save only to say, "In any case, please continue."

"Right," Twilight said, speaking a little more softly. "Anyway, as I was saying, we at Dark have been researching aura, its applications, its nature, and what we've discovered – one of the things that we've discovered – is really pretty neat." She tapped into the keyboard jutting out at a forty-five degree angle from the aura monitor, and the holographic projector burst into life, a light blue glow emitting from it as it began to project into the air in the garage.

What it projected was an amorphous green blob, shapeless yet moving gently as though it were alive, pulsing somewhat in a manner that reminded Sunset of a heart. And yet, in no other way did it resemble a heart at all; it was just a mass of something, resembling nothing.

"What is it?" Sunset asked.

"That is Penny's aura," Twilight explained. "It doesn't look like anything because, well, because – and I have to admit that this is only a theory, but it's a theory supported by all the present evidence-"

"Get to the point," Sunset urged.

"The point is that Penny hasn't finished figuring out who she is as a person yet," Twilight replied.

She hasn't found her cutie mark yet, in other words, Sunset thought.

"At least, that is the prevailing view amongst we who've been looking at this," Twilight went on. "It appears that, as a person grows and develops, as they figure out who they are, their aura starts to form into… well, why don't I show you?" She turned back to the keyboard and began to type away again. "This is… oh."

Sunset's eyes widened as the image on the holographic projector changed, the shapeless green mass disappearing to be replaced instead by a red rose.

And it was beautiful.

Sunset was not a great horticultural enthusiast, but she had never seen a flower so perfect as the one that was being projected before her eyes at this moment. Every petal was perfectly shaped, and there were so many petals, they rose in layers to make up the complete flower which blossomed to their view. Surely, no true rose could be so red; surely, no true rose could be shaped so consistently, without any defects of variation; surely, no true rose could hold the eye like this rose did.

"Is that you, Ruby?" Penny asked. "Your aura is… it's so lovely."

"And so well-formed," Twilight murmured. "Usually, at your age – or even at our age – I'd expect much more of a work in progress. You must be astonishingly self-actualised for… not just for your age, but period."

"Um, thanks?" Ruby muttered. "Uh… can I ask a question?"

"You don't know what self-actualised means, do you?" Twilight asked.

"Nope."

"It means you know exactly who you are."

"Doesn't everybody know that?"

Sunset laughed. "Far from it, Ruby, although life might be easier if that were true."

"Hmm," Twilight murmured.

"Is everything okay?" Ruby asked.

"Fascinating," Twilight said softly as she leaned forward.

"What is it?" asked Jaune.

"These silver lines on the edges of the rose," Twilight said, tapping the keyboard without looking at it so as to magnify the view of a single rose petal. Sure enough, the red of the petal was bordered with lines of silver around the edges, as though in adornment to a jewelled rose fashioned for ornament. "They… I've never seen anything quite like that before. Everyone's aura is only ever one colour– red in Ruby's case – so what is that silver doing there?"

"Silver eyes, silver on her aura?" Sunset suggested.

"As good a working hypothesis as any," Twilight allowed. "Do you mind if I bring up your aura for a moment?"

"I'd rather you didn't; it's likely to be a little embarrassing by comparison," Sunset remarked.

Twilight looked at her. "Do you mean that, or are you just being you?"

Sunset sighed. "Go on, get on with it."

As she had expected, the hologram of Sunset's aura looked rather embarrassing by comparison with Ruby's. Everyone was too polite to say anything, but nevertheless, Sunset felt her cheeks heating up as she averted her eyes from the child's sloppy crayon drawing of a sun being projected in front of her.

"Now, this is interesting," Twilight said. "Your magic is green, isn't it? That's the colour of your shields and your energy bursts."

"That's right," Sunset answered, still not looking.

"But I don't see any green here at all."

"That's because my magic isn't linked to my aura," Sunset replied. "Just as I told you."

"But Ruby's is?" Twilight inquired.

"It's a different kind of magic; it doesn't have to obey the same rules."

"I would have thought there'd be consistent principles behind it," Twilight mused. "Or at least some shared bedrock. Apparently not."

Let's be fair, we are talking about magic from two different worlds, Sunset thought. It would be amazing if there was consistency.

Jaune took a step forward. "Does knowing that Ruby's magic is connected to her aura in some way help you to… to help Ruby use it?"

"Hmm," Twilight mused wordlessly. "I, um… Sunset? Do you have any ideas at all? I know that it's not the same kind of magic, but, well, at least you have magic that you can use, so you're still the closest thing to an expert that we have."

"I would be an expert if we were discussing my own magic," Sunset insisted, "but this… if it's linked to aura, Ruby, can you focus your aura on your eyes? Maybe it just needs a strong boost, and if that doesn't work, we'll get Jaune to stimulate you."

"I'll try," Ruby murmured, "but I'm not that good at concentrating my aura."

"You can do it," Pyrrha said softly. "It's just a question of focus. Remove yourself from your surroundings and focus only upon yourself. Let the wall fall away until you are all that remains."

"That sounds easier than it is," Ruby commented plaintively.

"Yes," Pyrrha admitted, "but even so, I have faith in you."

"We all do," Jaune added.

Ruby smiled, if only for a moment, but in that moment, her eyes sparkled in the gloomy garage. But then the smile faded, and she closed her eyes and – judging by the look on her face – tried to concentrate.

It was either that, or something in her stomach disagreed with her, judging by the way that she was starting to scrunch up her face more and more.

Everyone in the garage was silent. Even Penny seemed to understand the importance of concentration for this. They all fell silent, and they all waited for Ruby, to see if anything would come of this.

Sunset herself thought it was not likely; if all it took was a sufficient application of aura, then surely, Ruby would have already had this down by now? If she just didn't have enough aura, then… what was the point of a power that required her to have Jaune-levels of inhuman aura capacity to actually do anything with it? It would be like most unicorns not being able to do any magic because they lacked the sheer power level required. Of course, it was not so; everypony had as much magic as they needed to follow their path in life as set out by their cutie mark, and Sunset was almost certain that it was the same in this case.

She was almost certain that this was not going to work, both because Ruby ought to have enough aura ordinarily to make use of her silver eyes if aura was required and also because aura wasn't magic. Magic in Remnant might graft itself onto aura, but aura was not the same as magic; at least, Sunset did not perceive it so.

She had mainly suggested this to buy herself a little time while she thought about other options.

Of course, there was no guarantee it wouldn't work; if it did, that would be great for Ruby… and Sunset would have a lot to think about in regards to how she saw the powers of the world and their relationship.

Ruby's eyes snapped open – and she cried out for a moment before shutting her eyes tight shut again.

"Ruby?" Pyrrha asked anxiously, taking a couple of steps forward. "What's wrong?"

"Did you know that if you concentrate your aura in your eyes, it makes you see better?" Ruby replied, in a pained, wincing tone. "Not a great idea to look into a light when that happens."

"Oh my," Pyrrha gasped. "Ruby, I'm sorry. Are you alright?"

"I can see a lot of colours in front of my eyes," Ruby declared, "but I'll be okay. Eventually."

"I'm not detecting any unusual readings from your aura," Twilight observed. "Or in your brain activity, for that matter. That doesn't seem to have done anything. Perhaps if Jaune were to-"

"I'm not sure that's a good idea," Pyrrha said, in a firmer tone that she was often wont to use. "Considering what happened when Ruby focused just her own aura around her eyes, she might permanently damage them if Jaune were to boost her aura in that area."

"Yeah, I don't really want to do that," Jaune added. "Besides, if it's about aura, then Ruby ought to be able to activate it with her own aura, right?"

"You make a good point," Sunset murmured, phrasing it as a concession and not something that she had already known before she suggested a pointless exercise to Ruby. "Twilight, how is that machine working out that Ruby's aura looks like that?"

"It's very technical."

"Try me."

"It's measuring the responses to multi-spectral animatropic resonance cascades."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "What in the cages of Tartarus are 'multi-spectral animatropic resonance cascades'?"

"I warned you it was very technical," Twilight replied. "Basically, it's an ultrasound for the soul."

Sunset's eyes narrowed. "Are you serious?"

"Yes," Twilight said. "Of course, it is still a very young science."

"More like pseudoscience," Sunset muttered. 'Multi-spectral animatropic resonance,' what kind of word salad is that?

"Sunset, do you have an idea?" Ruby asked.

"I don't know," Sunset growled. "I have always known that my magic was there, and so the fact that you can't just sense it is… frustrating."

"But not too surprising," Jaune said. "You might have always been able to sense your magic, but I didn't know that my aura was there until Pyrrha unlocked it in the forest."

"But Ruby does know that her aura is there," Sunset said. "So are you sure that you can't feel any… growths, for want of a better word, upon it?"

Ruby shook her head. "I can't feel anything except my aura." She paused. "So, even when you were starting to learn magic, you never had to work to… to get it out of you?"

"I had to work, but that isn't the same as not being able to feel it there at all," Sunset replied. "But… maybe there is something that I can do, but not here. I'd need to… to think about it a little more." Think about it and consult with Princess Twilight. "Twilight, is there nothing that you can do?"

"I don't know what I'm doing," Twilight admitted. "I've never seen anything like this before; this is… it's amazing that we were able to pick this up on Ruby's aura, but apart from that… I mean, we could try running a charge through Ruby's eyes and see if that jumpstarts something-"

"I don't think that's a particularly good idea," Pyrrha said firmly.

"No, probably not," Twilight admitted. She sighed dispiritedly. "I'm sorry, guys; this has been a complete bust. Like everything else lately."

"'Everything else'?" Penny repeated. "What do you mean, Twilight? Things have been going wonderfully so far, haven't they?"

"I meant… it doesn't matter, Penny; you're absolutely right. I'm sorry, Ruby. I'll keep studying the data that we've collected; maybe I'll have a brainwave."

"Don't worry about it," Ruby said. "If you figure something out, then that's great; if not… my mother managed to figure it out, and I'm sure I'll get there eventually."

Twilight smiled thinly. "That's very kind of you, but it doesn't stop me feeling like I've just wasted all of your time."

"It's okay," Ruby insisted. "Even though it didn't work, that doesn't mean it wasn't worth a shot."

"Like I said, it's very kind of you to say so," Twilight murmured. "Do you need any help getting out of all the equipment?"

"Nah, it's okay," Ruby said, pulling off the aura monitor. "Do you need help putting all of this stuff away?"

"No, thank you, I'll be fine," Twilight said, and with a little rustling and popping, Ruby, Sunset, and Penny unplugged themselves from all the scientific instruments. Pyrrha put one arm around Ruby's shoulder as the two of them – and Jaune and Penny – started towards the garage door which opened to admit the light into the dark, enclosed space.

"Sunset?" Ruby asked. "Aren't you coming?"

"I'll catch up," Sunset assured them.

Ciel looked at Sunset for a moment, and something unspoken passed between them; she nodded at Sunset – a curt nod, but at the same time a courteous one – and joined Penny and the others in leaving the garage, leaving Sunset and Twilight alone.

Their footsteps and the sounds of their talk died away.

"I really don't need help packing up," Twilight insisted as she knelt down on the ground and began to gather up wires.

"Maybe I just feel helpful," Sunset replied, using her telekinesis to pick up some cables off the floor and bundled them up in a coil. "So, what's up?"

"You mean more than my sense of failure?" Twilight asked.

"You aren't having a sense of failure because this one thing didn't work out."

"Aren't I?" Twilight responded. "I've spent half my life searching for magic, and now that I've found it, I can't understand it at all."

"It's your first try," Sunset reminded her. "You think I mastered every spell on my first try? Sometimes, it took until my second try."

Twilight looked up, a chuckled escaping her lips.

"But seriously," Sunset said, flopping back down into the old chair, "the study of magic is not something that can be rushed. Amongst my people, some… people spend their whole lives devoted to it."

"I don't have the luxury of a whole life to devote to it."

"You've got more than the time we spent here."

"I know," Twilight said. "It's just…"

"It's just that something else is bothering you," Sunset said. "Something related to Penny."

Twilight froze. "What makes you say that?"

"You clammed up when she asked you what was wrong," Sunset said. "You didn't want to hurt her feelings."

Twilight rose to her feet. "Penny… can be sensitive," she confessed. "We never want to upset her." She sat down in the chair recently vacated by Ruby. "It's not just Penny," she clarified. "It's also the fact that I haven't been able to trace the source of the video exposing Blake. Whoever they are, the means they undertook to protect themselves are incredibly sophisticated, and I… It just feels like I'm failing at everything that people are counting on me to accomplish."

"How are you letting down Penny?"

"Does it matter?"

"Maybe I can help?" Sunset offered.

Twilight frowned. She hesitated for a moment before pulling out her scroll and opening it up. Her fingers, lithe and delicate, flew across the screen to conjure up a holographic sword, a weapon that, at first glance, seemed to be one of Penny's weapons. With both hands, balancing the scroll upon her lap, Twilight reached for the holographic sword and began to pull it apart, dismantling what would have been the hilt if this had been a normal sword, turning it into its component parts.

"Is it classified?" Sunset asked. "Is that why you can't say anything?"

Twilight's hand began to glow with a faint purple light as she levitated a chocolate bar – one of the big, chunky ones that came in detachable blocks – out of her bag and into her waiting hand. She kept her eyes on Sunset as her hands unwrapped the chocolate. "Do you know anything about complex robotics?"

Sunset folded her arms and said nothing while she looked at Twilight's hologram. She was embarrassed to admit that it took her a moment to realise that it wasn't actually one of Penny's swords; the blade was the same, but the rear – the 'hilt' and the 'pommel' for want of better words – were much larger and bulkier than Penny's actual blades.

"Let me see," Sunset said. "You're not paying any attention to the blade or the laser cannon, but you have got a receiver and a dust battery which Penny doesn't need right now unless… you want to take her wireless, don't you?"

Twilight said nothing, but her silence said everything that Sunset needed it to.

Sunset kept her voice reasonably low. "I'm guessing that wireless weapons were always your original goal, but that you couldn't make it work, and so, you had to go with wire filaments, and now… you haven't given up hope."

Twilight frowned and sighed as she pushed her glasses back up the bridge of her nose. "It's not that it didn't work," she said. "The wireless system works just fine: a dust battery for independent power and a receiver to pick up the command signals from Penny – she even has the transmitter built in; it's just a redundant system right now. The swords already have thrusters for guidance and propulsion. The problem is that the power pack and the receiver made the back end of the sword too big to fit inside Penny's back-pack in the numbers required." Twilight sighed again. "It's far from ideal, but the council demanded results. General Ironwood couldn't stall them any longer. Hence, wires, and Penny will be stuck with wires unless I can figure out some way to miniaturize all this, and I just can't see it!" She picked up the scroll and threw it away; only Sunset grabbing it in the embrace of her own telekinesis stopped it from clattering onto the garage floor.

"I'm sorry," Twilight said. "I just… I've been working on this for months, and I don't feel like I'm any closer to getting it now than when I started."

"You need to have that many swords?" Sunset asked.

Twilight nodded wearily. "The mega-cannon mode requires the power of that many individual lasers in order to achieve the mandated armour penetration; for the same reason, we can't just reduce the output of the individual lasers in order to get away with a smaller battery, not that the savings in size are anything like commensurate with the reductions in capacity anyway."

Sunset's brow furrowed. From an interested lay perspective, she could understand why Twilight was having issues with this. Dust was the most efficient form of energy generation in Remnant, so if a dust power pack was too big, then there didn't seem to be much hope for anything else.

Assuming that it needs an actual power pack. "Can you not just use a battery, charged from Penny herself when she's not using the weapons?"

Twilight shook her head. "It would work, but in order to get a battery small enough, you'd have to accept an unacceptably low combat time."

"What's unacceptably low?" Sunset said. "Most battles aren't drawn out."

"Most individual actions are not drawn out," Twilight corrected. "Penny can't just despatch a group of beowolves and call it quits necessarily; she might need to have to respond to situations across a wide area for hours, maybe days without respite."

"Because now that you have Penny, you're planning to retire the Atlesian Corps of Specialists," Sunset replied. "Come on, you know that no flesh and blood huntress would be asked to rush up and down a full-scale battlefield like that; individual teams and units would have their own sectors and only respond to other areas in an emergency."

"I know," Twilight said softly, "but we both know that Penny isn't a flesh and blood huntress. The council expects to be able to push her harder and take greater risks with her, and she needs to be able to handle it. She needs to be able to fight for hours, days, maybe weeks without stopping. And she needs to have all of these stupid wires out of the way." She took her head in her hands, shaking it despairingly. "There must be an answer to this, right? This isn't an insurmountable problem."

"I don't believe in insurmountable problems," Sunset said. "Is there any reason you can't just expand the backpack to make room?"

"She also needs to look appealing to civilians, so that they trust her," Twilight explained. "Apparently, big, bulky backpacks aren't cute."

Sunset whistled. "Whoever set these parameters was doing you no favours."

"I know," Twilight groaned. "That's one of the reasons I was keen to give helping Ruby a shot: I could use a break from pushing this boulder up the hill."

"You can only bang your head against the wall for so long before it starts to hurt."

"Tell me about it," Twilight said. "Sunset, to go back to the topic of Ruby for a second, can I ask you something?"

Sunset plucked Twilight's chocolate out of her hand. "You can ask me whatever you like," she said as she broke off a piece of the bar.

Twilight stared at her.

Sunset offered Twilight her own chocolate back, even as she put the stolen piece into her mouth.

Twilight rolled her eyes. "Okay, why not?" she said, a slight trace of a sigh in her voice as she took the sweet back from Sunset. "Do you… is there any way that you could… give me some of your magic?"

Sunset choked on the piece of chocolate making its way down her throat. Her eyes bulged and then began to water as she broke out in a violent coughing fit, her throat straining as she struggled to eject the blockage.

"Sunset?" Twilight. "Sunset, are you okay? Oh, gods, let me help you!" She leapt up and darted around Sunset, hammering her back as hard as she was able to until the offending piece of chocolate flew out of Sunset's mouth and landed on the floor not far from her bike. "I'm so, so sorry about that. Do you need a drink of water?"

Sunset wiped at her eyes with one hand, regretting the blow to her dignity as she struggled to get her breath back. "No, I don't need a drink of water," she said, although her throat did feel very, very sore right now. Every time she swallowed, it was like ripping off a bandage. "I need you to… give you my magic?"

"Not all of it," Twilight replied, a trifle defensively. "I just… if I can study it in more controlled conditions, then maybe I could actually understand how it works well enough to be some help to Ruby."

"But it's my magic," Sunset said. "Given to me, a part of me."

"I'm not asking for all of it," Twilight said. "Just some."

"Would you ask me for just some of my aura?"

"Um, well, uh… you see… so is it possible?" Twilight asked.

"I… don't know," Sunset admitted. Complete transfer was certainly possible, but partial? That was something she was a lot less certain of.

"Would you do it if it was?"

"No," Sunset said at once. "This is… this is my magic, Twilight. My… my gift. Bestowed on me by… by destiny, that I could make my mark upon the world; if I give this up, if I give it to you or anybody else… without this, I am nothing."

"You're being very overdramatic," Twilight replied. "Even without your magic, you'd still be-"

"Without my magic, I'd be the underperformer I was in Canterlot," Sunset said sharply, "and don't deny it." Compared to Pyrrha or Rainbow or Ruby, I'd be pathetic, a joke. I'd be worth less than Jaune! "I will not suffer that. Not for anyone, and certainly not for the benefit of your understanding."

Twilight didn't bother to conceal the disappointment on her face. Her lips crinkled visibly. "If I can't experience, I don't know if I'll ever be able to understand," she said. "And if I can't understand, I don't know how I can help."

"That is a pity," Sunset said, "but it does not change my answer in the least."
 
Chapter 37 - Treat Her Right
Treat Her Right​



The common room was on the first floor of the dorm room, not far from the kitchenette; it was spacious enough for several teams at once to mingle and would have made a much better space for everyone to gather last night if it weren't for the fact that they had needed seclusion and security to share their secrets.

The furniture was red, as per Beacon standard, and the floors were plain, uncarpeted wood. A projector that students could use as a TV was set on a metallic stand at the back of the room, in front of the windows.

Sun was lying on one of the sofas, trying to use one of the cushions as a pillow.

Judging by the way that he was turning over and over, it didn't seem to be working very well.

Sunset, who had just come in carrying the books that Twilight had given her underneath her arm, saw him lying there, still dressed – or as close to dressed as Sun could be said to ever be, given his penchant for wandering around with his chest bared – with only his removed shoes a concession to what he was doing.

She stared down at him for a moment and seriously considered going back to her dorm room before curiosity got the better of her. "Sun?"

Sun looked up, bleary-eyed. "Wh- Sunset?"

"Good morning," Sunset said.

"Hey," Sun groaned. "These cushions aren't very soft, are they?"

"I'm surprised that a tough Vacuan like yourself needs a snuggly pillow to lay his head," Sunset remarked. "Shouldn't you be able to make do with a rock?"

"Hey, don't lump me in with Nebula and the rest of those jerks," Sun replied. "I don't see that there's anything wrong with wanting to be comfortable if we can be."

"One of the smartest things you've said since I met you," Sunset observed. "So, if you're not practicing masochism to prove that you are, indeed, a Hard Man from a Hard Land who is so much Harder than all of us soft, decadent city folk, what are you doing sleeping on the couch?"

"Oh, uh, you see… my team kicked me out."

Sunset blinked. "Come again?"

"Scarlet said that if I wasn't going to stick with my team, then I could find somewhere else to sleep," Sun explained. "They really weren't happy about me going off with Blake and the Atlesians."

"Well, I can't say I don't see why," Sunset murmured as she sat down on the arm of the sofa, her back half-turned away from Sun so that she had to twist her whole body around to look at him. "You do have a habit of ditching them for Blake."

"She's important to me," Sun said, stating the obvious.

"Somehow, I suspect that that doesn't mollify your team very much," Sunset replied.

"No, I guess not," Sun moaned. "But what am I supposed to do? Blake matters to me, like a lot. Like… more than anything in the world. How am I supposed to ignore it when she needs me?"

Sunset was of the opinion that Blake didn't really need Sun's help – not when she had Team RSPT backing her up, anyway – but at the same time, she couldn't deny that hearing him say those words was… it touched something in her heart in a way that her heart had not been touched for quite some time. It might be stupid, it might have gotten Sun into trouble with his team, it might be unnecessary, but that was what a good boyfriend was supposed to say, damn it! This was what Flash should have said, instead of ditching Sunset the moment their relationship became inconvenient for his reputation.

Sun was an idiot in some ways, but he was also a very good boy. Blake was lucky to have him. Sunset wondered if she understood just how lucky she was.

"Don't," she said.

"Huh?"

"Don't turn away," Sunset instructed him. "Don't ignore it. Go to her, every single time, and to hell with Team Sun. Be a man. Be Blake's man. Stand by her side, no matter what, because that's what a good man does when he loves a woman."

"Really?"

"Really," Sunset said with absolute conviction. "Don't you agree that Blake deserves to be treated like a queen?"

"Of course she does."

"Then be her good servant: loyal and faithful and true," Sunset instructed him. She got up. "Now, come on, follow me."

"Where?"

"Back to the dorm room; you can sleep on my camp bed for as long as you like until I need it."

"You mean it?"

"Yes, I mean it; my heart's not made of stone, you know," Sunset snapped, and snapped her fingers at the same time. "Come on, lover boy, let's go."

He followed her, the softer padding of his footsteps a counterpoint to the heavier tread of Sunset's boots as she led him back the way that she had come, down the corridor, past the dorm room doors, until at last, they stood once again – once again for Sunset, anyway – before the door into the Team SAPR dorm room.

Sunset tucked the books that she had hoped to read – not that there wouldn't be plenty of time to go back to the common room once she'd tucked Sun in and seen him settled – while she fished her scroll out of her jacket pocket and used it to open the door.

The latch clicked, and Sunset pushed it open.

Jaune was the sole occupant of the dorm room, sitting on his bed and reading one of the history textbooks with an intense frown upon his face. Ruby was with Yang, while Pyrrha was… Sunset wasn't entirely sure where Pyrrha was, or Blake, for that matter. But they weren't here; Jaune was the sole other presence in the room.

He looked up as Sunset came in, Sun following behind her.

"You're back early," Jaune said. "And, oh hey, Sun, what are you doing here?"

"I found him crashing on the couch in the common room and invited him to use my bed for a little bit," Sunset declared. "I hope you don't mind if I take my unicorn," she added, summoning it into her free hand with telekinesis. "I don't like strangers getting their hands on him."

"I don't need a cuddly toy; I just need a bed I can lie on," Sun declared.

"Uh, what's the matter with the bed in your own room?" Jaune asked.

"Don't worry, man. I'll be cool," Sun assured him. "I don't snore or anything; you won't even know that I'm here."

"Good to know," Jaune admitted, "but all the same, what's the matter with the bed in your dorm room?"

"The fact that it's behind a locked door," Sun groaned.

"His teammates have kicked him out," Sunset explained.

Jaune frowned. "How did they manage to lock you out of your own dorm room?"

"Neptune's a genius nerd," Sun moaned as he climbed into Sunset's bed.

"Hey!" Sunset snapped. "Take your shoes off first; this is a civilised dorm room." And I don't want mud or whatever else is on your shoes on my bed.

"Right, sorry," Sun muttered, as he kicked off his shoes. "I really do appreciate this."

"Someone can really do that?" Jaune demanded. "Lock a team member out of their dorm room?"

"It's actually not that difficult," Sunset said. "All you have to do is either disable the recognition on the door's sensors of that particular scroll – which is also the way that you'd allow access to anyone outside the team – or you could hack into the scroll itself and disable the subcommand that enabled it to respond to the door sensor."

"Do I want to know how you know that?" Jaune said, a trace of a whimper in his voice.

"I considered using access as a way to motivate you," Sunset informed him bluntly, "but you didn't need that kind of… stern encouragement." Not to mention, it would have been hard to get it past Ruby and Pyrrha.

"Right," Jaune murmured. "So… your teammates have locked you out, huh?"

"Yep," Sun sighed as he pulled the blanket over him.

"Because of Blake?"

"Because I kept ditching them."

"Right," Jaune said. "Have you told them you're sorry?"

Sun looked up and pushed himself up on his elbows. "Huh?"

"You know, maybe if you apologised they'd, let you back in?"

Sun shrugged. "They probably would," he admitted. "Well, Neptune would. I don't know about Scarlet; he's had it in for me from Initiation; he thinks I took his spot as team leader."

"What about…?" Sunset began, before she realised that she didn't know the name of the fourth member of Team SSSN.

"Sage?" Sun suggested. "I never really know what he's thinking; he's kind of the strong, silent type."

"Are you sure it's not just the fact that you're never around?" Jaune suggested.

"Heh, yeah, there's probably some of that in there, too," Sun acknowledged without a trace of shame in his voice. "But, anyway, maybe apologising would work, but it wouldn't feel right to apologise if I didn't mean it."

Jaune blinked rapidly. "If you… you're not the slightest bit ashamed of what you did, are you?"

"And he shouldn't be," Sunset declared.

"You're on his side?" Jaune squawked in astonishment.

Sunset shrugged. "Is there any reason why I shouldn't be on his side?"

"Because you're you!" Jaune exclaimed.

"And Sun's gallantry has touched my romantic sensibilities," Sunset asserted magisterially.

"Come on, Sunset, we both know that if I was dating Weiss and I had ditched the rest of this team to join Wisteria on a field mission, you'd have hung my guts from the curtain rail by now."

Sunset narrowed her eyes. "Would you rather be dating Weiss?"

"No, of course not!" Jaune yelled. "That's not what I meant, and you know it!"

"What I know," Sunset said, "is that you could learn a thing or two from this young man." She gestured at Sun with her stuffed unicorn.

"If you guys are going to have a fight, could you do it outside?" Sun asked, as he laid his head down on the pillow and closed his eyes. "I'm trying to sleep here."

"This is our dorm room!" Jaune exclaimed.

"Don't worry, this won't take long," Sunset assured him as she walked towards Jaune, who scrambled to his feet as she approached.

Sunset looked up at him and into his eyes. He was a nice boy… he seemed like a nice boy… but then, Flash had seemed like a nice boy too, which was one of the reasons why Sunset had made the mistake of making him her rock. And Pyrrha… Pyrrha wasn't as emotionally resilient as Sunset was.

Hesitation robbed her of the power of speech. Was this even necessary? Did she really need to give Jaune the talk? Was he really going to treat Pyrrha like trash?

You never can tell with guys.

Oh, come on, really? When he was sleeping in the same room as Pyrrha, Ruby, and Sunset, was he really going to bring all that down on him by acting like – as an older generation might have put it – like a cad?

What's the harm in nipping it in the bud before it gets that far?

Well, Jaune might think that she had a low opinion of him, for one?

No, you just have a low opinion of teenage boys.

Yeah, but how likely was it that Jaune was going to do something bad? He was a nice boy-

You thought the same about Flash.

But that was different. Pyrrha was in love with him.

Like you were in love with Flash.

She wasn't really, though, was she? She'd gotten over it.

Yeah, right. Keep telling yourself that.

None of that meant that Jaune was going to turn out anything like the same way.

But what if he does?

"Sunset?" Jaune asked. "Is everything okay?"

"I don't know," Sunset snapped up at him. "I don't… I'm sorry, I just… I'm trying to work out whether I need to… ugh… just don't hurt Pyrrha, okay?"

Jaune stared down at her, his blue eyes seeming especially innocent as he blinked down at her. "Huh?"

"You…" Sunset stopped herself from just saying 'you heard,' for fear it might sound too surly on her part. "Don't hurt Pyrrha. She…" Sunset also stopped herself from saying 'she loves you,' because if Jaune didn't realise that – and Pyrrha hadn't told him – then it wasn't Sunset's job to tell him. "She doesn't deserve it. So if this is some love 'em and leave 'em thing where you walk away as soon as you can say you tapped Pyrrha Nikos, or you're going to get bored in a few weeks and move on, or-"

"Sunset, come on," Jaune interrupted her. "How can you say stuff like that?"

"It's nothing personal."

"Isn't it? Because it sounds pretty personal to me!"

Sunset groaned. "This is what I was worried about; I'm not telling you this so that you can get offended, okay? I know that you're a nice guy, but I've been let down by nice guys in the past. Badly. And I don't want that for Pyrrha, because she's my friend, and I don't want her to get hurt. She doesn't deserve it, she's too-"

"I know what Pyrrha is," Jaune said. "I know exactly what a wonderful person she is and how little she deserves to get treated like… like that. And I would never do that! You're not the only person who cares about Pyrrha."

"I know," Sunset said, perhaps a little too sharply. She softened her tone. "I know. I just… you're a boy, and boys can change so suddenly…" She sighed. "Or perhaps I'm just projecting like crazy." She sighed again and even more deeply this time. "I really didn't come here to offend you or upset you or… anything, really. I just-"

"Wanted to help Pyrrha," Jaune said softly. "I get that. And it's okay. I mean, sure, I was upset at first when you acted like I might… come on, I've got seven sisters. I know how to treat girls."

"Really?" Sunset asked. "How's that?"

"With a deep respect born out of fear and a knowledge that they know where you sleep," Jaune said without hesitation.

Sunset couldn't help but snort with laughter. "Yeah, I'm sure you do."

Jaune smiled. "I… I don't know how long this is going to last… but that's only because I don't know how long Pyrrha is going to be satisfied with a guy like me when she's so… you know."

If only you knew.

"I don't know if I can make her happy," Jaune continued. "But I'm going to try, for however long she lets me.

Sunset looked at him for a moment, looking at his earnest face, looking into his eyes. "You… for what it's worth, I'm sorry if I bruised your pride a little; and for what else it might be worth… I think you are a good guy, and I should have trusted you."

"It's okay," Jaune repeated. "What are friends for except looking out for one another, right?"

"Yeah… right," Sunset murmured. "Anyway…" Her tail swished uncertainly back from side to side. "So, I'm going to… yeah. You… you think about what I said, okay? Just… think about it. And…" And treat her right.

Sunset didn't flee the room. She most emphatically did not flee the room. She simply left it, at a very fast and slightly undignified pace.

XxXxX​

Jaune watched her go, the door closing behind her with a little more firmness than strictly necessary.

He watched her go, and he felt sorry for her. He couldn't bring himself to feel offended for himself; he didn't blame her for what she'd said; not because she had reason to say it – she didn't, and she ought to have known him well enough to know that she didn't – but because… okay, back up a second. She had no reason to think that he would betray Pyrrha like that, no reason to suspect that his intentions were anything but pure, no reason to think that he wasn't in this for as long as Pyrrha would have him. And it was a question of how long Pyrrha would have him, because, well, why shouldn't get bored of a guy like him? Why wouldn't she wake up and realise that she could do so much better than Jaune Arc? Why wouldn't the most beautiful, kindest, bravest, strongest girl their age move on from a loser whose only attractive feature was being clueless? But if things ended – as Jaune felt certain, Pyrrha's protestations of love aside, that they would end – then it wouldn't be because he had ended them.

So Sunset had no reason on that count to say anything like that to him, to grill him, to press him, but for the other reasons that she had to say it, well… those reasons, he couldn't deny, and it was for those reasons that he felt sorry for her.

The more things went on, the more certain Jaune became that Flash Sentry had done Sunset Shimmer dirty. It wasn't obvious at first, because Flash was such a genial guy, so affable and good-natured, while Sunset was prickly and hard-edged; not to mention the fact that the venom that Sunset had for Flash sometimes got lost under the noise of her attitude towards other people. Plus, the fact that there were times in Jaune's school life when he hadn't been particularly inclined to feel very sorry for Sunset or to look too closely at her problems. Not to mention that he'd had enough of his own problems at other times or even at some of those same times.

But the more he looked, the more he felt as though Flash must have done something to really hurt Sunset, and the more he felt as though he couldn't just ignore that fact. Sunset could be difficult, and she was proud and stubborn, and she thought she was so smart, even though she was making terrible decisions… but she was also their team leader, and she was a leader who would always have your back, even if she complained about it all the while. She had forced him to get a grip, and even though she had tried to use him as an accessory to bullying as part of a petty revenge scheme, he couldn't ignore the fact that she had saved his place at Beacon too, and he knew – he knew in his gut – that she would do the same for Ruby or Pyrrha if either of them found themselves in trouble like that.

Sunset… Sunset took care of them, and Jaune felt as though they ought to take care of her as well, since they were a team.

Plus, there was the fact that if Flash really was hiding a dark side, then, well, just because he had lost interest in Weiss didn't mean that he wanted to see her end up in the arms of someone whose fair face hid a black heart.

He wasn't sure exactly what he could do, or ought to do to help Sunset with her problem, but he felt increasingly sure that he ought to – had to – do something.

Perhaps Pyrrha would know what to do. He should definitely speak to her about it before he did anything.

In the meantime… Jaune's eyes were drawn towards Sun, where the nominal leader of Team SSSN was lying in bed with the blanket pulled up so high that it almost hid his face.

"Hey," Jaune said. "Are you still awake?"

"Unfortunately," Sun muttered.

"How long have you been sleeping on sofas?"

"Since we got back from the train mission," Sun grunted. He lifted his head up a little bit so that he could look at Jaune. "How are you doing, by the way?"

"Distance helps," Jaune said. "So does having stuff to take my mind off it." He frowned. "How come no one has noticed you sleeping around the common room before?"

"People noticed; they just didn't care or thought it was funny."

Jaune winced. "That's rough," he said. He paused. "Listen, Sun… when Sunset let you in here, did she say anything to you?"

Sun hesitated. "Uh, yeah, she told me I'd done the right thing and that I shouldn't feel guilty about it."

Jaune rolled his eyes. "I meant what I said, by the way; if I pulled a stunt like that, I'd think myself lucky if all she did was lock me out of the room."

"Yeah, but you're on the same team as your girlfriend," Sun protested. "Are you telling me that if you were on a different team from Pyrrha, then would you let anything stop you from heading into danger with her?"

"I might let the three other people who I'm supposed to be facing danger with let it stop me," Jaune replied. "I mean… sure, I get it, and I'm glad that I'm not in your position… but it would be kind of insulting to Sunset and Ruby and…" – he plucked a name out of the air – "Yang to act like I was the only one who could help Pyrrha and keep her safe, and it would be doubly insulting to Ren and Nora and Dove if I kept ditching them and letting them go into danger without me. Triply so if I was supposed to be leading them into battle. I mean, don't you care about your teammates at all? Doesn't it matter to you that they might have to face real danger without you? Without anyone? They'll be a man down against grimm or bandits or the White Fang, and in the meantime… what? Do you think that Blake can't take care of herself? Do you think that Team Rosepetal doesn't have her back? Do you think that we don't have her back?"

"I know that Blake doesn't need me!" Sun cried. "I get it, okay. You don't need to rub it in. I know that Blake is surrounded by great people, and they're all so much better than I am, trust me."

Jaune was silent for a moment. "That's what this is about, isn't it?"

Sun nodded. "I want… I need to show Blake that I… that I'm more than just some bum, you know? I know… I know she doesn't love me. I know she doesn't feel the same way about me that I feel about her, but maybe… maybe if I show her that I'm the kind of guy who… who understands the things that matter to her and fights for them like she does then… then maybe… I don't know."

Jaune sighed. "Listen… I'm not great at this stuff either, so don't take my word for it, but I think… I think that if you want to show Blake a different side of you, then maybe, instead of chasing her around, you should show her that you're the kind of person that… not just the kind of person that she can rely on, but the kind of person that everyone can rely on… the kind of person that I think Blake would like to become. I mean, look at Sunset. Look at Rainbow Dash. Blake has a lot of respect for both of them-"

"Are you saying you don't think Blake respects me?"

Jaune hesitated. "I… don't really know?"

"Thanks, dude."

"The point is that Blake doesn't respect them because they both fall down at her feet and always go running off after her."

"Both of them have done exactly that," Sun pointed out.

"Yeah, okay, but they didn't ditch their… okay, they both did that too, but not in the same way that you did," Jaune insisted. "You know exactly what I'm talking about: Blake respects both of them because they're good leaders, because they take their responsibilities seriously, because she knows that… that we can all rely on them if we need to. And maybe that's what you need to show her."

"Is that what you show Pyrrha?" Sun asked. "That everyone can rely on you?"

"Pyrrha… I still don't really get what I did to get so lucky with Pyrrha."

Sun sighed. "I envy you, man."

"Hey, don't put yourself down too much; you're still with Blake, after all," Jaune reminded him. "I suppose what I'm really trying to say is, don't put too much stock in Sunset's dating advice."

"Okay," Sun murmured. "What's up with her? Is she okay?"

When it comes to guys, I don't think she is. "I don't know," Jaune lied. "I've really got no idea."

XxXxX​

Pyrrha had texted Dove, asking him to meet her under the shadow of the huntsman statue, but when she got there, she found that he had beaten her to their meeting place: he was sitting in front of the snarling beowolf – with the result that it looked a little as though it was about to pounce on him – reading Fairy Tales of Remnant. He must have heard her footsteps on the courtyard stone, because he looked up as Pyrrha drew near and scrambled to his feet.

"You don't have to get up," Pyrrha told him.

Dove smiled. "I think my grandmother would rise out of her grave and whack me with a broom handle if I didn't," he said. "Good manners were very important to her."

Pyrrha chuckled. "Well, if it means that much to you, then I can't stop you. Thank you for meeting me."

"It's not a problem," Dove assured her. "Plus, I'm a little curious as to why you want to talk to me specifically."

He had reason to be curious; it wasn't as though they interacted a great deal; even when Teams SAPR and YRDN interacted with one another, Dove was very easily drowned out by the more vocal and expressive personalities on his team. It made Pyrrha feel a little guilty about the fact that their first meaningful interaction was to ask him for a favour. She glanced down and fiddled momentarily with her red sash.

"I'm afraid that I would like to ask for something from you, however little right I have to ask it."

"You have the right to ask for whatever you like," Dove said. "Just as I have the right to say no."

"Of course," Pyrrha murmured. "You know… or you might not know… I've been training Jaune in swordplay."

"He has been improving by leaps and bounds," Dove told her. "The general opinion in the dorm room – and in Team Bluebell's dorm room, come to that – is that you've got something to do with it."

"Indeed," Pyrrha said softly; she found that she was not particularly surprised to hear that. It was no slight on Jaune to admit that he had arrived at Beacon in need of some instruction, and it made sense that she would be the one to provide him with that instruction. "Are there any… dissenting opinions?"

"Lyra thinks that Jaune was holding back when he first arrived at Beacon, so as to make himself seem weaker than he was so that his transformation would seem all the more impressive," Dove explained. "Like a sun hidden behind the clouds seems to shine brighter when the clouds disperse than a clear day ever can; her words, not mine."

Pyrrha smiled. "That would be a fine thing, if it was true, but… the general opinion is right; I have been giving Jaune some assistance. And I'm glad to hear you say that Jaune has improved; it shows that my judgement isn't blinded by… by my affection for him." She looked up into Dove's round face. "The trouble is… the trouble is that Jaune can't see the scale of his improvement because… because he's still some way away from beating me."

"Yang aside, we're all a long way from beating you," Dove said.

"I didn't come here to be flattered," Pyrrha said gently. "The point is… I was hoping that you might agree to become Jaune's sparring partner-"

"Because I'm much closer to his level than you are, and he can gauge his progress against me much more effectively?" Dove asked.

"I didn't mean to insult you," Pyrrha said quickly.

Dove held up one hand. "You didn't. My grandfather used to say that if you were insulted by the truth, then you either had too much pride or too thin a skin. I know that you're set high above me in your skill at arms. I know that I have work to do to climb the mountain that divides us." He fell silent, leaving Pyrrha unsure of whether he would agree to her request or not.

Nevertheless, she did not press him on it. She was, after all, asking him for a favour; impatience would hardly become her in this situation.

Pyrrha waited, as Dove half-turned away from her, his lips moving silently.

"I can do one night a week," he said. "In return for something from you."

"What?" Pyrrha asked.

"While you've been tutoring Jaune, I've been helping Lyra," Dove informed her. "She was a little better than Jaune at the start of the year, but I think he'd beat her now. Consequence of the difference in teachers; Lyra isn't as fortunate in her friends or teammates as Jaune is, so she's stuck with me instead of the Champion of Mistral."

Pyrrha didn't reply to that; there was no need, in her opinion; Dove would probably resent being patronised as much as Jaune did, but on the other hand, there was no need to lord her superior skill over him.

"If I give a night over to Jaune," Dove continued, "will you help Lyra on that night? I'm sure you can show her things I've not even considered."

Pyrrha smiled. "Of course," she said, warmly and readily. "You train every night?"

"No, three nights a week," Dove said. "Do you train every night?"

"Almost every night, unless there's a good reason not to."

"What about having fun?"

"Jaune… is determined to get better," Pyrrha said carefully, hoping that it didn't sound like she was suggesting Lyra was not… even though that was, to an extent, what she was suggesting.

"So does Lyra," Dove replied, a little defensively. "But she couldn't spend all her time practicing. What about homework?"

"I manage," Pyrrha murmured. "And Jaune… is fortunate to have Sunset and myself to assist him. Besides, we train every night but not all night."

"I see," Dove said. "You are truly blessed to have a mind as sharp as the edge of your sword."

"Fortune smiled upon me at my birth, and many other times after," Pyrrha agreed. "Shall I let you speak to Lyra and decide which day suits her best? If she even wants my help; she may not."

"True, in which case, I'm sorry, but I wouldn't be able to help Jaune."

"Of course. I understand," Pyrrha said. If that was the case, then her next call would be Blake, who fought with a sword sometimes, even if it was in quite an alien fashion to the style that she had been teaching Jaune. There was always Sunset, who now had a sword – courtesy of Pyrrha's mother – and who fought in a fighting style that could be called static, but Pyrrha thought that Sunset was too inexperienced with the blade; Jaune still needed to be challenged by his opponent. "I don't suppose that you know anything about attacking with your aura? Expelling it out through your blade, I mean."

"You mean like Ren?" Dove asked. "But with a sword? Is that possible?"

Pyrrha nodded. "I've seen it done, but I… I understand the theory, but not having ever trained it in myself, it's not something I could pass on to Jaune."

"And you thought I would know something you would not?"

"My mother – and the tutors she hired – taught me that expending your aura thus in an attack was a blunt instrument," Pyrrha said. "I was taught to be precise, but Jaune has the aura to spare for such attacks, in moderation. I wondered if you might have the skill."

"I'm afraid not," Dove said. "Although you've made me curious about it now. I might ask Ren if it is something he can teach me. In the meantime, I'll speak to Lyra, and let you know what she says."

"Thank you," Pyrrha said. "I appreciate your willingness to help me and Jaune."

Dove shrugged. "We're on different teams, but we all share a common purpose, don't we? We are… the light against the darkness, if that doesn't sound too pompous."

"Not at all. I think it's perfect," Pyrrha said, "and perfectly accurate too. You helping Jaune and I helping Lyra: what benefits one benefits us all."

XxXxX​

Blake was not blind to the fact that there was a degree of risk involved in walking around the campus with a book written by a faunus political prisoner in her arms, and she was certainly not unaware that she might have been better off reading this in the SAPR dorm room. But she had no intention of spending her entire time at Beacon cooped up in that room, and the book that she was carrying with her wasn't a White Fang recruiting pamphlet; it didn't advocate terrorism as a means of advancing political objectives; quite the opposite, if Twilight's summation of it was correct.

There was no reason on Remnant why she shouldn't take it to the library this morning and start to read it.

Plus, everyone else was in class by now.

So Blake walked into the library, the door swinging shut behind her, carrying Prison Journals pressed against her chest, title turned away from the world.

"Hey, Blake?"

Blake stopped, her golden eyes widening at the burly figure who had just emerged from out of the stacks in front of her. "Tukson?"

Tukson smiled warmly. "It's been a little while, hasn't it?"

"'It's been a…'" Blake fought to hold back the cry of irritation that threatened to rise up from her throat. "I went to the hospital to see how you were, and they told me you'd gone!"

"Yeah, I got discharged a few days ago."

"I couldn't call you!"

"They took my scroll away for my own protection, or something."

"You… how long have you been here?" Blake demanded.

"Since I got out of hospital," Tukson explained. "Professor Ozpin explained that it probably wasn't safe for me to go back to the bookshop right away, since the White Fang might, you know, try and shut me up again, but he also offered me a job here in the library. It seems there are a lot of books here that need to be catalogued, so that ought to keep me busy until this whole thing blows over."

Blake stared at him. She was speechless, torn between her joy at seeing him safe and sound and secure in this place, the heart of their fortress, and her anger at the fact that she had found this out by sheer chance of having to walk in here when he had been near the door. If she had stayed away – if she had decided to read in the dorm room, for instance – she would not have found out. She might never have found out.

"When were you going to tell me?" she demanded.

"You were away on a mission when I came here," Tukson explained. "I didn't want to distract you when your life, and the lives of those around you, were on the line."

"I got back from my mission the day before yesterday," Blake pointed out.

"Oh, I didn't know that," Tukson admitted. "I figured I'd see you around. And I did."

Blake sighed. "Yes. Yes, I suppose you did," she admitted. She bowed her head but then looked back up at him with a slight smile gracing her features. "I'm glad you're okay," she added.

Tukson took a couple of steps towards her and reached out to put his strong hands upon her shoulders. "And I'm glad you made it back from your mission in one piece. Are you allowed to talk about it? Do you want to talk about it?"

Blake hesitated. "I think it should be okay."

"But do you want to talk about it?" Tukson repeated.

"Yes," Blake said. "I've spent… too long hiding how I feel. Hiding parts of my life. I don't want to hide any more."

"Then do you want to sit down?" Tukson suggested. "There's no food or drink allowed in the library, but-"

"I'll be fine with just a seat," Blake said. "Are you going to be okay, or will you get in trouble for slacking off?"

"I hope not; who's around to tell?" Tukson asked as he took her by the shoulder and steered to one of the tables in the open heart of the library.

Blake pulled out one chair, and Tukson another as they both sat down. Blake put Prison Journals down on the table, still facing downwards.

Tukson nodded at the black book. "What's that?"

"It's nothing," Blake replied.

"If it was nothing, you wouldn't be trying to hide the title," Tukson pointed out.

"I suppose not," Blake admitted. "It's Rudi Antonio's Prison Journals."

Tukson frowned. "Never heard of them."

"So much for 'every book under the sun.'"

"It was just a stupid marketing slogan," Tukson muttered. "So, what's this book?"

"It's a philosophy, amongst other things," Blake explained. "About how the faunus can achieve equality non-violently by burrowing into systems and institutions. Apparently, anyway. That's what I've been told; I haven't actually read it yet." She decided not to mention the fact that it had an introduction by Sienna Khan.

Tukson nodded slowly. "And that's where your thinking is at now?"

"I don't know," Blake admitted. "Rainbow Dash thinks it's the way… I'm not entirely sure."

"'Rainbow Dash'?"

"An Atlas student, and a faunus," Blake explained. "She… I didn't trust her, at first. Or rather, I suppose I should say that I didn't get her. I didn't understand how a faunus could wear an Atlas uniform and not hate themselves for what they were a part of."

"And now?"

"Now… now, I kind of admire her," Blake admitted. "She's brave and loyal-"

"So are you."

"And she never hides who she is," Blake continued. "And she's comfortable with who she is. With all of who she is."

"You've had a tough life, Blake," Tukson told her. "The fact that you have some regrets doesn't make you less, and it doesn't mean that you have to be ashamed of yourself before some Atlas girl who hasn't had to make the hard choices that you've been faced with."

"I don't," Blake responded. "Well, what I mean is… I like her. And a part of me would like to believe that she's right about this. It's not as though anything else we've tried has worked out."

"Hey, show some respect," Tukson said. "Generations who came before you worked their asses off to get to where we are today. Just because things aren't perfect doesn't mean that we accomplished nothing. Do you think that I would have been allowed to own my own business right after the war finished?"

Blake was silent for a moment. "I suppose I haven't really thought about it."

"Take it from my grandpa: the answer was no," Tukson informed her. "It's fine to be mad at the injustice that you still see in the world, but don't let it drive you to despair. Things can change for the better."

"Do you remember how they changed?" Blake asked. "You say that you accomplished things, but how did you accomplish them? And if my parents' methods were getting results, then why… why did people older and wiser than me lose faith in them?"

"You ask me these questions like I was in the inner circle."

"Are you trying to convince me that you weren't?"

"I wasn't; I just knew people who were," Tukson clarified. "Anyway, you don't need me to tell you what you already knew: whatever might have been happening wasn't happening fast enough, and it wasn't happening in a way that your father could point to. What the White Fang was accomplishing, assuming that we were responsible, was changing hearts and minds; attitudes towards the faunus amongst the humans were softening every generation; at least, that's how it looked to me. Look at your friends; how many racist jackasses are there amongst them?"

Blake raised one eyebrow. "You think I'd be friends with a racist?"

"Okay, not your actual friends, your classmates."

"Ah, you mean the patronising way that adults refer to everyone a young person's age as their friend without bothering to find out if they really get along?"

"If you like, yes," Tukson conceded. "In your class, how many?"

Blake thought about it for a moment. "Only one that I know of for sure."

"And how is that regarded?"

"In a pretty negative light."

"Precisely," Tukson said. "Attitudes like theirs were once common, but now, they're rare, and not only rare but seen as vulgar and obnoxious; meanwhile, faunus who would have only been allowed into Atlas as janitors can become students now. And so it goes, things change and for the better. But that's not the kind of thing you can say when you're the embattled leader of a campaigning organisation. Changing attitudes are hard to prove, especially when it's the racists that stand out more than the people who aren't racist but don't do anything about it. People wanted laws on the books, they wanted signs taken down from shop windows, they wanted police reform. Your parents couldn't show them any of that; he couldn't even show that he was being listened to by the Councils in the four kingdoms. Sienna promised real results, to shake the kingdoms until they'd have no choice but to listen."

"Is that what's happening in Vale?" Blake asked. "Are things being shaken up?"

"You already know the answer to that, Blake."

"But I don't know if this is happening by Sienna's order or if this is Adam… letting his anger run away with him." Blake sighed. "It may be stupid, but I've already accepted that Adam is… I've accepted what Adam is. But I'd like to believe that I wasn't completely foolish for putting my trust in Sienna."

"Lots of us put our trust in Sienna at first," Tukson said. "There's no shame in it."

Blake looked into his eyes. "Do you really believe that?"

Tukson was silent for a moment, and even when he spoke, he did not respond. Instead, he said, "Did you bring that book here because you meant to start reading it?"

Blake nodded. "I wanted to see what it was like."

"I'll leave you to it then," Tukson said, rising from his seat. "The old way wasn't worthless, but it also led to Sienna Khan and Adam and what the White Fang is today and… well, it led to where we are now. So if you can find another way, if you think that it's in that book or anywhere else you might see it… don't be afraid to take it."
 
Chapter 38 - Three Stories
Three Stories​

And so it came to pass that the hand of God alighted upon the woman Mary, and the spirit moved within her, and his blessings fell upon her, and she was consumed with the divine grace.

Sunset adjusted the cushion behind her back. Since putting Sun to bed, she had returned to the common room to do what she had intended to do before she found Sun: take the books Twilight had provided and read up on what was known of magic in this world. She wasn't entirely sure what was true and what was religious embellishment, but already, she could start to see what Twilight was talking about: this was a Valish story, one of many lives of the saints from the Valish Orthodox Church, and not only did it begin in the same way as practically every other saint's life that she'd read so far, but there were clear similarities to their equivalents from Anima and Solitas. Sunset had even started keeping track, scribbling down the similarities on a notebook that sat beside her on the sofa.

All women. Age not stated but cultural context (unmarried, often under some kind of parental authority) suggests young when they came into power.

They all come into power. None of them are born with it. Possibly this is the religious element but perhaps truth to it.

Weird dichotomy: either know the previous prophet – or whatever – very well, so well as to be present at her deathbed, or they are complete strangers to one another. I have yet to see any middle ground.

In each tradition, there is never more than one at a time.


That was interesting. If her observations were correct – and if the accounts could be trusted upon this point – then it suggested that magic in Remnant was not something one was born to as a unicorn was, but rather something bestowed upon one like... like ascension, to be frank. It wasn't an exact parallel – you couldn't replace God or the gods with Princess Celestia and the holy spirit with a pair of wings or a horn and a crown and have the whole story still make perfect sense – but it was a better fit than Sunset had expected at first. It made sense, though, the more she thought about it; Equestrian magic was not, the occasional prodigy like Sunset herself aside, a catch-all or a force capable of shaking the foundations of cosmos. It had more in common with a semblance in that it reflected your personality and could range from great to staggeringly limited in its utility. It made sense to her then, when she stopped to think about it, that magic in Remnant would be something else, something on top of that, something reserved only for the chosen few.

The biggest difference – or at least the one that struck Sunset, coming from the Equestrian tradition as she did, as the most bizarre – was that none of these girls seemed to demonstrate their aptitude or worthiness for power until after it had been bestowed upon them.

But who was doing the bestowing? If it was not gods (Sunset wasn't prepared to say for sure, one way or the other) then who? If anyone?

Sunset returned to the story.

And Mary found that she had dominion over the fire and the water and that the gardens would bloom at her desire, and she was sorely afraid, for she did not understand the blessing of God. And the people were sorely afeared, for they comprehended not, and they shunned Mary for the changes that had been wrought upon her.

But then the old man came to the village of Providence and said unto the people there 'Where is the girl, Mary, daughter of a carpenter? I have come from afar seeking after her.' And the people of the village urged him to turn back, for the carpenter's daughter had been transformed, and they did not comprehend what she had become. Nevertheless, the old man asked again where she might be found, and with reluctance, they pointed him the way.

And then the old man went to Mary and said unto her, 'Be not afraid. Rejoice! For you have been chosen.'


Of course there was an old man. There was always an old man. Often, he played this kind of role, telling the chosen one what they'd gotten themselves into and giving them their mission from God, or the gods. Interestingly, he was never named. He was just an old man, but everybody seemed to trust him anyway. Was it the same man? No, that was impossible due to the broad span of time across which these stories took place; a better question to ask was it whether there was only one 'old man' at a time. After all, if all of these religious traditions were just syncretic additions to explain or cover up the existence of magic, then it wasn't too much of a leap to say that there only needed to be one old man at a time flitting across the world explaining the rules.

Although that begged the question of how he was getting around. One herald per chosen one made just as much sense, although that didn't explain why said herald didn't stick around for longer.

Who is the old man, and who told him what was going on? Sunset scribbled, before reading on.

And the old man took Mary away from Providence, and in the wilderness, he taught her to understand the blessing that had been granted to her: to command the fire and water, wind and lightning; to make the desert bloom and bring forth life where before there was only aridness; to comprehend what had been and what could be; to understand that she was now more than she had been, that she had been chosen and a great purpose now lay upon her.

As a rundown of what magic could do in this world, it was pretty comprehensive, and pretty consistent not only with Sunset's reading up to this point but also with Twilight's childhood recollection; flying wasn't mentioned, but that could easily fall under command of the wind. Sunset had already written down a list of her best guesses: based on these somewhat archaically worded statements, magic in Remnant possessed the following attributes or capabilities:

Elemental control (plus lightning)

Fertility?

Divination?


It wasn't a hard and fast list, and the only ones she was sure of were the ones that Twilight had confirmed with her childhood eyes. The rest were plausible but unconfirmed interpretations; although the narratives were consistent, they were consistent in unfortunately couching everything in turns of phrase that were open to dispute in what they actually meant. Sunset read on.

And the old man saw how she had grown as a flower blossoming amidst the weeds, and he was well pleased, saying unto her 'My child, I send thee forth to spread the good news to all nations; be resolute in the face of wickedness, be compassionate in the face of weakness; be wise, be brave, and be kind in equal measure. Go forth, for you are ready.'

Sunset frowned. This was the bit she didn't understand. Assuming that there was some force that was choosing to bestow magic upon these young women, then why? What was it in aid of? What was the point of it all?

Why does Equestria make princesses? To provide leadership and inspiration.

Yes, in the service of harmony and of Princess Celestia. In what and to what are these saints and prophets in aid?

God? Gods? If there are as many gods as there are faiths, then why are all their prophet-figures so similar? If there is no divinity but only magic, then from whence comes it and, again, to what end?

Why does the old man send her forth? What does he want or expect her to achieve?


Sunset had read a dozen similar accounts, and the accounts of what the girls did once the old man had decreed that they were ready: accounts of miracles, battles against the grimm – and in one memorable instance, with a trio of monsters who seemed themselves to have more than a touch of the magical about them – of how they had converted cities and peoples, or driven wickedness out of them; still, she felt that she was missing something. Perhaps Twilight would have a theory when they spoke again, for the existence of this system that seemed at once discernible and yet also to possess a quality that was tantalisingly outside of Sunset's reach.

I am groping in the dark... but I can feel something beneath my fingertips.

If this is magic, if magic exists in Remnant, then it is not the magic that I know; it is a kind of ascension, once granted for a purpose that is not clear and, if Twilight is to believed, still being granted albeit now hidden from the world for reasons which, again, are not yet clear to me.

By whom, and to what end? Answer those questions, and all will become clear.

And I will know how to obtain this power for myself.


XxXxX​

Even though we only got back from our last training mission a week ago, Professor Ozpin has already assigned us another one.

"Raven wasn't kidding," Yang muttered. "Two training missions in the second semester, and before they'd even gotten to Armistice Day? Professor Ozpin did push Team Stark hard." She glanced at Ruby. "You're not going anywhere again, are you?"

"I haven't heard anything about another mission," Ruby said. "Sunset hasn't talked about it; I don't think she'd keep something like that to herself, either."

"Good," Yang said.

"It wouldn't be such a big deal," Ruby said. "What's wrong with getting out of Beacon and helping people? And besides, you went on a mission too."

"There's nothing wrong with helping people, but my mission didn't involve me stowing away aboard an Atlesian military train so I could try and do what the police and the Atlesian military couldn't. Don't get me wrong, I'm proud of you for helping to catch Torchwick," – Yang wrapped one arm around Ruby's shoulders and squeezed her little sister tight and close – "but it doesn't change the fact that it shouldn't have been your job."

"Well… Professor Ozpin didn't exactly know that we were going to try and catch Torchwick on our way back, so…" Ruby trailed off, waiting for an expression of sisterly disapproval for her recklessness.

"Professor Ozpin knows more than you think he does," Yang said. "I think he knew exactly what you guys had in mind."

"You're starting to sound a little like Sunset," Ruby said. "She thinks the Professor might be up to something as well."

"Then Sunset Shimmer might be smarter than she looks after all," Yang said. "Come on; let's see what this second mission for Mom and her team was."

But everyone was up for it, and Professor Ozpin said that it was a mission that he could only trust the four of us with; I'm still not sure why that is – there must have been pro-huntsmen or even older students he could count on – but the way he said it made it very hard to refuse.

And besides, it kind of beats Professor Port's class.


"It's kind of depressing, don't you think?" Yang said. "You'd like to think Professor Port had been a good teacher when he started, even if he isn't any more." The events they were reading about took place in Professor Port's first semester, having been promoted following the retirement of his aged predecessor.

"Sunset says we're just bad students."

"Sunset says she can understand what Professor Port is trying to do," Yang corrected her. "I don't think even she says he's doing it well."

We went up to the top of the tower to see Professor Ozpin in his office. Professor Goodwitch was there too, although she didn't look too happy to see us. Professor Ozpin introduced us to a woman named Auburn; he called her an old student of his and a friend. Our mission is to escort Auburn to the village of Seclusion, where a girl named Merida lives; we're then to escort both Auburn and Merida back to Vale. Professor Ozpin won't say why this girl needs to come to Vale, and Auburn pretty much told me not to ask. Raven is suspicious about it, but I'm sure there's a perfectly good explanation. We set off at dawn tomorrow. We'll be moving through wild territory, so there's a chance of running into grimm, but if we don't go looking for trouble, then too much trouble shouldn't find its way to us.

The two sisters flipped to the next page, crossing the night and arriving at the next day in the blink of an eye.

I'm not sure what to make of Miss Auburn. She laughs a lot, and seems pleasant enough, but there's something about the way that she laughs that seems forced, strained somehow. It's like she's pretending to be a lot more genial than she actually is. She drinks a lot too; every time I look at her, she has a skin of wine in her hand; I think we're all amazed she can still function, although only Qrow had the nerve to actually call her out on it.

"Did I just read that?" Yang asked. "You read that, right? Uncle Qrow took someone else to task for drinking too much."

"I guess some people really do change," Ruby murmured, trying to remember the last time she had seen Uncle Qrow without a flask in his hand.

"Yeah, he went from calling this lady out to following her example," Yang summed up.

Anyway, as weird as it seems, she can still function, and pretty well actually. We were attacked by grimm this evening, just before twilight. More grimm than I'd expect to see so close to Vale, to be honest: beowolves and ursai. It got bad for a moment. Tai and Raven both had their auras broken, and I had to save Raven before a beowolf took her arm off.

I was going to use my silver eyes to destroy the grimm, but before I could, Auburn did something, I don't know what she did, but it didn't look like any semblance that I've ever seen. She was using fire and lightning and wind; at one point, it looked as though she was freezing leaves to make knives.

She took out the grimm, not me, and then she healed Raven and Tai's injuries; they were only minor cuts and bruises, but still, she just touched them, and they were gone. And while she was fighting, and while she was doing whatever it was that she did for Tai and Raven, it was as though I was looking at a completely different person: the real Auburn, not the one who pretends to laugh and hides who she really is. Someone serious, but maybe a little sad, too.


"The hell?" Yang said. "Does this make any more sense to you?"

"Mom… could be wrong," Ruby said, trying to steer the conversation away from the idea of magic; she didn't like lying to her sister, and more to the point, she wasn't very good at it, and she was worried that if they talked about this too long, then she wouldn't be able to keep the words 'Sunset has magical powers' from tumbling out of her mouth. "It could be a semblance that Mom had never seen before."

Ruby doubted that, however. She might have believed it before she'd started reading this diary and had Sunset confirm for her that magic was a real thing that really existed, but now… and Mom had magic too, so she probably knew it when she saw it, even if she didn't know that she knew it, if that made any sense. Had this Auburn been somebody like Sunset? Mom hadn't mentioned that she was a faunus, but that didn't mean that she hadn't been one; maybe she came from the same place Sunset did and they all had magic there.

Although what Mom had written about didn't sound like the kind of magic that Sunset did; Auburn wasn't throwing energy around or making shields by the sound of it. It sounded almost more like dust, only without the dust.

Another kind of magic, maybe? Ruby decided to ask Sunset about it; if anyone knew, then she would.

"I guess it could be that," Yang said. "Or it could be something else. Something like her silver eyes, maybe?"

"…Maybe?" Ruby said. "Maybe… maybe we should just keep going. Maybe she'll tell us… eventually."

I would have asked her just how she did that, but I had bigger problems tonight: Raven completely lost it with Qrow, yelling at him that this was all his fault, that he'd nearly gotten them killed. She said something about their family. I didn't understand it. I just wanted her to stop. I did stop her, but Qrow took what she'd already said to heart. He walked off. I went and talked to him, and I told him that of course it wasn't his fault, these things happen, that he fought well and that he's a valuable part of this team. I wish I could be sure that he believed me.

I'm worried about him. He seemed so upset about what had happened. He seemed to believe that it really was his fault, like he was a danger to the whole team, and he wouldn't even really explain why he felt that way.

I wish I knew why Raven had said what she did.

I wish I knew what to say to Qrow to make it better.


XxXxX​

The obscurity into which Rudi Antonio has fallen is as undeserved as his ideas are impractical.

Blake sat in the library, reading the Prison Journals that Twilight had gotten her. Tukson was gone, having bustled off somewhere else in the library to… well, to do his job, not to put too fine a point on it; she supposed that since Professor Ozpin had been good enough to offer him shelter from the White Fang, the least he could do was earn his keep while he was at it.

Besides, having a job made it a lot easier to explain Tukson's presence on campus; Beacon hadn't had a librarian before, but that was no reason why it couldn't have one – it had a library, after all; employing someone to maintain it made perfect sense – while the sudden appearance of a strange adult just idling around the school might have prompted questions.

Plus, Tukson would have been bored; at least this way, he got to spend time around books, which he loved, so being at Beacon probably wasn't a hardship for him.

To be honest, he might even be happier here than he would have been in Vacuo.

Meanwhile, she was sat in the library, reading Sienna Khan's introduction to the book. She had debated – long and hard – in her head as to whether she ought to bother with the introduction or not. Blake didn't really need to read Sienna Khan's words from long ago in order to understand the way the High Leader thought; she had heard her speak, received Sienna's plans and policies from her own lips, sat at her feet and learned from her. Blake thought – and not without at least some justification – that she could probably guess what Sienna Khan had to say about the idea of peacefully working one's way up the ranks of institutions dominated by humanity in order to seize control of them from within.

But people could change, or at least Blake devoutly hoped they could, and this introduction had been written a long time ago. It was possible that Sienna's views had evolved over time, for all that they had evolved for the worse. She had, after all, worked alongside her parents for quite some time before the split in the movement. It was possible that the Sienna contained within these pages was not the Sienna whom Blake knew.

And she had been curious to find out.

It wasn't looking all that hopeful.

Considering that these are his personal journals, Antonio is very guarded about his personal history, preferring to propound his ideals and philosophies. That is all very well for a philosophical and historical text, but at the same time, a cursory examination of his fate shows the naivety of his chosen methods.

It is important to bear in mind that this advocate of working within institutions, to dismantle their racism from within, was arrested as he was on the cusp of election to the Mistral Council because the other councillors were unwilling to countenance the election of a faunus to their midst. They were unwilling to even brook the possibility that their racist supremacy might be challenged by a member of the despised underclass.

And yet, Antonio, who spent the rest of his life incarcerated to prevent him from working to achieve change, would spend that time writing of the need to work within existing structures of power as he had singularly failed to do. How are we to explain this startling naivete?


Blake found herself frowning. It was impossible not to see and understand where Sienna was coming from. This was someone who had been locked up by the powers that be, and still, he advocated reform from within those same powers that had imprisoned him? Faunus had been radicalised by a lot less than life imprisonment.

And yet, at the same time, thinking about that fact – that much less severe offences had produced much more severe reactions from so many faunus – made Blake think that there must be more to it than simple naivete. After all, being thrown into prison to rot would make anyone a lot less naïve about the world works… wouldn't it? But there was a difference between being naïve and being idealistic; Ruby was the latter without being the former; she knew that the world could be a harsh place – how could she not? – but she chose to see the good in it and in those who lived in it regardless. She chose to see it as something worth preserving and protecting. Perhaps Rudi Antonio had been the same: not blind to the flaws of the system that had imprisoned him, but unwilling at the same time to write it off as so many faunus did.

She would have to read on and see, but first she would have to finish with the introduction.

However, this should not be taken as saying that the ideas that Antonio espouses in his journals are without merit. Indeed, I would recommend this book to anyone wishing to better understand the plight of the faunus, for Antonio's analysis of the structures that maintain the inequalities under which we labour is without peer.

Funny, Blake thought. You never recommended this book to me.

It is only when Antonio comes to the discussion of solutions that his thoughts become absurd.

It is true to diagnose, as he does, that it is cultural institutions more than coercive power that maintain the system of the world that so disadvantages us. We are not held in chains by the guns of Atlas alone but by the fact that all the world tells us we should be in chains and it is unnatural that we should be free.

However, Antonio places his faith to effect change in those same institutions and in changing them to change society. Ironically, in his reasons for doing so, he succumbs to the same cultural hegemony that he so presciently identifies: having been conditioned to take the status quo as normal and even desirable and to see the arc of history as a progression out of barbarism and into the light of civilisation, he cannot see the way forward save by becoming part of that progression.

In reality, if we are to challenge the institutions that constrain us, it will be by building our institutions and establishing our own culture, imbued with a deep belief in the equality of faunus-kind until it is intolerable for any faunus to accept less than what is given to a human.


But you didn't! Blake thought, with a vehemence that surprised her. It was just… the irony of it was so thick that she could almost choke upon it. Here was Sienna Khan, mistress of the White Fang, writing about how the true obstacle to the equality of the faunus was not coercive power, and yet she had refashioned the White Fang into an instrument of nothing more than coercive power! Blake had heard Gilda tell her about 'the old days' of the White Fang in Atlas, when the Belladonnas, her parents, had led the movement. The official history was one of peaceful protests that had failed to garner much support – or, indeed, any great results; that was what Blake remembered of her childhood: rallies, marches, waving placards while her parents spoke. Gilda had remembered something different: the breakfast club that had fed her and her friend – Blake wondered if that consistently unnamed friend had been Rainbow Dash and how she felt about having once been fed by the White Fang – before school when her parents couldn't; the neighbourhood watch who had kept crime down; the hall where all the moms met to talk shop and help each other out if they were struggling. All gone, under Sienna's leadership, replaced by a single-mindedly martial focus. Blake's parents might not have paid much attention to the social or self-help aspects of the White Fang, but Sienna Khan had trimmed down the movement until it was essentially the Atlas military reflected in a fractured mirror.

And now they're stealing Atlesian weapons so they can fight even more like Atlas.

If there was any building of alternative institutions going on, it was happening on Menagerie, under her parents.

Blake blinked, realising that might have been the most positive she had been about her parents' political accomplishments in… in years.

Huh.

Of all the possibilities when she sat down to read, Blake definitely hadn't been expecting that.

XxXxX​

There are many who came to be known as the Red Queens, bloody-handed women who carved a place for themselves in the unhappy history of Remnant, but there was only one who ever called herself the Red Queen: the first and vilest of them all, her real name lost to history for all that it deserves to stand alongside the worst examples of mankind as an exemplar of cruelty and malice.

What is known is that she was once a common brigand, the leader of a small band of miscreants hiding in the vast, wide lands of Mistral, preying upon helpless travellers and fleeing in terror from the knights whom the Empress of Mistral, Pyrrha, the Second of Her Name, despatched to keep the peace across the span of her dominions.


Sunset couldn't help but smile; she couldn't imagine what Empress Pyrrha, the Second of Her Name, had looked like, so her mind supplied an image of her Pyrrha sitting upon a gilded throne, looking awkward and uncomfortable as she dealt with the petitions of the court.

She'd hate it, though I daresay it would please her mother.

I wonder how many Pyrrhas there are in her family tree.


She had moved on from the lives of the saints and prophets and was now skimming through an account of the so-called Age of the Red Queens who had brought the Age of Miracles to a close with their barbarism. Twilight said that this was the point at which magic went underground as it were, and Sunset was about to find out why.

One day, this bandit queen met the Dark Mother

Sunset blinked and read it again. 'The Dark Mother'? That wasn't a name that she had come across before, and yet, it was used so casually that the author evidently presumed a familiarity with it.

Sunset scribbled the name down in her notebook as something to ask Twilight about before she read on.

One day, this bandit queen met the Dark Mother, and the witch offered her the power to do more than to raid defenceless villages and farmsteads: she offered her the power to take all of Mistral for her own.

'What would you have of me, O creature of the night, in exchange for this great gift you offer?'

'Nothing but a certain trinket in the possession of the Empress, which was rudely stolen from me in days long ago,' the witch replied.

And so, the bandit laughed, and with a light heart, she agreed to the Dark Mother's bargain, thinking little of it.


'Trinket'? An enchanted object of some kind? Sunset hadn't come across them yet either, but then, she had only just started reading.

And then the bandit hearkened to the witch and listened to her counsel with ears as keen as a fox.

And so, taking only a handful of her most skilled and trusted companions, the bandit queen lay in wait upon the road where the Prophetess Helen would be travelling, and when that good and virtuous lady came riding by, the bandits waylaid her. Though great power had been bestowed upon the prophetess, and she was bold and kind and wise beyond her youthful years, those vile vagabonds took her by surprise and cut her down, lovely as she was and virtuous. The bandit queen cut off her head, and as she smote the fair prophetess down, the gods bestowed all the power that once had belonged to her upon the villain who had laid her low.


Huh? Sunset stared at the page with such a blank expression on her face that if she hadn't been all alone in the dorm room, someone might have thought that there was something wrong with her. They couldn't… that couldn't mean what it said, could it? She was being stupid; there was another meaning to it. There… there had to be. Otherwise it meant… the text itself, the narrative voice, just called this unnamed woman a villain. She was a bandit. She cut off some poor woman's head, and for these kindnesses, she was rewarded with power? The power that, in Sunset's previous reading, had been bestowed upon the virtuous even if their virtues had not revealed themselves until after they came into the possession of great power?

You know, there are plenty of problems with the way that ascension works – starting with the fact that the gift was never bestowed on me – but at least you can't become an alicorn by murdering another alicorn! Sweet Celestia!

The image of someone cutting off Twilight's head in an attempt to ascend filled Sunset's mind and sent a shiver down her spine besides.

Killer of previous prophet gained her powers; who decides, and what criteria are they using? Sunset scribbled in her notebook. Her brow remained set with a deep furrow as she continued to read.

And when the old man came to her, as he had come to all the prophets who had come before her, to instruct her and to guide her upon her path, the bandit queen scorned him, saying unto him, 'Fall to thy prayers, old man, I have no need of thee or of thy council. The power is mine, as mine own will be mine, and I will not be the catspaw of thee nor any other living thing that breathes upon this earth. Rather, being now possessed of might unchallenged and unchallengeable, I shall from this day forth order all things as I will, yea, even across the whole of Mistral. For is it not fitting and proper that the powerful should rule, and those that have no power should slink low and obey as the sheep obey the shepherd? This world has beaten me with whips and chains, but I shall flay them in their turn with scorpions.'

Sunset found herself unable to suppress a wince. Stripped of its old-fashioned verbiage, it was the kind of thing that she could imagine herself saying, the kind of thing that she had thought more than once.

There but for the grace of Team SAPR go I. I mean, I'd hope that I wouldn't cut off anybody's head in order to get to the top, but…

She had been so lost when she came to Beacon; Atlas had done so much to grind down upon her, to step on her, to twist her with bitterness… if it hadn't been for her team, who knew what a few more years of crap might have done to her? It was an uncomfortable thought, that she might be little better than someone who was being lambasted as one of the worst monsters ever to draw breath, to feel that their words would come – or would have come, at least – very easily out of her mouth.

I am not her. I didn't become her, and I won't. My friends will keep me on the right road and will not let me fall.

My deeds will be of a nobler sort; provided they define me, I should be okay.


And so she sent the old man away, and he departed with much sorrow in his heart. It was then that the brigand cast aside her old name and began to call herself a queen, for in her pride, she believed that the power that had been granted to her had granted, too, the right to rule over all Mistral and the lands beyond. Many credulous peasants flocked to her banner, awed by her power, eager to do her service.

Either that, or they were terrified of what she'd do to them if she didn't.

Towns and villages who resisted her were put to the sword utterly, save only for a single survivor from each settlement to which the she and her host laid waste, whom they sent to Mistral to bring word of these calamities to the Empress. 'Lady, where are your warriors?' the people cried. 'Why do you not protect your people?' And the Empress Pyrrha wept to hear of the devastations that were being visited upon her subjects.

And the so-called queen began to be called the Red Queen, for she not only drenched the land in blood but herself also, and she found the name pleasing to her ears and took it for her own.

The Red Queen led her army, growing each day with villains sharked up from every low place in the land, to the gates of Argolis and laid siege to it, and at the same time, she sent a messenger to Mistral with a challenge to the Empress: to meet her in single combat before the walls of Argolis and decide the war at a single stroke with both their crowns upon the hazard.

Pyrrha the Second was fair and virtuous, with a heart so great that it burned at all the sufferings that the Red Queen was daily inflicting upon the people of Mistral. She was yet young and proud and a most puissant warrior of whom it was said that none could withstand her arms, and she determined at once to accept this challenge and put an end to the Red Queen's villainy once and for all. Yet the heart of the Emperor her husband was filled with sorrow, for he had heard the reports of the miscreant's inhuman power, and he feared she could not be withstood by any mortal.

At the gates of Mistral, where Pyrrha's horse was saddled and waiting, he held their daughter in his arms and begged her not to go forth to this battle, saying to her, 'My brave wife, this courage of yours dooms you.'

'If that is my fate, then I cannot avoid it but must meet it with all the valour in my heart,' said Pyrrha, victor of the people.

'You have no pity for your child or for your husband whom you shall soon make a widower,' he replied. 'This Red Queen shall destroy you, and would that I were better dead, for there will be no more joy for me without you, but only sorrows without ending. Pyrrha, you are wife and sister and mother to me; I have nothing but you and nobody but you; take pity on me now and on your little girl and do not go forth to a battle where there is no victory.'

And Pyrrha of the flaming hair replied, 'My lord, I, too, am filled with trepidation, but I would be shamed before the great-hearted men of Mistral and their wives in trailing robes were I now to shrink thus from the fighting like a coward. My foe has sent for me, and I cannot refuse. Nor is it in me to hide between the high walls of my city, since from my earliest youth, I have striven to excel in arms and win great glory for my house and for myself. I must go. For me, there is no other path.' And so, great-hearted Pyrrha reached out to take her daughter, but the child, frightened by the bronze of her helmet and the tall burning crest of crimson horsehair that stood tall upon it, took fright and cried out, clutching at her father's chest.

Then her great lady mother laughed aloud, and her lord father too, and Pyrrha swept the helmet off her head and took her daughter in her arms and kissed her, saying, 'Grant that this girl may like me be foremost amongst the Mistralians, as strong, and a greater leader of this city and this land; and grant that they may say of her 'she is a better prince than her mother ever was' that her father's heart may rejoice.'

And with those words, she mounted her horse and rode away and was never seen again by mortal sight. Long they looked for her coming from the high towers of Mistral, but she did not return by mountains or by sea. Instead, it was the Red Queen who arrived at the Mistral gates and laid the Empress Pyrrha's broken sword before them as a token of her victory.


Pyrrha's broken sword. It wasn't her Pyrrha, of course. Pyrrha wasn't dead, she hadn't ridden anywhere, no monster possessed of powers near to divine had challenged her to single combat, but… perhaps it was the way that the names being the same had caused Sunset to imagine the Mistrali Empress as her teammate, but what had started as the amusing image of Pyrrha sitting awkwardly upon a throne… it didn't seem so funny any more. For just as Sunset could fit the sentiments of the Red Queen, if not the language itself, into her own mouth, so too could she hear the sentiments of Pyrrha the Second echoing out of the mouth of her Pyrrha in the right circumstances. She could see her, before the gate, Jaune holding their daughter in his arms as he begged her not to go. And yet, she went anyway, turning away from him and mounting her horse, riding away, never to return. She would go, in those circumstances, just as her ancestor had. She would go because… because that was what a hero did.

And in the going, she would be lost to them.

I won't let that happen. We won't let that happen.

Pyrrha isn't going to die.
I won't let her.

Sunset started to skim through, past the bit where the Red Queen seized control of Mistral to the reappearance of the Dark Mother – whoever she was – demanding her pound of flesh.

But the Red Queen laughed at the bargain they had made, saying to her 'Get you gone, old crone; the sight of you offends mine eyes. I have no need to honour any bargains, for all that I have is the fruit of mine own strength and what my bold heart has won for me. Go, lest I should strike you down for your impertinence to make demands of me.' And the Dark Mother departed with her heart full of wrath.

Sunset skimmed a little further, to when the Red Queen died, peacefully in bed at what, all things considered, could only be called an unfairly old age.

And no sooner did the eyes of that most wicked of queens close than did her daughter stride out and say unto the people, 'The Queen is dead! I am your new queen!' But when the people cried out to her to show them her power, she could not, and all knew that the gods had forsaken her.

But the sorrows of Remnant were far from over, for in every corner of the world, new red queens would rise and set the world to bleeding.


XxXxX​

No philosopher should fear that his work will be superseded by those who come after them. Indeed, I feel that they should welcome it.

Perhaps it will seem to you who read my words in some later time that I protest too much when I say that I look forward to the day when future scholars will write in introduction to my work 'Antonio makes a trenchant point, but also talks a good deal of rot, as later events have shown'.


Blake smiled. Perhaps Rudi Antonio did protest too much, perhaps he was trying to convince himself of something that he couldn't quite bring himself to believe, perhaps he was even using the mortality of his work as a proxy to confront his own mortality in prison, but the fact that he could even write such a thing was, in its own way, quite charming. Sienna Khan had, indeed, done exactly as Antonio had wished that someone would, but somehow, Blake thought that she wouldn't be so charitable to someone daring to critique her own thoughts in such a manner.

Even more do I look forward to the day when my thoughts, set down here in this little book, have been rendered completely obsolete by events, when the faunus no longer have to struggle for equality, no longer have to fight to hold place with men, when a faunus sitting on the Council of Mistral or commanding the armies of Atlas or being headmaster of Beacon is as unremarkable to human and faunus alike as a rainy day – a rainy day anywhere but Vacuo, I hasten to add.

The smile remained upon Blake's face. Alas, that they were not there yet. Even if all of Rainbow's dreams and ambitions came true, her succession to General Ironwood's dual seats of command would still be a great novelty, a talking point, something for bigots to mutter angrily about and those who wished to be thought virtuous to point to and say how wonderful they were, that they had permitted a faunus to hold such high offices of state.

We've got a long way to go.

That day may be far off now, but I dream of it nonetheless. In this place, I have little to do but dream, and yet, the fact that I can dream – and write – makes the absence of other diversions bearable.

My cell is eight feet wide and six feet deep; walking up and down it gives me little exercise; I fear I am becoming unfit, even on the meagre diet which is the lot of a prisoner. And yet I can still dream, and in my dreams, I am free to imagine the better world which, I trust, future generations shall create by their labours.

It is my hope – a proud hope, but a hope nonetheless – but the thoughts I pen here may be of assistance in that endeavour.

All of which is a long digression from my point, which is that no philosopher should fear or be insulted if some later writer impugns him somewhat or does not accept the older notions wholeheartedly and without critique. Thought must advance, even as technology does, if society as a whole is to move forward.

All of which – forgive me if I repeat myself; I have not the services of an editor in this place – is to say that I mean no offence to Karl Feuer when I say that I disagree with him and that, in fact, a part of my intent is to explain why, in my humble opinion, he is mistaken.

Feuer was a human, but that should not stop him being read by all who care seriously about the oppression of the faunus – indeed, of all oppressed peoples, for the human who labours in the Mantle mines in these days is no less a slave than the faunus who risks death beside him.


Blake had, in fact, read Feuer, and she would even agree with Antonio's assessment: if one wished to understand, at least in part, the plight of the faunus, then Feuer's diagnosis of economic inequality could not be bettered. And yet, at the same time, she had felt as though she was reading the work of someone fundamentally mistaken in ways that she could not explain.

Perhaps Antonio was about to elaborate on that.

And yet there is a deep vein of historicism in Feuer of which we should be deeply sceptical. Feuer sees a revolution of the underclass as inevitable: at some point, the workers will tire of their oppression and rise up to establish a more equal society. That is why the working class are 'the class to whom the future belongs.'

And yet, this has not happened. The elites who control the kingdoms – at least the kingdoms of Mistral and Mantle-Atlas – have suffered military catastrophe, the collapse of the old monarchies and many of the ancient legal privileges of the noble caste, the loss of much territory to the creatures of grimm, have presided over loss of life on a scale unseen in history, have in their pride and folly brought our world to the brink of ruin, and yet there has been no revolution to tear them from their high places. Indeed, with the literal and metaphorical rise of Atlas, they seem more entrenched now than ever before. Even the Faunus Rights Struggle – to which I hesitate to attribute the word revolution – was an attempt by the oppressed not to overthrow the system but to join it, and to do so moreover at a level not greatly removed from their previous condition as slaves.


That's a little unfair, don't you think? Blake thought. I think we should give the faunus who fought in the war the credit of accepting that they knew exactly what they were fighting for.

How are we to account for this? Why is it that, far from being the inevitable, the revolution predicted by Feuer appears now to be an unlikely occurrence?

The answer is not to be found in coercive power. Turn your gaze away from those Atlesian airships! Impressive as they are, harbingers of the future of warfare as they may be, they are not the cause of our condition. Indeed, even when technology advances farther than it has presently, there will never be a fleet or army so vast as can hold a people in subjugation against their will.

No, the answer lies not in coercive power, but in the hegemony that the establishment enjoys over culture and, though culture, thought. Put simply, the ruling elites develop a hegemonic culture so that their values, self-serving though they may be, nevertheless become the commonsense values of all. So successful have they been at this project that even a faunus may identify their interests more closely with the ruling elite than with their own people striving for change.


Blake had to laugh. She couldn't help it. She knew that you weren't supposed to laugh in a library – although apparently you were allowed to play loud board games in there – and she also knew that it was probably a little cruel to laugh at a good person trying their best, but even so, she had to laugh. She had to laugh because Rudi Antonio had just described Rainbow Dash to a T in this book that was supposed to persuade Blake that Dash was right.

The unthinking, reflexive patriotism, the thoughtless assumptions about 'the way things are,' the inability to see change except in increments within an established framework, the identification of herself more with the Atlesian elite like Twilight and General Ironwood than with poor struggling faunus… it was all too perfect.

And yet, this was supposed to vindicate Rainbow Dash in Blake's eyes. Perhaps Twilight had simply misunderstood the book.

Or perhaps I need to read further on.

XxXxX​

I feel a lot better about Auburn now. It's like, now that she's shown us some of what she is – although she still won't explain; even when Raven asked her straight to her face, she wouldn't answer – she doesn't feel as though she needs to hide who she is. She doesn't laugh so much, but considering how fake and forced her laughter sounded, I think that's probably a good thing. She was a big help to me with Qrow. I talked to her, and she helped me find the words to tell him what I was trying to make him see: that he's my teammate and he matters to me.

I'm sure he matters to his sister too, even if she was mad at him.

I haven't spoken to Raven about it, but when we get back to Beacon, I'm going to suggest that she should apologise. I'm sure that her aura breaking with all those grimm around was scary, but there's no way that it could be Qrow's fault.

I can't understand why Qrow seems to believe it was. It was just bad luck is all.

Qrow seems a little better now. He still blames himself, but he doesn't seem quite as bitter about it as he was, which is something, even if it isn't perfect. I'll take it for now. I wish that I could make everything better, but if all I can do is make him feel valued in this team, then I'll do that and hope it helps. It's little enough, but from the way Qrow talks, I'm afraid it might be more than he's gotten from his family.


"We should skip this," Yang said. "It feels... wrong, reading this, don't you think? Like we're prying into Uncle Qrow's secrets."

"Yeah," Ruby agreed, feeling a weight of guilt at what they had already read settling on her stomach. "It's not like Mom, where... you know. Uncle Qrow... it doesn't feel right."

"Let's try the next page," said Yang.

We arrived in the village a little after first light, having encountered no more grimm than the ones that attacked us on the first day out of Vale. The girl Merida lives near the centre of town, and to be honest, I was expecting her to be younger. Professor Ozpin, Auburn, none of them talked about her age, but I assumed she'd be a child. She's actually older than I am, if not much. It seems wrong to call her a girl. The woman Merida.

She still lives with her mother, though, and her mom wasn't too happy to see us.

Well, when I say 'us,' I'd say she wasn't very happy to see Auburn. She barely seemed to notice us at all, but she gave Auburn a real earful about taking her daughter away. Merida herself was quiet; she seemed a little scared of something, though I'm not sure what, and I won't find out because when Auburn went inside the house to talk to the pair of them, she left us outside. There wasn't a lot to do until they came out except listen to Qrow and Tai complain about it until Raven told them both to shut up. Then there was enough for me to do in stopping an argument from breaking out. I actually agreed with Raven about that – the guys were getting a little annoying – but she didn't have to say it like that.

Since we had time, I took her aside and tried to talk to her about her attitude.

Raven didn't laugh in my face when I suggested she ought to tone it down. I guess that's something. She did look at me like I was a bit of an idiot though. We ended up talking a lot about Professor Ozpin; Raven thinks he's keeping things from all of us, but from me especially.


"She reminds me of Sunset sometimes, the way Mom writes about her," Ruby admitted. "I don't… I'm not sure that's a good thing."

"Hmm," Yang murmured wordlessly.

Ruby winced; it probably hadn't been a good idea to say that out loud. "Let's, uh, let's keep going, okay?"

"Mhmm."

I think she's right. The professor is definitely keeping things from us, and from me specifically. The difference between Raven and I is that I don't think that necessarily has to be a bad thing.

We're just kids. We're still in our first year at Beacon, and already, Professor Ozpin has shown us so much trust, even what you might call favour. He's given us training missions ahead of any other team, and unlike Raven, I see that as a good thing. I don't know about her or Qrow or Tai, but I'm here to help protect the world against its enemies, to save it if I can; if I can do that instead of sitting through Professor Port's class, I'll do it. And that's without mentioning the way that he's helping me with my powers; why would he do that unless he wanted to help me reach my full potential as a huntress? Why should Professor Ozpin tell me anything? Who am I? Who are any of us that we deserve all of his secrets?

Maybe he is using me – maybe he's using all of us – but if he is, then it's in a good cause, a cause that I would gladly be made use of in.


"See?" Ruby demanded, looking up at Yang. "Mom gets it."

Yang frowned, and a huff escaped her lips. "Ruby, I... never mind."

"What?" Ruby asked. "Come on, you can say it."

The frown on Yang's face deepened. "We have to hear this from Mom through her diary because she's not around to tell us herself," she said, the words galloping out of her mouth as though she were in a hurry to get rid of them. She grunted. "I don't know exactly what happened, and I don't know that it had anything to do with the professor or silver eyes or any of this stuff, but... I don't want that to happen to you."

Ruby stared at her elder sister for a moment. "I'm training to be a huntress, like Mom. It could happen."

"That doesn't mean I want to think about it, and it doesn't mean that I want to encourage it!" Yang cried. She shook her head. "It's not wrong of me to want to keep you safe for just a little while longer."

What does 'safe' even mean, really? Ruby wondered. She wasn't surprised at what Yang had said. Even Sunset, for all that she was really smart, didn't seem to quite get all the time what they were doing here. The way Sunset talked about glory and being heroes and their fame, it was almost as if she thought that they were going to live forever, like it hadn't occurred to her that they might die at any moment. As though she hadn't quite realised that death stalked their profession more persistently than any grimm.

Ruby hadn't been able to believe that since the day that her mom hadn't come home.

But she was here anyway, here at Beacon, learning to follow in Mom's footsteps because she knew, the same way that her mom had known, that this was right and just and necessary.

Yeah, she'd be lying if she denied that the coolness of being a huntress didn't excite her, she'd be lying if she'd said that wasn't a part of what attracted her to it, all the stories of great huntsmen in the books and all the awesome things they did. But there were a lot of cool jobs. Being a movie star was cool, being a singer was cool; being the voice actor in a cartoon was pretty cool too, but Ruby had never wanted to be one, or a singer, or even a movie star. She wanted to be a huntress because the world needed help of the kind that Ruby Rose could give it.

"Yang," she said. "I don't know what happened to Mom either; but whatever happened, I'm sure that she didn't regret a single decision that she made-"

"How can you say that?" Yang asked. "You don't think that she'd want to be here now, to watch us graduate-?"

"Not at the cost of turning her back on the right thing," Ruby replied firmly. "That's not who she was." That wasn't the person she remembered, however vaguely, and it wasn't the person she was reading about in this journal.

Yang sighed. "I don't want to see you get hurt," she said. "Is that a bad thing?"

Ruby shook her head. "I don't want to get hurt either," she replied, "but if that's what it takes... do you want to stop or shall we keep going?"

Yang hesitated for a moment. "Let's see what else she has to say."

Anyway, eventually Auburn came out and told us that Merida had agreed to come back to Vale with us. I don't understand why, or rather I don't understand why Merida decided to come; I talked to her and learnt that she used to be a Beacon student, but after graduation, she decided not to become a huntress but to come back here and defend her village instead. She wanted to be able to help the people she cared about without being given orders that would take her away from them. I think that's fair enough, even if it does mean she has to live with her mother because she can't afford a place of her own.

But it means I don't understand why she's leaving her village now. She told me that Auburn and Professor Ozpin were going to help her protect her village in a way that she never would be able to otherwise. She wouldn't say more.

I suppose it shouldn't surprise me that there are other kinds of magic that Professor Ozpin knows about and I don't; Auburn and Merida probably don't know about silver eyes.

If these are the secrets that Professor Ozpin chooses to keep from us, then fine by me; I don't need to know everything. And whatever the professor does, and whatever he tells or doesn't tell, there isn't a doubt in my mind that it's all for the greater good.


XxXxX​

We cannot build counter-institutions.

That's bluntly put, Blake thought. No wonder Sienna doesn't think you give the idea enough consideration.

One need only cast a cursory glance over the history of the kingdoms that have risen and fallen in Remnant to understand that no ruling class will tolerate the emergence of a state within a state, especially one that is composed of an underclass deprived of rights in the 'mainstream' society.

Okay, you've got a point there. A point underpinned by your own life, sadly.

Even though the supremacy of humans is established through hegemony, the elite will not hesitate to use coercive power against any challenge to that hegemony.

I can believe that too, unfortunately.

And besides, so great is the hegemony that the elite have achieved, so complete is their control over all existing cultural institutions, that any attempt to establish alternate institutions of any kind would be a hard task indeed. In what soil would these institutions root themselves, how would they sustain themselves, what audience would they find? One need only look at the – universally low – circulations enjoyed by counter-cultural journals, magazines, and newspapers, especially when compared to the popular media, to understand the scale of the proposition confronting such a path. When the ideas that underpin human supremacy are so entrenched in the popular imagination that even to suggest that the faunus ought to be given a measure of equality is to be treated both as a figure of ridicule and a dangerous menace to polite society, who would partake in new institutions that challenge everything that is commonly believed to be ordinary, respectable, or decent?

A few idealists cannot create a new culture single-handedly. There must be an audience eager to consume it, and I do not see such a thing.

No, our best chance – I would say our only chance – is to work within the strictures of the society that we seek to change.


Okay, now you agree with Rainbow Dash.

It will not be an easy task. In fact, I must confess that the march through the institutions of power and influence – dominated by elites as they, and geared as they are towards our oppression – will be a longer one than that undertaken by any general in any war ever fought in Remnant. But it must be undertaken. For the good of all faunuskind, it must be undertaken. We must enlist in the military and serve in the police forces; we must get jobs in the vast bureaucracy of state that turns the lofty directives of the Council into actions that touch upon the lives of ordinary men. We must send our children to the academies, combat and cultural. We must report the news, we must appear on film, we must write the movies and direct them too. We must ensure that there are faunus present in every part of the life of the kingdom and in the cultural life of those who live in it.

It is not enough to have a single faunus in a single room, though they be the most highly placed faunus in the room. We must be everywhere, until the outspoken amongst our enemies rage 'not another damn faunus!' Only then can we begin to change the culture.

And only once we have changed the culture can we change the world.


Blake shut the book and pushed it perhaps an inch away from her.

It was not quite what Twilight had led her to believe it was, but then, that wasn't too surprising, since apparently Twilight had never read it.

All the same, it had become something other than what Blake had accepted, something that, if it did not condemn Rainbow's ambitions, at least thought them… naïve, if that was not too unkind a way of putting. She might succeed; she might even succeed General Ironwood, but the words were written right there in black and white: it would not be sufficient to have a single faunus in a single room, though that room was the Headmaster's office or the Atlesian Council Chamber or the heart of a warship.

It was not so surprising to her that General Ironwood and Twilight didn't see it that way; it wasn't even a surprise that Rainbow Dash herself couldn't see that her rise, much as it might gratify her and her supporters, was not enough by itself. They were all, as Antonio would say, caught up in hegemony, brainwashed almost into accepting the status quo with all its flaws.

Blake meant no arrogance by it when she thought that one advantage of growing up outside the kingdoms was that she was less marinated in the culture of those kingdoms and all the assumptions that went with them.

One faunus was not enough.

Which is why it needs more.

Blake frowned. The thought had stolen into her mind unbidden, but now that it had so crept in, it proved very hard to dislodge. And who was to say that Rainbow didn't already know what Antonio had proclaimed, and that was why – or part of the reason why – she sought Blake's help in Atlas? Just because she hadn't said it out loud didn't mean that she was unaware.

One faunus was not enough. Two faunus wouldn't be enough either.

But it could be better.

Blake frowned. She hadn't made a decision. She wasn't sure what she wanted.

But she couldn't deny that… there was a temptation.

XxXxX​

In the four corners of Remnant ruled four queens. Four queens and no justice.

Never more than four, Sunset thought. She was nearing the end of the book that Twilight had given to her, and as well as the end of the text – large chunks of which she had admitted to skipping in order to get a general feel of events too far back to have been covered in history classes – she had a feeling she was nearing the end of the era of the so-called Red Queens.

There were no more prophets now, no saints performing miracles or carrying out the commands of the old man to spread the good news of whatever faith was promulgating these accounts. They were all gone now, hunted down and slain, and in their place, there were four queens – only ever four queens – who toppled ancient thrones and tore down the walls of storied kingdoms to exalt themselves above their fellow men in orgies of violent bloodshed.

Only ever four queens. Never more, never less.

Four queens, Sunset scribbled. Seems like a hard limit.

She was coming to believe that there was no omniscient being bestowing these gifts, whatever the legends might say. No God, no gods, no spirits choosing to pass down their blessings upon anyone. Receipt of the gift of magic was not the ascension to which Sunset had sought to equate it in her head; there was no Celestia looking down upon the young, ambitious unicorns and deciding that Twilight Sparkle was worthy to ascend while Sunset Shimmer was not. Had they both been born in Remnant, then Sunset could have ascended via compassing the death of Twilight, and the fact that she would have made herself a murderer would – if these legends be true – have proven no obstacle.

Sunset didn't want to believe that there was a god out there who thought it was a good idea to bestow power on the people who had just cut down the previously chosen recipients of it; if they existed, then she never wanted to meet them.

Let us assume then, for the benefit of my sanity if nothing else, that the magic is not bestowed. No one is chosen for it, except in a metaphorical sense that the magic must go to someone – there cannot be more or less than four people, all young women who have the power – but no being with a consciousness makes a decision on who should get it.

It just goes to someone.

From that perspective, the wonder isn't that it went to someone unsuited for it, the wonder is that it took so long.


How does the magic transfer? Sunset wrote. Kill equals get power. Power sometimes went to someone at the previous holder's deathbed. Other times to strangers.

Does this have rules? Power to the last person you see if eligible?


Sunset decided to keep reading, although there hadn't been any answers to this question yet, maybe there would be more to come.

The wizard

Sunset read that again. What wizard? Is that the same as the old man from before? Or an old man from before? Why suddenly call him a wizard now?

The wizard was filled with despair, as he saw the gift that the gods had given to mankind turned against them and become a tool for wickedness, and as he despaired, so did the world despair, and the grimm fed off the despair of the people and multiplied.

And the people, harried by grimm and tormented by their four queens, cried out 'Please, save us!'

And the wizard set forth to answer their prayer.

He gathered around himself five faithful companions, warriors renowned both for their skill at arms but also for their virtue, pure in heart and without a trace of wickedness in their souls: the Crimson Death, swift of foot and great of valour; the Summer Flame, whose heart did not burn less than the fire in her hair with rage at the pitiless cruelty that stalked the land; the Gilded Knight, whose courage sprang from a fearful heart; the Marble Girl, renowned for her honour as much as her peerless skill; and the Shadow, a humble faunus whom the others had freed from slavery.


Sunset's eyes narrowed. Perhaps it was unbearably egotistical on her part, but she couldn't help but feel that there was something familiar about those descriptions.

Well, I already knew that people recur across universes; is it really so surprising to see them recurring across time as well?

I wonder how many Celestias there have been in Remnant across the thousand years Princess Celestia has ruled Equestria?


Together, they made a sacred vow, that they would hold fast to their fellowship with one another come what may and that they would redeem the world from the cruelty of these queens or perish one and all in the attempt.

And so they set forth, these five heroes and the wizard who had assembled them, journeying under cover of night and hiding their faces from the spies of the queens, travelling through the lands of the grimm and enduring all the perils of the road.


Sunset skipped ahead to the interesting bit: that these six heroes had, one by one, hunted down the queens and killed them all… and that, to all appearances, was that. No new queens rose up to take the places of the dead ones. No new prophets, no more saints. The age of miracles was over, and when the Age of the Queens, too, passed, nothing else replaced it except, perhaps, something approaching modern history of the kind that would have been familiar to Doctor Oobleck. Magic was done.

And if Sunset had believed that some divine or divines was controlling who got magic, then perhaps she could have believed that; it would have made sense that any god handing out such gifts would have turned away at the sight of what had been done with them… except that they would have done that long before the wizard and his companions hunted down the last red queens and brought the time of magic to a close. And then there was Twilight's eyewitness account and the fact that there was a subculture of true believers tracking magic through the ages. All of which indicated that it hadn't gone away it had just… what? Stopped being so obvious? Why? Why would everyone who was fortunate enough to receive this gift just suddenly be okay with hiding their light under a bushel?

I wouldn't, in their place.

Why hide? Sunset wrote. Why hide your own magic? Why hide magic more generally? Was someone forcing them to hide? That made a degree more sense than all the inheritors of magic deciding on their own to keep it secret, but then, who would have the power to compel them, and over such a long span of years, how would such a policy be faithfully maintained? You'd have to assume a vast global conspiracy stretching down through the centuries, and that… that was just a bit farfetched; you'd need to be Celestia in longevity as well as wisdom in order to set up something like that.

I've been reading too long, Sunset thought. I have some answers, but mostly, what I have are even more questions.

Why do I feel as though the answers are so far away… and yet at the same time right under my nose?
 
Chapter 39 - Equivalent Exchange
Equivalent Exchange​

"You believe that Twilight's right? You really think there's more magic out there than just Ruby's eyes and all the stuff that you can do?" Jaune asked; Sunset couldn't help but note the somewhat incredulous tone in his voice.

"I'm still getting used to the idea that 'magic' is a thing outside of genre fiction," Blake said dryly.

"You should be honoured that I trust you with this instead of throwing you out of the room every time we want to talk about it," Sunset said, though she grinned up at Blake to take some of the sting off her words. "And as for your point, Jaune… why should magic be restricted to the – no offence – singular and esoteric instance of Ruby's eyes? It makes more sense that there should be at least some other kinds of magic out there too."

"I guess," Jaune said. "Although… I suppose I'm still getting a handle on this magic stuff. It's a lot to take in, you know?"

"But if my mom saw it, and if Twilight saw it, and if there's all this stuff written about it," Ruby reasoned, "that means it… it can't be a lie, can it?"

"I never said it was," Jaune said. "I just…" He laughed nervously. "It feels like I'm the only person here who found out this huge thing about the world that they'd never known before and is actually treating it like this huge thing, and if what Sunset read is true, then it gets even more huge… anyone can have… magic if they… if they…"

"If they're willing to kill for it, it seems," Pyrrha whispered.

"A system designed to attract the worst and repel the best," Blake observed.

"One hopes that there's more to it than that," Sunset muttered. "Perhaps Professor Ozpin knows, if anyone does. Since it seems that he knows a lot more than he lets on."

"For good reason, don't you think?" Blake asked.

Sunset leaned backwards, resting her hands upon the dorm room floor. "I… have yet to be convinced on that score."

"After what you read?" Blake demanded. "After what you told us? If the White Fang knew about that kind of power, there isn't anything that they wouldn't do to obtain it for themselves. Can you imagine what that would mean for Remnant? Do you honestly think that people have gotten any wiser, any better than they have since those days? Do you really think that the world can be trusted with the kind of power you're talking about?"

"I think that the world is full of power, and it hasn't ended yet," Sunset said. "What's one more power source in the scheme of things?"

"A power that can enable a bandit chieftain to bring down an empress," Pyrrha reminded her. "Is that not a thing to be afraid of?"

"A power that can be defeated in its turn," Sunset replied. She sighed. "Maybe there is a good reason for keeping this a secret, but that doesn't mean that I have to like having those secrets kept from me, okay? It feels as though every new thing that I learn in this place only opens my eyes to the fog of mysteries that surrounds us all. Am I the only person who feels that way? Am I the only person who is troubled by the fact that everything we discover only serves to increase our store of ignorance by revealing new things that we didn't know that we didn't know about?"

"But if it's for a good cause-" Ruby began.

"How can we know that for sure if we don't know all the facts about the cause?" Sunset demanded, cutting her off.

"Perhaps there comes a point when we have to trust," Pyrrha said, "as the rest of the world trusts in Professor Ozpin."

Professor Ozpin. Trust in Professor Ozpin. Professor Ozpin, the great huntsman, the youngest ever headmaster, the great man of Remnant. Trust him. Trust him to do what? To defend Vale? To serve the best interests of the Four Kingdoms? To keep us safe?

That was the crux of it all: trust Ozpin to do what? Sunset could accept, in abstract, the argument that Blake advanced: in a system that seemed to self-select for ruthlessness and concentrate power in the hands of those least deserving to possess it, then it made academic sense to hide the existence of said power, and that was true irregardless of the existence of other forms of power, like particularly strong semblances and the like. But why should Ozpin be the one in the know; he knew about silver eyes, he knew about whatever this other thing was, he knew a lot that other people didn't know, and why? Because he was a headmaster at a huntsman academy? So what? It didn't make him Celestia, with whom Sunset might have disagreed, but she could at least acknowledge that she had the ages of wisdom to back up her claims to make the big choices for other people.

And that was the other thing, the biggest thing, the thing that she wasn't sure that anyone else in the room would understand because they were all too noble for their own good but which Sunset saw as clear as day: leaving aside why Ozpin should have the right to make those decisions, what kind of decisions was he going to make? Even if you trusted him to do the right thing, that was only going to be the right thing for Remnant, or the human race, or the Kingdom of Vale, or all the human kingdoms, depending on his allegiance and the breadth of his perspective. It wasn't the right thing for Team SAPR or for the Xiao Long-Rose family or for any of them as individuals any more than Celestia's decision, right for Equestria, had been right for Sunset Shimmer.

That was the take away from Ruby's account that no one else seemed to see: that Ozpin had set Team STRQ out into peril half-blindfolded by a lack of understanding of what was really going on around them. Sure, it had all worked out okay that time, but Ruby's mom… well, she was dead, not to put too fine a point on it. It was all very well to send them out to fight grimm – that was what they were here to do – but what if Ozpin started giving them missions that brought them more and more into contact with the magic of this world, the way he'd apparently started doing for Team STRQ?

Ozpin might be acting for the greater good of Remnant, but if that greater good entailed getting SAPR killed, Sunset… she couldn't be sure that he'd do it, but she couldn't be sure that he definitely wouldn't either, and that… that was unacceptable.

Sunset's hands clenched as she glanced around the room. Ruby and Pyrrha were just the kind who would readily give their lives in a worthy cause; Jaune would probably do it too, and Blake… Blake was so desperate to atone at any cost. Sunset had to protect them, but how could she do that when she was mired in this swamp of unawareness? When she didn't know where the blows were going to come from?

I am not a piece on your board, Professor, and neither are they.

Still, it wasn't as though she could just march into the headmaster's office and demand answers, was it? No, as satisfying as the idea might be, it wouldn't actually get her anywhere. All she could do was keep learning as much as she could and hope it was enough when – if; she had to concede that none of this might actually matter – the time came.

There wasn't much more to say on the matter right now, and in any case, there wasn't any time to say it because Sunset's scroll went off. So did Blake's. They both fished them out and opened up their devices at the same time.

Sunset saw a message from Professor Goodwitch summoning her to the amphitheatre.

"The amphitheatre?" Blake asked.

Sunset looked at her. "You too?"

Blake nodded, jumping lightly off the bed and onto her feet. "I wonder what Professor Goodwitch wants?"

Sunset shrugged as he climbed up off the floor, more slowly than Blake's acrobatic display. "Improvised sparring class?"

"It's Friday afternoon," Blake pointed out. "There are no classes today."

"That's why I said it would be an improvised class," Sunset replied. "See you later, everyone; I'll let you know if it was anything important."

"Good luck, both of you," Pyrrha called as the two of them left the dorm room.

Outside, as the door closed behind the two of them, the huntresses were joined by Yang, Ren, and Nora of Team YRDN coming out of the room across the hall.

"Did you guys just get a message from Professor Goodwitch, too?" Yang asked.

"We did," Blake confirmed. "Are you three on your way over there as well?"

"We sure are," Nora confirmed enthusiastically. "At first I thought she was going to yell at us again – even though I don't think that we've done anything to deserve to get yelled at recently, but then, I don't ever really think that we deserve to get yelled at by Professor Goodwitch – but if you two are coming over as well, then I don't know what she could want."

"We'll find out when we get there," Ren said.

"Obviously," Sunset replied. "Where's Dove?"

Yang shrugged. "Not with us. Maybe hanging out with Lyra and Bon Bon? He does that a lot. If it's a whole team thing, he'll meet us there."

"Why would Professor Goodwitch want to see Sunset and I alongside your team?" Blake asked.

"Why would she want to see the three of us and the two of you?" Yang countered.

"As I said," Ren repeated patiently, "we'll find out when we get there."

They made their way down out of the dorms and across the grounds. The summer sun shone high above them, and the air was warm as they followed the paved paths between the lawns. As it was Friday afternoon, with classes ended for the week and all the students at liberty, there were various parties of students from all schools – some recognisable from their different uniforms, others wearing their field gear – sprawled out on the grass, studying or reading or talking. Laughter echoed towards the skies, unbroken even when an Atlesian airship passed overhead, temporarily blotting the sun and plunging the ground into shadow.

The five students made their way to the amphitheatre, eschewing the usual route into the changing rooms and heading straight through the main doors into the theatre proper where the spars and speeches took place.

They found that they were not the first to arrive. Professor Goodwitch stood upon the stage, and with her stood Professor Ozpin, leaning upon his cane with both hands. Team BLBL – the three remaining members of it, anyway – stood on the right hand side of the lower gallery, side by side, waiting. They had their backs to the doors, but all three of them looked around as Sunset, Blake and the three members of Team YRDN strode in.

The fourth member of Team YRDN had also preceded them there; Dove Bronzewing stood near the centre of the room, almost directly in front of the stage. He half-turned to face the others as they entered.

"Yang, Ren, Nora," he greeted them affably, each with a slight nod of the head. "Blake, Sunset."

"Dove," Blake replied softly, and Sunset could hear – and feel – the concern in her voice. What were they all doing here? What were BLBL doing here? Why had Professor Goodwitch – or Professor Ozpin, who must have instructed her to do it – brought them all together like this?

The other three members of Team YRDN – minus Dove – stood on the left of the room; Sunset and Blake took up spaces in the middle, to the left of Dove.

Sunset's tail flicked back and forth as she waited to hear what this was all about.

"Thank you all for coming," Professor Ozpin said. His tone was genial, and there was a slight smile upon his face as he ran his eyes across the assembled students. "I would have called this meeting in my office, but as you can see, there are quite a few of you." He chuckled for a moment. "Nevertheless, Professor Goodwitch has asked you all to join us so that we might discuss certain irregularities in the team roster that have arisen since the beginning of the semester and how those irregularities might be normalised.

"As you will all no doubt recall, at the beginning of Fall Semester, Miss Xiao Long, Mister Ren, Mister Bronzewing, and Miss Valkyrie formed Team Iron under Miss Xiao Long's leadership, while Miss Belladonna, Miss Heartstrings, Miss Bonaventure, and Mister Lark formed Team Bluebell, led by Miss Belladonna. This was in accordance with the standard practices around Initiation, in which partnerships were formed and teams assigned according to the relics chosen during the Initiation itself. However, as you will also remember, at the beginning of this semester… certain facts about Miss Belladonna came to light which made it impossible for her to continue as leader of Team Bluebell… at least in the eyes of her teammates." Professor Ozpin glanced at the other three Bluebells. Lyra shrank from his gaze, her expression shamefaced, while Sky shuffled his feet uncertainly. Only Bon Bon met the Headmaster's gaze without a trace of nervousness.

Sunset scowled at her. Self-righteous prig.

"The situation as it now stands is both undesirable and irregular," Professor Goodwitch declared. "Miss Belladonna is now living with Team Sapphire, all the while undertaking extracurricular activities on behalf of General Ironwood and the Atlesian forces." She managed to imbue the name of General Ironwood and his troops with a particular kind of disdain. "Team Bluebell, temporarily under the leadership of Miss Bonaventure, has only three members… and quite frankly, given your grades and performances in my class, I question whether you are capable of functioning in the field in your present state."

It was all Sunset could do to keep the grin off her face as Professor Goodwitch said that. It was harsh and rightly so. They deserved to hear that and worse. They were lousy huntsmen, lazy – Sunset had overheard Pyrrha telling Jaune about the deal she had worked out with Dove and how Lyra only trained three nights a week to Jaune's seven – and with the utter brass-necked gall to look down on Blake, though she was worth three times the whole pack of them! Imbeciles, the lot of them; it was high time that they were put in their place.

Yang raised her hand. "Professor… Professors, I get that this is about Blake's future, and I suppose Sunset's here because Blake is living with Team Sapphire at the moment, but I don't see how this affects Team Iron?"

"It affects Team Iron, Miss Xiao Long, because Mister Bronzewing has devised a solution which may resolve many of the issues thrown up by the current state of affairs," Professor Goodwitch said.

"Mister Bronzewing," Professor Ozpin added, gesturing out at the other students with one hand, "the floor is yours."

"Thank you, Professor," Dove said softly. Sunset had always thought of him as a little bit pompous, but he seemed uncertain in front of an audience now as he took a step forward so that everyone could get a better look at him. He didn't seem to know whether he ought to be addressing his fellow students or the professors, with the results that he first started turning back and forth in an effort to do both, and then ended up turned so that he was facing his teammates, side-on to the professors, and had his back to Team Bluebell. Judging by the way he started looking over his shoulder, that hadn't been his intention.

"I… I've liked being your partner, Yang," Dove said. "I was proud to fight alongside you at the Green Line last week. I've liked being a member of Team Iron; I've been proud to say that I was a member of Team Iron and that my teammates were Yang, Ren, and Nora." He paused for a moment. "I'm sure that you'll all be amazing huntsmen and huntresses and achieve all of the dreams we talked about on our first night together after Initiation." He looked at Blake. "Blake Belladonna, I… I won't pretend to know what made you do what you did, and if honourable people like Ruby and wise men like the headmaster believe that you deserve to be trusted then… then I suppose you deserve a second chance here, a real second chance.

"Lyra, Bon Bon, you… you were my first friends here at Beacon; when I stepped off the airship with no idea of where I was going or what I was supposed to do, the two of you helped me find my way. And Sky, you've been willing to listen to me and not judge and not spill… you're all my friends, and the thought of you going into battle with one man down and maybe…" He paused, trailing off. "I don't know, maybe it's just my provincial nature talking; I've been told I'm a little bit of a hayseed, but…" He scratched the back of his head with one hand. "I was brought up to always help a girl in trouble and always step in to protect a girl in danger. I don't really make a big deal of it because I'm not sure Yang or Nora really need it."

"Not really, no," Yang agreed, her tone playful and rich in amusement. "I'll let you know if I ever start getting… vapours or something."

"It's 'the vapours,'" Blake murmured, so softly that probably Sunset was the only one in the room who heard her.

"Anyway, the point is," Dove went on, "that I've suggested to Professor Goodwitch and Professor Ozpin that I should join Team Bluebell, and then Blake could take the open spot in Team Iron, since you don't have to have a problem with her." He shrugged. "Then Blake could get out of the Sapphire dorm room, and Team Bluebell would have four members. And I don't think we'd even have to change the team names." He smiled sheepishly.

Silence greeted the end of this speech, broken by Nora, her voice small and a little childlike. "So… you're leaving us?"

"I… I don't know yet," Dove said.

"But you want to leave us behind," Nora insisted.

"I want to do what's right," Dove replied.

Ren put a hand on Nora's shoulder. "And that is a very admirable thing to want; that's what any true huntsman should want."

"Is that what's going to happen, Professor?" Sunset asked.

"That depends on you students, Miss Shimmer," Professor Ozpin replied.

"Some of you students," Professor Goodwitch corrected. "You have neither choice nor veto, Miss Shimmer; you are here as a courtesy, since Blake is currently living in your dorm room."

"And she's welcome to stay there, if she wants to," Sunset declared. "Don't think that you have to clear out to go to any old place."

"Hey!" Yang cried. "Team Iron is not 'any old place.'"

"Would you be willing to lose Mister Bronzewing and gain Miss Belladonna, Miss Xiao Long?" Professor Ozpin asked. "By the same token, Miss Bonaventure, Miss Heartstrings, Mister Lark, would you be willing to have Mister Bronzewing as a teammate? And of course, Miss Belladonna, so much depends on you? What is it that you want?"

Blake hesitated, one hand clutched just above her chest, close to her heart. "I… I understand that this would be a big help to Team BLBL-"

"You don't need to think about what they want," Sunset said. "They're the ones who-"

"Miss Shimmer," Professor Goodwitch cut her off in an icy tone, "perhaps you should let Miss Belladonna finish?"

Sunset cleared her throat. "Sorry, Professor."

Blake's ears drooped a little. "I… I don't have any objection to joining Team Iron, if they'll have me, but… with my obligations to the Atlesians, then there's at least some chance that Team Iron will be left with only three members."

"I can speak to General Ironwood and see if we can't minimise the risk of that," Professor Ozpin said, "but you are correct, Miss Belladonna; the chance cannot be discounted completely. Miss Xiao Long, Miss Valkyrie, Mister Ren, you should be aware of this before you make any final decision."

"There… there's something else that you should know as well," Blake said, her voice rising for a moment to regain the attention of everyone in the room. "I… Rainbow Dash has asked me to transfer to Atlas at the end of this year. I… am considering it."

Sunset wanted – she so, so wanted – to take a picture of Bon Bon's expression when Blake said that. Lyra looked pretty startled to hear it too, but Bon Bon looked as though she had just bitten into a sandwich only to find that there were flies inside devouring the rancid meat. Oh, how it must gall her, Miss High and Mighty, that the team leader she had spurned and rejected as unworthy of her had been offered a place amongst the clouds of Atlas.

Since she couldn't really take a picture in front of the headmaster, Sunset settled for trying to fix the image in her memory instead.

"Miss Dash has asked this of you," Professor Ozpin murmured. "Has General Ironwood said anything about it?"

"We've talked about it," Blake said. "I think that he'd support the idea if I decided to go along with it."

Professor Goodwitch sniffed. "James continues to find ways of surprising me with his behaviour. Just when I thought that he couldn't-"

"Now, now, Glynda," Professor Ozpin interrupted quietly. "James merely wants what we all want: for all of our students to flourish to their full potential. If he believes that Miss Belladonna will do better at Atlas than Beacon, well… that is a matter upon which reasonable people might reasonably disagree. You say that you are considering it, Miss Belladonna?"

"Yes," Blake said, and her voice shook only a little. She glanced at Beacon's headmaster. "I mean no disrespect-"

"You needn't worry about hurting my feelings, believe me," Professor Ozpin said lightly. "I can acknowledge that Atlas is a fine school, and that some fine young men and women have emerged from it, without losing a scintilla of the pride I feel in Beacon and its students. You must do what is best for you, Miss Belladonna; so long as you find your path and walk it for the betterment of all mankind, then all of this great edifice erected for your education has been worthwhile. It has no other purpose."

Blake bowed her head. "That's very kind of you to say so, Professor," she murmured. "But, again, if I do go to Atlas at the end of the year, then Team Iron will be left with only three members."

"True enough, Miss Belladonna," Professor Ozpin acknowledged. He leaned upon his cane, and a sigh escaped his lips. "Sadly, that state of affairs is not unheard of amongst second year teams and higher. We do what we can to protect our students, but this world and this life are dangerous, and sometimes, our best is not enough. Team Iron would, in some respects, be more fortunate than others in a similar position."

"More importantly," Professor Goodwitch added, "there is always the possibility that a student from Shade or Haven, or perhaps even the great Atlas," – she laced the name with a touch of acid – "may decide to transfer to Beacon at the end of this year."

"Also a possibility," Professor Ozpin concurred.

"And it's a position that Team Bluebell are in now, and with less…" Dove trailed off. He glanced at his new teammates, or at those who might soon be his new teammates. "I mean, no offence, guys, but I think Yang, Ren, and Nora could handle themselves a lot better without a fourth guy than you."

"I think you're probably right," Lyra conceded in a voice that was half mutter, half groan.

Yang glanced at Dove for a moment, then turned her head towards Ren and Nora. She drew them close, the three other members of Team Iron huddling together, heads bent, speaking in whispers so that Sunset couldn't hear them.

"You don't have to take this just because they're offering it to you," she said.

A smile played upon Blake's features. "You want me to stay that badly?"

Blake's tone was fondly mocking, almost playful, but Sunset answered her in earnest. "I don't want you to go."

"It's a good plan from Dove," Blake insisted.

"Good for Team Bluebell; I'm not sure I'd say the same about Team Iron," Sunset replied. "And it's not-"

"Not good for me?" Blake guessed. "I don't think it's bad for me, either." She smiled. "You... I'll always be grateful for you giving me a place to stay when no one else would, but I don't belong in your bed, or even in your room." She paused. "Besides, I'm only moving across the hall."

"For now," Sunset said. "Is this what you want?"

"I… I don't know what I want yet," Blake admitted, "but I think that this might be a good start."

Team Iron – minus Dove – had finished their impromptu discussion. Yang looked at him. "This is what you want, isn't it?"

Dove didn't reply.

"Hey," Yang said. "Be honest. Don't worry about hurting anyone's feelings; just go for it."

Dove nodded. "This is what I want, not because-"

"Hey," Yang said, cutting him off with one raised hand. "You don't need to explain. You don't owe me – any of us – a word, and besides, I get it." She grinned. "So go get 'em, tiger." She looked up at the professors on the stage. "We're willing to take the risk of Blake being away or even leaving. Dove's right; we can handle it on our own, but…" Now, she turned her gaze and full attention to Blake. "If you want the spot, you can have it."

Blake smiled. "Thank you," she said. "I want the spot."

"Of course you do," Nora cried. "The coolest team in Beacon!"

Ren bowed his head. "I hope that our duties give us the chance to work together."

"So do I," Blake agreed.

Yang grinned. "Welcome to Team Iron, Blake."

"Thank you again," Blake said. She offered her hand to Sunset. "And thank you, for putting up with me and for always having my back."

Sunset pulled Blake into a hug, wrapping her arms around the other faunus and holding her tight. "Just so you know," she whispered into Blake's ear, "there'll always be a place across the hall for you when you ruin this chance like you did the other."

Blake snorted. "I'll keep that in mind. Don't joke; I might actually hold you to that."

I wouldn't mind at all if you did, Sunset thought.

XxXxX​

Blake sat down heavily upon her bed. Once all her stuff had been moved into her new dorm room, Team SAPR had insisted – with no possibility of refusal – that she had to come out with them to Benni Haven's for a goodbye, as though she was actually moving to Atlas instead of just across the corridor. Her new teammates had been very accepting about it, and honestly, Blake wouldn't have refused even if she'd had the chance; it was a nice gesture on their part, one of a series of nice gestures from Team SAPR since her secret had come out and even before it. They had always been there for her, whether she deserved it or not, ever since she had run away from Rainbow Dash; the chance to spend another evening in their good company, with good food to boot, was too, well, too good to pass up.

And it had been a good night. A very good night. Ms. Haven had even broken with a custom and taken a picture of the five of them with Fluffy, since Blake was – or had been – an 'honourary' member of Team SAPR for just a little while.

Blake didn't know what the future held for her – either in the sense of her immediate future with Team YRBN or in the sense of her larger future and the choice between Beacon and Atlas that she had yet to make – but she would always be grateful for the kindness of Team SAPR.

Nobody had been that unconditionally kind to her since… since she had turned her back on her parents.

The trouble was that the food at Benni Haven's was very, very filling, and her stomach was now feeling just a little bit delicate.

Yang strode into the dorm room. "Hey," she said.

"Hey," Blake murmured, one hand over her stomach.

Yang chuckled as she sat down on the bed next to Blake – unlike in SAPR's dorm room, the beds weren't arranged by strict name order; Ren and Nora slept side by side, and Yang and Dove had sat on the other side of the room; now it was Yang and Blake. She kicked off her boots and crossed her legs on the scarlet quilt beneath her. "Did you guys have a good time down there?"

"It was very nice, at the time," Blake said, with a slight touch of a groan. "The company was wonderful, but-"

"But you ate too much?" Yang said, with a grin on her face that could have devoured many unpleasant things.

"When Ruby is begging you to share a chocolate chip sundae with her, it's very hard to say no," Blake pointed out.

Yang let out a bark of laughter. "Yeah, don't I know it."

Blake's lips twitched slightly. "You're very lucky, to have-"

"A sister like her, yeah, I know," Yang said. "Of course, if I was really lucky, we'd be on the same team together."

Blake frowned. "I… I don't have any siblings, so I can't imagine what it's like for you, but Sunset-"

"Is becoming more of a sister to her than I am." Yang finished.

"That's not true," Blake replied. "I was going to say that Sunset takes care of her; they all do. Not that she really needs it. She's brave, capable; you should be proud of her."

"I am proud of her," Yang insisted. "I just…" She paused, staring intently at Blake. "How much have they told you?"

Blake hesitated. Yang asked how much Blake had been told, but Blake found it difficult to answer without knowing exactly what Ruby had told Yang. Asking that question, however, could seem facetious at best and downright insulting at worst, so she tried – she had no choice – but to guess what it was that Yang knew. She guessed that Ruby would have told Yang everything that pertained to her, but nothing more than that; she wouldn't have told Yang Sunset's secrets. "I know about her eyes," she said.

Yang nodded. "I thought you might. Hard to keep secrets from someone in the same room."

"Do Ren and Nora know?"

Yang's smile was a little wan. "I said it was hard, not impossible. Especially when you've no one to talk about it with where they might hear. No. They don't know. I don't… what would I tell them, that my sister has magic eyes? I like them both, but I don't want them to think I'm nuts. And I'm not sure that this is their business."

"But you were fine with Ruby telling her teammates and making it their business?" Blake asked.

"Ruby can trust who she wants to trust, and so can I," Yang replied.

Blake's brow furrowed. "Are you trusting me?"

"Ruby already made that choice for me, a little bit," Yang declared. "But… yeah, I think I trust you."

"Why?" Blake inquired. "I mean… why am I even here? Why do you want me here? Why were you so quick to offer me a place here?"

Yang affixed Blake with the gaze of her lilac eyes. "Because… because nobody should have to be alone, abandoned. Everyone should have… a place where they belong. A place they can call home. That's how I feel, anyway, and while I can't speak for Ren or Nora, I… I think that they feel the same way that I do."

"That's… that's incredibly generous of you," Blake murmured, "but all the same, you gave up one of your teammates-"

"What was I supposed to do? Tell Dove no, we couldn't spare him?"

"You could," Blake said, thinking to herself that Sunset probably would have said exactly that if Ruby or Pyrrha or even Jaune wanted to switch teams.

"Maybe," Yang allowed, "but I don't think Dove would have been very happy with me if I did. If this is what he really wants… it's better this way. If he feels that strongly about it, then who am I to stand in his way? I'm his team leader, not his owner."

"No, I suppose…" Blake trailed off for a moment. "I hadn't thought about it like that before." She paused. "Do you think they'll be okay?"

"Who?"

"Dove and Team Bluebell," Blake explained. "Or just Team Bluebell now, I suppose."

"I don't know about the rest of them, but Dove's got it where it counts," Yang assured her.

"Are you sorry to lose him?"

"Nah," Yang declared, and whether she was lying or not, Blake appreciated the fact that she seemed perfectly sincere. "I've seen you in sparring class. You're good. Not as good as me, maybe," she added with a chuckle. "But you're good. You'll do great as part of this team."

"If my situation allows," Blake murmured. "If… if I… you know."

"Don't worry about it," Yang said. "You do what you have to do right now, and later, we can worry about what'll happen if you decide to leave. You're really considering it then? Atlas?"

Blake nodded. "I really am. I haven't made my mind up to say yes, but I haven't made my mind up to say no, either."

"Why?" Yang asked. "I mean, if you don't want to talk about it, then just say so. I don't mean to pry into your business; I'm just curious, if that's okay."

"It's fine," Blake said, yet nevertheless, she paused a moment before answering. In fact, she did not answer, save with another question. "Yang, what is it that you want to do when you graduate?"

Yang shrugged. "The usual huntsman stuff, I guess. Saving people, hunting things; the family business."

Blake nodded. She had thought as much. "I… no offence, but I'm not sure that's enough for me."

Yang stared at her. "You're not sure that you can go out beyond the kingdoms to fight the monsters and then come back to find the monsters inside the kingdoms as high and mighty as ever."

"Exactly," Blake whispered. "If only people who deserved salvation were saved, then Ruby would be wandering the streets of Vale all by herself, but I think that we ought to at least try to make a world that doesn't deserve to be consumed by the grimm."

"No argument there, but you think Atlas is the place for that?"

"I think that in Atlas, a huntress can become powerful in ways that she can't in the other kingdoms."

"You mean in Atlas, a soldier can become powerful," Yang replied. "Because let's be honest, the reason why Atlas is different is that its huntsmen are military."

"Is that a bad thing, do you think?"

"I don't know, but you might find it isn't what you're used to."

"I've been in a military of sorts before," Blake pointed out.

"Right," Yang muttered. "Of course you have. And I guess you have a point; there isn't so much thing as a bigshot huntress the way that there are generals and stuff in Atlas. And if that's what you want, then… but do you really believe it? No offence, but it's Atlas. Do you think it can happen?"

"I don't know," Blake admitted. "That's what… I suppose you could say that's what's holding me back. It might be the best way to change the world, it might even be the only way, but I don't know if I have it in me to make that kind of sacrifice for nothing. That… and the fact that it's Atlas, and although the Atlesians I've met have been much better people than I expected, I haven't really met very many Atlesians." She sighed. "I just don't know. I haven't figured it out yet."

"You will," Yang assured her.

"Are you sure?"

"Absolutely," Yang replied. "When the end of the year comes, you'll know where it is you need to go. You might not even make your mind up, but you'll know in your gut." She grinned. "Speaking of the gut, do you have any room in there?"

Blake's eyes widened. "You want to fill me up more?"

"What do you think Ren and Nora are doing?" Yang asked. "They're cooking. Well, Ren is cooking, Nora is… keeping him company. Dove's coming back too."

"Really?"

Yang nodded. "Ren suggested it: we say farewell to one member of our team and welcome a new one."

Blake smiled. "That… that sounds lovely," she admitted. "But I can't guarantee that I won't throw up if I eat any more."

Yang's cackling laughter echoed off the walls.
 
Chapter 40 - The Infinite Man
The Infinite Man​



"Do you want to grab a table and set up while I grab our stuff?" Sunset asked, as the door of the A & P ice cream café shut behind them.

Cinder started towards the nearest table – which happened to be one of the ones near the window – even as she said, "I question why we're here."

"You know exactly why we're here; we're going to start work on our coursework for Legends class," Sunset replied.

"Obviously," Cinder said. "But why are we doing that here? We could have just as easily started work in the library, or in one of the dorm rooms for that matter."

"Neither of those places has ice cream," Sunset said flatly, because what other explanation was needed, really? "Have you really never gone to a coffee shop or the like to do your homework?"

Cinder stared at her blankly. "No."

"You poor, deprived girl," Sunset murmured. She had gotten a bit out of the habit of it here at Beacon, if only because it was such a long way to go to get into Vale, but she had come to places like this all the time in Canterlot. There was one particular place that she'd really liked, an open plaza in the Haymarket with a lot of food stalls and the like surrounding it, always quite busy, but if you knew the right time to get there, you could usually grab a seat. Sunset would head over there frequently – not least because it was close to the best antique bookshop in Canterlot – and get ice cream from a stall run by a unicorn named Strawberry Swirl who wore a red and white striped apron and who always acted as though Sunset Shimmer coming round was the best thing to happen to him all day. Sunset had been so egotistical that she'd assumed her presence was the best thing to happen to him all day. It had been a nice place to work, that plaza in the Haymarket. As nice as anywhere else she had put down her books and quill in Canterlot… weather permitting, obviously.

Sadly, it was a tradition she had found harder to keep up in the Canterlot of Remnant; the looks of disdain had been too much to put up with, in the end. But Vale – that dust shop owner aside – hadn't been so bad in this regard, so she had hopes for this place.

If her hopes were disappointed, then Jaune and Pyrrha would be hearing about it in the most strenuous terms.

Cinder looked as though she were trying to stifle a laugh. "Yes, truly the wretchedness of my existence has been thrown into stark relief by the fact that I never learnt to do my schoolwork in a café." She stood over the table, one hand resting lightly upon it but, as yet, making no move to sit down. "You know, the library may not have ice cream, but it does have all the books we may need."

"I have books right here," Sunset said, tapping the pack slung over her shoulder and getting a satisfying thump out of the books contained therein, "and besides, this is just our first session to brainstorm ideas. We don't need to worry about research just yet."

Cinder shrugged. "Space could be an issue."

"Space is not going to be an issue," Sunset insisted. "Honestly, I decide to take you somewhere nice, and all you do is quibble about it."

"Oh, so this is your treat?" Cinder asked. Her teeth flashed for a moment. "Well, in that case," – she sat herself down at the table, leaning back in her chair – "please, don't let me stop you spending your lien on me."

Sunset made a sound that was half sigh, half chuckle. "I knew you'd come around. What do you want?"

Cinder didn't even bother to look at the menus above the counter. "I'll have two scoops of vanilla and a small Atlesiano."

Sunset blinked. "That's it? You know you don't need to hold back on account of saving me money."

"I'm not."

"You could have fooled me," Sunset replied. "That can't be all you want."

"What should I want instead?" Cinder asked. "What's good here?"

"I don't know; this is my first time," Sunset admitted. "Jaune and Pyrrha went here on a date a couple of days ago; they said the pie was good. I was going to go for a sundae, though." She grinned. "Do you want to share a sundae? It'll be better than two scoops of vanilla, I guarantee it."

Cinder hesitated for a moment, before a slight smile teased its way to the edges of her mouth. "Alright, go ahead," she said. "Although I warn you, I've always had a little bit of a problem when it comes to taking only my fair share. Somehow, a fair share always turns out to be… everything."

Sunset chuckled. "I'm sure I'll hold my own," she said, pulling her satchel off her shoulder and slinging it over the arm of the other chair, leaving Cinder to watch over it as she made her way to the counter. While she and Cinder had been arguing, someone else had come in and gotten up there first, but Sunset didn't mind the wait too much because it gave her a chance to study the menus on the wall above. Jaune and Pyrrha had said that this place was nice, and the ice cream on the other side of the glass case seemed pretty nice too, even if Sunset wasn't entirely sure about the décor. Was there really a need for so many cows? She tried her best to ignore them all and focus upon what was available to eat. The hot drinks were pretty much as she had expected, but some of the hot chocolates seemed as nice as Jaune and Pyrrha had made them sound. She turned her attention to the sundaes, her green eyes widening as she saw that they were offering a vanilla, raspberry whirl, and strawberry sundae.

That had been her favourite order back in Canterlot, the real Canterlot. To be honest, it had been pretty much her only order, so regular that Strawberry Swirl had known to start getting it ready when he saw her coming.

It beckoned to her, like a little slice of home.

"Thank you," the girl behind the counter – Sunset wondered if this was the same girl that she'd been told about, the girl from Jaune's past – said to the customer in front of Sunset as he departed with his tray. To Sunset, as she shuffled forwards, she said, "Good morning, how can I help you?"

"I'll take a vanilla, raspberry whirl, and strawberry sundae for two, with wafers and chocolate flakes," Sunset said on instinct, only adding the 'for two' in a brief remembrance that this time, she had someone else with her. "And a… medium mocha and a small Atlesiano." It was a little early in the day for a lavish hot chocolate on top of everything else, and the little touch of coffee would help to keep her wits sharp. She decided that she would respect Cinder's drink order; they could always get refills if they were here for long enough.

"Eating in?" the girl behind the counter said.

"Yeah," Sunset said, biting back the urge to point out that of course they were eating in; that was why Cinder was sitting down. She didn't want this girl to spit in her coffee.

"Okay, if you wait here, I'll get all that sorted out for you as fast as I can. In the meantime… that's fourteen lien."

Sunset paid, sliding across a couple of cards. "So," she said, "you're Jaune's friend?"

The girl's eyes widened. "You know Jaune? Jaune Arc?"

"I'm his team leader," Sunset declared. "And you're Miranda Wells?"

"Sure," Miranda said, her tone a little wary without being unfriendly. "Jaune… told you about this place?"

"I hope it lives up to his recommendation," Sunset said.

Miranda laughed. "I'll try my best," she said. "So, are you here on a date, too?"

"A d-" Sunset glanced around at Cinder. "Oh, no, we're here for a study session."

Miranda's eyebrows rose. "A study session. In here?"

"You're a student, right?"

"A Literature student, yeah."

"You've never sat in a café and gotten some work done?"

"I work in a café," Miranda replied. "I do my work in my dorm room."

Sunset rolled her eyes. "So uncivilised."

"Hey, if it works for you, then go for it," Miranda said. "I didn't mean to… I might even try it myself sometime. I should probably stop talking and get your order before you ask for your money back, shouldn't I?" Nevertheless, she made no move to actually take their order, but rather lingered at the counter, watching Sunset before she leaned forwards, her elbows resting upon the work surface. "So, you're Jaune's team leader? Does that mean you're sort of in charge of him?"

"It means exactly that I am in charge of him," Sunset affirmed.

"Right," Miranda said softly, nodding her head absently. "Um, please don't tell her I said this, but… that girl, Pyrrha… she's really into him, isn't she?"

Sunset folded her arms. "Sure, she's got it bad, what about it?" You don't still think you're in with a chance, do you? Miranda Wells was pretty enough, and in a small town, she might even be thought of as a beauty, but put next to Pyrrha Nikos, and there was no comparison at all, even if you were so shallow as to only judge by looks. More to the point, if anything – or anyone – did come between Jaune and Pyrrha, then Pyrrha would be heartbroken, and the team would be split in two. Sunset wasn't about to let that happen.

"It's just that… when you really care about someone, it can make you… have you heard of 'unreliable narrator'?"

"Yes."

"It's like that, but with people you love, don't you think?" Miranda asked. "My point is… is Jaune any good? Pyrrha told me he was, pretty much, but she-"

"Cares about him too much, is that what you think?" Sunset asked.

Miranda shrank back a little. "Maybe," she confessed. "I just need someone more… is he any good?"

"Even if he wasn't, I wouldn't tell you," Sunset declared. "You see, Pyrrha may be his girlfriend, but I'm his team leader, and that means that when it comes to my team, I'm the most unreliable narrator there is, because I've got the best team in Beacon, and I'll fight any other huntsman who says different." She grinned. "But you don't have to take my word for it: come the Vytal Festival, keep your eyes open for Team Sapphire, spelled S-A-P-R, and you'll see for yourself just how good Jaune Arc is."

"'S-A-P-R,'" Miranda repeated. She blinked. "You realise that also stands for Se-"

"Yes, I know, although I wish I didn't," Sunset said rapidly. She considered herself very fortunate that nobody had stooped so low as to make jokes about it.

"Right, sorry," Miranda said. "I… I really will get your stuff together now."

She turned away, leaving Sunset to watch over her shoulder as Miranda busied herself with the getting of drinks and the making of sundaes. A sundae, anyway. The sundae itself was a delicious-looking concoction of ice creams, whipped cream, strawberry compote, and crushed shortbread biscuit, garlanded with lashings of red sauce and sliced strawberries. It was a riot of red, white, and pale yellow against which the two brown chocolate flakes stood over very starkly, but Sunset wanted them anyway. The two cups of coffee steamed on either side of the cold glass when they were all placed upon the tray.

"Enjoy," Miranda said.

"Thanks," Sunset replied, picking up the tray with both hands and carrying it back to the table where Cinder waited. "Feast your eyes on this, Miss Two Scoops of Vanilla," she declared as she set it down upon the table.

Cinder regarded the sundae for a moment. One obsidian eyebrow rose above a fiery eye. "I had no idea that you had such a sweet tooth," she murmured.

"Where I come from, everyone has a sweet tooth," Sunset replied as she sat down. "It's culturally illegal not to."

"Really?" Cinder asked in an arch tone. "How very convenient for you."

Sunset grinned. "Just try some."

Cinder picked up one of the small spoons dug into the sloping sides of the sundae and scooped out a small amount of sauce-covered raspberry ripple ice cream onto it. She placed it into her mouth. Sunset took a slightly larger spoonful, incorporating vanilla and raspberry, and let it set her teeth to shivering as she waited for Cinder's response.

Cinder nodded, although there was no great store of enthusiasm in her voice as she said, "I see why you wanted me to try this." She paused. "You spent a little time talking to the girl up there."

"She's an old friend of Jaune."

"Jaune has friends?"

"Stop it," Sunset said, her tone acquiring a warning edge.

Cinder chuckled. "You can't take a little mild teasing?"

"You can tease me; leave them out of it," Sunset told her.

"Suit yourself," Cinder acknowledged. "All the same, what did you have to talk about with a friend of Jaune Arc?"

"She wanted an honest assessment of his skill level."

"Did you give her one?"

"Of course not, I'm his team leader," Sunset said. "But that's what we talked about. That, and she thought we were here on a date, absurdly."

Cinder's eyebrows rose. "Is there something absurd about it?"

"Oh, please," Sunset said. "I'm so out of your league, it's not even funny."

Cinder smirked. "Of course. We must all know our places and our limitations, mustn't we? What would the world come to if we all set our heights as high as ambition?" She picked up her coffee and drained half of the small cup in a single sip.

Sunset's eyes widened. "Sun and moon, Cinder, what's your tongue made of?"

"Hmm?"

"How did you drink so much of that without burning your tongue?" Sunset repeated.

"Oh, is it hot?" Cinder asked, with a shrug of her shoulders. "I can't say I really noticed."

"Okay," Sunset said, slowly and deliberately, before she took a much smaller sip of her own coffee, and only after she'd blown on it first because it was very hot. The contrast of that and the ice cream was very pronounced, going from one to the other, but in a good way, pretty much. Sunset took out her copy of Fairy Tales of Remnant from the satchel hanging off the arm of her chair, her hands glowing as she levitated book, notepad, and pen onto the table in front of her as she pushed the sundae into the middle of the table – where they could both reach it – and her coffee to one side. "You're okay with something from the book, right?"

"Fine by me," Cinder answered, as she got out her own copy of Fairy Tales. "I'm a little surprised that it's fine by you. I thought that you might want to reach for something a little more… exotic."

"Wandering into the weeds is fine if you can find your way back again," Sunset explained. "I'm not sure I'm familiar enough with any off-book stories to do them justice in a piece like this." She remembered what had happened to Jaune and Ruby in their history quarter-terms in first semester, when the advanced approach that Sunset had led them on had exposed their weakness on the course basics. She wasn't going to let that happen to her.

"As I said, it's fine by me," Cinder repeated. "Not least because the story I was hoping we could tackle is in the book."

Sunset took another mouthful of ice cream. "Go on," she prompted.

Cinder leaned forward a little. "I was thinking that we could take on The Infinite Man." She drained the rest of her coffee.

"You want another one?" Sunset asked.

"Not right now," Cinder said. "So, what do you think?"

Sunset nodded. "It is an interesting story. There are a lot of different ways to look at it, which means that there is a lot to write about it."

Cinder rested her elbows on the table top. "What do you think about it?"

Sunset thought about it and covered her thoughts by taking first a sip of her mocha and then a bite out of her chocolate flake, and while she chewed, she pondered the matter. The Infinite Man was the tale a man possessed of… of magic.

Sunset stopped mid-chew, though she swiftly resumed, lest Cinder notice anything amiss. In the books that Twilight had given her, magical abilities belonged exclusively to women – to four women at a time – but here was a tale of immense magic in the hands of a man. How had he come by it, and what made him so special? Could he be the Old Man in the tales of the prophets? The wizard who had assembled the five heroes to hunt down the Red Queens? Or was it, perhaps, just a story?

Why should I take one set of stories as real and dismiss the other as just a story?

Of course, the Infinite Man was not just a powerful wielder of magic – he was also immortal, after a fashion, hence the name – but it was a strange sort of immortality, to Sunset's mind. She was, of course, no stranger to the notion: as every little colt and filly knew, Princess Celestia had lived for over a thousand years and ruled Equestria for nearly as long without appearing to age at all in all that time. But the Infinite Man did not endure forever – it would have been a very different story if he had – rather, he died and then reincarnated with a new face, one that even those closest to him did not recognise.

That sounded just a little farfetched to Sunset's way of thinking; perhaps it was arbitrary of her to dismiss the possibility, but having seen nothing like it in this world or Equestria – and the fact that, unlike the prophets or red queens or whatever you wished to call them, this man only appeared in one story – Sunset was inclined to call it a little bit of poetic license. Perhaps it had been based upon the sages who recurred throughout mythology, but Sunset doubted they had actually been the same person.

Cinder cocked her head to one side. "Sunset?" she asked. "Is something wrong?"

"No," Sunset said quickly, before she started to look even more insensible than she did now. "I was just thinking."

"A useful way to pass the time," Cinder observed. "What were you thinking about?"

"I was thinking," Sunset said, "that the Infinite Man considers that he makes many mistakes, but to my mind, he only makes one: the decision to throw the fight." It was, to Sunset's mind, a completely inexplicable moment for all the effort that the story made to explain it. The Infinite Man, over the course of two lifetimes, had established a mighty organisation, a band of followers who were described as being as gods in their own right and who dedicated themselves to the protection of the innocent and the advancement of the cause of righteousness. Yet these mighty warriors, these god-like men and women, had found themselves caught flat-footed when attacked by a crew of lawless resolutes led by a duel-wielding swordswoman bent on defeating a god, presumably for the satisfaction of her own ego. The Infinite Man had striven against her at first, but then, he had willingly laid down his life, baring his throat for her sword on the promise that she would depart and spare his followers.

Sunset had not been at all surprised to read on and find out that she had not spared the man's followers.

"He trusted in the honour of his enemy," Sunset continued, "and surprise, surprise, she had none. It was entirely foreseeable – no, it was obvious – that she would betray him like that."

"You don't think much of the reasons given, I take it?" Cinder murmured.

"The fear of collateral damage?" Sunset snorted. "Everyone died anyway, how bad could it have possibly gotten?"

Cinder smirked. "True enough, I suppose."

"And that's another thing that doesn't make sense," Sunset continued. "This group that the man sets up, they are supposed to be great warriors; it says so, in the story, they trained to become like gods and then they went out and fought the monsters, just like huntsmen do today; their legend grew exponentially over time, their numbers swelled as more and more people flocked to join them. And yet, in a single night of misfortune, they are broken, annihilated even, and by what? A rabble of scum from out of nowhere?"

"You find that strange?" Cinder asked curiously. "You find that difficult to explain? I'm a little surprised; it makes perfect sense to me."

"How do you mean?" Sunset asked.

Cinder was silent for a moment. "I think I will have that refill now," she said and got up from the table, leaving Sunset to wait and finish off some more of the sundae – Cinder wanted to get in quick or there wouldn't be much left – before she returned with another, larger, cup of coffee.

"Now," Cinder said, "where was I?"

"You were about to explain the fall of the man's followers," Sunset prompted.

"Ah, yes," Cinder said, stirring her coffee idly with a long spoon, scraping it across the bottom of her cup with a scratching sound that persisted as she spoke. "In a way, you answered the question yourself: they were just like huntsmen."

Sunset's eyes narrowed. "I don't follow."

Cinder continued to stir her coffee, the spoon making a wince-inducing sound as it scraped the cup. "Four academies: Shade, Haven, Atlas, Beacon. I'm sure that when they were founded, the first students to walk through the halls were just like the girl in the fairy tale who first convinces the Infinite Man to teach her: brave, honourable, committed to the fight. I'm sure that the Circle was once as mighty as its reputation suggested, just as the huntsmen who defend our kingdoms were once heroes worthy of song and story. But this story covers a span of generations: the young girl is a middle-aged woman by the time the Infinite Man returns from death the first time, and he lives another life before all that he worked for turns to ashes before his eyes. Look at what has happened to the huntsman academies in only a slightly longer span of time; the halls of these hallowed institutions have become the haunts of spoiled brats, Schnees and Winchesters and Kommeni with nothing to recommend them but family money, only here because they wish to reveal in the acclaim of being huntsmen, to be fawned over for their physical power as much as the power their money can supply. Such, I have no doubt, was the fate of the Circle: its fortress polluted and its strength diluted by mediocrities more interested in sharing in the prestige of membership of such a distinguished order than in working to further its goals, let alone give their lives for it. Such is the fate of all institutions; the iron always rusts, covered with the oxide of complacency until it crumbles at the slightest touch."

"I'm not sure I agree," Sunset murmured.

"Is there any particular part you disagree with, or is your dissent general?"

"I admit that there are some in Beacon whom I wouldn't have let in if I was the headmaster, but I wouldn't say that we're so rusted over yet," Sunset replied. "I'd say there are more good than bad still, at Beacon at least."

"We'll see," Cinder said. "Perhaps you're right. Perhaps the students of Beacon and the other academies are good for more than preening before the cameras at the Vytal Festival. You have, I admit, demonstrated that you and your team are certainly not without skill." She paused. "There is another possibility, if you find my first suggestion too cynical, which is that the Circle was never actually all that it was cracked up to be."

"You mean the stories exaggerate their prowess without considering what that means for their fall?" Sunset asked.

"Perhaps their prowess was exaggerated even during the Circle's existence."

"You think it actually existed?"

"I think something like it probably existed, or what inspired the story?" Cinder replied.

Sunset nodded; it was more likely than the Infinite Man's unlikely mode of immortality. "Okay, but you think they were never as great as the story would have us believe?"

"I think that they wished to be thought of as much greater than they were; they may even have believed it themselves before war came to their doorstep," Cinder said. "I'm sure they were perfectly capable of despatching grimm, but… well, look at your friends from Atlas and all their toys taking up the skies overhead. Where does this preeminent military reputation enjoyed by Atlas come from? Everyone agrees that they are the mightiest of the four kingdoms, but Atlas has not faced a war since its foundation; we are, as we are incessantly reminded, living in an era of peace. So upon what firm foundation rests all of this northern bravado? What have they done to earn it? If they were to be confronted by a true threat, by a power they could not overawe with the shadow of a single warship, would not all their fine talk turn to dust, and all their arrogance wither into fear?"

"Don't let Rainbow Dash here you say that," Sunset remarked.

Cinder snorted. "Don't worry, I won't. I find Atlesians tiresome enough already, as you might be able to tell; present company accepted, of course."

"Thank you," Sunset said, inclining her head graciously. "You certainly have a lot to say upon this story, no wonder you wanted to choose this one so badly."

"And you?"

"Nothing comparable to the amount of thought you've given to it, I'm afraid," Sunset admitted. "Except to say that… either or both of your suggestions has merit." Certainly it matched her Equestrian experience; Sunset had heard no less than Robyn Hill, their captain, admit to the princess that the Royal Guard had atrophied over the generations of peace that Celestia had wrought. That fact had not troubled Princess Celestia herself, who had preferred the peace to any toughening of the guard that might result from conflict, but it showed in the way that Equestria now seemed dependent on Twilight Sparkle and her friends to protect it from all menaces.

"And the moral of the story?" Cinder asked. "Is the man a hero, a villain, or a fool?"

Sunset considered it for a moment. "A fool," she said after a few moments. "He doesn't have the strength of character to be either hero or villain."

"No?"

Sunset shook her head. "He continuously bemoans his flaws, his unfitness to be a hero, still less a god, and yet he allows the girl to talk him into becoming a leader and sharing his power with others; later he allows his enemy to talk him into dying. Before that, when he died the first time, he comes back and wanders back to his old comrades seemingly for want of anything else to do or anywhere else to go, even though he keeps talking how unfit to lead them he is!"

"I'm intuiting that you were ever so slightly frustrated with him," Cinder murmured.

"Leaders should have a proper pride in themselves," Sunset declared, "and they should always put on a brave face amongst their followers." Princess Celestia had never shown Sunset any weakness, and when Sunset had caught her in a position of vulnerability, it was when the princess hadn't known that Sunset was there, watching.

"Is that how you run your team? With a brave face and a refusal to admit any fault or flaw?"

"No," Sunset admitted. "But I don't confess to more than I have to. Or at least, I shouldn't."

"You didn't learn that in Professor Goodwitch's leadership class."

"I've had better teachers in leadership than Professor Goodwitch," Sunset said. "My point is that, for all his power, the Infinite Man is a slave to the last word in his ear; he can be persuaded of anything; he ultimately shows no convictions at all. That's why he cannot be a hero or a villain, and so, he must be a fool."

"I agree that he is a fool, but not for those reasons," Cinder replied, "but because to be a hero or a villain, he would have had to have achieved something, to have done or built something that mattered. And yet, the only accomplishment we learn of – the only thing about him that is recorded – is that he built a society that was destroyed in two generations or so, leaving no trace of its existence. He built a fortress, he trained an army, but he did nothing with either of them."

"He sent them forth to help those in need," Sunset pointed out.

"Doubtless, they were still in need after his champions departed," Cinder countered. "Did he make himself a lord over the region? What did he do to keep these places safe after he saved them? Nothing. He sat in his fortress while the world grew dark outside until the darkness burst like a tide over his walls and swept him and all the fools who put their trust in him aside. The warrior woman, in destroying his Circle, accomplished more than he did in the end." She smiled. "I'd like to hear her story, find out what drove her to seek out a god and challenge him in battle. Was it simply for the thrill of the combat, or did she have a larger goal in mind?"

A smile played across Sunset's face. "If you were writing that story, what would your answer be?"

"I?" Cinder asked, seeming surprised to have been asked. "I… I would have it so that she sought out a god, this great challenge, greater than any that she could have found or faced before in her life… she sought him out because she wished to dance with death, because only in battle… did she feel alive."
 
Back
Top