Ultimate Hangman's Gambit IV: Justice is Blind (Innocent Victory)

No kill.

If Shard was the roleblocker, it's... unlikely that was because of him. Hmm. Tenfold claimed to be night immune, didn't he?

Well, Joe certainly came off as very aggressive 'yesterday', both to Tenfold and me. I suppose unless someone has anything dramatic to reveal he's got my vote for now.

[X] Joebobjoe

@Joebobjoe
 
Apparently I read that completely wrong, my bad. Still really suspicious of Az, and annoyed with Tenfold for not doing a basic demonstration of his power. Nothing particularly new on my end, any blocks?
 
Guess I'll vote Azrael. That claim is still very off. Also honestly just a vivor wildly flailing to try to be useful to Town and apparently failing utterly. I win when the Killer is dead or jailed and all other threats to me are eliminated. Though I can see why I'd be the first to go. Now the real interesting thing I have to wonder at is the brained with a statue kill. If it's a singular killer then why was there a flavor?
[X] Lynch Azrael
 
Well, nothing I can think of to say, so I'll just vote with Pawn.

[X] Joebobjoe
 
annoyed with Tenfold for not doing a basic demonstration of his power. Nothing particularly new on my end, any blocks?


SPEAKING OF MOTHERFUCKER

Not only did a find a minifridge packed to bursting in your room bbbuuuuuut also....a well worn stressball. Someone's got some severe (and severely repressed!) anger issues~, and for all that you harp on me for not properly doling out the fluff it seems like a fairly significant thing to not mention in your roleclaim and shit. 'Cause see the thing is I believe you when you say that you have a one-shot immunity at night, it'd make sense as a balance for a serial killer who's supposed to be Important.

Plus, I mean, Phoenix Wright is kinda gonzo. A large guy physically crushing people fits just fine.

[X] Joebobjoe
 
SPEAKING OF MOTHERFUCKER

Not only did a find a minifridge packed to bursting in your room bbbuuuuuut also....a well worn stressball. Someone's got some severe (and severely repressed!) anger issues~, and for all that you harp on me for not properly doling out the fluff it seems like a fairly significant thing to not mention in your roleclaim and shit. 'Cause see the thing is I believe you when you say that you have a one-shot immunity at night, it'd make sense as a balance for a serial killer who's supposed to be Important.

Plus, I mean, Phoenix Wright is kinda gonzo. A large guy physically crushing people fits just fine.

[X] Joebobjoe
Honestly those stress balls don't really get mentioned in my fluff. The entire thing just talks about eating a whole lot and not wanting to be murdered, because then I'd have to stop eating. Perhaps the balls are from actual legitimate stress over being killed?

Although in all seriousness don't blow an accusation on me today, you can do it tomorrow after alignment reveals. Your own theory disqualifies me from being the person who committed the murder in the OP. Remember, you're looking for someone who does torn apart as their kill flavor.
The foreigner in a puffy jacket crawls backwards until he hits the desk, sweating furiously. He reaches an arm out, waving frantically, as his mouth opens and shuts wordlessly. It's too late now, though. The shadow is upon him, striking downwards with the knife. There's a burst of feathers and, in the moment bought by the attacker's surprise, the foreigner reaches up and presses the little red button on the bottom of the desk. All across the building, gates slam shut, windows lock, and sheets of thick metal descend over the exits. The lights cut out, putting the pair in complete darkness, before-

red

that's all the victim can see, the red light strobing across his attacker's face. He can see their features, their clothes, their knife as it descends upon him once more...



February 13, 10:00AM
District Court
Courtroom No. 2 »


The Judge bangs his gavel, silencing the hubbub of the collected audience. "The Court is now in session for the trial of Rebecca Caul."

You look across at the prosecutor as she gives her little "The Prosecution is ready". Not a suit you'd seen in court before; certainly no Payne, and not quite up to the standards of an Edgeworth either. Paige Turner, you'd think they called her? Undefeated (of course), but a bit green to these parts. Thankfully she doesn't have a whip!

"-ight?" You hear someone saying. "Wright? Wright!" You jump a little behind your desk, turning to the Judge. "Should I just end the trial now, Mr. Wright? You don't seem very prepared."

"Sorry, Your Honor." You say, "The Defense is ready."

"Are you? Why don't you lay out the details of the case then? It shouldn't be too hard for an Attorney of your caliber." The Judge gives you an all-too-familiar frown.

"Y-yes, Your Honor. Ahem...the victim in this case is Pohr Ghai, a Khurainese visitor to LA. He was attending a conference at a local military base, to discuss things that are...classified, I believe. The military is unrelated - none of their officers were in the vicinity when Pohr Ghai, or his assailant, set off the lockdown. When we first found him, he had been..." You shudder at the recollection. "He had been Torn Apart, Your Honor."
 
Day 6 Ends
"After that...well, [JoeBobJoe] had been acting kind of off, so we decided on him pretty unanimously." You shrug. "We had kind of run out of steam by that point, and with no one dead we weren't sure what was going to happen. So...we just tossed him in. It was a hell of a thing, though, he was so big. We could barely fit him through the door, haha."

Turner nods. "Yes, he is...rather large. And his identity?"

You flip through your file folder. "He was...ah, here we go."

@Joebobjoe as Ronaldo McCheese has been Jailed.

"After that the nights got quieter. I mean, the night before had been quiet too, but. Well. Metaphorically speaking. People kept on not showing up dead, so we just...stopped jailing people. Nothing came of it, so we figured we were pretty set. Eventually, we got rescued, the people we jailed were detained, and those that made it out went back to their lives."

[The Innocents have won.]

"Well, Mr. Wright. That was a fascinating tale you told us. You may want to write a book about it." Turner smiles. "You'll need the money, once you turn over your badge at this stunning defeat. After all, it was your client who committed the crime, was it not? Or did you think that we would forget that this was a trial, and not storytime?"

The Judge nods. "Yes, Mr. Wright, do tell us why we shouldn't just throw the defendant in jail? You haven't proven that they aren't the killer, after all."

You gulp. All that talking, and now they want you to start the defense too? Geez, couldn't they have gotten some witnesses in here to do it instead? What kind of trial is this, anyways?

Penalty Count: [!!!!!]
 
Are the people who are still alive allowed to speculate or is this section of the game exclusively Tenfold's to deal with?
 
I wonder if he can call up witnesses, I've already shown up in court.
 
Trial Ends
You think back on the facts of the case that you've been able to gather so far.

You know for a fact that the killer was one of the people locked in with you during the event. Up until now, you'd assumed that it was someone who had yet to have been voted into a cell. However, what if they were already locked away? After all, there was nothing that would have prevented other deaths from other killers after the initial murder. Yes, that must be it.

The Killer had already been locked away by the time the killings stopped.

But which of them had done it? While you'd identified the mob affiliations of four of the people with you, and those who hadn't been locked away had obviously been innocent, there was nothing that said the Killer was someone you'd recognize in a lineup. But wait, what was it Maya had said earlier? Something about...ah, right!

The victim dropped a novelty clock.

Well, you'd dealt with those before! Who would have thought something like that would come back to haunt you? Clearly, the clock involved was the statue that had been used as a blunt weapon - or at least, it looked very likely to be.

The statue killer was the Killer.

That was it. That had to be it, the case didn't make any sense otherwise. Who else would have had the chance to steal if off of Pohr Ghai's corpse?

"Ms. Turner, if you'll ask the bailiff to bring an up-to-date report on the statue that was found, I believe I can tell you who the killer was within the hour." You smirk, hands on your hips and chest thrust out. "In fact, I'll go so far as to say that they'll find not only who the killer was, but that it was a clock as well!"

Turner raises an eyebrow. "Is the fact that it's a clock really so revelatory that it needs to be mentioned, Wright? It was used to brain people, not tell the time."

"Indeed it is, and let me tell you why." You flip through the court record until you find the page you're looking for. "As you'll recall, Maya said that, during our imprisonment, she channeled the original victim, Pohr Ghai. He seemed to be a remarkably unfortunate fellow, but there were a few interesting tidbits here and there; namely, that he'd had a novelty clock." You look up, in time to see Turner look stressed. She picks up her own notes. "Are you saying that-" "I am, Ms. Turner. The man who killed poor Benita Antidy was in fact the very same who killed Mr. Ghai! And when the result come back, I think that you'll find..." You raise your voice, making sure the whole courtroom hears "that the statue was used by none other than Condy Lure!"

The Judge gasps, then slams his gavel. "Bailiff! Get the results on that statue at once!"

***

"It looks like the statue is, indeed, a clock." Turner sighs, brow furrowed. "The blood matches Mrs. Antidy's, but there's no fingerprints on the statue. How can you prove it was Condy Lure?"

You blink. Well, you suppose, a member of the mafia wouldn't go around killing without something to cover up his tracks. Still, there's more than enough other evidence. "For one thing, there's the fact that the statue stopped being used immediately after Lure was put in a cell. Immediately after that, people started to be murdered with brute force, rather than with the statue. Additionally, there's the reason Pohr Ghai came to the country in the first place: to meet a long-lost relative." You shake your head. "Now, you tell me, why would a man in the mob, with an obviously fake identity, want to avoid someone with family ties?" You think you see Turner start to reply, but you cut her off, relishing the chance. "Because it makes him vulnerable! Once they know who he is, they can find out whatever they want to about him, as can enemy mobs! He had to eliminate Pohr Ghai to get rid of that chance, to keep his own identity safe. After all, it's not as though he felt any attachment for the man."

You turn to the Judge. "So you see, Your Honor? Means, Motive, and Opportunity, along with some crucial evidence."

The Judge nods. "Yes, well, we certainly will have to look into this Condy Lure character further at his own trial. As of now, though, I believe I can safely say that the Defendant, Rebecca Caul, is..."

NOT GUILTY
You smile despite yourself, the confetti raining down on you. When you think on it, though, it's a bit odd, isn't it? There was barely any witness testimony, and the culprit wasn't on the stand for the final blow. Also, isn't it usually a lot more difficult than just talking back-and-forth with the prosecutor? Something seems kind of-

da da DA, da da, Da da Da DAAAAAA

You jump with a start, hand scrabbling for your phone. "Boss!" You hear Maya's voice yell at you from the receiver. "Where are you!? The magic show started fifteen minutes ago!"

You swallow, hard. You mean, the fighting, the victory, the clonk on the head...it was all just a...?

"OBJECTION!!"

The 13th Turnabout: Fin
 
Last edited:
I regret that I only put the pieces together until after JBJ was lynched.

Do we get our rolecards now?

Also it seems that if we had lynched TFS instead of Phoenix... would the mafia have won?
 
Roles & Quicktopics
ROLES

The Mafia
@tankdrop24 as Don Warren Bowett (Don't Worry About It)
You are Don Warren Bowett, the toughest Mafia don in LA who isn't technically Italian. You ain't gotten as far as you have without gettin' a couple'a bones broken down the avenue, and you don't much care about doin' it now. Specially since you got your mooks to do it for you, and you can keep your squeaky clean image untarnished.

You are Guilty, but due to your connections, appear Innocent to investigation. You win when the Killer is either found Guilty or dead, and threats to your faction are eliminated.

Powers:
Pulling Strings: As the Godfather of your Mafia, you can command them to do as you say. Once per night, choose a target and a member of the Mafia to carry out the act by sending a PM saying Kill [Player] with [Mafia Member].
Night Kill: You don't particularly like getting your hands dirty, so when you have to, you use your feet. Your kill flavor is [Kicked Down a Set of Stairs].
Communication: What kind of Mafia would it be with no one to talk to? Speak with your compadres [here].

@Shard as Denise Zire (Desire)
You are Denise Zire, the on-again off-again girlfriend of about half the LA underworld. You go where the Don tells you, sleep with who the Don tells you to, and eat whatever you tell yourself to. It's a good life, if a bit hard to balance calorically.

You are Guilty. You win when the Killer is either found Guilty or dead, and threats to your faction are eliminated.

Powers:
Steamin' Sausage: You know your way around the bedroom, no matter the other occupant. Once per night, you can 'distract' someone, blocking their night power if they have one. To do so, send a PM saying Roleblock [Player].
Night Kill: Of course, you know what to do if the time comes to paint the town red. Your kill flavor is [Stuck Like a Pig].
Communication: What kind of Mafia would it be with no one to talk to? Speak with your compadres [here].

@Joebobjoe as Ronaldo McCheese (Royale With Cheese)
You are Ronaldo McCheese, the beefiest slab of meat that isn't already dead. You don't think much, and when you do, it's mainly just about eating. It's a shock that the Mafia's kept you on, considering how much you take out of their budget for your lunch, but you are pretty intimidating.

You are Guilty. You win when the Killer is either found Guilty or dead, and threats to your faction are eliminated.

Powers:
Chunk Vanderlarge: You are so ridiculously big that it takes a concerted effort to kill you. You are immune to one Night Kill.
Night Kill: You don't put much effort into killing, just picking the easiest spot and squeezing. Your kill flavor is [Popped].
Communication: What kind of Mafia would it be with noone to talk to? Speak with your compadres [here].

@LupineVolt as Condy Lure (Condylura)
You are Condy Lure, the secret agent of the Mafia. What no one else knows, though, is that you're the one who killed the man at the center of this case. You never actually had to do it before, but now...now you just can't get enough, can you? You want more-you need more. You just have to keep on going.

You are Guilty. You are the Killer. You win when everyone is dead, or when a mistrial is declared. You lose if you die or are found Guilty.

Powers:
It's No Fun If You Die Turn One: You cannot be night killed.
Mafia Kill: When you kill on the Don's orders, you're much more restrained. Your kill flavor when working for the Mafia is [Brained With a Statue].
Communication: What kind of Mafia would it be with no one to talk to? Speak with your compadres [here].
Bloodlust: When you kill for your pleasure, you let out the beast within, rampaging around in a frenzy. Your kill flavor when killing on your own is [Torn to Bits]. To use this power, send a PM saying Kill [Player].
You Ain't the Boss of Me: You can choose not to perform the Mafia kill, in exchange for using your own on a target of your choosing. Keep in mind that you can only perform one kill per night.

Originally, when the game was larger, McCheese was bulletproof because there was a vigilante as well as a mafia and a serial killer. However, three kills per night would have whittled away the players very fast, and was difficult to balance around. Not saying that the balance was perfect in the end anyways, but it was probably better than it would have been. I left bulletproof on him in the event that Lure decided to turn on his team, and also so there wouldn't be two 'vanilla' mafia members.

The Childhood Friends

@Pawn Lelouch as Juan Scarlet (One Red)
You are Juan Scarlet, one of an infamous trio of childhood friends. Together, you all get up to wacky hijinks, like robbing salty noodle carts or, in this case, busting into the scene of a crime in progress. Luckily, you all share a secret handshake, so no matter what happens, you'll always have your pals.

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Secret Hideout: No matter where you are, the three of you always manage to find a secret spot where you can chatter away. You can talk to your teammates [here].

@Mortifer as Olive Tew (Green Two)
You are Olive Tew, one of an infamous trio of childhood friends. Together, you all get up to wacky hijinks, like robbing salty noodle carts or, in this case, busting into the scene of a crime in progress. Luckily, you all share a secret handshake, so no matter what happens, you'll always have your pals.

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Secret Hideout: No matter where you are, the three of you always manage to find a secret spot where you can chatter away. You can talk to your teammates [here].

@TPK as Sky Santos (Blue Three)
You are Sky Santos, one of an infamous trio of childhood friends. Together, you all get up to wacky hijinks, like robbing salty noodle carts or, in this case, busting into the scene of a crime in progress. Luckily, you all share a secret handshake, so no matter what happens, you'll always have your pals.

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Secret Hideout: No matter where you are, the three of you always manage to find a secret spot where you can chatter away. You can talk to your teammates [here].

Not much to say on this, they were a pretty generic mason. I liked the idea of the puns only making sense once the role names of all three members were known, though. Their idea of not telling each other who they were until they absolutely needed to was pretty clever, as well. It's one way not to tip your hand in public posts.

The Innocents

@Nictis as Maya Fey
You are Maya Fey, head of the Fey clan and heir to the Kurain Channeling Technique. Though you've had your run ins with the law, you've managed to become a respectable spiritual authority, truly mature and well-mannered at all times. Well, you're good at putting up the front, anyways; your close friends know that you're still the same old, hamburger-crazy Maya you've always been.

You are Innocent, but because things always seem to end up like this, you read as Guilty to investigation. There's just something uniquely 'culprit' about your aura, it seems. You win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Kurain Channeling: Through mystical powers, you can channel the spirits of the dead. If done properly, the spirit will be bound to do only as you allow, and will tell you who, if anyone, it had targeted before dying. Beware, though, for the Killer is a strong-willed individual, who may overcome you. To channel someone, send a PM saying Channel [Player].

Nictis' vote tallying saved my butt, honestly, and they picked up some pretty good clues as well. Originally, I was going to have them get taken over by Lure if they channeled him, but at the point the game was at, I felt it would have been kind of a bad move balance-wise, and I painted myself into a corner with the fluff.

@LostDeviljho as Detective Valerie Curtain (Very Certain)
You are Detective Valerie Curtain, the LAPD's rising star. You're sick and tired of all the crappy detectives that've brought a bad name to the department, and this is your chance to prove your worth! Good guy, bad guy, you can always tell who's who - assuming you get a chance to go through their stuff, anyways. Good thing you don't need a warrant now!

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Gut Instinct: After looking through someone's belongings, you get a feeling about whether they're good or bad. You can determine someone's alignment once per night, by sending a PM saying Investigate [Player].

You were a completely ordinary cop, for what it's worth.

@The Phoenixian as Dr. Mal Waktas (Malpractice)
You are the esteemed Doctor Mal Waktas, an accredited surgeon currently working as a mortician at the local morgue. You really ought to be out in the hospital, saving lives, but for some reason patients just don't like you. For the life of you, you can't figure out why, either. In any case, now's your chance to show the world the skills of Waktas!

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

Powers:
Hip Bone to the Spine Bone: Once per night, you can use your amazing surgical techniques to save a life. Obviously, if they weren't dying, nothing will happen, but it's the thought that counts. To use this power, send a PM saying Save [Player].

And you were a completely ordinary doctor. I just had trouble coming up with a medical pun, honestly. No one wanted to be treated by Dr. Malpractice, so he ended up a mortician :V

Now it's time for the vanilla roles, whose descriptions were mostly identical apart from a short line.

@Azrael as Raymond Prospector (Raygun Protector)
You are Raymond Prospector, an up-and-coming scifi actor who just landed the big gig. You didn't meant to get caught up in all of this, but somehow you've found yourself in the middle of quite the kerfuffle! You'll have to do your best if you want to get out in one piece!

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

@Ellf as Benita Antidy (Be Neat and Tidy)
You are Benita Antidy, one of LA's most esteemed etiquette instructors. You didn't meant to get caught up in all of this, but somehow you've found yourself in the middle of quite the kerfuffle! You'll have to do your best if you want to get out in one piece!

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

@Deadly Snark as Purin Thweet (Pure and Sweet)
You are Purin Thweet, a dame that's broken as many hearts as she has dishes in her klutzy mishaps. You didn't meant to get caught up in all of this, but somehow you've found yourself in the middle of quite the kerfuffle! You'll have to do your best if you want to get out in one piece!

You are Innocent, and win when the Killer is found Guilty or when all non-innocent roles are eliminated.

And last but not least, needing no introduction...

@TenfoldShields as Phoenix Wright

You are Phoenix Wright, Ace Attorney, the most accomplished defense attorney of all California. Throughout your career, you've defended the innocent and always, somehow, managed to find justice end up in the right place. This case is a little different, though; some indeterminate time ago, you were caught up in the crime itself, and had to use extrajudicial methods to muddle your way through. Your role in this case is uniquely divided; you play a part in both the past and the present. Your goal is to not only find the culprit, but also to prove your client innocent. If you cannot prove your client innocent, you cannot win. Thus, you win only if the Killer is caught and you can prove it to the court.

You are Innocent.

Powers:
Time Paradox - Phoenix Wright is both a part of the case, and defending his client at trial. If he were to die during the case, he obviously couldn't be at the trial. Therefore, he is immune to Night Kills.
Crime Scene Investigation: You've made a career out of pocketing seemingly random items and flipping them out during a case at the exact right time. Once per night, you may Investigate another player and get one item that is related to them. To do so, send a PM saying Investigate [Player].
Objection!!: As before, you can only win by proving who the Killer is. At any time, you may send in an explanation of who you think it is and why, along with what you think their actions were. If you guess the Killer correctly, and have a reasonably good argument, then you win. You only have five chances before the Judge penalizes you for wasting Court time, though, so choose wisely.

Originally Time Paradox was much stronger, preventing Wright from getting nightkilled or lynched. That seemed too strong, though, and I used imprisonment as a different fluff for lynching, so he could be 'killed' without dying. Unfortunately, that broke poor Maya's ability beyond recognition, and luckily she died before things got too confusing. Still, having "The Killer is found Guilty" as an alternate win condition for everyone was an interesting wrinkle in the game: in theory, had no one killed anyone else, and Wright been able to collect the proper evidence, everyone except Condy Lure could have walked home free. That was never going to happen, of course, and I made sure to tell the Mafia that they could only win in traditional Mafia fashion, but had Wright found Lure guilty before they had been imprisoned, I would have let them walk away scot free.

Editing in the QuickTopic links, I see some complaints in the Mafia QT about Wright being able to knock out killers: the only killer Wright would have been able to knock out was The Killer, as that was who the case was centered around. While he may have found out other killers, he would have been penalized, as it wouldn't have proven his client innocent.

QuickTopics
 
Having a player whose ability is that he can get items out of peoples' rooms that those people weren't told they had was a bad idea. If that'd come up while I was still alive, I'd have done my best to get Tenfold lynched ASAP, because it was suspicious as fuck.
 
Having a player whose ability is that he can get items out of peoples' rooms that those people weren't told they had was a bad idea. If that'd come up while I was still alive, I'd have done my best to get Tenfold lynched ASAP, because it was suspicious as fuck.
It's a pretty normal (well, uncommon, but not unusual) role in my experience - a less-powerful flavor cop, that doesn't get the role name but does get some items that relate to the role.
 
I think the biggest surprise from this game was the mafia chat and how much searching for the killer defined their group.

It definitely makes some of their stranger actions come off as making more sense in context.
 
What I find weird is that Phoenixian never reported his roleblock night one.
To be fair in one of those cases I thought I was Maf. And in the other I actually got two.
I think the biggest surprise from this game was the mafia chat and how much searching for the killer defined their group.

It definitely makes some of their stranger actions come off as making more sense in context.
We needed it just as much as you guys did. Honestly I'm kinda annoyed that the wincon included an impossible situation (the killer being dead) and at the Phoenix Wright role in general. Because as I pointed out that role was pretty much a celebrity with night immunity and an investigative power.
 
Back
Top