- Location
- Canada
[X] Sophistication and Academia
Programing it to start after the OP solve most of the issues, after one only has to account with the few time where the tally doesn't group answer as it should.[X] Be extraordinary
Vote tally seems a bit messed up, so it might need to be counted manually.
Was approval voting allowed or were people just making assumptions?
At this point the only meaningfull change I made was having the Dragons formaly divided, I felt I needed to better drive home how badly the war had affected them. I plan to flesh out some things more when I will get to it but there won't be too many actual divergences for now. I do plan to note it when I will made changes compared to the RP, both in further developing stuff and in downright modifying when it will come to it.I did consider going for Wizarding Patrician in Sophistication and Academia, but my goal with that plan was to give a somewhat middle ground within the constraints of the character idea I had - Ravenclaw and a flair/appreciation for sophistication, which would be of the enlightened academic in Ravenclaw. I had other potential ideas for the character, but that's dependant on the choices the character takes, should this plan even be accepted.
For example, people could choose to go a more Wicked Cultured route (because smart and intelligent villains and antagonists are the shit) or a more well-meaning one. Another option would be for the character to have a motivation of making his family rise to the very top of their society in terms of status, social, politic and economic power, so the second tier (quite rich parents but not overly so) was best for it. It's the best place for the character to actually have wealth and some status and yet want more of it, if the player base decides that, of course.
To be honest, the point of the plan is to give an easily starting point from which to work towards a particular characterization: as a Ravenclaw and a Sphinx to boot, it's easy to swing either towards a pro-Rainbow Ministry stance, a low-key Pro-Grindewaldite (and even maybe future Voldemort supporter), or go for a neutral stance in the beginning and be a able to support it within the narrative with only a
few adjustments. I honestly think going for Ravenclaw gives us plenty of options, even if it may seem like a "safe choice".
And besides, I'm itching for a good Ravenclaw quest. Too many Slytherin ones, we already got Gryffindor in canon and tbh, I don't really care too much for Hufflepuff
@phil03 I was wondering if you were going to change some of the lore sections of the RP or you're going to let them as they were? I've seen the few you've posted, but haven't had the chance to go over them in detail.
Also, I can't wait to see the RP characters show up.
I did account for all that, don't worry. My reasoning was more or less what you say in terms of being able to shape the character to the point the character's political stance might shift after extensive character development: this is especially relevant when it comes to Grindelwald and Riddle, since it would take a committed player base to shift the Sphinx stance enough for the PC to consider allying with such people. Basically, if people want the PC to be villain/evil, they'd need to actually work for it given the starting political stance, which is a good thing in my opinion, since it would take commitment to go through it and not just half-ass it.Programing it to start after the OP solve most of the issues, after one only has to account with the few time where the tally doesn't group answer as it should.
By my count here is the tally at this point:
Sophistication and Academia: 14
Here there be Giants: 11
Here we go again: 9
Take it to the bank: 5
Be Extraordinary: 4
Plan Puffwitch, For that nice Emigrée flavour, The Outsider: 1
At this point the only meaningfull change I made was having the Dragons formaly divided, I felt I needed to better drive home how badly the war had affected them. I plan to flesh out some things more when I will get to it but there won't be too many actual divergences for now. I do plan to note it when I will made changes compared to the RP, both in further developing stuff and in downright modifying when it will come to it.
As for the characters from the RP, some of the choices of the next update would have you pick some friends and rivals you made during the last four years and you can bet there will be a fair few of them as options in both regards! In fact, while I do plan to have them stay who they are at their core, they might very well be the firsts in whom you might nevertheless see some differences from the RP if your choices change their backstories
As for your reasoning on your character, overall you make a solid case for your plan. The one caviat I would make would be when it come to how politics will play. Overall all choices you have will have consequences and be important in where the PC will start, how he/she is seen, his/her interactions and who he/she will be, political factions included. None of them are blankslates and the Sphinxes have their beliefs and program.
For the Sphinxes these beliefs and program include an opposition to everything they see as extremism, especially the violent kind, and that lead most of them to be fervent supporters of the war against Grindelwald. Obviously, and since we are talking about very decentralised factions here rather then political parties as we understand the term, there is always some exceptions, like Evelyn in the RP, but overall dislike for Grindelwaldism is one of the thing the overwhelming majority of them would agree on. This is reflected by the fact that choosing the Sphinx as your faction also give you the Anti-Grindelwaldite trait.
In fact, the Rainbow Ministry the (i.e the coalition government presently in charge of the ministry because of the war, more on them latter for those who didn't play the RP) is at its core an alliance between Sphinxes and Phoenixes that smaller groups joined more or less shortly after it was concluded.
Now, none of this mean that your beliefs are necessarely set in stone, traits gain be gained or lost and there is definitely ways to have a PC that is villainous for apolitical reasons. It is fair to say, however, that a Sphinx PC will start with a pretty firm position on the war and is unlikely to be convinced by what Riddle would propose without some serious changes in their ideologies beforehand.
Hopefully I didn't ramble too much but the overall point I tried to make, that choosing a faction is an opportant decision and that no matter what you choose you will open and close at least some posibilities down the line, is valid for all plan so I felt it was worth spending some virtual ink to make