Ridiculously Average Guy
I'm you, but stronger
- Location
-
Thinking about it, dream-walking combined with Time-hop, he might be able to explain it away as gaining the memories of a previous life.
But also, a lot of that shit was his fault. Sure people wanted to manipulate him, but his stubbornness and unwillingness to trust went to levels well beyond reasonable, especially with people like Moiraine and Lan, who were never doing anything but trying to help him, who were on his side 100% (technically, Moiraine would be against him if she felt he was going to go over to the Dark, but I don't know if that even counts). And he spent a lot, and I mean a LOT of time fighting the very idea of being the Dragon Reborn, despite everything, and kept running away from the very people who were trying to support him.
And the grief over the Far Dareis Mai was entirely self-inflicted.
I give you the women though. Aviendha drove me a little bit nuts, and Elayne... never got enough time with Rand for me to even care about their relationship really. Min was the only one who I felt was both likable and fleshed out.
So yeah, there's a lot of shit, but that's what will make it interesting. Hopefully. And I have room to change things. I haven't even really made a final decision on how bound to Rand's fate I actually am... so yeah.
While you make some good, valid points, I have to pick on a few.Am I alone in thinking that his paranoia was justified? I didn't trust ANY of those Channelers, ever, and their helping constantly came across as help in the way they want you to help which is frequently not going to be helpful for you.
They didn't exactly take help either. Like Mat rescuing the girls. They just did their best to pretend that it never happened until Bridgette set them straight and I'm still pissed off at them for laughing about him being turned into the queen's concubine.
Then there is all the undercover agents. You trust the wrong person you get kidnapped and beaten every night for a few weeks. Sure, the SI knows some of them but it's by no means an exhaustive list.
Besides, he went nuts from channeling and you are extremely unlikely to get any good at this before you also develop your own multiple personalities. Probably end up with both Lew AND Rand fighting over your body. Learning to fight so you don't need to rely on tainted magic that you can only half use is a sound strategy.
Far Dareis Mai being entirely self-inflicted is a legitimate point but that assumes that SI is capable of hurting women. That is such a major facet of Rand's character that I wouldn't be surprised if the SI gets stuck with it. If Sword skills carry over and some knowledge carries over, it would make sense for Rand's complete inability to hurt a women to also carry over and stop you from doing any such thing. Then again, you can just pick a male clan to carry honor and be done with it.
It's hard to imagine it being a curbstomp. He seemed constantly beset with enemies and even having a complete knowledge of the series can't stop a lot of this from happening. This isn't Worm where one normal guy can use knowledge to suddenly make the world a better place inside of a week. The story takes place over the entire continent and so much is going on and so many enemies abound. Rand is the center of everything. I would think it is easier to follow along on someone else's arc, like Perrin or Mat. They handle things that are reasonable, in comparison. They have limited objectives. Rand juggles way to many balls and has to be pretty much flippen everywhere. Plus, he can't get privacy at all.
Accepting he is the Dragon Reborn is helpful and some major things can be done, like not letting Taim be in charge of the Black. But a lot of it is really long term stuff, like cleaning the taint. Even after you get the statues, you still need to get a small army together to fight off the assault that will surely happen during it. The plan to reseal the bore will NOT go over well, no matter what. Plus the many fights.
There are no easy solutions, I'd imagine every problem SI fixes will lead to a bunch of new ones being spawned. The scope of the story is massive and Rand has a great number of extremely powerful enemies who are keeping an eye on him and are fully capable of changing their strategies based on the SI's actions.
I'd personally say you are completely bound to Rand's fate and if you weren't then you wouldn't be a Ta'vern (however it's spelled) anymore. Or, at least, a much weaker one. Which might give more freedom but will also mean he can be killed off a lot easier. Being one of those kind means you are bound to the invisible rails. Which isn't always a bad thing.
On a side note, any possibility that the Dark One also read the series? If he's telling the SI "I win again" in our world, then would he have memories of it?
I think I read those once... a while ago. Maybe.I humbly note that I wrote and completed two WoT crossovers with Ranma... but they were part of a trilogy that I admittedly gave up on.
I'm surprised we didn't see more licking of lips on Verin's part. "Shield... me? With. With Saidin? Ahm... yes. Yes I s-suppose. That would make sense. Yes it would."
More or less. The story is horrifying on so many levels...
Just for starters, time is looping. Anything that has happened will happen again; there is no true freedom, only minor variations, and the world can't escape that repetition so long as the Dark One is in his prison. Ishmael is insane, but of all the forsaken he's the only one I understand; he was driven to it by a philosophical point that actually matters.
But, release him? That would be a quite literally fatal mistake. Destroy him? You get a crapsaccharine world instead. There's no escape...
Except, hold on. Who was it who claimed that destroying the Dark One would be a bad idea? And don't we also sometimes call him the Father of Lies? Why did Rand listen to a demon claiming that killing him would be a bad idea, anyway?
I'm pretty sure that your perception of Moraine is heavily influenced by her later turnaround. You probably have read the books more often than I did, but in the beginning, I think she was very much a typical Aes Sedai in that she tried to assert control over Rand, generally played up the mysterious Aes Sedai act while giving away as little information as possible and tried to make him completely dependent on her. Only after she realized that the Dragon couldn't be dominated this way did she change tracks and actually attempted to get closer to him by being a decent adviser and friend. Much too late, since Rand had already fallen into the habit of working around her and she disappeared soon after.While you make some good, valid points, I have to pick on a few.
I just disagree about the paranoia. Rand's levels of paranoia were absurd, way higher than they had any right to be. He was paranoid about Moiraine from the very first book when he learned she was Aes Sedai, and no matter how much she helped him, no matter how many times he had to be saved by her, and no matter how clear it was that she was on his side, he fought her because she was Aes Sedai and for no other reason. And he didn't stop until book 5, and only then after he extracted an oath from her after she literally begged him to let her help him. And by then it was too late and she disappeared fighting Lanfear and saving his life again. Ungrateful ass.
Agreed. This was a really big What The Hell, Author? moment for me. Throughout the entire series, it is endlessly repeated that the Dark One is an unnatural influence. Not part of the pattern. That it perverts the world with its touch. And then, suddenly, in order to escape its rightful destruction, it turns out to be an integral part of it, needed for humans to remain human. Apparently the Creator designed a defective humanity on purpose, just as insurance so that the Dark One is never destroyed by the Dragon. What depressing bullshit.More or less. The story is horrifying on so many levels...
Just for starters, time is looping. Anything that has happened will happen again; there is no true freedom, only minor variations, and the world can't escape that repetition so long as the Dark One is in his prison. Ishmael is insane, but of all the forsaken he's the only one I understand; he was driven to it by a philosophical point that actually matters.
But, release him? That would be a quite literally fatal mistake. Destroy him? You get a crapsaccharine world instead. There's no escape...
Except, hold on. Who was it who claimed that destroying the Dark One would be a bad idea? And don't we also sometimes call him the Father of Lies? Why did Rand listen to a demon claiming that killing him would be a bad idea, anyway?
There are a lot of potential readings of this. Let me just name a few:Ishmael should have had a much more convincing argument at hand: Humanity is as much imprisoned by the pattern as the Dark One. They are just as trapped in this endless, pointless circle of time. All their accomplishments doomed to be erased, all their knowledge worthless and soon forgotten. Because apparently, all humanity is good for is as toys to entertain the Dark One in his prison. The Creator is an asshole.
Oh, I'm fairly sure the time loop was supposed to be considerably longer than a single age.The wheel exists, but not meaningfully. There's a cycle of reincarnation (which might have a technological origin and might not), and there's a cycle of "The Dark one tries to destroy the world."
But that's about as far as it goes. Too many other things change each age for anyone to really call it more of a pattern.
as I understand it, it's supposed to be 7 ages long. Complete and utter bullshit of course... it's a repeating pattern, supposedly, not a time loop.Oh, I'm fairly sure the time loop was supposed to be considerably longer than a single age.
Oh, what have you done? You had a perfectly sound infiltration-and-sword-duelling mission going - but now you ruined it by prematurely bringing in a bunch of opinionated women who will want to take over the operation.
In the place of the SI, I'd be much more worried about the insane dangers I am going to encounter just about now... never poke a sleeping dragon. Or grolm. Or whatever.
Really? I've always heard poke. This is the first time I've come across tickle instead. Also, they're covered in scales that can shrug off swords - I doubt they are ticklish.
Really? I've always heard poke. This is the first time I've come across tickle instead. Also, they're covered in scales that can shrug off swords - I doubt they are ticklish.
As for the Damane though, I don't quite see what he is planning to do with them. Unless he somehow convinces Egwene to take a bunch with them when they leave - put it under terms of rescuing them and they can free them later - I don't really see anyway to get them to follow. Pretty sure that they wouldn't just follow random people... Maybe they are trained to follow anyone who holds their leash even if they can't use it?