Ad Astra ex Lutum

Their complaints are something of a signifier of the general mood of the Sovereignty with if anything a view of the Authority as a militarized state that is built entirely around military matters.
Reasonable preparedness has been several times mistaken as some radical mobilization program with many of the professors hired and visiting convinced that something must be wrong with the general population.

Why does the galaxy think we're Space North Korea, wonders the elves, as they mobilize sizeable fractions of their entire population into the Reserves, in 'peace-time'.

In the general view of social sciences academia Dannan itself is a world that is challenging to survive on much less thrive, documenting the entire species as being in something of a permanent survival mode instead of what they perceive as a regular civilian mode of operation
All of this is of course wrong and misguided

Amazing. The elves really did look at the entire galaxy telling them they're all traumatized to the bone and flat-out rejected it because elves are 'just built different'.

Upon making the breach, the enemy decided to surrender instead of fighting on as expected.
Overall the operation was a complete success, with all objectives completed. Thirty-four (34) prisoners were taken, including the CO. Four (4) out of eighteen (18) of our force were wounded.

Elf Commando: Why the heck did the pirates surrender instead of fighting to the death? They only had a 66% fatality against a force a fifth their size, of which they killed none!

Limitations to filtration supplies have forced consistent attacks while plentiful reserves of exchange-era gasses have been utilized effectively
Attempts to use nuclear earthquake charges were noticed and criticized as a mild excess despite only a few hundred warheads used to destabilize networks

Only our favorite space-elves would use gas attacks and 'just' a few hundred nukes for urban warfare.
 
Two quick plan doodles:
[] Plan Discreet Spending
-[] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[] Specialist Unit Issue
-[] System Defense Optimizations
-[] Limited Batteries (-50B)

[] Plan Slightly Less Discreet Spending
-[] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[] Specialist Unit Issue
-[] System Defense Optimizations
-[] Heavy Laser Installations (-150B)

Point by point:
- Expand Technical Funding: The budget is next turn so might as well spend lol, and getting our issues with the basic functionality of PA ironed out in the first generation would be good for the future.
- Specialist Unit Issue: Our first gen lasers aren't that great so I don't think it's worth pushing for larger scale production. For now we can equip our best units with these and then circle back later for a second gen laser after we've digested the relevant techs a bit more. Also, even moderate equipment production cost increases will noticeably eat into our budget due to our 4 million elf army, so I'd rather spend that money on shipyards and industry and programs and blah blah etc. you get the idea.
- System Defense Optimizations: Our fleet will be focused on self-defense for the foreseeable future, so I don't think cutting the range is that much of an issue (this also disqualifies the Comprehensive Overhaul, since we don't have a significant need for a deep raider right now). I do also like the Light Cruiser Conversion for the improved general performance, but it's an extensive refit that involves extending the hull which introduces some technical risks since that's a pretty major change, and the extra 40B XCU it'd cost....blegh. If it comes down to it we can buy a couple unmodified Acalans for adventures, depending on how the XCU budget looks next turn. There's also the Heavy Tactical Destroyer, but that's mostly just too expensive for my tastes, in addition to the concerns about the degree of refit required (shared with the Light Cruiser Conversion).
- The lasers are mostly a question of detectability. Limited Batteries reduces the chance of us leaking, but also can only deter reconnaissance efforts and leaves more budget unused, whereas Heavy Laser Installations improves the bunker's defenses but might raise suspicions. FWIW we did roll well on the coverup so we might be able to afford the increased heat from heavier fortifications and it's also possible the Xolotlans leak the bunker which isn't something we have control over, so I'm personally leaning towards the Heavy Laser Installations, but eh, not sure on this so I'm open to arguments either way.
 
Last edited:
Heavy Laser Installations do seem like a good hedge. Otherwise, agree completely with all the other choices made in those drafts.
 
I do like the comprehensive refits, they are expensive, but would provide us with a very potent raiding force and could cause a lot of delays the PRLM's Manifest Destiny timetable if they are used well

If the blorbos are ever in trouble, they'd be perfect as well.

System Defense is probably the "optimal" choice for us, but there is something to be said about allowing some flexibility in our fleets. They'd be very limited outside their, albeit very important, role of protecting Daanan itself. Though its worth noting we do have a XS flotilla providing that role as well (they won't be adventuring out into the Dead Zone on our behalf either)
 
Last edited:
Coalition executives have indicated that strongly protectionist practices go against the spirit of the treaty, if not the text but even this complaint has been only stated informally. Current cultural interpretation teams believe that this is a half-hearted attempt to secure more profit instead of a genuine tension point of the relationship as strong export growth has contributed significantly to their bottom line. Their complaints are something of a signifier of the general mood of the Sovereignty with if anything a view of the Authority as a militarized state that is built entirely around military matters. Diplomatically the perception is not useless, but this will color perceptions across the known cluster significantly. Reasonable preparedness has been several times mistaken as some radical mobilization program with many of the professors hired and visiting convinced that something must be wrong with the general population.

These theoretically well-meaning academics have not produced a diplomatic incident yet but they have if anything been more pervasive than actual enemy agents. Xolotlan professionals who should know better have documented several qualities that they believe are indicative of severe societal stress on every level to make strange and radical conclusions. In the general view of social sciences academia Dannan itself is a world that is challenging to survive on much less thrive, documenting the entire species as being in something of a permanent survival mode instead of what they perceive as a regular civilian mode of operation. Militarization of youths has been criticized across several papers with the worst of the criticism coming from the softer Xolotlan core worlds convinced that current practices are stunting growth, damaging the youths, and harmful to self-perceptions of social competency.

All of this is of course wrong and misguided, because of an altered social base that has so far failed to endure any similar level of crisis. The development of early society in a universal and permanent state of privation has had some effects on the general mentality but their criticisms are fundamentally cultural instead of psychological. Intensive competition for positions has brought up the best of a generation and proven to be strongly motivating for all who can strive. Their models of population and mentality are derived from a concept that expanded variation would induce significant variation in personal capabilities instead of a general baseline where growth is determined solely by personality and will. Their models of support for those lacking ability are fundamentally flawed when applied to the Authority and can somewhat be disregarded outside of genuinely disaffected populations directly affected by acute trauma.
Bloody hell Ricky...

I find this tiring. It was fun in the chaotic periods of nuclear war and initial alien invasion, but I've been losing interest in our space elves because they (or at least our PC) sounds like the stereotypical cringy HFY (Humanity Fuck Yeah) protagonists. Wanking to their physical superiority, the outrageous yields of their atom bombs, and how overoptimized their society is to sending a tenth of it to die in military operations, all while the rest of the galaxy wonders when they'll finally modernize out of the "might makes right" philosophy of societal organization.

What light at the end of the tunnel is there for our space-Sparta?
 
Bloody hell Ricky...

I find this tiring. It was fun in the chaotic periods of nuclear war and initial alien invasion, but I've been losing interest in our space elves because they (or at least our PC) sounds like the stereotypical cringy HFY (Humanity Fuck Yeah) protagonists. Wanking to their physical superiority, the outrageous yields of their atom bombs, and how overoptimized their society is to sending a tenth of it to die in military operations, all while the rest of the galaxy wonders when they'll finally modernize out of the "might makes right" philosophy of societal organization.

What light at the end of the tunnel is there for our space-Sparta?
This feels like a very uncharitable reading; to me Ricky (our PC) comes across as very defensive, not wanking over any superiority. Especially considering Ricky is probably the most defeatist player character Ive seen. He's being defensive because his whole society and government is receiving heavy criticism out of "nowhere".

Also, calling elf society space-Sparta, in addition to being unfair, does not at all seem right. Might doesn't make right in elf society, you're elected based on your policies and such, or you move up the ranks as a military officer in a very normal way (if much slower due to immortality). In fact, we've been deliberately suppressing fascism, recently breaking their big party in two. It's a highly egalitarian democratic society, which admittedly is also highly militaristic. But its not a slave-state bent on oppressing and dominating 90% of its population.
 
Bloody hell Ricky...

I find this tiring. It was fun in the chaotic periods of nuclear war and initial alien invasion, but I've been losing interest in our space elves because they (or at least our PC) sounds like the stereotypical cringy HFY (Humanity Fuck Yeah) protagonists. Wanking to their physical superiority, the outrageous yields of their atom bombs, and how overoptimized their society is to sending a tenth of it to die in military operations, all while the rest of the galaxy wonders when they'll finally modernize out of the "might makes right" philosophy of societal organization.

What light at the end of the tunnel is there for our space-Sparta?
To an extent, the well, approach is far far more North Korea and being desperate then so to say feelings of superiority. Ricky himself is incredibly doomer on your actual prospects against a small fleet much less a state that is trying. With his assessment basically squarely that you will get kicked over without much you can do about. The current attitudes are more of him tilting that his own culture is being looked at as an oriental thing picked at because its oh so sad that the poor elves are struggling.
 
Bloody hell Ricky...

I find this tiring. It was fun in the chaotic periods of nuclear war and initial alien invasion, but I've been losing interest in our space elves because they (or at least our PC) sounds like the stereotypical cringy HFY (Humanity Fuck Yeah) protagonists. Wanking to their physical superiority, the outrageous yields of their atom bombs, and how overoptimized their society is to sending a tenth of it to die in military operations, all while the rest of the galaxy wonders when they'll finally modernize out of the "might makes right" philosophy of societal organization.

What light at the end of the tunnel is there for our space-Sparta?
Where do you even get that reading? this is Ricky not liking being told by another species that their culture and way of life is wrong. And I don't know how you got that take of elfs somehow caring about physical superiority or that their society is somehow optimized or that they are even remotely sounding HFY.
It has been a constant the entire quest since the aliens arrived that if any of the states around them actually made an effort the elfs would be crushed in an instant, that the war we recently had was with an underfunded corporate expedition that was still kicking our ass that we decided a treaty was better than to continue fighting which does not sound at all like what HFY content usually portrays.
And of course the core worlds of a superpower dislike the highly militaristic nature of the elfs, never mind that they have been moving from crisis to crisis, from their previous society with the panopticon, to the apocalypse to the invasion to now having a hostile neighbor intent on claiming them and their home as its property.
 
Last edited:
Tbf to Ricky when your population is immortal as a baseline the productive hours lost to reserve training do matter way less.

Still should hope we have enough up and comers who are willing to listen to the alien shrinks who are currently wondering if getting published off observing a severely traumatized society is explosive or not.

Edit: also I wish we had an option to fororfy a useless moon entirely to bushwhack a PRLM ship and make then second guess proving our fortifications
 
Last edited:
I think Heavy Laser Installations is the best choice and that the laser rifles are most worthwhile as lessons learned about how to build the next generation of lasers.
 
The "radical mobilization program" that foreign academics are freaking out about is the PE classes that teach basic infantry tactics in all our schools, not an actual significant amount of real mobilization pretty sure. A 4 million elf standing army and another few million reservists is what, maybe 0.5% of our population? That's a mobilization rate on par with the hyper-militarized juggernauts of... uh... Lithuania and Turkmenistan. Not really that extreme, less than half a Ukraine or Israel and less than a quarter of a North Korea.
 
[X] Plan Slightly Less Discreet Spending
-[X] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[X] Specialist Unit Issue
-[X] System Defense Optimizations
-[X] Heavy Laser Installations (-150B)

[X] Plan Blorbo Defense Fleet, Bargain Edition
[X] Plan Blorbo Defense Fleet

Moratorium's up. So voting for @CrabMonarchy 's plan. Prefer Heavy Laser Installations.

I would probably prefer issuing more of the rifle. But I'll bow to consensus on that. It's certainly not bad to iterate and expand our factory first. I just worry it's too slow for the amount of tension in our area

Edit: Approval voting for the Blorbo defense plans. We realistically can't really protect them. But we can try!
 
Last edited:
I do want to have a discussion on some of these options before I vote, despite favoring everything in Plan Slightly Less Discreet Spending, as to avoid making a silly decision simply because no discussion was going on.

Going down the list, Expand Technical Funding does seem like the best choice when put in the context of the first gen suit walking so the second gen suit can run. It clearly states that the extra work done here will help significantly for our next attempt; and I think implicitly it also states that the extra money spent here wont really be worth it for the current suit were building, when looking at a cost-benefit analysis. But again, thats fine, we're still in the phase where technical development is the name of the game.

As for the light laser rifle, the big thing is that its in somewhat of a weird spot doctrinally. I think that, given that the next plan will almost certainly demand a loooot of technical funding to actually expand upon all the theoretical technologies wer are developing, Specialist Unit Issue is the best bet. Two hundred thousand laser rifles is actually a lot of fucking laser rifles; if given to only frontline personnel that's still several armies worth of laser rifles. Ultimately if we get invaded next plan, having more or less laser rifles will probably not actually be that important compared to other, more strategically decisive weapons systems. Hence Specialist Unit Issue.

Id agree with System Defense Optimizations. This looks like by far the most robust variant for turning the ship into an escort ship, which is something we need. While having something that can deploy outside our system would be nice, system defense is and should remain our highest priority right now. We need to operate within our constraints here.

The moon fortification is the one im least sure of. Funding isnt realy an issue now unless we go for the absolutely heaviest fortification option, but thats so attention grabbing I think its super silly. The question is then between the cheapest, most discreet option or the "middle of the road" option. Going for the heavier one to "prevent waste" is a bad argument, but I think that the heavy laser installations still seem to be the most reasonable. We've already had PRLM ships entering our system in an aggressive fashion, and theres reason to believe they might escalate more. Theres a very real chance this moon will get raided even without them knowing about the artifacts. In addition, we arent the only ones that can leak stuff here, so doubling down on trying to be discreet only for the Sovereignty to let something slip would be painful. The heavy laser installations would make their worth known in any scenario except a full invasion fleet, given that we know laser batteries on planetary bodies can easily win most gun duels against ships much more expensive than them. In addition, ultimately this whole thing is about buying time for us too loot the moon. A smaller force is much faster and easier to mobilize than a larger force. I think finally, the fact that there is an explanation for why we're building such heavy defenses that doesnt involve the artifact; the fact that there is a jump point there, adds a lot of robustness to our deception operations. Most people will find the first layer of secrets and be content with it.

Therefor yeah, Id vote for this.

[X] Plan Slightly Less Discreet Spending
-[X] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[X] Specialist Unit Issue
-[X] System Defense Optimizations
-[X] Heavy Laser Installations (-150B)

However, I hope others consider the options in more depth, and hopefully come with some counter arguments somewhere.
 
[X] Plan Blorbo Defense Fleet
-[X] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[X] Specialist Unit Issue
-[X] Comprehensive Overhaul
-[X] Heavy Laser Installations (-150B)

[X] Plan Blorbo Defense Fleet, Bargain Edition
-[X] Expand Technical Funding (-100B)
-[X] Specialist Unit Issue
-[X] Mild Modernizations
-[X] Heavy Laser Installations (-150B)

System defense makes a lot of sense, but it does sacrifice flexibility. If we do the Overhaul we would have an extremely capable raiding fleet that could cause the PRLM a lot of trouble. If the Lirrir are ever in trouble we'd only really have our Light Cruiser to deal with whatever forces are against them if we do system defense.

I've made a variant plan that does mild modernizations as well, since the overhaul is costly, though we will be able to sell superconductors to gain export revenues.
 
[X] Plan Slightly Less Discreet Spending
[X] Plan Blorbo Defense Fleet, Bargain Edition

I'm willing to go for mild modernization instead but I'm really skeptical that the costs of a deep overhaul are worth the capabilities it gives.
 
Back
Top