Bloody Evolution (RWBY / LoR)

Have we had confirmation if Carmen is active on Remnant? Ash's conversation doesn't require such but I am curious how likely that might be.

We've certainly been seeing hints that Ash might turn against Binah. Whether by Carmen, Ozpin or her own will I doubt it can be averted now. Binah is too much a wildcard and too happily amoral.
 
Have we had confirmation if Carmen is active on Remnant? Ash's conversation doesn't require such but I am curious how likely that might be.

We've certainly been seeing hints that Ash might turn against Binah. Whether by Carmen, Ozpin or her own will I doubt it can be averted now. Binah is too much a wildcard and too happily amoral.

Pretty sure Binah had a nice lovely conversation with Carmen back when someone tried to unlock her aura.
 
Been thinking over why a vote wasn't present, and I wonder if the reason why is because Binah may be losing the Light real soon. The Spark of Light is the narrative conceit why we can vote, and if that isn't there, one has to wonder if something is happening to it.
is that the reason we can vote? I thought we were Binah's late-onset psychosis: the box-bot body is what protected Binah from the effects of looking into the Well, but she's not in the box-bot body anymore. And just remembering the Well can screw with the mind.

EDIT: so used to having to dig through chapters of text to find something implied, that I forgot that somethings are explicitly written in character sheets
 
Last edited:
is that the reason we can vote? I thought we were Binah's late-onset psychosis: the box-bot body is what protected Binah from the effects of looking into the Well, but she's not in the box-bot body anymore. And just remembering the Well can screw with the mind.

From Binah's Character Sheet, Traits tab:

-Spark of Light: The seed took ten thousand years to finally sprout. Enables access to vote options.
 
is that the reason we can vote? I thought we were Binah's late-onset psychosis: the box-bot body is what protected Binah from the effects of looking into the Well, but she's not in the box-bot body anymore. And just remembering the Well can screw with the mind.

Naron last quest, In the name of Love and Hatred, has Ai acknowledge the existence of the voters at the end of it, with them being revealed to be a being of the light, this quest seems to be using the same setup, except Binah acknowledged us way faster.

Though I have no idea where the idea of missing one single vote being due to her missing the light comes from, there are absolutely no sign of it in story, nor are there any reasons for it.
 
Seeing that this is a Quest working a lot with Project Moon's setting, I figured I should interweave what mechanics there are with the narrative as much as possible. You know, just like their games do :whistle:
 
That's two quests at the same time that are have a post with no voting. Coincidence? Maybe, iunno. But it's funny to imagine a weird crossover, of X broken open just ringing up Binah
 
Anyway, I don't think it is because binah lose the spark of light. It is just narrative reason because there is simply no choice to make at this point, there's no interesting thing happening and binah lost interest in following ash around like a babysitter.
If we tell her to follow, she will just veto it because she wants to do something different. If we tell her to do something different. Well, she's going to do something different anyway, who cares?
I really hope you are not pulling an turn into a distortion by the end of the month bullshit at us.
.. God now I want to write a ash omake, fuck
 
Ok, this idea popped into my head, and I just thought it would be cool. Another quest kinda like this, but it's Gebura in another fiction's world with Laetitia, Little Red, Der Freischütz, and the Child of the Galaxy. I know that these Abnos aren't all from the same floor, but I just think that the combo would be interesting, just to give Gebura some dedicated fighters to boss around (Little Red and Freischütz), and some cute but still dangerous kids to ad some levity(Laetitia and CotG). So Geb and co. have to beat up the big bad, and I'm thinking that Geb decides to set up a Fixer office as her front, as opposed to Binah's tea shop/info-broker. I was thinking Open for Business as a name.
I actually came up with a setting idea for Open for Business, Fire Force. I think seeing the world react to power sets that aren't based around fire would be interesting. And the possibilities of how the Infernal bugs could react to the Light and/or Gebura's E.G.O. would be real cool, because what would be better than the Red Mist? The Red Mist but on fire, that's what. Although there would likely be some scaling problems due to Fire Force being a shonen series.
 
i think she will get a new title, the crimson flame, the blood of the blaze.
or...
blood-soaked inferno.
And I don't think she will work for anyone, She likes to work alone more, Maybe she will be a repeating appearance like saving protags ass after Some misfortunes.
And she will be at a sideline saving people as she sees fit.
edit: idk why, but i want to do a ayin harry potter fic very badly. But I can't write. But I have so many good ideas but I just sucks at writing oh my fucking god.
it will be so bloody perfect with a slytherin Ayin, hokma and binah.
I want it I want it so badly fuck.
 
I want to see binah tearing the malfoys a new asshole with only words.
And dumbledore realizing that this little girls with black hair is more terrifying than that No nose.
 
...that could work, but why include Ayin and Hokma with her then? I can understand Hokma. He's the good cop to Binah's bad cop.

But Ayin?
 
As the harry potter stand in.
A guy with a real brain dealing with a black wizard with no brain will be very funny to see.
Also I have some plans with Hokma If I eventually put my mind to it and write the stuff out.
Carmen can join too, but yeah, theres going to be at least eight fan clubs at war with each other for her.
edit: orrrrrrr!
the original golden trio and this new trio of terror is going to duke it out because The golden trio think that binah is a death eater.
And ayin could finally have some more time with carmen together with no stress on their mind about saving the world.
edit: Ok, I'm going to make a Project moon related fanfic or crossover discussion thread, This is derailing the discussion. So I'm going to make it and link it here.
edit: here, Here it is.
Thread 'project moon related media crossover and fanfic ideas thread' project moon related media crossover and fanfic ideas thread Mature
 
Last edited:
24. Wingbeat of a Butterfly
Transcript
T'was:
Greetings, Madame Gale

Binah:
Grettings. I can not recall having the pleasure before. Few contact me in such a manner.

T'was:
Indeed. I prefer transactions to be made this way, I hope you do not mind.

Binah:
I have no reason to disagree with the customer's preferences. What is it that you seek?

T'was:
I am a private detective of little reknown. A client came to me with a missing person's case that I hope you may be able to help me with.
[Image attached]
Have you seen this woman or know of her current whereabouts? Her name is Cinder Fall.

Binah:
This woman has been in Vale a few months back. I have not seen her since, however. I will require a few days to make inquiries with my contacts.

T'was:
That is perfectly fine. Name your price and I will transfer it within the day.

Binah:
There is no need. Hold back the payment until our business concludes to spare both of us the hassle.

T'was:
...you are quite trusting

Binah:
No one has yet dared to cross me a second time. I am not worried.

T'was:
I see


Studying the exchange again, Binah has to wonder how much of it was bold-faced lies. It has been more than three months since Cinder died. On the other hand, this is not the City; the dead are not cleaned up on the regular. A missing person may not necessarily be dead.

The fact she has neither a face nor a voice to put to her mystery customer is vexing; only so much can be read from mere text. The fact this person had a picture of a teenaged Cinder creates a great many questions, too.

What will she tell them? If they are truly the detective they claim to be, Binah has to send them onward. If they are an agent of Salem, deflecting the issue will clearly point suspicion upon Binah. Ozpin and Ironwood come to mind, but neither of them even knew of Cinder's presence.

Binah looks up and stares into the oscillating colours of her lamp. It sits almost innocently despite being something torn from a dead woman's self. It sat there for months, perfectly inert in its cage. Yet if even the slightest opening were given, it would once again try to escape. Just like a living being.

Thinking back to her research into the golden light, Binah is tempted to feed some of that into the cage. In fact, she hit a snag recently. There is definitely something important about it that she missed, but she can not determine what. A single piece to the puzzle.

After making a few calls to determine if Junior or Roman met particularly odd people of late and pointed them her way, she returns to the matter at hand. A battery of light and an injector are gathered from the safe, then she places several more lamps.

Once the preparations are done, Binah calls for Courage and activates a number of instruments. Weiss has since left and Ash is gone as well. The door is locked shut. Only then does Binah carefully inject light into the cage.

It reacts immediately.

Before their eyes, segments of the rainbow swirl are drawn out and dissolve into the light. Most remains, but the readings change dramatically as they watch. What is more, a veritable avalanche of Dust flows from the cage. Courage quickly opens it so the reinforced glass does not shatter from pressure alone; Binah barely manages to Lock the separate light as it makes to flee. It drops into a multi-coloured sea, Dust of all types haphazardly mixed together. The entire floor is covered half a metre upward.

Even Binah is surprised by the results.

"Is there anything different about this Dust?" she asks Courage while fishing for the Locked light.

Her companion is already cupping a handful of the material, verdant streamers running over every grain. "No," she judges a few minutes later. "This Dust is exactly the same as any other sample I analysed before."

She then cleans out the cage to return what is left of the rainbow back in. It seems more clear now, actually. Binah ruminates on the matter while Courage separates the different types of Dust and has them carried into boxes. Even with magic at her disposal, the process takes the better part of an hour due to the sheer amount.

By this point, Binah has a good idea what she missed.

Then Courage finishes analysing what the cage actually contains. "The readings were far more clear now," she reports. "It is a parasite of some sort. A benevolent type that latches onto a person's self and extends it, granting them instinctual access to magic. But it is broken. I think it may be looking to reunite with the other piece or pieces."

"It is aware?"

"No. It has no real wants, but it knows it is not whole and it knows where the rest of it is. They are drawn to each other like magnets."

Curious. The magic was unaffected by the golden light, yet something was removed. Something that muddled the readings and had the same reaction as aura when the light was added to it, only in a far greater measure. If aura is indeed the light of the soul, or the self as Binah prefers, then the answer is clear now.

Binah picks up the cage as she begins to muse. "It seems that however this little one was torn apart, a piece of the soul it was once grafted to was taken along. That piece is now gone. Yet a mere fragment of a soul could create enough Dust to last a single hunter for months. You always said there was something human within it, did you not?"

"Correct. So Dust is dissolved human souls?"

"No. Dust is the remains of souls given physicals form. This light must be adjacent to Cogito in its ability to manifest the mind, hence why it could restore the five Abnormalities that came to Remnant. This also explains how it adapts elemental properties when coming in contact with aura, it may react to the prominent emotion." Binah's considerations are not contradicted, yet she frowns. "But is it the intended result, or a byproduct? It does not explain my own circumstances, even though all leads point right back to this light."

"We have little proof for that," Courage reasons, "only the absence of other phenomena or Singularities."

"A fair point. And yet." Binah's eyes close as she once again attempts to recall a year of lost memories. The gap remains as insurmountable as ever. "And yet. We just saw it interact with the essence of a person and turn it to Dust. Emotions, sensations, even memories. Something I lack a significant amount of."

Is this the reason of her amnesia? Are the reconstitution of her old body and the loss of memories tied together? Was this the requirement for her rebirth?

On that final question, Binah's train of thought stumbles to a screeching halt.

Could it be possible?

"Courage." But a single word has the diminutive woman's head snap up. Binah sports an actual cheshire grin; excitement courses through every fibre of her body. "Where does one go when they die?" Butterflies almost flap their wings at the edge of her vision. "Do they simply vanish into the void? Do they meet again, as stars?" A sound reverberates through the room, only half heard. Binah's intent grows stronger, her voice faster: "Does salvation await, or penitence?" Ten wings seem to spread but fade, as does the gleam of an iron cross.

She grabs the surprised Courage by the shoulders, eagerly peering into her wide eyes. "Do they simply fade after a final blaze of glory?" Binah asks to the sound of a match being struck.

"Or perhaps, child, perhaps Remnant has a different answer. Does this light burn away the person, or does it simply wipe the slate clean? Is there even a difference? We must know. This takes priority over everything else. Vale, Vytal, Salem, they all mean nothing compared to this."

Courage nods ever so slowly, intimidated and even the smallest bit afraid by the sudden fervour. Once let go, she takes some distance. "I will see what I can do, but I do not quite know how to investigate the matter. Beyond human testing, which I disapprove of in this instance." Her voice firms up toward the end, which does not fail to amuse Binah. She could insist, but there is really no need to alienate her co-conspirator.

"We can always find undesirables to conduct the tests on," she counters. "It should not be difficult to scour prisons for appropriate sacrifices. I can have Roman keep an eye out for the kind of person even he will not deal with." And there are quite a few of these types; human trafficking, hard drugs, and serial killers are among that number. "And if we find none, we can always seek for those on death's door to observe their passing."

"I concur with the undesirables, provided that we ascertain they are indeed deserving of death." Courage is quiet for a long moment, contemplating what they learned. When she looks up at Binah, her expression reveals honest curiousity. "Why do you suddenly care so much?"

The older woman huffs at that. "I was reborn as Binah to serve in Lobotomy Corporation. I was reborn yet again when Angela stole the Light. By this metric, I was once again reborn when I regained my original body on Remnant. Only this last time, it was a natural process that yet stands superior over every human accomplishment. The question of where we go in death has never been answered decisively. Only religion and spirituality offer an answer, but they all build on faith.

"Hokma faithfully led the Records Department, recreating the same agents again and again from their templates. Were they still them after their first death? After the hundreth? Where did they go? Is the answer in the Light that we were all meant to vanish into?"

Having been denied a proper end of her own for ten thousand years, Binah's curiousity burns. She must know for certain, now that the answer to the oldest question is within her reach. She falls silent, her intent communicated; Courage nods slowly. Her hands absently move the blindfold back in place.

"Then we will do it. Just like you help my sisters and I, I will help you." She begins to stow the unnecessary instruments away again, but pauses when her gaze falls on the cage. "Now that we know what this is, what do we do with it?"

Her question is quite relevant. Binah's rapid heartbeat calms while she studies the piece of magical prowess. "Could you adjust it to be implanted into someone of our choice?"

"Yes, but I need to discern which rules govern the eligible candidates first. In addition, only a piece of the whole will not confer remotely as much power. A drop in the bucket when compared to the prowess our group already possesses." Courage puts a hand on the cage then. "You could just let it go," she suggests. "Let it rejoin the rest."

"Yet the original owner will never be whole again," Binah counters. A part of their self was cleaned away after all.

Courage is not deterred. "But the core piece yet remains in the magic's embrace. That person may lack some memories and suffer other damages, but they will regain the most important piece."

Binah inclines her head at that. She is not wrong. What should they do with this yet caged power?


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XgK_ME-EJE

-Goal fulfilled: Figure out the reason behind Binah's amnesia


[] Release it, to rejoin the whole

[] Have it implanted into...
-[] write-in who

[] Take the remaining pieces
-[] write-in how
 
[X] Release it, to rejoin the whole
It's not exactly useful for us, let Salem aggro onto Ozpin and let him deal with it
Watch the fireworks, in other words
 
Last edited:
Back
Top