[X] - Select Nothing - I didn't ask for this gift, and I sure as hell don't want an Evil God's dodgy help.
In fantasy settings, specially those with multiple gods, they don't really tend to be all that great it seems. Also a trickster god, as if their blessings wouldn't have a downside. I doubt they would make things harder for entertainment, but they would probably be like "here, have this, now let me take this one thing away..." or something like that. I feel any buff with bring a debuff with it.
Anyways, I'm not too fond on getting a blessing from a god from this so soon. Also I just thought about Devil Survivor and how the MC got into the main war for power by getting power. Well, they defeated another candidate first, and just to survive, but still, I have a feeling that a 'blessing' may also work as a signal for others that want that throne thing. Just my thoughts. Also I probably will try and vote for non-demon king options. That would bring too much trouble unless for some reason we can pull an "Evil God Average" scenario and bluff our way to victory. Eh, either way I'm not really fond of that goal.
[X] - Try to calm my emotions. Panicking won't do me any good - I should figure out how I got here from the church, did I black out? How much did I miss?