Pov Benjen
The morning mist clung to Moat Cailin's towers like an extra layer of skin, turning the ancient fortress into something out of a story. Benjen Stark stood atop the Gatehouse Tower, looking over the place he ruled—if one could truly call this rebuilt ruin a seat of power. Nearly seven years of steady work had lifted the castle from its crumbling remains of the First Men to something that felt closer to its old glory, though there was still much to do.
Below in the practice yard, Jon Snow went through his morning drills with Ser Rodrick's second son, who had come to live under their roof the year before. The sound of wooden swords clashing echoed against the old stone, a noise now as common as the calls of marsh birds or the wind sighing through the nearby swamps. Their breaths steamed in the cold morning air, and their boots left dark tracks in the frost-coated ground.
"Watch your stance," Benjen called, more out of habit than true need. Jon rarely needed such orders anymore. Only six years old—nearly seven—he already showed the same dedication to swordplay that made Benjen think of another dark-haired youth who once trained in Winterfell's yards. Even at his young age, Jon had a seriousness that sometimes worried Benjen, as though he believed he had something vital to prove.
The fortress itself looked nothing like the ruin Benjen had claimed eight years back. Then, the Gatehouse Tower was the only place fit to live in—its ancient stones had withstood the long centuries of neglect that brought down its companion towers. Now, three of the twenty towers had been mended. Their walls were cleaned and strengthened, their rooms warmed by hearths and filled with daily life. The Children's Tower, named for the old carvings on its walls, housed the household guard, while the Drunkard's Tower—still leaning in spite of all efforts—held the kitchens and servant quarters.
Benjen's own rooms were on the upper floors of the Gatehouse Tower, along with Jon's and the maester's quarters. Old Maester Willam had arrived five years ago, thanks to the Citadel's orders (and Ned's request). The aged maester had proven vital. His skill in architecture guided the restoration, and his healing knowledge handled the frequent wounds that came with this kind of rough work.
A cool gust swept over the battlements, carrying the deep, earthy smell of the swamps. The Neck spread out in every direction—a huge stretch of marshes that had shielded the North for countless years. Benjen had learned to read its signs: how fog gathered before rainstorms, how certain birds went quiet when strangers passed, and how shifts in the water told of changing seasons.
This was not the future he had imagined for himself when grief and guilt nearly drove him to join the Night's Watch. Back then, he saw only darkness before him—the crushing knowledge that the last wolves of Winterfell had survived a brutal war, but at a terrible cost. Brandon dead, Lyanna dead, their father burned by a mad king. The Wall had seemed like a refuge, a place to bury his sorrow and find some purpose.
Yet it seemed the old gods—or fate—had other designs. He recalled the day Ashara's answer arrived. Her words cut through his grief like a knife of Valyrian steel. She reminded him of Brandon's devotion to family, of his promises that still mattered. Most of all, she spoke of both nephews with a tone that made him think about what he owed his blood.
Now, gazing down at Jon, he felt the mix of pride and caution that had set him on this course. His nephew had thrived here, free from Winterfell's tangled politics and Lady Catelyn's cold gaze. Jon still carried a seriousness far beyond his years, but at least here he could learn the sword without worry, and study under Maester Willam without facing wary stares.
Footsteps on stone drew Benjen's attention. Ser Donnor Marsh, leader of his household guard, came up next to him with the steady pace he always had. He'd arrived six years earlier, bringing a knowledge of the Neck's channels that proved priceless. Most importantly, he respected Jon for his strengths rather than looking down on his birth.
"Good morning, my lord," Donnor said, stopping beside him near the battlements. "Our scouts report travelers on the causeway—merchants from White Harbor by their banners. They should be here by midday."
Benjen gave a slight nod, thinking about room in the stores and how much they might trade. Word of Moat Cailin's slow renewal had spread, bringing more merchants with each season. "Prepare the Merchant's Hall," he replied. "And ask Maester Willam to check on our grain supply. We might not see winter for a few years yet, but it's best to trade while costs favor us."
Donnor bowed and left, leaving Benjen alone with his thoughts. Below, Jon was done with his practice and stood watching the master-at-arms guide the younger boys. The scene made Benjen remember training in Winterfell's yard—Brandon showing him the proper way to hold a sword, Lyanna leaning out from the gallery and demanding her turn…
Benjen's hand slipped into a pocket, touching the unopened letter meant for Starfall. He had not sent it, always holding back at the last moment. Maybe it was the fact that Ashara had turned him down so many times before, or the fear that pushing too hard would sever the fragile link he kept with his brother's son in Dorne. Still, every few moons he wrote, offering marriage and a safe place for Edric. Each time, Ashara refused, as he half-expected.
Yet he kept writing, unable to shake the sense that someday all might change. Edric would grow, and questions would come. The careful story Starfall told might not hold forever. When that day arrived, Benjen wanted Ashara to know one thing: Moat Cailin stood ready for her son—a place with no courtly gossips or power games to threaten him.
The thud of hooves on the causeway made him glance west. A small hunting party was coming back, led by Jojen Reed, Howland Reed's oldest child. The crannogman lad often visited, whether to be with Jon or for reasons deeper still, Benjen could not say. There was an age in Jojen's eyes, a wisdom that went beyond normal sight. But he was good for Jon, teaching him the secrets of the Neck and the legends of the Children of the Forest.
Benjen descended the worn tower steps, his boots ringing on stone that had stood here for untold centuries. Each morning, he walked these halls, checking on the rebuilding. It felt unlike Winterfell and its busy corridors, but it had gained a homelike feeling after so many years.
He reached the great hall, which had fresh timber floors brought in from the Wolfswood. It was already alive with movement: servants setting out bread just pulled from the oven, guards off night watch searching for breakfast. Tapestries from White Harbor merchant caravans now brightened the old stones, which had stood through the ages of the North. Sometimes, in the pre-dawn hush, Benjen wondered about the tales these walls could tell.
"Uncle," Jon called, coming in from the yard with sweat still on his brow. "Jojen's just returned. He spotted travelers near the causeway."
Benjen felt no particular rush of hope or worry. Moat Cailin often saw travelers now that its restoration was common knowledge. Instead, he watched Jon, who seemed more energetic than usual—clearly eager to learn who these newcomers might be.
"We'll talk about it over breakfast," Benjen said, nodding to an empty bench. "Clean yourself up first."
Jon hurried off, and Benjen's thoughts wandered north, to Winterfell, where another nephew was growing up under Ned's care. Robb Stark was Jon's age—they had been small children together once, before Benjen brought Jon south. At times, he questioned whether he had made the right choice, pulling the boy away from his father's home. But then he saw how free Jon was here—laughing with Jojen Reed, loosing arrows without judgment—and he knew he had done what was best.
Before long, people drifted into the great hall for the morning meal. Jojen Reed joined Jon, the boys speaking in hushed tones. The crannogman lad had an uncanny gift, a sense of things that went beyond normal sight, likely inherited from his father. His green eyes flicked to Benjen for a moment, as though gauging the reason behind the travelers on the causeway. Though Jojen seldom spoke of such matters outright, Benjen had learned to consider both the words and the silences of the Neck's people.
"My lord," Maester Willam said, stepping near with the light clink of chains. "A raven arrived this morning—from the south."
Benjen accepted the rolled parchment, noticing the Dayne seal pressed into the purple wax. He recognized it at once from House Dayne's star sigil, having seen it many times. But something about this particular letter felt different—thicker, more formal.
"Thank you, Maester," he said softly, slipping it away. He would read it alone later. He had learned not to lift his hopes, but he sensed something unusual here.
The hall bustled as servants brought warm bread, salted fish, and eggs cooked with wild onions taken from the glass gardens they'd nurtured. Eight years of hard labor had strengthened both the walls and the people who lived within them, ensuring they could endure even the North's hardest weather.
Benjen watched the spread of food but was lost in thought. Every repaired stone, every harvest—it all spoke to the time and care they had poured into making Moat Cailin livable again, though there was always yet to do.
"Uncle?" Jon's voice cut through his silence. "Is everything all right?"
Benjen managed a faint smile. "Only thinking, lad." He rose from the table, turning to Ser Donnor. "See to the merchants when they arrive. I have other tasks for now."
He left the hall, retracing his steps through the corridors and up the spiral stairs of the Gatehouse Tower. With each climb, the air felt colder and thinner, away from the warmth of hearth fires. At last, he reached his solar, where he paused to glance out the wide window at the misty swamps and the ancient causeway.
This was where he penned letters south, where he fulfilled a promise that had nothing to do with Winterfell's harvests or guard rosters. Here, in private, he kept up a delicate correspondence about Brandon's son.
Breaking the wax seal at last, he opened Ashara's letter. The parchment rustled like a whisper. He expected her usual kind but firm refusal. Instead, the opening lines made his pulse jolt:
"Dearest Benjen, Your last letter spoke again of marriage, of making a home for my son—for Brandon's son. For years, I have refused out of grief, out of fear, out of a desire to keep Edric close. But circumstances have changed...
He read it twice, even three times, noticing how her words hinted at something new. Something had happened to Edric that forced Ashara to reconsider old choices. She spoke of him being "too strong to stay hidden" at Starfall. Benjen wondered what exactly that meant.
He stood and walked to the window, staring at the grey causeway. He had imagined, many times, a second boy of Brandon's crossing that road, coming to the same safe place Jon had found. How many years had he made plans for that possibility?
A knock sounded at the door. "Enter," he called, folding the letter quickly.
Jon walked in, still in his practice garb. "Uncle, Maester Willam wants to know if you plan to answer the merchants' requests about the extra grain, and—" He paused, seeing the serious look on Benjen's face. "What's the matter?"
Benjen gazed at this nephew, so much like Lyanna it sometimes hurt. Jon had thrived away from Winterfell's whispers. Could Edric Dayne find peace here too? "Nothing bad," Benjen said gently. "But things may shift soon." He motioned Jon to sit, deciding how much truth to reveal. "What do you know of House Dayne?"
Jon's eyebrows pulled together. "They have the sword Dawn. And there's the title 'Sword of the Morning.' You've been writing to them for years, more so than any other house in Dorne or beyond."
Benjen nodded. "Lady Ashara Dayne has written to say she might come north. Possibly with her kin. To stay here at Moat Cailin." He didn't mention Edric yet. That would come in time.
"Here?" Jon's grey eyes widened. "Why would they leave Dorne for the Neck?"
"For eight years, I've offered Lady Ashara marriage," Benjen explained, pouring two small cups of watered wine. "She has always refused, but something changed. She wants to meet in secret, talk about things she won't put down in a letter. Whatever happened must be serious."
Jon paused, thinking. "Is that why you rebuilt so many empty rooms in the Children's Tower? You were planning for this, even if you weren't sure it would happen?"
Benjen gave a soft laugh. "Hope dies hard, lad. I always thought they might come someday. The old gods know I've sent enough ravens hoping to make it so."
He looked at Ashara's letter again. "She wants to speak first in White Harbor, away from too many curious eyes. Something at Starfall pushed her to finally change her mind."
Jon's voice was cautious. "Will it upset things here? We've built a good life."
Benjen shrugged lightly. "It will bring changes, yes. But Moat Cailin was built to protect the North from dangers. It can protect people too, if we let it. You found a place here—maybe they will too."
He studied Jon for a moment, recalling how the boy had grown to trust this place. "Her household has a boy your age. It might be good for you both, sharing training and lessons."
Jon's nod was slow. Benjen noticed the tension still in his shoulders—he had learned caution as a "bastard," always wary of new people. "Have you told Lord Stark?"
"Not yet, but I will write," Benjen said. "Still, Moat Cailin belongs to me to govern. Your father gave me this fortress to command. Who I invite here is up to me."
Hearing Ned's name seemed to calm Jon a bit. Despite their complicated relationship, the boy trusted that Ned had meant for him to have a home. "When will the Daynes come?" he finally asked.
Benjen sealed a reply to Ashara with House Stark's dire wolf stamped in cooling grey wax:
Dear Lady Ashara,
Your message was most welcome. I understand the need for privacy, and if we must speak away from letters, White Harbor is a fine choice. Lord Manderly will be a polite host, and his hall is secure.
With fair weather, you should reach there in about a moon's time. Let me know when you journey, and I will see everything is ready. Bring only those you trust, as you see fit.
I look ahead to our meeting.
Benjen Stark
That evening, Benjen climbed to the highest point of the Gatehouse Tower, where ancient kings had once watched for enemies approaching through the Neck. The sunset painted the swamps in shades of amber and gold, while mist began its nightly crawl across the marshlands. He could see why the First Men had chosen this spot—on clear days, you could spot movement from leagues away, whether friend or foe.
He pulled out Brandon's old knife, the one his brother had given him on his tenth nameday. The blade still held its edge, though the leather grip had worn smooth from years of handling. Strange how life moved in circles—here he stood in a fortress older than the Andals, preparing to shelter Brandon's son just as he'd sheltered Lyanna's.
The thought gave him pause. He'd never allowed himself to draw that parallel before, but now it seemed obvious. Two boys, both carrying dangerous blood, both needing protection from the world's cruel judgments. Perhaps that's why Ashara's letter had affected him so deeply. Whatever had happened to young Edric in Starfall, whatever changes had finally convinced his mother to accept northern sanctuary, Benjen recognized the weight of necessary secrets.
A lone raven circled the tower before landing nearby, its black feathers gleaming in the dying light. It fixed him with one bright eye, as though waiting for something. Benjen remembered Old Nan's tales of ravens carrying more than just messages, of birds that served as the gods' own witnesses.
"Watch then," he murmured to the bird. "Watch and remember. The wolves are gathering again, though not for war this time." The raven cocked its head, then launched itself into the darkening sky, disappearing into the gathering dusk.
Below, torches began to flicker to life along Moat Cailin's walls, and the evening mist thickened around the ancient towers. Soon enough, Benjen knew, these stones would shelter another of Brandon's blood. The thought filled him with equal parts anticipation and unease—like standing on the edge of a great change, knowing the step forward must be taken but not quite seeing where it would lead.
Author's Note:
Thank you all for reading and for the support! I really appreciate the comments and feedback you've been sharing.
Next chapter will be out tomorrow. Hope you enjoy this one!
Also! I've started another self-insert story set in the
Naruto universe. If you're interested, check it out and let me know if you'd like to see more of it. Your feedback helps a ton!
🔗
Naruto: Kinetic Ascension (SI/OC)
Thank you! 🚀