You feel weak, emotionally exhausted, still taking in impurities from Mami's soul gem so she can keep healing herself, keep reaching out toward life. You can't exactly go and stop Mama like this.
For a moment, you hear her footsteps falter - then speed up, with the thump of a dropped purse, and she comes into view at a surprisingly brisk run, considering her footwear.
"Girls, what's happening? I smelled… blood, and heard… Sayaka crying…" she trails off as her eyes land on Mami, still in her magical girl outfit, on the pool of blood beneath her, on Kyouko, similarly outlandishly dressed…
And on the scattered rifles lying around Mami's body. She's already taking out her phone - you kind of need to do something now.
"Please don't…" you beg, "call the police or the ambulance right now. This… this isn't something they can deal with…"
"Madoka…?" You watch as she stops dialing and lowers her phone - she trusts you enough to hesitate, just for a few moments.
"I can… try to explain, I promise, but…" you force out, turning back to Kyouko. "Can… can I let go?"
"Y-yeah. I think so. I'll use the cubes if I gotta."
You pull your hand away, watching Mami's gem closely. Eventually, you're satisfied it won't suddenly darken and turn away. A weight falls from you, a tension you hadn't realized had built up inside you releasing as the secondhand pain fades away. You slip from Kirika's grip, run toward Mama, cling to her and begin to sob, letting everything out as you cry into her arms.
You're glad Mama's here. Despite not really knowing what's going on, she manages to take charge of the whole, messy situation, and get Mami inside on an improvised stretcher with Kyouko's help.
It's about half an hour later by the time you and Sayaka have calmed down a little, curled up together on the sofa in your living room. You feel relieved, really, crying that much. You'd been acting so strangely today that it's a strong reminder that, despite everything, you're still an ordinary girl.
Really, the one acting the most strangely is Kirika, though. You're not sure if it's since you kissed her (you really did that!) or since she saw the moon (you don't want to think about it more than you have to), but she's been oddly willing to do more or less anything you say. Mostly, you've had her helping Mama out, feeling too exhausted to make decisions yourself - bringing Mami's spare rifles inside, cleaning up the blood on the road, hiding the evidence without complaint.
She'd brought you the salamander earring, too - and it really is slightly different than the first one you saw. Instead of the eighth setting being filled, it's the fourth, of course, this one with a sharp-edged, ice-blue stone. You note, before you firmly set it somewhere out of sight, that the earring has an uncanny resemblance to the giant witch on the moon.
"Madoka…" Sayaka eventually mumbles, "how… how are you feeling?"
"I… think I'm okay. I think I'm going to be okay," you answer, exhausted, but full of the calm clarity born of catharsis. "How about you?"
"I'm scared. I don't want this… I want to forget, but… it'd be wrong to forget. Even if I asked Kyubey to make me forget, I'd still be part of this world…"
"Mm. Don't wish for something like that, Sayaka. If you're going to make a wish, you need it to be something you can say, afterwards, that you don't regret." You take her hand and hold it tight, offering her your shoulder to rest her head against.
"But… I just feel so useless. Even Kirika's better than me…"
You shake your head, squeezing her hand a little. "No. Kirika's Kirika, and you're you. Only you can be yourself. So don't try to be Kirika, figure out what Miki Sayaka can do."
"But… Mami-san almost died there. You almost died, Madoka, and I… Kirika jumped right in, when I just stood there and stared. I… I'm powerless, Madoka. I can't protect anyone…"
"I don't think that's right, Sayaka. Your life is precious, too. It's good to want to protect people, but the person closest to you, the one you can protect the most, is Miki Sayaka, right?"
"But…"
"You don't think Mami and Kyouko would be here right now if they didn't protect themselves first, do you?" you gently chide, putting on a faint, nervous smile.
"Mmn…" She begins to cry quietly again, nestling into your shoulder, and you hold her close, wiping away her tears.
Eventually, the six of you are sitting together around the dining table. Kyouko's still transformed, a yellow ribbon running from her wrist through the doorway to Mami in the spare room. It's something of a tight fit, getting six around the table, but you just about manage, with Sayaka and Kirika either side of you, Mama and Papa opposite, and Kyouko at the end. You're not sure how much of an appetite you can muster after all that, though.
"How's Mami-senpai," you ask cautiously, eyes following the ribbon as Papa serves up his homemade curry.
"She's asleep right now, with the curtains closed," Kyouko replies. "She's gonna make it, but… yeah, she took a lot of damage. Right now, she's using her magic to substitute for the damaged parts of her body, so she won't be able to untransform for a few days."
"Magic? Transforming? Is this some kind of code…?" Papa asks, setting down plates in front of you and Sayaka. He'd been feeding Tatsuya and putting him to bed while everything else played out, so he'd missed a lot.
"I wish I could say yes," replies Mama solemnly. "Unfortunately, I've seen it for myself. It's the real thing, Tomohisa, and… some of the girls are in deep."
"So all of you are… magical girls?" he asks next, a plate offered to Kirika. "Go ahead, dig in. You all look like you need it."
"Thanks for the food," the four of you chorus, you and Sayaka trying to put some enthusiasm into it, while Kyouko doesn't need to fake it. "And… nah, it's just me and Mami right now - active in Mitakihara, anyway."
"So when did this start?" Plates land in front of Kyouko and Kyouko - you'd object, but this is Kyouko.
"I dunno," replies Kyouko, holding off from digging in just long enough to give a full reply. "'parently Joan of Arc was a magical girl, so a while. I've been in the business two years now; same for Mami." She leaves it to you three to answer for yourselves after that, and starts shoveling curry into her mouth.
"Mmn. Sayaka and I wandered into something dangerous yesterday after school, and Kirika-chan got caught up in it just this afternoon - it's… so much…" Something comes to mind - Kyubey'd mentioned that ordinary people couldn't see magic, and you definitely remember people not being able to see him, so- "…um, Mama, can I go and get my notebook? It might be easier to explain with that."
"Of course, Madoka, but don't take too long and let your food get cold."
You slip out of the room and fetch the notebook in which you'd drawn all those outfits from your bag, along with a pen and the earring - then collect the second earring from the living room. You tiptoe as you pass the guest room, where the yellow ribbon runs under the door - you don't want to wake Mami, even if you did check your eyes are back to their usual pink.
Papa's finished serving up when you get back, and Sayaka's slowly eating too. The table is more or less silent, the mood awkward. You sit down and start eating too - your dinner seems slightly overcooked, but it's still Papa's homemade cooking, and considering the circumstances, he'd done an exceptional job.
With the notebook on your lap, you think about how much you should tell them.
It's tough. There's a lot of things you don't want to tell Mama. Really, you don't want her to be involved in this at all, but at the same time… she already is. From her perspective, she was willing to help you hide an incident involving guns, so you owe it to her, really.
It's still embarrassing, though. You don't know, really, if you'd even be able to explain what just happened without including the really frightening parts. Or the scandalous parts you're not sure you're ready to tell your parents. Right now, you feel comfortably human, and you don't really want to spoil it.
You start simple, pacing yourself with food, covering, with Kyouko's help, the basics of magical girls - wraiths and witches, Soul Gems and Grief items, replenishing magic, the fact that you get a single wish in exchange for the contract. You hadn't drawn any pictures of witches - you don't think you could really do the horror justice - but you've got useful illustrations for the rest.
By the time you're done, Mama's already frowning, deep in thought.
"I don't like it. Having to keep hunting to replenish your magic… it doesn't really fit the image of a 'magical girl', does it? In the adult world, we're always having to watch out for that sort of thing. When someone offers you a deal that seems too good to be true, that's usually because it is."
"Yeah, that's about the way of it," Kyouko replies.
"You say the wishes are real, though?"
"Yeah," Kyouko confirms; "Kyubey even said he doesn't mess with the results," Sayaka adds right after.
"Hmm… it's true that a magical wish is something amazingly valuable. This world's crooks probably wish they could offer something that good," Mama ponders. "But he might be lying, and even if he's not, this stinks of fraud. There's good reasons the law doesn't recognize most contracts signed by minors- aaagh! Dear, I think this is going to be a whiskey night after all."
"Is that… bad?"
"It's fine, it's a Sunday tomorrow," Mama replies with a wink. "You girls are having a tough time of it right now, so someone's got to look out for you- oh, Madoka, I already texted Kazuko about Tomoe-chan, so you don't need to worry, okay?"
"Kazuko?" Kirika asks, surprised and unable to place the name.
"That's Saotome-sensei to you~" Mama teases back. "I always stay out late with her after a breakup." You can tell she's trying hard to keep everyone upbeat after what happened… "So. This Kyubey, does he only make contracts with middle school girls?"
"Mostly. Some girls are younger than that, some are older, but I've never heard of him contracting an adult or a boy. He's kind of like an idol recruiter, huh…"
Papa sighs, shaking his head. "I remember talking about those. If I'd known to mention strange mascot creatures too…"
"Mm. He's the kind of creature who hands out wishes to girls who've got something they want to wish for right now, like healing someone's illness or getting a boy to go out with them, rather than ones who might think it through and wish for, I don't know, world peace or something?"
"Yeah, he's like that. He'll let you wish away your worries, but it never lasts - oh, seconds!" Kyouko's already finished both plates, and is still hungry for a third.
"Oh? Does being a magical girl come with a bottomless stomach, too? Here you go."
"Yeah, basically. Thanks!" You leave the redhead to her insatiable gluttony and move on to the next topic, your own plate still half-full.
"The truth is, though, that even if it's a trick, or a lie, there's still monsters that need to be fought. This world is a scary place, and it's all hiding just out of sight of ordinary people…" you murmur. "Even the moon is different on this side…"
"What was that thing, anyway, Kyouko? Some kind of super-gigantic witch?"
"…yh, smm-" She finishes her bite of food. "Somethin' like that."
"Yeah." You turn to Mama, suddenly nervous. This is one of the parts you'd been most afraid of. "There's something weird - even weirder than 'normal magical girl stuff' happening right now. The giant witch in the moon, I… I think it woke up earlier tonight. And we've been being… attacked, I guess, by… I think they might be its familiars or something. That's how Mami-san got hurt so badly…" You draw a brief sketch of the eldritch moon in your notebook - you can't, mercifully, reproduce the true horror of that face - and show it around the table.
"'The moon is dark, and the gods dance in the night; there is terror in the sky, for upon the moon hath sunk an eclipse foretold in no books of men or of earth's gods…'," Papa utters, eyes closed in memory. "HP Lovecraft. I used to be quite a fan of horror back in college. I, ah, certainly didn't expect to one day learn that we're living in a world like that."
You hadn't expected that. You're not sure how much genre knowledge will help here, but you're prepared to go with it.
"The dolls, um… familiars dropped these earrings. I think they're probably enough proof they're connected to the moon." You hold up the two earrings, comparing them to the sketch, then touch them together - to your… well, you could say surprise, but you'd half-expected something like this would happen - the two earrings reconfigure, twisting and splitting like some unearthly Rubik's cube, merging together like some kind of eye-watering reverse Banach-Tarski paradox until there's only one, with both gems set in its rim.
"…Y-Yes, that's about how I imagined eldritch artifacts would look. You haven't tried wearing them, right?"
You shake your head. Well, you doubt it'd be worse than what you'd already seen in creating them, but you're not really enthusiastic about trying. You let Kirika hold the earring, at least, turning it over and over in her hands…
"That's good. Normally, I'd say knowledge can only help you, but with things like this, it can sometimes be better to stay in the dark until you're ready."
You look back down at your food and pick at it. Kirika's finished hers, but Sayaka doesn't seem to be doing much better than you. You don't think you'd even have had this much of an appetite if your parents weren't taking things so well.
After all, you think you understand what you saw in the doll's memories.
You don't want it to be true, but if it is… then you're the only one who can save a lot of people, right now. Starting with Sayaka and Kirika. They'd almost contracted without knowing this…
"I… um, I don't know if that's a good idea, Papa. When we sealed away the doll just now, I saw… something like a vision. A memory, maybe. I feel like… it's something everyone needs to know about."
"Write it down, and I'll read it first. I can't become a magical girl, so I should be okay," he replies. You're starting to feel angry at Kyubey, thinking about how he might've pressured other girls into making contracts, without anyone to turn to for advice.
It takes a little while, but you decide to be honest in your notes rather than write something like 'a bow-wielding magical girl I don't recognize.' If it's a possible future, you can still avert it.
After that, you can't do anything but watch as your father reads over the notes and implications, several times, brow furrowed.
"Hey, Madoka…" Sayaka addresses you, eyes narrowed. "Are you sure you should be trusting weird visions from creepy dolls?"
"Not completely, but… I think I trust them more than Kyubey right now," you reply. "Tomorrow, let's get some answers out of him, okay?"
"Mmm."
"That's right… in cosmic horror stories, there are a lot of frightening gods that don't care about humanity, but it's the ones that do and know how to disguise themselves, like Nyarlathotep, or their human followers, that are always the most dangerous," Papa eventually says, seeming to come to an understanding.
At last, he looks up, closing the notebook and handing it back to you. "I don't like this, but… you need to know what it is you're being offered. I'm not sure how much to believe what my daughter says she saw, but Madoka's never even once lied to us. Madoka, it's okay for you to tell them, this, I think."
"…okay. Thanks, Papa… I'm sorry for putting you through this," you say, almost becoming teary-eyed again as you smile at him.
"So what's Kyubey hiding from us?" Kyouko asks, finishing her third plateful with a toothy grin you're really not feeling good about being about to ruin. "You wanna spill the beans, Madoka?"
"I'd like to know, too. I almost let him trick me." "Yeah, so did I."
"Even I was thinking about making a wish before this," you admit, no giggle, no blush on your face, just nerves. "But… well, the truth is… I saw us. Well, me, and Kyouko, and Mami. There was another girl, too. We were at the station platform, and we were all transformed… even me, I was a magical girl in the vision, and… Mami kind of… snapped, like she did just now. Only, um… well, she destroyed Kyouko's Soul Gem, and then I… well, the me in the vision… destroyed hers."
"Oi, oi… we were fighting among ourselves? I mean… after that, I can believe it, but… wait, you mean… why just the…" Kyouko flounders, gears turning in her mind as she thinks through the implications.
"Mmm. You'd think that destroying a magical girl's Soul Gem would just make her stop being magical, right? But… that's not how it works. That's not how Kyubey made it. Because a Soul Gem is…"
"A gem that's a soul," Kirika finishes for you, a flat wryness to her words as the truth dawns on her. "It's that simple."