- Location
- universe
If he threatened to kill him, he should follow through with it. Empty threats serve no use but bluster, which is the worst thing that an officer can be seen to do.
Otherwise, good fic.
Otherwise, good fic.
I think you're coming at it from a very modern perspective which is alien to Youjo Senki. Remember the lynching and the man hung as a traitor? This is not a society of powerful media and hard checks on authority. Interfering with the military could easily be considered treason, and any attempt to moralize that 'how could I think children are soldiers', or discount the kids as capable of volunteering, could be considered criticism of the military's ethics- very, very dangerous if not suicidal.Unlikely. They will probably get reprimanded half-heartedly by their superiors, but that will be all. The simple fact is that most people are going to agree that Tanya and Frederik are too young and thus will have little interest in punishing those who treat them as children.
That would not help as they were in the train so you could not fly very high without blasting a hole in the roof and flying low inside the train would be mistaken for simple wire tricks.You can fake papers, he probably doesn't have the skills to discern a milspec computation orb, and uniforms are just clothes. Flying up 50 yards under your own power is harder to fake. And flight mages have an uncrossable gap.
Maybe not jail time, even the harshest judge would be hard pressed to declare that two ten years old with military documents are not a little out of the norm, especially if they are already graduates from officer's school so the controller got a reasonable and legal enough motive to do what he is doing. That said I do fully agree with your reasoning but I would also add that they are probably going to feel at least a little guilty for forgetting that those two do come with some obvious disadvantages that a normal soldier of either sex would normally face and that they should have taken their circumstances into account.I think there is an element of cognitive dissonance between the academy and it's military and society at large. Those officers will be among the most jingoistic and buy into the idea that the volunteers for the military, scum or not, are heroes who want to save the Fatherland. Any civilians who failed to volunteer will be set next to that with the idea the volunteers are more virtuous because of their courage and sacrifices. That will be the academy's ideology.
Frederick and Tanya come into that as the most radical examples of volunteers making sacrifices for the Fatherland- risking their lives and giving up their childhood. Then they not only keep up with the curriculum but excel at strategy, a discipline higher ranking officers identify with themselves. They are also really, really cute. It's not the way of the military to give praise, but the level of affection and pride the academy officers have in Frederick and Tanya is probably absurd.
The academy officers undoubtedly did not assign a minder because they are confident in the children's proven competence and their own authority as expressed by the papers the kids were given. No one should dare question written orders in the military unless they are betting their ass. For civilians to interfere with military orders is straight-up criminal.
Now some pathetic civilian scum train operators are questioning the express written authority of the high ranking officers, shaming the brightest heroes of the Fatherland, and disrupting military logistics. They may be questioning the ethics of military and working against the war effort if it is chosen to be seen that way. I'd bet someone is doing jail time at the least.
'They sure are cute together.' think almost everyone who see them"You never change, right? You'll always be a pragmatic psycho!"
"And you will always be an idealistic fool!"
The amateur part probably coming from his business related psychology classes he must have taken at college or as part of his office training which is why he knows so much about manipulating people but is so easily surprised when people act in the direct opposite way he expected since his target audience is not composed from subordinates, coworkers and bosses but instead of the military equivalent which despite sharing just enough common points with their modern civilian counterparts for Tanya to relate their interaction with office politics they got varied motivations and their definition of common sense is so different from Tanya that she always falls into traps of her own making by expecting people to respond to her signaling the way she planned instead of them misundertanding her actions and doing the opposite.Hehe. Nice! A lot of Tanya's intelligence and manipulative side got lost in the anime, but part of her former incarnation's opinionated nature came from the fact he was not just a skilled manipulator, but also an amateur psychologist.
Kidnapped two Warrant Officers, believing they were two children.
If they are warrant officers, they are the ones that need to salute upon seeing the 2nd lieutenant, that's a commissioned officer rank and outrank warrant officers, then he returns the salute, not the opposite. Sure, everyone is green as hell, and the 2nd Lt. might be inclined to overlook it given their age, if he even gets himself together from the surprise, but I'd expect Tanya to be very well versed in military protocol at this point, and not pass what she thinks an opportunity to impress.The soldier saluted "Second Lieutenant Pruttman, I'm here to take you both at the base of Saufort by order of the Commander!"
What the hell?! The official translation uses that, even if in a single passage, I can only guess as a massive blind idiot translation, given how good the author generally is on military minutia. Maybe meant the Fahnrich rank, then the author translated to the closest Japanese term, which got translated into English?
If they are warrant officers, they are the ones that need to salute upon seeing the 2nd lieutenant, that's a commissioned officer rank and outrank warrant officers, then he returns the salute, not the opposite. Sure, everyone is green as hell, and the 2nd Lt. might be inclined to overlook it given their age, if he even gets himself together from the surprise, but I'd expect Tanya to be very well versed in military protocol at this point, and not pass what she thinks an opportunity to impress.
Basically, a 2nd Lt. still has a higher rank than Warrant officers. Therefor, Frederick and Tanya should be the ones saluting here.
WO is the "middle" between NCOs and Officers if I remember correctly.
looked at her badly. Was true that we were both adults in bodies of children, but beautiful things did not have an age limit to be appreciated.
"I'm sorry… Warrant Officers Degurechaff and Konig?" said a voice I did not knew.
We both looked in its direction. A skinny soldier in uniform of the Imperial Army was looking at us with disconcert.
"Yes. Who are you?"
The soldier saluted "Second Lieutenant Pruttman, I'm here to take you both at the base of Saufort by order of the Commander!"
"Thank you" I said saluting back "Shall we move?"
From this paragraph, it is the 2nd Lt. who salutes first, which goes against protocol. It should be Frederick and Tanya salute him first. Then the man would salute back.
Which I think was a mistranslation in the official English version of the books, because generally speaking, a Warrant Officer would be someone in a highly specialized track, outranking enlisted and Non-Comissioned personnel, but still not having an officer commission. Historically, as I understand, it came to be in the Royal Navy, to handle that it had a highly aristocratic officer corps, but had too many highly technical roles in a ship that needed skilled personnel.
This isn't actually the case. The deployment to Norden is actually a her final training exercise before graduating. That is why when the Entente invades Tanya gets field promoted to second lieutenant since that shifts her from legally still being an officer cadet, and thus not legally allowed to fight, to being an officer and thus able to be sent into battle.
I don't have the Anime on hand to check, but the wiki says she graduated and THEN was assigned to the artillery squad in Norden.This isn't actually the case. The deployment to Norden is actually a her final training exercise before graduating. That is why when the Entente invades Tanya gets field promoted to second lieutenant since that shifts her from legally still being an officer cadet, and thus not legally allowed to fight, to being an officer and thus able to be sent into battle.
I haven't read the LNs so I don't know if they go into detail but my guess would be that during these training deployments officer cadets are given temporary non-com ranks to enable them to legally fulfill their duties. Which normally probably consists of bossing around a bunch of enlisted.
So Tanya's page on the wiki says:I don't have the Anime on hand to check, but the wiki says she graduated and THEN was assigned to the artillery squad in Norden.
However the anime is quite clear on this:Tanya successfully graduated from the Military Training Camp at the age of 9 after-which she was promptly promoted to Warrant Officer and put in command of the artillery firing squad before being deployed on her first Mission.
So maybe this is a difference between the anime vs. the LN and/or manga or alternatively the people writing the wiki may have misunderstood what Tanya was saying with "I finished my training".Episode 2 - 11:15 onwards said:But afterward, I finished my training. The only thing missing before graduation was to finish my training deployment in the North
Ah, the two infinity things are at it again: human stupidity and politician promises