Okay. So I've been sick recently, and all my inspiration for my Trek stuff seems to have dried...
User | Total |
---|---|
thebrute7 | 6 |
My knowledge level is set at what I could recall off the top of my head at the time I decided to update this story. Which amounts to basically everything in the first four books (which I know best and read just a month or two ago), most of the stuff in the middle books, and only general knowledge of the last books. That's a very general overview of my knowledge, since I remember some specifics and not others.Should be interesting to see how the chat with Verin goes, since you know about her triple agent working as a Black while trying to help the Light. Given that there are a couple of other ways to get around the vow in canon (either by stilling or using the Oath Rod), she might not have to go through with her sacrifice this time.
I think the best thing for "Rand" is to tell his secret to some people he knows that he can trust, using his inside knowledge to prove it.
Oh, wait. The SI only read some of the books? Though Verin didn't reveal the truth about her until Gathering Storm. Exactly how much has the SI read? Did you read through most of the series a while ago and just hadn't really reread much of the material since, or did you only read through the first five or so and then get the rest from what you heard others talk about?
You also know exactly how to get rid of the taint on saidin, and how to beat Shai'tan at Tar'mon Gai'mon... and what will happen if you're dumb enough to destroy him.
This pretty much. I know vaguely that it involves the use of the Choedan Kal and requires channeling saidin through saidar to filter the taint into Shadar Logoth, but the specifics of the event aren't well remembered by me (the SI, not me the author). And even then it would be hard to acheive it much faster than in canon because I need the protection of at least a dozen if not more channelers, preferably all with angreal or sa'angreal, and I need at least one other male channeler to allow for the use of Callandor (and for pointing out the male Forsaken).Well, I mean, kind of. You know what Rand did, but you don't really know how Rand did it. Reading about someone doing something and actually doing that thing are extremely different.
Yes and no. In the books, Rand's madness from channeling manifested as the insane voice of Lews Therin Telamon, the previous Dragon.Also, from the vagaries of canon I've managed to pick up, hasn't a situation like this happened before? Where a past-life took over?
Well, knowing the Seanchan's origin isn't super helpful. I know the names of some Darkfriends, but specific names are few and far between. And even then it isn't too helpful to have a name if I don't know what he/she looks like. I remember the names of the Forsaken (at least their Forsaken names if not their old ones), some of whom may be mixed up/wrong due to faulty memory, and I know where most of them set up shop.Well, you're screwed.
But seriously, you have a few opportunities. You already know the truth about the Seanchans origin, you know the names of several dozen high level Darkfriends, you know where the various Forsaken will build their areas of influence. You know the truth of the Aiel, you know about the flaw in Culandor (apologies for spelling errors), where to find the various ter'angreal like the Key statuettes or the Bowl of Winds.
You also know that you'll basically be crowned emperor and get three smoking hot girls out to have your babies, so its not all bad.
Looking forward to seeing how this turns out. Please continue.
While this is true... I actually picked him because his life kind of sucks. I wanted a setting that I couldn't get out of having bad things happen, because something I have come to realize is that I really hate writing bad things happening to characters I like. So in one sense, it is to improve myself as a writer.Why pick Rand to end up as?
It was downplayed but the guy suffered chronic pain due to his brandings and wounds. Plus, there's the whole going insane thing that there is no easy way out of. Then the enormous level of expectation that is dropped on you, with pretty much everyone that surrounds you looking to manipulate in some way. Then there is all the fighting, and fighting, and FIGHTING. Rand got tossed into the deep end too many times to count. Sometimes he lost and got horrible torture as punishment.
Just... god damn NO. His life sucked royally and it took years to work out. You could say that he got a harem out of it and an army of amazons but anyone that lists that as a positive doesn't recall the amount of grief that caused. The women in his life drove me nuts. Min was the truly loyal one that wasn't trying to control him, while also being incredibly useful to have around.
While you make some good, valid points, I have to pick on a few.Am I alone in thinking that his paranoia was justified? I didn't trust ANY of those Channelers, ever, and their helping constantly came across as help in the way they want you to help which is frequently not going to be helpful for you.
They didn't exactly take help either. Like Mat rescuing the girls. They just did their best to pretend that it never happened until Bridgette set them straight and I'm still pissed off at them for laughing about him being turned into the queen's concubine.
Then there is all the undercover agents. You trust the wrong person you get kidnapped and beaten every night for a few weeks. Sure, the SI knows some of them but it's by no means an exhaustive list.
Besides, he went nuts from channeling and you are extremely unlikely to get any good at this before you also develop your own multiple personalities. Probably end up with both Lew AND Rand fighting over your body. Learning to fight so you don't need to rely on tainted magic that you can only half use is a sound strategy.
Far Dareis Mai being entirely self-inflicted is a legitimate point but that assumes that SI is capable of hurting women. That is such a major facet of Rand's character that I wouldn't be surprised if the SI gets stuck with it. If Sword skills carry over and some knowledge carries over, it would make sense for Rand's complete inability to hurt a women to also carry over and stop you from doing any such thing. Then again, you can just pick a male clan to carry honor and be done with it.
It's hard to imagine it being a curbstomp. He seemed constantly beset with enemies and even having a complete knowledge of the series can't stop a lot of this from happening. This isn't Worm where one normal guy can use knowledge to suddenly make the world a better place inside of a week. The story takes place over the entire continent and so much is going on and so many enemies abound. Rand is the center of everything. I would think it is easier to follow along on someone else's arc, like Perrin or Mat. They handle things that are reasonable, in comparison. They have limited objectives. Rand juggles way to many balls and has to be pretty much flippen everywhere. Plus, he can't get privacy at all.
Accepting he is the Dragon Reborn is helpful and some major things can be done, like not letting Taim be in charge of the Black. But a lot of it is really long term stuff, like cleaning the taint. Even after you get the statues, you still need to get a small army together to fight off the assault that will surely happen during it. The plan to reseal the bore will NOT go over well, no matter what. Plus the many fights.
There are no easy solutions, I'd imagine every problem SI fixes will lead to a bunch of new ones being spawned. The scope of the story is massive and Rand has a great number of extremely powerful enemies who are keeping an eye on him and are fully capable of changing their strategies based on the SI's actions.
I'd personally say you are completely bound to Rand's fate and if you weren't then you wouldn't be a Ta'vern (however it's spelled) anymore. Or, at least, a much weaker one. Which might give more freedom but will also mean he can be killed off a lot easier. Being one of those kind means you are bound to the invisible rails. Which isn't always a bad thing.
On a side note, any possibility that the Dark One also read the series? If he's telling the SI "I win again" in our world, then would he have memories of it?
I think I read those once... a while ago. Maybe.I humbly note that I wrote and completed two WoT crossovers with Ranma... but they were part of a trilogy that I admittedly gave up on.
I'm surprised we didn't see more licking of lips on Verin's part. "Shield... me? With. With Saidin? Ahm... yes. Yes I s-suppose. That would make sense. Yes it would."