"This is the Mitakihara Municipal Office. An evacuation order has been given…" Public announcements echo over the sound system in the hastily repurposed community centre as bedraggled and windswept families file in from across the neighbourhood. Outside, trees bend back and forth, leaves and entire branches being torn off by the strong wind. In the distance, the storm clouds churn and swirl over the ocean, and you know, somewhere out there, Homura is waiting for it to begin.
Your family's just sitting along with the others, on a mat laid out and allocated for them. Mama and Papa from back then are doing their best to stay calm for Tatsuya, of course, leaving Madoka to sit, deep in thought.
"Is this a sleepover? Are we camping?" Tatsuya asks, not really understanding the situation.
"That's right. We're all camping here tonight!"
{This is…} It's Papa's voice, but different from the one in the memory. The real one, viewing the memory with you.
{This is the morning following April 30th, 20×●. Right now, it's midnight on the evening of Walpurgisnacht, on the Brocken in Germany.} you reply. {This is the 108th iteration, by the way - um, you could call it a maha-kalpa, but I think that's a bit violent, and it sort of mixes things up a bit, too. It's not strictly wrong, though- um... that part will make sense later.}
{Is the city going to be okay?} asks your mother, as the lights flicker a little.
{Mmm. In a sense, anyway, this time. Well, this is the last maha-kalpa that will be experienced by this lost trichilocosm, but rather than me explaining it, it's best you see for yourself.}
Time passes, in the way of a dream - without waiting, it's simply clear that it's a little later. The light outside is slightly brighter, the storm closer…
The building shakes, and the lights almost go out entirely. Madoka gets to her feet and turns away, clenching her hands.
"What's wrong, Madoka?" asks Mama hurriedly.
"I-I need to use the bathroom." It's embarrassing, really. That you couldn't be honest even in this loop. She leaves, and the memory follows her, out to a gallery looking out on the storm, where Kyubey's waiting atop a railing. Branches are hurled past, the trunks of the trees outside creaking and bending.
{Can you see him?}
{That's Kyubey? He certainly has a disarming look to him.} comments Papa.
{I definitely wouldn't trust him.} Mama's got that yankee voice again. You can imagine her clobbering him with a baseball bat, if she could see him for real.
<Is it true that Homura can win by herself?>
<Would you believe my words if I told you?> Neither of their mouths are moving, a stark contrast to the raging tempest outside.
<By now, there's no point in words. Go and see with your own eyes just how far Akemi Homura can get against the Walpurgisnacht.>
<Why does she push herself so hard to fight?>
<Because she hasn't abandoned hope yet. If it comes to that, I'm sure she'll even reduce this timeline to nothing like the others, and continue to fight. She'll just continue to repeat this meaningless sequence.
It's no longer possible for her to stop, or to give up. The moment she allows herself to believe that everything was pointless and Madoka's fate can never be changed, Akemi Homura will succumb to despair and become a Grief Seed. She knows this too - which is why she doesn't have a choice. She has to keep fighting, even if she has no chance of winning.>
<So you're saying as long as she continues to hope, she can't be saved?>
<That's right. Just like every other magical girl throughout history. Madoka, you watched it with me, didn't you?>
Madoka turns away from Kyubey and begins to sob, those painful memories returning. <But, but…>
{Out there, a girl who's important to me is fighting against the storm. She's doing everything in her power to stop it from reaching here - she stole weapons from the SDF, tried her best to recruit every magical girl she could… but Kyubey made sure she had to face it alone. So there'd be no choice but for me to go and save her.}
{Did you?}
{Mmm. I saved her, like it wanted me to. But I didn't give it what it wanted.}
{I'm gonna clobber that little rat.}
{You won't be able to see it. But… it's okay. I have some ideas for how to beat it this time.}
"But…" Madoka turns away, heading resolutely for the exit, beginning to rush down a set of steps. And is caught, Mama's hand around her wrist.
"Where do you think you're going?"
"Mom…"
"I have to go save my friend-"
"Leave that to the firefighters. We civilians have to stay put." You'd almost never seen her this fierce before.
"It has to be me!"
And then she slaps Madoka, and you can still feel the sting, a little, even now. You should've been more honest from the beginning. Why do magical girls never tell the truth to the people who care about them?
{I'm sorry, Mama. I… even after Sayaka died, and Mami and Kyouko too, I still couldn't bring myself to tell you the truth. I wanted to make amends for that, now that I have the chance in this world.}
{You weren't joking when you said it was going to be painful… I can't believe I slapped you.}
{It's okay. This world isn't on a path to tragedy like that one. This time, I won't accept an answer that needs any sacrifices. Not even me.}
"You're not the only person in this world!" she yells. "Do you even know how much the people around you-"
"I know." Madoka answers, interrupting her with a hand to her cheek, her mind made up. "I really do understand."
Mama's staring at her. Judging her. Making up her mind.
"I love you too, Mom. Dad, too. I know how much you all care about me. I know I need to value my own life.
But this is different. It's because you're all so important to me that I have to protect you. That's exactly why… there's somewhere I have to be right now!"
"And you can't tell me what this is about?"
Madoka shakes her head. You know you were absolutely convinced you couldn't, back then… but you don't remember why. Even after Sayaka's funeral, you couldn't tell anyone. Not Mama, not Kyousuke, not Hitomi…
"Take me with you, then."
"I can't. Stay with Papa and Tatsuya. Don't make them worry about you."
You can see the Mama from the memory wavering, even as she knows you won't come back from this.
"You said I grew up to be a good girl, right? That I don't tell lies, and I don't do bad things. Do you still believe that? Will you trust that what I'm doing is right?"
{I told Homura-chan once that I'd never have the courage to do something like this. I really underestimated myself…}
{Nobody does, until the time comes that they have to, I think.} answers Papa.
Mama is firmer. {Nobody should have to.}
The Mama in the memory reaches out… but second-guesses herself. "Are you certain you're not screwing up here? You're not being misled by anyone's lies?"
"Mm." Madoka nods. And receives a slap on the back, pushing her onward down the steps. "Thank you, Mama."
She runs. Through the fierce storm, past shattered trees, downed signs, overturned cars. Past a parade of clowns and green elephants, bells ringing louder than the howling wind. Past uprooted buildings, the wreckage warped into the roots of a vast concrete tree. And inside she goes, drawn by an instinct for her route, for her destination.
It's not a labyrinth, but it's very like one - the inside of the tree eerily calm, patterned in monochrome. She ascends, turning, rushing, and exits high atop the carnage, to where a dark-haired magical girl lies bleeding, her leg trapped under rubble.
Kyubey's waiting, of course.
And in the distance, the witch hangs upside-down from her giant gear, wimple and veil blowing in the wind, skyscrapers whipping around her and tearing apart into clouds of debris.
{So that's a witch's real form. She looks… almost like a collage, like she's been pasted onto the world.}
{Mmm. That's Walpurgisnacht. She's made up of hundreds of souls, maybe thousands, gathered up over the ages. People used to say she was the strongest witch of all. She doesn't have a labyrinth, and she doesn't really have any one person's individual characteristics, so she meshes better with the real world than most of them.}
{Most of them are worse?}
{Mmm. Not stronger, but weirder.}
{Is this going to happen again…?}
{We'll stop it. We're strong, this time, and we won't let Kyubey lie to us.}
{I hope so.}
"Homura-chan, I'm sorry. I'm going to become a magical girl now."
"I- no, you can't-!"
"I finally know what I want. I've found the wish I truly want granted. So I'll use my life for that wish."
"Don't! Because then, what have I- what have I been…" Homura's struggling, trying to pull free, but in vain.
{That girl… have we met her?}
{No. She exists in this world, but she swapped places with Kirika-chan for some reason, so she's in Kazamino City. I met her on Sunday, actually. She… I owe her a lot, but she doesn't remember.}
{I'd like to meet her, one day.}
{Maybe after all this is over, I'll bring her home and introduce her to you.}
Madoka steps toward her, kneels and takes her hand.
"I'm sorry. I'm really sorry… But I believe it's because you've protected me for so long, and put so much hope in me, that I'm the person I am now. I'm really, so sorry… but this is the answer I've finally found. Please, believe in me - I promise the answer I've found won't be in vain."
"Madoka…" She begins to cry slowly.
<Now that you've become a causal singularity around which the destiny of numerous worlds revolves, no matter how enormous the wish, you will most likely be able to realize it.>
"You're telling the truth, right?"
{He is. Homura-chan did something that's not really meant to be done. Every time she couldn't save me, she turned back time to March 16th, repeating these six weeks over and over. Because of that, she created an attractor within causality that bound my fate to the fate of the universe itself. I don't think Kyubey actually realized something like that could happen until it did…}
<Now, Kaname Madoka, what is the wish you will pay for with your soul?>
Mama and Papa are silent, as the understanding begins to sink in.
"I…" Madoka takes a deep breath. "I want to erase all witches before they are even born. I will erase every single witch in every universe, past and future, with my own hands." She begins to shine with a blinding light, even Homura covering her eyes before it.
<If that wish- if that wish were to come true, it wouldn't just be on the scale of temporal manipulation. You'd be opposing karmic destiny - the very laws of causality themselves!>
She shines yet brighter, not speaking a word, but clear in confirming her intent.
<Do you truly intend to become a god?>
{I don't think Kyubey had a concept of 'god' before this. He doesn't remember either, of course.}
"I don't mind becoming a god or anything else. All those magical girls who held onto their hopes and fought against witches - I don't want to see them cry. I want them to stay smiling until the end. If any rule or law stands in my way, I will destroy it and rewrite it. That is my prayer. That is my wish. Now, grant it, Incubator!"
After that, you watch as she transforms in a brilliant halo of light. She strings her bow, lets loose a single arrow that rains down in multitudes. She parts the clouds, and calms the storm, and a brilliant blue sky appears, its light shining ever brighter as pink arrows shoot off to banish distant darkness. The witch breaks apart, cloth and metal flaking away until only the gear remains, splitting as the silhouettes of spent magical girls whirl in their final dance.
And the memory unravels, and falls apart, and you're back in the living room of the Kaname household again.
"I can't show you any more after that, because the rest isn't made for human eyes to see. Really, it's a paradox for the knowledge to exist in the universe - the primum movens isn't meant to provide evidence for its own cause, but there's mitigating circumstances this time."
"So… what happened?" Papa asks, looking quite overwhelmed, but also full of intense curiosity.
"Imagine you're knitting a scarf, and you realize, suddenly, that you made a mistake right at the beginning, and the entire stitching pattern you used is wrong, so you have to take the whole thing apart. But it's not like you've wasted any of the wool, so you just unravel it, fix the mistake and put it back together with the same wool you used before. It's sort of like that, but for the universe.
There are a lot of patterns in causality that act as attractors, so even though I erased all the witches, most of the same events happened anyway. But I wasn't allowed to be present in the first maha-kalpa. Or the second, actually, initially. I got to sneak back into the world because someone created an even bigger paradox, and the causal attractors still left a space for Kaname Madoka to exist."
"…aren't there still witches in this world, though?" Mama points out, not yet really at peace with your explanation. You think she's got Saotome-sensei and Sonomi-san on her mind.
"Mmm. I think someone made some sort of paradox that lets witches exist, but also there's a rule barring external interference this time, so in order for the wish I made to still function, the world has to let me incarnate here and have a causal record as a mortal existence. Everyone forgot I existed before, but it's still really sad sometimes to just watch over people, so I think I like this better… oh, right! Um… Papa, on Saturday night there was that whole panic with the moon, right? And you were quoting Lovecraft, and we were comparing things to that…"
"I remember, yes."
"Well, um, basically, the way a wish like that actually works, is hope and despair have to balance out to zero, no matter what you do. So what it does, is it lets magical girls live out their lives and spread hope, and then when their Soul Gems turn completely dark, and it's time for despair, it transfers their entire causal burden into me. So their soul gets stored as a record, and the karmic imbalance accumulates on me. Then, eventually, after all the witches in all the universes are erased, I fulfill my destiny and instantaneously become a witch, only, then I erase that witch too, and that destiny is transferred back to me as well."
"That's a divergent sequence, though, Madoka. Wouldn't that require an absolute infinity to exist?"
"Mhm. Actually, it lets several exist. Because Kyubey uses his contracts as a means to harvest energy that isn't bounded by traditional statistical thermodynamics, the upper bound on the viable lifespan of the universe also becomes an absolute infinity, and the amount of hope brought by magical girls over that span is also infinite."
"But doesn't that mean the amount of despair is also infinite?"
"Actually, um, I can kind of cheat at that part too. I don't really want to suffer infinite despair, so I found a bunch of ways around it that are… um, well, basically I'd have to explain how karma is quantized in detail, and I honestly don't remember in my current state. The important part is that everything's basically going to be okay, because I'm here.
But, um, the witch in the moon - one of them, anyway - is mine, or rather, she's one of the records of Kaname Madoka that was detached from me, like the Madoka upstairs. She's sort of required to exist to keep the balance working because of the particulars of the paradox and the rule against external interference, or that's how I think it works, anyway. So, um, you don't need to worry that I'm some kind of dangerous eldritch creature like Azathoth or Yaldabaoth or something. I'm nothing that bad, really."
Mama's fallen quiet, just leaning against Papa, murmuring things like, 'our daughter is really amazing, isn't she?'. You've probably exhausted her - that or it was the baldy in Accounting.
"Mmm. I'm sorry I kept us all up so late talking about complicated subjects. I just… recently, I've really been feeling how similar keeping secrets is to just telling lies. I don't want to become like Kyubey, pretending like I'm a good girl who doesn't tell lies, but using secrets and half-truths all the time and telling myself that's different."
"That's good. I'm glad you feel that way…" answers Mama, her eyes shut as she rests on Papa's shoulder.
"Tomorrow, I think…"
You don't have another expedition set up yet, so…
"I think I'm just going to go to school," you say, as if it wouldn't be a big deal in the least.
"You're sure, Madoka?" Papa asks, once again just taking something a bit ridiculous in stride. "You know only Madoka is enrolled right now, though, and… aren't you too old to be in middle school?"
Huh. You hadn't thought of it quite like that before. In principle, you're several quintillion years too old to be in middle school, at least.
"If Madoka's enrolled, then I'm enrolled. Besides, I need to talk to the teachers about some things."
You're also a bit worried about what might be happening in places like Futatsugi. Although, at the same time, you've got a few good reasons to go to school, most of all Sayaka and Kyouko; and because of Oriko's warning, you don't really want to leave town on anything major until tomorrow.
And, of course, being at school doesn't stop you from keeping in touch with what's going on in Kazamino and Asunaro.
Really, though… you think you just want a little taste of calm and normality before you dive back into the thick of things.
"If you're sure that's what you need to do, Madoka. Are you going to bed now?"
"Mmm, I think so. I really did a lot today…"
"Good night, then, Madoka. Sleep well."
You leave behind Mama and Papa, and head up to your room, change into pajamas, and nestle into bed with Madoka. It's warm and comfortable, and you think, maybe, if you curl up just so, you'll be able to avoid rolling out during the night.
Soon enough, you're drifting off into slumber, your hand gently entwined in Madoka's.