Remove ads

On the Road to Elspar [Book 1] (Dryad Mercenary Schoolgirl Quest)

Reader mode
First
[x] Staff
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

Second
[x] Mace
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Trade and Commerce
 
First Preference
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce

Second Preference
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany
 
#1
[x] Mace
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

#2
[x] Bow
[x] Beastiary
[x] Scouting and Tracking
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Buster Sword
 
First preference
[x] Mace
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Bestiary
[x] Trade and Commerce

Second Preference
[x] Dagger
[x] Alchemy and Botany
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword
 
Given the new options, I would like to propose that we have Neianne pick up mace, then transition that to axe.

The reasons are the following:
- Monster Hunter World is good.
- Switch axe is awesome.
- Kei doesn't like axes or switch axe for some reason, and needs to be properly exposed to them.

Failing that, I'm good with the bow options.

First preferences
[x] Mace
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Bestiary
[x] Trade and Commerce

Second preference
[x] Bow
[x] Beastiary
[x] Scouting and Tracking
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Buster Sword
 
First preferences
[x] Mace
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Bestiary
[x] Trade and Commerce

Second preference
[X] Tome
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany

I like axes so lets try to get one.
 
Last edited:
First Preference:

[X] Staff
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce


Second Preference:
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce

Come now, better a dagger than a mace. You still need some wind up for Maces rather than the quick quick stab stab of daggers in enclosed spaces that does not allow us to Buster Sword our problems. And much easier to carry.

Same argument against bow. A completely different paradigm to our playstyle and does not solve our thing for enclosed spaces and accessability.
Adhoc vote count started by Crow on Jan 31, 2019 at 9:42 PM, finished with 30 posts and 22 votes.
Click to expand...

Adhoc vote count started by Crow on Feb 1, 2019 at 5:07 AM, finished with 51 posts and 32 votes.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
So, now that the vote is on the way and all the debating is basically done, I'd like to thank everyone for keeping it all respectful and tasteful.

I've seen how votes like this can go, especially with it stopping and restarting, and this was pretty tame instead. So, thank you all!
 
First preference
[X] Mace
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Scouting and Tracking
[X] Advanced Unarmed Combat

For synergy of hammer and door lol. And Scouting and Tracking currently look more useful in this year upcoming fight than large scale strategy that Strategy and Logistics provides?

Second Preference
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Alchemy and Botany
[X] Advanced Unarmed Combat

For throwing knives and poison synergy, and I like CQC.

Edit : add a bit of explanation.
 
Last edited:
First preference
[x] Staff
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

Second preference
[x] Mace
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Trade and Commerce
 
First
[x] Staff
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

Second preference
[X] Tome
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany
 
#1:
[x] Bow
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Alchemy and Botany
[x] Bestiary

#2:
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Alchemy and Botany
[X] Advanced Unarmed Combat

The main appeal of tome and staff to me is Elizabeth interactions - but honestly I feel like Neianne is holding her own in that even without magical knowledge. Maybe she can be Elizabeth's common sense, so she can actually explain her ideas to a layperson? Always important for a researcher. :)
 
Last edited:
First Preference:
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany

Second Preference:
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce
 
First
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce

Second
[x] Staff
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword
 
#1
[x] Mace
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

#2
[x] Bow
[x] Beastiary
[x] Scouting and Tracking
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Buster Sword


str bows is bae, I wanna see dual wielded mini balistas

jk
 
First

[x] Dagger
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Bestiary
[x] Alchemy and Botany

Second

[X] Tome
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany
 
First
[x] Dagger
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Buster Sword
[x] Bestiary
[x] Alchemy and Botany

Second
[X] Dagger
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Trade and Commerce
 
First Preference - Lawmaker Neianne
[X] Mace
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Scouting and Tracking
[X] Law and Politics

Second Preference - Bodyguard Neianne
[X] Straight Sword
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Etiquette
[X] Trade and Commerce

Nothing more to say that I haven't said already. Bust skulls, break limbs, crack open armor like it was a silly crustacean. Go Neianne, live your dreams!
 
I feel some of you are missing the point, of second preferences of differing choices.

The secondary choices are there if there isn't a majority pick, so your supposed to pick a runner up or second pick not a rehash of the first, doing the opposite and choosing the same thing is ludicrous.

I understand that some of you, want your choices picked, I do, but doing this hurts the voting process.

Everyone's got something they want to be voted in, if it's not chosen, just wait until the next year vote and use the previous year's information to make a case.

The voting that is going on now is too late to pull that type of thing, everyone's too invested in one pick or another.

I'm not immune either to bias, but everyone's taking potshots at others in low-key ways, this doesn't make voting comfortable.
 
Revya Alt.Zero said:
I feel some of you are missing the point, of second preferences of differing choices.

The secondary choices are there if there isn't a majority pick, so your supposed to pick a runner up or second pick not a rehash of the first, doing the opposite and choosing the same thing is ludicrous.

I understand that some of you, want your choices picked, I do, but doing this hurts the voting process.

Everyone's got something they want to be voted in, if it's not chosen, just wait until the next year vote and use the previous year's information to make a case.

The voting that is going on now is too late to pull that type of thing, everyone's too invested in one pick or another.

I'm not immune either to bias, but everyone's taking potshots at others in low-key ways, this doesn't make voting comfortable.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Everyone is voting in the way that the voting system was explained to them and no one is even saying anything.
 
Lazy Minx said:
Everyone is voting in the way that the voting system was explained to them and no one is even saying anything.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
What they are asserting is that some people are following an implied 'spirit' of the voting system and presenting two at least somewhat different primary and secondary options and some people are following only the 'letter' of the voting system and presenting a secondary option that is presumably very very close to the primary with only a single thing changed.
 
No, some people forget to vote on second choices, or just pick the exact copy their first votes.

But your right about, the way the voting works.

I think there would be a more voting veriaty, if you couldn't pick the same thing you picked as the first choice, but that's not how it works.
 
Last edited:
First
[x] Staff
[x] Strategy and Logistics
[x] Tactics and Command
[x] Trade and Commerce
[x] Buster Sword

Second preference
[X] Tome
[X] Buster Sword
[X] Tactics and Command
[X] Strategy and Logistics
[X] Alchemy and Botany
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top