Voting is open
Fighting with Depression - by Meowgician
Fighting with Depression

"So, I can't help but notice," Remarked Alejandro Ortiz with a raised eyebrow, tilting his head at the wind-swept cliff covered in grass and the calm sea reflecting the sun below. "This environment seems to favour me very heavily. Not very promising for you, given I usually win our little spars."

"That's why you're letting me get some set-up in," Responded Iván as he pushed the last full-length mirror into place. "Gotta level the playing field, otherwise you'll just stomp me, and you can't work off your sadness like that, now can you?"

"And yet this is nowhere near enough." Alejandro glanced at the twelve mirrors surrounding him, still not moving from his position with his arms crossed. "You're planning something. You think, no, you're certain it's going to be enough to win."

"Aren't you going to ask me what it is?"

"Don't waste our time, you wouldn't tell me." Alejandro finally shifted from his position, kneeling down to pluck some blades of grass from the ground and practically sighed out out his transformation phrase "Let's get this over with… Enough."

The ever-present breeze increased in intensity and swirled around Alejandro, picking up pollen and fragments of willow catkin from nowhere until it formed an almost ethereal pink cocoon around him, visible yet not quite real. By the time the wind died down and the pollen evaporated into the ether, he'd transformed into Willow in the Wind, all without budging a single inch.

"Banter is never a waste of time! Maybe if you weren't such a killjoy you wouldn't be so depressed." This needling earned him a sharp glare from his otherwise impassive brother, before his face once more settled into the calm mask of neutrality.

"Alright, alright, I'm sorry, I just… You've been stuck in this rut for so long…" Iván's trademark smile faded for a moment, before returning in full force. "Calm waters, reflect my soul!"

Iván took a step forward and the floor beneath his foot rippled as though it were shallow water he had stepped on and not solid ground. He took another without missing a beat and his front foot sank into the ground with no resistance, followed by the rest of his body falling forwards with his back foot as an anchor to rotate around. Not a moment later, he had emerged, fully transformed into Lotus on Still Waters, from the rippling ground, or rather fallen out of it, still walking forwards like nothing out of the ordinary had happened.

Then, leaving no time after the end of his transformation, Lotus dashed straight at Willow, who for his part, ignored the feint and instead took a moment to imbue the grass he'd plucked with some extra reality, fashioning them into sharp and dense pieces of flora truly deserving to be called blades. Then, as Lotus turned on a dime and dove into one of the mirrors, Willow began throwing the blades at the mirrors surrounding him, counting down as he shattered them.

11…

Lotus silently emerged feet-first from the mirror behind Willow, his left hand catching the top edge,

10…

The momentum both driving him in a loop above it and pushing it forwards,

9…

And then even faster and further as Lotus completed his loop and kicked off it, aiming to engulf Willow with its rippling surface.

8…

This elicited a raised eyebrow from Willow, as he'd seen the entire scene play out on the mirror in front of him, so he simply elected to target the one behind him next,

7…

But Lotus was already jumping into his Starshoot, an ornate hand mirror, under the cover of the now shattered but still obscuring distraction,

6…

And allowing him to emerge from an unexpected angle, landing a dropkick that briefly stopped Willow from accumulating any more years of bad luck as he tumbled across the grass. Willow recovered swiftly and reached out with his own Starshoot, an ephemeral blue string that floated on wind currents not of this world, seeking to touch Lotus and weigh him down with his reality.

But Lotus had already retreated back into the closest mirror out of Willow's reach, and then immediately emerged in his blind spot, landing yet another hit. This turned out to have been a bad idea, however, as the Starshoot had been a feint, and Willow had shed enough of his own reality that the jab that would have put him on the back foot, or killed an ordinary human, merely disoriented him for a moment as it passed through his head with only some resistance, as though it were passing through honey.

This momentary disorientation, fortunately, gave Lotus just enough leeway to dodge Willow's outstretched hand by centimetres, and dive back into the mirror he'd emerged from, which Willow promptly shattered. Lotus had been moments away from losing the spar on the spot.

5...

As he emerged from another mirror, he did something he hadn't done the whole match, and stopped for a beat.

Willow stepped to the side as he threw another blade, expecting to narrowly dodge Lotus's Starshoot as it was called back to him,

4…

But that too, had been a feint, and as Willow's attention strayed behind him, Lotus took the opportunity to attack from an unexpected angle yet again, and land a devastating series of punches that would have won him the match, but with Willow shedding so much reality so fast, only made him stagger back, buying Lotus time to retreat, and bringing him closer to a victory that still continued to accelerate away.

So, for his final trick, Lotus emerged in front of Willow, and gestured at him to come with a mischievous grin. Willow simply looked impassively at him, and shattered the last mirror outside his line of sight.

3…

Lotus briefly shot back with an indignant glare as he stepped back in the mirror, then emerged from another one and feinted at Willow, who rushed forward to meet him only to see him dive back into safety. So Willow shattered one of the remaining mirrors, and reached with his Starshoot towards the other one, laying a trap he was sure Lotus could not escape,

2…

And instead of emerging from the last mirror, Lotus dove out of the one he had just entered, tackling Willow with enough force to win the spar a third time, but with Willow having so little reality left, it was only enough to cause both of them to lose their balance and tumble across the grass.

Lotus managed to recover few fractions of a second earlier, which was just enough time to get out of Willow's reach and get to a mirror, but not before Willow also got back up and shattered the penultimate one, leaving Lotus stranded with his back against a sheer drop into the ocean.

1…

What was left was less a game of cat and mouse, and more the final moves before checkmate. Lotus was ordinarily too fast for Willow to catch, but with so little space, and Willow slowly closing in, matching every feint with one of his own, all Lotus could do was slowly retreat holding his mirror as he was backed into a corner…

Until, mere metres away from Willow, Lotus grinned and shattered the last mirror he had been so jealously guarding…

0!

And levitated its shards for a moment before throwing them straight at Willow, who made no move to dodge.

"I am nothing."

Instead, he shed his last bits of reality, leaving nothing behind but the Image of Willow, which the shards passed through harmlessly. A beat later, the Image stepped to the side, having predicted exactly when Lotus would recall his Starshoot, at the same time reaching out with his own.


And with that single touch, it was over. Lotus dropped his Starshoot and his knees buckled under the suddenly increased weight of reality, but he remained standing, a testament to their many past spars.

"You've got to be the least enthusiastic tag player I've ever seen" He quipped with a smirk.

Willow backed away, not looking at Lotus, but at his Starshoot on the ground. "Just tap out and let's go home. We both know how this ends."

Any Hanazakari without Lotus's combination of strength, experience fighting Willow, and sheer, unbridled stubbornness would have collapsed under their own weight by now. Lotus instead raised a hand to his head, agonizingly slow and trembling with effort despite his mouth now widening into a full on grin, then did a two-fingered salute before flicking it at Willow.

"Sayonara, Sunshine!" And he fell backwards off the cliff and into the sea.

Willow simply walked to the edge, kicked Lotus's Starshoot off the edge as well, and backed off to observe the spot Lotus had jumped off of moments earlier, the touch of haste in his kick being the only thing to betray his anxiousness at knowing that Lotus was enacting his new trick, but still not knowing what it was.

Willow's attention having been successfully misdirected, he did not hear the shards rearrange themselves back into a complete mirror behind him, and was completely taken by surprise when Lotus shot out of it with all the momentum he'd built up with his fall off the cliff, and grabbed onto Willow's arm, taking advantage of all the extra reality he had been given to make sure Willow couldn't escape, and sending the both of them on a ballistic trajectory straight into the sea, cackling madly all the while.


"And scratch one more victory for me!" Lotus shouted over the wind as they flew (or, rather, fell with style) through the air. Willow, for his part, yanked his arm out of Lotus's grip with more than a little bit of anger because he already won he doesn't need to touch me why won't he let go.

"Don't you usually lose?" Willow responded after taking a moment to get back in control of his emotions.

"That just makes these victories all the sweeter!" Lotus responded, mania still dancing in his eyes as they reached the peak of their arc and gravity started to send them downwards once more.

"Will it still be sweet after we've both climbed back up to the car soaking wet?" Willow deadpanned, looking meaningfully at the blue sea that they had been accelerating towards all the while.

"I don't have to set a single foot in the sea to get back," Lotus stretched out his arm, offering a hand to Willow. "And neither do you."

Despite the wind rushing past them, and the sea being only moments away, Willow took a second to look disapprovingly at Lotus's outstretched hand, though he couldn't stop his smile at being offered the choice.

"I'll swi-"

*SPLASH*



"So, feeling better after your little swim?" Asked Iván as he tossed a towel at Alejandro, who responded with a non-committal grunt.

"That's not a no… So it means you're finally happy!" Iván piped up with cheer in his voice. Alejandro could almost believe it was genuine, if Iván weren't his brother. If it hadn't been so many years since he'd become a shell of his former self, an exterior of success with nothing on the inside.

Still, at least he should be honest. He'd already tried presenting that façade to his family, and it had only caused more pain for everyone involved.

"I'm not happy. Nor am I sad. I'm not anything. At least not until my emotions recover from using my powers."

"Still sounds like an upgrade to your usual depression!" Iván was still trying to keep things positive despite everything, bless his heart.

"Careful now, you might get accused of sympathizing with the Frost Fair!" Alejandro joked with a smile so faint and brief it might not have existed at all. It certainly wasn't genuine, no matter how hard he may have tried to make it so.

"I certainly wouldn't call it an upgrade in the sense you're thinking. There's no joy either, and even as it slowly comes back, it feels… I don't know how to fully explain it… Hollow?" Alejandro finished drying himself off, and handed the towel back to Iván as he gazed wistfully at the sea, melancholy creeping into his voice.

"At least when I'm feeling depressed, I feel like I'm still alive. And when it dies down to just a calm melancholy, it can even get a bit… comfortable, almost." He then shook his head, as if it would help clear his thoughts, and started to walk back to their parked car. "Still, it's nice to get a break from it every now and then."

Iván then began "Well, Sergio and I-" and he put his hand on Alejandro's shoulder and it's colder than a FUCKING FROSTFARER why won't he listen he knows I hate it getitoff!

"What the hell did I tell you about not touching me?!" Alejandro immediately snapped as he swatted Iván's hand away, his voice cracking under the weight of his sudden burst of anger.

"Come on, you were doing so good!" Iván complained, "Do you really have to make such a big deal out of it?"

Having the audacity to be indignant at me for wanting my personal space to be respected.

"Apparently, I do, because if I don't then you simply don't care!"

"Please, be reasonable. Let's just get in the car and go home." Iván said as he reached out to Alejandro once more.

This turned out to have been the wrong move yet again, as Alejandro managed to aggressively back away from the outstretched hand, even as his tone became more diplomatic.

"Just… Leave. I need some time alone to cool off. I'll make my own way back."

"What, are you going to walk? Look, I'll have enough power in about fifteen minutes to get back with one of my mirrors and you can take the car, okay?"

"No... I want you gone now. You drive... I'll make my own way back." Alejandro replied, the words catching in his throat, as he turned away and walked towards their former arena, the debris having been cleaned up by Iván earlier.

"Hey-" Iván started behind Alejandro, but suddenly cut himself off when the latter abruptly turned around and silently glared.

"Are we really doing this now?"

No response was forthcoming.

"Fine, let's compromise. I'll wait in the car for you to calm down, and then we can go home."

Alejandro didn't shift or change expression at all, and yet still managed to communicate that he would not be accepting this.

"Are you really going to treat your own brother like this?"

"Enough!" For the second time that day, the winds swirled around Alejandro and he transformed, once more without budging a single inch.

Iván flinched in surprise, and a small staredown ensued while he waited for an action, any action, that never came.

"Did you seriously transform just to glare harder at me?!"

The complete lack of response indicated that this was, indeed, what Alejandro had just done.

"Alright, fine, you win. I don't have a response to that."

Iván and Alejandro finally turned away from each other, the former acquiescing and driving away, while the latter detransformed, walked to the cliff's edge, and sat down, his legs dangling over the sheer drop and his head held high with his eyes closed to savour the breeze.

After a few minutes, once his breath had stopped being so shaky, Alejandro opened his eyes, and then began shaking again, this time with bitter laughter.



Like a willow in the wind, Alejandro bends in response to hardship. He bends to fit into his new role, to exist in a society that does not accommodate him, to compromise with others who don't even realize a compromise is happening in the first place. He may not break, but that doesn't stop the bending from hurting.

Originally, his power was merely to make objects more than real, emphasizing their properties, metaphorical or otherwise. But, as his self-image deteriorated, so too did his physical self in Hanazakari form, losing reality and rendering him harder to physically touch, to connect with. And he would also learn that passing his reality on to others would bring them down, just like his worst fears.

Of course, anything he'd imbued his reality into would still be fully capable of harming him. After all, if he'd lost nothing in the Frost Decade as the defender of Valencia, if he had a loving family, and a comfortable government job as the face of Hanazakari in Spain, yet he still felt so awful… He could only conclude that the cause of his suffering was himself.

Still waters may be beautiful, yet soon enough they will grow stagnant, and the life that once flourished in them will be choked by the very plenty they once benefited from. Iván looks at other people, and he only ever sees himself. He is kind to himself, and so he is kind to others. But how could he ever understand and be kind to someone different to him, if he does not see those differences? There is no volume at which a deaf person will hear you.

I originally got this idea when Arlequine mentioned that "negative" emotions were just as capable of fueling Hanazakari powers, and I wondered, what would a Hanazakari who fuels themselves with depression be like?
It's also the reason for the title. To fight with something can have many possible meanings. Is it an ally you fight alongside, or an opponent you fight against? Or perhaps it is some tool you use, or a burden that weighs you down? For a Hanazakari, depression can appear to be all four. Yet it is a toxic companion they are better off without, and a tool that extracts a price too steep.

I am so happy with this piece, which is something REALLY rare for me. Still, I am well aware that it is by no means perfect (For a start, I cannot into physical descriptions) so, please feed me constructive criticism.
 
Last edited:
Still, I am well aware that it is by no means perfect (For a start, I cannot into physical descriptions) so, please feed me constructive criticism.

The only major issue I have with this omake is that it could use more line breaks, since the lack of them makes it kinda hard to read. I'd definitely recommend a line break every time a different character speaks.
Other thing is I'm a little worried about is people confusing Lotus in Still Waters for Blue Lotus, but given you introduced him as Iván first I don't think that'd be much of a problem, plus given the line about the Frost Fair I'm guessing that may have been intentional.

Those two were the only things that got to me though, otherwise it looks pretty good. You get a sense of the characters' personalities, plus I admit I hadn't planned much about Spain for this Quest so it was good to see it covered.

I'll also say we've already met at least one Hanazakari so far whose power is fueled by their depression, though it's a slight spoiler so I won't say who it is
 
Recap: The First 100,000 Words
Long ago, an alien race that would become known as the Frost Fair lived on the planet Cocytus, or so it was later named by humans. It was said the Frost Fair committed the ultimate sin of betraying 'God', and so were cursed with immortality, which may have seemed a blessing at first until, as ages went by, it became more and more difficult for them to feel any emotions due to all the experience they'd already had. So the Frost fair began growing Heart Leeches, detachable organs that would let them drain the emotions of others into themselves.

The Frost Fair would come into conflict with the planet Pathragada, home to a civilisation of sentient and magical plant races. The Pathragadans gave one of their lowest castes, the Dandelionhearts, permission to anoint other species with their civilisation's powers, each based on a flower, to fight on their behalf. Come the 1990s, the Dandelionhearts would arrive on Earth where, as they'd done with other species, they chose to anoint vulnerable humans with the power to defend themselves as the Frost Fair were about to attack. These anointed humans were called many names, in Japan they were the Hanazakari.

This began what Earth would call the Frost Decade. It was originally a secret war between the Hanazakari and Frost Fair, with the latter playing games and trickery to steal people's emotions, if not hand them over. Inevitably the 'Veil' was shattered and the world at large learned of the Hanazakari and Frost Fair. This led to both governments and corporations recruiting Hanazakari, with the UN forming the taskforce RUNE to deal with the Frost Fair and any more threats like them, and many of those corporations going over to the Frost Fair's side with their promises of riches and technology.

In Japan, the Frost Decade ended with the battle of Shin Sekigahara. There it seemed like the Frost Fair were wiped out for good, but one of them, who'd later go by the alias Blue Lotus, would secretly be captured by RUNE for their Project Lazarus experiments. But the last of the Dandelionhearts were killed at Shin Sekigahara too. The last Dandelionheart, named Emet, was held by the Black Rose Koyomi Arisugawa and slain by the Hellebore Hibiki Izumi. With the power of the Hanazakari Rosemary, RUNE wipes Hibiki being Emet's killer from Koyomi's mind.



Twenty-three years later, would-be journalist Miyako Nozawa runs away from home after heated conflict with her parents over her transitioning. Being a massive fan of the Hanazakari, she heads to the town of Hinodeharu, where the Internet told her one of them lives. This turns out to be Koyomi, now a serious author under the pen name Kuramazov. Koyomi at first wants nothing to do with Miyako, but sympathises on learning she has nowhere else to go, so lets her stay at her house until Miyako can find accommodation elsewhere.

It turns out Koyomi is an outcast in town, due to several incidents of her acting out and assuming a Frost Fair plan was afoot when there was none, the scars of the Frost Decade still strong in her mind. Miyako learns this behind Koyomi's back from Reiji Yuuki, a boy who works at the local theatre and, because of how none came to save his dead brother, holds a grudge against Hanazakari.

Before going to bed that night, Miyako leads the internet off Koyomi's trail by lying that she's not in this town. The next day, Koyomi takes Miyako job- and house-hunting, and they run into a boy called Kazuya Kai. Infested by a Heart Leech a very young age, Kazuya has lived almost his whole life without emotions, his prestigious family shunning him out of shame despite him being their firstborn.

Miyako investigates a miko job offer at the local Inari shrine, whose head priestess turns out to be Koyomi's estranged friend Asahi Higashi, who never got to be a Hanazakari. Miyako being accepted, she tries to see if Asahi can somehow exorcise the Heart Leech from Kazuya. Reiji comes along too, Kazuya being his friend throughout high school due to never caring about Reiji's more 'dramatic' side. Asahi's exorcism goes horribly awry until Koyomi steps in, transforming into a Hanazakari for the first time in years. However, in her fury against this Heart Leech, she accidentally almost kills Kazuya in the process. Still, the ritual is ultimately a success as the Leech is finally slain.

The next morning, Miyako meets with Hayato, Asahi's son, who's too quick to muse on what it'd be like to be emotionless. Meanwhile, Kazuya's and Reiji's injuries leave them in hospital for days. While visiting them, Miyako runs into Kazuya's younger brother and family heir Ryoichi Kai, though he says nothing to her.

Once out of the hospital, Miyako tries to help Reiji put on a play to aid his struggling theatre. They go through a few ideas, including Miyako trying to get her own fanfic staged, but ultimately they're able to adapt one of Koyomi's books, Ladder to Heaven. The play is something of a success, but afterwards Koyomi cryptically tells Miyako that Higanbana, the Cultivar of the main character of Miyako's fanfic, is the same as that of Namie Hirasaka, the first Hanazakari Koyomi ever saw die.

Koyomi, being an independent Hanazakari, is then visited for inspection by the White Egret Yumemi Hoshizora, a Brigadier with RUNE who was Koyomi's girlfriend during the Frost Decade before they drifted apart, Koyomi having no love for the military. Things get nasty, but Yumemi offers to let Koyomi see RUNE's top-secret Project Lazarus as proof the organisation is doing good for humanity, Miyako and Kazuya also being allowed to come along. But Koyomi is only horrified and enraged to see what the project really is, that not only is a Frostfarer still alive but that RUNE would use him to make humanity more like the Frost Fair.

The Frostfarer, Blue Lotus, then lures and leeches Miyako to give him enough willpower to break out. As RUNE end up failing to contain him, Koyomi tries to kill him only to be forced to let him go to avoid also killing a captured Miyako. Miyako rescued but Blue Lotus still on the loose, Yumemi then says she was never on board with RUNE's plan after all, and was trying to goad Koyomi into killing Blue Lotus for her to take the heat. Koyomi remains scornful regardless. Miyako meanwhile vows to write an article detailing Project Lazarus and that there's a Frostfarer still out there.

Sometime later, Koyomi pays a visit to the Shin Sekigahara memorial, Miyako and Reiji tagging along with her. While there they encounter the ISS cosmonaut and Zinnia Vasilisa Mirova, who is hunting after a crashed alien spaceship. Said spaceship is of a Bamboo Pathragadan, who being from a lower caste has never been given a name, Koyomi dubbing them Sfira. On the train back they are attacked by the Freesia Kurara Minakata, a Hanazakari Slayer from the Earthly Purified cult, targeting Koyomi for being a 'Bad Seed' for letting the last Dandelionheart die. When Koyomi fends her off, Kurara uses her Cultivar to turn Vasilisa into a toy then holds her hostage.

Koyomi then detours to Nagoya to rescue Vasilisa and find out what the deal with the Earthly Purified is. While there, she recruits the non-binary Peruvian detective Alstroemeria Palmira Sakata, and none other Hibiki Izumi who's looking for the missing mangaka Orange Emi Daimon. Emi turns out to be a rare Hanazakari who hates her own Cultivar. They also run into Ryoichi, who says the cult has been siphoning his family's fortune.

Encountering the cult leader Rafflesia Mariya Kamizono, she claims she'd have the power to usher in the Resurrection if not for those Bad Seeds somehow stopping her. Koyomi's group takes Vasilisa and Emi then runs, with Vasilisa eventually transforming back to human, but now needing a wheelchair due to the 'modifications' Kurara made to her in toy form. A phone call to Yumemi gets Koyomi to remember that Hibiki was the one who killed Emet.

Afterwards, Miyako begins having nightmares which Asahi judges are stress-induced from her time with Koyomi. She then makes Miyako promise not to visit Koyomi anymore, a promise Miyako promptly breaks in secret. She and Hayato find Emi hanging around Koyomi's house, fawning over her like she did her old cult leader despite Koyomi wanting none of it. The jealousy Hayato suddenly shows towards Emi makes Miyako worry that his fondness for Koyomi goes beyond being grateful for saving his parents' lives and into age gap-ish territory.

They all then learn that a lone swan that has been terrorising the forest is in fact a Hanazakari, the Maidenstears Maimi Tobi, now trapped in swan form after the Cultivar malfunctioned. Asahi then happens upon them and learns Miyako lied to her, with Koyomi then agreeing with Asahi as she's worried for Miyako's safety.

Back at her house, Koyomi finds Sfira captured by Vasilisa, Hibiki, and the Narcissus Chigusa Kagamino, a singer who seemingly has not aged. Vasilisa wants to settle which country shall gain 'custody' over Sfira with a tournament, which Hibiki and Chigusa employed by the megacorp Yamahi Productions go along with, and which Koyomi is disgusted by. Hibiki and Chigusa however then cheat and steal Sfira away, the alien putting up little resistance due to how they were conditioned as one of Pathragada's lower castes.

Koyomi goes with Emi and a regretful Vasilisa after them to Chigusa's manor. There they find Hibiki and Chigusa in conflict with each other, as Chigusa wants to siphon Sfira's power to start a new Hanazakari generation herself, stealing that plan from YamahiPro who Hibiki is still loyal to. But then Blue Lotus attacks and manages to drain and kill Hibiki in a trap, turning her into a Jack Frost wraith and candidate for a new Snow Queen, the most powerful Frostfarer imaginable. All this YamahiPro has given him permission to do, as they believe a threat like the Snow Queen will bring the golden age of the Hanazakari back, making them more money.

Blue Lotus barely escapes afterwards, hounded by Koyomi. Having at least rescued Sfira, Koyomi then goes back to reunite with Miyako and take back what she said, this experience telling her she can't leave her to fend for herself should Blue Lotus attack her.



Known Hanazakari and Cultivars:

Sword: Koyomi - Darkness, Kurara - Turn people into toys and back, Emi - Turn pleasure into pain, Fleur de Lys - Branding, Cherry
Wand: Yumemi - Dreams, Hachiro - Dogs, Chigusa - Make images of herself come alive, Chrysanthemum
Cup: Palmira - Gold, Mariya - Reanimating the dead, Nepeta - Cats, Mikoto - Desserts, Henrietta
Pentacle: Vasilisa - Anti-Gravity, Hibiki - Cultivar copying through acting, Maimi - Swan transformation, Rosemary - Memory storage, Heather



QM's Note: That should be it, but if you feel there's anything I should've also mentioned, please let me know
 
Last edited:
The only major issue I have with this omake is that it could use more line breaks, since the lack of them makes it kinda hard to read. I'd definitely recommend a line break every time a different character speaks.
Other thing is I'm a little worried about is people confusing Lotus in Still Waters for Blue Lotus, but given you introduced him as Iván first I don't think that'd be much of a problem, plus given the line about the Frost Fair I'm guessing that may have been intentional.

Those two were the only things that got to me though, otherwise it looks pretty good. You get a sense of the characters' personalities, plus I admit I hadn't planned much about Spain for this Quest so it was good to see it covered.
Fixed the line breaks issue, I think.
As for Lotus on Still Waters, I was originally only going to go for a flower that blooms on water to connect it with his mirror powers, which left me with either the lotus or the narcissus. Narcissus was already taken, so I was already leaning towards lotus, then I saw that it is connected to purification, and I was immediately sold on it being the right choice for Iván. After all, it is, in a way what he is trying (and failing) to do in helping his brother with his depression.
Though it is true that I wanted there to be a lotus Hanazakari so they can be salty at Blue Lotus for stealing their flower name.

Anyway, thank you for the criticism, I really appreciate it!
 
Of course, anything he'd imbued his reality into would still be fully capable of harming him. After all, if he'd lost nothing in the Frost Decade as the defender of Valencia, if he had a loving family, and a comfortable government job as the face of Hanazakari in Spain, yet he still felt so awful… He could only conclude that the cause of his suffering was himself.
Note to self: Alendaro, Willow of the wind is an important person in Spain

Could be a useful bit of info to remember for me. He might be mentioned in passing by a character in an omake I'm trying to work out.
EDIT: Making and bookmarking this comment seemed to be the easiest way to remind of Alendaro's existence.
 
Last edited:
Anyway, thank you for the criticism, I really appreciate it!

You're welcome!

My assumption was that Iván had been attacked if not leeched by Blue Lotus back during the Frost Decade, with the latter remembering the name. Though technically the Lotus and Blue Lotus are separate flowers (Lotus is in the family Nelumbonaceae while the Blue Lotus is in Nymphaeaceae) so there was never an actual overlap anyway.

Though we do have a Lotus Hanazakari already, Padma in Full Bloom (Lotus in Sanskrit), but she was only briefly mentioned as the 'multiverse Hanazakari' so I don't blame people for not remembering her. I've also said it's possible for multiple Hanazakari to have the same flower as there are only so many flowers, and you could see 'jumping into a mirror world' as related to 'multiverse' for them to be different people's emotional expressions of the same root power.

Anyway, with there being nothing that contradicts what's happened so far, I've made this a Sidestory so you've got 100 points to spend on XP!
 
So the Frost fair began evolving Heart Leeches, detachable organs that would let them drain the emotions of others into themselves.
Well that's not how evolution works. I assume the intended meaning is that they either started modifying their altered biology technologically - with the Heart Leeches being something akin to carefully-cultivated teratomas or HeLa clusters - or that their hunger for emotion supernaturally twisted their bodies, causing them to form Heart Leeches as a means of satiating that hunger.
 
Winterfest and User's Choice are Here!
Here to say I'm overseeing the Merry Media Criticism Contest for Winterfest. It shouldn't take up too much of my time, but a heads-up anyway:

forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Merry Media Criticism Essay Contest

Welcome to the 2023 Merry Media Criticism Essay Contest!

Speaking of Winterfest, people may also like to nominate Fool Bloom for Best New Work, Best Ongoing Quest, or Best Original Work.

Planning to close the vote once Meowgician gets back to me on where they'd like their 100XP allocated
 
Last edited:
You're welcome!

My assumption was that Iván had been attacked if not leeched by Blue Lotus back during the Frost Decade, with the latter remembering the name. Though technically the Lotus and Blue Lotus are separate flowers (Lotus is in the family Nelumbonaceae while the Blue Lotus is in Nymphaeaceae) so there was never an actual overlap anyway.

Though we do have a Lotus Hanazakari already, Padma in Full Bloom (Lotus in Sanskrit), but she was only briefly mentioned as the 'multiverse Hanazakari' so I don't blame people for not remembering her. I've also said it's possible for multiple Hanazakari to have the same flower as there are only so many flowers, and you could see 'jumping into a mirror world' as related to 'multiverse' for them to be different people's emotional expressions of the same root power.

Anyway, with there being nothing that contradicts what's happened so far, I've made this a Sidestory so you've got 100 points to spend on XP!
The thought that Iván might have met Blue Lotus didn't even occur to me, though now that I think about it, Alejandro's power is basically perfect for subduing people non-lethally, so he very well may have been the one to capture him in the first place. I do imagine that you'd already have planned who did capture him, though.

This is, incidentally, the main reason he wins so many of his spars with Iván, they're more or less equal, but they don't want to actually hurt each other. The levitating mirrors trick, for instance, would have likely given Iván a much better chance of winning if used at the start, but it would have also probably cut Alejandro a fair bit. The only reason it was used at the end was because Iván was certain it wasn't actually going to be able to hurt him, and he needed it to set up his plan with the reconstructed mirror.

I don't actually know much of anything about flowers and flower language beyond what I look up, and maaaaybe some of the basics, so the Lotus and Blue Lotus actually being different flowers is news to me. I also used the list of Hanazakari in your first post as a reference, and Padma wasn't there.

Anyway, I think I'll put the 100 XP into Koyomi's mind
 
Last edited:
Speaking of Arcs, I'd be eager to hear how people think Fountain of Youth stacks up in comparison with previous arcs?

I feel a bit rude saying this, but since you asked, I feel like the last ark was fairly weak. A lot of the action happened for "reasons" and there wasn't much in the way of emotional payoff. At least part of that is down to how the votes went—Why was abandoning the fight to look for Sfira ever presented as a good idea—but there's a bigger issue with things coming up out of nowhere and then either getting sidelined or resolved without much interaction or change. To my mind there are four major sub-plots that stand out in this arc:

The first major sub-plot is Koyomi deciding she needs to distance herself from Miyako, because the new Frost Fair makes it dangerous to be around her. It ends with Koyomi deciding she can't put distance between herself and Miyako because the Frost Fair are dangerous. Between these two points, Miyako spends the first half of this arc ignoring the separation and isn't really relevant to the second half. It feels like this went nowhere and resolved itself, which runs counter to the emotional buildup that was presented by the start.

The second major sub-plot is the introduction of Maimi, and her attempt at relevance. This feels like it's mostly setting up future arcs and, to that end, it was handled fairly well. We'd already seen hints of Maimi before, so the angry swan didn't come out of nowhere, and the whole thing raised new questions about her while adding solid world building. Even the "attempt at relevance" ties in nicely with what will probably become a core theme for her, vis-à-vis being stuck as a swan.

The third major sub-plot is Sfira's kidnapping and rescue. As with the first sub-plot, this feels like something that should be pretty important, but it just sort of happens and then gets resolved. There's a brief scuffle when the kidnapping itself happens—where a new character walks in, picks Sfira up, and then walks off with her, while everyone else feels like they're fumbling around—but that's about it. Then, at the end, Koyomi basically repeats the same thing, in reverse. We don't really learn anything as a result of the kidnapping, nor does it change much in and of itself. It feels like it's only purpose was to get the cast to Chigusa's manor and the only reason we went there was so Blue Lotus could kill Hibiki there. Put another way, if Blue Lotus had attacked durring the kidnapping, it feels like we would have ended up at basically the same place, storywise.

Finally, there's Hibiki's death. You gave the Doyalist reason for wanting her dead, and that part makes sense, but the entire sequence that lead up to her death doesn't. Why did Koyomi think it was a good idea to abandon the fight with the biggest threat she knowns of, injuring herself in the process and leaving behind the most vulnerable member of her team and both of the people Blue Lotus was targetting, in a desparate attempt to rescue someone who was in no immediate danger whatsoever? Why did Vasilisa and all of the Chigusas follow her? Why did Hibiki consider following Blue Lotus's advice for even a second, when it made absolutely no sense and she had so many better options? Seriously, how does "make an emotionally deadend creature feel pain when confronted with what it loves" sound like a viable plan? Espesially when her other options are "turn them into a doll with a single touch" and "blind them with darknes before stabing them with a propper sword?"
 
This is a good post. I didn't say anything, because it's likely enough that my decreased investment and participation was a side effect of being otherwise really busy, but it's probably fair to say it's both.

Honestly, I think Arlequine is better at writing dialogue than she is action, so the magical-girl-battle side of the cast suffers. The most memorable of Koyomi's 'friends' are probably Yumemi and Emi, and that's because so much time has been spent on their complicated relationships with her. While Vasilia, Palmira, Hibiki etc might become more, their relationships with our main cast is currently summed up as "fought with/against Koyomi", they just kind of hover around to fill out the party without having much of a personal connection.

There's clearly significant effort put into world-building, but I'm really not here for the setting, I'm here for exasperated Koyomi rolling her eyes at this goddamn zoomer menace Miyako. I agree that cutting out Miyako and resolving it right away, with minimal contemplation or drama, only served to hurt this arc. I understand that there are important plot things going on and flashing back and forth to Miyako living her normal life would have dragged things out with poor pacing, but I might have preferred we followed Miyako's daily life for a chapter, and then learned about this whole chapter after the fact- I just enjoy her and her friends more. I understand the wish to keep the Frost Decade vague, but that doesn't help characterize the half of the cast who are defined by their experiences during it.
 
While Vasilia, Palmira, Hibiki etc might become more, their relationships with our main cast is currently summed up as "fought with/against Koyomi", they just kind of hover around to fill out the party without having much of a personal connection.

I'd argue Hibiki sort-of had more going on for her with her relationship to Yamahi and the and the constantly recurring question of why is she still working for them and why was she ever willing to do what they said? Unfortunately, her death kind-of short circuits that arc. We could still find out about it, but she's already dead, so a lot of the emotional impact is already gone.

There's clearly significant effort put into world-building, but I'm really not here for the setting, I'm here for exasperated Koyomi rolling her eyes at this goddamn zoomer menace Miyako. I agree that cutting out Miyako and resolving it right away, with minimal contemplation or drama, only served to hurt this arc. I understand that there are important plot things going on and flashing back and forth to Miyako living her normal life would have dragged things out with poor pacing, but I might have preferred we followed Miyako's daily life for a chapter, and then learned about this whole chapter after the fact- I just enjoy her and her friends more. I understand the wish to keep the Frost Decade vague, but that doesn't help characterize the half of the cast who are defined by their experiences during it.

I don't think those two things are necessarily connected, but that might be part of the problem. There's a pretty natural reason to not bring Miyako along for the raid, namely, "Why would you willingly bring a civilian into a combat situation?" You don't need the secondary justification of "Miyako's having nightmares and maybe she shouldn't be part of this Hanazakari stuff," so if that was part of the logic behind having their emotional split, the inevitable resolution ends up feeling a bit hollow.
 
I don't think those two things are necessarily connected, but that might be part of the problem. There's a pretty natural reason to not bring Miyako along for the raid, namely, "Why would you willingly bring a civilian into a combat situation?" You don't need the secondary justification of "Miyako's having nightmares and maybe she shouldn't be part of this Hanazakari stuff," so if that was part of the logic behind having their emotional split, the inevitable resolution ends up feeling a bit hollow.
It's only connected in the sense that this arc, by design, focused on (imo) the weaker parts of the story. We have mostly managed to bring Miyako into combat situations because we didn't know they were going to be combat situations, and deviating from that formula was an authorial choice. You're right, this same end goal could have been accomplished by just leaving her behind, without building up the separation. But while that might have saved us time, it wouldn't have addressed the core issue I have with the arc.
 
I do think that the sudden swing of the vote toward "Let's go rescue Sfira, it's not like Blue Lotus is here or anything" was what really dragged this arc down.
 
Yeah, that was... kind of bizarre, I think.

And it feels like it did kind of set us up for a situation in which Hibiki could be easily killed off, which in turn makes a lot of her story arc simply irrelevant barring further plot twists that seem kind of unlikely at this point. Because so far the thing that's been signaled to us is "bringing back the dead isn't actually possible, or is possible only through a miracle that will never happen in this life."

I'll also say we've already met at least one Hanazakari so far whose power is fueled by their depression, though it's a slight spoiler so I won't say who it is
I figure it can't be Koyomi, or she'd be very, very powerful, exceptionally so, and she doesn't seem to be.

But hell, I could be wrong.
 
Last edited:
Vote closed
Carnival Masks 7.1
[X] 150 Emotional Intelligence + 75 Emotional Strength
[X] 75 Technique + 150 Mind

[Koyomi's Technique has reached the Rank of Knight]
[Koyomi's Mind has reached the Rank of Knight]
[Miyako's Emotional Strength has reached the Rank of Baroness]


It should've been that simple. Koyomi may have seconded Asahi in saying that Miyako should stay away from her, but she had come back, said sorry, said she was wrong to leave her. But Miyako knew things were never that simple, much as she didn't want to face that. So far nothing Hanazakari-related had been neatly tied up, only exception she could think of was the play they'd put on for Reiji's theatre, if that counted.

Her ear pressed just below the shrine window, Miyako felt her spine shudder as she listened in on Koyomi and Asahi snapping at each other inside.
"Absolutely not!" Asahi said, "If this Frostfarer already knows you, it'll come after you and Nozawa will be caught in the crossfire. The exact same thing happened with me, need I remind you!"

"Asahi, if Blue Lotus comes after Miyako and I'm not there, which he absolutely will if he thinks he can get more emotions that way, she'll be defenceless," Koyomi said back, Miyako squirming as she was reminded of that. "Who's gonna be there for her? Maimi's a swan, and you were almost killed by a single Heart Leech. And need I remind you that me sticking around you back then is the whole reason you're still alive!"

"Are you trying to blackmail me?" Asahi so suddenly accused her. But she then steadied herself and said more normally, "First, that was an abnormally strong Heart Leech. And second, look, it's just... I had nearly the same nightmares as her back in those days. I don't want to have to hear she woke up screaming again," she trembled at that sentence's end.

"Better she has those nightmares and is still alive than not. And it's not like I'm gonna take her to the front lines or anything," Koyomi said. Miyako knew she meant well, Koyomi always meant well... but the mere thought having that nightmare again could've paralysed her. 'Better than being dead' was barely any consolation.
She could then faintly make out Koyomi adding beneath her breath, "Besides, how much of this is about Miyako and how much is about you? You hate the whole idea of someone else needing a Hanazakari to save them, am I right? Now that I do remember about you."

"The Frost Decade was over twenty years ago!" Asahi shrieked out on a dime, Miyako not needing to eavesdrop to hear that. Taking several further deep breaths and with tears staring to form, she brought herself to say, "Nobody should need a Hanazakari to save them anymore. It-it was supposed to be over. Instead, not only can't you kill a single Frostfarer, but now you tell me this thing's killed a Hanazakari. What good will you being around her even do?"

"What good will me not being around her do?" Koyomi asked back, sounding like she'd restrained her voice at the last second. "And the only reason I haven't killed him yet is him playing dirty and manipulating everyone there against me." And being maybe too concerned for Sfira once, she kept in her head. "The next time, he won't be so lucky. I assure you," she hissed.

"Alright, if there's really a risk he could come right after Nozawa, fine, you can keep an eye on her," Asahi gave in, but had to add, "But don't think I won't keep my eye on you in turn. Do I- do I make myself clear?" She strained to still sound authoritative, which she usually had no trouble doing around Miyako.
On the bright side, at least she didn't say 'you're on thin ice', would've been too close to home.

"Crystal," was all Koyomi said before she walked out.

Standing back up and stepping away from the window, Miyako to keep appearances walked up and asked Koyomi, "So, uh, what was that all about?"

"Settling your boss' whole 'you stay away from her' thing, that's all," Koyomi said, then sighed, "I'm sorry, I was such an idiot to genuinely consider that."

"Really, it's fine," Miyako said on impulse, but had to ask, "Er, you and Higashi-sama were friends back in the day, right? Because, er, all you mostly do is argue with each other. Ah, granted, I'm sure that's what plenty of old friends are like," she raced to add that last part. "So I guess you got to know each other through you saving her, huh?"

"No, I first met her before I was anointed," Koyomi said instead, "She sat to the right of me in school, felt it was only polite to introduce herself. Since she was a rare classmate who wasn't singling me out for being Jewish, even if she didn't know, my young self felt obliged to keep hanging out with her."

"That was nice of her," Miyako winced as she said. "Like, I never told anyone in school I was trans, didn't really know myself till near the end of it. Yeah, I can keep a secret, believe it or not. Er, ahem, my point is, giving how scared I was to tell anyone, I definitely get why someone not judging you for your identity would've meant a whole lot." Only then remembering the part about Asahi not knowing Koyomi's heritage, she added, "And I'm sure she would've been A-OK with you being Jewish, she accepted me being trans."

"You do realise you're talking decades of difference with her?" Koyomi asked. "Speaking of Asahi though, you're still looking for a place to stay outside the shrine, aren't you? Rooming at the shrine just seems like a temporary arrangement to me, that's all," she said like that was her only issue with Miyako staying with Asahi.

That question blindsiding her like Koyomi's Cultivar, Miyako said, "Er, no, not really. I had a look once, but even the rents were too much." And I'm fine staying with Higashi-sama, really, she thought.

"Hah, can sure see where you're coming from. Why d'you think I had to settle for a shack on the edge of the forest?" Koyomi said, then muttered, "Well, other than me not being able to stand neighbours," as if Maimi, Sfira, and Emi didn't now count.

Miyako twitched. "Wait, you're a successful author. I thought you had like mountains of yen on you?" she asked.

Koyomi let out a half-chuckle half-groan at that. "As if. Only the biggest writers can just sit back and rake in Scrooge money from publishing their shopping list or whatever. The rest of us, well, we take what we can get," she said.

If that's what authors make though, then is it even worse for journalists? Miyako thought. "But hey, some good news. I may not have been looking for many other places to stay, but I've got my article on Project Lazarus all finished! Well, er, a good enough draft anyway. Come on, I'll show you," she said as she ushered Koyomi into her room, the latter relieved to be out of potential earshot of Asahi.

Scrolling through what Miyako had typed up on her laptop, Koyomi nodded in approval but then had to say, "Right, well it's good, or at least satisfactory, so far," being impressed that Miyako had managed to keep her rambling journalistically reined in, "It's just I'm afraid it could use an update."

"Oh yeah, you said you fought with Blue Lotus again when you went to rescue Sfira," Miyako said, then beamed like the sun was behind her eyes, "That must have been so cool! Er, pun not intended. You and your fellow Hanazakari fighting the Frost Fair again, just like old times-" Miyako's cheer was stifled when Koyomi then laid a hand over her mouth.

"It wasn't a thing like that," Koyomi sighed, "Blue Lotus killed one of us and turned her into a Jack Frost. That one of us was..." she struggled to continue, as despite all the grief Hibiki had given her when alive, Koyomi knew how much Miyako had looked up to her, "Izumi Hibiki."

Her face turning pale, Miyako gasped, "N-no, that can't be true. I mean, I knew Hanazakari died, b-but not Hibiki-sama, and forced to serve the Frost Fair in death too?"

"Afraid so," Koyomi said, coldly thinking She died as she lived, though she couldn't bear to say that to Miyako. "I told you as it would've been on the news anyway. Ugh, to think Yamahi will probably love that her death will bring back a ton of interest in her, bunch of people saying how much she meant to them regardless of if she ever did. They're happy to take whatever last table scraps Blue Lotu can give them, like they'd really care."
She didn't bring up the part about the Snow Queen though, not now anyway. As she promised Asahi, she wouldn't be taking Miyako onto the front lines anyway, and her article just alerting the world about Blue Lotus ought to be enough to set everyone on him, ought to. So Miyako didn't really need to know, right?

"I-I see," Miyako blubbered out. Feebly attempting to dry her eyes, she then said, "I've got no idea how Reiji-kun's gonna react, he was into Hibiki-sama more than I was, long after everyone else moved on. He'd be- He'd be..." she couldn't bear to finish, another thought coming to mind. "Oh no, Emi-sama! Hibiki-sama was her friend, well, one of the closest people she said to a friend, and she was there when it happened, wasn't she? She'd be, oh no, I don't know how she'd be feeling. I should really check up on her."

"Should you?" Koyomi had to ask. "If you don't know how you'd comfort Yuuki, Daimon would be an even more uphill battle. Especially with the other news she received this morning..." she had to be cryptic.

"Wh-what other news? And Daimon-sama meant a lot to me before I even came to Hinodeharu, I can't leave her alone of all people!" Miyako pleaded.

"If you insist," Koyomi said, eyes half-rolled. "She's in my basement as before, I'll have to admit we got lucky finding you a place to stay here, despite my *ahem* issues with my old friend. No such luck with Daimon, though that's in part because she'd refused to leave so far," she grumbled. "As for that other news... her publisher fired her. She told me she was on leave, but as typical of publishers didn't think so, said she missed one deadline too many."

Article:
Miyako flinched hearing that, the sheer thought of anyone, but especially Emi, losing their job right in the middle of grieving. But her mind was made up, she would help Emi through this, she just needed to:
[ ] Ease in, just ask how she was feeling, don't bring up any of the heavy topics until she was comfortable.
[ ] Ease in, try cheering her up by talking about how much Emi's manga meant to her back in school.
-[ ] And how it's still meaningful; her publisher can take her job, but they can't take the impact she made on her readers. (GreatWyrmGold write-in)
[ ] Get straight to the point, it was gonna be gotten to anyway, and ask Emi about the heavy stuff.
[ ] Ask Koyomi if she could talk things out with Emi with her, in case she said something wrong.
[ ] Maybe not talk to Emi, not yet, but just stay with her a while, let her know she was there.
[ ] Actually, her mind wasn't made up. Maybe talking to Reiji would be easier.
[ ] Talk with Reiji and Emi together, with how Hibiki's death would impact them both.
-[ ] Rather than talk about how Hibiki's death would impact them, talk about how her life impacted them and what they can carry forward from that. (EpsilonRose write-in)
[ ] Write-in
 
Last edited:
"Better she has those nightmares and is still alive than not. And it's not like I'm gonna take her to the front lines or anything," Koyomi said.
Even odds she'll sneak after you for some investigative journalism before all of this is over.

"Hah, can sure see where you're coming from. Why d'you think I had to settle for a shack on the edge of the forest?" Koyomi said, then muttered, "Well, other than me not being able to stand neighbours," as if Maimi, Sfira, and Emi didn't now count.
Koyomi's too involved to recognize her own tropes, but surely Miyako realizes that accumulating a bunch of semi-wanted friends, teammates, and roommates is normal for brooding loners.

Her face turning pale, Miyako gasped, "N-no, that can't be true. I mean, I knew Hanazakari died, b-but not Hibiki-sama, and forced to serve the Frost Fair in death too?"

"Afraid so," Koyomi said, coldly thinking She died as she lived
...pissing me off.

"Oh yeah, you said you fought with Blue Lotus again when you went to rescue Sfira," Miyako said, then beamed like the sun was behind her eyes, "That must have been so cool! Er, pun not intended. You and your fellow Hanazakari fighting the Frost Fair again, just like old times-" Miyako's cheer was stifled when Koyomi then laid a hand over her mouth.
Miyako was truly born in the wrong generation. She missed her true vocation: Being the cheerful genki ditz who holds the magical girl team together.

"Oh no, Emi-sama! Hibiki-sama was her friend, well, one of the closest people she said to a friend, and she was there when it happened, wasn't she? She'd be, oh no, I don't know how she'd be feeling. I should really check up on her."

"Should you?" Koyomi had to ask. "If you don't know how you'd comfort Yuuki, Daimon would be an even more uphill battle."
I mean, yes, but Miyako is probably the best-suited to fighting that uphill battle. Speaking of which...


[X] Ease in, try cheering her up by talking about how much Emi's manga meant to her back in school.
-[X] And how it's still meaningful; her publisher can take her job, but they can't take the impact she made on her readers.

I like the general approach—personal, focusing on the good that Emi has done, despite all the reasons she thinks she's worthless—but I want to tweak it to be less retrospective. Less nostalgia, more hope.
 
[X] Ease in, just ask how she was feeling, don't bring up any of the heavy topics until she was comfortable.

Well, if got her to write her article, maybe Asahi was right to put Miyako into off-screen time out after all. :V (The on thin ice pun probably got more of a chuckle out of me than it should.)

Although, I probably shouldn't be joking too much, given the drama which surrounds that bit. I don't thing Emi wants to hear about her manga right now, so being her usual bouncy self (within limits) and hoping it pushes off some of the depression is probably the best Miyako can do right now.
I do think that the sudden swing of the vote toward "Let's go rescue Sfira, it's not like Blue Lotus is here or anything" was what really dragged this arc down.
While I generally agree that the arc suffers from not being very focused and a lack of Miyako/the social aspect, I don't think that choice is what put the nail in the coffin.

Granted, I'm looking at this from the perspective of somebody that already figured that if that fight was where Blue Lotus gets his Hanazakari Jack Frost to raise the stakes for future encounters this isn't the point we stop him and so instead we might as well put the focus on making sure Sfira actually gets saved. Looking at the QM comments afterwards, it doesn't seem like that read was wrong, so I'm probably less frustrated with the whole thing than someone that expected a more successful outcome might be.

Still, it's not like Koyomi didn't have a practical reason for adding another fighter to their side (there were in fact concerns about her reasoning for rescuing them were too pragmatic) and Hibiki didn't die because she was left alone against a superior opponent. Hibiki died because she had an emotional collapse that left her vulnerable on the battlefield. Something similar presumably would have happened with the other choices and while they might have framed it in a more satisfying way, that firmly puts us in the realm of what if.
 
Honestly, I think Arlequine is better at writing dialogue than she is action, so the magical-girl-battle side of the cast suffers.

I'll say a good thing about writing a Magical Girl story is it's a lot easier to get away with having sub-par battle scenes as long as the characters are well-written, as opposed if I was doing say a Battle Shonen or Tokusatsu Quest. Not that there aren't MG series that focus more on fight scenes, but I'm speaking generally.

Which yeah, I'll admit the problem with Vasilisa and Palmira is they are kinda gimmick characters, as I thought adding some pulp sci-fi and noir archetypes in would be fun, but not much beyond that. Though Palmira does have the implication that their hard-boiled attitude is just an act. Kind of a good thing Snapdragon wasn't voted for earlier, since now I've got more time to tweak her character if she does show up.

Miyako was truly born in the wrong generation. She missed her true vocation: Being the cheerful genki ditz who holds the magical girl team together.

It is the opening line of the Quest after all
 
Last edited:
[X] Ease in, try cheering her up by talking about how much Emi's manga meant to her back in school.
-[X] And how it's still meaningful; her publisher can take her job, but they can't take the impact she made on her readers.
 
[X] Ease in, try cheering her up by talking about how much Emi's manga meant to her back in school.
-[X] And how it's still meaningful; her publisher can take her job, but they can't take the impact she made on her readers.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top