Saving the Bluenette (Puella Magi Madoka Magica)

What should I do with the epilogue?


  • Total voters
    26
Created at
Index progress
Complete
Watchers
61
Recent readers
0

A magical girl's potential is determined by the weight of her karmic destiny.

Homura twists back time with the sole purpose of rescuing Madoka. The entire fate of every single timeline – all of those billions of people – comes to depend on Madoka, again, and again, making Madoka the strongest magical girl to have ever existed, the only one who could stop Walpurgisnacht.

What if Homura did the same thing, but with Sayaka Miki?
Chapter 1
I hope nobody's done this before.

Persephone's Waltz is one of my favorite fanfictions of all time. In my opinion, Remember the Human is the closest I've ever gotten to writing something of the same quality, followed closely by Arc One of Sailor Mercury Crystal, but I'm making another attempt here.

Unmarked spoilers for all of Puella Magi Madoka Magica, all twelve episodes of which are necessary to be able to fully understand the story.

Cross-posted to AO3.







Loop 99.

Starting a new loop with her clockwork buckler repaired her injuries. Some moments ago, Homura's leg had splintered beneath a boulder of reinforced concrete, but now, it was fully ambulatory.

Homura Akemi's magic was unreasonably useful. She had survived many early witch encounters just by using her buckler as a kind of panic button or ejection seat, which she had punched at least eight or nine times on the way to becoming truly competent as a magical girl. Homura did rank herself a cut above Mami Tomoe. Mami was no rookie, but (Homura thought) she didn't have the unassailable situational awareness and self-control to keep from taking unnecessary risks.

Homura lay in a hospital bed. Her hair roped into two long pigtails. A pair of useless thick red plastic-rimmed glasses sat on her face. What did she see? Bags, booklets, and paperwork to enroll at a school that would place her in Madoka Kaname's homeroom – and a paper calendar. It was March 16th, the day of her hospital discharge. That left her some time to rest and recuperate before returning to work.

She summoned her soul gem. It darkened during her hopeless battle with Walpurgisnacht as she finally realized that saving Madoka Kaname was beyond her power. But now, its swirling purple crystal glowed fiercely. In flashing through Homura's mind, Kyubey's taunts gave her an idea.

Should Madoka Kaname make a contract, she would be the only magical girl strong enough to defeat Walpurgisnacht and save Mitakihara City from complete annihilation. But Homura had promised Madoka (in a past timeline) that Homura would save her from that fate, from being devoured by the soul-sucking monster that every magical girl was destined to become. Kyubey was Mephistopheles, and Homura would keep Madoka from dealing with him. But how else to defeat Walpurgisnacht without contracting Madoka?

Kyubey had explained that by triggering so many time loops whose existence was conditioned on Madoka's survival, Homura had magnified the weight of Madoka's karmic destiny. That made Madoka's magical potential stronger.

Why not create another 'most powerful magical girl' and rely on them to defeat Walpurgisnacht? It didn't have to be Madoka Kaname.

"Sayaka Miki," said Homura.

To save Madoka, she would first save the bluenette.

Homura Akemi pressed the nurse call button. She wanted lined paper.



Loop 99.

Homura mentally queried her hammerspace: How much equipment do I have?

She started all her time loops by robbing the Japanese Strategic Self-Defense Force blind. It was how she knew that her magic could penetrate and manipulate plain matter – her hylekinesis let her bypass pin-tumbler-locked doors. Invariably, the sheer quantity of missing equipment would immediately trigger prefecture-wide security alerts that were prohibitively difficult to circumvent. She could only heist once per loop, but that was no issue.

What was she carrying? A collection of handguns from SIG Sauer and Heckler & Koch. Her favorite pistol: a simple Beretta M9. M67 grenades by the several thousand. Belt-fed machine guns: a few thousand Sumitomo-licensed Minimi SAWs. Hundreds of thousands of rounds of 5.56x45mm NATO belted together with disintegrating links. On her last loop, she'd stolen Howa-built recoilless rifles and 84mm rounds, but Walpurgisnacht seemed to shrug these off without issue. She decided to 'standardize' on more readily thievable license-built Panzerfaust 3s, her standby for witches or familiars that could seemingly withstand bullets. The JSSDF was a cornucopia of magically stealable firepower: With every loop, the stolen weaponry 'respawned.'

Mastering mass hylekinesis had been a game changer for Homura. She could lay out a hundred Minimis, unload them, field strip them, clean them, reassemble them, and reload them, all in perfect synchrony, like a ballistic Sorcerer's Apprentice. And then she'd discovered how to do this in hammerspace, which was when Homura became unkillable.

(Except by Walpurgisnacht, Homura thought.)

Mami fought with flourish and spectacle, which was a weakness of hers. (Was it a conscious choice? Was it to give her a sense of control after the death of her parents?) But the theatrics of her fighting style still had advantages, and Mami had put in work to make it practical. To fire rapidly, she would summon dozens of single-shot rifle muskets at once, each of which permitted telekinetic handling, and Homura had known (after asking) that neither the muskets nor the telekinesis were powers that Mami possessed immediately after contracting with Kyubey. It could be learned, and so Homura had learned it.

Homura would start copying Mami more closely. But instead of 19th Century rifle muskets, Homura's weapons would be contemporary. She would walk the witch's labyrinth in a cloud of animate machine guns, a murder of crows. She would defeat every witch by sheer overwhelming firepower. She would slaughter witches like gallows and collect grief seeds like eggs on Easter Sunday.

That served two purposes. It let her farm grief seeds, for one, which she might offer as an enticement to Mami or Kyouko if they were disagreeable. But an absurd lethality would have a psychological effect, too: if Mami, Madoka, Sayaka, or Kyouko saw her, they would respect her as a deadly force.

Maybe even as a leader.

Homura palmed her face. She just realized–

–since she couldn't beat Walpurgisnacht by herself, she would have to rely on others–

–like Sayaka Miki, which meant that they would be working together, like in the old loops, which meant that–

–she was building a magical girl team, and–

–owing to her age, experience, and direct knowledge of the threat they faced, she would be in charge.

Fine, thought Homura. I will rely on others now, as I clearly need to. The thrill of outsmarting Kyubey's doomsaying still intoxicated her, so walking back an old solemn oath didn't feel too shameful. Her promise to Madoka was what mattered most.

But she wouldn't be relying on them unconditionally. Both Sayaka and Mami lacked the inner constitution not to be ruined by the revelation of where witches came from. If they lost a team member that way, Homura wasn't sure how to manage Sayaka and Mami's emotions. And awful revelations aside, Madoka was so self-sacrificing that she might just contract immediately, which (Homura realized) would be a problem if she got to see Homura at her most awesome before Homura had a chance to warn her.

Out of all of them, Kyouko might be the easiest to deal with. She already had the cold pragmatism of a veteran magical girl. Homura could just hire her for grief seeds.

Homura reflected that this would be a challenging learning experience, but she had long since learned to muscle past that fear. She'd never built a bomb before becoming a magical girl, let alone shot a firearm. Learning to manage a group of people was an entirely different skill set.

Oh well. The buckler's time travel gave her infinite time to test new strategies. She would have to be content with looking foolish in the early loops.



Loop 100.

Homura Akemi had stopped in the middle of the Mitakihara Middle School skywalk, several paces ahead. Madoka Kaname, the Nurse's Aide for Class 2A, was 'escorting' Homura to the Nurse's Office. But her guidance seemed wholly unnecessary: It was as if Homura had walked this route a hundred times and only wanted the time to talk to her.

Homura was mostly quiet. She still carried the air of dangerous mystery that she'd held since entering the classroom. Madoka knew that she ought to be gracious and welcoming – Homura was a new student, after all – but the prospect of saying anything made her nervous. She'd tried making small talk – the name 'Homura' meant 'flame,' which Madoka thought was cool – but each attempt sputtered and died. It was as if Homura were as terrified of speaking as Madoka herself.

But now, they were at the skywalk, and Homura had stopped mid-step. She did an about-face and fixed Madoka with her gaze. "Kaname-san," she began, interrupting Madoka, "do you treasure the life you currently live? Do you consider your family and friends precious?"

"W-well… I…" Madoka began. "Yes, I do. Both my family and my friends. I love all of them and consider them very precious."

"Do you really?"

"Yes, really! I couldn't lie about something like that."

"I see," said Homura.

Then she looked down and began unfolding a sheet of A4 paper that had somehow appeared in her fist.

"Homura-chan?"

The paper contained a crude sketch of some kind of animal. It looked like a cross between a fox, a bunny, and a kitten. It was white. It had pointy ears, but from those ears dangled long flaps of flesh-like curtains, ringed by halos and tip-tinged with pink. Madoka thought it was kind of cute, but there was something about its eyes. They looked like dark pink marbles, blank, soulless, and devoid of human sympathy.

Madoka glanced at Homura's face, which looked weirdly squished and paler than her usual skin tone. Homura was chewing her lip.

"Have you ever, uh, seen one of these?" she said.

"Uh," said Madoka. "Uh. No?"

"You will see one soon," said Homura. Her face was turning pink. "It may approach you when you're alone. You may see one outside your bedroom window, trying to get in."

Madoka scratched her head. "Um, okay? Is it– what kind of animal is it?"

"It calls itself Kyubey," said Homura, "which means Incubator."

Madoka squinted at Homura.

"The Incubator will offer you a wish in exchange for becoming a magical girl," said Homura. "No matter what it offers you, you must say no. Terrible things will happen to you if you say 'yes.'"

Madoka had no idea how to continue the conversation. Was this some program the school had devised to keep students from trying illicit drugs?

"Uh, okay," said Madoka.

"And," Homura added, "to be clear, that warning is meant for you specifically. If Sayaka Miki wants to make a contract to become a magical girl, then encourage her. She should do it, but not you."

Madoka's face creased deeply, like an 'everywhere frown.'

Homura was folding the sketch and putting it in her pocket. (Wait, did the uniform even have a pocket there–)

"I can figure out my way from here. Thank you, Kaname-san," said Homura, her face flaming.

Homura turned and went on her way.

Madoka was so confused that she didn't move from where she stood.

Then she heard footsteps echoing through the hallway. Homura rounded the corner.

"Oh, good, you're still here," said Homura, slowing from a sprint to a jog. "Please keep the drawing."

Madoka took the folded A4 sheet.



Loop 102.

"And then she just left," said Madoka.

Mami Tomoe and Sayaka Miki stared at the drawing. They all knelt on pillows around a low chabudai table on which they'd spread the picture. "It is a good depiction of Kyubey," said Mami. "But the justification for Akemi-san's warning is still a mystery to me. Unless– Kyubey?"

"I may have some insight," said Kyubey from Mami's lap. He leapt onto the table. "As an Incubator, I can sense the magical potential of potential mahou shoujo." (Kyubey had explained that Incubators were so named because they were tasked with helping magical girls reach the final stages of their development, an explanation which the three girls accepted.) "Sayaka Miki-san is unusually strongly endowed, but Madoka Kaname-san's potential would shake the Earth and Heaven." Kyubey put a paw on his chin. "Perhaps Homura-san wants Sayaka to help protect Mitakihara but is afraid that a magically empowered Madoka Kaname would be too much of a threat to her power?"

"I've encountered Homura-san while out witch hunting," said Mami, frowning slightly. "I keep my distance and don't follow her into labyrinths, but I can see that she works very quickly. She can kill ten witches in the time it takes me to kill one."

"Homura told me that I shouldn't contract because it would hurt the people I cared about," said Madoka.

Sayaka did a double-take. "Is she threatening you? Like, 'don't become a magical girl or I'll come after your friends and family?'" Sayaka growled. She set her tea cup onto the table. "You shouldn't listen to that. If you're the strongest magical girl there ever was, then put on the miniskirt and go show her who's boss."

Madoka set down her tea cup and hugged Sayaka. "Thank you, Sayaka-chan, but– I don't think that's what she meant. She looked embarrassed when she gave me the drawing, like she was afraid of what I would think of her."

"Even I have a hard time just admitting the existence of magical girls," said Mami, cautiously.

"And besides," said Madoka, flipping over the drawing. She pointed to ten digits scrawled between a rectangle of fold marks. "She left her number. Maybe– we could call her?"



Loop 102.

"I mean no harm to the people you care about," said Homura Akemi. "I meant it in the way Mami-san suggests; that becoming a mahou shoujo involves enormous sacrifice and could endanger your loved ones. Magical girls sometimes fight each other, and you are right that Kaname-san's power would make her a target."

(She kicked herself hard for not rewriting her script around the Kyubey drawing. She had pre-written her skywalk speech to Madoka and said it every loop, over and over, until the lines burned into her memory like sear marks on a steak. So that was why Madoka and the others had been so reluctant to trust her in the previous loops. At least she hadn't shown up at Madoka's bedroom window to give her the drawing.)

"As for why I want Miki-san but not Kaname-san," Homura paused. She had taken some time to come up with a satisfactory explanation but remained unsure whether it would be convincing. "I think Miki-san can cope with the pressure of being a magical girl of such power. She could navigate her inevitable rivalries with other magical girls more smoothly. For her, the personal sacrifice would be less than for Kaname-san, making it sustainable."

(She was gambling that Sayaka, too, was fiercely devoted to Madoka's protection. If Homura could frame contract execution as Sayaka's voluntary sacrifice to protect Madoka, then she might convince everybody listening.)

Homura could tell that Sayaka was still thinking about it; like Homura, Madoka was watching Sayaka; Kyubey stared at nothing in particular, seeing nothing and hearing everything; and Mami was watching Homura cooly and skeptically, taking a sip from her teacup.

It hadn't been too difficult not to make Mami distrust her as much as usual. Literally handing Madoka a picture of Kyubey and telling her not to make a contract with him was surprisingly effective: Homura mostly hadn't needed to shoot any Kyubeys since the start of the loop. Without Kyubey warning Mami against her, there was space for the two to converse on friendly ground.

Homura had missed this, she realized. She missed eating meals with the other girls in the exquisite comfort of Mami Tomoe's apartment. This could become a regular part of her life now. Part of Homura wanted to start sobbing, but she crushed– no, gently parried the feeling. For now, she had an image to maintain.

"Mami-san, regardless of whether Kaname-san or Miki-san choose to contract," said Homura, "I wish to form an alliance with you."



Loop 103.

Before the four went on a witch hunt, they would use the early antechambers of a witch's labyrinth as an indoor firing range. They were in a cave. What looked like giant fossils lined the walls. Boulders littered the ground, all brightly colored and stamped with the image of a small children's doll with floppy ears. That helped them in two ways: first, it (apparently) showed them what the witch would look like, and second, the boulders were just big enough to use as shooting targets.

(Mami was reluctant to take Madoka and Sayaka on a hunting trip with Homura, but – bewilderingly – Kyubey had vouched for her. "I think our interests may intersect," he said, staring at Homura. Strangely, Homura had shivered.)

Neither Madoka nor Sayaka had yet contracted, and both Homura and Mami had warned that the baseball bat that Sayaka had brought would be largely useless in a battle with a witch. In lieu of the bat, Homura had a pair of SIG Sauer P226s to split between them.

"These have no manual safety," said Homura. "If the weapon is loaded and you pull the trigger, it will fire."

"Homura-chan," Madoka said nervously, "are you sure we should have these? It seems–"

"Unsafe?" finished Sayaka. "Sorry, Madoka, I'm on Homura's side here. We're in real danger from these monsters. It only makes sense to carry real weapons to handle them."

"We don't expect you to use them," said Mami. (Mami had initially thought Homura's recommendation to be overkill, but it didn't take long for Homura to convince her.) "They're for emergencies only. Don't shoot at the witch if you don't need to. Conserve your ammunition."

"Within reason, you don't even have to worry about shooting me or Mami," said Homura. "I would survive being shot in the head." She handed out spare magazines. "But still. Only shoot if you are threatened."

"We'll collect everything when we're all done," said Mami. "You won't have to smuggle them home in your bookbags."



Loop 103.

They stood on a wide terrace enclosed by wavy red fencing. The floor was cake. The walls receded into the distance, like the world's tallest greenhouse dome, except they were fruited layer cake. Black polka-dotted spheres that walked on four leg stubs leaped to bludgeon them. Mami and Homura kept a hemispherical space around them clear of familiars for a hundred meters in every direction: Mami kept firing at a swift pace, summoning new rifle muskets by the dozen, while Homura maintained her own steady volume of fire, telekinetically teasing aimed single shots from the belt-fed Minimis.

Madoka and Sayaka held their pistols in awkward isosceles shooting stances, barrels aimed at the floor, gawking at the magical slaughter unfolding before their sight. Kyubey sat on Sayaka's shoulder and went back and forth on what Sayaka might wish for.

It was like shoveling dead mice out of a crawlspace. The familiars didn't stand a chance.

Mami Tomoe came to the slow but certain realization that Homura Akemi was stronger than her. It was wildly incongruous that magical girls would rely principally on firearms as their primary armament, but it made sense in practice. It wasn't like modern militaries would use anything less than the deadliest weapon their soldiers could carry, and none of them used swords, let alone magical ribbons.

Mami remembered that learning to fashion her magical ribbons into rifle muskets transformed witch hunting from a task that required nigh-suicidal courage into a manageable night job. She remembered that it had been absurdly difficult – forming ribbons into precise mechanisms and magically solidifying them, replacing percussion nipples with ribbons that would spark like fireworks when struck, doing the same thing with the powder load in the chamber – and mused that she just must have been that desperate. Witch hunting was terrifying.

She didn't remember that happening in any episode of Sailor Moon.

But Homura had actual firearms. She stood in place, machine gun at her shoulder with three more floating in the air around her, and when the familiars tried to gather densely for a new assault, Homura just summoned three more. How many did she have? She wasn't just making them on the spot, was she?

The machine gun in her hands went empty. Homura dismissed it with a tap, and an identical but fully loaded machine gun replaced it.

The last of the familiars fell dead. They stood in a vast puddle of shell casings and steel belt links.

"Akemi-san," said Sayaka, with a look of awe, "did you get those when you contracted?"

Homura tilted her head and blinked a few times. "Oh, I see. No, I, ah, requisitioned these."

"How many do you have?" asked Mami.

"A lot," said Homura.



Loop 103.

"We keep our distance," said Mami Tomoe, her tone resolute. She watched the witch – the small stuffed animal with the pink floppy ears – through a scope Homura handed her. She didn't show it, but Mami was bursting with life. Trampling through the witch's labyrinth under cover of endless machine gun fire felt unfair. Mami was invincible.

Well, not really, Mami hastened to remind herself. She was working together with another magical girl, and as a matter of basic courtesy, you wouldn't take unnecessary risks so as not to force the other girl to extricate you from a mess of your own making. And Madoka and Sayaka were there, too; Mami would take every precaution to ensure that she wouldn't leave them at the witch's mercy.

"Affirmed," said Homura Akemi.

The witch (Homura called it 'Charlotte' after catching some illegible black lettering on the walls) sat at the far end of a vast chamber, loosely like the ones that had held her familiars. Platforms like giant swirly lollipops rose tens of meters into the air. Charlotte seemed completely harmless, which was definitely a trap.

Sayaka and Madoka hid in alcoves near the chamber's entrance that would keep them far away from the line of fire. Mami had summoned a few dozen rifle muskets, and Homura had laid out a firing line of seven Minimi machine guns. Mami and Homura's plan, simply stated, was to stand in the open and start blasting.

"Can you pin Charlotte in place with a harpoon?" asked Homura. That was an advantage of Mami's hylekinesis: She could produce specific and unusual weapons with minimal notice.

"Certainly, Akemi-san," said Mami, with an odd lilt to her voice. She summoned a harpoon gun that sparkled with silver Damascus patterning. It sat on a large tripod before her. She tilted the harpoon just so and fired.

The harpoon had no attached cable. They were pinning the witch in place, not reeling it in for its blubber. It flew in a graceful parabolic arc, vanishing into the distance, the broad edge of its speartip crushing the witch doll's midsection–

–and a monumental serpent, its body black and speckled with red polka dots, eyes like a halved jawbreaker, and wings like a small child's angel costume, erupted from the crushed doll's body and surged toward them like a missile–

–where it met a fusillade of ribbon-wrought musket balls and machine gun fire. It writhed, screaming in agony as the unending barrage pinned it against the far wall–

"We may need to move, Akemi-san!" shouted Mami. There were no visible familiars; it seemed safer for them to separate so that Charlotte attacking Homura wouldn't turn Madoka into collateral damage. The walls rumbled, and broken fondant masonry cascaded down the chamber's far side.

"No, we won't," said Homura. She swept a hand before her, summoning what looked to Mami like an RPG (but which Homura would identify as a Panzerfaust), shouldering it, and firing it straight into Charlotte's open mouth–

There was a high animal shriek, and Charlotte the Witch exploded into an expanding column of fire and dust.



Loop 103.

"I want to be a magical girl," said Sayaka Miki. "And I know what I'll wish for. I have this close friend, he's a famous violinist, but he got caught in this accident–"

"I, I kind of want to be a magical girl too," said Madoka, "But, I understand that Homura-san must have her reasons–"

They had returned to the apartment. Mami Tomoe stared at her with reverent awe whenever she thought Homura wasn't watching. Homura had given her the grief seed to keep, saying that Mami needed it more than she did.

"I can speak with Sayaka Miki, Homura Akemi-san," said Kyubey. "You needn't trouble yourself."

"I hope that I made a good impression," said Homura. She struggled somewhat to think of what to say. For instance, she didn't know if demanding that she be the team's leader would seem tactless. It might be more natural to split those duties with Mami, who (Homura would admit) was more socially graceful than she was. "I would like to do this again as your friend and teammate."

"I would like that," said Mami, speaking quietly. She rubbed the back of her neck. "I admit, I'm… surprised by all this. To be a magical girl is lonely. I've missed the feeling of fighting alongside friends."

Homura could tell, immediately, that Mami was speaking from a deeply dug well of emotion and didn't interrupt.

"Will you be staying, Akemi-san?" Mami asked.

"I," Homura didn't know how to reply. She had not expected that the witch hunting trip would have gone this well and wanted to take time off to recuperate and to figure out her next steps. Had she formed the bulk of her magical girl team already?

What would happen if she said yes and if she said no? Her greatest fear now was saying something stupid that would wreck all of the progress that she just made. They wouldn't instantly forget what Homura had done for them if she left. But maybe, by staying, she could influence them – say the right thing at the right moment to bring them closer to Homura's ultimate goal?

Homura chastised herself. She was thinking like an Incubator. (Although, dispassionately planning to achieve your goals wasn't intrinsically bad.) But to say the right thing at the right moment, she'd have to know what both would be, and she didn't.

Homura decided to leave. "I have prior commitments," she said. "But you can reach me at the number I gave you." Homura glanced at the Incubator. "And, I suppose, through Kyubey."

"Of course, Homura-chan," said Kyubey, with too much enthusiasm, as Homura stepped outside.



Loop 103.

Homura heard a voice coming from further up the hall. "Homura-san," said Mami's voice.

Homura looked back, eyebrows raised. "Uh," she began, "Yes? What do you need?"

"Homura-san," Mami looked bashful. "Would you– like to go to dinner with me?"

Homura looked confused. Her mouth hung slightly open. "Oh," she said. And then, "Ohhhh."











A/N: A few people have asked about this, so I decided to put it in an author's note. The 'hyle-' in 'hylekinesis' roughly means 'matter.' I use it to denote the kind of transfiguration and extrasensory material perception that it would take to fashion yellow ribbons into a working caplock musket.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 2
Loop 103.

Homura Akemi texted Mami Tomoe to coordinate their dinner date.

They decided they wouldn't go out to a restaurant, although Homura had still taken the preparatory step of robbing a local bank of several hundred thousand yen in case she was asked to pay. (She did not mention that to Mami.) They were both magical girls: They expected to discuss virtually nothing else and preferred to do it away from listening ears.

They would meet in Mami's apartment. Homura strongly preferred this. She had her own apartment, but it was good as a place of retreat and nothing else. Burying its charitable blandness in magical projections and diagrams of Walpurgisnacht (provided by Kyubey, of all people, sharing mundane Incubator technology) meant turning it into a white, featureless void. Homura only went there to plan and to brainstorm; it wasn't meant as a real living space.

Mami's apartment felt like home to Homura Akemi. Until last night, she hadn't visited it in so long.

After finishing the witch hunt, accepting Mami's dinner date, and heading home to her apartment, Homura Akemi cried. Like Mami, she'd forgotten what it felt like to fight alongside close friends. This was what had vanished from her life the day she declared she wouldn't rely on anyone anymore. Homura felt alternately silly and foolish. Could she let her heart soften without looking like a mess?

They wore their school uniforms. Mami Tomoe had prepared omakase sushi for them, which made Homura's eyes widen. She deeply appreciated the effort, but it was entirely unnecessary, Homura had insisted, and then Mami had broken down into wrenching sobs of her own as if she'd rolled every nigiri while choking back tears. Mami said she was crying "because I'm not alone anymore."

"They look up to me," Mami cried into Homura's shoulder. "Madoka and Sayaka, they think I'm so cool. But I'm really not worth looking up to. I only pretend to be cool. I'm really pushing myself hard. Even when I'm scared, or hurting, there's no one I can talk to. All I can do is cry on my own."

She thinks of me as an authority figure, Homura realized. To her, I'm wiser and more experienced. I'm someone that she can rely on. She thinks that if she falls, I will be the one to catch her.

And it occurred to Homura that Mami might be right. A set of number wheels on the inside of her buckler told her how long it had been chronologically since she had contracted with Kyubey. She had spent more than a decade in her time loops. She was a veteran. If Mami had questions, then (perhaps) Homura was best equipped to answer them.

Everybody needs a backstop, Homura reflected. Whether it be their parents, their teachers, their coaches, their priests. Magical girls were magical children, and it was by the sheer pragmatic cruelty of the Incubators that they always sought to contract the societally unmoored.

Of course, Mami wanted to cry on Homura's shoulder. Every other shoulder was gone.

"You're not alone anymore, Mami-san," said Homura, not understanding the words as she spoke them. But she had the sense that her presence mattered more than her words.

Mami went on crying for a little while. "You're right," she sniffled. "I'm not alone anymore, am I?"

Mami withdrew from their embrace. Still holding Homura's hands, she locked eyes. "Will you really stand and fight with me from now on? Will you really stay with me?"

"If someone like me will do," said Homura. "Yes. Always."



Loop 103.

"You would receive grief seeds on request, as needed," said Homura. "Were we to separate after the 30th, both of you would receive two-fifths of the grief seeds we'd collected since you joined, less however many of our shared grief seeds you had already used." Homura paused deliberately. "We can also offer a one-time payment of one hundred thousand yen. Kyubey will handle the accounting for the grief seeds and the money."

"Money makes it a tempting offer," Kyouko Sakura began. She leaned back in her chair. "Sounds like you need us more than we need you."

They were meeting in Homura's apartment instead of Mami's: Mami explained that she and Kyouko had baggage that made her apartment a poor meeting place. Sayaka and Madoka were still rubbernecking, as was Yuma Chitose from where she sat next to Kyouko. The seats were single-colored concentric circles that ringed a central stage – still level with the rest of the room – that sat beneath a dizzying flock of diagrams and storm-blurred photographs of the largest witch any of them could ever have seen. The background was a featureless white void.

Homura had set out plates of untoasted white bread on the central table. The symbolism was rather on the nose, but it was a gesture of good faith that she thought Kyouko would appreciate. Homura had offered a slice to Kyouko as they sat themselves, and they both took a bite. Homura set her leftovers on the table while Kyouko finished her portion in three ravenous gulps.

"We both need each other," said Mami Tomoe. "Walpurgisnacht arrives on the 30th. Our only hope of beating it is to work as a team. You're a powerful and experienced magical girl. And Yuma's healing power–"

"Yuma's off the table," Kyouko growled. She stabbed a finger at Homura, the rest of the hand still bearing a half-eaten apple. "Like she's always been, gun nut. You know what I told myself when I took her on? 'Maybe I can't feed her. Maybe I can't send her to school. But the one thing I can do is to keep her from contracting with Kyubey.'" She took another bite, chewed, swallowed. "And then you came along–"

"Believe me," said Homura, "I understand your anger and your frustration. I, too, have someone whom I cannot allow to make a contract–"

"Right. Pinkie, sitting just over there." (Madoka's hand went absently to her pink hair.) "Don't bullshit me. I can sense magical potential like any other mahou shoujo. You want to beat this witch? Get her to contract, and leave Yuma alone."

"But Yuma has already made the contract," said Homura. "And you know as well as I do that her dream is to be someone important, someone strong enough to be useful. She has healing magic that we don't. If nobody stops it, Walpurgisnacht wipes Mitakihara City off the map. Helping us defeat it would be the most useful thing Yuma could do."

Yuma nodded along until Kyouko elbowed her (gently) in the ribs.

"You know how we work," said Mami. "You know that we're no pushovers."

"Right," said Kyouko, with a wolfish grin. "You kill so many witches that if you didn't respect others' territory, there'd be nothing left for me. Just, why bother with the familiars? Why not let them eat enough to become real witches with real grief seeds?"

"Because we're magical girls, and we're here to protect people," Sayaka snarled. "Our grief seeds come from witches, not our neighbors."

(Homura deliberately hadn't told the others to let her do the talking. She expected and wanted Sayaka to butt in. Homura was still a stranger to the subtleties of romance, but she could tell that Sayaka's sheer bloody guilelessness ingratiated her to Kyouko strongly.)

Kyouko's mouth quirked. "I'd call you a dope, but it seems you've found a way to make it work."

"It's teamwork and technique," said Mami. "Witches pose some threat to us. Familiars largely don't."

(Homura actually agreed with Kyouko's reasoning and largely didn't bother hunting familiars in her previous loops. She kept a hectic schedule: When she needed grief seeds, she needed a lot in a short span of time.)

"Working with us," Homura said, "you will never go hungry, and you will never lack for grief seeds." Homura flipped some of her hair behind her back. "What would it take for you to say 'yes'?"

Kyouko tilted her head, mockingly imitating one of Homura's mannerisms. "A million yen in cash," she began, "right fucking now," she said.

"We could do that," asked Homura.

Kyouko froze in place. She squinted at Homura. "Bullshit. Do you, really?"

"Would you join us and help us defeat Walpurgisnacht for the other things mentioned, plus one million yen in cash?" asked Homura.

"Sure?" said Kyouko, still squinting.

Homura waved her hand. A monstrous pile of yen notes summoned to the table in a neat, quadrangular stack.

Kyouko leaned over, grabbing a money bundle still wrapped in a money band. "This is–"

Kyouko transformed into a magical girl and pressed the yen notes into her forehead. "Fucking hell, these are real?"

"Do you need assistance in transporting these?" said Homura. "I strongly advise against depositing this money in a bank, as that would trigger a criminal investigation."

"You cocksucker!" shouted Kyouko. "Did you rob a fucking bank?!"

"Yes," said Homura.

Mami Tomoe was laughing.



Loop 103.

Homura did not like the group's name. She was fine with 'the Mitakihara Group' because that's what they were. But 'the Mahou Shoujo Yunion (MSY)' was taking things too far. They were never supposed to be that large, to be that bureaucratic. Mami and the others were thrilled by the group's success, but all of this publicity created entropy (in the figurative sense, not the physical sense meant by Kyubey). Already, Homura had lost the ability to track the timeline's evolution fully – there were too many people to surveil and too many responsibilities to juggle.

It was Sayaka's idea, naturally; Homura had done too well in mentoring her. Sayaka had asked, they had looked, and then they'd discovered: magical girls in Mitakihara and elsewhere could be found online with minimal effort. Years ago, at the dawn of the Internet, the net-savvy of Kyubey's contractees formed 'role-playing groups' on Internet fora. It became a subgenre. There were badges and flairs for 'real' or 'confirmed' magical girls. Forum threads went on for hundreds of pages as different girls argued about the best ways to find witches, whether magical girls should form teams, and where and how territory could be respected. They posted pictures of themselves that laypeople assumed were very elaborate cosplays.

These fora had rules. To the others' puzzlement and Homura's blind terror, the largest forums always had rules that forbade role-players from claiming that witches come from magical girls. Arguments concerning that subject always became too unruly for moderators to handle.

(They all followed a pattern. A prominent magical girl 'role-player' would win notoriety for themselves on a forum: They would offer well-meant advice and encouragement to newcomers, organize social outings, and even help 'arbitrate' disputes between different groups. Often, they would form groups themselves or else join them when they already existed.)

(Then, one day, they'd lose their minds. It was common for 'witchgaters' (which is an idiomatic translation from Japanese into English) to 'at-mention' the omnipresent 'Kyubey' and then blast them with hateful polemic, all the while insisting that 'Kyubey' had betrayed them and their trust. Sometimes, they would claim that 'Kyubey' had turned them into zombies. The bans came swiftly. Witches came from magical girls? Sure. And for that matter, Soylent Green came from people.)

(It became a 'meme.' To claim that the 'Kyubey' account was a Faustian monster would elicit eye-rolls and groans from the common lurker.)

(Homura had explained this to Kyubey and asked if he had any comment. He stayed quiet for a time, his ears and tail whipping back and forth in what seemed like silent laughter, and confirmed that the 'Kyubey' accounts were all his.)

Regardless, Sayaka's idea was simple. (Madoka had also contributed substantially, Sayaka always made sure to stress. It was their idea.) The MSY would announce its presence in Mitakihara. They would print QR codes linking to their announcement thread and post them around the city. ("Are you a magical girl? Scan here to learn more about the MSY!") And they would set up an emergency hotline: other magical girls in Mitakihara could private-message the MSY forum account with their phone numbers, and if they found themselves in trouble (during a set of 'business hours' past the end of the school day), they could call the MSY for help.

This would mean splitting the party, Homura had stressed. The five of them working together were unstoppable in any witch's labyrinth: modern machine guns, rifle muskets, gun swords, and fire lances kept witches and familiars at a comfortable distance, and even when they didn't – Sayaka and Kyouko were well-experienced with fighting up close. Mistakes did happen, and Yuma could heal them before the fight was even over. Yuma herself cut the team's grief seed consumption by a factor of two-thirds. Would they send Yuma as part of the rapid response team – her plus Mami and Kyouko, and leave Homura and Sayaka to hunt by themselves? Being a loner meant taking hits that a teammate could have prevented.

But they had a duty, Sayaka had argued. They were magical girls sworn to protect the innocent. They were now powerful enough to protect the ordinary people in their territory. Now, it was time to protect others like them.

This drove Homura up a wall, which Madoka and Mami thought was endearing and quite funny. But they agreed with Sayaka. Even Kyouko agreed with Sayaka. Now that Madoka wasn't coming with them – she took the responsibility of managing the MSY's forum accounts – every time they finished a hunt, Sayaka would go home with Kyouko and Yuma, and Homura had secretly bedded with Mami Tomoe enough times to understand what that meant.

They were all strong enough to handle it. Homura was just being a worrywart.



Loop 104.

Homura refused to join the Mahou Shoujo Yunion, hoping to stop Sayaka and Madoka in their tracks.



Loop 105.

Whenever they split the party, Homura would always accompany Sayaka.



Loop 106.

Soon after forming their alliance, Homura steered Mami, Sayaka, and Madoka into accepting 'Never split the party' as an inviolable common-sense rule for witch hunting.



Loop 106.

The girls were two first-years named Reina Hirata and Sara Nasu. The call for help came from Reina. Sara was inconsolable. Her soul gem had neared total corruption. She'd just learned something horrible (Reina wouldn't elaborate) and was going to shatter her soul gem, which Kyubey said would kill her. Both had transformed, but Reina didn't want to subdue Sara. Sara would fight back, which would leave her soul gem exhausted.

This wasn't the kind of call to which they were meant to respond, but Sayaka insisted, as she always did.



Loop 106.

After the MSY's arrival, Sara Nasu's soul gem reached full corruption. She didn't shatter it in time. Sara Nasu became a witch: a wingless dragon in a black bridal veil.

Mami and Kyouko harpooned Sara's witch form into the walls of her labyrinth as Reina pled with her to come back as her old self. Kyubey led Madoka to the exit. (Homura had given Madoka a concealed-carry holster to wear beneath her school uniform for these visits, so she was not unarmed.) Homura tasked her Minimis with area denial, perforating any familiar to approach them. Sayaka bifurcated any who escaped the Minimis but kept her attention on Sara in case her witch form needed to be killed immediately. With Walpurgisnacht, Homura had explained, the plan was to rely on Sayaka to deliver the killing blow.

Homura learned many things from Reina's begging. They were best friends, Sara and Reina. Kyubey had approached them both, and they both contracted together. They wished that their fates would be forever intertwined and that their companionship would last forever. They were rivals with another magical girl in their class. They saw her become a witch.

Sara hadn't wanted that. She hadn't wanted to spend the rest of her days with Reina as a witch, cursing and devouring everything they'd held precious. And yet, Reina had been so lonely before meeting Sara that even a witch's companionship would be meaningful.

Reina's soul gem had gone black. Yuma pressed a grief seed into her palms, but Reina threw it aside.

Reina's soul gem reached full corruption, and she became a witch from inside the labyrinth. An explosive gust of wind sent the MSY and Sara's familiars tumbling like leaves. The witches Sara and Reina joined together, two dragons sucking each other's tails. Reina's claws ripped the harpoons from Sara's body.

"We need to retreat!" cried Homura. The new double-witch resolutely ignored Homura's machine gun fire.

Sara's witch form disgorged Reina's tail, droplets of magma spraying from its mouth like spittle. It inundated the floor where Mami and Kyouko stood with liquid flame, killing both of them instantly.

"Mami! Kyouko!" Sayaka screamed. She summoned a gun sword with a blade two meters long, readying herself to charge–

Homura reached into her buckler, fingers looping around a tiny brass handle, and yanked. She felt something give – shifting levers clanked against the inside of the buckler – and Homura felt her soul being ripped backward through time–



Loop 127.

This time, Mami managed to snare Homura with her ribbons. She also managed to gum up the clockwork of Homura's buckler, preventing her from pausing time or aborting into another loop. The last vestige of the labyrinth's distortion blew aside with the wind.

Mami aimed a rifle musket at the soul gem on Homura's left hand. Sayaka cleft the musket's barrel in two with a gun sword while Kyouko pinned Mami's arms behind her back.

"Drop it!" shouted Sayaka. "Stop! Stop, now!"

"You knew!" Mami screamed. "You knew this entire time, and you never told us?!"

Homura took deep breaths. She knew that it was difficult to answer truthfully. If Homura claimed to be a time traveler, Mami might use a ribbon to crush Homura's left hand.

"Sayaka and Yuma! You doomed both of them! Everyone here will turn into a witch, and for what?!"

"For Madoka," said Homura.

Mami screamed at the sky.

"Mami, I love you, but I need you to let me go," said Homura. "We're a team–"

Mami blasted Kyouko out from behind her with a thunderous kick. Still screaming, she summoned an oversized Tiro Finale that she aimed at Homura–

"Don't!" screamed Homura.

Sayaka shot Mami in the head with a gun sword, shattering her soul gem. Mami's body collapsed to the floor, her eyes sunken and blank.

"Dammit, Mami," muttered Sayaka. "Fucking, dammit–"
Kyouko launched into a river of profanity. Yuma began to cry. Madoka was at Mami's apartment, but she'd soon learn too.

"Only four," Homura mumbled as her restraints melted away from her body. "Only four against Walpurgisnacht."

And the other three would have significant trouble trusting her. Their fellowship might well be broken–



Loop 136.

Kyubey explained that the energy generated by every witch transformation to occur in one of Homura's loops was still being carried forward into their new loops to follow. He offered Homura his full cooperation and assistance. On behalf of the Incubators, Kyubey would name Homura a trusted ally.

Homura shot him in the head, then again with the rest of her Beretta's magazine, and then stomped on his corpse, grinding it into the pavement, screaming all the while.



Loop 137.

Sayaka was getting powerful enough that Homura didn't fully trust the rest of her group to kill her in her witch form. She had neared the point where 5.56x45mm NATO did not fully dissuade her. Homura had been resorting to stopping time and clapping cooked frag grenades against Sayaka's witch form's body by the several hundred, which she found more tedious and more logistically unworkable with each loop.

The sensible thing would be to reset the timeline as soon as Sayaka turned witch, but Homura wanted to practice in managing the fallout amongst the others. Managing their newfound anguish and distress was a riddle that she lacked the emotional intelligence to solve.

Homura had tried warning the group of Kyubey's deception immediately after joining them, and they refused to believe her. She'd attempted that as far back as Loop 2, and they hadn't listened; she lacked credibility as a newcomer.

And she couldn't wait either: If she waited to tell them until after Sayaka had executed her contract, then Sayaka would justifiably hate her. Sometimes Sayaka attacked her for her deception, particularly in loops where she hadn't found Kyouko but where Hitomi Shizuki confessed her feelings to Kyousuke Kamijou.

There had to be a way to break the truth to the group so they knew exactly what they were sacrificing by contracting to fight as magical girls. There had to be a way to tell them of their impending doom without immediately driving them into despair. To let them live in ignorance until they learned that lesson from miserable fate was hideously cruel and entirely unworkable.

And, in any case, it was threatening Homura Akemi with real death that she could not avoid with her clockwork buckler. Homura was not suicidal – or at least, yet, or anymore – and that meant trying something new.



Loop 137.

Homura asked Madoka to accompany her to the nurse's office, engaging her with polite small talk. She purposely steered the conversation toward making the world a better place. Ever the self-depreciator, Madoka doubted that she would make a meaningful difference.

Only then did Homura give her the drawing of Kyubey and warn her not to form a contract. And now, she told her not to let Sayaka contract until they could speak further. She made sure to point out the phone number scrawled on the page.

They met, once again, in Mami's apartment.



Loop 137.

It was easy enough to prove that she was a magical girl. From there, believing that Homura wielded time magic was a small leap. She could readily demonstrate her flash step technique indoors to prove that she could stop time and then use that to explain how she had successfully stolen so much military equipment from the JSSDF. From there, she had to convince them she was a time traveler.

She took Mami, Sayaka, and Madoka to go hunt Charlotte the Witch, as Homura had done for the past thirty-four loops. That would establish Homura's bona fides as a magical girl of power and experience.

She showed them the reading on her clockwork buckler's stopwatch – the literal years she had spent trying to get this month just right for the sake of those she loved. And then, to prove that she had relived the days between March 16th and April 30th more than a hundred times, she recounted everything she knew about them.

She told Sayaka about Kyousuke Kamijou, the accident that had hospitalized him and ruined his hand, and how often she visited him. She spoke of things that hadn't happened yet – that Kyousuke hated that Sayaka always brought him classical music to listen to, beautiful compositions that his ruined hand could never perform again. Homura spoke of Sayaka's sense of justice, how she balked at leaving regular people to die at the hands of familiars so they could grow into seed-bearing witches. Homura explained the truth behind the soul gems – that their name was literal, and Sayaka's face turned gray.

Homura told Mami about her ribbon muskets: every single thing that Mami had taught her about manipulating matter through hylekinesis; the specific books that Mami read to understand what she was building; the notes that she had taken on the witches that she'd killed. She told Mami that her coolness was an affectation and that she was miserable without others sharing her emotional burden. She told Mami that they had a lot in common. Mami had often (privately) called Homura 'senpai' in the more recent loops, which made both of them cheerfully uncomfortable. They had both had sex.

And Homura told Madoka the full story of all that had happened since Homura first contracted with Kyubey. She spent extra time on the ninety-ninth loop – the one on which she came up with her current strategy of empowering Sayaka – because that loop felt particularly instructive.

When asked directly, Kyubey confirmed that witches came from magical girls. Mami grabbed him and snapped his neck, twisting his head from his body. Neither piece bled.

"Is that what it's like?" Madoka gasped. "To be a magical girl?"

To Homura's surprise, none of them had broken down crying. They absorbed Homura's words with grave solemnity, as if seeing the warp and weft of their lives being woven out before them. And here is where my life choices killed me.

"It is," said Homura. "I don't think it has to be. But on my second loop, I swore to spare you that fate. That has been my driving purpose for several years."

"Do you even care about us?" asked Sayaka. "I'm the key to your plan, apparently. Do you care about me?"

"I don't know how to answer that question. I don't know how I feel," said Homura. "I care about Madoka, and I care about Mami. You grow closer to Kyouko than to me."

Homura sighed. "You're a means to an end, but it helps me if you're strong, happy, and healthy. I'm sorry, Miki-san, that's the most I can say."

Sayaka Miki put her face in her hands. "Fine," she said. "You know what, fine. I'll take it."

She stood from the chabudai and strode to a nearby window. "I'll… I'll do it," she said, her shoulders sagging. "For Kyousuke. For Madoka. And for Mitakihara. I'll become a magical girl."



Loop 137.

At Sayaka's insistence, they would privately warn every magical girl to contact the Mahou Shoujo Yunion's forum accounts or hotline that the witchgaters were telling the truth.

Moreover, the MSY began offering grief seed delivery. Kyubey remarked that this would cut their grief seed supply chain at two points and was promptly beaten to death.

The MSY started receiving inquiries from magical girls seeking to join its membership. Madoka announced that the MSY may open itself to new membership, but no sooner than April 30th.



Loop 137.

This girl should not have contracted.

Madoka gave her a grief seed, slipping it into her palm that stretched through a slightly cracked front door, after which she fled back inside without even a 'thank you.' Madoka, Sayaka, and the others were surprised. Their beneficiaries largely weren't warriors down on their luck: They were recluses. Hikikomori. Those who couldn't support themselves.

(To save time, they flew between delivery stops. Homura had opted to transport Madoka (who insisted on coming along) by holding her in a bridal carry, which Homura (to her unspoken humiliation) found arousing enough that she blushed midflight. The others didn't question the arrangement because it made sense: Homura was most experienced at flight and could stop time if Madoka ever came loose and fell.)

The MSY came to interview her "to understand our clientele better," said Mami. The girl agreed. They met in the alleyway behind her apartment building to avoid encountering her parents.

Her name was Mayu Kitaoka. She was a second-year and an academic disappointment. Homura sympathized, though it had only taken a few loops for her to master the material covered in Class 2A. This girl had barely passed since her first school enrollment, and now, she was doing no better.

She was unattractive, Homura thought. She was overweight. Her mouth was too big; her eyes were too close together. She knew that – she had said, choking back tears – and it didn't change when she transformed.

She became a magical girl a month ago. Her wish, she had explained, was to pass math class that semester.

She had never gone witch hunting. Not once. Kyubey told her to, and she ignored him. She didn't want to be a fat magical girl, but that wasn't what she'd wished for–

Homura grabbed Madoka and froze time, leading her around the building's corner and outside of the witch transformation's energy blast. Homura returned to where she was standing – in addition to her usual machine guns, she summoned three dozen recoilless rifles – and clicked the crown of her clockwork buckler back to its innermost position. The clock returned to regular operation. Time unfroze, and the five magical girls of the MSY entered the witch's labyrinth–



Loop 137.

"You may be the most effective magical girl team I've encountered," said Kyubey. "This has forced me to change my recruitment strategy in Mitakihara City."

(Mayu Kitaoka left no body, her remains fully consumed by the collapse of her witch's labyrinth. Madoka had returned from around the corner of the building.)

"The mere death of a magical girl yields no energy. Only a magical girl's final transformation from girl to witch helps to defeat entropy. Generally, I don't contract the weak: I need contractees strong enough to survive their battles until their faith is broken.

"But now, any witch that enters your territory will last, at most, days. You are killing witches and their familiars faster than either can be replenished.

"So I changed tacks." Kyubey scratched behind one of his ears with a hind leg. "I'll tell you a short story. Imagine a girl – a potential contractee – whose beloved mother is dying of incurable illness. I appear to the girl, offering her a single wish. What else does the girl wish for than to share one last cheesecake with her dying mother? Only later does she find that she could have wished for her mother to be cured. What happens to the girl?"

"She turns into a witch immediately," said Homura.

"Just so," said Kyubey. "Now, in Mitakihara, I mostly don't contract those of great karmic destiny. I contract those who will meet swift ends, finding themselves ultimately in your vast supply of grief seeds–"

Mami shot Kyubey in the head, and he exploded.

"You know, it always used to be me doing that," said Homura.

"I needed to do something," said Mami, her voice funny. "If we were in my apartment, I would have broken my tea set. Thrown it against a wall."

Madoka was crying into Sayaka's shoulder. Kyouko was stomping on some of Kyubey's remains. Yuma's gaze tracked between the four of them. She was smart enough to understand what was happening but young enough that her greatest concern was to see how others were reacting.

"We're just killing people, no matter what we do. No matter what we try," cried Madoka. "I wish– I wish it weren't like this. I just– I just wanted to help people–"

"We're fucking executioners, is what we are," said Kyouko. "For anybody dumb enough to fall for Kyubey's tricks – we're the ones to kill them."

"But that's how it is," Mami whispered. "It was always like this. And we can't stop what we're doing. If we stop killing witches, then the witches will kill even more."



Loop 137.

They posted new signs. "Wondering if you should become a magical girl? Scan here!"

It linked to the same thread announcing the MSY's hotline, but Madoka edited the first post. "If you aren't already a magical girl, don't become one," it said. "Once you are, you can never go back."











A/N: When writing about magical girl and witch population dynamics, I referenced this page from the Puella Magi wiki: Population dynamics - Puella Magi Wiki
 
Last edited:
Chapter 3
Loop 137.

The day after they'd formed an alliance, Homura provided Madoka and Sayaka with binders full of Class 2A homework solutions through April 30th. They didn't want to forsake their schoolwork entirely. They wanted to maintain their normal civilian lives in parallel with their nighttime work as magical girls: that is, they wanted to believe that they would live beyond Walpurgisnacht's doomsday.

Homura also had homework solutions for Mami Tomoe despite Mami being (nominally) a year older. This also came by abusing time travel. In several cycles, Mami actually completed her homework, of which she gave photocopies to Homura. Then, if Loop 137's Mami needed to finish her homework for April 21st, Homura would give Mami five different versions of the completed assignment from five previous loops, each authentically produced by another Mami Tomoe.

In principle, Madoka and Sayaka could have used the same system to inflate their grades, but neither particularly cared, and they implicitly trusted Homura's homework solutions. They got questions wrong on purpose to avoid arousing suspicion.

Kyouko and Yuma, being unenrolled in classes, were spared the trouble.

Being magical girls consumed their after-school lives. They needed time. Madoka and Sayaka both had Homura and Mami over for dinner with their parents – this was to allay suspicion when they came home late or not at all. Purportedly, they were sleeping over at Mami's apartment. All Mami and Homura had to do during those dinner visits was to act deferent and mature.

It was April 27th, and Walpurgisnacht came in three days.



Loop 137.

Homura had built a mechanism for Sayaka's benefit. The machinist cut it from an aluminum block roughly the size of a chessboard. Near a corner was a small wheel with a recess shaped and sized to match Sayaka's soul gem in the form it took after she transformed. Around the wheel wrapped the tail end of a hollowed track. The track's cross-section was just large enough to accommodate a grief seed, which could then be slid through the track by hand until it came into contact with the wheel, after which the seed would drop out the track's end and (hopefully) into some waste receptacle. Several grief seeds could be loaded onto the track and swept into rapid contact with the inset soul gem.

Homura Akemi knew how to use power tools – as her pipe bombs could attest – but this workpiece was complicated enough that she contracted a machine shop to produce it for her. She gave them a description, the dimensions of Sayaka's soul gem, and a dozen grief seeds for testing. The finished product came days later, with the cautious recommendation that it be kept well-lubricated. Homura obliged, dipping a grief seed in gun grease and swiping it back and forth through the track.

Homura explained the purpose of the device – which she spontaneously dubbed 'the seed loader' – to the others.

"So when Walpurgisnacht arrives, I'm the only one who's going to be shooting it," said Sayaka.

"You're the most magically powerful out of all of us. I've never been able to scratch Walpurgisnacht, but in the last loop–" Homura stopped. She hesitated. "Using all of the energy in your soul gem, you summoned a gun sword the size of a tanker truck, and when you shot Walpurgisnacht, you blew off its left arm. The time loops are working to make you stronger."

"What happened to me after?" said Sayaka, already knowing the answer.

"You became a witch immediately. The grief seeds sewn into your belt didn't have enough of a mana reserve to account for what you'd just spent. All of them – your soul gem and the grief seeds – reached full corruption and spawned into new witches."

"So, the time loops are working, but they're also not," said Kyouko.

Kyouko and Yuma were living with Mami full-time now. It was easier and magically cheaper than shielding an empty hotel room with illusion magic. They sat next to each other around the glass chabudai. Kyouko ate apple slices from a bowl with a dessert fork, and Yuma ate a box of pocky sticks from Kyouko's personal supply.

"The plan isn't to sacrifice Sayaka, is it?" asked Madoka.

"It's not," said Homura. "That's what the seed loader is for. We're using Sayaka as an artillery piece." Homura pointed to the recess on the seed loader's wheel. "Sayaka will transform and then put her soul gem there," then she pointed to the start of the track, "and we'll load grief seeds in the loading track there. We'll load the track until it's full, so that adding another grief seed ejects another out of the end. Anytime Sayaka uses any magic, her soul gem replenishes from the six grief seeds surrounding it. One of us will stand beside Sayaka with the seed loader and an ammo pouch of grief seeds.

"Sayaka will deliberately overdraw her soul gem to shoot Walpurgisnacht. The grief seeds touching this wheel will restore her soul gem to full brightness. Then the person managing the loader will shove another six grief seeds onto the track, ejecting six corruption-laden grief seeds for Kyubey to ingest. Then we repeat."

"Makes sense," said Sayaka.

Homura didn't hear any quavering in Sayaka's voice, nor did she hear the bombast of somebody trying too hard to seem self-confident. Sayaka simply accepted what Homura told her with a soldier's bearing, which surprised her.

Sayaka had grown up, Homura realized. Being surrounded by others to whom she bore responsibility had changed her. She knew that she had a role to play, that she didn't like that role, and that she would do it anyways because it was the right thing to do.

Homura was bizarrely proud of her, she realized. In the old loops, Sayaka was an aggravation, a useless gnat whose sole impact in the world was to suffer in ways that made Madoka hurt to watch.

The worst part was that Homura still didn't think that her old self was being uncharitable. Sayaka Miki had been a pitifully weak magical girl, which made her quixotic aspirations pathetic. Her actual capacity for great deeds would never have matched her soaring rhetoric, a fact that she never had the self-awareness to accept.

(As she thought this, Homura wondered just how deeply her experiences had embittered her. She didn't like herself like this.)

But now, Sayaka had matured. She was strong magically and temperamentally. She could control her emotions, problem-solve, and work with others to achieve a common goal. And now– Homura cared about her survival. Homura was no longer sure that saving Madoka was her only goal. Maybe she wanted to save everyone.

"Will Miki-san need to overdraw her soul gem?" asked Mami. "Could she only mostly drain it? I expect overdrawing the entire soul gem at once would be quite painful."

"If it turns out that she can't manage the pain, then we'll make that change," said Homura. "But Walpurgisnacht will target her as soon as she lands her first hit. We'll have to make every shot count."

"What happens when it does?" asked Sayaka. "You said Walpurgisnacht throws entire buildings?"

"I stop time, link hands in a chain with everybody else on the roof from which we're shooting, and we relocate by flight," said Homura.

"It sounds like I wouldn't be able to be the loader," said Madoka.

"Yeah, Madoka's not coming," said Sayaka immediately. "Sorry for stealing your line, Homura."

"No, you're right," said Homura.

"Then who will be the loader?" asked Yuma. "Me?"

Kyouko swallowed another apple slice. "Won't you be busy with healing? Or, hmm, maybe making sure that Sayaka can shoot is a bigger priority?"

"I could just do it myself," said Sayaka. "Then I won't have to coordinate with someone. I've got telekinesis, so I don't need my hands."

"That'll work," said Homura. "We can do dry runs against witch familiars to ensure the process works."



Loop 137.

With the first familiar, Sayaka used (perhaps) ninety percent of her soul gem's power. This was not painful, but she suffered physical exhaustion that only the grief seeds took away. She had summoned a gun sword the size of a school bus, the shot from which vaporized the familiar and excavated a hundred-meter hole in the labyrinth witch-stone behind it.

With the second familiar, Sayaka told Homura to reset the timeline if overdrawing her soul gem turned her into a witch. (Homura had asked the machine shop for two copies of the seed loader in case something like that happened.)

The first shot annihilated the familiar, nearly triggering the labyrinth's structural collapse. Sayaka recharged and fired again, screaming as she did so. (This was a deliberate stress test. Against Walpurgisnacht, they needed multiple shots in rapid succession.) Homura saw black lightning coruscating over Sayaka's body as she charged new grief seeds into the seed loader – but she didn't turn into a witch. They fled the collapsing labyrinth.

Kyubey – clinging to Sayaka's midsection – happily ate the discarded grief seeds.



Loop 137.

"Honestly, Homura, I think all of us should have one of these," said Mami. "If you could have that shop remake the seed loader with sling swivels so that we could wear them, maybe with one Kyubey per person for grief seed disposal, I'd be able to summon enough muskets to stop the armies of seven different nations."

Homura stared. She really hadn't expected this so close to Walpurgisnacht's arrival.

"I think– I'm not sure, Mami," said Homura. "We might need to redesign these for that. What if you forget about the grief seeds you've already loaded, and one turns into a witch while you're still wearing it–"

It was two o'clock in the morning of April 28th.



Loop 137.

"It wasn't cheap," said Homura.

Homura returned to the same machine shop, explained what she needed, and offered a hundred-thousand yen to have the parts ready in twenty-four hours.

The final parts, as delivered, were nearly the size of a grapefruit. These were just the recessed wheel ringed by a metal track with added sling swivels so the girls could wear them on the body. (Homura had also stolen a number of service rifles from the JSSDF, so they had fabric slings.) There was the hole for new grief seeds and the hole where used seeds came out.

And (as Kyubey would explain if asked), given the group's efficiency at hunting witches and their familiars – every grief seed to eject from the seed loader's mechanism used to be a person, the vast majority of which had been magical girls for only a few days.

The girls tried not to think about that too hard.

It was four o'clock in the afternoon of April 29th.



Loop 137.

It was the evening of the last day. They weren't going witch hunting: This was a day for rest, recuperation, and personal reckoning. Meteorologists were monitoring the weather patterns that would (supposedly) give rise to Walpurgisnacht's storm system, but the storm warning hadn't yet been issued. They all slept over at Mami's apartment.

Homura and Mami had taught the others how to read witch runes. They now knew their foes by name – or at least, the name they bore after their transformation – making debriefing easier after each encounter.

Homura had shoplifted GoPro cameras that they all wore while witch hunting. They would return to Mami's apartment and discuss how the battles could have gone differently. Homura asked Kyubey to set up Incubator-built 3D projectors, like in Homura's apartment, and he obliged, even procuring an adapter that would accept human microSD cards and convert from human video file formats. Analyzing the two-dimensional video footage from every camera, the Incubator projector would render a three-dimensional image of the witch's labyrinth and the girls' positions inside. Kyubey remarked that their group had been the only ones ever to ask for this equipment.

Homura usually directed the discussion. Sometimes, it was Mami. Other times, Sayaka, Kyouko, or Yuma would have questions or suggestions, and speaking would fall to them. Mami would switch off the projection when they were all done, banishing the infinite white void and restoring the coziness of her home's interior decoration and warm tea.

On the evening of the last day, Sayaka wanted the projector.

"The battle with Elsa Maria," said Sayaka. Kyubey's ears twitched, and they saw a monochromatic landscape, fully black and white.

(They'd all remarked that Kyubey was remarkably blasé about how many times they'd killed him. Kyubey pointed out that he lacked emotions, that he mostly didn't feel pain, and that there were so many of him that he was functionally immortal.)

"Maybe five minutes into the battle," said Sayaka. "There. Homura, you saw a group of Sebastians in the distance, standing on a hill. Why didn't you shoot them?"

"Maybe she didn't want to spook the witch, or she was conserving ammunition?" offered Madoka.

"I don't think so, Madoka. I want to hear Homura's answer."

The greatest sign that Sayaka had grown, Homura reflected, was that it became harder and harder to lie to her successfully. In past cycles, Homura might have used one or both of Madoka's deflections, and Sayaka might have been too self-absorbed in her hero fantasy to catch the deception. Knowledge and self-awareness made Sayaka stronger, as it had for the rest of the team.

"I was leaving them to the rest of you," said Homura truthfully. "I wanted to give you more experience with killing familiars."

"Which means that you still think we're less experienced than you are," said Sayaka.

"That belief wouldn't be unfounded, Miki-san," offered Mami.

"I know, Mami," Sayaka replied. "I know that we're fighting these witches and familiars for practice. My point is that we're not fighting like we're in a real fight. We're not fighting like how quickly we make kills makes a difference. If you have a shot as clear as the one Homura had while we fought Elsa Maria while fighting Walpurgisnacht, then you're fighting for real, and you take that shot."

Sayaka sighed. "I'm supposed to grow to be more powerful than you are. Maybe I am already. But Homura, you're not fighting like you think we'd ever do better than you."

Homura had to choose her words carefully. The most obvious response (that she'd used in the past) was, "You won't," but that was terrible on multiple levels.

Homura was the team's leader, she realized. The others truly were putting their trust in Homura's hands, and Homura was returning that trust with tactful transparency, and somehow it was working. They were a team. They were deadly. They each took Walpurgisnacht seriously and prepared themselves for its arrival. And they accepted their fate as magical girls with dignity and strength.

Was that it? Was that what Homura had been missing this whole time: the power of love?

(Homura prevented herself from rolling her eyes. And yet–)

To love someone is to help them grow. If you never stop babying a mentee, then you've failed as a mentor. To box and confine them just to preserve your rank superiority is sad.

"You're right," said Homura after a long pause. "My apologies, Miki-san."

A few seconds later, Sayaka nodded. "I know you would have fought for real against Walpurgisnacht. I know you always have. I know you have it in you."

Sayaka gestured at Kyubey, and the projection vanished, leaving behind a chabudai table set with tea.



Loop 137.

Unless Kyouko and Sayaka or Homura and Mami wanted privacy, they would all sleep on futons laid out over Mami's ground floor.

Like a sleepover, they would talk before falling into slumber.

"Do you all want to be magical girls forever?" asked Madoka.

The others met her with a swift chorus of 'no's.

"I mean, if it weren't for witches," Madoka clarified. "If witches and familiars really were just ordinary monsters who ate people, and none of them came from magical girls. What if we really were just fighting for justice and keeping people safe?"

"What about our soul gems, though?" asked Sayaka from Kyouko's futon. "What would happen if they got corrupted?"

"Let's say that it kills the magical girl, but they don't turn into a witch," said Madoka. "But they still hold your souls and all that."

"And how would our wishes turn out?" asked Kyouko.

"Let's say that's the same as now."

"Yeah, no," said Kyouko immediately.

"Do you mean that, though, Kyouko-chan?" asked Homura out of genuine curiosity. "Becoming a magical girl gave you a way to feed and care for yourself."

Kyouko was silent for a time.

"More than that, it gave me this," she said. "Shit, I don't know. Here, I almost feel– happy? I still wish my dad hadn't murdered my whole fucking family, but at least here, I'm good. I think."

"I'm happy being a magical girl," said Yuma. "I'm glad my parents are dead."

Kyouko barked with laughter.

"I knew what I was doing when I made my contract," said Sayaka. "Becoming a magical girl was just the right thing to do. It had to be me, right, Homura?"

"Yes, Miki-san," replied Homura.

"I don't know if I'll survive tomorrow," said Sayaka. "But as long as we beat Walpurgisnacht, as long as that monster doesn't touch Kyousuke and Hitomi, I'll be happy."

The next pause was unusually long.

"Mami? Homura?" asked Sayaka.

"I suspect Akemi-san's answer is the same as mine," said Mami. "We're happy being magical girls because it means we won't be alone."

Another bark of laughter from Kyouko, but a friendly one. "God, you're all fucking nerds."

"I spent more than a decade reliving this month-and-a-half," Homura began. "For nearly all of that time, I found the greatest success working alone. If I didn't do something, then nobody would. Now– Now I can just ask someone. I'm still not used to that."

"To think," Sayaka added dryly, "this all started because you wanted a way to make me less 'useless'."

"Childrearing is not just the parents," Homura replied.

"So, you all like being magical girls, because it means we're together?" asked Madoka.

"I think so, Kaname-san," said Mami.

Madoka giggled.

"But, I guess– what wouldn't you all like about being magical girls?" Madoka continued.

"All of the other magical girls who aren't as lucky as we are," said Sayaka, somewhat loudly.

Beneath the futon's sheets, Kyouko took Sayaka's hand in her own, stroking its back slowly with her thumb.



Loop 137.

The clock ticked past midnight, and it was April 30th.











A/N: "Childrearing is not just the parents" is, according to ChatGPT-4, a Japanese proverb roughly synonymous with "It takes a village to raise a child."
 
Last edited:
Chapter 4
Loop 137.

The Japan Meteorological Agency announced that Mitakihara lay directly in the path of a Violent Typhoon with wind speeds exceeding 194 kilometers per hour. Authorities called for a total evacuation of the entire city.

The speed with which the storm appeared and turned dangerous was unprecedented and record-breaking, and there was not enough time to fully evacuate Mitakihara City before its arrival.



Loop 137.

Every loop, Homura recorded the heading from which Walpurgisnacht would approach the city and the speed with which it moved, enough to project a cone of uncertainty over the Incubator's map of Mitakihara City.

Madoka evacuated with the rest of her family. Her mother's work offered a phone hotline for concierge services that couriered them to the community recreation center, which authorities had swiftly repurposed as a storm shelter. The building was constructed sturdily on a hill, and the city's crisis experts hoped that it would escape damage from storm surge even if storm winds stripped its glass windows like plastic cling-wrap.

The MSY arrayed themselves alongside the harbor, hoping to initiate contact with Walpurgisnacht as far away from the storm shelter as possible. A high carpet of rushing storm clouds ran above them like a treadmill's belt. From the water came a low fog that swallowed their feet. With the fog came familiars: a walking carnival of green elephants and pink poodle horses driven and ridden by knee-high animal trainers. Long ropes of multicolored bunting rose high into the sky as if tied off to the antenna mast of an invisible skyscraper.

The familiars passed. Kyouko stepped away from the formation to cover their six o'clock. The familiars would attack them as soon as they successfully hurt their target. Kyouko saw the high-rises behind them turn dark. They had not yet broken and risen into the sky, as Homura explained would happen when Walpurgisnacht got close enough, but they were still affected by the witch's magic.

Sayaka Miki stood at the front of the formation, her seed loader mounted to a chest rig that Homura had also stolen from the JSSDF. Her rig also bore two ammo pouches, each bearing forty-eight grief seeds. The discharge chute on the seed loader ran into another pouch on Sayaka's waist that carried a Kyubey.

Homura had a personal stash of grief seeds that she had amassed over her time loops, but she did not usually share it. They aimed to be fully self-sufficient from only the seeds they'd gathered during that loop, and they all understood that Homura needed them more than they did. If Homura ever died or turned witch, they were all truly doomed.

Starting with the most recent iteration, the MSY had collected more than two hundred grief seeds over about forty days of witch hunting – after accounting for grief seeds they'd used or given away. They would use these in battle. All of them. They each carried a seed loader and ammo pouches of grief seeds – about twenty per person.

Having made visual contact with her target, Sayaka Miki began conjuring a gun sword. Following tips that Mami and Homura had given her, she reduced the sword into a load-bearing truss and expanded the gun into the main gun of a super battleship. The actual conjuration took only a few seconds, but the others could already see the black corruption of her soul gem wicking into the grief seeds of her seed loader. Breathing heavily, Sayaka was charging another six grief seeds into the chamber of her seed loader.

(Sayaka had managed to drain almost exactly one hundred percent of the magical energy stored in her grief seed. She'd had to do this slowly to achieve that level of fine control and didn't expect that she would manage it again once Walpurgisnacht began shooting back.)

"Well, here we go," said Sayaka. She held out a grasping hand to ease her telekinesis, and the gun sword fired.

The percussive blast of the oversized gun sword's report was skull-shattering. It had a sharp metallic timbre, like the high notes of a ringing church bell. The gun sword's cannon shot cleft through time and space, and the air it shoved aside left a visible wake in the storm-blown waters of the harbor.

The shot struck Walpurgisnacht in its clockwork support base. It knocked the rotating gears askew, splintering the support rod armature that bore the laughing harlequin that comprised the witch's body.

(In the storm shelter, Madoka clutched her hands over her ears. When her parents asked her what was wrong, Madoka responded that she'd heard someone scream.)

Homura joined Kyouko, summoning a nest of machine guns. The familiars turned and charged them. From behind the machine gun emplacement, Homura shouldered and fired Panzerfausts at the charging elephants while Kyouko readied a wall of spears for any familiar that made it past.

Sayaka dismissed the gun sword and began summoning another. "That's it," she said, "come and get it."

Sayaka overdrew her soul gem. Yuma laid hands on her body, helping to heal the magical muscle breakdown. (Sayaka's power set already included magical healing and recovery, but to make use of it would deepen her magical exhaustion.) Sayaka fired this gun while screaming.

This shot struck Walpurgisnacht's 'torso,' shattering the dangling harlequin into pieces.



Loop 137.

Every single person in the shelter was clutching their ears.

"What is that?" said Madoka's mother.



Loop 137.

It's working!
reported Mami.

The laughing harlequin had plummeted into the ocean. But the clockwork base from which it dangled – that kept moving.

They could still hear the laughter, but it had changed its tone. It used to be a laugh of mockery to deride those who challenged it. But now it was sharper and higher-pitched, almost shrieking, like a forsaken soul witnessing the unfulfillment of rock-bottom expectations, like someone to whom real love was a joke by its nonexistence.

Tornadic waterspouts dipped into the harbor. More familiars marched directly up the sea wall, feet clinging horizontally to moss-slicked stone. Walpurgisnacht's broken clockwork flung itself toward them like a frisbee.

"Move!" shouted Homura, popping her buckler's crown. Time stopped.

Homura dismissed her machine guns back into hammerspace and grabbed Kyouko's hand. Kyouko grabbed Sayaka, who grabbed Yuma, and Homura grabbed Mami. They flew a few hundred meters, and Homura burned a grief seed as fuel. Carrying so many passengers like this put a heavy strain on Homura's soul gem, forcing her to admit that Mami's suggestion had been good: They all were better off with their own seed loaders.

They settled on top of a warehouse. Homura charged another grief seed into her loader, and she clicked the crown back into position–

–and Walpurgisnacht's clockwork base crashed into their previous position hard enough to leave a blast crater. The shockwave sent Homura sprawling. And Walpurgisnacht–

Homura stopped time on sheer reflex, freezing Walpurgisnacht in time perhaps five meters away from crushing her and her soul gem into limestone powder.

"So, the basic idea of using Sayaka as heavy artillery had passed the proof-of-concept stage," said the Kyubey snuggled into her waist pouch. "The problem is that it still doesn't kill Walpurgisnacht fast enough for the witch to die before you do."

Homura sighed.

"You've lost, unfortunately," Kyubey added. "If you unstop time, all of you die instantly. Relocating first would just force you to waste grief seeds."

It wasn't possible for Kyubey to unzip his bag from the inside. Homura considered leaving the Incubator there but ultimately decided to free him.

Kyubey poked his head out of the bag. "Well, I didn't expect that of you," he said. "It wasn't even necessary. I communicate by telepathy."

"I'm desperate, Incubator," said Homura.

Kyubey watched her, but as always, his expression was inscrutable.

"Walpurgisnacht has put you in a peculiar position," Kyubey continued. "You can reset the timeline, but most of the grief seeds you collected in this cycle have gone unused. The obvious thing to do would be to take the others' ammo pouches while they're frozen, which would feel like theft."

"I thought Incubators didn't 'feel' anything," said Homura.

"Incubators understand contracts and negotiation, as you're well aware," said Kyubey. "We can recognize when a party negotiates in bad faith, which almost always happens due to the party's emotions. Emotions that prevent an Incubator from negotiating fairly with others are mental illness: They prevent the Incubator from functioning in our society."

That made Homura tilt her head. "I suppose that makes sense." She cast her gaze over the warehouse rooftop. "I'll say goodbye to them before I reset."



Loop 137.

Homura took Kyouko's arm, dropping her out of the time stop. Kyouko's flying body came to a jerking stop that nearly toppled Homura, and Homura had to help her to her feet. Kyouko mostly wasn't watching her; she was staring at the violent remnants of Walpurgisnacht frozen in mid-air, meters away from killing her.

"Well, fuck," said Kyouko. "Guess you have to, huh?"

"Yes. Can I take your grief seeds with me?" Homura thought some more. "And your GoPro, and your seed loader. Keep your soul gem– I can't take that back with me–"

Kyouko nodded. "Go for it, sister." She reached into another pouch on her chest rig and handed Homura a box of pocky sticks. "I'm not one for sappy shit. See you in the next life."



Loop 137.

"Going to be another loop, then?" Mami asked sadly.

"Looks like it," said Homura.

"So, it'll be you and the next version of myself," said Mami, "and not just me?"

"I'm afraid so."

Mami was smiling despite it all. "I expected this to happen," she said. "I'm just glad we made the most of our time together."

They exchanged a long kiss.



Loop 137.

"I like you, Akemi-san," said Yuma with childish delight.

"I like you too, Yuma-chan," said Homura, kneeling to hug her. "You were a big help."



Loop 137.

"So, I wasn't good enough," said Sayaka.

"No, Sayaka. We didn't prepare well enough," said Homura. "There was nothing you could have done differently to prevent this."

"But half of not preparing well enough is not having thought things through," said Sayaka. "You'll get around to it in a later cycle because I couldn't think of it now."

"Miki-san," said Homura, indicating her buckler, "this is my hundred-and-thirty-seventh loop. I understand how you feel– how frustrated you are that it didn't end here. And I'm telling you not to blame yourself for this because I'm taking full responsibility."

"So, what, then? It's alright because we'll get it done eventually?"

"It's not alright," said Homura, "but we will get it done eventually."



Loop 138.

Homura lay in a hospital bed. Her hair roped into two long pigtails. A pair of useless thick red plastic-rimmed glasses sat on her face.

She heaved a fathomless sigh.

Now what?

Now she had to do all of that all over again. She'd have to reintroduce herself to the others. Go witch hunting again. Meet Madoka and Sayaka's parents again. Sleep over at Mami's place again. Form the MSY again. Plan for Walpurgisnacht again.

A horrible thought occurred to Homura. What if she found the others boring now? What if Mami poured out her heart for Homura, only for it to be 'more of the same' for her? What if the cooperation they'd managed in the last loop was a fluke, and they'd never work together like that ever again, all because Homura had stopped caring?

But she still loved Madoka, even after a hundred-and-thirty-eight loops. And in a sense, Madoka was even more useless than the old Sayaka: She was an infant to be kept from drowning itself in pails of water, and even now, during combat, she was purely a bystander.

Aw, crap, now she had to start meditating on what true love meant to her.

Homura heaved another equally dramatic sigh.

Why couldn't I get along with the others before my hundredth time loop?

Because she was alone in their presence, she reflected. They were truly ignorant of so many things and reacted with hostility when she tried to enlighten them. She had genuinely tried to help them, and they rejected her help as lunacy. They didn't respect her, and so she didn't respect them.

In fact–

Wasn't Madoka the only one who had reacted productively after learning that magical girls became witches? During Loop 2, she managed to kill Mami to keep her from hurting Homura. On that loop, Madoka and Homura had killed Walpurgisnacht together – just the two of them – though both had exhausted their soul gems.

(How was Madoka already that powerful? Homura wondered. Did the loops build her up that quickly?)

(And then she remembered: In Loop 0, before Homura had contracted, Mami and Madoka working together had slain Walpurgisnacht by themselves.)

(Madoka was the common thread. Her archer's bow and her fractal arrows slew witch and familiar with unmatched deftness. Walpurgisnacht was as helpless before her barrage of arrows as was the typical familiar before Homura's machine guns; neither Mami nor Homura had even contributed much. The weight of Madoka's karmic destiny must have been gargantuan even before their magnification by Homura's time loops. Would she have grown up to be a politician?)

Homura loved Madoka because–

–because Madoka was actually remarkably capable. And deeply principled, and deeply kind. And Homura had seen those things, and all of them had blessed her.

And the same was true of the others after Homura truly got to know them. But it took so much effort to make them show the deep principles and deep kindness they already held – to create the environment and atmosphere where others would respect that openness. It would have been so easy for Homura to fall back on casual cruelty – spoken words akin to telling Sayaka that she would never surpass Homura – and everyone would realize that Homura wasn't to be trusted.

No, Homura wouldn't be bored with them. Homura wouldn't write them off. Homura had found reliable friends and she would stick with them. She'd found a way to make them understand the truth, and once they knew, they were willing to help her.

(Homura had directly asked Kyubey whether she could bring the others' soul gems back in time, and he had given her a hard no. Her time loops could only drag back a single person. Since the others' soul gems were literally their true, soul-bearing bodies, bringing one back would count as an extra person, which her buckler couldn't manage.)

Soon (today), she'd get out of the hospital. Soon (in the next couple of days), she'd meet Mami, Sayaka, and Madoka, and (after disposing of Oriko Mikuni and Kirika Kure) Yuma. And some days after that, she'd meet Kyouko. Every time, it would be a meeting between old friends. And every time (Homura double-checked hammerspace for the GoPro cameras), Homura would bring the start of their new selves.



Loop 138.

"What are problems in the world that you wish you could help solve as magical girls, but can't?" asked Madoka from her futon on Mami's floor.



Loop 138.

Mami and Sayaka had conjured titanic guns and aimed them at Walpurgisnacht's clockwork base. Kyouko had summoned a monstrous fire lance the length of a small warship. Yuma was ready to lay hands; Homura had ringed them with machine guns.

Correcting an obvious oversight, Mami linked everyone's ankles with spooling lengths of ribbon. If Homura stopped time, it would stop for all of them.

(Though Homura still couldn't pause time during their initial bombardment. The cost of maintaining the time stop was proportional to the magic being used by the time stop's occupants. Mami, Sayaka, and Kyouko were all using several times the total mana capacity of their soul gems simultaneously, an expenditure that would make Homura immediately turn witch.)

Magical girls had sharper reflexes and shorter reaction times than baseline humans. Sayaka and Mami would fire first, aiming to cleave the clockwork into thirds. Kyouko would fire her lance and magically steer it into the largest piece of its body they could see. They hoped to stagger Walpurgisnacht long enough to fire at least three salvos.



Loop 139.

–for long enough to fire at least four salvos.



Loop 140.

–five salvos.



Loop 179.

It took too long to single-load grief seeds into the seed loaders. How could they make that faster?

Grief seeds were small and spherical with decorative 'horns' poking out a full diameter's length along their polar axes. Consultation with Kyubey and physical tests found that the seeds still worked if you ground off the horns with a Dremel. That turned the grief seed into a sphere. (Kyubey and physical tests also confirmed that shattering a grief seed did nothing except disperse harmless magical energy.)

What was the fastest way to load grief seeds into a mechanism that would brush them past a soul gem?

Sayaka suggested that they copy the design of 'paintball markers.'

They would wear 'feed pouches' over their chests like baldrics stuffed with grief seeds. At the base of the pouch lay an electrically motorized seed loader. Soft paddles reached up into the feed pouch from the seed loader, scooping grief seeds towards the soul gem. A motorized agitator ensured that each paddle caught a single grief seed; there would be no gaps or double feeds to the soul gem. The seed loader still ejected into a 'Kyubey pouch' to keep from littering Mitakihara with new potential witches.

Having contracted nearly every major machine shop in Mitakihara in some loop or another just to make the old seed loaders, Homura had drawn up a shortlist of the most reliable. But the parts she had been ordering were now complicated enough that Homura had to spend weeks engineering them herself with computer-assisted design software, and then several more days putting them together after delivery. That was fine; the others had enough veterancy to witch hunt without her presence, and Homura knew her way around a soldering iron.

Mami successfully taught Homura to conjure a touch-hole fired, muzzle-loading rifled cannon. For all of her magical master of her stolen firearms' manuals of arms, Homura hadn't had the hylekinetic power to summon her own weapons ex nihilo. The weapon was primitive when viewed through the lens of real military history. Still, its crude simplicity made it magically cheap – just enough for Homura to manage and then imbue with her own magical power.

They managed to fire ten salvos, burning through fifty grief seeds apiece. After Walpurgisnacht closed the distance, Homura had to abandon her conjurations, which she couldn't produce or carry along quickly enough for them to be combat effective. Sayaka's full responsibility was to deal with the broken remnants of Walpurgisnacht – the central cog of its clockwork base and the splintered wooden shaft of its rod armature. They had given her two allotments of fifty grief seeds for this battle, meaning that this time loop ran on a grief seed deficit. They suspected that it might make a difference – that this time, Walpurgisnacht would fall.

Homura kept seeing blue light. Whenever she looked skyward, she saw the flash of an azure cutlass. Each slash rent deep gouges in Walpurgisnacht's remnant body. Every blow brought new screams.



Loop 179.

Madoka's parents clutched Tatsuya close. They'd reasoned that the sound of a typhoon roaring between skyscrapers just sounded uncannily like screaming, but it was clear that the noise disturbed them.

Madoka's mother poked her, snapping Madoka out of a trance.

"I'm proud of you, Madoka," she said. "Tatsuya's scared, so he's watching you, and he sees that his big sis isn't."

Madoka nodded, unsure how to reply except with the banal reassurance that, "I know we'll get through this."

The next wave of screams was even louder.

"I really think we will," said Madoka, smiling.



Loop 179.

While Sayaka battled Walpurgisnacht, the others battled its familiars.

They weren't just fortifying themselves on a rooftop and letting the familiars come to them. They did kill those that came close, but their goal was to kill any familiar that might hurt or distract Sayaka. Wherever Sayaka touched the ground, Yuma, Mami, and Kyouko were there. Yuma laid hands while Mami and Kyouko blasted and carved. Homura stood on higher ground, perforating Walpurgisnacht's menagerie before they could reach the fight.

Mami ribbon-linked their ankles, being careful to spool out and reel in slack so as not to trip her allies. Mami and the others would signal Homura telepathically and then her buckler would tick into a deep freeze. Sayaka eschewed the ribbon link: She used too much magic for Homura to handle the strain, and she was fast enough to dodge Walpurgisnacht without assistance.

I think I have her, Sayaka said telepathically. Homura, move!

Without thinking, Homura threw herself off the rooftop. Walpurgisnacht crashed into the concrete behind her.

Homura righted herself mid-fall, aiming for the next rooftop over. She felt the telepathic screech and crackle of an overdrawn soul gem. Looking up–

–a cutlass blade, a razor to unvein a skyscraper, slashing down like the paper guillotine of God–

–a building's edifice being swallowed like a bundle of facial tissue down a toilet–

–a monsoon of crumbled masonry and broken glass fell, and then it was quiet.

And then the remaining familiars turned and fled.

Sayaka? Homura asked.

Still here.

Yuma, Mami, Kyouko?

All accounted for
, said Mami.

They took a minute to regroup. Homura looked around.

The city lay in ruins, like slashed and burnt jungle. In every skyscraper that Walpurgisnacht lifted into the sky lay hundreds, or thousands, dead. Steel frames lay naked and exposed, like human bones at an archaeological dig site.

But it wasn't the entire city. Many spires still stood. The community recreation center's storm shelter lay untouched.

Madoka was still alive.

All of them were still alive.

They'd done it.

They'd killed Walpurgisnacht.











A/N: I tweaked this chapter in response to reader feedback saying that (1) Homura should be stopping time so that Sayaka (and the others working 'magical artillery') could have been shooting and recharging from inside a time stop, and (2) Mami should be linking the ankles of all her teammates so that they could all time stop at the same time.

I fixed (2) by having Mami use that strategy. I addressed by (1) by specifying that magic used within the time stop inflicts a proportional mana cost on the time magician maintaining the time stop.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 5
A/N: Puella Magi Madoka Magica: A Different Story revealed that Kyouko possessed illusion magic, including the ability to make doubles of herself, but that she lost that power 'subconsciously' after the death of her family.











Loop 179.

The ruse by which Sayaka had separated from her parents was to be at Mami's house when the evacuation order came. From that point, there was not enough time to reach the recreation center; Sayaka would 'have to' shelter in place with Mami and the others. Kyubey had, of his own volition, erected magical barriers to protect all of their homes, and had pulled strings to maneuver Sayaka's parents out of the line of fire.

This surprised Homura and the rest. Surely, the Incubator would want their homes razed and their loved ones dead because that would push them closer to becoming witches? Not so, said Kyubey, at least in this case: The Incubators had allied with Homura – and the rest of the MSY, by extension – and were providing help in good faith.

Then, why had the Incubators allied with her? Homura asked. She'd never seen Kyubey act this way. Was it just because Homura's time looping allowed the Incubators to 'double-count' witches born during the new timeline?

Yes, said Kyubey, but not only that. (He pointed out, somewhat crossly, that Mami had shot him the last time they'd discussed this, which kept him from finishing his explanation.) Witches and their familiars were akin to an invasive species that preyed upon regular humans. Incubators had to manage witch populations in their assigned sectors to keep human populations viable, which meant carefully manipulating local magical girl populations as a form of biological control. Relationships between an Incubator and their contractees were usually long-running: The Incubator needed the contractee principally to clean up the witches and familiars left over by the magical girls who preceded them.

Since the formation of the Mahou Shoujo Yunion, Kyubey found this unnecessary, at least in Mitakihara. Rather than poring over ecological models, he could simply contract as many 'instant-witches' as possible and trust the MSY to catch and kill all of them before they killed anybody besides their parents. Mitakihara City went from three to four witch transformations per week to eight or nine transformations per day, even before the double counting from Homura's time loops. Kyubey seemed to shiver with delight as he explained this, which Homura found disturbing.

"You are a valued partner to us, Akemi-san," Kyubey had said.



Loop 179.

Walpurgisnacht
was dead.

Homura, Sayaka, Mami, Kyouko, Yuma, and Madoka drank tea around the chabudai table in Mami's apartment. Cell service had been restored, and Madoka and Sayaka sent periodic group selfies to their parents to reassure them that they were still alive and unharmed.

They had technically saved the day, but Walpurgisnacht had still become one of the worst 'natural' disasters in Japanese history. The damage that the storm had caused, toppling skyscrapers and plunging bridges down onto the highways below, staggered analysts. Several tens of thousands of people were likely dead. Television reports struck an optimistic tone, but it was clear that search and rescue efforts would take a long time.

Sayaka pointed out that, being magical girls, they could sense the presence of other magical girls through rubble. They could sweep the city. Emergency services placed a low priority on searching, say, the upper fifty floors of a hundred-story skyscraper that had toppled to the street below, but that was precisely the kind of physical trauma that a magical girl could survive.

Madoka voiced concern that those buildings might collapse on them while they were still inside, and it wouldn't be possible to excavate a path to rescue their rescuers.

All assembled grudgingly conceded the point. They would not mount their own search and rescue efforts. They wouldn't beat Walpurgisnacht again on Loop 180 without cutting even deeper into Homura's personal grief seed supply, so they would not take unnecessary risks. They had all survived, and they wanted to keep it that way.

That shouldn't dishearten them, Madoka added, fingers tapping her phone's touchscreen. They were doing their best, and in the future, they would find ways to do better.

Homura's phone chimed. She drew her phone and unlocked it, seeing four new messages trickle in from Madoka. They read:

You relived the same month and a half almost 200 times just to protect me and you finally succeeded

I can't even begin to say how thankful I am

That experience hardened you but I know you well enough to know just how much you cared

You truly are my very best friend


Homura started crying.

"Is everything alright, Homura-san?" asked Mami.

"It's fine," Homura spluttered. "Kaname-san sent me a heartfelt note, and I'm crying."

"I'm doing one for each of you!" Madoka added, still tapping. Mami's phone chimed.



To: Mami Tomoe
From: Madoka Kaname

react to this like it's another heartfelt note so that Homura and Kyubey don't notice anything

I'm going to become a magical girl and I know what I'm going to wish for

to erase all witches before they are born. every witch in the universe, past and present and future, with my own hands

let the others know for me? ♥️




Loop 179.

"Oh my goodness," said Mami in a funny voice. She wasn't sure how to act 'normal' (though – she realized – she could play off her reaction as the messages moving her deeply), so she covered her mouth with a hand, opening telepathic links with Sayaka, Kyouko, and Yuma. "Thank you so much, Kaname-san."



Loop 179.

(Madoka didn't know whether Kyubey could refuse to grant a wish, but since Kyubey and Homura were 'allies,' Kyubey might notify Homura immediately that Madoka was about to form a contract, and Madoka knew how Homura would react.)



Loop 179.

"I'm sorry, I need to excuse myself," said Homura.

"Take as long as you need, Homura-chan!" said Madoka, waving.

Mami Tomoe had no idea what she should do.

One of her closest friends just revealed that she wanted to become God and had the means to do so.

I mean, I did tell her to think long and hard about what to wish for, Mami thought, with a mental chuckle that sounded like lead-ironed anxiety.

Mami had seen the empowered Sayaka battling Walpurgisnacht. That was the result of about eighty loops. And Madoka had been boosted by more than twice as many loops as Sayaka. And she had more karmic destiny to start with. Madoka had managed to slay Walpurgisnacht on her first attempt, before Homura even started her time loops.

"Kaname-san," said Mami (out loud because Madoka lacked telepathy), "Are you sure? You'd be taking on so much responsibility–"

"It would erase Walpurgisnacht before it ever existed, and last night would never have happened," said Sayaka. "None of those people had to die; with this, they wouldn't. I'm all for it."

"You'd be rewriting all of human history, wouldn't you?" said Kyouko. "Would we even still exist in the new universe you create?"

"And it's only for magical girls, right?" asked Yuma. "Ordinary girls with bad parents still get hurt."

"It's alright to be worried," said Madoka. "This is actually just the first version of my wish from several weeks ago. The one I've settled on just now–"



Loop 179.

Homura had pressed her forehead against a bent streetlamp to support her while she cried.

They'd won. They'd finally won. The question of how to keep Madoka safe and uncontracted and all of the uncountable prerequisites needed for that goal – she didn't have to mind them anymore. Homura was free.

(The sidewalk was damp, and the air was heavy with humidity. The streetlights were on – thanks to some loosely prosocial skullduggery on Kyubey's part.)

But what about the witch system? What about the neverending Incubator harvest of humankind? She had once asked Kyubey, and he'd told her that Incubators had coexisted with mankind since before written language, that Incubators had shaped humanity's growth to its own ends.

What had the Incubators envisioned? Agricultural, industrial, and digital revolution. They wanted humans to be so numerous that they could withstand witch predation by their sheer weight of numbers. They wanted humans to be disaffected, to be unhappy with their own lives, and to be disconnected from the fruits of their own labor so that they might forsake all they knew to become a magical girl. And they wanted humans to be disconnected, to weaken the support systems that might prevent a magical girl from becoming a witch.

Homura didn't care–

(–wait, really?)

Homura didn't care. Madoka was everything, and everything was Madoka. And then, it was Madoka, Mami, and the rest. To care for them was already so challenging to her sense of control – keeping each of them alive, healthy, and motivated took so much energy. For her to care about anything else would topple her, like a shoe rack laden with barbells. As long as her beloveds were safe, the world could burn, and she would be happy.

There is a limit to everybody's caring.

Homura felt a presence just behind her.

"As a courtesy to an ally, I'm letting you know," said Kyubey, "that Madoka is just now forming a contract with me–"



Loop 179.

One moment, Madoka was speaking her wish to the Kyubey in front of her.

The next moment, that Kyubey had been shot nine times, and Madoka's hands were being cuffed behind her back. The space around them had frozen into unnatural stillness.

"Homura-chan–" was all she could manage before Homura garroted a cleave gag between Madoka's open lips.

"I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry," said Homura.

Homura finished shackling Madoka's legs and lifted her in a bridal carry–



Loop 179.

One moment, Madoka was saying, "–that I had the power to bring or to banish anything–"

And the next, she had vanished. Bullet holes pockmarked the Kyubey to whom she'd been speaking, and the front door was burst wide open.

"Dammit, Homura," growled Kyouko, as they all transformed.



Loop 179.

Any magical girl's soul gem gave them the power to track other magical girls in the vicinity – not just witches or familiars. Homura needed to get out of tracking range, as far away from Mami's apartment as possible.

And do what?

Homura didn't have an answer to that.

Kyubey is allied to the entire MSY for all practical purposes. He'll help them track you.

Homura gritted her teeth.

What will you even say to them when they find you?

Homura didn't know.

(And Homura also didn't know why the others were letting Madoka contract. What kind of wish had Madoka chosen?)

She kicked off of shallow rooftops, using her power of flight to buoy her just long enough to reach the next roof. Wherever possible, Homura kept her time stop active while moving.

Madoka was trying to say something to her. Homura considered removing her gag, but she was afraid that the moment she did, a Kyubey would appear, and Madoka would shout out her entire wish in under a second before Homura could stop her.

Kyubey did appear when Homura alighted onto the roof of a department store, leaping precisely onto and then digging his paws into Homura's shoulder.

"The others are chasing you," said Kyubey.

"They won't catch me," Homura responded. "I'm moving unpredictably, and I'm moving faster than they are."

Every time Homura triggered a time stop, she would pick a random direction from within the hundred and eighty degrees in front of her before she started moving. To stay right behind her, any pursuers would have to guess the exact turns and course headings that Homura had taken – all that in addition to keeping pace with her, since her time stop let her move faster.

"Are you helping them track me?"

"Not me personally, no," answered Kyubey.

"Good." She would have found a way to dump him if he were.

"Don't you want to know what Madoka was going to wish for?" Kyubey asked. "It changed the others' minds. Perhaps it would change yours?"

"It's a wish that benefits you," said Homura, "That is your nature, is it not?"

"Yes," Kyubey admitted. "but Kaname-san formulated the wish that way of her own volition. Literally, everyone would stand to benefit."

"Mmhmm," said Madoka around the cleave gag.

"I'm communicating with her telepathically: Madoka Kaname is promising not to contract with me until you give verbal consent," said Kyubey. "Would you be willing to remove her gag?"

Homura stopped. (The sky above was gray, but also still.)

"No," Homura felt herself say.

"Hmm?" said Madoka.

"Why, Akemi-san?" asked Kyubey.

Homura leapt once more.

"Is it because you know that it would take you one step closer to Madoka making a contract," said Kyubey. "And beyond keeping Madoka alive, preventing her from contracting has been your life's greatest goal for over twenty subjective years."

Homura tried to ignore him. Dislodging him from her shoulder would take a free hand; she'd have to set down Madoka first.

"Every wish is born from a contractee's innermost desires," said Kyubey. "Do you doubt Madoka's that strongly?"

"Innermost desires?" Homura spat. "Like passing math class for the current semester?"

"Madoka is no fool, Akemi-san," said Kyubey.

"Mmhmm," said Madoka.

"What harm is there in knowing, Akemi-san?"

"I don't know," Homura conceded. "But you've been my adversary for so many loops that I can't help believing there's something. I don't trust you, Incubator."

"I can see that you're not willing to budge on this point," said Kyubey. "I had hoped that you would first hear Kaname-san's wish from her own lips, but instead, they will come from mine.

"The first five words of her wish are," Kyubey began, "'I wish I were God.'"



Loop 179.

The rest of the MSY gave pursuit. Kyubey had told Homura the truth: He wasn't helping the others to track Homura. When Homura left soul gem scanning range, the MSY changed tacks. Homura had forgotten in her haste that Madoka still had her smartphone, with which the larger group could track their real locations in real-time via social media.

Madoka and Sayaka, being more 'tech-savvy,' had configured location tracking for the larger group as soon as they formed the MSY.

If they hadn't, then Kyubey would have navigated for them, though he would have admitted that to Homura. He, too, stood to benefit massively from the latest iteration of Madoka's wish, as nearly anybody would from being on a first-name basis with God.

They brainstormed telepathically while moving. Mami quickly devised a way to speed their travel with her ribbons, and Kyouko rediscovered a power that she'd lost with the deaths of her old family.

Her new family gave Kyouko Sakura power over illusions.



Loop 179.

"I'll act as her interpreter since you won't remove her gag," said Kyubey.

Homura was in the process of shackling Madoka to a stairway enclosure on the roof of an eight-story building, the chains passing through and around a set of heavy pipes.

Madoka was remarkably nonchalant, offering no resistance and even holding up her arms so that Homura could more easily reach them with the shackles. She hummed reassurances to Homura through the cleave gag.

("Christ, what is wrong with me," muttered Homura.)

"The whole wish is this: I wish I were God, that I had the infinite power to bring or to banish anything into or from existence by my own hands, including witches and entropy and human suffering, all with my friends by my side," said Kyubey-as-Madoka.

(Homura carried JSDF rations in her hammerspace. That meant that she could feed Madoka, but at some point, she would need to use the bathroom, and Homura wasn't sure if she'd be able to find a functioning toilet–)

"Are you afraid of the wish? Or are you afraid of not seeing me again?"

"Both," said Homura, her voice quavering. "I'm scared of both."

"I promise that you'll see me," said Kyubey-as-Madoka. "I promise we'll be together."

"But what about everyone else?" Homura gasped. "How will you have time?"

"Time will mean nothing to her," answered Kyubey. "She will be everywhere, always."

Homura sat with her back to the stair enclosure, hugging her knees to her chest.

"I know you feel like all your sacrifice has been for nothing. I promise you that it wasn't. This is the best possible ending for all of us. This is a happy ending."

Homura didn't reply. She buried her forehead in her knees.

"As a courtesy to an ally," said Kyubey, speaking for himself, "I'm letting you know: I've now given your location to the rest of the MSY, and let them know that you've stopped." Kyubey paused. "Although that makes little difference: They've been tracking Madoka's phone this whole time."

Homura cursed her own stupidity.

"You did move quickly," said Kyubey. "It would take an hour for them to reach you at regular magical airspeed."

This was probably, somehow, a lie of omission.

Kyubey's ears twitched. "From Madoka: Is this where you plan to make your last stand?"

Homura didn't answer.

"Are you trying to kill them? Do you want them to try to kill you?" Kyubey-as-Madoka continued.

Homura didn't answer.

"Homura-chan, don't!"

Homura sighed.

Reaching into hammerspace, she laid out her weapons. Dozens of Minimis on high-mounted tripods, aiming skyward.

Next, Homura popped a quartet of road flares, one for each rooftop corner. Come and get me.

Then Homura summoned an HK416 rifle and shot Kyubey several times.

Then, she went over to Madoka and removed her gag, a ropy sling of saliva stringing away from Madoka's mouth. Homura wiped it away with her sleeve.

"Why didn't you make this wish earlier?" asked Homura. "Before Walpurgisnacht even arrived?"

"Because Kyubey would have told you what I was wishing for. I knew that you would try to stop me," said Madoka, "If you saw me try to make that wish even once, you would try to prevent it on every future loop. You might have stopped the wish just by resetting the timeline."

"So that's why? You needed to wait until we finally beat Walpurgisnacht so I wouldn't reset the timeline?"

"Not just that," said Madoka, smiling apologetically. "I needed to wait till then – because only then would the others be strong enough to defeat you."

It started to rain softly.

"Please don't do this, Homura-chan," said Madoka.

What else could Homura do?

To reset the timeline was an option. She could spend several loops farming grief seeds, beat Walpurgisnacht again, and then kidnap Madoka to a locked basement with air ducts too small for Kyubey to crawl through. But that would make Madoka even more unhappy than contracting now. That was a failure state by itself. And the others would never stop searching for her, and might never forgive her for breaking their fellowship, and Homura would be alone again.

Homura heard a sound like a flag flapping in fast winds and turned to face it.

She saw silken yellow ribbons slicing through the air. Some lashed around streetlamps; others rolled into foot-like coils that tread against the pavement. Each ribbon sprung out spider-like from a tight-knit center: a cluster of hand- and foot-holds that bore the rest of the MSY: Mami, Kyouko, Sayaka, and Yuma, plus one Kyubey. The vehicle came to a fluid, bouncing halt that left Mami and the others a meter above Homura's eyeline.

So much for regular airspeed.

"Akemi-san," said Mami, "let Madoka go."

"No," said Homura, her voice funny.

(Suicide by cop? thought Homura, as though her body weren't her own. Is that really my plan?)

Sayaka leaped from the ribbon carriage onto the roof. Some of the Minimis moved to track her. "If you want a fight, you haven't thought this through, Homura. You know that Madoka might get hurt."

"We'll all be careful," Homura responded.

(If I open fire on them with the Minimis, she thought, then stray rounds will probably shatter their soul gems. I could kill them all.)

"If we're really fighting, that's not good enough to keep her safe, and you know it," said Kyouko. Mami, Kyouko, and Yuma all dismounted. "You're not going to run away. All the action will be right here."

Homura didn't know what to do.

"There will be no battle," said Homura. "All I have to do is stop time to shatter all your soul gems at once." Homura press-checked her HK416. "That would have been harder had you kept your distance, but you're all in front of me."

"Would you?" asked Yuma. "Would you do that, Homura-chan?"

Would Homura 'save' Madoka by killing all their closest friends?

"I just don't want Madoka to contract," said Homura. "That's it. That's all I ask."

"We can't do that, Homura," said Mami. She held out her left hand, reaching to take Homura's rifle. "Please, Akemi-san."

Homura stopped time as Mami took a step towards her.

"I've been alone before," said Homura.

Leaning into her rifle's stock and peering through her optic, she shot Mami in the head, Sayaka in the stomach, Kyouko in the upper chest, and Yuma in the neck, firing three rounds apiece to ensure each soul gem was shattered. Five rounds for the Kyubey still on the ribbon carriage. With each shot, the rifle thrummed in her hands – comfortable to shoulder, heavy and stable enough not to muzzle climb.

Homura lowered the muzzle, her breath wavering and unsteady.

What have I done?

Dead. They were all dead.

(Sayaka had parents.)

Just herself and Madoka left.

(I'll be kidnapping her everywhere I go.)

But Walpurgisnacht was gone, at least?

The HK416 had dropped to Homura's side.

(This was it. This would be her life now.)

No tears. Homura felt a buzzing sensation from the top of her scalp to the balls of her feet.



Loop 179.

But when Homura dropped the time stop–

–the bodies she'd shot were deflating, like blow-up dolls, air hissing from tripled pinpricks in thin clothlike plastic. Homura stared in bewildered amazement until–

–one pair of hands from behind threw a bag over Homura's head–

–two pairs of hands seized both of Homura's arms, the one on the right side ripping the HK416 from her grip–

–the one on the left jamming fingers into Homura's buckler and spraying the space inside with ribbons like foaming rubber–

They kicked out Homura's legs from underneath her and took her backward to the ground, her bag-wrapped head striking the rooftop hard enough to give an ordinary person a concussion.

"No, dammit, no!" Homura cried.

"I'm sorry, Homura-chan," said Madoka from behind her, "but I have to make my wish now. I promise you, everything you've done for us has prepared us for this. I'll be with you soon, okay?"

"Madoka!" Homura screamed.

The light emitted by Madoka's wish shone through the bag's weaving as she turned to an unseen Incubator and uttered the words:

"I wish I were God–"

Those words and several others, and Madoka's wish came true.











A/N: A musical inspiration for this fic is the song "See the Day" by The Altogether.
 
Last edited:
Epilogue
March 16th.

Homura lay in a hospital bed. Her hip-length hair lay strewn over the bed beneath her. The curtains beside the neighboring picture window were wide open, filling the room with polished sunlight. What did she see? Bags, booklets, admissions paperwork–

–and Madoka Kaname, dressed in her school uniform, sitting on a chair at her bedside, hands clasped penitently in her lap.

"Good morning, Homura-chan," said Madoka. "Are you feeling alright?"

"I am fine," said Homura. She sat upright, slowly. "It's done, then?"

Madoka nodded. "I'm afraid so, Homura-chan."

"Where are the others?"

Madoka waved a hand, and an image appeared before them. They saw a large waiting room filled with rows of plastic chairs, naturally lit, with large televisions showing the queue's progress. "Kyouko and her family are visiting a municipal family registry to finalize Yuma's adoption," said Madoka. "Kyouko now remembers that much of her father's congregation chose to stay after his excommunication, paying enough during collection for the family to support themselves. Yuma now remembers having gone through Child Protective Services and being placed with Kyouko's family."

She waved her hand again, and the image changed. "Sayaka and Mami are both at school."

Homura noted that there was a second Madoka in the image of their shared classroom.

"After school gets out," said the first Madoka, "Sayaka and I will visit Kyousuke at the hospital, but instead of buying music, we'll go to a candy shop and buy candies that can be unwrapped with one hand.

"As for Mami, she and her parents will try to cook daifuku mochi once they get home."

Homura raised her eyebrows. "That means– None of us have contracted in this timeline?"

"That's right," said Madoka.

Homura narrowed her eyes. "We're still living with Kyubey, aren't we?"

"We can talk to him if we want to, but I took control of the witch system away from the Incubators. Any magical girl who forms a contract does so with me."

Now Homura was frowning. "And they just accepted that?"

Madoka glanced at the ceiling, rubbing the back of her neck. "In exchange, I help them to, ah, de-age stars? They thought it was a very good trade."

"And witches?"

"No magical girl who runs out of magic or falls into despair turns into a witch. I take their grief and their suffering into myself. They die peacefully."

Homura leaned back against the headboard.

"And you're okay with this?" said Homura, with a note of pleading.

"Yes, Homura-chan," said Madoka. For the very first time in as long as Homura had known her, Madoka sounded exasperated. "Believe me, I know exactly how hard you fought to save me. But this contract was actually good for me. I'll never turn into a witch. I've already destroyed the witch I would have become before it could ever have existed. I live everywhere in the universe, and a part of me still lives on Earth. I can still talk to you face-to-face. It's exactly as if I'm my normal, uncontracted self, except that I can be in several places at once, and I'm also a living god."

"But I failed you–"

"Homura-chan," Madoka said hurriedly, clutching Homura by the lapels and then shaking her, "you're being silly! Stop it! Homura, we won! We can fix literally every problem on Earth now, and none of it would have been possible without you!"

"But Madoka–"

"Stop! Stop! Stop it!" Madoka shouted. "I found a safe way to contract with Kyubey that means I'll never have to worry about becoming a witch ever again! I'll never have to worry about bad things happening to me or my friends! I'll never have to worry about dying! Nothing can hurt me! Homura, I'm God!"

Madoka let go, and Homura slumped back against the headboard.

"I'm sorry, Homura, it's just–" Madoka sighed. "All of this, and you still kidnapped me at gunpoint and then tried to kill all our closest friends. Looking back at older timelines, I recognize that you always did that for a reason – because contracting with Kyubey would doom me – but you didn't have that reason here. That's why I'm frustrated with you."

"What do the others think?" asked Homura.

"The same way I do, mostly," Madoka said. "You told them what you've been through at the start of each loop. They'd all forgive you if you asked."

Homura sighed.

Frankly, it was obvious that Homura's time loops had skewed her judgments of right and wrong, and Homura knew that. Living with Madoka's absolute safety as her sole purpose for being – what would happen if Homura were to shoot someone was not, to her, an intrusive thought, but a routine one.

"I'm sorry for deceiving you," said Madoka. "I wanted to do something to deserve how hard you fought for me. I just couldn't do it where you could see."

Homura laid back down, staring at the ceiling, trying to put words to what she felt. She felt that she'd lost her sense of agency, that she was a small boat at the mercy of river rapids, that she was an autopilot drone executing orders whose issuance she no longer remembered.

She'd been unmoored for so long.

Now, she finally had space to ground herself and find her footing.

Homura had betrayed the entire MSY, kidnapping one of them and trying to murder the rest. She had to admit they were being quite generous with her, far more than a layperson would be.

And what had Homura wished for? She'd wanted to redo her first meeting with Madoka, but instead of Madoka protecting her, she would be powerful enough to protect Madoka. The wish came true: Homura had become that powerful, and it was enough for her and the others to win their most decisive victory. Her wish had been granted.

Homura rubbed her eyes for a long time. She sighed deeply, feeling something give in the mattress beneath her. She felt a crackling sensation in her psyche.

"I forgive you," said Homura. "And I'm sorry for how I reacted to your wish."

"I forgive you," said Madoka.

They didn't hug – Madoka sensed that Homura was lying down to steady herself. Madoka considered taking Homura's hand but thought better of it.

Homura rolled her head to the side, reestablishing eye contact.

"Then what?" she asked. "You're God. How's that gone so far?"

"It's been less dramatic than I expected," said Madoka. "Kyubey told me that erasing witches would mean restructuring the universe, and he was right. We still need magical girls to battle 'wraiths' who are born from human grief and drop small grief cubes when they die."

"Is that the most you can do?"

"No," said Madoka, shaking her head vigorously. "No, no, no. I could sort humanity into 'good' and 'evil' and kill everyone in the 'evil' camp with a thought."

"But you're not doing that," said Homura, "because it would plunge the entire planet into chaos."

"Exactly," said Madoka. "Besides, I don't think the best possible Earth works only because of me or the people I kill. On the best possible Earth, humans solve human problems. I think I'll appear before people with great karmic destinies and help them fix whatever's wrong with society. Academics, organizers, politicians, and so on. I might even contract them, regardless of gender."

"So, mahou shoujo and mahou shounen, too?"

"Most likely. It will be their wishes that create God's paradise, here and everywhere else."

Homura was silent for a moment.

"Would that include me?" Homura asked.

"Only if you want." Madoka grinned. "The Mahou Shoujo Yunion needs its founders."

Homura sat up and swung her legs out to the side of the bed.

Homura asked, "What wish of mine would most please you?"
 
Back
Top