...her power has 'malfunctioned', which put her parents in a coma they still have not woken up from, and all she can think of is her not-quite-girlfriend?

I am not sure whether that is dedication, or obsession.

[x] Just tell her about your powers and the coma

I wonder, if she saves Chloe in this loop and her parents die instead, will she find the cost acceptable?
 
Last edited:
...her power has 'malfunctioned', which put her parents in a coma they still have not woken up from, and all she can think of is her not-quite-girlfriend?

I am not sure whether that is dedication, or obsession.

I wonder, if she saves Chloe in this loop and her parents die instead, will she find the cost acceptable?

I feel like it might not just be Max's powers at work here right now, especially now that she's been timelooped and universe hopped at least twice (or more). There might be power overlap, or exotic power interaction that cocked up everything, or just plain chaos theory, but I highly doubt that Max's the sole culprit (maybe even at all responsible and this is just the place her power dumped the Info) for her parents' comas in this 'verse.

Also like, it's implied/alluded to in all 3 LiS games (LiS S1, BtS, and LiS2), that there are more people with superpowers, and it's still left a mystery as to why all of a sudden people are activating powers so closely near one another in terms of time. We've only seen 2 general locations, Arcadia Bay and Seattle, the rest of the world is kind of a mystery and LiS2 is still underway with Ep3 not out yet.

I feel like with the first game's events still fresh in her mind, Max has been living away from her parents for at least 1~ months or more? I forget; but she just had this rip roaring PTSD time travel Hunt for The Serial Kidnapper/Killer adventure with Chloe, so of course Chloe feels closer and realer? Max's parents spend the entire game events at least a monthish prior not really being a presence in Max's life because she was living at Blackwell, so of course she's going to automatically seek out the one person she'd been counting on and working with throughout this entire adventure. Max is running on adrenaline, she still is probably her PTSD-focus, it'll hit Max later, probably.

[X] Just tell her about your powers and the coma

We can drop the timeloop bullshit in here later, maybe go dig up Rachel while were at it.

THEORY TIME: The Storm that fucks Arcadia Bay is Rachel's weather/nature powers, and her powers without a controlling intelligence are doing that last thing she subconsciously desired, destroy Arcadia Bay with all the things that hurt her still in it, damn the consequences.
 
Last edited:
...her power has 'malfunctioned', which put her parents in a coma they still have not woken up from, and all she can think of is her not-quite-girlfriend?

I am not sure whether that is dedication, or obsession.

We're a few loops away from how many times it took Homura to develop a determination to save (and love for) Madoka so strong she became a literal God. I'd say we've got both in spades at this point.

It's probably not going to change either, unless we can defeat our personal Walpurgusnacht.

Or for those of you who aren't into good anime, we're Ahab, the Storm is our White Whale.
 
Last edited:
I'm kind of surprised Max even keeps trying, given how Space-Time has the most delightfully twisted anti-harassment protocols. Mean, the first time she would of gone through a trippy nightmare world that would even pull from stuff she never saw just to mess with her (such as Warren's crush on her being a little... Stalkerish).

Sure, she knows better than to mess with the far past, given all the unpredictable variables she'll need to deal with. Yet the most likely way to negate the storm is to go back further. After all, Max has only tried saving a life shortly before they die. The universe is pretty much all geared up for some cosmic inevitability, only to be left confused about the box of murder not arriving.

No wonder something inevitably goes awry, the universe is an Amazon customer repeatedly ordering the same thing because their order keeps getting forcibly cancelled.
 
Voting is now closed

[X] Just tell her about your powers and the coma
Nevill, Markala, Teen Spirit, 7ime1ock

Going to try to finish up the talk with Chloe today, maybe in the turn after this coming one.


We're a few loops away from how many times it took Homura to develop a determination to save (and love for) Madoka so strong she became a literal God. I'd say we've got both in spades at this point.

It's probably not going to change either, unless we can defeat our personal Walpurgusnacht.

Or for those of you who aren't into good anime, we're Ahab, the Storm is our White Whale.
Cliffsnotes Essay on the Major Symbols of Moby-Dick said:
For Ahab's interpretation, it is helpful to consider the captain's comments in the pivotal Chapter 36. There, the captain says he sees Moby Dick as a "mask," behind which lies a great power whose dominance Ahab refuses to accept. Ahab sees that inscrutable power as evil.
 
Last edited:
1.05
A few minutes later you find yourself wearing a pair of comfortable PJ pants, men's boxers, a soft PJ top, and your oversized sweater from the lost and found on top of it all. Even though your mind is alert and practically still on the verge of panic, your body is so exhausted that it's a struggle to not fall asleep as you lean against the wall behind Chloe's bed with blankets piled on top of you.

Chloe finished cleaning up the small mess you'd made by the window. You're thankful you didn't wake up Joyce or David with the crash. Or maybe you did, but they're used to Chloe sneaking in and out.

The taller girl takes a seat on the end of the bed and fixes you with a serious gaze, still tinged with worry. "Little better, Max?"

You give a small nod, moving at all hurts, which she seemed to have picked up on.

"So, what's up?" She asks.

You break eye contact and gaze at the far wall of the room. Where do you even start? What do you even tell her? What's too far and how much do you have the energy to prove? Even you're not sure what's really going on right now.

Well, she saw the hospital gown, so that's at least a place to start.

"Well-" You cough again quietly. Your voice is getting a little firmer, still not quite there though. "My family was driving me and my stuff to the Bay back in September-" Chloe's face hardens slightly. "But we were in an accident. A bad one. I-" You hesitate a moment. "I don't remember it, but it left all three of us in comas…" There. That's not a lie. It's not the truth, either.

Chloe's looking concerned now, her eyes dart quickly to her phone before she guiltily meets your gaze again.

You steel yourself, reflexively twitching your right hand and snagging a few threads that hold to attention for a moment, before drifting off at your inaction.

"Chloe, I have… powers." You pause. This part always makes you feel stupid. "Like. Time powers."

Her gaze holds on you for a moment. Her eyes dart again. She starts slowly reaching for her phone. Ugh.

"Chloe look, just- just watch this." Her arm wavers and retracts to her side. Her gaze is dubious, and slightly cautious, but she's watching. There's always a part of her that wants to believe.

You spread your arms, as if for her to verify that you are definitely sitting there, then with a muttered "Ow..." you get yourself up from the bed, and pace over to the side of the room her door is on. She follows you with her head, face becoming more incredulous by the second.

With a sigh, you spread your arms again, raising your right just a bit higher. Then, you pull the colour from the world, watching Chloe's head reverse-follow you from the bed, and then cancel the rewind at approximately when you think you spread your arms the first time.

"Ta-da." You say, your voice flat.

Chloe's head whips around as her whole body tenses and she jumps in surprise. Well, she's wide awake now.

"Holy shit Max, wha- what the fuck?" You give a little shrug. "But- you- You said time powers, but you teleported!"

You shrug again. "I walked over here, then rewound- uh, turned back time to before you saw me walk over."

She gapes at you, leaning back on her elbows on the bed. "Does that mean that I just- or… I guess, one of me? Just watched you walk over there and pose like an idiot?"

You give her a small grin. "Smartass." Maybe one more example… just to prove it. This doesn't count. You raise your right arm a bit and twist the threads.

Chloe gapes at you, leaning back on her elbows on the bed. "Does-"

You cut her off. "Yes Chloe, that means some other you just watched me walk over here and pose like an idiot." A weak, but nonetheless smarmy grin spreads across your face.

Chloe's eyebrows shoot up as she gapes at you for a second more. "Smartass…" She mutters. "That's cheating, but point taken…" Her expression turns serious. "Max, this is kind of…. Fucking awesome. But… you didn't answer my question."

She watches you go back to the bed before speaking. "Why are you here? Like. I appreciate you trusting me with this and all, and it really is hella cool. But why me?"

[] Write In
Ya, I'm making y'all do a write-in for this one. What's Max's attitude towards Chloe going to be like? You're in a world that became different from yours before you even canonically got your powers, what's to say Chloe's in the same danger as before?

≅≅≅​
PAGE TWO! GIVE IT UP FOR PAGE TWO!
(Chloe is gonna have one more question for you after this, then you'll be going to bed. Make sure to let me know anything you wanna get said before then.)
 
I'll give it a try.

[x] You're so important to me. This isn't...this isn't the first time I've done this. All of this. Bad shit just...keeps happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about, over and over. I don't know why, and I...I t-try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Not for long. I'm just so...so tired. I just want to see my best friend again.
 
Let's just be honest: You've been doing the time thing for a while, as in "Modern day tragic hero" while. You started all of this to save her life, but every time you're forced to either let her die or allow a storm to destroy Acadia Bay- because Time really doesn't like being screwed with.

Just, make it clear Max is trying to force a third happy option, and just won't stop even though others would of gave up long ago.
 
Let's just be honest: You've been doing the time thing for a while, as in "Modern day tragic hero" while. You started all of this to save her life, but every time you're forced to either let her die or allow a storm to destroy Acadia Bay- because Time really doesn't like being screwed with.

Just, make it clear Max is trying to force a third happy option, and just won't stop even though others would of gave up long ago.
I agree, but that doesn't seem like a now response. She's not asking for our whole motivation and questline, she wants to know why her friend showed up at 1 AM and with magic.

Better to save the motive talks for the morning, I think.
 
[x] You're so important to me. This isn't...this isn't the first time I've done this. All of this. Bad shit just...keeps happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about, over and over. I don't know why, and I...I t-try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Not for long. I'm just so...so tired. I just want to see my best friend again.
 
[x] You're so important to me. This isn't...this isn't the first time I've done this. All of this. Bad shit just...keeps happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about, over and over. I don't know why, and I...I t-try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Not for long. I'm just so...so tired. I just want to see my best friend again.
 
[x] You're so important to me. This isn't...this isn't the first time I've done this. All of this. Bad shit just...keeps happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about, over and over. I don't know why, and I...I t-try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Not for long. I'm just so...so tired. I just want to see my best friend again.
 
I think PMMM is already out. We could get really meta right now.

We could tell her that we're Homura, she's Madoka, Walpurgisnacht is coming. Round 14, here we go again.

Ah, but there's no garuntee they've both seen it.

So thinking ahead, how are we getting Nathan and Jefferson arrested without the former standing over Chloe's warm corpse.

I mean, I guess we could steal a gun and ambush them at their own bunker in the woods, Max is probably crazy enough to go through with it at this point (they can be our Oriko and Kirika!) but probably healthier for both her and Chloe not to start murdering people.

I could go either way.

She probably hasn't tried that yet, 14 loops is pretty early, I don't think Homura went ice cold killer for a while after that. Especially since Max is doing weeks not months.

I'd also like to acknowledge in passing with Chloe at some point that despite the superpowers being true we are probably crazy.
 
Last edited:
Nathan is a mess, but someone who clearly needs proper help. Not emotionally abusive parents, peers who just see him as a living dumpster fire, and certainly not that excuse for a human being.

Dealing with Jefferson is easy enough, Max did just that in a couple timelines during Episode 5. Honestly, her biggest problem is just the storm and making sure the abnormalities isn't just Time being mad at her.
 
Voting is now closed

[X] You're so important to me. This isn't...this isn't the first time I've done this. All of this. Bad shit just...keeps happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about, over and over. I don't know why, and I...I t-try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Not for long. I'm just so...so tired. I just want to see my best friend again.
Spector29, Markala, 7ime1ock, Teen Spirit
[X] Kkutlord's response.
Kkutlord

I'll always argue that at their core, PMMM, Life is Strange, and Steins;Gate are all essentially the same story. Different permutations and wholly different ways of delivering the plot, as well as different messages being brought across, but ultimately about one thing. The universally relatable wish that we could go back and change actions we regret, and have infinite chances to not push away people who we love or have loved.

Of course, there's something to be said that each of those pieces of media also contain a, usually harsh, refutation of that wish, but I don't wanna get too preachy.

Note too though, that while this story is based on Life is Strange. It is not Life is Strange.

I'd also like to acknowledge in passing with Chloe at some point that despite the superpowers being true we are probably crazy.
Noted.
 
Last edited:
1.06
Thinking about why… You almost laugh. Almost. Why would anyone subject themselves to this? Each time you tried you knew just a bit more than the last. Memorized a few more conversations, found more ways to get things done faster. Each time hoping, praying that it would be enough to tip things in your favour, enough to get Chloe out of the unfair fucking grudge Arcadia Bay seems to have for her.

That's the crux of it, isn't it? Chloe. You're doing it for her. For her.

You open your mouth, but the sudden feeling of wetness trickling down your face has you shutting it prematurely and looking into your lap. You wipe your eyes with your sleeves that hang down well past your hand.

You feel, from the way the bed dimples, Chloe scooch up closer to you. Not close, but closer. You look up, her face shows worry, almost a protectiveness. Guess she didn't expect that response to her question.

Well, neither did you, you suppose.

Emotion floods up from your chest where it feels like your heart is caught in a vice grip. The words just come spilling out. "You're so important to me Chloe and this isn-" Your voice hitches breathily and you choke back another sob. "This isn't the first time I've done this, all- all of this. Bad shit just keep happening, to you, to me, to everybody I know and care about. Just- over, and over, and over-" You bury your face in your sleeves and try to keep quiet as shudders wrack your body, frail as it is.

You distantly hear Chloe get up and come back. When she speaks her voice is uncertain, scared even, but gentle. "Hey, Max, here." You unbury your face from your sleeves and see her offering you a box of tissues.

"Th-thanks." You take the whole box and pull a few tissues from it. Chloe is quiet as you blow your nose and recompose yourself.

One last swallow to try to clear the lump of irrational guilt and fear of rejection in your throat - nope- and you continue. "I don't- I don't know why bad shit keeps happening, I try and try to fix things but so far it's never worked. Never for long. Never for long enough." You look up at her, blinking your watery eyes enough to focus your vision. She looks back intently, hanging on your every word, thinking. "I'm just so… so tired, Chloe. I just…" You break eye contact and your voice fades to almost a whisper. "I just want to see my best friend again."

Chloe keeps her silence, and you chance a glance up. Awh. You recognize that expression. She's thinking, hard. Her brow is furrowed and her eyes narrowed, staring, almost glaring to the side, as if the answers to all the questions fighting for attention in her head are hiding just out of sight.

Her face suddenly relaxes and her piercing, blue-eyed gaze swings back to you. "Max, I-" Her voice wavers with uncertainty, before her jaw sets and she continues in her smooth alto. "This is... a lot." You nod as she continues. "But Max, even if I don't really get everything yet, I'm…" She sighs. "I'm on your side, okay?" She reaches out and awkwardly kinda pats your shoulder before withdrawing sheepishly. "Besides!" She says with a forced brightness. "You've got totally badass superpowers now, what kind of idiot would I be to just kick you out now?"

You offer a wan smile at that, which she readily accepts with a grin of her own. A flurry of white movement from what little you can see of the window catches your attention, and your smiles falls as you scoot forward on the bed. Oh no…

Chloe gives you a confused look, then follows your gaze, standing up and peering over her desk out the window. "Snow?" She says. "In October?"

Your mind races. This is… different. Not much different, but different. You're sure the snow usually falls in the afternoon, you usually see it with Chloe at the lighthouse right as the sun is setting.

"Yo, Earth to Max?" Chloe's voice rings in your ear for a second as you shake your head and refocus your eyes. "You good?"

"Sorry, uh- yeah." A small nod in return.

"Let's try to grab some shuteye, okay? Hopefully a few hours of sleep before my mom wakes us up." She pauses at that thought. "Yeesh. Explaining you might be a doozy…"

You giggle quietly. "I guess so…" She gives a smile back before tucking into her side of the bed.

You're about to let yourself drift off after she shuts the light off, but you feel her prop herself up, so you roll over towards her. "Everything alright?" Her face is pensive in the cool evening light, shadows of snowflakes cast a dimly dancing show over her closet, portending a coming calamity you don't even want to start thinking about tonight.

"You said time powers, right?" She speaks slowly, as if restraining herself. You give a small nod. "What if- ugh." She pauses, searching for the words. "After you… left. I had a close friend." Icy nervousness suddenly clamps in the pit of your stomach. "She… disappeared like six months ago and she hasn't been found." She looks at you, her restrained words belying the childlike hope that burns softly in her eyes. "Do you think… your powers could help find her? Or even make it so she never went missing?"

You roll onto your back, breaking the eye contact. You don't think you can. Not without soft photojumping to your time in Seattle and only having god knows how long to warn Rachel about Jefferson, and that would only help if she took you seriously.

But… you consider. There's more going on this time. The woman in the hospital room, who you don't think was a hallucination. The woman who was familiar in so many ways, yet none felt like tics you'd seen on anyone you know. She had glowing tattoos, she could draw in the air, she appeared to you out of nowhere then went right back to that nowhere. Do you want to risk telling Chloe you can and possibly crush her even harder if - when- you do find Rachel? Do you want to just tell her what happened? The options feel like a crushing vice pushing the breath out of your chest.

[] Write in

≅≅≅
I have a tendency to outwardly screw my face up to match the emotion of words I'm reading in a book or hearing in a movie or play, and I suppose I do it while writing too cause all the muscles in my face feel like they just ran a marathon lmao. Thanks for the very well worded write-in Spector29, that gave me a lot to work with.​
 
Well, we could always have Max explain that it'll require a lot of effort to affect things that far back. That, and explain there's tons of unknown variables when toying with the past. Like, a totally-hypothetical-example being saving one people from being crippled (cause dying is... totally just an impairment) ends in someone else getting disabled.

So basically, Chloe would need to share as much as possible if Max is going to minimize any crazy changes to the timeline, like them being friends with Victoria- which is totally just a hypothetical example, yes sir.
 
[X] Plan Interesting Name
[X] Agree to help. Try to find her in this timeline first.
-[X] If she's dead, consider (meaning vote in thread) jumping back to Seattle and warning Rachel about Jefferson.
--[X] Repeat said conversation until she takes you seriously and you are satisfied with the present timeline. If that fails, do things according to the original timeline.
-[X] Warn Chloe about Rachel possibly being dead or worse and the consequences if we use our power to change the timeline. Also, tell her about us trying to find as much as we can in this timeline.
--[X] Include telling Chloe how our efforts could possibly make everything worse, for Rachel or others.
--[X] Tell her what happened (before?).
-[X] Rest first and have a plan to explain your presence in the morning, if we're not hiding.
-[X] Get Chloe to tell all she knows about Rachel, if it's useful to us.


So, what about doing something like this? Also, tell me if I should add/remove something.

Edit: Changed some things.

Edit 2:
[X] Plan Butterfly

I like this plan much better.

Edit 3:
[x] Plan Letting Her Down Easy

Changed vote again.
 
Last edited:
She probably hasn't tried that yet, 14 loops is pretty early, I don't think Homura went ice cold killer for a while after that. Especially since Max is doing weeks not months.

I'd also like to acknowledge in passing with Chloe at some point that despite the superpowers being true we are probably crazy.
Homura went through roughly the same month for roughly the equivalent of ten years. Max has been going through the same week for nearly three months. This Max has a long way to go before she goes through what Homura did but Homura had a full month, I think. A week is far more stressful and gives Max far FAR less to work with.
 
Clairifying Question: Have we tried saving Rachel? It would cost Max relatively nothing to try out, and it would matter for our answer if we did or not.
 
Last edited:
Clairifying Question: Have we tried saving Rachel? It would cost Max relatively nothing to try out, and it would matter for our answer if we did or not.
After the debacle with the Alternate Timeline, Max focused her efforts exclusively on the "Canon" timeline, for reasons noted in the photojump power description. Any attempts to save Rachel using her current set of powers would risk the aforementioned issues.

Essentially she was lucky that she was able to revert the changes with the Alternate Timeline due to the same photograph existing in the Alternate Timeline, but her worry with soft jumps is that anywhere in between when she jumps and when her anchor photo was taken, the photograph could end up destroyed, making it impossible to revert.
 
We can try, but we're not in any condition to right now. Just escaped from a hospital, was in a coma.

[ Plan Butterfly
-[Agree to work out a plan, Explain the mechanics of our powers. Explain how we have to be sure the photo survives so we can try again.
-[ Explain how we tried to save her dad in the beginning but she ended up dying instead. Don't give details. It's always like that, if you change one thing, something else is changed to match. It seems like time demands equivalent exchange.
-[Explain we already know the killers, and how her step-dad has caught or killed them before, but we're gonna hold that info until she promise not to immediately go after them, they've killed both him and us before.
-[Also tell her this whole thing started when we first went back to stop Nathan from killing her in the school bathroom, turns out he's unstab and it's really easy to send him into a complete breakdown. Actually, go a little into how Chloe seems to be cursed, she gets killed constantly. Like holy shit Chloe, almost every day you managed to get killed, it's worse than an escort mission.
-[Plan to explain your presence in the morning. Not too hard, our parents aren't likely to wake up any time soon and we were alone in the hospital.
-[Make the inevitable PMMM and Steins: references to help her understand.

P.S. Sorry, been convinced otherwise

Invistext says we're not alone
 
Last edited:
Well, we could always have Max explain that it'll require a lot of effort to affect things that far back. That, and explain there's tons of unknown variables when toying with the past. Like, a totally-hypothetical-example being saving one people from being crippled (cause dying is... totally just an impairment) ends in someone else getting disabled.

So basically, Chloe would need to share as much as possible if Max is going to minimize any crazy changes to the timeline, like them being friends with Victoria- which is totally just a hypothetical example, yes sir.
That's not a bad idea.

[x] Plan Letting Her Down Easy
[x] "It's...remember when I mentioned I've d-done this before? This...isn't the first time you've asked." (Pause for reaction and to answer clarifying questions about power mechanics) "I can help. I...m-maybe know where Rachel is. If she's not there, there might be...we might have a chance." (Pause again in case she catches the implication she's already dead)
-[x] "But Chloe...things are different this time. The a-accident is new. Rachel...Things with Rachel might be different too. I promise I'll do what I can to help you, regardless." (Pause for response)
-[x] "Chloe, with all the timeline changes...You've got to tell me if anything's different. Not-...Not now, in the morning, but it's Important. Time travel is...dangerous, and unstable, and...if try to do anything major...there's a chance I never come back at all.

Anything else (like the full power infodump) can wait till the morning, and this:
-[X] Also tell her this whole thing started when we first went back to stop Nathan from killing her in the school bathroom, turns out he's unstab and it's really easy to send him into a complete breakdown. Actually, go a little into how Chloe seems to be cursed, she gets killed constantly. Like holy shit Chloe, almost every day you managed to get killed, it's worse than an escort mission.
Is definitely not going to end well. This is a fresh loop, we've got to build a little trust and rapport before saying things like that.
 
Back
Top