This Tarot deck is a dick, wow. I swear there are cards in here that aren't personal attacks on the character you made, honest.
Hey, this is par for the course for a dream journey, right? :V

[X] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
[X][ANTE] Four of Cups

Mechanically speaking at worst we lose 1 Willpower (and are already at 4/6 explorations) and get nothing from this exploration, so why not? (Three of Swords would also work, but I'd rather not potentially lose that connection lol)
 
Hm. The Page of Wands gave us the option to spend a willpower for a guaranteed Supernal resource. Here, we have to spend a willpower for just a chance at the resource, with a chance at capital L Losing something from our Pneuma. Two data points isn't enough to properly put together a trend, but it does seem appropriate in this metaphor for the "Face Cards" (right now, the Page and the Knight) to be particularly potent - so I suspect that a 1:1 trade of Willpower to Supernal resources is a "good deal", and will calibrate my expectations accordingly for the moment.

I'm not certain how important the Pneuma is as a resource just yet - certainly the Aces seem like something we don't want to give up unless it's actually important to do so, but how much does Losing the Four of Cups itself from our Pneuma (and more broadly, from our deck) matter, for instance?

From a mechanistic perspective, I'm leaning towards not taking the gamble just so we can gather more data on how things operate before making potentially permanent decisions - but I'm concerned that might just be my loss aversion talking, and on a narrative level I'm not sure constantly "playing it safe" will mean good things for our character.
 
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.

11/24 is absolute garbage odds when the standard set so far is at least a guaranteed Pneuma pickup or Supernal resource for 1 Willpower.
Mechanically speaking at worst we lose 1 Willpower (and are already at 4/6 explorations) and get nothing from this exploration, so why not?
Well, perhaps because Willpower is our literal most precious resource, and spending it for no gain would be incredibly wasteful?

Plus, given that we've seen an opportunity to substitute an Aura for a Willpower already, it's not like moving on is without its own potential benefits.
 
[X] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
[X][ANTE] Four of Cups
 
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.
[X][ANTE] Three of Swords
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, I am surprised by how few votes were cast this time around. The lack of votes on Day 0 made sense to me, because that was a plan vote that was kind of complicated (and I'm thinking about whether I want to handle Night 2 differently and see if people like it better), but this vote was pretty straightforward, very close, and still only barely cracked double digits. Is it just the mechanics that are the stumbling block? If so, uh, that's unfortunate because "vote on how to handle a thing you run into in the dream" is going to be the vast majority of votes.
Well at least personally, i'd intended to catch up and vote, but uh. Then i got sucked into the addiction that is In Stars and Time, so... luckily for you i escaped a little sooner today than i did yesterday :V

[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.
 
The best case is Pneuma card + Supernal Connection + new card in Ascent Deck though, which seems like something we might want eventually?

(@picklepikkl To check my understanding of mechanics, Aura cards basically never go back into the Ascent Deck, right?)
You've misread the option, I think. The card that is revealed from the Ascent Deck gets shuffled back into the Ascent Deck, it's not a new card moving there from the Unseen. You do not currently have any Auras. So the best case is a WP for a card added to the Pneuma and a Supernal Connection, and the worst case is a WP for one card added to the Pneuma and one card Lost from the Pneuma (which can be the same card, but don't have to be).
[] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
But you are correct that Auras do not by any means you know of go back into the Ascent Deck. They can either be spent and go to Lost (as the Five of Swords did) or at the end of the Night any unspent Auras go to Lost. That's the way it works by default, and you have not seen anything yet that messes with that. Does that answer your question?
 
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.
In that case, better not to be rash with this thing, it's not worth the chance of their mental state absolutely tanking on a failure lol
 
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.

Take the guaranteed win.

I liked the fight as a post-battle discussion. Keeps the dream mysterious and vague.
 
Last edited:
Er, whoops. Sorry! I've been trying to maintain a near-daily update pace (i.e. "pulling a Boney") both because it's psychologically good for me to maintain momentum and because hopefully "hey, this is being updated regularly" is a charm point that can balance out the "this is original content" issue Deathbybunnies brought up. But I guess that creates issues for people who aren't as terminally online as I am. I don't want you to get left behind, especially since you contributed a bunch of key ideas during the character creation votes!

Anyway, update imminent.
I think I'm an outlier, because I almost exclusively read original content quests. If you're doing a daily update thing some of us are gonna fall behind, and some people will inevitably miss a vote or two. That being said it will probably be good for attracting new readers.
 
I want to see what's in our heart. That kind of self-insight can hurt to be sure, but it's better to know.
[X] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
[X][ANTE] Four of Cups
 
Last edited:
I want to see what's in our heart. That kind of self-insight can hurt to be sure, but it's better to know.
It's true that you probably want to know this kind of stuff early, before you go too far in the Ascent and have to stick to the path you already carved?

[X] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
[X][ANTE] Four of Cups
 
That turned out pretty well!

I don't think I like this gamble. Definitely losing Willpower to maybe gain a resource feels bad on its own, but then on top of that we may also loss a card from our Pneuma? Reading the description of the Pneuma in the rules:
Your Pneuma contains your triumphs, your capacities, and your internal reservoirs of power -- everything that you have achieved, and acquired, through brave and capable dreaming. At the start of the quest, it contains:
  • 0 The Fool, representing your native magic and versatility as a questing occultist
  • The Ace of each suit, representing the potential for various Aspirations that you hold within yourself
So losing The Fool would mean losing our magic??? That seems pretty disastrous. Losing the Aces similarly seems bad, losing a fundamental part of our potential for growth. Losing our newly gained Page of Wands probably means losing our connection with Idra? Also seems bad. That leaves the Three of Swords and Four of Cups, but:
-What is the symbolism of losing the Four of Cups immediately after gaining it? We go into the museum, we look at our heart and the hearts of others, and our response is such that we fail to retain anything? Wouldn't that mean that we responded so badly to what we learned that we actually earned nothing?
-Losing the Three of Swords sounds like it would be good, since the vulture is bad, right? But an obvious reason for the vulture to leave us is if it already got if fill. Getting a look at our own soul sounds like the kind of thing that could lead to the kind of breakdown the vulture may feast on.

So yeah, I don't like this deal. Thanks but no thanks.
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.

On the other hand, I can definitely see the narrative argument for going for this. Though I would suggest those who feel that way give more thought to the narrative implications of the various potential losses.

[X][ANTE] Three of Swords
 
Last edited:
I liked the fight as a post-battle discussion. Keeps the dream mysterious and vague.
Thanks! I spent like two hours struggling to depict the duel in an entertaining way and failing before I realized I could just... not write the duel, and instead focus on the character interaction, which is the most important part of Idra's section. This also has the added benefit that the stiff formality of their early interactions is jammed right next to the more comfortable banter of their later interactions without anything in between to buffer the contrast.
So losing The Fool would mean losing our magic??? That seems pretty disastrous.
I would probably write a Loss of the Fool as damaging your facility with the elemental magics of the dreaming-realm, specifically on the "versatility" side of things; if there is a game-over condition associated with the Loss of cards from your Pneuma, or even a lesser mechanical consequence (like how each Ace you Lose locks you out of specific categories of Aspiration), I promise I'll tell you.
-What is the symbolism of losing the Four of Cups immediately after gaining it? We go into the museum, we look at our heart and the hearts of others, and our response is such that we fail to retain anything? Wouldn't that mean that we responded so badly to what we learned that we actually earned nothing?
That's basically exactly how I'd do it if you anted 4C and lost the draw, yeah: the experience of seeing your own heart would be sufficiently upsetting that you would not gain any insights from seeing the hearts of others.

(As a note, reminder that even those voting against going into the gallery can cast an [ANTE] vote.)
 
[X] Spend 1 Willpower: Add this card to your Pneuma and reveal the top card of the Ascent Deck. If it is a Two, Three, Four, or Five, Lose the winner of the [ANTE] vote from your Pneuma, or gain a Supernal Connection if it is anything else. Then shuffle the revealed card into the Ascent Deck.
[X][ANTE] Four of Cups
 
Hmm.

On a narrative level, if we are going to gamble on it, I think we should do so with the three of swords.

The "worst case scenario" there would be that we look at our heart, have a breakdown, and the vulture leaves after feasting upon our misery. We would still, however, carry the knowledge of what our heart is like (aka have the Four of Hearts in our Pneuma), and thus could start working on mending whatever was so rotten it caused the breakdown in the first place.

(Mechanically, on a "failed gamble", we'd be spending a Willpower to trade the Three of Swords for a Four of Cups in our Pneuma.)

[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.
[X][ANTE] Three of Swords
 
Last edited:
Mechanics aside, I don't think Ash the character is ready for this.

[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.
[X][ANTE] Three of Swords
This Tarot deck is a dick, wow. I swear there are cards in here that aren't personal attacks on the character you made, honest.
Plot twist: The deck totally is a dick, and this isn't the ascent. It's the descent. *spooky lightning* 👻
 
I think this one proves that the deck is very sassy, not just to us but to the QM.
So, last week, I was at a holiday party with my friends. ("But there are no major holidays at the vernal equinox this year!" you might protest. Gentle reader, do not worry about it.) As part of the festivities, the host was performing Tarot readings. I, of course, got in on that action. To save time, we were doing simple three-card spreads, past present and future. My query was simple: what's the outlook on my current creative project?

The card for the past was the Seven of Cups, a card signifying potential, imagination, and daydreaming. And, like, yes. I know that my previous attempts at long-form creative writing have all gotten bogged down in the planning phase. I am well aware of the fact that I get lost in the enjoyment of thinking about how cool it will be and then rob myself of the motivation to actually make the damn thing. But, like, did it have to say so, publicly, in front of all my friends and also an impressionable toddler whose view of me is now no doubt forever tainted?

(Something like this also happened the last time I got a reading from him. Little in this world has made me question my rational-materialistic view of reality quite so much as the way his Tarot deck invariably goes for my jugular.)
 
(Something like this also happened the last time I got a reading from him. Little in this world has made me question my rational-materialistic view of reality quite so much as the way his Tarot deck invariably goes for my jugular.)
Tarot seems to be quite fond of you. You're even running this very quest because of it! <3
 
[X] Take a breath, and move on: Gain this card as an Aura.

Yeah I do not like those odds
 
I have been suitably convinced that the four of cups is more valuable than the three of swords.
So, last week, I was at a holiday party with my friends. ("But there are no major holidays at the vernal equinox this year!" you might protest. Gentle reader, do not worry about it.) As part of the festivities, the host was performing Tarot readings. I, of course, got in on that action. To save time, we were doing simple three-card spreads, past present and future. My query was simple: what's the outlook on my current creative project?

The card for the past was the Seven of Cups, a card signifying potential, imagination, and daydreaming. And, like, yes. I know that my previous attempts at long-form creative writing have all gotten bogged down in the planning phase. I am well aware of the fact that I get lost in the enjoyment of thinking about how cool it will be and then rob myself of the motivation to actually make the damn thing. But, like, did it have to say so, publicly, in front of all my friends and also an impressionable toddler whose view of me is now no doubt forever tainted?

(Something like this also happened the last time I got a reading from him. Little in this world has made me question my rational-materialistic view of reality quite so much as the way his Tarot deck invariably goes for my jugular.)

Potential imagination and daydreaming implies that your storytelling has potential for you to realize, which is a pretty good way to start I'd say.

[x] [ANTE] Three of Swords
 
Back
Top