- Pronouns
- She/Her
Time to go deep undercover and become friends with a bunch of Death Eaters and blood purists so we can snack on popcorn while watching their impending dooms like a TV show 🍿🍿🍿
The Shyish Student (An Amethyst Apprentice in Hogwarts) [Warhammer Fantasy/Harry Potter]
- Thread starter Oksbad
- Start date
- Crossover Fantasy
You have to keep in mind that the person's reaction is also important in determining how funny it is. Hermione has very strong possibilities for humor.
I don't remember anything about this happening in the book. The only thing I know of that it could be is something related to Magister Grey. Of course it could be completely unrelated to us, but it's still noteworthy.
Shinji117
Endless Troller
- Location
- Rokkenjima (Sydney)
- Pronouns
- He/Him
IIRC it's the excuse for why Dumbledore isn't at Hogwarts when Harry and co 'have to' go into the forbidden corridor to stop the stone being yoinked.
- Location
- Madness realms
Perfect representation of the Hogwarts teachers hapoy to say reassuring statements not happy to actually do anything.
The wiki says that it was a letter from the Ministry, but I could see Quirrell doing that instead. In canon the attempt was made after Christmas, but here Quirrelemort has some other concerns, like Nyx's pomander. Combined with the grindylow incident, and Voldemort probably wants to get out ASAP.
We did see a vision of green light, which could be the killing curse.
- Location
- USA
[X] Don't talk to Hagrid about your concerns.
[X] Just tell her that Neville's been locked out of the common room before. Ask her to help make sure he isn't again.
Warning delivered to those responsible and the individual in danger. Neville's Fate has been influenced, let the World turn as it may.
[X] Just tell her that Neville's been locked out of the common room before. Ask her to help make sure he isn't again.
Warning delivered to those responsible and the individual in danger. Neville's Fate has been influenced, let the World turn as it may.
Dunkelzahn
Dragon of the Sixth World
- Location
- Manitoba, Canada
Praise Morr! Now to get into arguments with Trelawney over who is actually in imminent danger or not
As far as people we can actually interact with go, I'd say Ron. Imagine Zagreus trying to explain to Ron that he's in serious danger, only for Ron to not believe him in the slightest given their history together, forcing Zagreus to take desperate measures to make sure Ron stays safe, much to Ron's aggravation (and possibly to Harry and Dean's amusement).
As for the vote:
[X] Talk to Hagrid about your concerns.
I'd like to know if Fluffy would, under ordinary circumstance, pursue someone outside of his designated protection zone or not. Because if Fluffy is trained not to pursue/attack anyone outside the door's entrance, then that has some implications given that the vision version of Fluffy did (never mind the whole 'door seemingly opening on its own' bit, and whatever the flash of green means).
[X] Just tell her that Neville's been locked out of the common room before. Ask her to help make sure he isn't again.
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
Probably not, there would not be screams after it happened. Unless it was used on somebody else than him.
Honestly think that what actually happened in the vision was Neville got attacked by Voldemort with a killing curse that misses thanks to Fluffy attacking the unnaturally smelling man. Neville is just screaming because he is seeing one of his professors being ripped apart by Good Doggo.
- Location
- Canada
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Welp, can't possibly regret saving Neville from death. Good choice to go with.
I do fear we are getting hoodwinked into causing Neville's death instead…
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
I don't think thats how morrite prophecies work. Outside of Doomings.
How so? We saw a vision, we could be misintepriting it and instead of fluffy saving Neville doggo is locked up tighter and Neville gets killing cursed.
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
Because thats not how Morrite future telling works? Morr is not going to tell you something just to lead you down the path to fulfill it. He isn't some cheap TV Tropes tragedy hour edgelord.
Dooming tells you how you die, that much is true, but as far as i am aware, his visions are otherwise just that, visions of future, to do with what you will. He isn't Tzeentch.
Last edited:
You completely misinteprited my post, congrats.
Our vision showed Fluffy attacking someone after a flash of green, with Neville screaming
Your interpretation is that was a vision of Neville dying.
My image is that we saw Fluffy save Neville from Voldemort's killing curse and our anti-Fluffy actions could just end up Neville there chasing his rememberball and getting ganked with Fluffy unable to help.
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
Then the vision would not be named Friend in Danger.
Again, i don't think Morr hands out self-fulfilling prophecies.
Last edited:
You don't call a near-miss with the killing curse a danger?
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
In my universe, where Voldemort kills Neville, yes. In yours, the interpretation is that it will miss. Since it is foretold by a vision granted by Morr, there was clearly no chance of it hitting. Ergo, no danger.
I disagree. What we saw was a situation where a single thing going wrong ends with Neville dying. The situation is dangerous.
- Location
- United Kingdom
Hell, one of the big reasons we got this vision now was because we were celebrating Von Alxber's night, which came about because a priest got a vision from Morr and used it to avert the disaster he foresaw.
It's entirely possible things still go badly despite our attempts to change things, but the vision itself isn't going to be a trick.
Side note, I am curious why Zagreus didn't consider that the vision might be from Morr.
It's entirely possible things still go badly despite our attempts to change things, but the vision itself isn't going to be a trick.
Side note, I am curious why Zagreus didn't consider that the vision might be from Morr.
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
Right, which is why we told him what we did.
But you think it ends up with Fluffy eating Quirrel, and the situation apparently resolves itself without our input. So clearly he has never been in actual danger of dying.
I choose to believe that Morr did not give us the prophecy just to set us on path to kill our friend by saying a wrong line somewhere down the line because he gave us the prophecy in the first place.
Last edited:
pucflek
Verified simpleton
- Location
- Czech Republic
Kids solving Crimes again ahoy.
[X] Don't talk to Hagrid about your concerns.
[X] Share the details of your vision, as you've shared with Neville himself. Ask her to keep an eye out on Neville.
My reasoning is mostly that, well, you would expect Hermione to be disagreeable to this, because, you know, the way she views Divination in canon. But i am pretty sure she gets soured on the idea of it being legitimate, if not always reliable, subject by the disaster trainwreck that is Trelawney. She appears to respect Zagreus's academic prowess. So i think it would be okay to go for the most overt option, because she is not yet disillusioned, and she might have a rivalry going on but clearly respects him as a peer.
[X] Don't talk to Hagrid about your concerns.
[X] Share the details of your vision, as you've shared with Neville himself. Ask her to keep an eye out on Neville.
My reasoning is mostly that, well, you would expect Hermione to be disagreeable to this, because, you know, the way she views Divination in canon. But i am pretty sure she gets soured on the idea of it being legitimate, if not always reliable, subject by the disaster trainwreck that is Trelawney. She appears to respect Zagreus's academic prowess. So i think it would be okay to go for the most overt option, because she is not yet disillusioned, and she might have a rivalry going on but clearly respects him as a peer.
Last edited: