- Location
- canada
ok in order1) It's immaterial if they are or aren't. My plan does work better if they will bother to melee, because frankly most things in a real situation won't be limited (and if frost nova is supposed to be a relevant spell of theirs then they will want to close to use it) but even if they want to stay at ranged then keeping together on the charge to mass shock is still a good tactic.
Ranged units directly behind the attackers can't shoot in any situation, either static or advancing. That way lies the magic situation of friendly fire in the back. They MUST displace for line of sight to do anything or the frontal attackers were alternatively so far dispersed in skirmish mode as to be unable to hold a frontline anyway (ie all the elementals rush through the gaps and/or shoot their ranged attacks back onto a common target themselves).
2) This very much depends on how the enemy chooses to react but my inclination is to say that kind of targeting that isn't attack closest is more risk prone than anything else, because it just takes one situation of one guy having to solo for things to start going wrong with the kind of spacing you seem to describe.
3) They still need to surveil the whole line for who to heal most at any given point in time as well as maintain focus and presumably line of sight. There's no handy healer UI.
4) Damage potential of riflemen isn't relevant, it's about putting them both in the best position to succeed and giving a no-brainer situation on what to focus on first.
5) They're going to be far less capable of taking that damage than the footman in any circumstance. And in a realistic scenario, they either risk getting mobbed in melee with no one assigned to them to where they start being able to not even shoot, or they take more damage anyway and place more healer strain.
6) No, I was questioning how the elementals get to the caster even if they frost nova. They're still physically body blocked. They can't teleport past.
And you can't have your cake and eat it too with game logic. ;P
1) they have ranged frost nova, plus I never said the riflemen will be right behind the footmen as the footmen will be moving forward to close in. Finally DO YOU HAVE ANY clue how HARD it is to charge while holding up a shield wall? there is a reason why footmen using defend move slower! And before you try to pull 'veteran troops' card NO that tactic is so RARELY used that expecting them to be experienced in it is ridiculous.
2) once again veteran troops.
3) true I will give you that but I am prepared to lose a couple given everything we probably will.
4) I still say my method is a fair bit better.
5) they are unlikely to be mobbed in melee but even if they are WoW riflemen have melee weapons and can use them fairly well.
6).... your kidding right? you do remember the 'they are on flat terrain by a riverbank' right? meaning they can just walk around? and even ignoring that without the footmen engaging them they are free to range attack our casters.... which is what they would do
I am not using GAME logic I am using the Logic that comes from thinking about how magic effects a battle like this and how Warcraft tactics happen in cannon... NOT IN GAME but in the books, in descriptions of battle etc.
Last edited: