Petals of Titanium -- My Life as a Mecha Setting Bridge Bunny Quest

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on

For a change, let's try....

[X] Someone you care for is lost
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged

why must you hurt us soooooo. Poor mecha pilots... plot armor's only barely enough to cover Gloriana.
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged

Let's do this, Rose. Go take one for the team!
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged

Well... hopefully the repairs to the sensor suit that broke regulation pay off.
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged
 
In a large scale fleet action, coordination is the key to victory. A less coordinated enemy force means more opportunities to exploit, while they will have a harder time doing the same to us.

In a similar vein, bombing the Rose means our side loses some of its own coordination edge, due to the loss of intel it provides. It can be argued that the Rose is just one ship and won't affect things that much - but I doubt it will be narratively insignificant. The Rose still has a part to play in this season finale.

Now that we've whittled down the cast to people I care (more) about, I'm reluctant to kill off any more. But I'll tactically change my vote to "Someone you care for is lost" if necessary.

[X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
But...
[X] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage
 
[X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
[X] The Rose is severely damaged

Why do you hurt me so, Gazetteer? Why do you make me choose where the knife will fall?
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged

It's not a real battle until the Rose gets torn to shreds again.
 
[X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
But...
[X] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Gazetteer on Oct 7, 2019 at 12:57 AM, finished with 13 posts and 13 votes.

  • [X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
    [X] The Rose is severely damaged
    [X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
    [X] The Rose is severely damaged
    [X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
    [x] Someone you care for is lost
    [X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
    [X] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage
 
Hm. So considering our side has extensive lists of the enemy fleet I'm going to guess key targets are their command ships, and vessels bearing whatever trump cards a bunch of fanatics who decided to ditch whatever little supply chain they in theory were able to maintain if they won.
 
"No," Rao says again. "The original document slated a number of ships for garrison and other backline duty, for various minor points they expected to capture swiftly on their way here. The same as their Iapetus attack fleet. If I had to make a guess, I suspect that they pulled all of those in and consolidated them back into the fleet."

"Even if they win, they won't have any supply lines to speak of, then," Sikes noted. "Not even what little they might have had. An insane gambit, but almost understandable, if they had word that the other major prong of the invasion has already failed."

actually, it was the right move. if they win here they just win. Their foes will have their beating heart torn out, facing both utterly untenable strategic losses, and the near-total destruction of their fleets. Sure survivors might roll up their supply lines immediately after, but well, so what? I'm assuming supplies are still coming in, so they can just hole up somewhere until the next shipment from Jupiter makes it, or failing that loot and pillage smaller orbitals to supply smashing the last few holdouts, or just punch through the remanants and leave. if they lose here those extra ships are fucked anyways, just maybe in a position to be able to retreat while burning some stuff down.

On a grand strategic scale, the cost is low, ships that would not change the ultimate outcome one way or the other. Sure it makes both a win or a lose blooier, but it's not like those ships would be needed in they win, or enough to really matter if they lose.

[ ] The Inner Fleet defenders rally at the appearance of reinforcements

morale is important, but we have a material disadvantage so I think its more important to spoke the enemies wheels.

[ ] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on

would you mind explaning what this would mean? like, we got their flagship or we wiped out a class of ship their plans needed?

[ ] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet

hmm, this one looks tempting. It speaks of the enemy being vulnerable but still able to hurt us. We probably want to take this if we don't maul the rose, since I suspect it would be able to take advantage of the enemies fucked up sensor nets to do a thing.


[ ] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage

I'm leaning no on this, because i'm aiming for a strategic win rather than the draw driving them off but taking heavy pop or industry damage would be.

[ ] Someone you care for is lost

not really sure who we'd lose, no one had any big death flags, but probably not one of the new pilots. their not really close to us.

[ ] The Rose is severely damaged

If this was at the end of the fight this would be an easy pick. But the fight is ongoing, and I'd put the rose as more useful than any one mech, so this would do the most damage to our ability to mitigate further harm.


I'm leaning towards characer death.
 
Last edited:
I'm about to go to sleep but I feel like people should be more careful about the 'Rose severely damaged' option. This is a major fleet battle and there's only so many hits we can take.
 
[X] The enemy formation is becoming scattered and stretched thin in trying to respond to the Outer Fleet
[X] The Rose is severely damaged
It honestly feels a bit nostalgic to fuck the Rose up one last time.
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] Someone you care for is lost
 
not really sure who we'd lose, no one had any big death flags
I dunno. This seemed pretty big and flaggy.
But there are always more, so many more, and J6 is making herself more and more of a target. Even she can be overwhelmed.
"Don't you want to live?" Daystar whispers. It's hard to see where she is, precisely, with how small the display is.

"Yes," J6 says.
 
Last edited:
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged
 
I dunno. This seemed pretty big and flaggy.

Not sure if its any more than

He's only just had this thought when Milo finds himself beset by a pair of Vespulas himself. They're meant to be scouting mecha, as far as he understands, but they maneuver on a dime, and they have enough firepower to take out a standard Banner in a pinch. Milo's not fighting in a standard Banner, thankfully, but the Empress Banner's improvements lay more in the realm of speed, scans and communication — It still isn't as fast as the ominous, eight-eyed shapes darting toward him through space.

One of them scores a hit, the shots striking his unit's cutter arm at an angle that doesn't penetrate, but he doesn't like the way it's suddenly sticking. He'll need that cutter when they close. Space around Titan, win or lose, is going to be a graveyard for years to come. Any one of them could become part of it.
"Trying, ma'am!" The two remaining Vespulas that are still on Sylva and Loboda are the ones running interference now, darting and striking against the two Banner pilots, while the other half of the two surviving squads bear down on Gloriana. They'll reach her before her subordinates can assist.

Gloriana switches to the ship channel. "Rose, I'm switching to close combat maneuvers, unable to sustain long range fire support." As this has been going on, the Rose has succeeded in remaining frustratingly hard for the frigate to hit but worrisomely, the near misses are coming closer and closer all the time. The Rose's return fire has yet to penetrate the enemy vessel's shields. This was going to turn into a mess.

It will be one of them, but it could really be any of them.
 
HHHhhnnnnnggggghhhh, reading the newest chapter had me making a heap of distressed kitten noises, not sure what I want but I see death flags everywhere, lets throw an Oddjob hat into the ring here and see if it comes back to cut me.

[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] The Rose is severely damaged
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on

At the current time and situation, destroying critical enemy units is far better than any other options since the enemy fleet is too huge, which means attritional warfare is far less useful than killing key targets to eliminate both their command capability AND reducing enemy morale. That and this also guarantees the best long-term benefits since those important targets won't be a threat ever again as returning villains that can rally for another attack in the future.

[X] Someone you care for is lost

While emotionally sad, this option would be much less of an impact for winning and surviving the battle and future overall. There's no way people are going to choose civilians at this point, and losing Rose effectively means losing both the scanning contributions of North from The Rose, along with killing off the main character with and the ship's crew in several updates as the ship becomes too damaged to avoid death.

Basically it's picking between either 1, killing mass numbers of civilians, or 2, picking to lose an entire ship and all it's capabilities early in battle, or 3, losing one person. In the end No matter who, I don't believe they are more important than the first 2 for both story values and chances of victory.
 
Last edited:
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on

[X] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on

[X] Population centres on Titan's surface take serious damage
 
[X] Mosi's intelligence allows the Outer Fleet to eliminate several key targets early on
[X] Someone you care for is lost
 
Back
Top