What should the next Quest be?

  • Paths of Rhun (Middle Earth East Quest)

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • By Your Will (Dungeon Keeper 1 Quest)

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • Another Legend Quest (Gilgamesh, Lucrezia, Mordred, etc)

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • None of the Above

    Votes: 4 25.0%

  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .
So, two options. Option one; potential and even likely damnation as Jeanne is driven to extremism and falls under the sway of a Dreadlord, and that's if the Grand Crusader doesn't conveniently die and she gets murdered and her corpse possessed. She might redeem the Crusade though and remove said Dreadlord.

Option two; the guys who are definitely good people and much less susceptible to corruption, but the going is at least at the start going to be a lot tougher. Not least of which because she came from the Scarlet Crusade and the Argent Dawn will be suspicious of her for that reason.



Okay, first, we appear to have some very different views on the Argent Dawn. Second, quite frankly, the support of Stormwind and the Alliance are not exactly a bad thing, even if it means doing the Alliance's bidding.

And the Argent Dawn isn't bound to that at all. It favours the Alliance to an extent, yes, but that's because the Dawn is largely made up of humans and their allies. They've a notable and sizable contingent of orcs and trolls as members as well, and no few undead who shed the Scourge's control and joined up.

If anything, the Scarlet Crusade is more likely to join the Alliance than the Argent Dawn is once the Plague Lands are retaken and the organisation that did it actually becomes a geopolitical factor because there's no way they're going to accept the Forsaken controlling anything in Lordaeron and they don't have the manpower and resources to effectively oppose an entire nationstate on their own, never mind one that can call upon the rest of the Horde for reinforcements.
Ya ok several problems with this assessment...

1) The argent Dawn NEVER included a significant number of Horde members outside of a few Forsaken, you are thinking of the MUCH later Argent Crusade which ALSO didn't actually have many Horde members beyond a handful of Blood Elves as most Horde members joined the Warsong offensive except for Death Knights. Also the Argent Crusade (which is what the Argent Dawn becomes) is almost entirely an Alliance faction and does end up becoming a purely Alliance faction Post Wrath given they fight the Forsaken as much as the scourge at that point. (again around the same time as the Alliance is focused on fighting the Horde... Hmmm parallels parallels.)

2) I have no problem JOINING the Alliance, as long as we are our own nation rather than a breakoff faction/pawn of the Alliance.

3) The Argent Dawn does a whole lot of nothing until Wrath comes around and spends a good chunk of the time beforehand killing off Scarlet Crusade members rather than actually fighting the Scourge... They are the single most Hypocritical faction in existence and are honestly just backstabbers rather than proper crusaders in my eyes.
 
Okay, people who know Warcraft, anyone recognize these names?

Who do people think is the holiest/the best with the Light/the best teacher?

Cause that' a pretty important factor to me and might make me change my vote, and I imagine at least a few others might agree with me there.
no one in the Argent faction is currently significant in any way while Morlune is a 2nd generation Paladin from the Silver Hand known as Morlune the Mighty and is definitely a powerful paladin (though not sure how good a teacher but it seems he is a decent one and he likes us too.)

The other names include Malak the Avenger again a Silver hand member, IDK about the other two but between those guys the Crusade will let us become a very Powerful Paladin with a fair bit of ease I would say.
 
2) I have no problem JOINING the Alliance, as long as we are our own nation rather than a breakoff faction/pawn of the Alliance.
We aren't a nation and, I mean, it's not impossible but I'd be pretty surprised if we wound up in charge of this nation considering we are a foreigner to this nation and to this group.
 
We aren't a nation and, I mean, it's not impossible but I'd be pretty surprised if we wound up in charge of this nation considering we are a foreigner to this nation and to this group.
I wouldn't so long as we end up exposing mr. Dreadlord and become important enough to this faction. At the very least I think we will be very important to the nation once it is created.

Besides I don't want to be some two bit adventurer which we will be if we join the Argent Dawn, I want to be involved in some important battles at least.
 
.... *Coughs, then hides the many, many times he's seen CK2 players aimed solely at marrying Jeanne or her equivalent in their game*
Ah, I remember my holy maiden, such a incredible strategist, my nobles hated me for making her a noble and telling them to go fuck themselves but I didn't care, shame she wouldn't become my queen, it wouldn't even be against he vows seeing how my king was celibate.
 
I'll put in a tally here. The vote will end either tomorrow afternoon or Saturday morning. After that will come the interlude vote.

EDIT: no one noticed the poll, huh?
Adhoc vote count started by King Tharassian on Mar 22, 2018 at 4:05 PM, finished with 558 posts and 15 votes.
 
Last edited:
[x] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
 
Ah, yes... The "Sadistic QM Principle."

Don't be fooled. Redeeming the crusade won't be easy, but it is certainly possible, given the divergences I used for this version of the setting.

Oh, I wasn't thinking you'd deliberately screw us over.

But it's a definite risk for Jeanne, should she join the Scarlet Crusade, and redemption will be a long, hard road for an organisation rapidly radicalizing and hardening.

1) The argent Dawn NEVER included a significant number of Horde members outside of a few Forsaken, you are thinking of the MUCH later Argent Crusade which ALSO didn't actually have many Horde members beyond a handful of Blood Elves as most Horde members joined the Warsong offensive except for Death Knights. Also the Argent Crusade (which is what the Argent Dawn becomes) is almost entirely an Alliance faction and does end up becoming a purely Alliance faction Post Wrath given they fight the Forsaken as much as the scourge at that point. (again around the same time as the Alliance is focused on fighting the Horde... Hmmm parallels parallels.)

Even in Classic WoW Light's Hope Chapel had orcish and undead members walking around. As I said, there's a definite human advantage in numbers, but they are more inclusive.

The Forsaken had gone off the deep end and the Horde under Garrosh were much more aggressive and less willing to cooperate in any manner that didn't leave them in charge and reaping the benefits while suffering the smallest risk possible. That the Argent Crusade ended up aligning with the Alliance is not unexpected in that case, especially when the Forsaken are forcibly raising the dead including the Crusade's own.

Also, by the time of Classic WoW the Scarlet Crusade had gone so crazy they killed anyone not part of the Crusade on sight.

2) I have no problem JOINING the Alliance, as long as we are our own nation rather than a breakoff faction/pawn of the Alliance.

We are far more likely to become an Alliance puppet as the Scarlet Crusade than we are as the Argent Dawn. Because the Argent Dawn can argue it's an inclusive organisation, while the Scarlet Crusade is much more insular and racist.


3) The Argent Dawn does a whole lot of nothing until Wrath comes around and spends a good chunk of the time beforehand killing off Scarlet Crusade members rather than actually fighting the Scourge... They are the single most Hypocritical faction in existence and are honestly just backstabbers rather than proper crusaders in my eyes.

You mean aside from fighting the Scourge in the Plaguelands? Quite frankly, until Wrath of the Lich King happened the Argent Crusade was absurdly resource starved. They were a resistance movement forced to live off the land more than anything, while dodging a humongous army that outnumbered them massively. They survived by dint of not being annoying enough to be wiped off the map, while the Scarlet Crusade remained because it was a useful patsy to the Burning Legion.

The Argent Crusade started being able to move resources around because the Lich King let up on them a little after the fiasco that was the Battle for Light's Hope and the Horde and Alliance turned their gazes northwards after the second time the Scourge attempted to infect the entire world with Plague.

EDIT: no one noticed the poll, huh?

That's a little early for that, don't you think?
 
You mean aside from fighting the Scourge in the Plaguelands? Quite frankly, until Wrath of the Lich King happened the Argent Crusade was absurdly resource starved. They were a resistance movement forced to live off the land more than anything, while dodging a humongous army that outnumbered them massively. They survived by dint of not being annoying enough to be wiped off the map, while the Scarlet Crusade remained because it was a useful patsy to the Burning Legion.

The Argent Crusade started being able to move resources around because the Lich King let up on them a little after the fiasco that was the Battle for Light's Hope and the Horde and Alliance turned their gazes northwards after the second time the Scourge attempted to infect the entire world with Plague.
ok no, they barely fought the scourge... mostly because they had what? a couple thousand people tops? they only had two bases in total and were nearly non-existent pre-WotLK... And that is not something we can fix. I want the Holy warrior quest here as Jeanne fits it so well, not some basic WoW adventurer quest and only the Scarlet Crusade can really give us that.
Even in Classic WoW Light's Hope Chapel had orcish and undead members walking around. As I said, there's a definite human advantage in numbers, but they are more inclusive.

The Forsaken had gone off the deep end and the Horde under Garrosh were much more aggressive and less willing to cooperate in any manner that didn't leave them in charge and reaping the benefits while suffering the smallest risk possible. That the Argent Crusade ended up aligning with the Alliance is not unexpected in that case, especially when the Forsaken are forcibly raising the dead including the Crusade's own.

Also, by the time of Classic WoW the Scarlet Crusade had gone so crazy they killed anyone not part of the Crusade on sight.
again no they did not have orcs and Forsaken beyond a couple of notable INDIVIDUALS! thats a big difference from having them in the rank and file. The only people in the Argent Dawn that were Horde races were a few break offs from their faction, not representatives of it. Plus the Forsaken are outright evil at this point in heck I can't think of a time where the Forsaken didn't do extremely evil actions and slaughter hundreds of living innocents.

Also AU plus we are NOT part of the Crusade nor are the Murlocs and yet they seemed to be fine with us, and with talking to the murlocs so your assessment of them is wrong here.
We are far more likely to become an Alliance puppet as the Scarlet Crusade than we are as the Argent Dawn. Because the Argent Dawn can argue it's an inclusive organisation, while the Scarlet Crusade is much more insular and racist.
Again AU and only the highest parts of the Crusade were racist. Also from what Morlune stated they obviously are not as bad as they were in canon. Also again there is a difference between being a puppet faction in all but name like the Argents were vs being a member nation in its own right.

As I said I do not CARE if we are part of the Alliance I care if they control us and we can't do shit about it because we have no power without them. I do not like the Horde, they are a garbage faction full of the Evil races beyond the odd individual here and there.

Varok was a part of the original Horde which commited Genocide so he is Evil.
The Forsaken have yet to make it through an expansion that is not focused on another planet (BC) or just outright ignores the factions (legion) where they don't commit an act that is outright evil.
Thrall allows the Warsong to run among in Ashenvale until he abdicates. He also just fails to do much of anything to address all the crimes of the orcs and other leaders of the Horde.
The Tauren have the Grimtotem clan which are as Racist as you say the crusade are.
The Goblins are willing to do ANYTHING for money even kill the planet they live on.
The Blood Elves up until BC worshipped demons basically.
Only the Trolls are actually half decent among the Horde. (which is super ironic really.)
 
Last edited:
And points to anyone who can guess my justification for how quickly it happened! ;)
My immeadiate thought here is that the Scarlet basically bled themselves in a bad way working with the Forsaken as little as possible and the Argent Dawn not getting much more willing co-operation. With the Dawn being forced to run&hide and the Forsaken having their own issues, it mostly leaves the Scarlet as the guys running around DOING things.

Another thought is the Dreadlord is just THAT good, in a sense- basically they kind of repeat what happened to screw over Lordaeron-corrupt the heir to power since he'll be young and foolish, knock off the veteran but not quite so old to need replacement leadership and have your pasty rise to power.
So in theory, if we protect the old man, we can avert this...Assuming THAT is the play the Dreadlord decides to go for.
 
Demonic interference?

I mean, that's the canon answer.

Partially. But there was also an influx of recruits a couple years back.

Varok was a part of the original Horde which commited Genocide so he is Evil.
The Forsaken have yet to make it through an expansion that is not focused on another planet (BC) or just outright ignores the factions (legion) where they don't commit an act that is outright evil.
Thrall allows the Warsong to run among in Ashenvale until he abdicates. He also just fails to do much of anything to address all the crimes of the orcs and other leaders of the Horde.
The Tauren have the Bloodhoof clan which are as Racist as you say the crusade are.
The Goblins are willing to do ANYTHING for money even kill the planet they live on.
The Blood Elves up until BC worshipped demons basically.
Only the Trolls are actually half decent among the Horde.

1:.... Ehhh... Well, If you look into one or two things, you'll certainly think so IC...
2: Yeah...
3: The resource scarcity is very poorly represented in-game.
4: Tauren? Racist? I.... never got that impression. o_O
5: Yep. The Venture Co. is active nearby in this version. I can't wait! ;)
6: Worship? Nah, they just practice a Nietzschean atheism as a general rule. The Light is still a thing, but the death of the Sunwell also led to the development of the sun-reverence tradition into the beginnings of an actual cult.
7: Dey be trolls, mon. A' course dey be cool.

My immeadiate thought here is that the Scarlet basically bled themselves in a bad way working with the Forsaken as little as possible and the Argent Dawn not getting much more willing co-operation. With the Dawn being forced to run&hide and the Forsaken having their own issues, it mostly leaves the Scarlet as the guys running around DOING things.

Another thought is the Dreadlord is just THAT good, in a sense- basically they kind of repeat what happened to screw over Lordaeron-corrupt the heir to power since he'll be young and foolish, knock off the veteran but not quite so old to need replacement leadership and have your pasty rise to power.
So in theory, if we protect the old man, we can avert this...Assuming THAT is the play the Dreadlord decides to go for.

See my other response too.
 
3: The resource scarcity is very poorly represented in-game.
4: Tauren? Racist? I.... never got that impression
ok 3: True but they never bother to trade or just hire themselves out as mercs or something... I mean the night elves have infinite lumber they can sell it pretty easily and cheaply as long as the Horde was willing to pay for it.

4: It was just the one clan, but that clan was the largest Clan among the Tauren and the 2nd most politically powerful... (also sry I meant GRIMTOTEM. not Bloodhoof, :oops:)
 
ok no, they barely fought the scourge... mostly because they had what? a couple thousand people tops? they only had two bases in total and were nearly non-existent pre-WotLK... And that is not something we can fix. I want the Holy warrior quest here as Jeanne fits it so well, not some basic WoW adventurer quest and only the Scarlet Crusade can really give us that.

Having Jeanne act as a rallying point for the cause of Lordaeron won't result in the Argent Dawn gathering recruits and reinforcements how? I mean, that's basically what Jeanne does for a living, and did it quite well in France. Either by cleaving them from the Scarlet Crusade or by luring in hopeful adventurers from the South (seriously, that's a thing that happens).

And yes, they did fight the Scourge. They're basically your only quest givers in the Plaguelands, especially the Eastern Plaguelands prior to Cataclysm. There were just notable man and materiel constraints in no small part because they had few hardpoints to hide in.

again no they did not have orcs and Forsaken beyond a couple of notable INDIVIDUALS! thats a big difference from having them in the rank and file. The only people in the Argent Dawn that were Horde races were a few break offs from their faction, not representatives of it. Plus the Forsaken are outright evil at this point in heck I can't think of a time where the Forsaken didn't do extremely evil actions and slaughter hundreds of living innocents.

Given that the troll tribe that joined with the Horde is supposed to be tiny, the orcs fled the Eastern Kingdoms as a single group and left as few people behind as possible, the tauren are Kalimdor native and the Forsaken are evil, crazy and have issues, that's not all that bad.

Also AU plus we are NOT part of the Crusade nor are the Murlocs and yet they seemed to be fine with us, and with talking to the murlocs so your assessment of them is wrong here.

I was figuring we were early in the timeline; the corruption of the Scarlet Crusade has not yet taken hold, although it is having an influence.

Again AU and only the highest parts of the Crusade were racist. Also from what Morlune stated they obviously are not as bad as they were in canon. Also again there is a difference between being a puppet faction in all but name like the Argents were vs being a member nation in its own right.

The Scarlet Crusade may end up a member nation of the Alliance, but it'll be a member in name only. We'd have more in common with Theramore than with anything else, while the much more neutral position of the Argent Dawn makes it more likely the Horde and the Alliance will accept its claims of territory because in that case their enemy doesn't have it. They both benefit more from an independent Argent Dawn, while the Scarlet Crusade has only 1 alliance option.

As I said I do not CARE if we are part of the Alliance I care if they control us and we can't do shit about it because we have no power without them. I do not like the Horde, they are a garbage faction full of the Evil races beyond the odd individual here and there.

Varok was a part of the original Horde which commited Genocide so he is Evil.
The Forsaken have yet to make it through an expansion that is not focused on another planet (BC) or just outright ignores the factions (legion) where they don't commit an act that is outright evil.
Thrall allows the Warsong to run among in Ashenvale until he abdicates. He also just fails to do much of anything to address all the crimes of the orcs and other leaders of the Horde.
The Tauren have the Bloodhoof clan which are as Racist as you say the crusade are.
The Goblins are willing to do ANYTHING for money even kill the planet they live on.
The Blood Elves up until BC worshipped demons basically.
Only the Trolls are actually half decent among the Horde.

Varok Saurfang is more neutral to me; make no mistake he has a lot to answer for, but while he's not decided to dedicate his life to gaining redemption, he has nonetheless sought to better himself and teach the next generation of orcs to be better. He succeeded with Dranosh. Garrosh... not so much.
True on the Forsaken; it's a miracle they haven't been wiped off the face of Azeroth yet.
Thrall is powerful and influential, but he has limitations when it comes to controlling the orcs. That's part of the problems that the Horde has; the orcs are rather arrogant, selfish and violent, and hard to keep from screwing things up as a result.
You mean the Grimtotems, which are indeed very annoying (and end up betraying the rest of the Tauren in the lead up to Cataclysm). The remaining tribes are generally decent people.
Hey, mercenaries are mercenaries. Goblins are basically what you get when you create an anarchocapitalist society.
The Blood Elves don't have issues so much as subscriptions when it comes to a lot of things.
And yeah, the trolls on the whole are a rather decent bunch. Vol'Jin was awesome, and it's a real shame he's dead. That alone would've been enough for me to support destroying the Legion.

Partially. But there was also an influx of recruits a couple years back.

Would these be survivors from Marshal Garrithos' forces?
 
Last edited:
I was figuring we were early in the timeline;

The way this works is both AU and early. Some things are different (At least one is in the interlude you all got between Chapters 1 and 2), but this is also early 25 ADP. Several months will pass before WoW would have canonically started by my reckoning.
Adhoc vote count started by King Tharassian on Mar 22, 2018 at 6:04 PM, finished with 574 posts and 19 votes.

  • [X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
    [X] You went with the Argent Dawn to Chillwind Camp. They were naive, but well-intentioned, and you found just as much righteousness in them as in the Crusade.
    [X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
    [X] You went with the Argent Dawn to Chillwind Camp. They were naive, but well-intentioned, and you found just as much righteousness in them as in the Crusade.
 
[X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
 
Would these be survivors from Marshal Garrithos' forces?

*Dungeon Keeper narrator voice* Jackpot winner! *Disco Inferno plays*
Adhoc vote count started by King Tharassian on Mar 22, 2018 at 5:51 PM, finished with 573 posts and 18 votes.

  • [X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
    [X] You went with the Argent Dawn to Chillwind Camp. They were naive, but well-intentioned, and you found just as much righteousness in them as in the Crusade.
    [X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
    [X] You went with the Argent Dawn to Chillwind Camp. They were naive, but well-intentioned, and you found just as much righteousness in them as in the Crusade.
 
[x] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
 
[X] You went with the Crusaders to Vandermar. They were harsh, but justifiably so, and you preferred to be among people who would know you than start over a second time. It was selfish as far as you were concerned, but you felt as though it would be forgiven this once.
 
[X] You went with the Argent Dawn to Chillwind Camp. They were naive, but well-intentioned, and you found just as much righteousness in them as in the Crusade.
 
Back
Top