- Location
- The Great Beyond
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
@TheMaskedReader stands as the one to be lynched currently. Obviously. But hey, I figure he deserves to know that.
Welcome to Moonton (Mafia)
- Thread starter Terrabrand
- Start date
- Mafia
We Just Write
Blatantly Plural
- Location
- New England
- Pronouns
- Plural
Actually, TMR is at 6 votes, not 7. It would take two more votes to hammer them.
Azrael
Sakura Saber
- Location
- Throne of Heroes
The day is ending in a couple hours and when it does, plurality lynch happens. Which means TMR, as the person with the most votes, will be lynched.
- Location
- Academy City
- Pronouns
- They
Day has ended
- Location
- The Great Beyond
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
Stop. Hammer. (And yes, I can count. This is correct)
atk50
Rationally Insane
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
See, problem is, at the time I had no suspicion. Then, I became suspicious of TMR (at least somewhat), but he's close to hammer. I don't see another target that I'd want to take down, but his speculation could just be him trying to figure things out and keep conversation going for the day, so I'm not eager to vote him up. As it stands, he's highest on my suspicion list, but I'm not sure I'm ready to commit my vote.
To be more specific:
I see this not as a scumtell, but as flavor speculation on the setup. While, yes, the whole summoning thing was a bit obvious and probably should have been clear, I don't think this is scummy play.
I'm considering my options. I don't want to be the one to push a lynch on what could just be nothing. I'll be back with a vote if I sort out who I am most sus of.
As I was typing, really?
This is why I'm not assigning my vote to TMR. I'm more skittish with my votes in a Hammer game, you should know that by now.
As it stands, I
Night One Begins
- Location
- The Great Beyond
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
Day One End
The debate rages, focusing on three of those present for hours. But then one of the others says something rather strange. After all, they're trying to summon the Old Moon! To speak of such issues as a problem is quite odd.
And so while their back is turned, villager after villager beseeches the Old Moon that @TheMaskedReader is rather suspicious, no?
Abruptly, before anyone quite expected it to happen, the sky tears open. A roaring sound fills the ears of all present. And then TheMaskedReader falls through a chasm in the earth that opens abruptly.
@TheMaskedReader has been [Taken by the Old Moon]. He was the Village Healer. He was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The voice of the Old Moon rumbles forth. "That was one of my servants. I am dissapointed, do better."
The village is shocked by the turn of events, to say the least. All retreat to their homes, considering how things could have gone wrong, and thinking towards the future.
Night One has begun. Night One ends in fourty-eight hours or when all night actions are recieved.
The debate rages, focusing on three of those present for hours. But then one of the others says something rather strange. After all, they're trying to summon the Old Moon! To speak of such issues as a problem is quite odd.
And so while their back is turned, villager after villager beseeches the Old Moon that @TheMaskedReader is rather suspicious, no?
Abruptly, before anyone quite expected it to happen, the sky tears open. A roaring sound fills the ears of all present. And then TheMaskedReader falls through a chasm in the earth that opens abruptly.
@TheMaskedReader has been [Taken by the Old Moon]. He was the Village Healer. He was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The voice of the Old Moon rumbles forth. "That was one of my servants. I am dissapointed, do better."
The village is shocked by the turn of events, to say the least. All retreat to their homes, considering how things could have gone wrong, and thinking towards the future.
Night One has begun. Night One ends in fourty-eight hours or when all night actions are recieved.
- Location
- Phoenix, Arizona
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Jesus christ, guys, give a guy a chance to post?
Also, I'm a bit disappointed...I finally got a non-scum useful power role in a game that probably isn't power madness! Ah, well, that's the way the cookie crumbles.
Still though, you guys really leapt on me for a bit of idle speculation.
Ahem, Village Healer, yes, I was the Doctor, no other powers. I healed by the Power of the Old Moon, so there might be another doctor who uses herbal remedies or something, but...don't count on it.
Well, uh, I...don't really have any other information. Thanks for the courtesy tag, Terrabrand, sorry I didn't catch it, but that's the way it goes, I suppose.
See some of you in deadchat later!
Also, I'm a bit disappointed...I finally got a non-scum useful power role in a game that probably isn't power madness! Ah, well, that's the way the cookie crumbles.
Still though, you guys really leapt on me for a bit of idle speculation.
Ahem, Village Healer, yes, I was the Doctor, no other powers. I healed by the Power of the Old Moon, so there might be another doctor who uses herbal remedies or something, but...don't count on it.
Well, uh, I...don't really have any other information. Thanks for the courtesy tag, Terrabrand, sorry I didn't catch it, but that's the way it goes, I suppose.
See some of you in deadchat later!
- Location
- The Great Beyond
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
All night actions recieved. Day two will be going up soon, need to right night PMs etc first.
Day Two begins
- Location
- The Great Beyond
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
Day Two Begins
For most, the night passes peacefully. But where thirteen left, eleven return.
The Old Moon rumbles with fury, and demands the missing be found.
The first case was simple. The Priestess of the Old Moon herself is found stabbed, dead in the streets. Beloved by the village, friend to all who live here, life cut brutally short.
@Nanimani, the Priestess of the Old Moon, has been [Stabbed Through The Heart]. She was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The other is more bizarre and frightening. A body is initially not found. But by procces of elimination, they conclude it must be the missing Village Trapper who is gone. A patient man, watching his traps in the dark so often, lit only by the moon, now gone. Eventually, they find bones picked clean by the beaks of birds as the only sign of what happened.
@Archeo Lumiere, the Village Trapper, has been [Devoured clean down to the Bone]. He was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The Servants of the Old Moon gather and throw accusations once more, feeling pressed as they are picked off one after another...
Day two has begun. Day two ends in seventy-two hours or when hammer is achieved. At 11 players, hammer rests at six votes.
For most, the night passes peacefully. But where thirteen left, eleven return.
The Old Moon rumbles with fury, and demands the missing be found.
The first case was simple. The Priestess of the Old Moon herself is found stabbed, dead in the streets. Beloved by the village, friend to all who live here, life cut brutally short.
@Nanimani, the Priestess of the Old Moon, has been [Stabbed Through The Heart]. She was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The other is more bizarre and frightening. A body is initially not found. But by procces of elimination, they conclude it must be the missing Village Trapper who is gone. A patient man, watching his traps in the dark so often, lit only by the moon, now gone. Eventually, they find bones picked clean by the beaks of birds as the only sign of what happened.
@Archeo Lumiere, the Village Trapper, has been [Devoured clean down to the Bone]. He was a Servant of the Old Moon.
The Servants of the Old Moon gather and throw accusations once more, feeling pressed as they are picked off one after another...
Day two has begun. Day two ends in seventy-two hours or when hammer is achieved. At 11 players, hammer rests at six votes.
Threnodist
occupying Haudenosaunee & Osage land she/her/hers
- Location
- Pittsburgh
So elephant in the room, apparently there is somebody who can manipulate vote counts
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
And why we NEVER let a vote be one off of hammer, EVER. Its just asking for things to play in the favor of scum, we don't need to hammer to get a kill, SO DON'T TRY TO HAMMER ANYONE. TMR wasn't given a chance to speak and look at the time we still would be in day 1 right now if he was given such a chance with a living doctor.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Me
Cyri
Az
QT
Threnodist
Archeo
IJW
These 7 were the players who were on the TMR vote train. Either one of us is a double voter or someone has a seperate PM vote that they can give to Terra. Since we can't actually prove the latter option, the former is the one that we will have to narrow down for now.
I know that I'm not a double voter so I'm removing myself from my personal list, though obviously anyone else can't do the same.
Cyri
Az
QT
Threnodist
Archeo
IJW
These 7 were the players who were on the TMR vote train. Either one of us is a double voter or someone has a seperate PM vote that they can give to Terra. Since we can't actually prove the latter option, the former is the one that we will have to narrow down for now.
I know that I'm not a double voter so I'm removing myself from my personal list, though obviously anyone else can't do the same.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Granted the Village Trapper from Archeo doesn't sound like a double voter at all so it's unlikely that it was him, but since we don't know what his role was it's impossible to rule him out unless we use the living group of 6 players and put them on two seperate vote trains, where whichever one wins narrows down things further and ruling out that was Archeo's power.
Azrael
Sakura Saber
- Location
- Throne of Heroes
Why is it always Nani.
Always always always Nani.
And wow, those both sound like they could be power roles, and this probably isn't a power madness game. RIP.
Looking at the kills, this isn't likely a cult game. Looks like Maf and SK to me, but I suppose one of them could be a Vig. I doubt it though.
Always always always Nani.
And wow, those both sound like they could be power roles, and this probably isn't a power madness game. RIP.
I doubt it was Archeo, I can't think of a reason why a trapper would have two votes. Oh, might as well deny it was me while I'm at it. One assumes it wasn't QTessaract, but they could have been acting.
Looking at the kills, this isn't likely a cult game. Looks like Maf and SK to me, but I suppose one of them could be a Vig. I doubt it though.
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
The fact that the night was what? Three hours, does lend great credence to at least not many night actions and thus the non-power madness nature of the game. The other factor is that I believe this game is in the same universe as Brighton and that game also wasn't power madness.
For now, I'm unsure if the likely double voter is town or scum both are possible, though its much stronger in scum's hands since they already have vote control.
Where I wish to start this day phase is with,
[X] Lynch Cyricubed
They began the TMR train, and showed concern with Archeo being alive, Archeo being night killed the first night is a bit odd.
For now, I'm unsure if the likely double voter is town or scum both are possible, though its much stronger in scum's hands since they already have vote control.
Where I wish to start this day phase is with,
[X] Lynch Cyricubed
They began the TMR train, and showed concern with Archeo being alive, Archeo being night killed the first night is a bit odd.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
This is rhetorical but one of the best players who is memetically the N1 target for most night actions and notably he faded into the background D1 so that he was less likely to be observed. It's not that surprising since the doctor died D1 and the aforementioned Nani background fading.
- Location
- Academy City
- Pronouns
- They
Shit. I was not expecting a double voter on that, this is... unfortunate, to say the least. On the plus side, with the reveal of a (almost certain) serial killer in the form of "picked clean, there are only two real setup options.
2 scum, 1 sk, 11 town (likely)
3 scum, 1 sk, 10 town (unlikely)
Anything else would be too punishing or too bastard. Regardless of which it is, we have a vote majority, and will probably still have ir even if tommorow goes as badly as it possibly can. That's where the good news for us ends.
We lost our doctor, what looks like a cop?, and some pr I don't know. Seeing as the multivoter is probably scum (if not, they're new) just based on the playing, that leaves us with 1-2 power roles only, and some of our strongest ones are gone. I think we can afford to miss at most one more lynch, maybe two if we hit the serial killer first and remove a kill or we get a crossfire. Hardly insurmountable, but that was a brutal day/night cycle.
2 scum, 1 sk, 11 town (likely)
3 scum, 1 sk, 10 town (unlikely)
Anything else would be too punishing or too bastard. Regardless of which it is, we have a vote majority, and will probably still have ir even if tommorow goes as badly as it possibly can. That's where the good news for us ends.
We lost our doctor, what looks like a cop?, and some pr I don't know. Seeing as the multivoter is probably scum (if not, they're new) just based on the playing, that leaves us with 1-2 power roles only, and some of our strongest ones are gone. I think we can afford to miss at most one more lynch, maybe two if we hit the serial killer first and remove a kill or we get a crossfire. Hardly insurmountable, but that was a brutal day/night cycle.
- Location
- Academy City
- Pronouns
- They
This means someone on the lynch train was almost certainly scum. I actually kinda doubt it was pawn, because he's usually more cautious than that, but that's still 4 people to whittle down to identify our multivoter.
[X] Lynch Cyricubed
He started the train on TMR, which is a bit of a red flag, and has a vote on him already so pressure shouls be easier. Let's see what he has to say to defend himself.
[X] Lynch Cyricubed
He started the train on TMR, which is a bit of a red flag, and has a vote on him already so pressure shouls be easier. Let's see what he has to say to defend himself.
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
So just as general polling, what faction do people believe the double voter is and reasons why they think so?
I think the double voter is town because scum already have vote control going into the game. Scum having an extra vote on top of their ability to coordinate is dangerous in a game with hammer.
I think the double voter is town because scum already have vote control going into the game. Scum having an extra vote on top of their ability to coordinate is dangerous in a game with hammer.
- Location
- Academy City
- Pronouns
- They
I think it's almost certainly scum. Town had no reason to multivote there, so any town multivoting would have to be automatic (not impossible, admittedly) or a newbie messing up.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Generally double voters are automatic, unlike mayors so I would buy it being automatic.
And I expect the double voter is town on the same reasoning as Comi. Scum having access to a double voter shortens the number of cycles until they control the vote. That's already questionable in a larger game, there's no way that they would have one in a game with only 14 players.
That's just shoddy design and I doubt he designed the game like that consider the guide we just wrote.
