"These were some of the best days of my life. I got to try so many new things and I learned so much in subjects I hadn't ever even heard about. It was intoxicating."
"You two look out for each other, okay?" Mom tells the boys.
"Okay, Mom. We will," Aron promises.
Ketlan makes an equally affirmative, if indistinct, sound.
Aron bounces on his toes as Mom helps Ketlan put his jacket and book bag on. She'd already helped Aron with his. They're getting ready for
school! It's a new experience, even if Aron's spent years going to school at this point. The last two days at home have been nice – his parents doted on him, and he got to eat home-cooked meals and play bloodlessly with Ketlan, all while getting used to being Aron J. Carpenter – but it's Monday now, and that apparently means school. He's a bit excited to see what it's like: a new school with new eyes.
"Try to make friends," Mom continues, "and listen to your teachers, and stay out of trouble. If you see anyone doing something they're not supposed to, or if anyone gives you a hard time, tell a teacher and they'll take care of it. And–"
"Mary," Dad interjects. Mom's name is Mary? "Dear. They'll be fine."
She stares at him for a long moment, worry writ across her face. They're both so easy to read, so much more expressively varied than most people. Mom relaxes.
"You're right," she admits.
Mom and Dad lead the boys outside to wait for the bus, and Dad has to keep Mom on the porch while Aron and Ketlan wait on the curb. Dad's going to be late for work, but he said that's fine today. One of Ketlan's hands grips Aron's, and the other clutches his stuffed bunny to his chest. Would he like it if it were alive? It wouldn't be hard to make it move and talk and eat; the big challenge would be to keep its feel and appearance intact without making it smell.
"Do you think moving here was a mistake?"
Aron only hears Mom's quiet question because of his enhanced ears. He's certain Ketlan didn't.
"I'm worried about the boys," she continues before Dad can answer her question, which seems a bit rude. "They're still so young, and it's a new school in a new town, and they've both been acting so odd and withdrawn, and what if the other kids give them a hard time? You know how sensitive Ketlan is, and Aron is so combative about it all and I–"
"Mary, dear, sweetie, love of my life and mother to the most beautiful boys in the world," Dad soothes. "It's going to be okay. This is a good town, with good folk; you saw how everyone came together to look for Aron. And our boys are tough; they won't let some mean kids get them down."
"But when Aron ran, he said…"
"I know. But he'll grow past this change. You've already seen how much happier he's been these last couple days. I think he's starting to see things our way, and he'll be fine."
"..."
"And hey, at least in a small town like this, with the Nine dead and gone, we won't have to worry about them getting caught up in any cape nonsense," Dad jokes.
"...It
is statistically safer," Mom hedges.
"Exactly. They just have to deal with the same stuff we dealt with when we were their age."
"Oh my god," Mom says despairingly. "Aron's going to hit puberty soon, isn't he."
Ketlan startles and turns to look at the parents as Dad lets out a roaring laugh. He turns back to face the street and murmurs, "They're so weird."
"They're a good mom and dad," Aron says in response. "They love us."
Ketlan fixes him with a stare. "You're weird too."
Aron isn't sure what to say to that, so he just sticks his tongue out at his little brother. Ketlan does the same and makes a
nyhhh sound, so Aron one-ups him by sticking his tongue further out and making a louder
nyhhh sound, and the cycle repeats until Aron licks Ketlan, who jerks away.
"EWW!" he yells. "MOM! ARON LICKED ME!"
"Aron, don't lick your little brother," Mom says, though her smile is audible, which confuses Aron.
If he's not supposed to lick Ketlan, then why is she smiling? And if it's okay to lick him, as the smile implies, then why would Mom tell him not to? It seems like Mom doesn't have a problem, but Ketlan is forcing her to arbitrate in his favor, which doesn't make sense since he's the son and she's the mom and moms have the power. The rules of this family are so hard to grasp. His time here has been so soft, it makes him wonder what sorts of secrets they're all hiding from him.
There's little time to consider that though, as the bus arrives. The two brothers climb aboard as the doors open, find a seat with a window facing their parents, and wave goodbye.
Carpenter
Aron raises his hand and asks, "But why is that bad? If only one can live, why not pick the better one? Or why not make the two babies into one?"
Mr. Anderson, the English teacher, sighs. "Mister Carpenter, when I told you to raise your hand before you ask a question, I suppose I should have specified that you should wait for me to acknowledge you as well."
"Oh, sorry." Aron puts his hand down. There are so many little rules to this place. "But why did the dad have to pick one of the babies to kill in the first place? Neither was terminally malformed or anything, and if only one is important, shouldn't they keep the other around for its organs?"
Mr. Anderson looks around at the intrigued faces of the other students and decides to answer. "Because that's the rule of the society. It's population control. The Communist government that rules the society only allows a certain number of babies to be born in a year, to keep things same."
"What's a Communist?" Aron asks.
"Simply put, it's a very bad person who wants to take away people's freedoms."
"Why would you put a bad person in charge of your society? That seems silly."
"That's what makes this society a dystopia. The whole book is about what happens if communists took over and got to rule their way. Everyone's lives become regimented and the same, because the Communist government sees everyone as the same, just cogs in the machine. Remember how everyone shares a birthday, and they only get the same single present? And how everyone's houses look the same, and they all wear the same clothes? That's because they lack freedom."
Aron looks around the room his entire age group is compelled to be in and sees three boys wearing the same shirt with a graphic of Legend. Most of the students are wearing samey looking blue jeans. He remembers how his house at 186 Nightingale Drive is build the same as the rest of the drive, just with different colors. "Are we Communist?"
"Mister Carpenter, that's enough," Mr. Anderson barks. "We're already far enough off topic. Let's get back to the reading. Susie, you're next."
"But I just want to know–"
"Mister Carpenter," Mr. Anderson cuts Aron off, "take your seat and let us finish the chapter. You've distracted the class more than enough."
"But–"
"Or do I need to send you to the principal's office?"
The class quakes with a low, ubiquitous "ooooo" from all the students. Aron looks around, not sure why all the other kids look so scandalized.
"Would the principal be able to answer my questions?" Aron asks, and judging from the vein that appears on Mr. Anderson's forehead, it was the wrong thing to say. He braces for a hit that doesn't come.
"That's it! I'm writing you up. I didn't want to do this, but you give me no choice." Mr. Anderson grabs a slip of paper from his desk, writes something on it, and gives it to Aron. "Take this to principal Brown and tell him what you did. And don't try to lie, I'll be talking to him as well."
Aron looks down at the yellow slip he's been handed, filled out with basic information like the date, Aron's name, the class, the time, and a explanation:
disruptive in class; talking back. Aron doesn't understand how a piece of paper is the punishment Mr. Anderson seems to mean it as.
"Well? No use trying to get out of it," says Mr. Anderson. "Go."
"Where am I going?" Aron asks.
"Principal Brown's office," Mr. Anderson grinds out.
"...and where is that?"
Mr. Anderson takes a deep breath, though it doesn't look to calm him. "Riley," he calls, and I don't know how but he's found me out. I ready my phalangical scalpel – the only internal tool I have that still works; I should have repaired and readied, stupid! – to put him down and get away, but before I can, another girl says,
"Yes, Mr. Anderson?"
I shoot a glance her way and realize this is the same girl from role call earlier: Riley Planter. Aron relaxes, same as he did earlier, when role was called.
"Would you escort Mister Carpenter to the principal's office?" Mr. Anderson asks her. "And then come back here?"
"I can do that," Riley says, standing.
Mr. Anderson nods her off and the kids take that as their cue to leave. Riley leads Aron into and down the hall, toward the entrance where the school bus let him off this morning.
"You shouldn't have done that," Riley says.
"What did I do?" Aron asks back.
"You were talking back to Mr. Anderson!" She sounds scandalized. "You can't talk to the teachers like that."
"Like what?"
"Like how you did! Mr. Anderson gave you so many chances to stop but you kept doing it."
"He wasn't answering me."
"Was he not answering you, or was he not giving you the answer you wanted?" Riley asks like she's repeating something wise.
"I was just curious."
"Curiosity killed the cat."
"Only if you don't know what you're doing when you dig around inside it."
"What?" Riley asks, horrified.
"Curiosity is a good thing, and if you have to crack a few skulls to make croquettes, that's the way of the world." Aron's been told that plenty of times.
The horror abates mildly as Riley corrects Aron, "The saying is 'you have to crack a few eggs to make an omelette.'"
Aron blinks at her, not quite seeing the difference.
Riley huffs. "You have to learn to not be so pushy with the teachers and just let yourself be curious later, okay?"
"But curiosity is a good trait and should always be pursued; that's what Uncle Ja–"
I stop Aron. Aron… wasn't told that. He never met the one who told me that, and that man… He hated everything, he said. He hated Bonesaw, he said. But he said he loved Bonesaw too. Did he? Was he lying. One has to be a lie for the other to be true, or they could both be lies, but they can't both be true.
Was he w– No. That man wasn't wrong. He's never wrong. Not until he started not being himself. But Riley and Mr. Anderson are telling Aron otherwise, so… What does that mean? Are they wrong? Or was he lying? He can't have been wrong, so he must have been lying, which isn't being wrong, it's just saying something that's wrong without
being wrong, and he wasn't ever wrong until Bonesaw failed and let him become wrong, and he knows everything and– Knew. He
knew everything. He doesn't because he isn't. He…
"Aron? What's wrong?"
Aron shakes his head to clear the weird thoughts. He's not sure what he was just thinking about; the thoughts dissolve into so much white noise playing at the edges of his mind. "Nothing, sorry," he says. "Let's go."
He'll go to the principal's office, explain what happened in the classroom, tell him he was just trying to learn, and Principal Brown will tell him what he did wrong. He'll take the punishment and it'll all be okay.
Carpenter
"...and that's why Principal Brown gave me that to give to you," Aron explains.
Mom purses her lips as looks over the note again and digests his story. He still doesn't understand why he's in trouble, but Principal Brown said that "there's a time and place for everything, and the middle of class, when everyone is trying to learn, isn't that," and then wrote him this note to give to his mom.
"I still don't understand what I did wrong," Aron says.
"Oh, sweetie," Mom says tenderly. "Some people don't like it when you question them too much, or do what they don't want you to do. Mr. Anderson has a lesson plan – Do you know what that means?"
Aron shakes his head.
"It means he's planned out in advance what he wants to go over each day, and since he only has so much time in a day, he sometimes has to move fast."
"...And I was stopping him," Aron concludes after a moment of thought.
Mom nods.
It makes a certain amount of sense. Aron wouldn't like it if he was working on a project and trying to finish it and someone else kept bothering him and getting in his way, especially if he was working with a deadline. "But isn't school
for learning? That's what you said: that we have to go there to learn. That's what I was trying to do."
"It is, but there's a balance. You're there to learn, but so is everyone else."
"So why don't they ask questions?"
"Well, if everyone asked questions, there wouldn't be any time for the teacher to get through the lesson, and then no one would learn everything they need to learn. Does that make sense?"
Aron huffs. "I guess. But that stinks."
His mom sees his pout and lays her hand on his arm. "How about this: when your teacher tells you to stop asking, you can write your questions down and bring them home, and I'll try to answer them. Would that be okay?"
"Really?" Aron asks, excited. "Yes! Please! Thank you, Mommy!"
She grins at him and he grins back, and she offers to let him ask about The Giver while she makes dinner.
Carpenter
"Aron, phone for you," Mom calls from the kitchen.
He doesn't let his confused displeasure show on his face. He doesn't want to talk on the phone. He wants to play Legos with his little brother. But he knows he's supposed to ask, "Who is it?"
"It's James."
He doesn't know who James is, but he's pretty sure he's supposed to, so he says to Ketlan, "I'll be right back," and steps away from their project to answer the phone. Mom hands it off to him with a smile and he takes it and returns the smile. She goes back to sorting through coupons and sales booklets at the table, and he puts the phone to his ear.
"This is Aron," he says.
"Aron! Where were you last night?" James asks.
"...What do you mean?"
"We were supposed to play P.F. Three last night. I sent you the invite but you never even came online. Does your internet even work out there? It says you haven't logged on since Friday. Our clan's gonna kick you if you get rusty, man."
It's one of Aron's video games friends, from Indianapolis. What a bother. "...I don't like that game anymore."
"
What?! You're kidding. It's the best game on the market. What else do you even play? Don't tell me you went back to Triumvirate for The World. That game is for babies."
Aron sends a look at his mom. She's occupied, engrossed in finding the best deals. He peeks around the corner and Ketlan is occupied too, still building on their lego city.
"Aron, are you there? Hello? Can your stupid town not even get calls? Helloooo?"
"Don't call here again," Aron says. "I don't want to play with you anymore. I hate you. Goodbye."
He sets the phone back in its cradle on the wall before James can say anything else. If not for the distance between Burgess and Indianapolis, he would kill his old friends to stop something like this from happening again. He watches the phone for a minute to make sure it doesn't ring, that James doesn't try to call back. It stays silent. Good. Aron smiles and returns to playing with Ketlan.