- Location
- Ottawa
I think this is an interesting point- I want to say I agree overall with your critique of DotFA, but I feel the need to expand upon something; DotFA could have been written better, certainly, but I think in context of itself, it makes a lot more sense. DotFA was never supposed to be 'the history of the world for your 2nd age game'. It was supposed to be that for your First Age game.
I get that. But my criticism applies for First Age games too. DotFA takes place in the year 3516; everything in it is geared towards playing a game set in that year. The story of Rose Petal Tea's excessive tax demands is from the 1730s...it's eighteen hundred years out of date, it doesn't matter.
And honestly, even if it was happening right now, it'd be pretty thin game fodder.