Virian
Sage of Reason and incomplete information
- Location
- Where logic has never been before
- Pronouns
- he/him
Please don't, that's how we got the mess that is 40k.
But yeah, this is the Eldar in a nutshell.
Last edited:
Please don't, that's how we got the mess that is 40k.
The issue with the whole sane man trope is that it requires special conditions in order to work. Unless you're powerful enough to shrug off everything that is thrown your way you have to play by the same rules as everyone else does.I'm going to be honest, I hoped that the MC would be something of a foil to the 40K setting. My biggest pet peeve with 40K, is that nobody seems to acknowledge how fucking corny and goofy it is. I'd hoped that the MC would've been the straight/sane man, looking in and laughing(with all of us) at the ridiculousness. Instead, it's like he went native.
I could overlook the sudden xenophobia and the sudden case of "hard man do hard choices" syndrome for a little while. But more and more it feels like he's trying to fit in with cool kids, so he thinks, talks and makes decisions like someone born in the setting.
It makes me nervous about the future of this fic. Will he actually do something original with Reapertech, or will he just try to recreate 40K tech, with a twist?
I like the fic, I am eager for every chapter and I won't drop it yet. It's just... wasted potential, you know?
If you ever find yourself in Biel Tan... However possible that is and you don't get annihilated within the first attosecond, ask one of the people in the Path of Service... Though you may find them in sore demand as they are much fewer in number in Biel Tan than of other craftworlds, ask them to take you to the library where they hold the records of how many enemies the Craftworld has.the moment someone enters the 40K universe. Blaming the Eldar is mandatory, just like asking the emperor to cover your ass. (unless you are a machine god that can cover yourself)
But yeah everything that went wrong in 40k can be traced to the Eldar.
And honestly, with the amount of mess they make, that the other races need to clean. I wonder why their not more effort into exterminating them. (not advocating genocide just I wonder why the other race arent "more" genocidal toward them)
I agree that OP needs to do interact with the universe and take it seriously. But The Sane Man should already do that. What I'm worried about is how it affects their thinking. Like, even if they read the lore or all the Black Library novels, why are they acting like they're gospel? Even in the books, it's quite clear that the authors wrote the characters like they're xenophobic, biased and brainwashed with propaganda; ie. not having reliable perspectives on events. Even the Emperor isn't free of this, otherwise he'd not gotten got like he did. But OP doesn't act like that's the case.The issue with the whole sane man trope is that it requires special conditions in order to work. Unless you're powerful enough to shrug off everything that is thrown your way you have to play by the same rules as everyone else does.
Two things.I agree that OP needs to do interact with the universe and take it seriously. But The Sane Man should already do that. What I'm worried about is how it affects their thinking. Like, even if they read the lore or all the Black Library novels, why are they acting like they're gospel? Even in the books, it's quite clear that the authors wrote the characters like they're xenophobic, biased and brainwashed with propaganda; ie. not having reliable perspectives on events. Even the Emperor isn't free of this, otherwise he'd not gotten got like he did. But OP doesn't act like that's the case.
This sort of thinking is a big problem with the 40k fandom overall, so it's not such a big deal because you see this in most fanfics, but it is a little disappointing. Like, his idea of a racially segregated republic. It seems to be based on the Imperiums view of Xenos, about how you can't thrust them - due to what happened before the Imperiums founding, or something. The problem is that there's NO reason for someone from our time, with our common understanding of how bias and interests form how history is written, to believe it one iota. I'm not saying that the alien races that are the Imperiums main opponents aren't dangerous, but it's important to notice that the ones that weren't that are most likely genocided and then forgotten. We know that after the fall a lot of Xeno allies turned on humanity, but how often did the opposite happen? How often, during the crusades, did they stumble onto a planet where humanity had enslaved their alien neighbors or the conflict wasn't as black and white? Where humans and aliens lived quite amicably, working side by side with each other? Those instances wouldn't count and just like racist/nationalists/nazis today, proof of cooperation or the world being more nuanced than what they believe, would not be seen as flaws in their ideology.
The authors have made these things extremely clear for the reader, without out and out saying it, so why do we have so many SI's that blindly swallow the Imperiums narrative almost whole sale, with so little critical thought? Some might just disagree with how the Emperor went' about things, but that's it. That's what's dissapointing. Despite being a nation of minds, working together, they haven't stopped and thought about these ideas and how it should affect their view of how they should go about things.
This will affect how OP deals with the wider universe and that's the problem. What strategical and tactical decisions will they take, thinking like that? Will they be able to use their advantages in creative ways, or will it stop with 40k ideas with some reaper tech, patched in?
I would assume in the"Creative Discussion & Worldbuilding" section.Quick question, where would be best to post that thread? I am not sure if fits directly into user fiction or should be elsewhere...
pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeas tell me Cegorach just signed his on death warent along with the eldar race
Mekhane is connected to the warp in the same way Aphrael is. Like her, his power is from the warp, but not of the warp. Like all beings possess a conection to hell, this is theirs and theirs alone. Essentially its their birthright. But when you fuse so many birthrights together you get a massively different result, and thus this power is yours and yours alone.If my guess is right, he is actually ensuring he is surviving.
I mean, if Mekhane wanted to, he could have gone the Necron Pylons Go Brr route. Which would lead to the death of beings like the Eldar. Because destroying the Warp would do... a lot of damage.
If Cegorach is making sure the OCP that is Mekhane is now as tied to the Warp as every other living being... well... it kinda closes that route.
And allows Mekhane to eventually take over once he kills the other Warp Tumors.
Kinda surprised the Knife didn't have Anarchy in it too. But then, he is probably still sealed up and too weak to do anything. And Emps isn't ascended yet. So the 6.
So, I'm trying to understand this. It implies that a "third microcycle" is a unit by itself. But it has third in it? What is it third to?
Ah, easy.So, I'm trying to understand this. It implies that a "third microcycle" is a unit by itself. But it has third in it? What is it third to?