SAPR: Volume 2

Chapter 80 - The Tower
The Tower​


Twilight had broken through the encryption moments before the shooting started.

She wished that she could take more credit for that, but the truth was that, without the computing power of the entire CCT at her disposal, she would never have been able to brute force her way through the security on the email that had outed Blake's past to Beacon and the world. Still, it had been her decryption programme, and it was her trace programme that started running immediately once the encryption was broken.

"Yes!" Twilight yelled, barely resisting the urge to leap out of her seat as a map of Remnant appeared on the monitor in front of her, and a blue trace-line began to depict for her the progress of that email backwards to its point of origin.

Whoever sent it was good. It wasn't just the encryption that was protecting their identity; it was the sheer number of places the mail bounced between. A less sophisticated trace might have been foxed by it. The passage was traced in reverse: it had been sent to every Beacon student and the VPD from the CCT here in Vale, the very tower in which Twilight sat; it had been sent to that tower from the Mistral CCT, and to there from Atlas, then back to Mistral, then Atlas again, then Vacuo, then back to Vale, bouncing off a few accounts in Vale that Twilight was 95% certain were bots or dummies, then Atlas, Mistral, more dummy accounts, Vale-

And that was when Twilight heard the shooting echoing up from below her.

Twilight was not a soldier by temperament or trade, but she had lived in the world of soldiers for all her life. Her father had reached Colonel by the time he retired, her brother was the commanding officer of the Council Guard, her family moved in the circles of officers and soldiers; two of her best friends were huntresses. Twilight wasn't a gun person, but she had spent enough time around gun people that she could identify several different types of weapon by the sound, and right now, the sound of multiple Atlesian assault rifles firing on fully automatic was unmistakable.

But how? Well, obviously, they were putting their fingers on the triggers and pulling back hard, so the question was more accurately why? Or, what? Why were they shooting, what were they shooting at? The White Fang? Had the White Fang gotten onto the campus? Nobody seemed to be shooting back. Grimm? Had the Creatures of Grimm gotten into Beacon?

Neither option was particularly promising. This was Beacon Academy, after all, a self-proclaimed light amidst the darkness; if their enemies had entered the fortress, then…

Then why was Twilight only hearing the firing now? If there were enemies rampaging across Beacon, then Twilight ought to have heard a lot more fighting than just shooting going on down below her in the tower. Localised fighting? A small scale attack? That… that made sense. The distance between the tower and the ballroom combined with the music from the dance would mean that nobody would hear the shooting in the tower, allowing time for the attackers, whoever they were, to do whatever they had come here to do.

Of course, that still didn't explain exactly who these attackers might be-

Spike, sitting on Twilight's lap, barked loudly, rousing her from futile – and, in the circumstances, somewhat pointless – speculation and bringing her back to the more important question of what, in the circumstances, she ought to do next.

Twilight glanced at the monitor, which was still depicting the progress of her trace on the source of that mail.

Twilight had seen more fighting than she had expected when she took this assignment, and she felt it was fair to say that it hadn't gone very well so far, armour or no. The cyclops in the forest would have killed her if it hadn't been for Pyrrha and Cinder; Adam would have killed her if it hadn't been for Sunset and the fact that the threatened arrival of her friends had convinced him to withdraw. She had spent the train fight in the armoured carapace of a Paladin.

All of which was to say that the idea of summoning her armour to join the battle down below did not strike her as a wise one.

She had already proved that was not where her forte lay.

And there were much smarter courses open to her.

Twilight snatched her scroll off the worktop in front of her. It was running the tracing programme, but with a single swipe of one trembling finger, she opened up a new window. She opened up her address book, scrolling through the folders to the one labelled 'Friends' which contained five headshots within it.

Her hand didn't shake at all as she selected Rainbow Dash.

XxXxX​

Rainbow Dash was standing in the upper gallery, looking down at the dance floor below. In particular, her attention was focussed on Penny, who looked like she was making Ruby Rose a little bit dizzy as she whirled her around on the floor.

"I'm not entirely sure how much fun Ruby is having down there," Sunset observed as she joined Rainbow at the balcony. "Do you think I ought to rescue her?"

Rainbow looked up to see that her fellow team leader was smirking. For her part, Rainbow didn't smile.

"Sometimes," she confessed, "I feel more like a mom than a team leader. Like I'm watching somebody grow up right in front of me, figuring themselves out as they go."

"She'll be doing well if she gets it right the first time," Sunset muttered. "Especially with you as a role model."

"Oh, that was feeble, even for you," Rainbow said. She frowned. "I'm watching her grow up, and I'm leading her into battle. What does that make me?"

Sunset leaned on the rail beside her. "The White Fang send children into battle, judging by Blake and some of the people she knows."

Rainbow frowned. "I don't know about you, Sunset, but I'd like to think that 'better than a bunch of murdering terrorists' is a bar I could clear pretty easily." Only, you know, maybe I can't.

Maybe we – the whole of Atlas – haven't.
The memory of the brand on Adam's face rose to the forefront of her memory. She hadn't heard anything from Cadance about the progress of her investigation. Maybe there wasn't any. Maybe the tracks had been covered too well, maybe the SDC was just untouchable. Maybe…

Rainbow dismissed the other possibility. Cadance had given her word; she was trying, no doubt about that.

She had warned Rainbow it might take a while.

"You okay?" Sunset asked.

"Yeah," Rainbow said quickly. "Yeah, I'm fine, why?"

"You looked a little bit ill for a moment there," Sunset said. "Something wrong with the punch?"

"No," Rainbow replied. "Just… a memory."

Sunset nodded. "That face, right?"

"How did you know?"

"Because I try not to think about it either," Sunset said. "It… makes it harder to remember we're the good guys."

"Tell me about it," Rainbow muttered. She shook her head. "I'm going to go. Can you do me a favour and keep an eye on Penny for me? I would ask Ciel, but I don't want to bother her when she's got a date."

"Oh, but you're fine imposing on me?"

"Have you got anything better to do?" Rainbow demanded.

"Have you got anywhere better to be?"

"I'm going over to the tower to check on Twilight."

"Ah," Sunset murmured. She smiled. "Sure. I'll keep an eye on Penny. You go."

"Thanks," Rainbow said. "And for the party too; you and Yang did a pretty good job. I mean, you're no Pinkie Pie, but-"

"I'll pretend you stopped at 'thanks for the party,'" Sunset said. "Now get out of here."

Rainbow grinned and turned to go. She was interrupted before she'd gone more than a couple of steps by the buzzing of her scroll. The vibrations sent shivers up her spine for a moment before she pulled her scroll out from the back of her waist and pulled it open.

Twilight's face confronted her. "Rainbow, I need you."

Rainbow straightened up. "Twi, what are you-?" She stopped as her equine ears pricked upwards visibly at the sounds she could hear coming out of her scroll. Sharp, rattling sounds, numerous and repeating. Sounds to make Rainbow's blood chill. "Twilight, is that gunfire?"

Twilight nodded. "Yes. I think the tower is under attack."

No. No, no, no, no! This wasn't happening. This couldn't be happening? How the hell was this happening? It wasn't even like the forest; Twilight was still at Beacon for crying out loud! She was in the CCT!

Get a grip. Calm down. Focus. You can't help Twilight by Twilighting. Rainbow took a breath, and clamped down on her rising panic hard enough to think straight and ask the question, "What floor are you on?"

"Nine," Twilight said, just as the noise ceased. "The shooting has stopped."

Rainbow nodded. "Show me the room."

Twilight turned her scroll away and waved it around, giving Rainbow a panoramic view of the entire room.

"Okay," Rainbow said. "That bank of desks in the far right corner, near the window. Hide under there, don't move, don't make a sound; I'll come get you."

"Right," Twilight agreed, as she brought the scroll back around to show her face. She glanced away. "Someone's coming up the elevator."

"Hide, stay quiet, and don't panic," Rainbow snapped, sounding closer to panic herself than Twilight seemed. "I'm on my way!" She ended the call, and leapt off the upper gallery, landing heavily in the middle of the ballroom floor. "PENNY!" she yelled, causing her teammate to stop – holding Ruby up by the arms – and look her way.

"Come on, we've gotta roll!" Rainbow shouted, trusting Penny to follow her as she began to run for the exit, shoving people aside as she did so. "Come on, make a hole."

Rainbow kept her scroll out as she sprinted out of the ballroom; she tried to type as she ran, but she kept hitting the wrong keys on the display. She gritted her teeth as she skidded to a halt, halfway to the CCT already but still seeming so far away from Twilight and… Rainbow tried to keep from thinking about what might be going on in there, what might be happening to… no, don't think about it, dammit, calm down! She typed in the coordinates to summon her locker.

"Rainbow Dash!"

Rainbow turned to see that Penny wasn't the only one who had followed her out of the ballroom. Ciel was there too, and – a little more surprisingly – Ruby and Sunset, the former running in bare feet, having apparently discarded her high heels.

For herself, Rainbow was glad that she'd worn boots to the dance.

"What's the situation?" Ciel demanded as the four of them closed the distance towards her.

"Twilight heard gunshots in the CCT, then the shooting stopped and someone started coming up the elevator," Rainbow said. "I think she's in trouble."

"Understood," Ciel said, pulling out her scroll. Sunset and Ruby did likewise.

"Why would anyone want to attack the CCT?" Ruby asked as she summoned her locker.

"Could be the White Fang, although I kinda hope not," Sunset muttered. "If they can get in here whenever they want, it's not good."

"There is no positive in any hostile being able to breach the security of the campus," Ciel said.

"We'll find out who they are when we catch up to them," Rainbow growled as her locker slammed into the ground in front of her, smashing the stones of the courtyard path before popping open to reveal her wings, guns, and anything else that she might want.

Rainbow tore a slit up the side of her skirt all the way to the top, so that she could move her legs more freely.

Rarity would totally understand when she found out.

The lockers of Sunset, Ruby, and Ciel arrived as Rainbow still was strapping the Wings of Harmony onto her back. Rainbow didn't bother with telling them they didn't have to come or any of that stuff; it wouldn't have worked, and anyway, Twilight might need all the help she could get.

"You go on ahead," Ciel said, and with a single deft tug, she pulled her entire skirt off, letting the fabric fall to the ground as she stood in a pair of tight running shorts beneath the overly elaborate bodice. "I'll inform General Ironwood, and then we'll follow."

"Right," Rainbow said, grabbing her belt with Brutal Honesty and Plain Awesome holstered on it and clasping it around her waist.

"How did you-?" Sunset began.

"An Atlesian student is prepared for any eventuality, including that her garb may become suddenly unsuitable," Ciel declared matter-of-factly. She pulled Distant Thunder out of its locker. "Acceptable at a dance, invaluable in a shipwreck."

"Or a fight," Rainbow muttered as she pulled on her goggles, tinting the whole world red as they covered her eyes.

"Is Twilight going to be okay?" Penny asked anxiously.

Rainbow looked into Penny's wide eyes and forced herself to smile. "Of course she is. Twilight's gonna be just fine. Because we're going to save her."

She turned away, kicking off the ground as the jetpack of her wing-suit propelled her off the cobbled stones and up into the air. Her wings extended, catching the currents of the cool night air as Rainbow soared upwards towards the ninth floor of the CCT.

Hold on, Twi. I'm on my way.

XxXxX​

The elevator was creeping upwards towards her floor. Twilight half-rose from her seat, but stopped. Out of the corner of her eye, the monitor screen had caught her attention.

The trace programme had tracked the message as far as… Drachyra? The signal had been bounced off Drachyra? No, more than that; that was where the encryption had been picked up from. Twilight boggled, staring at the monitor as her eyes widened behind her glasses. This… this was impossible. Drachyra was a barren wasteland, wracked by storms and infested with grimm. Nobody lived there, and even if they did, there was no technology that would allow anyone to connect to the CCT network… was there?

There's no way my programme could be wrong. Then… that means…

The signal had come to Drachyra from…Twilight watched as the blue trace line went right back to where it had started from, Beacon… from the scroll of…

An official photograph of a supremely confident young woman appeared on the monitor, smirking out at her. The name beside the picture was Cinder Fall.

Sunset's friend. But… but Cinder helped save my life. She protected me in the forest! Why-?

Once more, she was roused by the sound of Spike barking loudly, looking at her and then shaking his head in the direction of the elevator shaft as if to say 'hey, remember the emergency?'

"Right," Twilight said. "Thanks, Spike." Fight. Bad guy. Have to hide.

Twilight ran for the back of the room, leaving her scroll and, well, everything else behind her as she dived under the bank of desks nearest the window. She hunched down and covered her mouth with one hand as, with the other, she covered the mouth of her dog.

I'm really sorry about this, Spike, but we can't make a sound until Rainbow Dash gets here.

Twilight waited, huddled under the bank of desks, breathing in and out through her nose.

I left my work on the monitor!

Whoever came up here would see it and know that she was here! There was no point in hiding at all! Twilight knew that she ought to get up, to go back, to grab her stuff and erase the evidence of her work, but… but she was afraid. She didn't mind admitting that. It sounded like someone had just taken out all the guards, and now, they were on their way up here… to her.

She wasn't brave enough to get out and show herself under those conditions. Her combat record wasn't impressive enough, to say the least, to justify that kind of courage, especially not against someone who had torn through the soldiers down below. No, she should do as Rainbow said, and hide, and wait.

She couldn't see anything beyond the desk under which she was hiding. The green light of the CCT monitors reflected off the polished floor. She was too low down to see much out of the windows but starlight.

Twilight couldn't see the elevator, but she heard the click of heels upon the floor, and she heard the sultry voice of Cinder Fall echoing across the room.

"Really? Who?" Cinder was silent for a moment. Twilight guessed that she was talking to someone else. "And is there a good reason why you just let them leave?"

Rainbow Dash. She's talking about Rainbow Dash and… someone else; Penny? Ciel? But then… that must mean that she has allies at the party, keeping watch.

Her teammates? Are they in on this too?

What is even going on here?


The only thing she knew for certain was that if this was Cinder Fall, if Cinder was her enemy, then she had made the right choice to try and stay hidden. She'd seen the way that Cinder fought, how she and Pyrrha had effortlessly dispatched the cyclops that had smashed its way through all of Twilight's drones; even with her armour, she would have been screwed going up against Cinder and out of her mind to have tried it.

As Ciel had told her, there was no shame in shirking a pointless fight, with nothing of consequence riding upon the outcome.

"I see," Cinder purred. "Never mind. I'll deal with it."

Twilight held her breath as she heard the clicking sound of the woman's steps upon the floor.

It was definitely Cinder; Twilight hadn't spent an enormous amount of time with her, and if it hadn't been for that time spent together in the forest, she might not have been so sure, but they had spent that time together in the forest, and she did recognise Cinder's voice.

"So, you figured it out. Clever, clever, Twilight Sparkle; you really are a talent."

You've got someone pretty talented on your side too, Cinder.

Twilight could hear the woman working on the computer. Erasing Twilight's work, probably. Or…no, there must be more to it than that, because she couldn't have known that Twilight was here before she came here, could she? Twilight had only told her team; Penny was too innocent to betray Atlas – not to mention, she was watched too constantly for that – and Ciel would never even contemplate it.

Which meant that nobody had known Twilight was going to be here when they launched their attack. Which meant that-

"Come out, come out, wherever you are," Cinder called. Twilight could hear more footsteps, but she couldn't tell exactly where they were in relation to her hiding place.

She started to breathe through her nose before she passed out. Spike was starting to fuss and fret. She scratched behind his ears and hoped that he could understand that she wasn't doing this to be cruel to him.

"Open your eyes, you have to get up," the woman whispered in a sing-song voice.

"Monsters are coming to gobble you up.

Out of bed, hide under the floor,

The monsters are breaking down the door."

It was a nursery rhyme. No, it was a hide-and-seek song. Or was it both? Twilight hadn't exactly had friends to play hide-and-seek with. Was it a traditional thing? Was it Mistrali originally? The sort of thing that children got taught to tell them what to do when the grimm attacked, except it had gotten tamed in places where the grimm didn't show themselves until the original meaning had been lost.

Except right now, hiding under a desk as a monster prowled the room searching for her, her footsteps echoing, Twilight felt she could understand the meaning of the original very, very well.

"Hide in the cupboard, are they near?

Monsters know how to smell your fear."

Rainbow Dash where are you?

"You'll hear the screams and then you'll know:

Mommy and Daddy can't help you now."

The chair nearest Twilight was rudely shoved away, and a masked figure dressed in black loomed over, a cruel smirk disfiguring the smoothness of her face.

"Close your eyes, don't look up," she said.

"Here comes a monster to gobble you up."

Twilight yelped as she was grabbed by the neck and dragged out of her hiding place. She beat futilely at the other woman, but Cinder paid as much notice to her feeble blows as she would have paid to a gnat.

Twilight winced as she was slammed back-first into the wall. Spike barked furiously and leapt at Cinder, who half-turned before kicking him away. He flew across the room and hit the far wall with a yelp of pain.

"Spike!" Twilight cried, half a second before she was slammed into the nearest desk so hard that she smashed through the monitor with her face, breaking her glasses in the process. Twilight shrieked as the pain slashed at her through her aura.

"You should worry less about your dog and more about yourself," Cinder said as she pulled Twilight up until the two of them were at eye level. Though her – now spectacle-less – view was a little blurry, Twilight could swear that Cinder looked like she was enjoying this.

Her smile, as best Twilight could tell, was hungry, and as sharp as a blade.

If… if she erased my work, and now she… how will my friends ever know who…who she really is?

Twilight gasped as Cinder began to squeeze her throat. No, it was more than just squeezing. Cinder's hands were boiling hot, burning hot, they were burning through Twilight's aura just through contact, just like the cyclops in the Emerald Forest.

Only this time, Twilight didn't have her armour to shelter in as her aura began to drain away.

She groaned and moaned in pain, twitching and writhing in futile efforts to escape the unbearable heat.

"I didn't plan on you being here," Cinder declared, "but since you are here, I'm rather glad. After all, I just have to kill you, and then nobody will be any the wiser." She chuckled. "You have no idea how much I've detested you, you spoiled little girl." She squeezed Twilight's head a little tighter. "You have no idea how hard or cold the world can be, because whenever its chill reaches you, you just take a step back and let someone else deal with it. That's what you did tonight, isn't it? You called on faithful Rainbow Dash to save you." Cinder shook her head. "Well, if she gets here, I'll kill her-"

The windows of the CCT were shattered by the impact of Rainbow Dash, wings outstretched, busting through them and into the room. She soared across the chamber, a wordless yell bursting out of her throat as she slammed one fist into Cinder's cheek. The blow was hard enough to shatter Cinder's grip on Twilight, who collapsed to the floor as Cinder herself was tossed backwards, smashing through a bank of desks, skidding backwards across the floor.

The Wings of Harmony folded back into the backpack as Rainbow Dash stood over Twilight like a mother bear, casting a shadow over her as long and as reassuring as an Atlesian cruiser.

"Everything's going to be okay, Twilight," Rainbow declared. "I'm right here."



General Ironwood had heard Rainbow Dash bellow Penny's name across the dancefloor – it was unlikely that there was anyone who had missed it – and he had seen the three members of Team RSPT leave the ballroom in a great hurry, accompanied by half of Team SAPR, while the other half – Jaune Arc and Pyrrha Nikos – looked about as confused by it as the rest of the guests at tonight's party.

Ironwood glanced at Ozpin. "Something I should know about?"

"I assure you, James, that I am just as in the dark as you are," Ozpin replied. "Why don't you try and discover what's happening while I prevent the spread of unnecessary panic amongst the other students?"

Ironwood nodded, and he had already walked out of the ballroom – Ozpin, meanwhile, headed back inside – when his scroll began to buzz.

He tapped his earpiece to take the call audio only. "Dash?"

"It's Soleil, sir."

"Report." Ironwood snapped.

"Twilight Sparkle reported gunfire from the lower levels of the CCT," Ciel said, as calmly and as matter-of-factly as if she were reporting the weather. "Gunfire then ceased, but a possible assailant began to ascend in the elevator. Rainbow Dash has gone on ahead to secure Twilight Sparkle; myself, Cadet Polendina, and Sunset Shimmer and Ruby Rose of Beacon's Team Sapphire will follow immediately."

Ironwood bit back a curse. Someone was attacking the CCT? Under his very nose? And Twilight was in there! His goddaughter, the brightest mind that Atlas had produced in a generation, and she was in danger – again.

Nobody could have predicted that anyone would be able to infiltrate Beacon and overpower the guards. Not that his ignorance would save Twilight, nor excuse the loss of all that she might have done for Atlas over the course of her life otherwise.

And even that might be a small matter compared to the possibility that this had nothing to do with Twilight Sparkle at all. What if they knew what Ozpin was hiding in the vault underneath the tower? Had Amber's assailant come back to finish the job? What if they knew about the relic? Ironwood didn't know where exactly the Relic of Choice was – only Ozpin knew that; it was a secret even amongst the secrets of their organisation – but who knew what clues to its hiding place might be hidden in Ozpin's office if somebody got up there?

Is it her? Is she making her play?

General Ironwood controlled his voice. There was no point in letting Soleil hear how concerned he was. "Good work, Soleil. I'll try and raise the guard detail and summon reinforcements to support you. Good luck."

"Thank you, sir."

"Ironwood out," Ironwood said. He tapped his earpiece again, ending the call from Soleil and enabling voice-activated contact. "Lieutenant Reynolds, this is General Ironwood, status report."

There was no response.

Ironwood's feet carried him, almost subconsciously, towards the tower.

"Lieutenant, this is General Ironwood, please respond." No answer. "Sergeant Barnes, do you copy?"

Ironwood scowled. "Schnee."

There was a momentary pause before Winter Schnee's voice came over the line. "Sir."

"The CCT has come under attack. Load up three Skygraspers with marines and meet me outside the tower ASAP."

"Understood, sir. Do you want me to alert the Vale authorities?"

"We'll deal with that when the situation is contained; for now, double time it. Twilight Sparkle's in the tower."

"Yes, sir."

"Wonderbolt Lead," Ironwood said, ending his call to Winter and speaking a new contact name.

"Spitfire, reading you loud and clear, General," The squadron leader of the Wonderbolts, known by the callsign Spitfire, came on the line.

"Prep your team for ground action and rendezvous with me outside the CCT on the double; shots fired, situation unknown."

"Copy that, sir. Wonderbolts inbound."

Ironwood began to reach into his jacket for the pistol he always kept concealed in a shoulder holster. He was interrupted by another message.

"Ironwood."

"Soleil reporting, sir. We've arrived at the CCT; all guards have been neutralised."

"Dead?"

"Unknown, sir; we haven't made a comprehensive-"

"Don't bother; securing Twilight is your top priority," Ironwood said.

"Yes, sir."

The sharp rattle of gunfire began to sound in Ironwood's earpiece. "Soleil!"

"Coming from above us, sir."

Rainbow Dash. "Hurry, Soleil."

"Yes sir!"

XxXxX​

Ruby pressed the elevator button repeatedly, prodding it over and over again as if it was going to make the lift come down any faster. And as she pressed, she was muttering inaudible encouragement to it, or perhaps she was just upset that it wasn't moving fast enough.

Sunset left her to it. If she wanted to do something other than nothing, then let her. Even if it wasn't going to make the elevator come down any faster, then it wasn't going to make it move any slower either.

And it meant that she didn't have to look at the bodies of the Atlesian soldiers scattered around the atrium of the tower.

Sunset didn't know if they were all dead. Since General Ironwood had given them the clear not to waste time checking every one, nobody really wanted to spend any time checking any of them. So Sunset didn't know if they were all dead, but she did know that at least some of them were. You didn't get up again from having your neck twisted into that angle, and if you weren't crying out from a stab wound like that, you weren't going to cry out ever again.

The atrium was riddled with bullet holes, but so far as Sunset could tell, none of the Atlesian troops had been shot. There were some blade wounds, but no gunshots that she could see. Which meant that the Atlesians must have missed a lot of shots. Which meant that whoever they were up against was very good. Agile, fast, able to dodge like a fiend.

Sunset wished that she'd worn gloves; she was starting to sweat just a little bit.

Come on, where's that elevator?

Ciel was standing over one of the fallen Atlesian soldiers, one of the ones they were sure was dead. Her head was bowed, and her eyes were closed. Was she praying? Religion wasn't a big thing in Remnant, and certainly not something Sunset would have expected to see from an Atlesian.

"And now I vow to take up your struggle," Ciel murmured. "Until the final victory is achieved or I join you in the green fields beyond the mud and blood in which we live. Through your sacrifice shall the kingdom prosper and our enemies fail."

"I… I don't understand," Penny said, as she looked around at the fallen all around her. "Why… who would do something like this?"

Ruby looked at her. "I… I don't know exactly who's responsible for this, Penny. Not yet, anyway. But… there are a lot of bad people in the world who just don't care about life, who fight and kill because they can. They're… they're worse than the grimm because they know that what they're doing is wrong, but they do it anyway. And that's why we have to fight them. That's why we have to fight them with everything we have, because it's the only way we can protect our friends."

"But why?" Penny repeated. "Why would anyone deliberately do something that they know is wrong?"

Ruby sighed. "I really wish I had an answer for you, Penny, but I don't. I don't think anybody does.

"Their motives are irrelevant," Ciel declared. She opened her eyes, but her expression remained grimly set. "They are the darkness, no less than the creatures of grimm. They are the darkness, and we are the light that will burn them into nothingness."

One of the elevators finally began to descend down towards them.

"I don't think we can always understand why people do what they do, Penny," Ruby said. "Sometimes, all we can do is stop them before they hurt anyone else."

XxXxX​

Rainbow broke through the windows, shards of glass bouncing off her goggles and getting stuck in her hair. She roared in anger as she swept into the room like an avenging angel because no one, but no one, but no one treated her friend like that and got away with it.

She was moving so fast that even with her shout, she still blindsided her opponent, a single woman in a black catsuit, catching her with a blow that knocked her across the room and, more importantly, got her to let go of Twilight.

As Rainbow's opponent recovered her footing, Twilight collapsed onto the floor next to Rainbow Dash. Rainbow glanced down at her. Her glasses were gone – smashed probably – and there was a terrified look in those purple eyes.

"Everything's going to be okay, Twilight; I'm right here," Rainbow said. She paused. "Did she hurt you?"

Twilight shook her head. "My aura didn't break."

Rainbow couldn't restrain the sigh of relief, any more than she could restrain the murderous glare that she shot towards Catsuit Girl, who just stood there looking down at them both with an infuriating smirk on her face.

"Cinder," Twilight murmured. "It's Cinder Fall."

Rainbow's eyes narrowed. Sunset's friend? What the hell? "Is that right?" she muttered. "Twi, Ciel and Penny are coming up in the elevator; when the doors open, run for them, okay?"

Twilight swallowed and nodded her head. "Okay."

Rainbow focussed all her attention upon Cinder "You want to play rough?" she asked. "You want to play with someone who knows how to punch back?"

The smirk on Cinder's face didn't waver for an instant.

Rainbow reached for her machine pistols, Brutal Honesty and Plain Awesome filling her hands as she swept the weapons up, pointed them at Cinder, and squeezed the triggers. Both guns blazed, muzzles flashing, cartridge casings falling to the floor at her feet.

Cinder didn't dodge. She raised both her hands before her, and the bullets slammed harmlessly into… what?

A shield? Never seen her do that before.

Not surprising she'd hold out on us.


Rainbow let her empty guns fall to the ground. Guess I'll have to do this the old-fashioned way.

Slowly, Cinder produced a capsule and flicked the cap off and onto the floor.

She waved her arm in a wide arc before her, spreading dust out from the capsule like seeds on a farm or something. The dust solidified a moment later, transforming into a wave of glass daggers that flew straight for Rainbow Dash.

"Twilight, stay down!" Rainbow snapped as she leapt forward and rolled beneath the wave of glass which passed, harmlessly, over her head. Rainbow rose right in Cinder's face, throwing a right hook.

Cinder blocked. She grabbed Rainbow's wrist, twisted-

Rainbow head-butted her in the face. Once, twice, three times, and the obsidian mask she was wearing shattered with a crunch, and that smirk on her face wasn't looking quite so smug any more, was it?

Rainbow threw another punch with her free hand.

Cinder caught her fist in her open palm.

And now it was Rainbow's turn to smirk as she let Cinder have it with an aura boom, turning her aura outwards with a blast like a cannon that, sure, burned through thirty percent of Rainbow's aura in one hit but was totally worth it for the way it sent Cinder flying backwards, smashing through two banks of desks and chairs before she skidded to a halt.

Rainbow charged, trailing a rainbow behind her as she ran with all the speed of her semblance to bull rush Cinder before she could recover. Rainbow yelled wordlessly as she carried Cinder into the far wall and slammed her into it so hard she made a dent.

Don't. Hurt. My. Friends!

Rainbow got a clean punch in on Cinder's face. Cinder dodged the second punch, but Rainbow converted it into an elbow strike. She swung again.

Cinder managed to evade the blow and catch her arm in a lock. Rainbow struggled as Cinder spun her around, got her hand on Rainbow's neck, slammed her into the wall, and then threw her away. Rainbow landed on her feet but with her back to-

"Look out!" Twilight yelled.

Rainbow wasn't able to avoid all the arrows; one of them hit her, shattering or exploding or something that hurt like hell and felt like it had taken another chunk out of her aura with it. She didn't know exactly how much she had left. She certainly didn't have time to check.

Cinder leapt into the air, hovering there for a moment as twin blades of black obsidian formed in her hands out of dust crystals. Then she descended like a hawk.

Rainbow dodged her initial swings. She kicked, but Cinder took it on her arm. Cinder slashed again, and Rainbow had to block at a cost in aura. Rainbow swung at her. That damn smirk was back again as Cinder ducked under the punch and threw one of her swords into the air.

The sword spun once as Cinder grabbed Rainbow's arm.

Again? Dammit!

The sword spun a second time as Cinder threw Rainbow over her shoulder and onto her back.

The sword spun a third time as Cinder caught it, reversed it, and brought it downwards, point first.

Rainbow caught the blade between her palms, then kicked upwards off the ground.

Cinder was still smiling. Rainbow was really starting to hate it.

She raised her fists. Cinder raised her blades in a high guard.

They charged at one another. Rainbow swung her fists and lashed out with her legs in high sweeping kicks, and Cinder ducked and dived and leapt away from them before slashing with her twin blades which Rainbow also sought to avoid. She was probably taking something off Cinder's aura, but she was also getting her own sliced away in the process; she could feel that, even if she couldn't gauge the exact amount. She risked another aura boom, knocking Cinder backwards at the cost of another chunk of her own aura in turn.

Rainbow panted slightly.

She has to be close to the limit if I am.

I just wish she'd stop smirking.


If Cinder was fazed at all by what Rainbow had done, she didn't show it. She combined her two swords at the pommels, forming a bow. A trio of arrows formed out of dust. She aimed squarely at Rainbow Dash.

Rainbow wasn't fazed; she could dodge those-

Cinder's smile broadened as she switched aim to Twilight, still lying on the floor, and let fly.

And Rainbow did the only thing she could.

She leapt into the path of the arrows.

"No!" Twilight yelled as the arrows exploded. Rainbow cried out in pain as her aura broke, the magenta field rippling over her body as she lost all protection from the flames and shards of glass. She hit the floor with a thud and the clank of her wings, her arms and side aching. She could feel blood, warm and sticky, starting to run. Not a lot of it, but she could feel it anyway. She groaned as she tried to get to her feet.

"Stay down, like a good dog," Cinder said, as she planted a foot on Rainbow's chest and pressed down, driving Rainbow back onto the floor. She cocked her head to one side. "Flower of the north," she murmured, as her black swords reformed in her hands. "Didn't anyone ever tell you that the tallest flowers get cut down?"

"No!" Twilight shrieked, getting up and starting to run towards them as though… Rainbow didn't know what she was thinking.

Cinder ignored her, looking down on Rainbow Dash as she raised her blades.

A green laser blast forced Cinder to leap hurriedly out of the way as Penny, Ciel, Ruby, and Sunset emerged from the elevator.

Penny's swords formed a halo around her head. "Get away from my friends!"

Cinder's ever-present smirk faltered; in fact, she looked downright irritated for a moment. Her smirk turned into a scowl as she raised her swords.

Laser beams leapt from Penny's blades, the green pulses flying straight and true towards Cinder. Cinder's swords shattered in her hands, breaking apart into fragments of glass which she flung outwards before herself, the ambient light in the room reflecting off the shards of glass like… like mirrors.

Mirrors off which Penny's laser beams were reflected, rebounding in all directions, up into the ceiling, down onto the floor, back at Penny and the others. Sunset flung out one hand, a shield as green as Penny's lasers forming in front of the group on which the blast dissipated harmlessly, but by then, Cinder had already turned and ran, crossing the room without further opposition, leaping out of the broken window pane and into the empty air.

XxXxX​

Sunset rushed to the shattered window, ignoring Rainbow Dash and Twilight for a moment, ignoring the crunch of glass shards underfoot because all she could concentrate on was that this was Cinder, Cinder who had attacked the CCT and tried to kill Twilight.

It was Cinder who had betrayed them all.

Sunset could hardly believe it. She'd seen it with her own eyes, that face, that smile, but she could still… still hardly believe it.

I thought that you were like me. I thought that we were kindred spirits.

I thought that we were friends.


She had thought that they were so alike… was Cinder that good a liar, or was Sunset such a poor judge of character?

Sunset didn't know the answer to that, but she did know, as she watched Cinder fly – fly! – from the ninth floor down towards the ground, that she wanted answers.

And so she teleported, leaving Ruby and RSPT behind to appear in a burst of green light directly in front of Cinder as she landed before the tower.

"You're not getting away so easy," Sunset growled as she raised Sol Invictus to her shoulder and pointed it squarely at Cinder.

Cinder smiled. "Hello, Sunset."

Sunset's eyes narrowed. "I did wonder why you weren't at the dance," she said, "but you seem to have made your own amusement."

"Well, I did also tell you that I was planning to have some real fun."

Sunset bared her teeth. "Why, Cinder? Why have you done this?"

"Why?" Cinder asked, and she sounded almost surprised. "I thought that you of all people would understand, if anyone could understand. We're so alike, after all, you and I."

Sunset swallowed and tried to avoid the dry, brackish sensation in her mouth. "I'm not so sure of that any more."

Cinder laughed. "Oh, Sunset. Just because you've found out that I've been lying about certain superficial details of my allegiance, as though you've never done the same. It doesn't change who I am inside. It doesn't change the similarity between our hearts. It doesn't change that you and I are the same thing: monsters."

Sunset shook her head. "No. I'm not-"

"I feel it," Cinder hissed. "Inside you, calling to me, waiting to be unleashed. Let it out, Sunset. Embrace who you really are. I can show you, if you like." She held out one hand. "Let me help you, the way that somebody once helped-"

Sunset fired, squeezing the trigger of Sol Invictus as fire roared from the barrel of her rifle.

Cinder raised her hand and blocked the round effortlessly. "Now was that really necessary? I'm only trying to do what's best for you."

"I know who I am," Sunset growled, using her anger to mask her uncertainty. "And if you are my enemy, if you have always been my enemy, then I'm not going to just let you walk away."

Cinder smiled. "Do you think you can defeat me, Sunset Shimmer?"

"I know I'm going to try."

Twin swords sprang into existence in Cinder's hands as she forged them out of dust. "Very well. I'm very sorry that things have come to this. I had hoped… but, as you well know, destiny cannot be avoided. Come then, Sunset Shimmer, and let fate decide which of us to crown in glory!"



XxXxX​

This chapter includes a last minute change - Cinder using the glass shards to send Penny's laser beams rebounding back on her - for which credit is owned to RuleroftheValaxy, whose Hellfire Phoenix one-shot Red and Gold is something I really do advise you to check out.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 81 - Little Ashes
Little Ashes​


Sunset parried Cinder's stroke with the stock of Sol Invictus, but the force behind the blow was enough to push her backwards. Her platform shoes scraped against the ground as she skidded backwards.

Sunset countered, lashing out with the rifle-butt like a club aimed at Cinder's head. Cinder ducked. Sunset let go of the rifle with one hand and loosed a beam of emerald energy from the palm of her hand. It struck the courtyard stone in a shower of debris as Cinder leapt athletically away, doing a backflip before landing gracefully on her feet.

"You know, I really envy you at times," Cinder murmured.

Sunset reversed her rifle so that she could once more use it as a gun. With one hand, she felt along the wooden stock until her fingers made out the scar that Cinder had made in the wood. "I thought you envied me all the time?"

Cinder smirked. A chuckle rose from her lips. "Oh, I do, of course. Every day, every waking moment, I am consumed with envy. But sometimes, such as now, I confess that I am… particularly envious."

"'Particularly'?" Sunset repeated. "Why's that?"

"Because you can use your magic freely, and nobody cares," Cinder declared, in a tone so casual as to almost be offhand.

Sunset felt a chill feeling run down her spine, which was funny, because at the exact same moment, sweat started to trickle down her arms. "What are you talking about?"

Cinder's laughter was cold. "Come now, Sunset; we're all alone in the night out here, with no one but the stars to hear our darkest secrets. You don't have to pretend or pass your talents off as a semblance. We're both initiated into the higher mysteries. What you do is magic, and I'm guessing that you've had it for some time, considering you're so much better at it than you are with any of your other skills." She chuckled. "No offence intended, of course." She began to circle Sunset, like a wolf circling the flock in the dead of night. She pointed one of her black blades at her opponent. "So my question to you is… where did you get it?"

"I was born with it," Sunset growled. "My question to you is how do you know about magic, and why didn't you say anything before now?"

"That's two questions, but I'll answer anyway, even though you didn't really answer mine," Cinder said. "Because I'm… a classy lady." She laughed softly. "I know about magic because I know everything. My mistress told me all before she sent me out into the world to do her bidding. But she didn't tell me about anyone quite like you."

Sunset grinned. "Guess she didn't quite tell you everything then, did she?"

"I know more than you could comprehend," Cinder insisted. "Sunset, please, listen to me. There is more at stake here than you know. However clearly you think you see, I promise, you are blind to the truth. Professor Ozpin has made you blind and keeps you so; he will put out your eyes if you allow it. If you follow him, he will lead you into the abyss."

"I am no one's blind follower!" Sunset snapped.

"Are you not?" Cinder asked, sniffing. "Then prove it."

"How?" Sunset demanded. "By joining you?"

"Why not?" Cinder replied "The world is changing, Sunset. There's an east wind coming that will sweep away everything that all these people have ever known. Only those who are strong enough to survive, only those who deserve to survive will be spared when the storm breaks. Join me, Sunset. Prove that you are worthy of survival, as I already know you are."

"And what if I do?" Sunset said. "What happens to Pyrrha? What happens to Ruby? What happens to Jaune or Blake, what happens to any of them?"

Cinder's smile was positively vicious. "As I said: only those who deserve to survive."

"Yeah, that's what I thought," Sunset muttered. "If you expect me to take a deal like that, then you don't really respect me at all, do you?"

"I respect your intelligence."

"But not my integrity."

Cinder laughed. "Creatures like us don't have integrity, Sunset; it's a luxury we can't afford. We do whatever we have to do to survive, to thrive, to achieve our dreams."

"I'm nothing like you!" Sunset lied, because she was a lot more like Cinder than she would have cared to admit.

She had a feeling – call it a hunch – that the next words to come dripping out of Cinder's mouth would be to point out exactly how much of a lie that was, how alike she and Sunset were, and so Sunset forestalled that by firing the last two bullets in her rifle's cylinder.

Cinder blocked them, somehow, again, but in that moment of distraction when she was doing that, Sunset had teleported right in front of her and hit her across the face with the stock of her rifle.

Cinder staggered backwards; Sunset pursued. Sunset swung again; Cinder parried with her obsidian blades, swept Sunset's guard away, and slashed across her midriff. It was Sunset's turn to retreat and Cinder's to pursue, black blades swinging.

"Is this all there is?" Sunset demanded as Cinder battered her strokes against her guard like the waves beating upon the shore. "You betrayed the whole world, and for what? Because you think you're better than everybody else? Is that really all there is?" At least the White Fang have a cause.

"What more is there, in the end?" Cinder shouted, and she threatened to slip a stroke through Sunset's guard.

Sunset fended her off with a beam of magic that threw her off her stride, even if she was able to evade it. "A reason?" Sunset suggested. "What are you hoping to get from this? What's going on? I just want to know why."

"Why? If you're not going to join me, then what does it matter?" Cinder demanded. She slashed; Sunset pirouetted out of the way and countered with a sideways blow, which Cinder ducked to get under Sunset's guard. Sunset retreated, parrying before countering with a thrust of her bayonet.

"Because I want to know why you ended up this way," Sunset said. I want to know how far you've gone and how close I was to becoming just like you. I want to know… I want to know how someone so charming, how someone who won me over so completely, how someone I could care so much about so quickly, could come to this. "If you tell me why, then maybe I can help you!"

"I don't need your help!" Cinder yelled. Her blades clashed against Sunset's rifle, glass sword scoring the wood as Sunset twirled her weapon to strike with butt and blade intermittently. "I don't need help from anyone!" She swept Sol Invictus out of Sunset's hands to land in one of the flowerbeds. "I am about to change this world!"

Cinder thrust straight at Sunset.

"But why?" Sunset repeated, as she turned and leaned out of the path of Cinder's oncoming blade. And as the blade swept past and Cinder's momentum carried her forwards, Sunset reached out and grabbed her by the arm.

In that moment, she was filled with a desire to know, to understand what could drive Cinder Fall, the person she'd trusted, the person she'd fought beside, the person who had seemed so like herself in so many ways, to turn against the kingdoms for reasons that couldn't possibly be so nebulous as she was making them seem. Sunset wanted to know – she needed to know – what had produced someone who was so like Sunset but who revelled in describing herself as a monster. She wanted to know – she needed to know – if they were really as alike as Sunset had thought and Cinder was making out. She wanted to know – she needed to know – if she could have turned out like Cinder seemed to be.

She wanted to know. She needed to know. She was filled with a desire to know that burned within her, and so, as Sunset's hand closed around Cinder's wrist, she felt something spark within herself, and then a feeling like ten thousand volts running down her arm. Sunset's head jerked backwards; her eyes widened as they were filled with pure light, brilliant white light consuming the night sky and the high towers of Beacon and anything else that she could see. There was nothing but the light, no sound but a high pitched whistling in her ears, no sensations but the electric feeling rushing down her arm and then…

And then…

Then Sunset saw.

XxXxX​

"What's that place, Momma?"

Sunset saw a young Cinder Fall – she saw things, but she also understood things instinctually, as if she'd seen all of this before – a mere child, who barely went up to the knee of the woman holding her hand as they walked down the Argus street. Not just any woman. Cinder's mother.

She – the mother – was wearing the uniform of an Atlesian officer. She'd been stationed at the base in Argus; she'd fallen in love with a local man, a Mistralian; Cinder was the result.

Cinder's mother looked at where she was pointing, to the grand, old-fashioned building nestling behind a pair of wrought-iron gates at the end of the street. She knelt down beside her daughter. "That is Sanctum Combat School; it's where the next generation of huntsmen and huntresses start their training."

"Could I go there and become a huntress too one day?"

Cinder's mother chuckled. "If you still want to." She kissed young Cinder on the forehead. "You can be whatever you want to be in this world, muffin."

"Really? I can be anything?"

"Anything at all," Cinder's mother said. "And I can't wait to see what you decide to do with your life."


XxXxX​

"Daddy, where's Momma?" Cinder asked. "When is she coming home?"

Cinder's father was a tall, well-dressed Mistralian man, who had the dark hair and amber eyes that his daughter had inherited. He sat at a writing desk, side-on to his daughter, and he didn't look down at her, even as she stood looking up at his face, desperate for answers.

His whole body seemed to shudder, and as Sunset watched, he gripped the pen in his hand especially tightly.

Cinder's mother was dead. Sunset knew that, even if the little girl who was asking where she was didn't. Whether it was because of some especial understanding or because she knew how these stories went, Sunset wasn't entirely sure, but she knew. She knew in the same way that she knew this man at the desk was Cinder's father, that this Argus townhouse that might have looked elegant and comfortable if the lights hadn't been turned out to shroud so much of it in darkness was her home.

"Daddy?" Cinder repeated. "Daddy, where's Momma?"

Her father's head bowed. "Ashley… your mother…"

Ashley. That was her name. Cinder's name, or at least the name she used to have. Ashley Little-Glassman, because her mother had decided to hyphenate her name, and her father had agreed to it being passed on to their daughter. Thinking that… it gave Sunset a headache just to think about it, as if the fact of Cinder's old name was physically painful.

Painful to her. To Cinder. Part of a past that she would rather forget if she could.

"Ashley," her father repeated. "Your mother… she's gone."

Cinder – Ashley, but Sunset found it easier to think of her by the name she knew – blinked in confusion. "'Gone'? What do you mean, gone? Where did she go, Daddy?"

"I don't know," her father said. He put his head in his hands, and Sunset could see that there were tears running down his face. "I don't know; I only know that…that we're never going to see her again."

Sunset had known that it was coming, but that didn't stop it from hitting her like a punch to the gut when it arrived. It felt as though she'd lost her own mother, except that Sunset had never known her own mother, and so, she'd never had any need to mourn for her. Except now, faced with the death of Cinder's mother, she could feel tears pricking at the corners of her eyes.

This was a woman that she'd only seen once, in somebody else's memory. She didn't know her at all, she had no idea what kind of a mother she'd been, she knew nothing about her as a person, and yet, here she was, about to weep for her, feeling the loss of her as though she'd been told that Princess Celestia had passed away in Equestria during her absence. She felt emptiness inside of her, an absence that might never go away.

Why was she feeling like this? Was this… was this how Cinder had felt?

Cinder's eyes were wide, and she stared at her father in silence, as the gloomy darkness that had already claimed so much of the house closed in around her, until the only light was a small patch around young Cinder herself, with no source that Sunset could discern.

And then even that light was snuffed out, and everything was plunged into darkness.


XxXxX​

It rained during the funeral. Her mother was buried with full military honours; a section of Atlesian soldiers in tall hats fired a three-round salute, and afterwards, the commanding officer – a stern-faced woman whose hair was starting to turn grey – folded up the Atlesian flag and presented it to Cinder.

As though a rag torn from a pole was a reasonable substitute for a mother and her love.

She hated that flag. She hated that flag and everything it stood for. As far as she was concerned, that flag – and the Atlesian military who upheld it – were the ones who took her mother away.


XxXxX​

"Ashley, I have something to tell you," her father said, as he knelt down before her. Cinder looked a little taller, but she couldn't have been very much older because – slight increase in her height aside – she still looked like an adorable little kid. "We're leaving Argus and going back to my home in Mistral."

"Leaving? You mean… for good?"

"Yes," her father said. "I… I can't stay here after… I know that things haven't been perfect since… but they'll get better, I promise. Once we get to Mistral, we can start over again."


XxXxX​

Cinder hadn't been too sorry to say goodbye to Argus. Sunset wasn't entirely sure how she knew that, but her best guess was that she was connected to Cinder's thoughts somehow. It was as though when she had touched Cinder's arm, she'd been able to read her memories. Was this her semblance? Was she a touch telepath?

No, or not entirely, anyway. She wasn't just reading Cinder's thoughts, or even seeing them. She was no detached observer in this place. She had felt Cinder's grief for the loss of her mother as raw as if it were her own. She had felt her anger and her rage at Atlas for taking her mother from her. And now, she felt Cinder's loneliness. She hadn't been sad to leave Argus because there was nothing there for her. She hadn't had any friends there. She kept to herself, and the other children avoided her. That was a feeling that Sunset knew well enough: reading in the corner of the playground when everyone else was fooling around, convincing yourself that they were wasting their lives while you were making the most of your time because it made you feel a little better; listening to their conversations and wishing that you understood so that you could join them; convincing yourself that the one person in the world who loved you was the only one you needed.


XxXxX​

And sometimes, that was all that you needed. As Sunset watched memories of Cinder's father teaching her how to shoot with a bow, how to fight with two swords the way he said her mother had – Cinder was always using wooden swords at her age – as she watched the way that her father would buy Cinder these glass figurines, these little animals until she had a whole menagerie of them on the shelves of her bedroom wall; as she watched the way she'd run eagerly to him when he came home… as she watched all of that, Sunset was once more reminded uncomfortably of herself. She was reminded of the way, whenever Princess Celestia had to travel to Manehatten or Baltimare or somewhere like that, Sunset would count the days until she came home again, make sure that she was there, one of the first people to greet the princess on her return. She was reminded of the way that they'd sit on the throw rug in front of the fire with hot chocolate as Princess Celestia would explain this or that principle of magic to her. She was reminded of the way she always felt so warm, so safe, so loved in the princess' presence. She was reminded of the softness of Celestia's coat when they nuzzled one another.

XxXxX​

Sometimes, that one person who loved you was all that you needed to get by in life and be happy… but unfortunately, it was rarely possible to stay that way for long.

"Ashley, I want you to meet Lady Clytemnestra Kommenos," Cinder's father said, as he presented this woman to his daughter. "She and I are going to be married this fall."

From Sunset's perspective, Lady Kommenos seemed to be cut very much from the same cloth as Pyrrha's mother; they didn't look alike, but in their carriage and bearing – not to mention the fine quality of their attire – they were very much of a type: proud old women with more ancestors than they had money, and they had a
lot of money. Lady Kommenos, it turned out, had two daughters of her own: Philonoe and Phoebe.

Phoebe? Phoebe Kommenos, and didn't Lady Nikos refer to a Lady Kommenos? Phoebe is Cinder's stepsister?

The look of the two girls was right: the young Phoebe in Cinder's memories had eyes as dark as night and hair of spun gold, just like Phoebe's roots when the dye started to wear off; she wore her hair in curls, long ringlets falling on either side of her face.

They kept that quiet, didn't they?

No. No, it was more than that. It wasn't just that they were pretending not to recognise one another when their paths happened to cross. Cinder had frozen up outside the ice cream parlour, and that hadn't been an act, Sunset would bet Soteria on it.

Cinder had been terrified then.

As she was terrified now. Sunset could feel the fear, the anger – she could
feel it – she felt angry and afraid herself. She wanted to fight and flee at the same time, and Phoebe was the cause.

Sunset wasn't sure that she wanted to find out why.

"I want you to try and make friends with your stepsisters," her father told her. "It isn't right for you to be so alone."

"I'm not alone, Daddy," Cinder said. "I have you."

Her father had smiled at her. "I know you do, my sweet, but I'd like for you to have friends your own age. Will you try, for my sake?"

Cinder nodded. "I'll try, Daddy, I promise."


XxXxX​

Unfortunately, Phoebe and Philonoe were not greatly interested in being friends with their lonely stepsister. Phoebe dreamed of being a great huntress, aided by the finest weapons and armour that her mother and stepfather could buy for her, and she delighted in using her stepsister as a training dummy. Philonoe was more feminine, which only meant that she preferred to hurt her stepsister with words rather than with blows. On one particular night, after seven year-old Phoebe came home grievously upset because a young prodigy two years her junior – a certain Pyrrha Nikos – had beaten her handily in the Junior Tournament, she had taken it out on Cinder so badly that even her father had noticed the results.

For the most part, however, her father's presence prevented the Kommenos girls from going too far, and when he and his daughter were together, things were as they had been before, and if the days of happiness were more intermittent, at least Cinder could be happy with the one person in the world who cared for her.

And then Cinder's father died, and whatever troubles Cinder had felt before were shown to be mere prologue to the misfortunes that now descended upon her head.


XxXxX​

"Stop it!" Cinder shrieked, as Phoebe and Philonoe gleefully smashed all of her glass animals, tearing the fragile ornaments from the shelves to smash to shards and splinters on the floor. Any pieces that survived the fall in recognisable fashion, Phoebe stamped upon until they were as broken as the rest. "Stop. Please stop."

They did not stop. They didn't even hesitate. Cats and dogs, horses and camels, elephants and tigers, they were all hurled down to the floor as though they had incurred the wrath of the gods.

They were so fragile. As frail as human lives. And like those lives, they were destroyed.

Sunset felt tears pricking at the corners of her eyes as she watched Cinder's collection, lovingly built up with gifts from her father, destroyed by her stepsisters for no other reason than because they could.

"Please," Cinder pleaded, lunging towards Phoebe, grabbing her by the arm. "Please don't; they're all-"

Phoebe grabbed Cinder by the neck, and Sunset found herself recoiling in fear as Cinder was slammed into the wall.

"Don't touch me again," Phoebe snarled into Cinder's face. "You know what will happen if you do, don't you?"

Cinder whimpered, and sobbed and nodded frantically. Even Philonoe looked a little discomforted.

Phoebe smirked and released Cinder, who shrank to the ground in the corner of the room, huddling beneath the shelter of her frail arms as her beautiful menagerie was turned to broken glass.

And then, when the stepsisters' sport was done, they made her clean the debris off the floor.


XxXxX​

Sunset could feel everything. She felt the confusion when she was stripped of her room and clothes and dressed in rags to work as a servant in her own house, the fury when she went out into the garden and screamed into the night because her parents had promised, they'd promised that they wouldn't leave her, so where were they? Mother said that she wanted to see what Cinder did with her life, Father had promised that things would get better, but they'd just gotten so much worse, and they'd left her! Her own parents had abandoned her to the mercies of these people! She hated them. She hated all of them; she hated Phoebe and Philonoe and Lady Kommenos who made her do all the work around the house, and she hated mother and her father too for leaving her.

Sunset could feel all of it. The hate, the rage, the desire to get back at each and every one of them coursing through her, burning away at her childhood kindness. She felt the brooding anger that accompanied each slight, the deadening sensation that came from trying to cope with a constant stream of insults and abuse, the ever-present brooding melancholy that consumed her. She felt everything that was done to Cinder as though it had been done to herself: the humiliation, the degradation, the way her home became a prison with the added insult that she was responsible for maintaining it.


XxXxX​

"-never been so humiliated in all my life!" Lady Kommenos cried. "Lady Nikos practically laughed in my face!"

Phoebe looked down in shame. "It's not my fault, Mother."

"Of course it's your fault, you stupid girl!" Lady Kommenos shouted. "Pyrrha made a laughingstock out of you. You couldn't even land a single blow on her!"

"She's cheating!" Phoebe snapped. "I know she is; I just don't-"

Lady Kommenos' hand struck swift and hard, slapping Phoebe across the face, twisting her head sharply.

"Enough!" Lady Kommenos snapped. "Do you have any idea how ludicrous you sound when you make such accusations? You make yourself seem not only useless, but a sore loser too. If all the money I spend on your training and equipment cannot deliver victory, then you could at least seek to impress the crowds with your grace and bearing in defeat!"

As she scrubbed the floor in that room, Cinder felt – and Sunset felt it too – a touch of well-deserved schadenfreude at Phoebe's humiliation.

Unfortunately, she made the mistake of snorting loud enough for Phoebe to hear her.

And the look in Phoebe's eye as she looked at Cinder drove all pleasure from Cinder's heart completely.


XxXxX​

Cinder shivered, and Sunset shivered too. She was afraid. She was terribly, terribly afraid. The room was dark, and Sunset felt as though there was a monster in there with them, out of sight, waiting, prowling. She wanted to run, but she couldn't. She did not dare. Her legs – her whole body – was frozen in place.

She was hiding in one of the pantry cupboards, in the dark, her body contorted to fit in that small space. She covered her mouth with both hands, even as her eyes welled up.

She didn't want to risk any sound getting out.

"Cinder?" Phoebe called in a sing-song voice. "Come out, come out, wherever you are?"

Cinder didn't move. Didn't make a sound, because there was a monster in the kitchen, and she was desperate not to be found.

"Open your eyes, you have to get up," Phoebe called, as Sunset could hear her footsteps in the kitchen beyond the darkness.

"Monsters are coming to gobble you up.

Out of bed, hide under the floor,

The monsters are breaking down the door."

Cinder stifled a moan of fear and tried to shrink back yet further into the cupboard.

"Hide in the cupboard, are they near?

Monsters know how to smell your fear."

Cinder's fear only rose at that; she began to quiver with panic, wondering if she had chosen the right hiding place, if maybe she should have hidden somewhere else, if maybe the garden would have been better.

"You'll hear the screams and then you'll know:

Mommy and Daddy can't help you now."

The cupboard door opened. Candlelight flooded inside, dispelling the darkness to reveal Phoebe, a smile like a knife upon her face.

"Close your eyes, don't look up," she said.

"Here comes a monster to gobble you up."

Cinder screamed, but no help came. She beat at Phoebe, but it was all in vain as she was dragged, kicking and screaming and struggling to no avail, out of the cupboard and into the kitchen.

Sunset didn't want to see what was coming next. She didn't want to be a witness to it, she didn't want to be a part of it. She turned away, she closed her eyes, she covered her ears against the screaming.

But she felt it, nonetheless.

She felt it all.


XxXxX​

It was her stepsisters who started calling her Cinder instead of Ashley; they called it her for so long, and they and her stepmother were the only people that she spent any time with, that it had become her name. Who was Ashley? A foolish, spoiled little girl who hadn't understood the way the world really worked, an idiot who believed in love and happiness and that the arms of a parent would keep you safe. Ashley was another girl, who had lived another life, a pleasant life and one to be envious of, but not her life. Not her. That hadn't happened to her. All of those things that they remembered had happened to somebody else. She was Cinder. Cinder Little-Glas- no. No, that wasn't her either. Those names meant nothing to her. They belonged to the people who had abandoned her. They were somebody else's parents, and she didn't want their name. She was Cinder, Cinder nothing, Cinder of the fireplace, Cinder the slave; just Cinder.

Cinder the Destined. When she was not working, she read; she read the old Mistralian warrior epics, full of great princes and warriors driven on by destiny to great and terrible fates. If they had endured adversity, it was no matter, because they had destiny carrying them forward, and secure in that knowledge, they had gone forth and endured all trials. That was her; that was what she had to be: destined, and confident in her destiny. It didn't matter how much they teased her, they beat her, they insulted her; it didn't matter what they made her do or where they made her sleep. All that mattered was that she had a destiny, a great destiny, the greatest destiny that had ever been seen in the world of Remnant, and she would overcome all of this and all of them because destiny had willed it so.

Phoebe went to Atlas Academy; despite the money lavished on her training and equipment, she continued to be, at best, an average fighter. Her path crossed that of Pyrrha Nikos more than once, and every time, she was effortlessly swatted aside. And while she was away at school, Cinder would steal her training weapons in the middle of the night and resume the instruction that her father had begun: with the bow, with the twin swords, with the javelin. She unlocked her aura simply by persistently willing that it should be so. She trained by night until she was at least as good as her stepsister was who trained during the day and with no expense spared.

When she was fourteen years old, with stepsister Phoebe away at Atlas, Cinder Nothing had locked her stepmother and stepsister Philonoe inside the house and then burned it to the ground.

Sunset could feel the heat of the flames as she stood and watched it burn. She could feel the satisfaction as her stepmother and stepsister screamed for help which did not come. She could feel the glee at being free of them, the joy at their being dead, the feeling that once again, life lay open before her to choose her own path.

She could be whatever she wanted to be in this world.

She had fought, she had killed, she had stolen; she had disdained the criminal gangs who infested Mistral's lower levels and had rained down wrath on any who tried to use her for their purposes. Cinder had aimed at higher things than simply being a skilled enforcer.

She had her sights upon the upper town, upon the high society that her father and her unlamented stepmother had been a part of.


XxXxX​

Sunset saw a party, a glittering Mistralian party, more crowded even than the reception that she, Sunset herself, had attended in Mistral as Pyrrha's guest. Everyone was so splendidly turned out; jewellery glittered upon every lady's neck and arm and finger, and on many of the men as well. The colours were a riot of golds and reds and purples. The air was rich with the scent of expensive perfume. The great and the good of Mistral mingled and talked and danced and ordered the whole kingdom as they willed.

Mistral was ruled from such events as these, Cinder realised; the policies of the kingdom were set not in the council chamber but by men and women of good family setting the world to rights over hors d'oeuvres, accompanied by glasses of exquisitely aged wine that had been laid down in the days of their many-times great-grandfathers.

Sunset saw Pyrrha, younger then but quite recognisable, already the talk of the city; the great and the good fawned over her; Pyrrha's mother stood over her, basking in the reflected glory of her daughter's skills as people talked of her as a champion of the regional tournament, of the city, even of the Vytal Festival.

It was strange; as herself, Sunset could recognise the signs of Pyrrha's discomfort with all of this, the way that she didn't talk much, the way she looked and held herself with subtle discomfort… but Cinder didn't notice any of that, and so, through her memories, Sunset could feel all of the resentment, the rage that Cinder had felt – and still felt, now that Sunset reconsidered some of the things that Cinder had said about Pyrrha – towards her: the precious princess of Mistral, the spoiled brat, the girl who had everything she ever wanted handed to her because everyone loved her so much, the girl who never had to work for anything in her whole life because she was pretty and rich and came from the right family, and so, she didn't have any worries. She got all the chances, she got all the choices, she could be anything that she wanted in this world, while Cinder… it was as though people could tell, despite her stolen dress, that she didn't belong here, that she wasn't one of them, that she was an outsider, unwanted, unclean.

She hated them. She hated all of them. Sunset could feel the rage, the hollow absence of all other feelings; no one to love, no one to cherish, nothing but hatred, hatred incarnate, hate for Mistral, hate for Pyrrha, hate for Phoebe away at Atlas, hate for the high society that didn't want her, hate for the parents who had abandoned her, hate for the whole wretched system of the world that seemed determined to destroy people like her.

She had lived a life of fear and powerlessness, but no more; she would be the one to put others in fear with her power. She would be the enemy of this world and its destruction.

She was Cinder, and she would see this whole rotten edifice… Fall.


XxXxX​

Sunset saw-

XxXxX​

"NO! Get out of my head!"

Sunset was jolted out of Cinder's thoughts and feelings as she felt a powerful punch to the stomach that threw her, pinwheeling through the air, to land flat on her face on the stone.

Sunset groaned just a little as she looked up. Cinder was gasping. Her face was pale and she looked… she looked afraid.

"What…" Cinder murmured. "What was that?"

Sunset started to push herself up off the ground. "Did… did all of that really happen to you?"

"Stay where you are!" Cinder snapped, and Sunset had the sense that she was now – perhaps for the first and only time – seeing the real Cinder, stripped of all the masks that she used to hide herself from the world and all those in it. "Stay away from me."

"Cinder…" Sunset murmured. "Ashley-"

"Don't call me that!" Cinder snarled. "I... I care for you, Sunset; you make me feel... but if you call me by that name again, I will burn you from the inside out, I swear it!" She breathed heavily, in and out. "My name… my name is Cinder Fall, the harbinger of this world's destruction! I'm not… I'm not some stupid little girl who believed that her mother loved her and that her father would protect her from all danger! I am Cinder Fall, and my destiny will not be denied! Not by Ozpin, not by Ironwood, not by Pyrrha Nikos, not by all the power of Atlas and Mistral! And not by you either, Sunset Shimmer. If you have really seen what you were never meant to see, then you have to know that I won't stop until-"

She was stopped in mid-flow by a bright spotlight suddenly shining down upon her, illuminating her like the star of a play.

Sunset looked up to see an Atlesian dropship, the first of several swooping down out of the night sky, shining the spotlight down on Cinder.

"This is the Atlesian military. Keep your hands where we can-"

Cinder ran. She turned and ran, fleeing into the night with the Atlesian dropship in pursuit.

Sunset did not pursue. She wasn't really dressed for a fight, she didn't have her dust… and as one hand went to her stomach, to the scar that Adam had given her, Sunset couldn't help but reflect on how badly it seemed to go for when she pushed her luck in battle.

So she stood there, her enemy gone, but her soul full of the feelings that that enemy had left behind.

She could still feel it. All the anger, all the rage, all the bitterness. When she thought about Atlas, Cinder's disdain mingled with her own feelings towards it, amplifying the bitter memories that she had about Canterlot and warring with the attachment she felt towards RSPT. When she thought about Pyrrha, Cinder's hatred mingled with her own affection like oil and water, her thoughts flickering between her own feelings and those of Cinder from moment to moment.

Sunset would have liked – she would very much have liked – to say that she had never felt so much anger and hate inside anyone before, but that wasn't true. She had felt it before: inside herself.

Thinking about Cinder was like looking in a mirror.

And it was terrifying.
 
Chapter 82 - The End of the Night
The End of the Night​


Pyrrha was coming increasingly to regret the fact that she had stayed in the ballroom after Sunset, Ruby, and the Rosepetals departed; judging by the uneasy look on his face, it seemed that Jaune was feeling the same way.

Like everyone else – she could hardly have missed it – she had heard the crash as Rainbow Dash leapt down from the upper gallery to land in the middle of the dance floor, yelled for Penny, and then rushed out into the night. She had seen Ruby, Penny, Sunset, and Ciel follow Rainbow out, but she had not followed herself. She hadn't been asked for, Jaune hadn't been asked for, and Sunset and Ruby had seemed more curious as to what Rainbow was doing and why she was acting this way than they seemed to have been requested or required by her.

Whatever was going on with Rainbow Dash of Team RSPT, Pyrrha had told herself that it was none of her business, and it had been easy to tell herself so, at first, once the immediate disturbance of Rainbow's entry and abrupt departure had subsided and the dancing had resumed. Jaune was here, his arms were around her, seeming to fit her body so perfectly as if they had been made for one another. They had the music and each other, and in his arms, she felt so comfortable and so wanted and so…so happy that it was easy to tell herself that Sunset and Ruby would soon return, that whatever had so bothered Rainbow was nothing that ought to bother Pyrrha, that everything was going to be alright, and they could continue to dance and talk untroubled.

But then General Ironwood stalked out of the ballroom, grim-faced, his look as hard as the armour on one of his warships, and it got a little bit harder for Pyrrha to tell herself that. Jaune also began to look more troubled, and the fact that – contrary to what Pyrrha, at least, had expected – Sunset and Ruby did not swiftly return only added to the sense of unease that was building up like a dust charge in her gut.

They weren't the only ones to have noticed that something was up. Yang was looking increasingly agitated, and Emerald and Mercury of Team CLEM – neither their team leader nor their fourth teammate had come to the dance tonight, as far as Pyrrha could see – were looking worried as well, although in their case, it was harder to understand.

By this time, Pyrrha and Jaune had stopped dancing and were sitting at one of the tables that lined the eastern edge of the ballroom.

"Do you think we should have gone with them?" Jaune asked.

"They… they didn't ask for us," Pyrrha said, although even as she said it, she could tell how feeble it sounded in her ears. She frowned. "But, yes, I'm beginning to think so."

Jaune looked as though he wished that she'd given him a different answer. "But… come on, we're in the middle of Beacon; how much trouble could they really have gotten into?"

Pyrrha looked at him, and in that moment, she was sure that they were both thinking the same thing.

"Yeah, we should go look for them," Jaune said as she started to rise from his seat.

"I'm not sure that Professor Ozpin would approve of that," Blake murmured as she drifted over to their table. With a jerk of her head, she gestured to the headmaster standing by the doorway, a benign smile seeming to be fixed upon his face as he – by the looks of it – attempted to dissuade Yang from leaving the party early. Yang was gesticulating wildly with her arms, but so far, she hadn't just pushed past him and left anyway.

Pyrrha pursed her lips together. "I'm sure that the professor has his reasons, even if they're not immediately clear to us."

"Probably," Blake agreed. "Although that doesn't mean that he has good reasons, necessarily."

"What if they really are in trouble?" Jaune asked anxiously.

Blake's expression was pensive, her brow furrowed slightly. "I'm going to go to the bathroom," she murmured. She looked at Pyrrha. "Wait two minutes, then go in yourself and meet me outside the window."

"Is it empty?"

"Cinder's teammate Emerald went in a little while ago," Blake said. "But that's the advantage of the ladies' room: solid doors."

Their plans were interrupted by the tramp, tramp, tramp of marching feet upon stone, the thumping, stomping sound that preceded the arrival of a column of Atlesian troops led by what Pyrrha guessed to be a pair of specialists in blue flight suits with yellow flashes on their collars. The music stopped as the Atlesians entered the ballroom, and all the dancing ceased as well, as everyone on the floor – everyone in the room – went quiet and stared at the new arrivals as they strode in with weapons at the ready.

Professor Ozpin seemed, if not nervous, then at the least none too pleased by this intrusion by the forces of Atlas. The genial smile was gone from his face, and he no longer leant upon his cane as he made his way over to one of the two specialists, a woman with red-amber hair in a wild, spiky cut like flames burning on top of her head.

"May I ask what you intend by this show of force, specialist?" Professor Ozpin asked. "This is still a school, not an Atlesian military base."

The female specialist glanced at him. "Sir, what's gone on here tonight should concern you just as much as it concerns us." She raised her voice. "I'm looking for Emerald Sustrai and Mercury Black of Haven Academy's Team Clementine. Emerald Sustral and Mercury Black, will someone please identify them?"

A murmur ran through the students in the ballroom.

"What's this about?" Yang demanded. "What's going on?"

"If you're name isn't Emerald Sustrai or Mercury Black-"

"Dammit, I want to know if my sister is okay!" Yang snapped.

"Emerald and Mercury both went to the bathroom, a few minutes ago," Blake said, getting up and stepping away from Pyrrha and Jaune's table. "They haven't come out."

The specialist glanced at Blake and might have recognised her; it was hard to tell if the nod she gave was simple acknowledgement or if it had any respect in it. "Soarin', take the little boys' room."

"Right," the male specialist – Soarin', one could only assume – acknowledged, and a pair of Atlesian soldiers split off from the main group behind each of the two specialists as they both produced their weapons: the woman carried what looked like some kind of flamethrower, judging by the bulging tank of fire dust at one end; the man carried a crimson tower shield and what Pyrrha at first took to be a sword before it transformed into an assault rifle in his hand.

The students made way for them – encouraged by the professors, who all moved to in some way shield the students from anything that might be about to happen – as they approached the doors into the two bathrooms, which sat side by side at the far end of the room. They approached, waited outside the doors for a moment, nodded to one another, and then as one, they kicked in the doors and burst into the respective toilets.

A moment later, they both emerged, looking disgruntled.

"The window was open?" the woman asked.

"Yeah," Soarin' said. "You?"

"The same," the woman growled. She tapped something in her ear. "General, this is Spitfire. Sustrai and Black aren't here; they slipped out of the bathroom windows before we arrived. I had Misty and Fleetfoot covering the back, but they didn't see anything; they must have cleared out before we were set up. We got here too late. Blitz too, sir? They must have known we were coming. Do you want us to do a sweep of the whole grounds? Roger that, sir. Oh, General, one more thing. I've got a lot of anxious people here; what should I tell them? Yes, sir, on the double."

The woman who had identified herself as Spitfire cleared her throat. "Ladies and gentlemen, tonight, the CCT tower here in Beacon was attacked by an individual named Cinder Fall," – a shocked murmur ran through the ballroom, but Spitfire ignored it to continue speaking – "this individual was stopped before she could accomplish any serious damage but managed to evade Atlesian forces and is still at large. Her teammates have also fled before they could be questioned with regards to the extent of their knowledge and involvement."

Murmurs of shock and alarm ran through the crowd – Pyrrha knew from just a glance at Jaune that he had put it all together just as much as she had – but Spitfire didn't give them a chance to finish.

"General Ironwood requests that all students remain here under the protection of these guards while our forces conduct a thorough search of the campus for these fugitives."

"In this instance, I am inclined to agree with the General," Professor Ozpin said, raising his voice until, like the clouds on an overcast day, it blanketed all the other voices in the ballroom. "Please, ladies and gentlemen, I urge you all to remain calm. I assure you that there is neither cause for alarm nor reason to panic. I apologise for the disruption to what had proven a most entertaining evening, but I promise you are all perfectly safe; I have little doubt that the fugitives have already fled the grounds, but just in case, you will all remain here until the all-clear is sounded, and your professors and I will join our Atlesian allies in standing guard until the school has been thoroughly investigated. Team leaders, please give the names of any of your teammates who are not here to Professor Goodwitch, who will go round them up and bring them back here so that everyone can be accounted for."

"Why should we just stay here?" Yang asked. "We can help! And what about Ruby? You still haven't told me anything about where my sister is!"

"I am sure that you would all be quite willing to assist the investigation at this time, Miss Xiao Long, but it would be imprudent of me to allow students to venture out into the night against an enemy who… might well turn out to be too much for you to handle," Professor Ozpin said. "It is for the best that you all remain here."

"Not until I know that Ruby's okay!"

"Which one of you is Jaune Arc?" Spitfire demanded.

Jaune looked a little uncertain as he got to his feet. "I-I'm Jaune Arc."

"Come with me," Spitfire said. "We need your semblance."

"What?" Pyrrha asked. "Is someone hurt?"

"Is it Ruby?" Yang asked.

"No, it's one of our people, but there is a little Vale kid up there too, I think," Spitfire said. "Come with me, and you'll see for yourself."

XxXxX​

Rainbow Dash groaned. Her aura was taking a while to come back after it had been broken by Cinder, and even when it did come back, it wouldn't fix all of these injuries right away. Which meant that she was just going to have to suffer through the pain for a while. There was nothing especially wrong with that – she could handle the pain – what she couldn't do was handle it quietly.

She groaned again, and Twilight let out a little yelp as though she was getting sympathy pains or something. Twilight was the closest to Rainbow Dash as they waited in the wrecked computer room. Penny, Ciel, and Ruby were all standing guard, but Twilight was just sort of lingering there, looking down at the floor and now making noises.

Rainbow winced as she sat up a little straighter. "Twi? Are you okay? You told me that she didn't hurt you, right?"

She had thought that she'd been there in time to save Twilight from any real harm; she'd thought that Twi's aura hadn't broken. If she'd been wrong about that, if Twilight had gotten hurt… how was she going to live with it? How was she gonna explain it to everyone back home?

"Rainbow Dash," Twilight's voice was soft and quiet and so pitiable it was mushing up Rainbow's heart, not that she'd ever admit to that. "I'm sorry."

"'Sorry'?" Rainbow repeated uncomprehendingly. "Come on, Twilight, what do you have to be sorry about?"

Twilight looked at her, and Rainbow saw that her eyes were filled with ears. "This is all my fault!" she wailed. "If I hadn't been here, or if I'd been stronger, then you wouldn't have had to come rescue me and-"

"Hey," Rainbow said, not unkindly but firmly enough to cut her off. With one hand, she gestured for Twilight to come closer. "Come here."

Twilight blinked. "Huh?"

"Just... come here," Rainbow said. She appreciated the way that nobody else in the room was looking at them; this was going to be hard enough without people staring at them. "It'll only be for a second."

Twilight looked uncertain, nervous, a little on edge still, but nevertheless, she came closer, stepping around the debris that littered the floor and kneeling down upon that floor next to Rainbow Dash.

"Does… does it hurt?"

"A little," Rainbow admitted. "Only for now, though."

"I'm sorry, I-"

"Stop saying that," Rainbow said. "My job – part of my job – is to keep you safe. And I did that tonight." She wiped away Twi's tears with one hand. "So what if I took a couple of hits doin' it? You're safe. That's all that matters."

Twilight closed her eyes. "Don't you ever get tired of having to take care of me?"

"Never," Rainbow said firmly. She put one hand on the back of Twilight's head and nudged it so that their foreheads were touching. Rainbow closed her eyes too, for a moment. "That's why it doesn't matter if you don't know how to fight someone like Cinder, because you're my friend, and I will always be there to keep you safe." 'To each of us falls a task,' that was what Rainbow believed, just like she'd told Yang and Blake; Rainbow didn't know what Twilight's task was yet, but she was sure it wasn't to fight anybody. And if Rainbow's task turned out to be just keeping Twi safe, well… that was okay by her. "You don't need to apologise to me; I should be the one saying sorry. I wasn't there for you when you needed me."

Twilight shook her head, pulling away. "No, you…" She trailed off, but then she smiled. "You were right in the nick of time, just like a hero should be."

Rainbow sniggered, and then winced when the sudden movement caused the pain in her side to flare up.

The elevator arrived on their floor and opened with a ding sound that drew every eye. Ciel reacted on instinct, aiming Distant Thunder at the lift as the metal doors slid open.

"At ease, Soleil," General Ironwood said, looking supremely unconcerned about the ridiculously large gun being aimed at him as he strode out of the elevator and into the room that had briefly been a battlefield. "If our enemies do come back, they'll have to get through Specialist Schnee this time."

Ciel lowered her weapon. "Sorry, sir. I suppose I am a little… on edge."

"Understandable, in the circumstances," General Ironwood said as he clasped his hands behind his back and walked towards Rainbow Dash and Twilight.

Rainbow tried to rise to her feet, gritting her teeth against the pain. "Sir-"

"Don't get up," General Ironwood instructed. He looked down at Rainbow, and then at Twilight. His voice softened, his tone becoming kind and almost fatherly. "Twilight, are you alright? How are you feeling?"

Twilight wiped her eyes with one hand. "I'm… kind of a little shook up, I suppose, but I'm fine, sir, thank you for asking."

"Are you sure?" Ironwood said. "I understand that she had you cornered for a while. I should have provided more security."

"Rainbow Dash arrived quickly enough, sir," Twilight murmured.

"And for that, you have my thanks, and that of Atlas," General Ironwood said, with a look down at Rainbow Dash. "What about you, Dash? How are you feeling?"

Rainbow groaned. "I'm not used to losing, sir, but I'll live." She smiled, though a wince of pain got out to ruin it a little. "My pride's hurt worse than I am."

"If she's what I'm afraid she is, then you've got nothing to be ashamed of," General Ironwood muttered.

Rainbow frowned. "Sir?"

"Nothing," General Ironwood said quickly. He pinched the space between his brows, seeming annoyed at himself. "You did well," he told her. "You reacted swiftly and decisively, and you performed the first duty of any team leader: to protect your teammates. Yes, the enemy got away, but Twilight lived, and so did you; that's what matters here, and that's what makes tonight a victory." He paused. "But the fact remains that this should never have happened."

"Permission to speak, sir?" Ciel asked.

"Granted, Soleil."

"May I enquire as to the status of the criminals?"

"Unfortunately, Cinder Fall and all her teammates have escaped or slipped away before we could get to them," General Ironwood admitted. "We're searching the campus, but if they're smart, they'll have left the school already."

"General, sir," Twilight said, as she climbed to her feet. "I think Cinder probably wiped all the evidence, although I haven't checked, but… before she arrived, my trace on the email that she sent just finished… one of the locations that it was routed through to conceal its origin was Draco."

Rainbow's eyebrows rose. "The dragon continent? But there's nothing there but grimm! Isn't there?"

"I thought so," Twilight murmured. "But what if I'm wrong? What if we're all wrong?"

General Ironwood frowned. For a moment, he didn't say anything at all; he looked as though he was thinking about something. "I believe you, regardless of whether the evidence is still there, and I'll consider what you've told me. In the meantime, I know that you've been through a lot tonight, but are you able to work?"

"Yes, I am," Twilight said.

"Twi, you don't have to-" Rainbow began.

"Yes, I do," Twilight said firmly. "You got hurt tonight because I don't know how to defend myself, because I wasn't able to stand up to Cinder; you say that I'm not useless, well, okay, but then let me be useful. This is what I know how to do. What do you need, General?"

"I want you to do a complete systems diagnostic," General Ironwood said. "Check everything; Cinder doesn't seem to have expected you to be here, which means that she came to the tower with other intentions, and I want to find out what those intentions were and how much progress she made with them. Check everything, everywhere, and remove anything dangerous that our guest might have left behind."

"Yes, sir," Twilight said. She hesitated. "Although… I could use a fresh pair of glasses from my room."

"I'll have someone bring them over," Ironwood said. "I don't want you leaving this room until I give the all-clear. I know I said it's unlikely that they're still on the grounds, but I don't want to take any chances. For that reason, Ciel, Penny, I want you to remain here on guard."

"Yes, sir," Ciel said.

"General," Penny said softly. "Why would Cinder want to do this? Wasn't she supposed to be a student, one of us?"

"She was never one of us," Ciel muttered darkly.

"Because she wasn't from Atlas or because she wasn't a huntress?" Ruby demanded.

Ciel was silent for a moment. "Neither would appear to be the case, at present."

"It's true that Cinder did play the part of a student, as did her teammates," General Ironwood said. "But it appears likely that that was just a ruse, to gain entry into Beacon for… for some purpose that has yet to be determined."

"But why?" Penny asked again. "She was even friends with Sunset! She helped save Twilight and Ruby and everyone in the forest!"

"Ingratiating herself as part of her cover, perhaps," Ciel suggested.

"But why would she betray us all like this now?" Penny demanded.

"We don't know yet, Penny," Twilight said softly. "Like the General said, it's yet to be determined."

"I wish that I could tell you more," General Ironwood declared. "Really, Penny, I do, and that goes for all of you here. But for now, I have to ask you to trust me and stand guard until I tell you otherwise."

"What about me?" Ruby asked.

"Miss Rose, you're not under my command," General Ironwood said, "but I would take it as a favour to me if you would stay also. Your teammates will be up shortly."

Ruby nodded. "You can rely on me, sir." Her scroll began to buzz. Ruby laughed nervously. "That's probably just my sister…" she murmured as she pulled out the scroll from behind her. "Ah! It's Sunset!"

XxXxX​

Sunset could half see the tower from where she stood, in the shadow and the shade of the trees that stood in the Beacon courtyard, with the dirt around it scuffing her feet as she hid under the leaves from the moonlight that might otherwise have illuminated her presence and location.

She didn't want to be seen right now, not by anyone. Hence why she had skulked off after her fight with Cinder and hidden, sort of, in a place where she could see the tower but where she was pretty sure that nobody up in the tower could see her. She'd revealed herself to the Atlesian soldiers and huntsmen searching the grounds, because she wasn't that stupid, but she didn't want Ruby, Jaune, or Pyrrha or Team RSPT to see her.

She didn't want to see them because she hated them, all those interfering-

Sunset shuddered. She didn't want to see them because of stuff like that. She wasn't sure that she could keep it all inside.

She didn't really want to call Ruby either, but she knew that if she didn't do anything, then they'd probably come looking for her, and she certainly didn't want that. So, as she looked up at the tower from her sort-of hiding place, Sunset took out her scroll with trembling hands and selected Ruby from her address book.

She called voice-only, so that she didn't have to see Ruby's face and feel… whatever it was that Cinder felt about her.

"Sunset!" Ruby cried, her voice emerging loudly from out of the scroll. "Are you okay?"

"Yeah," Sunset lied. "Yeah, I'm fine."

"Where are you?"

"It doesn't matter."

"What do you mean 'it doesn't matter'? You just-"

"I said it doesn't matter, which means that it shouldn't concern you!" Sunset snapped. She scowled, at herself. "I'm sorry, Ruby, I'm really sorry. I didn't mean to… I'm just a little… I'm sorry, I didn't mean it."

"Sunset…are you sure you're okay?" Ruby asked, her voice suffused with concern.

"I told you I was fine."

"I know," Ruby replied. "But you don't sound it."

"I…" Sunset hesitated. "I'm just a little high strung after… you know."

Ruby was quiet for a moment. "She got away, didn't she?"

Sunset made a noise that was not quite a word. "I couldn't stop her."

"Well, neither did we, so don't beat yourself up about it," Ruby said. "Twilight's safe, and she's checking out the computers now, and at least we know that she's a bad guy now, so everyone will be looking for her, so it's not like she got away clean or anything." Ruby paused. "You liked her, didn't you?"

Or was it seeing my reflection in the mirror that I liked? "She… Ruby, is it okay if I say that I don't want to talk about this right now?"

"I guess," Ruby said. "Just… you know that you can talk to me, right? I'm sure that you can talk to all of us, but, if you want to, you can talk to me."

Sunset couldn't help but smile, if only for a moment. "Yeah, I know. Listen, do you know where Jaune and Pyrrha are?" She shuddered at the unexpected venom which she put into Pyrrha's name. She hated her.

Of all the warriors loved by the gods, I hate her the most.

No. No, I don't; that's Cinder.
She hates Pyrrha, not me.

I don't hate her… that's why I can't risk being around her right now.


Cinder's emotions boiled like an angry sea inside of Sunset's soul. Thinking about the things – the people – that made Cinder mad was enough to get Sunset mad in turn; it didn't matter that Sunset knew Pyrrha better than Cinder ever would, it didn't matter that Sunset understood all the things that Cinder had so angrily misconstrued about who and what Pyrrha was, it didn't matter that Pyrrha was one of Sunset's best friends; right now, just thinking about her was starting to make Sunset furious. She didn't know what she'd say, what she'd do if she saw her.

She had to stay away until she could get a grip on this.

"No," Ruby said. "But I think they're on their way up here. They're going to want to know that you're okay."

"Tell them I'm fine," Sunset said. "But tell them… tell them I won't be coming home tonight."

Ruby was silent for a moment. "Sunset, where are you? What's going on?"

"Nothing," Sunset insisted. "I've just… facing Cinder… I've got some stuff to think about. Things to sort through in my head. So… don't worry when I'm not back tonight. Tell them that, will you?"

"Sure," Ruby said softly. "Sunset… if something's wrong, you know we're all here for you, right?"

"Yeah," Sunset said quickly. "Yeah, I know. Goodnight, Ruby. I'll see you around." She snapped the scroll shut and put it away.

We're all here for you.

But I don't know if I can be here for you right now.

I don't know how safe it is for me to be around you all right now.

I don't know when I'm going to get a grip on this.


It was the sort of thing that she might have spoken to Twilight about – Princess Twilight was someone about whom Cinder had no opinion to interfere with Sunset's own attitudes – except that the journal was up in her room, and she couldn't go back to get it without risking running into somebody that she didn't want to see.

So much hatred, so much contempt, so much venom in everything that she thought about everyone. She hated Pyrrha, she despised Jaune, she wanted Ruby dead, but – for whatever it might be worth – it wasn't as personal as her desire to accomplish Pyrrha's destruction was. Blake was vermin in her eyes. Rainbow Dash was a blustering oaf who deserved to see her world burn before her eyes before she died, and Cinder's general contempt was only heightened by the sense that she had been responsible for tonight's failure. She wanted Twilight to burn. Yang's smile had infuriated her, Nora's laughter made her want to rip the girl's tongue out of her throat, Weiss was emblematic of everything that she reviled about the world. Sunset herself… Sunset was the only one that Cinder didn't either dislike or hold in contempt.

That was the worst thing of all, to be honest. Sunset could have stood to know that her enemy didn't like her very much, but instead… instead, she liked her. She had actually liked her. That hadn't been a lie. Cinder's own emotions confirmed it.

She'd thought that they could be friends, for a while, until Cinder had to kill her… because they were so alike.

What am I going to do?

Sunset sighed and ran one hand through her hair as she looked up at the uncaring moon above her.

Won't someone please tell me what I should do?

XxXxX​

The sky was cloudless, and Cinder could see the moon hanging above her without interruption.

The moon and all the stars as well. They shone bright above, uncaring of Cinder's plight, heedless of the fact that she had been exposed for the serpent she was, forced to fly from Beacon a wanted fugitive.

She had loved the sight of them once, but now… now she found them cold and cruel, the witnesses of her failure.

Failure. Yes, she had failed. It was a bitter draught, made all the more bitter because it was so novel to her. Cinder Fall was not used to failure. Failure, defeat, flight, these were things that happened to someone else, to a different girl, younger and more foolish in every respect.

The girl into whose heart Sunset had seen, the girl whose past had been laid bare to her.

I am not she, and she is not me. What Sunset saw was the past of someone dead, the last echoes of a ghost.

That girl burned to death in the fire, just the same as Philonoe and Lady Kommenos.

I am not her, and she is not me. I am Cinder Fall, and I do not fail.


And yet she had failed. It was the first time. Even her prior setback had been at least a partial success, but this… this had been an unmitigated disaster. They knew who she was, and she and her followers had had to fly from Beacon one step ahead of the Atlesian forces; while it was not guaranteed that they would discover the virus she had planted in the CCT, Cinder would not bet against the fact, which meant that they could not rely on turning the strength of Atlas against them.

When the blow fell, they would find all the guns of Atlas waiting and ready to oppose them.

Meddling daughters of the north. Self-righteous self-appointed defenders of the world. Of all the warriors at Beacon, Cinder detested Pyrrha the most, that vain and foolish princess, but as a group, there was none that drew her ire more than the daughters of the north who walked so proud, who talked so bold, who thought that they could go wither they would, do what they would, order all things as they would without reference to anyone but themselves.

They thought themselves so powerful and, in their power, so secure. But Cinder meant to show them what true power looked like and how their technological prowess of which they were so proud paled by comparison.

But how? Yes, how? How was she to proceed now? How was she to explain this setback to her mistress?

I am not without advantages, even now. She still had the White Fang force massing under Adam's command; she still had all the dust that Torchwick had acquired for her; the anvil may have been shattered, but the hammer remained intact.

But what good was a hammer without an anvil? It could shatter glass, but it would no more than dent steel.

I must be an alchemist then, and turn steel into glass that it may be broken.

As she began to consider how that might be accomplished, Cinder felt a smile spread across her face. Yes. Yes, that was a way, if Salem would permit it. The resources existed to have it so. Yes, that would do.

This was not the end. She was not yet defeated.

Her scroll went off. Cinder wondered if she should, perhaps, have gotten rid of it; she had thought it untraceable, thanks to the efforts of Doctor Watts, but evidently, it was not so. Twilight Sparkle had found a way to breach his many layers of security, even if it had taken her the processing power of the CCT to do it.

Yes, she should certainly dispose of this, but it was a good thing that she had waited until after she had had this conversation.

Not that was glad to see that Sweetie Drops was calling – in fact, Cinder rolled her eyes at the identity of her caller – but she supposed she ought to answer.

There was some slim chance that the idiot had something worth hearing.

Nevertheless, Cinder didn't bother to keep the irritation out of her voice as she answered. "What?" she demanded.

"Did they make you?" Bon Bon asked, hissing anxiously into her scroll. "Everyone's saying that you attacked the CCT! Did they make you?"

The call was voice only, but Cinder almost wished that Bon Bon could see the look of seething disgust, teeth clenched, eyes smouldering, upon her face. "The operation was not as successful as might have been hoped for."

"Don't give me that crap-"

"Watch your tongue," Cinder growled. "I am still the appointed leader of this operation. You are tasked with serving and obeying me."

"Appointed by who?" Bon Bon demanded. "Wait, never mind, I don't want to know. Where are you?"

"That's not something you need to know, any more than you need to know whom I serve," Cinder informed her sharply.

"I need to know where you are so that I can join you!"

"No," Cinder said coldly. "You don't."

"I do, what if they-"

"If they even suspected your involvement with me, you wouldn't be at liberty to make this call," Cinder told her.

"Your cover is blown, the mission is done, you need to extract me-"

"DO NOT TELL ME WHAT I NEED TO DO!" Cinder roared into her scroll. "I DO NOT TAKE INSTRUCTION FROM YOU, YOU STUPID INCOMPETENT DEADWEIGHT! YOU HAVE BEEN PRACTICALLY USELESS TO ME SINCE YOU ARRIVED AT BEACON!"

She took a deep breath, mastering herself. "But you have an opportunity to redeem yourself and serve me better from now on. Let me clear up what seems to be your misconception: this mission is not over. I am not finished. Certainly, I am not defeated. This is a setback, but one from which I will recover and rise in glory greater than my enemies can imagine. You are, once more, my eyes at Beacon. So you will go to Twilight Sparkle and her friends and tell her that her near death has given you a new perspective on things, you will apologise for all your quarrels, and you will beg their forgiveness. They, being… such performatively good people, will accept your apology and welcome you with open arms. And you will tell me everything. And you'd better make a better job of this than you did the last time I set you a similar task…" Cinder trailed off; she considered pointing out that if Sweetie Drops didn't do a better job of it this time, then she, Cinder, might not be able to guarantee the safety of her teammates… but in her present state, such a threat might seem ridiculous and could weaken her position rather than strengthening it. "Or somebody will find out that we are connected. Do you understand?"

Bon Bon was silent on the other end of the scroll for a moment. "Yes," she said tersely.

"Good," Cinder said sharply. "I'll be disposing of this device soon; I will contact you again at my discretion. Make sure you have something to report when I do."

Bon Bon sighed. "Yes, Cinder."

XxXxX​

Bon Bon hung up and threw the scroll down onto the bathroom floor where she proceeded to flip Cinder off with both hands.

She then proceeded to bury her face in both hands.

How did I get myself into this?

She had wanted to change the world. She had looked with envy at Rainbow Dash and Twilight Sparkle – General Ironwood's protégé, the genius prodigy – she had seen the way that their accomplishments, their promise, their status, drew others to them like two lights guiding ships into harbour.

She had envied that. She had wanted that for herself.

She might have done better to admit that she simply didn't have the talent for it and made her peace with something more ordinary. Instead… instead, she had gorged on the flattery of Doctor Watts, little suspecting there would be a moment when the bill came due.

"Who is he?"

"That hardly matters, does it? After all, he won't be with us for much longer."


Bon Bon got up off the toilet and stood in front of the sink, running the hot water over her hands. It was scalding hot, but it did nothing to wash the blood off, no matter how hard she scrubbed at them.

To Cinder, she was an incompetent fool, but to everyone else if the truth came out, she would be a criminal. A murderer. At best, a pathetic object of pity.

She would not suffer that.

She didn't want Lyra to see her that way.

There was a knock on the door.

"Bon Bon?" Lyra asked. "Are you okay in there?"

No, Lyra, I'm not okay. I'm trapped in the iron maiden of my bad choices.

Things were spiralling way out of control. What was going to happen now?

She had no idea; she just knew that she wasn't going to be getting out of this any time soon.

"Bon Bon?" Lyra called again.

Bon Bon turned and scooped up her scroll off the floor as she walked towards the door. She opened it with an apologetic smile. "Sorry," she said. "Do you want to use the bathroom?"

"Are you okay?" Lyra repeated.

Bon Bon sighed. "No," she admitted. "I can't… I can't believe this. A traitor, living among us."

"You mean another one?" Sky asked from the back of the room.

"I think…" Bon Bon hesitated, but if she was to fulfil Cinder's new instructions then burying the hatchet with Blake would be a necessity. Rainbow wouldn't give her a second look until she did. "I think it's time that we admitted that we were too hard on Blake. After all, it wasn't Blake who attacked the CCT tonight. In fact… I'm starting to wonder if the release of that stuff about Blake wasn't a smokescreen, a deliberate attempt to make everyone look at Blake with suspicion to draw attention away from… the real enemies."

"Maybe," Sky allowed. "But that Haven girl, I'm sure I've seen her hanging around with Sunset a lot; how do we know they're not all in on it together?"

"'All'?" Dove asked. "How do we define 'all'? Are you suggesting that Ruby Rose is a traitor to humanity?"

Sky hesitated. "Just because she seems nice-"

"I will not pretend to know her well, but I think I know her a little better than you," Dove declared, "and I think I know her well enough to say that she possesses the heart of a true huntress, and while I cannot say the same for Sunset Shimmer, she loves her teammates well. I cannot think she would betray them, and I cannot think that they would betray all that Beacon stands for."

"Nor would Dash or Twilight," Bon Bon said. "Frankly, all things considered, it's going to be a while before I start pointing fingers again."

Lyra nodded. "I wonder why they did it, those Haven students. I mean, most of them were human, weren't they? So they couldn't be White Fang. Do you think they were grimm cultists?"

"Aren't they just a bunch of crazies?" Sky asked.

Lyra turned around to look at him. "But what if they weren't?"

"We can't know the answer," Bon Bon said. "And, with luck, we never will, because we'll never see them again."

If only that were true.

XxXxX​

Cinder heard the doors out onto the balcony creak behind her. A slight gesture of her head, a swift glance behind her, told her that it was Emerald standing in the doorway.

"Is there something I can help you with, Emerald?"

Emerald folded her arms and looked down at the balcony boards beneath her feet. "Mercury and Lightning, they… they want to know what happens now?"

Cinder smirked. "Mercury and Lightning. But not you?"

Emerald shifted uncomfortably. "I… I know you have a plan to turn this around."

Cinder chuckled. "Such trust."

Emerald hesitated. "Cinder, are… are you okay?"

"Are you concerned about my wellbeing, Emerald?" Cinder asked, amusement in her voice.

"It's just that, after tonight… I mean, I know that it hasn't gone the way you would have wanted," Emerald murmured. "How… how do you…?" Cinder heard Emerald's footsteps on the wooden boards as she approached. Out of the corner of her eye, she could see Emerald's hand reaching out for hers. "It's okay to-"

Cinder jerked away before Emerald could touch her. "Stop," she commanded, her voice cold and hard. "Do not presume that I am so discomfited by this that I require your pity or your comfort."

"'Pity'?" Emerald repeated, taking a step backwards, away from Cinder. "No, that's not-"

"Then what?" Cinder demanded. "Do you think me weak? Do you think me lost?"

"No."

"Then what?" Cinder snapped.

Emerald looked away. "I just… I just wanted you to know that it's okay."

"'Okay'?" Cinder repeated, a bitter laugh rising from her throat. "'Okay'? Our cover has been exposed, my virus stands under threat of discovery, the eyes of the Emerald Tower see as clearly as they ever did, and all the strength of the North remains arrayed against us; all of my plans for this night have been undone; how then, is this okay, you stupid girl?" She raised her hand, and Emerald cowered before the blow.

"Please," she whimpered, covering her face with her arms.

Cinder paused, her hand seeming to stick in the air as though it were crystallised.

'Please,' the foolish little girl had begged. 'Please don't, please stop, please don't hurt me. '

And Phoebe had paid no heed to all her pleading.

Slowly, Cinder lowered her hand. "I… I am sorry, Emerald," she murmured. She did not really know where this sudden impulse towards mercy had come from, but she felt it nonetheless: the urge to be better, to be lordly and generous, to be a gentlemare… what an odd word, she knew not where it had come from. "Forgive me. I… I am out of sorts tonight."

Emerald lowered her arms and once more looked on Cinder's face. "That… that's fine, Cinder; that was all I was trying to say. It… it's fine if you're not fine. After the night you've had, no one would blame you."

"I am not sure Mercury or Lightning will be so forgiving," Cinder murmured. "But I will speak to them and raise their spirits, ere I make account for this night to my mistress. Where are they?"

"In the dining room," Emerald said. "Um, Cinder?"

"Something else?"

Emerald swallowed. "Our… our hosts, they… there's a girl; they've got her… she's tied up."

"These people are disciples of the dark," Cinder informed her. "They worship the dark powers that manifest as Creatures of Grimm; some such merely hope to be spared death at the hands of those powers, while others covet such power for themselves. Did you imagine that the worship of darkness was done without deeds of darkness?"

Emerald whispered. "What will they do to her?"

"Sacrifice her, most likely," Cinder replied, "to the Ideal of the Grimm."

Emerald winced.

"You disapprove?" Cinder asked.

"I… who is she?" Emerald asked quietly.

"A child of the streets, probably," Cinder said. "A nobody."

The house in which they had taken refuge was a large one, considering its place out beyond the Red Line, in the more vulnerable part of Vale. Most families with the means to afford such a house would have found shelter on the right side of the walls, but this family had chosen to establish themselves here, in the danger zone, where for the most part, only Vale's poorer residents were to be found. Of course, these parts of Vale were less well policed, and more to the point, there were a lot of people here whom no one would miss.

"So was I, before I met you," Emerald murmured.

"We are the guests here, Emerald," Cinder reminded her. "It is not for us to dictate the behaviour of our hosts. Besides, if we were to let her go, she might bring the authorities down upon us. Speaking of which." She squeezed her scroll in her hand, crushing the device into a twisted, ruined, useless mass. "Come," she declared. "Let us go."

Emerald fell in behind her as Cinder strode off the balcony and into the dark and shadowy house; most of the lights were off, but Cinder could find her way easily enough; she could see as well in darkness as any faunus could, one of the many advantages that she had acquired as a result of the joining. She had been purged of many of her human weaknesses.

And of course, it had given her a way into this house, this sanctuary for the night.

She was all that their hosts hoped to become.

Said hosts met her as she was descending the staircase, the two of them standing side by side, the husband looking proud and the wife apprehensive. They had even put on their best clothes for her, as if she were some sort of civic dignitary coming for tea.

They were fools, as all such cultists were, if they thought that a few black masses muttered before an altar or some discrete murders would protect them from the wrath of the grimm, but they were useful fools to her, at present.

Or at least… they had been.

"You servants have been fed and watered, apostle," the man declared. "They await your presence in the dining room."

"Good," Cinder said. "I thank you both for your hospitality. Rest assured, your good services will not go unrewarded."

"Your good graces are all that we require, apostle," declared the wife.

"Your presence is a sign that we are not forgotten by the darkness," the husband said. "We would be honoured, apostle, if you would join us tonight for mass and partake with us in the body and the blood."

Cinder felt Emerald tense up. Why? The sacrifice these useful idiots had acquired was no part of their company. Why should she care about the fate of one she did not know?

And, what with Cinder and the rest having taken refuge here, it really was better that she die with all her knowledge.

"I am afraid there will be no mass tonight," Cinder said. "I require your shrine for my own private communion."

The husband looked surprised to hear it, but he said. "O-of course. As you wish."

"And I require a scroll of you," Cinder said. "My own has become… unusable."

"You may take mine, and gladly," the wife promised.

"Good," Cinder said. "Furthermore, my companions and I will also be taking your vehicle in the morning; we have a long journey before us and canot afford to rely on our feet."

"Everything that we have is at your disposal, blessed one," the wife declared.

"I am delighted to hear it, and so is that great darkness which we all serve," Cinder told them, in a tone as soothing as her lies. She smiled thinly. "Your services will not be forgotten, I guarantee," she promised, to they whose names she had already forgotten. Or should it be that she had never bothered to remember.

Nevertheless, the empty words seemed to gratify the two of them, and they left her in peace at that point to continue her way into the dining room, where Mercury and Lightning Dust were waiting for her.

Lightning had her feet up on the table, staining the fancy dining cloth; Mercury was gnawing on a chicken leg.

"I see that you've changed out of your suit," Cinder observed, noting that Mercury was back in his combat attire.

"You're welcome that he had something to change into," Lightning said. It was she who had brought their weapons and their gear away from Beacon when they had been forced to flee at such short notice.

"Thank you, Lightning, for doing your job," Cinder said sharply.

Lightning smirked. "It's as well somebody did their job properly tonight, huh?"

Cinder sucked in a sharp intake of breath and reminded herself that this was not the moment to start murdering her own minions. "Tonight is a setback, true," she said, "but one from which we will recover."

Mercury swallowed. "How?"

"Our goals remain the same," Cinder declared. "Our ultimate objective remains the same. We will obtain the crown and the powers of the Fall Maiden-"

"For you?" Lightning asked.

"For me," Cinder confirmed. "And for my mistress."

"Right," Lightning murmured.

Cinder stared into her eyes. The powers of a Maiden were, as the name suggested, only for women. That meant that Mercury could get no ideas above his station, as it were, and Emerald… Cinder had no suspicions regarding Emerald's loyalty, but Lightning Dust… if any of her group were to betray her, it would be Lightning Dust. She had already seen it once; upon the road, there had been a moment when Lightning had been tempted to administer the coup de grâce herself. For now, her understanding that Cinder was the stronger of the two of them outweighed her greed and lust for power, but if that balance should shift…

If it came to blows, Cinder was prepared and confident in the inevitable outcome. For the moment, however, Lightning was more valuable to her alive than dead.

"Once again," Mercury said. "How?"

"Cinder has a plan," Emerald insisted.

"Cinder's plan is why we're in this mess!" Mercury snapped. "This isn't just a minor setback-"

"All setbacks are minor, provided they do not alter the outcome," Cinder declared. "And the confusion of the night may have blinded you all to the fact that we have lost very little and still have much. Not least our lives, our strength, and ourselves."

Lightning snorted. "Are you going to tell us that when we work together we can do anything?"

Cinder chuckled. "And why not? Are we not strong? Are we not resolved? Are we not fierce and fire-hardened by adversity?" She looked around the room. The thief, the butcher, the bandit. "Have we not known the cruelty of the world? Have we not been named outcast and unclean by it, banished from the society of these corrupt and iniquitous kingdoms, condemned to lead lives less than beasts, for even animals are fed and cared for and even pampered by those who are set over them?

"We have been less than that; we have had no one to care for us, no one to rely on but ourselves, and has it not made us strong?! We have that strength, still. Yes, our enemies are numerous, their skills are considerable, and their power is great, but they have not known the chill winds that we have endured. What do they know of hardship, those spoiled children up at Beacon, those Atlesians in love with their own ingenuity, these men of Vale grown soft in their complacency? They have not felt what we have felt, have not endured as we have endured; they are soft, and the fires which hardened us shall consume them when we visit the flames upon them and upon this whole wretched kingdom of Vale!

"We shall do as I always intended that we should do: spread discord, set friend against friend, make old enemies of new allies, set all the swords of men against one another and then…" She smiled. "And then unleash my mistress' creatures to devour them all. And we shall do it because we have been strengthened by adversity. We have been cast out, accounted worthless, ground down beneath the boot of the world's callousness, but it is because we have been counted worthless that we have the strength to overthrow great empires, topple the towers of the high, and cast the lords of men down from their lofty seats!"

She looked at them, and she could see her words striking home. Lightning and Mercury might affect a cynicism about the world, a carelessness to its doings, but if that had truly been so, she never would have reached out to them. They were of use to her because, in some way, they thought as she did. They, like her, desired to show the world how foolish it had been to cast them from its midst.

"Stay with me," she urged. "Trust in me. And together, I vow that great things will yet lie before us."

"We're with you, Cinder," Emerald vowed. "All the way."

Lightning nodded. "Let's burn this place to the ground."

Mercury grinned. "I've come this far, I guess. No sense backing out now."

"Indeed," Cinder said. "Lightning, did you retrieve the Seer?"

"Yes, and you're welcome to it," Lightning said, picking up a black sack off the floor and dumping it on the table. "It gives me the creeps."

"Is it awake?" Cinder asked.

"I hope not," Lightning muttered.

Cinder carried the sack into the shrine, a dark-enshrouded chamber where a grey beowolf carved of stone snarled above a wooden altar carved with lurid, monstrous images. It all had rather a performative air about it, children playing at darkness and evil.

Of course, their play was not without its teeth, as shown by the victim of whom Emerald was so concerned, but all the same… a secret place of worship, human sacrifice, offerings to some nebulous idea of darkness and destruction… and then, the next day, you went to work and bought a cup of coffee on the way to the office and made sympathetic noises when your colleagues complained about the commute. None of this worship, this faith, required them to change in any other way the way in which they lived their lives.

They made sacrifices, but they did not make sacrifices; none were required of them by the absent focus of their worship.

How unlike the truth behind the myths, who asked much, yes, but who promised much and delivered much in turn.

Although there was no true power in it, nevertheless, Cinder laid the sack upon the altar and took a step backwards from it.

She opened the bag, and the seer emerged. It had no eyes; it appeared at first glance to be some sort of sphere of glass – either coloured dark or filled with some murky opaque liquid – standing upon legs fashioned after teeth. But the crusting in places of plates of bone betrayed the truth of it, and as Cinder waited, a golden light began to shine out of the dark depths, and the seer rose into the air as fleshy tentacles tipped with points of bleached white bone descended from the base of it.

Nothing yet was visible but the light; nevertheless, as the grimm hovered in the air, Cinder could feel herself being watched, weighed, and judged.

She dropped to one knee. "Mistress."

Cinder's head was bowed, so she did not see the face of Salem appear within the seer, but she did hear her mistress' voice echoing out from the creature and into the cellar, caressing her with a maternal gentleness.

"Cinder," Salem said. "I gather that you have some ill news to bring me."

Cinder took a breath. "How much do you know, mistress?"

"Whether I know everything or nothing should be of no concern to you," Salem replied. "Tell me all, regardless."

Salem, she was sure, would know if she lied, and so she said, "I have been… defeated, Mistress." How bitter that word was to say. "At first, everything went according to plan; I easily despatched the guards Ironwood had set around the tower. However…"

"Go on," Salem urged.

"I had not known that there would be someone else in the tower besides the guards," Cinder said. "One of Ironwood's pet protégés. She has broken the encryptions used to protect the message I had sent regarding Blake Belladonna's past and identified me as the source. She… she may also know that the signal bounced through Draco."

"I see," Salem murmured, her tone inscrutable. "Is there a reason you did not simply kill her and let her take her knowledge to the grave?"

"I tried," Cinder said. "That was my first move after inserting the virus into the CCT. But she summoned an ally to protect her, and although I was victorious in battle, more of their comrades arrived, and I… I was forced to retreat."

"You mean to flee," Salem corrected her. "I cannot imagine that you are still at Beacon."

"No," Cinder confessed. "My followers and I were forced to abandon the school and evade the Atlesian forces. We have taken refuge-"

"Where you have fled to is irrelevant, so long as you are safe," Salem said. "Are you safe, Cinder?"

"We are, Mistress," Cinder said. "For now, at least."

There was a moment of silence, broken by Salem's sighing. "Oh, Cinder. I confess that I am… disappointed."

Cinder closed her eyes, flinching away from the word. "I… I am sorry."

"'Sorry' hardly makes up for such complete incompetence," the lugubrious voice of Doctor Watts emerged from out of the seer. "You have been exposed; my virus will soon follow-"

"That is not certain," Cinder insisted.

"But it is likely," Watts insisted. "Why, you have even put our own location in jeopardy."

"That was not my doing," Cinder replied, her voice sharpening. Doctor Watts was not Salem, and she would not be spoken too in such a fashion by a mere equal. "You're the one whose encryptions could be broken by a child!"

"And you are one who insisted on using them in such a petty fashion," Watts said, contemptuously. "Was it worth it, for all that it has cost us?"

"Don't be so gloomy, Arthur," Salem said, her voice even and calm. "As yet, it has cost us little or nothing."

"But ma'am, if James-"

"Ozpin is already well aware of where to find me, if he wishes to do so," Salem declared, causing Cinder to wonder if that fact was as new to Watts as it was to her. "And Ozpin knows that even if he mustered every huntsman in Remnant, he would not have the strength to reach me here. This land belongs wholly to the grimm… and to me. Our enemy is too well aware of this to trouble us in our own home again."

Again? Cinder kept her expression neutral, with just a hint of contrition. It would do no good if Salem believed that she sought to pry into secrets that were not hers.

"You are right, of course, ma'am," Watts said. "But nevertheless, the fact remains that Cinder's incompetence has put all of our efforts in Vale in grave jeopardy."

Cinder growled. "Mistress, I assure you that I will do and deliver all that I have promised you. Vale will fall, Ozpin will die, the relic will be yours, and I will become your Fall Maiden."

"Your confidence is admirable," Salem said. "But how do you propose to accomplish all of this with your cover at Beacon blown and your true loyalties revealed?"

"At first light, I will join the White Fang forces mustering to the southeast, and accelerate the timetable of our assault," Cinder said. "There is no point in waiting until the Vytal Festival now."

"Do you still believe that such an attack can succeed?" Watts demanded.

"I believe that it will give me what I need, a new means to spread discord between the defenders of Vale," Cinder declared. "To which end, Mistress, I request the services of the Sirens to help spread anger and uncertainty."

Salem was silent for a moment. "For now, you may have one single Siren, the one who calls herself Sonata. The other two shall remain here as hostages for her continued obedience. That may change later, but for now… proceed with the rest of your plans."

"Thank you, Mistress, I will."

"You have been confounded tonight," Salem said. "But even I have endured failures in the course of my life. What matters is not that you have failed, but how you respond to that failure. Pick yourself up, understand why you were defeated, and in that knowledge, grow stronger."

"Yes, Mistress," Cinder replied. "I guarantee, I shall not fail you again."
 
Chapter 83 - The Day After: Sunset
The Day After: Sunset​


Pyrrha knelt, her aura broken, her weapons shattered before her. Pyrrha knelt, and Sunset stood over her, triumphant.

Pyrrha looked up at her, that infuriatingly beautiful face trembling with a mixture of pain and fear, her eyes wide with the despair that would soon engulf the entire world.

"Do you believe in destiny?" she whispered.

Sunset said nothing. She stood over the helpless girl before her, drinking in her power over the so-called Invincible Girl. She savoured her triumph like nectar and ambrosia. She had won! The champion of Mistral, the darling of high society, the one they all flocked around to praise and flatter and make much of, and yet, here she knelt, helpless and defeated at her feet while she, the despised outcast, the one they had scorned with hostile, pitying glances, the one they had sought to degrade and cast down, the one they had expelled from paradise, stood triumphant over her.

The smirk that grew on Sunset's face was cruel and terrible. "Yes," she declared, for she believed in destiny, and her faith had been rewarded, justified, proved beyond doubt. She had allowed inexorable destiny to drive her forward, and now, her hour had come: the hour of the setting sun when darkness would engulf the world.

Fire sprang up in the palm of her hand. The flickering flame – scarlet and gold, like the pattern of Sunset's burning hair – danced reflected for a moment in Pyrrha's emerald eyes.

And then, still smiling, Sunset turned her palm towards Pyrrha and engulfed the champion of Mistral in the flames.

Pyrrha screamed. And Sunset, the other Sunset, the Sunset who stood unseen and held fast in the shadows on the edges of the scene, howled in helpless, futile, anguished outrage as she watched herself murder her best friend.

And it wasn't even the first time.

Her eyes had run dry of tears watching this and other scenes like it. Blake spat in Sunset's face before Sunset cut off her head; Ruby pleaded with her before Sunset shot her through the heart; Jaune…

Sunset gasped for breath as the world around her shimmered and split apart into a hundred thousand fragments like shards of coloured glass that hung suspended in the void for a moment before reforming into something and to somewhere new. Sunset didn't recognise these places – maybe they were places that Cinder remembered – but even though she'd seen Cinder's past, Sunset hadn't been paying enough attention to the backgrounds to get a real sense of them.

And now her attention was too much on what she did recognise. Though she had seen this before, Sunset found that she couldn't look away.

Jaune lay on his back on the ground, his shield gone and his sword beyond his reach. Sunset, the other Sunset, the one that Sunset was forced to watch commit unspeakable act after monstrous crime, stood with one foot upon his chest and a flaming spear in her hand.

"No!" Sunset yelled. "Stop it! Don't do this!" She sobbed, though her tears were all cried out, whether for her friends who had become her victims or for herself… she couldn't say.

Perhaps it was for all of them.

"No," Sunset whispered, wanting so desperately to look away but absolutely unable to do so. "No, this isn't you. This is Cinder, this is her, not you; this is… this is…"

"Calm yourself, Sunset Shimmer."

Sunset gasped, looking upwards as the world around her dissolved, turning to smoke and then, like smoke, being blown away by the strong gale that suddenly gusted all around, rippling through Sunset's hair and tugging at her jacket as it swept the other Sunset and Jaune and everything else away; and through the gale, that still, small voice cut like a knife: "Calm yourself."

Sunset was left standing in a field of stars, looking up at the moon; not the broken moon of Remnant, spilling its shattered fragments out across the night sky, but the whole and silver moon of Equestria beneath which she had grown up. She had studied by the light of that moon; she had caught glimpses of it peeking through the gaps in the curtains as she and Celestia sat before the fire and Sunset absorbed as much of the princess' wisdom as she could comprehend and less than she had believed at the time; she had walked beneath it, lived beneath it… and left it behind like everything else in that world.

Yet now, it shone above her once again.

And out of that moon, that familiar and so long vanished moon, descended an alicorn of midnight blue, her flowing mane as liquid with power as that of Celestia itself steaming behind her. Her cutie mark was a crescent moon upon black, the same symbol that glowed upon the gorget she wore around her neck.

She flew down from the moon and settled – stood, if such a word had any meaning here – upon the same surface of nothingness that held Sunset still amongst the stars. A ground – barren and empty but present nonetheless – appeared beneath them.

The eyes of the alicorn were filled with pity. "Dark are your dreams tonight, Sunset Shimmer."

Sunset stared at her; stared up at her, for although there was not such a great difference in their heights, nevertheless, there was something about this crowned alicorn that invited her to look up. Her mere presence calmed Sunset, soothing Cinder's boiling anger within her and setting it, like a raging beast, to sleep.

"Who?" Sunset whispered, as she felt a deep calm settle over her, smothering all other feelings like a blanket. "Who are you?"

"I am Luna, princess of the moon and night and mistress of the dreaming realm. And I have heard a great deal about you, Sunset Shimmer."

"Luna," Sunset murmured. "You… you're Princess Celestia's sister? You're Nightmare Moon?"

The words were out of her mouth so fast that Sunset could only regret them once they had flown past her lips and were past all hope of recall, and yet, Princess Luna did not grow angry, as Sunset might well have done in her position. Instead, her expression turned melancholy, and her dark blue eyes filled with regret.

"Yes," she said. "I was Nightmare Moon, once. But I have been saved, redeemed from darkness by Twilight Sparkle and her friends."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "Twilight… never mentioned that."
No wonder Celestia loves her so.

No, no that was not right. Celestia did not love in mere reward, nor did she love in due proportion to the services rendered by she to whom that love was given. The love of Princess Celestia was not a thing that could be bought even in the coin of service to the realm or to herself; rather, it was the water in a well from which all could drink… provided they were worthy of the purest of all waters.

For the salvation of her sister, Sunset had no doubt that Celestia would forever be grateful to her newer and more successful student… but if she loved Twilight as she had once loved Sunset – as Sunset dared to hope and to believe that she was yet somewhat loved – then it was not for that service, or any other of the services that Twilight had done. Celestia loved her only for herself.

"Perhaps Twilight did not wish to boast of her deeds; humility is one of her lesser virtues," Luna declared.


Something that we don't exactly have in common, Sunset thought, taking some comfort from the way that Luna had named Twilight's modesty a lesser virtue, the implication being it was not one of the vital ones. Sunset hoped not, or she was in trouble.

"And yet," Luna said, "though Twilight and her friends have cleansed my soul, they cannot wipe clean my past as though it never was. I was Nightmare Moon, upon a time. I have that darkness within me, and that regret." She glanced at Sunset out of the corner of one eye. "Something that we have in common, you and I."

Sunset turned away from her, and as she turned away, that barren emptiness on which she stood became a cliff, and beneath her and before her gleamed Canterlot in all its glory. The spires twinkled in the moonlight, and the many lights that shone in the city matched the stars set in the firmament above in multitude and brightness.

Sunset sat down, her legs dangling off the edge of the cliff. Silently, Princess Luna settled down upon her haunches beside her.

"You miss it," Luna observed.

Sunset frowned. "Only children fled from crueller homes than mine do not feel homesick from time to time, I think." She sighed. "If I could live with my friends of Remnant, yet in the gentler world of Equestria, I would count myself blessed beyond deserving… save that I would have no outlet for my ambition."
For what need has Equestria of a Sunset Shimmer when it has a Twilight Sparkle here already?

"Your friends," Luna said. "Are those… were they your friends?"

"They are my friends," Sunset muttered. She lifted up one knee, pulling it back from the abyss and resting her booted foot upon the cliff; she rested then her forehead on her knee. "I… I don't want you to think that that was me. That wasn't me, that… I wouldn't do that." She scowled. "I don't want to do that."

"And yet you fear you will," Luna murmured. A statement, not a question.

"It's her anger, not mine," Sunset insisted. "But… it's in me now. I can feel it… and it feels so familiar to me. The things she feels, Cinder; her anger, her envy, her wrath… they are not alien to my soul."

"Nor to mine," Luna said. She smiled wryly when Sunset looked up at her. "You know the story, do you not?"

"Celestia never spoke of it," Sunset said, lest Princess Luna think that her sister had been in the habit of gossiping about her in her long absence.

"That is not what I asked," Luna said. "You know the story anyway."

"You were jealous," Sunset said. "Filled with resentment and desire for something that Princess Celestia could not give you." She snorted. "Something else we have in common."

"Indeed," Luna murmured, sounding less than entirely proud of the fact. "I know the taste of envy very well, and equally well, I recall what lengths it can drive the desperate."

"But you were saved," Sunset said. "You told me, Twilight… Twilight and her friends, they wielded the Elements of Harmony and-"

"Shall I tell you a secret?" Luna asked, her voice a soft conspiratorial whisper. "You seem like the sort of mare who enjoys secrets, though you may not enjoy this one."

Sunset wasn't sure if she was being insulted or not. "You can tell me whatever you want to tell me, Princess."

"The Elements of Harmony may have cleansed me of the outer manifestation of my darkness," Luna said. "If the circumstances were different, perhaps they would have done the same to you. But the truth is that the darkness inside… it never leaves. Although I might wish that it were otherwise, I fear that you may have to carry this anger that is not yours for the rest of your days, or until time cools the fires that now burn so brightly and with such heat. Just as I must carry the guilt of all that I did in my madness and my folly."

Sunset stared up at the princess of the moon for a moment, seeking comfort in her face, in her voice, in running the words that she had spoken over and over again in her head. Seeking comfort and finding none. "That… that's it?" she whispered. Her voice rose, sharpened with anger. "That's it?! You came all this way to tell me that there is no hope?"

"I did not say 'no hope,'" Luna said. "I said that there was no easy solution. I am the princess of the moon, not of miracles."

"You might not have said that there wasn't any hope, but you certainly implied it!" Sunset snapped. "You saw my dreams, you know what I'm struggling with; how am I supposed to just… to just live with it? I killed my friends, and I enjoyed it!" She sobbed; her whole body was wracked by a shudder of pain as she buried her face in her knee. "Celestia help me, I liked it."

Sunset felt something settle on her arm. A dark wing, soft and feathery. "Brave heart, Sunset Shimmer," Luna said. "You are not yet beyond all hope. That you feel such sorrow is cause for joy. Do you think that she whose rage you have stolen would shed tears?"

Sunset didn't reply. "You said… you said that you carried it with you?"

"Every day," Luna said. "And every day, when I see the little ponies of Equestria forget, or act as if they have forgotten, that there are once more two diarchs in the realm, I feel it like a pinprick in my heart, a needle of that old jealousy returning once again. But I am on guard against it now and armed against its terrible allure. Arm your soul, be vigilant… and do not let your most potent weapon rust in its scabbard, unused and forgotten."

"How can my magic help me with this?" Sunset asked.

"I said nothing of any magic," Luna said, with a hint of reproach. "I had shut myself away long before my fall was complete. I did not talk to the sister whom I did not trust… whom I hated and blamed for all my troubles. I had no one that I could confide in, no one to whom I could unburden myself, no one… no one at all to help me when I was most in need of it. You are not yet so unfortunate, nor will you be unless you bring such a fate upon yourself."

Sunset couldn't keep the scepticism out of her voice as she said, "You think I should talk to my team about the fact that I dreamt of murdering them?"

"If you accept the aid of your friends, then they may remain only dreams," Luna said. "You cannot run from this, Sunset Shimmer; you cannot hide from it in darkness or in light. Sooner or later, you will have to confront it, and when you do… it is never wise to face such things alone. Farewell."

"Wait!" Sunset cried as Canterlot below her and the Equestrian sky above both began to dissolve into the void. "You're leaving?"

Luna rose into the air, looking back at Sunset over her shoulder. "Though your dreams are dark, you are not the only pony having nightmares tonight. And I have said all that I could usefully say. Goodbye, Sunset; it may be that we shall meet again."

"Are you…?" Sunset hesitated, torn between a certain awareness of how childish her request would sound and a desire to ask it anyway. "Are you going to tell Princess Celestia about this? I… I don't want her to know…"
What? I don't want her to know what's happened to me? Don't want her to know what I'm becoming? Don't want her to know… anything?

Luna stared down at Sunset, and said nothing, and her face conceded nothing.

Then she was gone, and all was plunged into darkness.


Sunset woke up, her eyes snapping open to the light of early morning coming in through the library windows.

Sunset groaned as she sat up, rolling off the bed of books – new books, the ones that she knew could take it; she wasn't a barbarian – that she had made to sleep up in a secluded corner of the upper level of the library where hardly anyone went. She had to sleep somewhere if she wasn't going back to the dorm room, and she couldn't go back to the dorm room. She hesitated to think what Ruby would have thought if she'd seen and heard her tossing and turning in the grip of nightmares.

Ruby. Ruby was the only one that she could think about, the one that Cinder loathed the least. She hated Ruby Rose as she hated everyone, but it wasn't as visceral as her dislike of Pyrrha, and so, it didn't send the same surge of anger through Sunset's veins.

Trust them, Luna had said. Talk to them. Tell them everything. Yeah, like that was going to happen. Perhaps Princess Luna meant well, but she didn't get how things were in this world. This wasn't Equestria. People didn't forgive so easily, and they didn't take things in their stride the way that ponies did; if she told them the truth… there was no way they wouldn't turn on her.

"Did you sleep in here? On books?"

"Gah!" Sunset jumped at the sound of Blake's voice, nearly falling over as she turned to see the faunus girl watching her from the corner of the stack. "What are you doing, sneaking up on me like that?" Interfering little animal. Why can't she leave me alone?

Get out of my head, Cinder!


"I thought I was being pretty loud," Blake said.

"Trust me, you weren't," Sunset said. "What do you want?"

Blake's amber eyes narrowed. "Did you sleep on books?"

"Only the ones that could take it," Sunset replied defensively. "What are you doing here?"

"Looking for a new bodice ripper."

"Really?"

Blake rolled her eyes. "Of course not, I'm looking for you."

"Well, who asked you to?" Sunset demanded. Keep your nose out of my business before I cut it off! Sunset huffed and turned away. "I'm sorry," she said. "I'm sorry, I just… thanks for coming to look for me, but you should go."

There was no sound of Blake going, and as stealthy as she was or could be, Sunset was inclined to attribute that to the fact that she hadn't actually gone anywhere. The sound of her voice confirmed her suspicions. "Everyone's worried about you," Blake said. "The rest of the school is talking about the attack, Yang's mothering Ruby as though she was in real danger up there, but all that Team Sapphire can talk about is where you are and why you didn't come home last night."

Sunset grunted. "So why are you here?"

"Because Pyrrha thinks that you should be given your space if you want it, and Jaune and Ruby don't know any better than to agree with her."

"But you do," Sunset said, still without turning round.

"I know that, with some things, letting them fester only makes them worse," Blake murmured. "And I know that, if I was in your position, you'd be one of the first to try and help me out of the hole I was in. What happened last night?"

"Nothing happened."

"You went after Cinder, then she escaped, and you won't come home? And you expect anybody to believe that nothing happened?" Blake demanded. "Sunset, what's really-?"

Sunset saw, out of the corner of her eye, Blake reaching for her hand. She pulled away, panic at the thought of Blake discovering the truth in such a way making sweat start to form on her back. She jerked backwards, wheeling to face Blake as she stepped away from her.

"Don't touch me!" she hissed, and Cinder's hate mingled with her own panic to put an edge on her voice like a sword.

Blake couldn't quite hide her dismay; the drooping of her ears was a dead giveaway. "I washed my hands," she muttered mulishly.

"It's not that, I…" Sunset sighed. She would have to tell. She couldn't… she couldn't just not explain, and she couldn't spend the next four years in the library. She would have to tell someone. She would have to tell Blake, since Blake was here. She would have to tell, and then… well, she might have to leave Beacon when she was done talking, but… but at least then her friends would be safe from her.

"I found my semblance last night," Sunset said. "I unlocked it when I was fighting Cinder."

Blake stared at her for a moment, as though she was waiting for something else. "Congratulations," she said, in a soft, dry voice.

The very word was bitter in Sunset's ears. "It's not a good thing," Sunset said. She walked to the balcony and looked down upon the library, empty this early in the morning. Her pony ears drooped down on top of her head. "I have… empathy, you might call it. Or touch telepathy. Or a little of both. If you'd touched my hand… I would have felt everything that you were feeling, seen what you were thinking. Like I did to Cinder."

"My god," Blake murmured, dismayed comprehension obvious in her voice.

Sunset gripped the wooden balcony rail tightly with both hands. "I saw her… how she ended up this way. I felt her anger, her rage, the way that she hates everyone and everything and… you all in particular. You know, she really doesn't like you for going after Torchwick and the White Fang the way you did. And the fact that you survived her attempt to get you arrested just made her even madder."

"I'm flattered," Blake said dryly.

"You shouldn't be; she's a dangerous person to have it out for you," Sunset said. She bowed her head. "The things that I see… the things that I feel… they don't leave me when I break contact. I've got it all in me. All that anger towards the people I care about, and on top of all of that, I've only got to touch someone to get everything that's in them dumped on me as well!" Sunset took a deep breath and risked a glance at Blake. "So that's why I didn't come home last night. What was I supposed to do?"

"You could have talked to the people who care about you?" Blake suggested as though it was such an obvious thing to do.

"Yeah, because you always do that, don't you?" Sunset snapped. She cringed. "You see. I get…" She shook her head. "I… it's so familiar to me."

"What is?"

"This anger, the rage she carries around with her all the time," Sunset said. "I've felt it too, when I was living in Atlas. It fits into me like I'm a glove and her emotions are the hand the glove was made for. I remember feeling the way that she feels, hating the way that she hates; I remember it so, so well that it… and she hates my friends. She hates them so badly that she wants them all dead, and sometimes, when I think of them now… there's so much anger… how can you honestly say that I shouldn't stay away?"

Blake stared at Sunset in silence for a moment. Then, still in silence, she held out her hand.

"What are you doing?" Sunset demanded.

Blake stepped forward and laid her hand out on the wooden rail. "Touch it."

Sunset glanced between Blake's face and her hand. "You've been listening to me, right?"

Blake nodded. "That's why I want you to take my hand."

Sunset hesitated, her hand balling up reflexively at the idea. She didn't want to use her semblance on Blake; she didn't particularly want to use it at all. She hadn't asked for this, or for what it would cost her to use it. She wondered, with slightly bitter thoughts, about why she couldn't have had something like pyrokinesis as her semblance, something that didn't make her hate herself and fear for those closest to her.

She didn't want to use her semblance on Blake, but looking into her eyes and the firm, unyielding set of her expression, it was pretty clear to Sunset that she wasn't going to be able to get away with not using it.

And so, tentatively, gingerly, Sunset touched Blake's proffered and unresisting palm with the tips of her fingers. She felt that same spark jolting through her arm that she had felt when she grabbed hold of Cinder, and she threw her head back as she felt her consciousness thrown forwards out of herself and into-

XxXxX​

Blake stood on a dockyard, somewhere Sunset could not place, crouched down and sobbing as a ship sailed away into the distance. A woman, Sunset couldn't get a good read on how old she was, with tiger stripes running down her dark arms, placed a hand upon Blake's shoulder. Sienna Khan, Sunset knew from Blake's memories of this day, this moment; just as she knew that the ship sailing away was carrying Blake's parents to Menagerie so she knew that this was the woman who succeeded Blake's father as leader of the White Fang.

"Your father was a great man, once," Sienna said. "But he was always cautious, and old age has turned that caution into fear. We require boldness now if we are to prevail and win a world for all our brothers and sisters to share in freedom."

Blake climbed to her feet, and wiped away the tears from her eyes. "I understand."

"Do you?" Sienna asked, looking into Blake's eyes. "Do you truly understand what we must do? Or do you remain here as a spy for your father?"

"No!" Blake yelled. "My father's weak, he doesn't get it, he's given up!" She scowled. "I won't ever give up. I want to see us achieve equality, and I won't stop fighting until I do. I belong to the faunus now, and to you."

Sienna Khan smiled, and as she smiled, Sunset couldn't help but think that it was that smile, and not the stripes on her arm, in which she most possessed the aspect of the tiger.


XxXxX​

Blake walked down the street; it was the late afternoon, and she was on her way to a meeting. A faunus woman, a dog faunus with terrier ears and dark skin, was coming the other way, pushing a pram in front of her with a little boy inside.

She was walking quickly, her heels clicking rapidly on the stone of the pavement as she walked, and though she was trying to hide it, as she passed, Blake could tell that she was in some distress.

It didn't take Blake long to notice the source of that distress: a human man, bald and slovenly looking, his face – probably never particularly good looking – deformed by odious hostility; he followed her from a distance of about fifteen feet or so. He sounded as though he'd just rolled out of some bar; he kept slurring his words as he yelled at her in a harsh, ugly, nasal voice. "Hey! Hey, I'm talking to you! You're on benefits, aren't you? That's why you had that kid, so you could steal our benefits! Isn't it? You're a thief, and you don't belong here!"


XxXxX​

Sunset saw no more distinct memories from Blake, but she felt…she felt anger. A surprising, shocking anger to come from Blake Belladonna, who rarely raised her voice and walked through life with an expression so calm that it was almost placid. But beneath those still waters, it seemed that a raging tempest surged and buffeted, or at least, that it had. Rage against her parents for abandoning the fight and so for abandoning her, rage against the Schnee Dust Company for treating the deaths of innocent faunus struggling to support their families as an acceptable write-off, rage against the four kingdoms for spouting the rhetoric of equality while turning a blind eye to oppression, rage against those who thought that they could taunt and abuse faunus in the street without consequence, rage against the fact that there were no consequences for them more often than not, rage against the fact that innocent women like that mother had to live in fear.

Anger that this was the world they lived in.


XxXxX​

Sunset pulled away, clutching her hands together as she looked into Blake's eyes.

"That anger? That's something that every faunus feels or has felt sooner or later," Blake said. "When we're on the receiving end of the injustice of the world, when we see someone else suffering from that injustice, we feel it. It builds up with every callous remark or thoughtless action from those who should know better. It isn't unique to you, and it certainly doesn't belong to Cinder Fall; I don't know what she's gone through in her life, but if she's angry that she wasn't given the life that she wanted or deserved… she can join the line."

Blake pursed her lips together. "No offence, Sunset, but there are times when I think that you want to live your life as though you're the hero in some kind of story; you act like you're unique, the only person in the whole world who does the things that you do, feels the way that you do. And sometimes, I can even see why, but when it comes to this… I'm sorry to say you're just not that special."

"I am absolutely that special, and more," Sunset replied, bristling as Cinder's pride mingled with her own. She took a deep breath. "What happened?"

Blake blinked. "When?"

"In your memory," Sunset said. "The woman being followed down the street. What did you do? It felt as though you wanted to punch the guy."

"I did; I did want to, I mean," Blake said. "But the police might have picked up the mother if I had, just for being in the wrong place; I followed them both, discreetly, over the rooftops, to make sure that he didn't do anything besides run his mouth. After a while, he gave up and… stopped bothering her. She wasn't hurt, and she and the child got home safe." Blake folded her arms and leaned against the balcony rail. "When I told Adam – he wanted to know why I was late for a chapter meeting – he told me that I should have killed the man. He told me that he would have, and even then, a long time before he became… or before I realised… I believed him.

"We all feel the same anger, Sunset. We all rage at the injustice of our situation. But we don't have to let it rule us, and we don't have to let it make us monsters, like Cinder or Adam. Anger is a consequence of living in this world, but giving in to it is a choice. One I've seen too many good people fall prey to; please don't make the same mistake."

Sunset shook her head. "You think I want to?"

"I think you've overcome your own anger," Blake said. "Is there any reason why you can't overcome Cinder's?"

"But what if I can't?" Sunset asked quietly. "What if I lose this time, what if… what if I hurt them?" She frowned. "We're so alike: both orphans; both fallen from grace, cast out from lives of luxury and spoiled indulgence into something much harsher, crueller, colder; both ambitious, envious of those who have what we want. A couple of wrong turns, and I could have become her."

"But you didn't."

"That doesn't mean that I won't," Sunset said. "Especially not since I feel exactly the way that she does; it's like I'm halfway there already." And I'll get there if Cinder has anything to say about it. She didn't mention that Cinder had tried to get Sunset on her side to Blake; that was a step further than she was willing to admit at this stage.

"I couldn't bear it if I hurt them," she said.

Blake was silent for a while. She looked away from Sunset, her golden eyes scanning the empty library beneath them. "Have you ever looked at someone and thought 'they are the personification of this word'? Have you ever looked at someone and that word just popped into your head whenever you set eyes on them, because even if it didn't capture every single thing about them… it still got to the heart of that person better than any other word that you could think of?"

Sunset… couldn't honestly say that she had experienced the phenomenon that Blake was describing, although to hear it described, it made a lot of sense. She said nothing. She just waited, silently, to see where Blake was going with this.

"Living with you, getting to know Team Sapphire," Blake continued. "I look at Ruby, and I think 'this girl is the embodiment of courage.' I can't think of any situation where she'd hesitate to throw herself into the breach to protect… anyone. She wouldn't need to like them, she wouldn't even need to know them, she wouldn't care how great the danger was-"

"All that she'd need to know was that somebody was in trouble, and she'd be there," Sunset murmured. "Locked, loaded, and swinging Crescent Rose with wild abandon." She sighed. "I don't exactly like that tendency in her, but I can't deny it either. I just wish that she was the embodiment of caution or self-preservation or something like that."

Blake chuckled. "No."

"No?"

"No," Blake repeated. "You might think so, but… but the truth is that if she weren't the way she is, if she weren't the embodiment of courage, absolutely unafraid of anything, then she wouldn't be Ruby Rose. Certainly, she wouldn't be the Ruby you love."

Sunset considered that for a moment. She tried to imagine a cautious Ruby, a careful Ruby, a Ruby who gave some sign of valuing her own skin. It was hard to do, very hard, and Blake was right, the result didn't look much like Ruby Rose. "You may be onto something with this."

Blake nodded. "I look at Pyrrha, and I see the personification of gentleness."

"In the old meaning or the new one?"

"Both," Blake said. "That's what makes it so apposite."

Sunset couldn't argue with that, and so she didn't. "And Jaune?"

Blake seemed to take a moment to consider Jaune Arc. "Decency." Blake waited, as if she expected Sunset to ask what word she, Sunset, might be considered to embody. Though her mouth was dry with expectation, Sunset didn't ask; how much she actually wanted to know depended entirely upon what the answer was.

"And when I look at you," Blake said, after a moment or two. "I think of the word 'resolve.' You keep fighting, and you never give up, and you never turn away from a challenge. That's what I thought, anyway. I'd hate for you to give up now and prove me wrong."

Sunset said nothing. Her gaze flickered to Blake and then away again, as her appreciation for Blake's friendship warred with Cinder's dislike of the other girl.

"I don't know what it's like to have all of Cinder's feelings inside of you," Blake said. "But here's what I do know: Cinder Fall tried to have me arrested and turn the whole school against me, but Sunset Shimmer helped get me out of that trouble and persuade the people who matter to let me come back to Beacon. Cinder Fall has been using the White Fang to wage war against Vale, but Sunset Shimmer helped me fight back and try to stop the fall of a movement that used to stand for something real and important. Cinder Fall went to the tower last night to do damage; Sunset Shimmer went to help a friend in trouble. Cinder Fall might hate Pyrrha and Jaune and Ruby and even me… but Sunset cares about all of us. I believe, no, I know that to be true. You may be alike in some ways, but you could say that about you and Pyrrha; you could even say it about you and me!

"Adam and I are a lot alike too. We both feel the same anger at what has been done to our people, but the difference is that I don't let my anger destroy who I am… or at least, I hope I don't," Blake said. "That's the point: the difference is as important as the likeness. You both want to be recognised, fine, but you want to shine over the world, and Cinder wants to tear it all down. Your families, your feelings… none of it changes the fact that you're a good person, and she isn't… and none of it changes the fact that you have three friends who want to help you if you'll let them."

Sunset was silent for a moment. "Four."

"Huh?"

"The way I see it, I have four friends who want to help me," Sunset said.

Blake blushed a little as her cat ears perked up a bit. "Well… I don't know if… I thought I should try. Did it help?"

Sunset nodded. "You… you make a lot of sense. It's not gone, but… but you're right; I can't hide from it, and I can't let her win by letting her emotions rule me. She's not going to get the best of me that easily."

Blake nodded. "Resolve."

"I have to live up to your expectations, now that you've said it," Sunset said. She stepped back from the rail. "They'll understand, won't they?"

"I don't doubt it," Blake said.

Sunset found that, if she could take a step back from Cinder's thoughts, if she could fight her way through the fog of another girl's anger and hatred, she didn't really doubt it either.

And let's face it, if she wanted to control her semblance so that she could touch people without finding out everything about them, she could do a lot worse than talk to Pyrrha.

Pyrrha. Sunset flinched at the anger that flared within her at the thought of Pyrrha, the spoiled-

No. No, she was going to fight this. She had to fight this. She wasn't going to let Cinder win. She was going to embody resolve and rise above this as she had risen above all other obstacles.

Pyrrha whom she hated. Pyrrha who had everything she wanted. Pyrrha, who understood Sunset better than anyone else. Pyrrha, whom Sunset could talk to as an equal and trust as an equal.

Pyrrha whom she wanted dead. Pyrrha who was so overrated. Pyrrha who had worked her ass off to become strong just as Sunset had. Pyrrha whom she loved.

Pyrrha whom they all loved so well. Pyrrha she wanted to protect.

Pyrrha her enemy.

Pyrrha her teammate.

Pyrrha her friend.

Pyrrha her friend.

Pyrrha her friend. Sunset breathed in and out. Pyrrha her friend. She had to focus on that, focus as much as she had ever focussed on a complex magical spell. Focus on the feelings that were hers and leave the thoughts of Cinder Fall to wither on the vine.

"Are you okay?" Blake asked, concern evident in her voice.

Sunset took a deep breath. "I'm not fine," she said. "But I am better. Come on, let's go."

With Blake at her side, Sunset began to head home.
 
Chapter 84 - The Day After: Ironwood
The Day After: Ironwood


"They were here," Ironwood growled, slamming his fist onto the table in a bid to get through to the old man who sat behind his desk looking more exasperated by Ironwood's behaviour than he seemed at all concerned about the disaster that had very nearly unfolded last night. "Ozpin, they were right here!"

"We're very much aware of that, James," Glynda hissed, possibly to distract Ironwood from the fact that Ozpin had just put his head in his hands as though Ironwood was giving him a headache.

Ironwood was starting to think that they both deserved a lot more than a headache from having someone shout in their ear.

"I've known Twilight Sparkle since she was a little girl, and last night I nearly had to tell her parents that she was never coming home," Ironwood snapped, venting his anger into Glynda's face. She might not have deserved it, it might be that he was overreacting to her remark, but there was a part of him that needed to vent at somebody, even if she wasn't a particularly deserving target of his wrath. When he thought of what could have happened last night if Twilight hadn't had the presence of mind to call Rainbow Dash for help: Twilight dead, the CCT potentially compromised, the identity of the mole lost. They had stood on the knife's edge last night and it was only thanks to Twilight Sparkle that they had fallen onto the right side. The enemy had come close last night, too close; did they even realise just how close they had come to landing a crippling blow? "I have eleven men dead; good men, soldiers of Atlas; I have another seven in the infirmary and some of them might not make it unless their luck turns. So don't talk to me as though I'm making a mountain out of nothing! Salem put four agents right in the heart of Beacon under our very noses and we never saw it coming. Haven students! What's Leo even doing out there that he let this happen?"

"Running Haven Academy, one would hope," Ozpin sighed. He lifted his head out of his hands. "Although I do concede that it is troubling that Salem was able to insert Miss Fall and her team so easily, and that they were able to gain Leo's complete trust as they did."

Ironwood clenched his jaw. "What does he have to say for himself?"

"I don't know," Ozpin admitted. "Leo hasn't reported in for some time."

"Then perhaps it's time you asked him why that is," Ironwood said. He took a deep breath, and made a conscious effort to master his emotions. If Ozpin dismissed him and anything he had to say because he thought that Ironwood was acting too emotionally, too irrationally, then that wouldn't help their cause one bit. If being calm was what was needed to convince Ozpin then he would try to be calm. Anything to make the old man see.

"I have served you faithfully for many years," Ironwood said, leaning on the desk so that his face was closer to Ozpin's. "I've risked my career, even my life, because I believed in you and in what we were doing for the good of the world." He sighed. "I still believe in what we're doing." He let that, and the implicit words he had not spoken, hang in the air for a while. "But we can't just sit on the rocks in Beacon or Atlas and watch as the tide rises around us until the world is under water! And if Leo has betrayed us then don't we need to know about it sooner than late?"

Ozpin stared at him for a moment. Ironwood didn't know whether it was because the two of them were so close to one another or because he was more cognisant now of Ozpin's faults, but he would swear that he had never seen him look so old before.

He looked away, as a deep sigh of regret escaped him. "Raven… now Leo, too? Am I so poor at choosing those in whom to place my trust?"

"I hope not," Glynda said. "You trusted us, after all."

Ozpin's lips quirked upwards in a smile. "Thank you, Glynda." He pulled his scroll out of his pocket. "I accept that there is some force in what you say, James. Perhaps we should find out what Leo has to say about all of this."

"Would you like us to go, professor?" Glinda asked.

For himself, Ironwood had no intention of going anywhere until he heard Leo's explanation – and it had better be a damn good one – so he was glad when Ozpin shook his head and made it superfluous to need to argue the point. "No, you can both stay. You might as well hear this."

He opened his scroll and placed it face up upon the transparent surface of his desk. With one hand, Ozpin played with some of the buttons, and a holographic interface burst out from the scroll into the air above the desk. At first it was a hologram of nothing, just the three-dimensional equivalent of static, but after a few moments – moments in which Ironwood and Glinda walked around the desk so that they were standing behind Ozpin and all facing the same direction - it resolved itself into an image of Leonardo Lionheart rendered in blue-green, looking out at them.

"Ozpin!" he cried. "This, uh, this is a pleasant surprise. James, Glynda, it's really been too long since we've last spoken."

"It certainly has," Ironwood growled.

"It's good to see you too, Leo, and to hear your voice," Ozpin declared affably, as though there weren't serious questions to be asked over some of Leo's recent decision-making.

"Indeed. We're almost all here," Leo said jovially. "I'm a little surprised Qrow isn't there too." He looked over his shoulder, as though he half-expected Qrow Branwen to start tapping on the window of his office in Mistral asking to be let in.

"At the moment Qrow is still on a mission," Ozpin said. "He's out of contact, even more than you."

Leo's eyes bulged. "I haven't reported to you because I have nothing to report!" he squawked indignantly. "We're both busy men, I didn't think that you'd want me to call you up every week just to tell you that all is well and quiet in Mistral."

"Nothing to report?" Ironwood demanded, clenching his robotic hand into a fist as he leaned over Ozpin's shoulder. "What about Cinder Fall, do you have anything to report there?"

"Cinder Fall," Leo murmured.

"Cinder Fall attacked the CCT here in Beacon last night," Ozpin said. "A number of Atlesian soldiers were killed or wounded. Later, Miss Fall's team-mates fled before they could be questioned which, I'm sure you will agree, strongly suggests that they were involved in some way. In addition, there is some evidence linking Miss Fall to the recent upsurge in White Fang activities here in Vale."

"My gods," Leo said. "Was any damage done?"

"My men are dead, weren't you listening?" Ironwood snapped, barely resisting the urge to punch Leo through the hologram. "And a young girl of great importance to Atlas – and to me – nearly joined them. And all because-"

"James, please," Ozpin said, holding up one hand for calm.

Ironwood clenched his jaw and backed off with great reluctance. He turned his back, and walked towards the emerald-tinted windows of Ozpin's office.

The old man didn't understand. He couldn't understand why this had Ironwood so frustrated. Ozpin was an intelligent man, a great man, but he sat up here in this tower like a grey-haired spider and he spun his webs across Remnant, grooming his teams of huntsmen and huntresses and sending them out to fight and die in the battle against Salem and her forces. He didn't have friends, and Ironwood was under no illusions that even those closest to him like Glynda and himself were truly in his confidence. He approached his war like a game of chess, moving his white knights and pawns across the board to keep the blacks at bay and guard the four white queens who held the key to the entire game.

Ironwood wasn't like that. He was Twilight's godfather, her father had been his XO, he'd personally handpicked Rainbow Dash to lead Team RSPT because he'd gotten to know her well enough to put his trust in her; these weren't chess pieces to him, they were people, people who looked up to him, people who sought his approval, people who put their lives in his hands because they trusted him without reservation.

Even if it was for the good of the world, it pained him that he wasn't fully worthy of their trust, that he sullied it with lies and half-truths and omissions.

And even if it was for the good of the world, he couldn't just send them to their deaths without it weighing on his soul.

If the old man could, well… Ironwood wasn't sure which of them was the lucky one.

"As I hope you can see, Leo," Ozpin continued. "It appears that Miss Fall was our enemy from at least the moment that she entered Haven Academy, and although we have no direct evidence linking her to our true foe, it seems unlikely that they could be completely unconnected. She may even be the woman who attacked Autumn and stole a part of her power."

Leo laughed nervously. "Ozpin, with all due respect, some of that is pure conjecture." His face fell. "But that's not why you called me, is it? You… you think I'm involved in some way? After all that I have done-"

"Calm down, Leo," Glynda said. "Nobody is accusing you of anything."

"I think that James would like to, wouldn't you James?"

Ironwood turned and walked back towards the hologram. "I'd certainly appreciate some answers."

"Leo," Ozpin said, calmly but firmly. "We've spoken to Mister Arc, Miss Nikos and Miss Rose." They would have spoken to Miss Shimmer, too, but she had absented herself and nobody knew exactly where she was. "They both told exactly the same story: that you introduced Miss Fall to all four members of Team Sapphire, as one of your top students while at a party in Mistral during the spring vacation."

"You're taking the word of three first-year students against me? After everything-"

"This is not about taking anyone's word over yours, this isn't about apportioning blame, this is about getting to the truth," Ozpin declared, sounding a little testy at this point. "Your relationship with Miss Fall-"

"Yes, I took an interest in Cinder Fall," Leo declared. "Do you know why? It's not because I'm a traitor or a servant of Salem! It's because she was especially talented and I was desperate. If she really did attack the tower and kill James' soldiers-"

"If?" Ironwood snapped.

"Then you must understand how good she is; how swift, how strong; probably a match for Pyrrha, or close to it. Ozpin, I don't think you understand the kind of pressure that I'm under here. You gave me this position but since then you've continually poached the best and brightest of Sanctum's graduates and left me and Haven to make do with the residue that you didn't want."

And what does that have to do with anything? Ironwood thought. It wasn't that Leo was entirely wrong – Ozpin did take the best students who might otherwise have gone to Atlas, Haven or Shade. He tried to, at least, but Ironwood liked to think that he'd gotten pretty good at defending his turf and keeping the students that he wanted at Atlas where he wanted them - he'd lost Weiss Schnee, which was disappointing, but he was inclined to blame that at least partly on her father; if Leo hadn't learned to do the same that was no excuse for letting traitors and enemies into their midst.

"You're exaggerating," Glynda said. "Professor Ozpin only encourages a select few students that have the potential to be valuable assets to our cause to attend Beacon instead of any other huntsman academy."

"Do you know how long it's been since Haven last had a Vytal Festival champion?" Leo demanded. "Mistral invented the arena, and the kingdom's tradition of heroic combat stretching back into days of myth and legend is a source of great pride. It grieves them to see that tradition faltering in the modern day, outdone by kingdoms with no such heritage, and I am the one they blame for it! People think I'm incompetent, and because I'm a faunus they think they have a right to tell me so my face. I have to listen to the likes of Lady Nikos sneer at my record while Mistral-born huntsmen win honours for Beacon and Vale, for you! Pyrrha was supposed to turn things around for us, with her at the forefront this year was going to be our year, but then you had to go and take her too! At this rate the council is going to vote to dismiss me and then what use will I be to you or our enterprise? I saw a talented fighter with the potential to put Haven back on the map and I grabbed that opportunity with both hands. Did I look closely into who she was or where she and the rest of her team came from? No. Should I have? Well, perhaps, but I had no other choice but to do as I did. You left me no other choice, Ozpin. Do you want me to remain in post to serve you here or not?"

So your defence is incompetence? Ironwood attempted to keep the contempt he felt off his face and out of his body language. Are you any more use in that case then if you were a traitor? All your justifications can't obscure the fact that you let our enemies into the heart of our defences and only blind luck prevented them from doing incalculable damage.

Do you actually have a reason why we should still trust you?


"No one wants to see you dismissed from your office," Ozpin said, with surprising geniality in his tone. "I merely wanted to get my facts straight. Thank you for being so honest with me, Leo. I hope you understand that I need to give this matter a great deal of thought. Goodbye. Please try to keep in touch in future."

Leo sighed. He looked as though he was sweating. "Goodbye, Ozpin. Glynda, James. Until next time."

"Quite," Ozpin said, before he hung up.

"Do you trust him?" Ironwood demanded. "Do you believe everything that he said? Do you believe anything that he said?"

"I… have sometimes been overzealous in my desire to have the best talent in Remnant here at Beacon, where I could better evaluate them," Ozpin confessed.

"That doesn't excuse leaving Mistral completely undefended," Ironwood said. "I left-"

"Not everyone has an oversized army," Glynda pointed out.

"I admit that there remain some unanswered questions," Ozpin said. "Questions that we may never be able to fully answer unless, by some happy accident, we are able to capture and interrogate Miss Fall. But I am not willing to condemn a man who pledged his loyalty and service to me without further proof than I currently possess."

And what about my loyalty and service? Ironwood wanted to ask. He huffed. "So we do nothing?"

"What can we do at this point, James?" Ozpin asked. "Miss Fall is in the wind, possibly she has fled to join her allies of the White Fang but we don't know where they are either. What can we do but wait, and be ready for her next move when it comes? What would you have me do?"

Ironwood was silent for a moment, because as much as he didn't like it the old man had a point. He had a fleet and an army but no target against which to turn either of them.

He resolved to have another crack at Torchwick; perhaps having his boss uncovered and forced into hiding would make him more willing to talk.

It was about all they had to go on at this stage.

Ironwood clasped his hands behind his back. "We need to do something about Twilight."

"Your student?" Glinda asked. "What do you mean?"

"Although the data from her trace looks like it was wiped, Twilight saw it," Ironwood said. "Cinder routed her mail outing Blake Belladonna as part of the White Fang through Drachyra. You can understand why she thinks that's important."

The price of keeping secrets from the world: the members of Ozpin's inner circle all knew that Salem had her fortress somewhere on the grimm-infested dragon continent, but as far as the rest of Remnant was concerned it was simply grimm-infested, and so to Twilight the fact that someone – the White Fang, a nebulous human terrorist organisation, somebody – might have operations there was something worthy of investigation; and Ironwood couldn't simply tell her that, in his opinion, it wasn't because, to be frank, if he hadn't know what he knew he would absolutely think it worthy of investigation.

Ozpin closed his eyes and leaned back in his chair. "We cannot beard her in her den, James. She is too ancient, too powerful and her grimm there are too numerous. You could not force your way through to the gates of her dark fortress with all the strength of the Atlesian military nor could you defeat her when or if you got there." He bowed his head, once more looking far older and wearier than was generally the case. Ironwood couldn't be entirely sure what he was thinking about, but he wouldn't have been surprised to learn that Ozpin's thoughts were turning to Team STRQ and to the failure of their strike eighteen years ago.

That was the moment when we stopped trying to do anything but hold the line. That was the moment when we handed her the initiative, and we've never gotten it back.

"I know," Ironwood said. "But Twilight Sparkle doesn't. So what do I tell her?"

"Tell her you'll take it to the Council," Ozpin said.

"I have two seats on the council," Ironwood reminded him. "And Twilight's sister-in-law holds another. If I tell her that I'm going to take it to the Council then I'd better do it or she'll find out that I haven't, and if I do take it to the Council then… her family has influence, the Council may agree that this is something that we need to investigate. Especially if I back it, which I'd have a hard time not doing."

"Because of your position, or simply because you like this girl?" Glynda asked.

"Because her trust is important to me," Ironwood said.

Ozpin opened his eyes. "I hope that you have a suggestion of your own to make, James."

"As it happens, I do," Ironwood said. He hesitated for a moment, knowing that his suggestion would not be popular. "I want to bring her in."

"You want what?" Glynda demanded.

"And not just Twilight, but Rainbow Dash as well," Ironwood continued. "Perhaps Miss Nikos too, and Miss Shimmer if she can be found, although your students, your call."

"How very generous of you," Glynda muttered.

"If you want Pyrrha Nikos to be your guardian then we're going to have to trust her at some point," Ironwood said. "And none of us are going to be here forever, or even in our posts forever. At what point do we put our trust in the new generation to carry on this fight after us?"

"When they're a little older than seventeen or eighteen," Glynda said.

"None of us were that much older when Ozpin brought us in," Ironwood replied. "If we were any older at all. Twilight has one of the brightest minds in the history of Atlas; Rainbow Dash is one of the bravest soldiers I've ever seen; frankly, these are the people we need to fight this war and the kind of people in whose hands I could feel comfortable placing the world when we're all gone." He took a step towards Ozpin. "We don't have to tell them everything right now, but let me tell them something. Let me give them at least a peak behind the curtain and I swear to you, you won't regret it."

"We've thought that before," Glynda murmured. "This is information to break the greatest of paragons."

"No," Ozpin sighed. "The greatest of paragons died faithful to the last." He closed his eyes. "I am not so naïve as to think that… if I tell Miss Shimmer and Miss Nikos, they will not keep it from Miss Rose. Is this what Summer would have wanted?"

"Even if Summer were here, she wouldn't get to make that choice," Ironwood said. "Not on behalf of her daughter."

"It is too soon," Glynda insisted. "They are too young, still, too unseasoned. Team Stark were a year older-"

"She's moving more quickly now," Ironwood insisted. "We have to-"

"Give her more servants? Terrify more children into betraying us?" Glynda demanded.

"I know my people," Ironwood declared.

"I thought that I knew Raven!" Glynda snapped. "We all did!"

"Raven Branwen was a bandit from a line of murderers and thieves," Ironwood was nearly shouting now. "The surprise isn't that Raven quit, the astonishing thing is that Qrow didn't… much as I hate to credit him with anything." He paused for a moment. "Rainbow Dash isn't Raven," he said. "She doesn't have somewhere to run, she has something to protect, and I could probably say the same of Miss Nikos-"

"But not of Miss Shimmer, I fear," Ozpin said, his voice thin and weary. "Miss Shimmer has great potential, but… but, as Glynda reminds me, Raven had great potential, too." He hesitated. "But… but perhaps James is right. Perhaps events are moving too swiftly for caution. She is on the move, and we must match her somehow, set our agents against hers."

"You won't regret this," Ironwood said forcefully. "They're made of the right stuff, Oz, I'll stake my reputation on it."

"That's exactly what you're doing," Glynda reminded him.

"I know," Ironwood said. "And I do it without fear."

"Without fear?" Glynda repeated. "None at all."

Ironwood frowned. "I fear for them," he admitted. "I know what I'm getting them into, what I'm asking you to ask of them. But I have no fear, none at all, that they'll let me down."

Ozpin looked at him, his thoughts concealed behind his inscrutable eyes, and said nothing.

Until, at length, he spoke.

"Very well," he said. "Let us open their eyes… and pray that we are better judges of character than once we were."
 
Chapter 85 - Pure
Pure​



Sunset hesitated outside the SAPR dorm room. Her scroll was in her hand to unlock the door, but she paused, dithering over actually doing it. She glanced at Blake as her free hand balled up.

"You're going to stay with me, right?"

Blake had a slight smile playing across her face as she nodded. "I'm not going anywhere."

"Right, that's… that's good to hear," Sunset said. She took a deep breath. And then another. She could do this. It was just walking through a door.

I am Sunset Shimmer; I have crossed worlds and universes and chased my fate across the world; I have walked through more imposing doors than this.

So why does it feel as though I'm about to be called out on the carpet by Princess Celestia?

Is this Cinder's nervousness?

No. That would be too lucky. Cinder doesn't get nervous.

Or does she?


It occurred to Sunset that while Cinder might not want to think that she got nervous, Ashley had certainly gotten nervous in the past. Maybe, just maybe, it was a touch of Cinder's apprehension that she was feeling at the thought of confronting her friends.

After all, if Sunset could feel Cinder's hatred of Pyrrha, why wouldn't she also feel Cinder's fear at the idea of confronting Pyrrha and Ruby together, head on?

Or Sunset herself was just afraid of telling them everything, but it made her feel better to detach herself from that particular unheroic emotion and pretend – and who was to say that she was definitely pretending? It might be true – that this wasn't her but another instance of Cinder's invasion of her soul.

Especially when that enabled Sunset to tell herself that Cinder was scared of a fight.

And she, Sunset Shimmer, wasn't afraid of anything.

She flashed her scroll in front of the door, and it unlocked with a click.

The dorm room was as silent as a mausoleum as Sunset stepped inside and-

"Sunset!"

Sunset stopped, almost knocked over onto her backside as Ruby ran into her, wrapping both her arms around Sunset's chest.

"You came back!" Ruby yelled. She looked up into Sunset's face. "Where have you been? We were all so worried about you!"

Sunset made an awkward noise out of the back of her throat as she awkwardly tried to envelop Ruby without touching her with her hands, which meant that she was sort of flailing about with her arms and using her elbows to pat Ruby on the head. It was all very… 'awkward' was the word that summed the whole thing up best, really.

She looked over Ruby's head. Jaune looked relieved but at the same time wasn't making any effort to hide his curiosity. Pyrrha's arms were folded, but she had a fond smile upon her face.

"Uh, Ruby," Pyrrha said. "Perhaps you'd better give Sunset a little space."

"Oh, right," Ruby said, hastily releasing Sunset and backing away. "Sorry."

"Don't apologise," Sunset said, as she was able to make enough space for Blake to enter the room and close the door behind the two of them. Sunset sidled over to her bed but didn't sit down on it. She clasped her hands together behind her back. "That's my job right now, I think."

Ruby laughed nervously. Pyrrha looked away for a moment. "Well, I can't deny that we'd certainly like to know what happened last night… but it feels fair to admit that you aren't the only one who feels at fault. I should have gone with you."

"We both should have," Jaune said. "If we'd gone with you, then maybe… maybe things would have been different, and that's on us."

"I've been trying to tell them that it wouldn't have made any difference if they had come, or even if Blake had come too," Ruby said. "That's right, isn't it? Cinder ran off as soon as she realised how outnumbered she was, and she would have done the exact same thing if Pyrrha and Jaune were there."

"Definitely," Sunset said. "She wasn't going to stick around for a fight with two more fighters to go up against." She considered the possibility that Cinder's rage against Pyrrha – the rage that she could feel simmering inside her just by being this close to Pyrrha, the rage that she was having to keep a lid on and hope that it didn't boil over – might have driven her to try and take her out when the chance presented itself, but she dismissed the idea as swiftly as it had formed in her head. Cinder Fall was a lot of things, most of them bad, but she wasn't stupid. Not even her desire to murder Pyrrha would prompt her to fight a hopeless battle against unwinnable odds.

Despite her dislike for the champion of Mistral and everything she represented, Cinder was still cognisant of Pyrrha's reputation. Her presence would only have made Cinder get out of there even faster.

Ruby nodded briskly. "And then Sunset would still have gone after her and then…" She trailed off, looking a little guilty for having brought the situation back to the 'and then.' "I mean, uh…"

"What happened last night?" Jaune asked. "Why didn't you come back? Where were you?"

"In the library," Sunset admitted.

Jaune frowned. "After lights out?"

"She slept on some books," Blake said disapprovingly.

"New books," Sunset stressed. "Books that I knew could stand up to it. Besides, it's not like I'm heavy."

"But… why?" Jaune demanded. "I mean there's a perfectly good bed right here."

"You'd be surprised," Sunset said, risking a slight smile.

Judging by the expressions on the faces of her teammates, they weren't in much of a mood for levity.

Sunset huffed. There was no getting away from this, was there?

Well, no, of course not, you idiot. Did you think that you could come back here and you wouldn't have to tell them?

But Blake was okay with it, so they will be too.


Sunset glanced at Blake, who gave her a barely perceptible nod by way of reassurance.

You are Sunset Shimmer, and you can do this.

You told them about your magic; you can tell them this.

You are Sunset Shimmer, and these are your friends.


She clasped her hands tighter together behind her back. "As Ruby has probably told you," she said, "Cinder fled the tower, and I teleported after her."

"How did she get down from the tower?" Jaune asked. "I mean, aura and all, but that's a long way to fall. Did she have a landing strategy?"

"You could say that," Sunset said. "She flew."

"What?" Jaune exclaimed.

"Is that her semblance?" Pyrrha asked.

"If flying is her semblance, then how is she stopping bullets with one hand?" Ruby said.

"That could just be theatrics to cover up the fact that all those hits are draining her aura away," Pyrrha suggested. "I've taken part in a few blind tournaments – tournaments where only the referee can see the aura levels of the combatants – where some contestants tried to cover up the fact that they were using aura through flamboyant displays or misdirection; Cinder's hand motions could be in the same line."

Blake coughed into one hand, and with the other, gestured towards Sunset.

"I'm sorry," Pyrrha said. "Please go on, Sunset."

"I fought Cinder," Sunset said. "I… I was holding my own, I suppose." It was hard to remember how the fight had been going before she activated her semblance because of everything that had happened after that. "I… I wanted to know how she could do it. How she could betray us, betray the world, betray everything that huntresses are supposed to stand for. I liked her, you know? I… I like her a lot. I thought we were so alike."

"Personally, I'm afraid I can't say that I ever saw it," Pyrrha murmured.

Sunset blinked. "Really?"

"No," Pyrrha admitted. "You… you had your moments, but you were always quite open about how you felt, even if your expression of those feelings was… sometimes rather obnoxious. You were never snide, and I never felt as though your words had double meanings. Cinder… I always felt as though there was something I couldn't trust about her."

Sunset was silent for a moment. "You… I… thanks."

Pyrrha looked a little confused. "For what?"

"You'll understand soon, I think," Sunset replied. "I was fighting Cinder, but while we were fighting, I kept asking her, demanding that she tell me why, why she'd done this. I just wanted to know how she could do it. I wanted to know how someone so like me – someone who I thought was so like me, even if some of you don't agree – could do something like that. And that… it seems to have activated my semblance."

"Really?" Ruby squeaked. "Is that what you were upset about? Wait, why would you be upset about that? Activating your semblance is awesome!"

"It is when you have an awesome semblance like super speed," Sunset said. "My semblance is… not so great."

Her words hung in the air for a moment before Jaune said, "Would you like us to guess?"

"Right, right," Sunset said. "I… I'm not entirely sure what to call it. It's like a combination of empathy-"

Ruby gasped. "You mean you can turn off electricity and deactivate robots?"

Sunset looked at her flatly. "No, Ruby, that's EMP, and that would actually be cool to be able to do. Empathy is… feelings and stuff."

"Your semblance is… feelings and stuff?" Ruby asked, sounding surprised and disappointed at the same time.

"If you'll let me finish," Sunset snapped, causing a crestfallen look to descend on Ruby's face. She sighed and groaned at the same time. "Sorry, I just… this isn't all me, but I can't escape the blame for it. My semblance is a combination of empathy and touch telepathy. When I touched Cinder's arm... I saw her past. I know who she is now. I asked how she could turn out this way…and then I found out."

For a moment, none of them said anything. Then Jaune let out a soft, "Woah. Really?"

Sunset nodded and sat down on the bed with her hands resting between her knees. "I didn't see absolutely everything. I didn't see anything about who she might be working for, I didn't see what she's planning… but I saw her childhood, I saw the things that happened to her. I saw what took a good, sweet kid and turned her into a monster."

She stopped, the words dying in her throat.

"Sunset?" Jaune asked.

"I… I'm not sure if I ought to tell you," Sunset admitted. "It feels… it feels a little like betraying her."

"You just said that she betrayed humanity," Ruby reminded her. "Betrayed everything that being a huntress is about."

"Does that mean it's okay for me to betray her secrets?" Sunset asked. After all, just because we're enemies doesn't mean that we're not friends.

And yet, Ruby's response, lacking in sympathy as it was, made her think that perhaps betraying – some – of Cinder's secrets might be the lesser of two evils. After all, it was clear that no one was particularly inclined to cut Cinder any slack as things stood, but perhaps once they had heard her story, they would look more kindly on her, they would understand a little better.

Perhaps, if they heard the truth, they would feel the way that Sunset did.

Without all the anger and hatred and desire to kill.

Sunset's brow furrowed. "Cinder's mother was an Atlesian pilot, in Argus. One day… one day, she didn't come home from a mission."

"That's not an excuse," Ruby declared.

"I'm not finished yet!" Sunset snapped. She shook her head. "Sorry, I… I haven't finished. In fact, I've hardly begun. Cinder's father decided that it would be for the best – best for him, anyway – to move away from Argus and the unpleasant memories. And so he took his little girl back to Mistral, where he'd come from. He was a kind and devoted father, as well as Cinder could recall anyway, but… I suppose he must have felt that she needed a mother's care. And so he married again, choosing, for his second wife…" – she looked at Pyrrha – "Lady Clytemnestra Kommenos."

Pyrrha's eyes widened. "'Kommenos'? Phoebe's mother?" She gasped. "Cinder was the stepsister?"

"You knew that Phoebe had a stepsister?" Sunset replied. "But you didn't recognise Cinder?"

"I never met Phoebe's stepsister," Pyrrha told her. "Everyone… most of what I'm about to tell you has been told to me after the fact, I must confess. I was only a girl at the time; the only thing I really understood about Phoebe Kommenos was that she was my opponent… and not really on my level."

"I'm afraid you did Cinder no favours with your prowess," Sunset muttered. "After her defeats… Phoebe used to take her humiliation out on Cinder."

Pyrrha frowned. "What do you mean?"

"I… I'd rather not say," Sunset said. "I didn't want to see it, and I certainly don't want to repeat it."

Pyrrha bowed her head. "So… it was true."

Sunset stared at her. "You knew," she whispered. "People knew."

"Nobody knew anything," Pyrrha insisted. "But… there have been rumours about Phoebe for several years, and amongst them… my mother says that Lady Kommenos married beneath her socially, the second time, but that her second husband's wealth made up for it. When her second husband died, the Kommenos' step-daughter withdrew completely from society. Lady Kommenos was well known, Phoebe competed in tournaments, but their stepsister… I don't even remember her name; certainly, I do not recognise the name of Cinder Fall."

Sunset said nothing. Cinder's old name, the name of the little girl who had suffered under Phoebe's cruelty, that was something she would not divulge. That was a secret that was not hers to reveal.

"A girl who was never seen," Pyrrha went on, "who was always said to be ill, who might as well have been a ghost? Of course there were rumours."

"'Rumours,'" Sunset repeated in a voice as sharp as Soteria's edge. "Rumours. People talked about it, they whispered about it, they guessed what was happening to Cinder inside that house, and they did nothing! Celestia! No wonder she's so angry!"

"What was anyone supposed to do?" Pyrrha asked.

"I don't know, rescue her?" Sunset suggested acidly. "Gotten her out of that damn house? Fought for those who could not fight for themselves?"

"It's not that simple," Pyrrha murmured.

"Why not?" Sunset demanded.

"You know why," Pyrrha cried. Her bosom heaved. "You have been to Mistral, you have stood in the company of the high, you know why."

Sunset was silent for a moment. "Because the Kommenos family was well born, and wealthy too, so they could do as they pleased, and none dared challenge them." She scowled. "No one even wanted to, did they?"

"I don't know," Pyrrha confessed. "I was too young to know."

Sunset shook her head in disgust. "So much for the glory of Mistral," she muttered, and in that moment, she felt in tune with Cinder's hatred of the place, her feelings resonating with Sunset's own. They had known. They had all known, or at the least had strong suspicions, and yet… and yet nobody had cared enough to do anything about it. None of them.

If that was the world they lived in, then let it burn.

Sunset scowled. No. No, that was too much, too angry, too wild and scattershot and too unjust in turn. Condemn, yes, but not punish.

Yes, wag your finger at them and then leave them free to abandon the next victim.

Or instead make so many other victims of those innocent of all part in this? Pyrrha was too young to know what was going on.

When she is older, she will turn away just as they did.

No, she won't; she isn't like that.

They're all like that!

SHUT UP!


"Sunset?" Jaune asked anxiously.

Sunset blinked rapidly. "Sorry, um… what was I saying?"

"You weren't," Blake observed.

"But, I have a question," Jaune said, raising his hand tentatively.

"You don't have to put your hand up," Sunset told him.

"Right," Jaune said, but kept his hand up. "So, Cinder and Phoebe are stepsisters, and Phoebe… yeah. Is that why Cinder kept it to herself?"

"I think Cinder wanted to keep her past mysterious," Sunset replied. "But… yes, that's one of the reasons." She didn't mention what she'd seen outside the ice cream parlour, the way that Cinder had frozen up with terror in Phoebe's presence. She wouldn't humiliate Cinder like that, make her out to be even more of a victim.

She got the impression that Cinder wouldn't appreciate that.

"And is that why Phoebe didn't mention it either?" Jaune asked. "Because she was afraid that people would find out what she did?"

"No," Sunset said. "I don't think she has to worry about that," she added, with a glance at Pyrrha that the latter did not deserve. "No, I think the reason that she didn't mention it is that she didn't recognise Cinder."

"How could she not recognise her own sister?"

"Stepsister," Sunset clarified. "And-"

"She believes that her stepsister is dead," Pyrrha murmured. "As did everyone. There was a fire, in the year that Phoebe first went to Atlas; all the rest of her family burned to death, or… or so it was believed. When Phoebe came home for the funeral, she seemed… so upset. I… actually felt sorry for her, at the time."

"Whatever she did, whatever kind of person she was, she did lose her mother and sister," Jaune said. "If that happened to me, I… I mean I haven't spoken to my Mom since I left for Beacon, but… if I found out that she'd died, that any of my sisters had… I… I'd just… God, I can't even…" The very idea was apparently enough to leave him looking downcast and disheartened, and he started to half lean, half sit down on the nearest desk.

Sunset looked away. "Obviously, Cinder didn't burn to death," she said. "In fact… she's the one who set the fire."

"Really?" Pyrrha asked. "As far as I recall, there was no suggestion of arson."

"Then she was good at covering her tracks," Sunset replied. "But she did it." She did not add that she could hardly blame her. "That… that's the last memory that I saw; after that, she… she was able to throw me out somehow, break our connection."

"I must say, it seems quite enough," Pyrrha said softly.

"Mhm," Blake agreed. "So, what are you going to do?"

"About what?" Sunset asked, genuinely curious as to what Blake meant.

"About Phoebe Kommenos?" Blake demanded. "She abused her stepsister; she can't just be allowed to get away with that-"

"Has she not already gotten away with it?" Sunset replied. "In Atlas, she is considered a model student, and no one ever punished her for what she did."

"Yet," Blake added.

"What do you mean?"

"I mean that that could change," Blake declared. "You know the truth, you what she did, you could tell General Ironwood-"

"That my newly activated semblance enabled me to see into the soul of our enemy?" Sunset asked. "Lest you forget, as far as the world is concerned, I already have a semblance."

"I am sure the General would keep your confidence," Blake said.

"I'm sure you do, Rainbow Dash," Sunset muttered. "I am not so sure." And it wasn't just because Cinder numbered General Ironwood amongst her enemies – although she did. She had contempt for Professor Ozpin, the senile old fool, but she feared Ironwood. No, that was not quite right; she did not fear the man. She feared no one – except Phoebe, the terror that she could not escape – but she was wary of the strength at his command. She understood what it meant to set herself against the power of Atlas, for all that she was resolved to do so, no matter the cost.

But it was not just Cinder's feelings affecting her mind, although Cinder had told her something: there was a connection between the two men; they were more than just colleagues. Whatever Professor Ozpin was involved in, General Ironwood was involved in, too.

"And so you will say nothing?" Blake asked. "You'll let her keep getting away with it?"

"It's a little late for Cinder either way," Sunset said.

"But not for her other victims," Blake insisted. "Trust me, Sunset, there will be other victims. Someone like that… as good as she is at hiding what she really is, there's no way she'll be able to suppress it completely."

So what if there are other victims? I don't know them, Sunset thought bitterly, and although the bitterness belonged to Cinder, she could not with such certainty say the same for the callousness. She held her peace and kept that thought to herself as her tail curled upwards. "I… I will speak to Rainbow Dash about it," she muttered. "I will consider it, at least."

Blake's lips twitched upwards ever so slightly, and only for a moment. "Thank you," she whispered.

"But that's not all there is to it," Ruby whispered. "Is it? You didn't stay away because you saw Cinder's past."

"No," Sunset said, with a sigh. "I didn't just see Cinder's past; I felt her emotions as well." She glanced at Pyrrha. "She really hates you. She doesn't like any of us – she wants us dead – but you… you she hates especially."

"Why?" Ruby asked.

"Yeah, how could anybody hate Pyrrha?" Jaune added, looking up.

"You were both at a party, a few years ago at least," Sunset said. "You were only a kid, if her memories are accurate. Everyone was fawning all over you."

"That describes several parties I attended with my mother," Pyrrha said. "When I was still young enough that I was a precocious prodigy, before I grew up and my abilities started to become a threat to the dignitas of my fellow nobles. I'm afraid that I don't remember encountering Cinder Fall at all before the spring vacation."

"I'm sure she'd hate you even more if she heard that you didn't remember her at all," Sunset said, with just a touch of wryness entering her voice. "Considering that that's the whole reason she hates you to begin with: you had everything that she wanted so badly but could never have." She snorted. "Kind of like why I didn't like you."

"Sunset-" Pyrrha began.

"I didn't come home last night," Sunset said, cutting across her because she needed this to be out there, to be done with; she needed the sword hanging above her head to descend one way or another; she couldn't wait in trepidation for their reaction to this any longer. "I didn't come back here because… because I didn't stop feeling her when we broke skin contact. She… it's like she left something in me. I didn't suck her feelings away, but it's as if they're my feelings now as well. All of her hatred, all of her anger… everything she feels for you." She closed her eyes, but then she opened them once again and forced herself not to look away; she forced herself to look into those stricken faces, those masks of shock, until it was done. Till she was done. "She wants you dead. All of you. All of us. She's got a list, and we're all on it. Except… except she might be willing to take you off the list because-"

"Don't say it," Blake said.

"Huh?" Ruby asked.

Blake rolled her eyes. "Cinder and Sunset both have this idea that they're the same. I've tried to explain to her how ridiculous that is."

"I admit that we're not twins separated at birth," Sunset said. "But we're not so different that-"

"Yes, you are!" Blake insisted. "And I've already explained why. It doesn't matter that some of your backgrounds match, it doesn't matter that you feel the same thing, it doesn't even matter that you have similar natures if that's even true. It's what you do that matters, and what you do… what you do is right and righteous, even if it isn't always for the most righteous reasons. You're not a monster, Sunset, and you never were. If you were, then I… I'd know this time; I'd know better this time, and I wouldn't… I wouldn't let myself… I'd know."

Sunset stared at her. You wouldn't let yourself what? You'd know better than… than when?

When you were with Adam?


Ruby's voice, soft and trembling, cut across Sunset's thoughts. "Is that what you thought?" she asked. "That you were like her?"

Sunset's brow furrowed for a moment. "No," she said. "But I was worried – I am worried – that I could become like her; Cinder certainly thinks I can."

"Then she's an idiot," Ruby said. "There's no way in Remnant that you could become like Cinder because... because you've got us, and we'd never let that happen."

Sunset smiled thinly. "Yeah. Yeah, I've got you. I think… I think that's the difference between us. After her father died, Cinder didn't have anybody to turn to, but I… I've got you. You guys are my saving grace." She pursed her lips momentarily. "I just wish that all her anger and hate didn't feel so at home in me." I just wish I didn't feel as though I'm struggling to keep a lid on it just being in the same room with all of you. She could feel it inside of her like a tiger in a cage, growling and flashing its claws, lunging at the bars in the hope that the iron of Sunset's virtue – such as it was – would give way before the bestial strength of Cinder's fury. It wanted to lash out, it wanted to strike; it was as if, disconnected from Cinder's own mind, her wrath had no more caution but only a wild, untamed desire to inflict pain and destruction on all that it despised the most.

And why shouldn't it want that? Cinder won't be harmed by the consequences, only me and my friends.

Pyrrha looked pensive, Jaune looked as though he just didn't know what to say – or maybe even what to think – but Ruby had a look in her silver eyes as though she'd just come up with a plan. "So… what you're saying is that when you touch someone with your hand… you feel the way they feel inside you?"

"Yes," Sunset said slowly, wondering where Ruby was going with this. "That's about-"

"Got an idea!" Ruby cried, and before Sunset could say anything, do anything, Ruby had covered the distance between them in a burst of rose petals and grabbed Sunset's hand in her own small, pale grasp.

"Ruby, wa-" Sunset opened her mouth to protest too late as Ruby's warm hand pressed against her skin. There was that electric jolt running through her arm, and Sunset's head was thrown backwards as she saw…

She saw…

Ruby in a white cloak. No. No, it wasn't Ruby, it couldn't be. This woman was older, and she wore her hair braided at the back which Ruby never did – her hair wasn't long enough.

Mom. The word echoed through Ruby's mind, which was also Sunset's mind right now, or something like that. Mom. Sunset was looking at Ruby's mother.

Ruby's mother, smiling at her. Smiling at Ruby, but as Sunset looked through Ruby's eyes, it was as if Mom was smiling at her too, and she felt such love, love like a fire inside of her; not the all-devouring inferno of Cinder's hatred but the cosy fire that rose from a fireplace to illuminate a draughty room, a fire to snuggle in front of with a blanket wrapped around your shoulders and a hot chocolate in your hands and Mom sat beside you while you leaned on her.

Sunset looked through Ruby's eyes into the softly smiling face of Ruby's mother, and she felt safe.

And then Summer Rose turned away, her white cloak billowing out behind her, and Sunset knew, Sunset knew just as Ruby knew, even if she hadn't known it at the time, but she knew now that her mother was never coming back. That this would be the last time that Ruby ever set eyes on her mother.


Sweet Celestia, how old were you when this happened?

Summer Rose walked away, her white cloak rippling in the breeze like a forlorn flag of an army on the verge of defeat; she walked away, never to return.

Like Cinder's mother.

Sunset gasped, or she would have done if she had had mouth to gasp or if there had been any air to bear the sound away. She hadn't… she hadn't thought about that before. She hadn't made that connection. She'd been so focussed on herself, in the bond that Cinder saw between the two of them, that she hadn't noticed that Ruby and Cinder also shared a connection: their mothers had walked away; they had gone off to fight in some battle of which their daughters knew nothing, for a cause which their daughters could not comprehend, and they had never come back.

As if in response, summoned by Sunset's thoughts, Cinder's anger reared its head like a dog catching the scent of a rabbit in the field, her anger at her mother's death, at the Atlesian military that had taken her away, at the world that had driven her to risk her life in battle howled like a baying wolf, and in Ruby's soul and in her thoughts, an anger answered like another pack returning that same howl. Anger at her mother, for leaving her daughters behind, for risking her life, for leaving them and their father to their grief and their guilt, for leaving Dad to decline and Ruby to cry and Yang to struggle with the burden of holding the wounded family together. Anger at her for leaving them.

Yes, there was anger in Ruby's soul, and perhaps Sunset should have expected that; nobody could be as pure as a newborn babe, and Ruby wasn't that much younger than the rest of them, not to mention she had cause enough for anger besides. But that anger was but a minor key in the music of Ruby's soul, a dark discordant note that did not disrupt but rather almost enhanced the loveliness of the symphony that swelled around Sunset like the music of creation.

Cinder's soul was a jarring sonata, full of angry swipes upon the strings and incensed pounding on the drums and notes played on instruments improperly strung and out of tune, all furiously competing with one another to strike the strongest note in the concerto of hate. At best, it achieved a certain dark majesty when Cinder managed to hold together all of her wrath and direct it to a single common purpose; at worst… at worst it crept out of Sunset's soul and sought to corrupt the gentler, more harmonious music that entered from Ruby. Ruby's soul sang of love, of friendship, of valour and compassion and so many virtues bundled up in such a small package. Though she felt anger towards her mother, she nevertheless revered the cause in which she had given her life, and she was prepared to give her life for it as well.


The peace that endured for fifteen years was purchased with blood that was red like roses.

That thought… it didn't seem like Ruby's thought; the language was too grand, too sophisticated, or was it that Ruby thought like that but couldn't express herself in such words out loud, or simply didn't want to? Whatever the truth, the thought echoed throughout Ruby's mind, a low and sweeping note of the cello but one which nevertheless stood out clear as a bell amidst the other instruments.

The embodiment of courage indeed, she would think nothing of giving her life so long as but a single life – not even a life she knew; a complete stranger would suffice – was purchased by her sacrifice.


Truly, she puts the rest of us to shame.

And yet, that anger. The discordant note, the note to which Cinder's anger called out eagerly, seeking and sensing kinship, reaching out, amplifying it, seeking to twist and corrupt all else, to burn all other feelings from Sunset's soul and leave only anger and hate behind.

And then, in answer, a silver light rose up all around Sunset. All else dissolved, Summer Rose and all the rest, and there was nothing but silver light. There wasn't even ground beneath Sunset's feet, and she was falling through the void as the silver light rose up like shining wings to envelop her.

And it
sang.

Ruby's thoughts didn't linger on any one memory for very long. Sunset tumbled through flashes, images of things past: Team SAPR carving their initials on the wall of the dorm room, Pyrrha's smile when Ruby told her that she had at least one friend at Beacon, Sunset's first real apology to her team after the Forever Fall field trip, dinner at Benni Havens', Sunset singing to her that night..

The silver light enveloped Sunset like swaddling clothes, and the light, that bright, beautiful, glorious light seemed to burn Cinder's anger all away. Sunset couldn't hate Pyrrha because she was filled with the affection that Ruby felt towards her; she couldn't hate or fear herself because she was swimming in Ruby's trust in her; she couldn't despise Jaune because the warmth of Ruby's feelings towards him were wrapped around her like a cosy blanket; she couldn't even hate Blake because Ruby's feelings were too bright: the light that shone like a star from Ruby's soul chased Cinder's darkness all away like grimm feeling before the approach of a great huntress.

And the music, such music such as Sunset had never heard before: such sweep, such depth, such concord. Such beauty.


Sunset was once more in the dorm room, sitting on her bed. But now, she realised, she had tears in her eyes.

"Did… did it work?" Ruby asked tremulously.

Sunset looked at her in amazement and, to be quite honest, a degree of awe as well. "'Did it work'?"

"I thought…" Ruby hesitated. "I thought that maybe some happy memories would drive out Cinder's bad ones."

"'Some happy memories,'" Sunset repeated. You have no idea, do you? You've got no clue just what you are. Perhaps it ought to be kept that way. Sunset was living proof of the dangers of telling someone that they were too gifted, too special. "Yes," she said simply. "Yes, it worked. I… I feel a lot better now."

That was an understatement. It might even be the understatement. That light, that warmth, that music. Sunset felt as though she had woken from the kind of dream that made you cry to dream again; it was taking a great deal of self-restraint not to touch Ruby's hand a second time to hear that sound anew, see that light, experience that feeling one more time. When she looked at Jaune and Pyrrha now, she felt not Cinder's wrath but Ruby's love; such feelings would fade, in time… but now, Sunset found that she didn't mind if that fading took its time.

Pyrrha took a few steps towards her. "I can help you train your semblance, if you like," she said. "So that you can control when you use it."

"Thanks," Sunset said. Until then, maybe she should consider a pair of gloves.

Sunset's scroll went off; so did Pyrrha's at the exact same time. With a glance at one another, they both pulled them out.

It was Professor Goodwitch.
 
Chapter 86 - Behind the Curtain
Behind the Curtain​



Sunset and Pyrrha held one another's gaze for a moment, before they both answered their scrolls together.

Immediately, the stern face of Professor Goodwitch appeared on both of their screens, glowering out at them from two different directions as if she had somehow managed to split herself into two people to achieve even greater quantities of restrained disapproval.

"Miss Shimmer," she said in a tone that was brisk and businesslike. "I see from the view that you have found your way back to your dorm room. Although you don't yet seem to have found your way to a change of clothes."

Sunset was still wearing her dress from last night's dance. "Not quite yet, Professor, although I was just about to find my way to the shower."

"That would probably be for the best," Professor Goodwitch said dryly. "I'll inform Professor Ozpin that you'll be somewhat delayed."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. "No offence, Professor Goodwitch, but why would the headmaster be interested in my ablutions?"

"Professor Ozpin would like to see both you and Miss Nikos in his office," Professor Goodwitch said. "Ideally, you would come at once, but I think it would be best if you were to wash and change first, so I'll tell him that you'll be here in twenty minutes."

Sunset leaned forwards a little. "Why does the headmaster want to see us?"

"I suggest you come to his office and find out for yourself, Miss Shimmer," Professor Goodwitch replied with just a touch of tartness in her voice.

"We'll be there, Professor," Pyrrha said.

"Thank you, Miss Nikos," Professor Goodwitch said. "We'll be expecting you. Please try not to keep the headmaster waiting any longer than necessary."

She hung up without saying goodbye.

Sunset folded her scroll away as the screen went black. "That sounds… interesting."

What was most intriguing to her was the fact that the invitation had been extended to Pyrrha and herself. If the headmaster had just called Sunset in to see him, then she would have assumed that it was some routine bit of team leader business, a mission assignment or something that she would be supposed to brief out to her teammates later. If she and Ruby had been called in, then she might have thought it was something to do with last night's events. But Sunset and Pyrrha? Why would Professor Ozpin want to see the two of them but not Jaune and Ruby? Why call in half the team and not the other half?

"Maybe he just wants to talk to you about Cinder?" Jaune asked. "About when we met her in Mistral?"

"Then why aren't you being invited?" Sunset asked, as she got off the bed.

"The rest of us have already spoken to the Professor about that," Pyrrha informed her. "While you were… away."

"Fair enough," Sunset said. "But then why ask you back to talk about the same thing again?"

"Ultimately, speculation is less fruitful than just going to his office to find out what the professor wants," Blake pointed out.

Sunset snorted. "Yeah, good point. Pyrrha, I'll be in and out as quick as I can."

She showered swiftly, barely taking any time to feel the warm water work the knots out of her shoulders or to properly lather up her hair with shampoo and conditioner the way that she would have liked to do. Maybe she'd have another shower after she was done with whatever Professor Ozpin wanted.

Whatever he wanted. Sunset frowned as the water washed down her back and the little shampoo she had used washed out of her hair. What did Professor Ozpin want with her and Pyrrha?

Sunset couldn't have said exactly why she didn't trust the headmaster. Cinder hated him for reasons that Sunset couldn't properly discern, even if Cinder understood them herself; Ruby looked up to him as the model of a huntsman; but Sunset… Sunset couldn't quite bring herself to trust him, even if she couldn't have explained everything about why. Maybe it was just the lingering memories of Princess Celestia and the way that she had kept Sunset in the dark for so long, but was that really a good reason to look askance at Ozpin? After all, Celestia had acted with the best intentions, and Sunset had forgiven her for what she had done, so why should she look at another man, a different person, with suspicion?

Perhaps I just don't like being kept in the dark.

And perhaps I have good reason to feel that way.
Not all secrets were harmless, after all. In a world like this, secrets could get people killed, and Professor Ozpin had secrets by the handful. Just from Summer Rose's journal alone, it was clear that he knew about silver eyes and about the prophets and their magic, and he was keeping this information to himself, doling out small morsels of knowledge to those he trusted in proportion to his trust. Was that what this was about? Was he about to ladle out a small spoonful of information to Pyrrha and Sunset in exchange for… what?

That went back to the old problem: why not bring in the whole of SAPR, as he had apparently brought in the whole of STRQ?

Sunset sighed. Blake was right; the only way to find the answers was to actually go to his office and see what he wanted. So she finished showering and changed into her habitual outfit plus a spare pair of Pyrrha's brown opera gloves to prevent any unwanted activations of her semblance; they didn't fit her too well – Pyrrha's arms were more muscular than Sunset's – but since she strapped her vambraces on over the gloves, she was able to stop them falling off completely, and although they might be slipping down past her elbows, that was all hidden under her jacket, so nobody could see it anyway.

Sunset might have taken her weapons, but as Pyrrha was waiting for her without them, there wasn't really any way to avoid following the lead of her teammate and going without.

"Are you ready?" Pyrrha asked.

Sunset nodded. "Yeah, I guess I am. I mean, I'd prefer it if we knew a little more going in, but since we don't… might as well go and see for ourselves.

Pyrrha frowned. "I don't understand why you have this attitude towards the headmaster."

"Besides the fact that he's keeping secrets, you mean?"

"While that would appear to be true," Pyrrha said, "I'm sure that he has a good reason for it."

"I'm sure… I'm sure that Professor Ozpin himself thinks so," Sunset allowed.

"He's a hero," Blake pointed out.

Sunset looked at her, and folded her arms. "And how do a lot of faunus see Adam Taurus?"

Blake was silent for a moment. "Point, I suppose."

"I don't get it," Jaune said. "You're not seriously suggesting that Professor Ozpin is-"

"A murderer? No, of course not," Sunset said. "I'm just saying that just because a lot of people think you're a hero doesn't make you a good man. It just makes you a great warrior with a cause people can get behind." She sighed. "I don't know really; maybe I'm just paranoid, I just…"

She didn't finish, because she's said it all before and there was no sense repeating it now. It was easier to just let it lie. After all, nothing had happened yet. When it happened – if it happened – then that would be the time to deal with it.

Professor Ozpin might have secrets, but for now, he had also been quite obliging. If he started to make more use of them as he seemed to have once used Team STRQ, then that would be the moment to start worrying, to demand answers, and to make a serious effort to get her more trusting teammates to open their eyes.

But that time had not come yet, and so Sunset and Pyrrha left Jaune, Ruby, and Blake behind and set off from the dorm room towards the tower. A raven croaked at them from somewhere in the trees as they made their way across the courtyard.

"I don't know what Professor Ozpin wants to talk to us about," Pyrrha said softly as they walked, "but I'm sure that whatever it is, it's nothing to be concerned about."

Sunset smiled. There are times when I wish that I could share your certainty, but more times when I'm glad that I'm no longer so naïve. "You're probably right," she said, without much conviction in her soul, no matter how much she was able to put into her voice.

More Atlesian troops guarded the Emerald Tower, and for the moment at least, it wasn't just regular soldiers either; they had huntsmen with them, not students, but Specialists in crisp white uniforms. The tower was still closed, but once Sunset and Pyrrha identified themselves, they were waved through by the guards and were able to get into the elevator without any more difficulty.

The lift rose slowly, crawling upwards with a grinding sound. Pyrrha and Sunset waited in silence, neither saying anything.

For all that she talked about there being nothing to be concerned about, Sunset would have been surprised if Pyrrha wasn't every bit as curious about what was waiting for them up there as Sunset herself. Pyrrha might be more trusting of authority, but she was still human, after all; she had to wonder.

So Sunset let her wonder, and she wondered herself, pondering over why they had been summoned and for what purpose and wouldn't this elevator just hurry up already so that they could find out?

"I can't exactly say why," Sunset murmured, as the elevator climbed, "but I'm reminded of the time my… Princess Celestia first invited me for a private conference. It was a long walk down the corridor to get to her study, and by the time I got there… I had no idea what she wanted to see me about; she'd just invited me to come to see her alone, in private, and so I couldn't help but imagine all the things that might be about to happen to me. Was I about to get kicked out? By the time I walked through the door, my knees were shaking."

Pyrrha chuckled. "Somehow, I'm having a hard time imagining that."

Sunset grinned. "I was only young at the time. But she… she was so good about it; so polite, so kind, so gentle. She knew exactly how to put me at my ease."

"Then there was nothing to worry about."

"The contrary, in fact," Sunset said. "She wanted to make me her personal student, her… her apprentice, if you like." She smiled sadly. "I could have followed in her footsteps if I had been a better person."

Pyrrha was silent for a moment. "You're a better person now."

"That's kind of you to say."

"I meant…" Pyrrha hesitated. "Sunset, have you ever thought about going home?"

Sunset looked at her. "I… no, I can't say I really have."

Pyrrha shrugged. "You're still young. Maybe there's still time. If you went back, then-"

"Ah, I see what you mean," Sunset said, interrupting her before you could finish. "And… you're probably half right. I could go home, if the time was right. Princess Celestia would take me back, I'm sure. But it's too late for… for all the other stuff. She found a new student while I was away, a better m-" She stopped herself before she could say 'mare.' "Someone better than me. That destiny belongs to another now. I have no claim on it, nor can I have any share in it."

"I'm… sorry to hear that."

"Besides," Sunset said, with a grin that was not entirely forced, "what would you guys do without me? Or are you just desperate to get rid of me?"

"N-no, I don't-"

"I know," Sunset said.

Pyrrha nodded. When she spoke again, her voice acquired a playful edge. "Who knows, perhaps Professor Ozpin is going to make us his personal students?"

Sunset snorted. "Yeah, maybe he is." The elevator shuddered to a stop. "I guess now we'll find out, won't we?"

The lift door slid open, and Sunset and Pyrrha stepped out into the office. The gears of the clock ground by inexorably overhead and cast their shadows on the floor beneath.

The spacious office was far from empty. Professor Ozpin sat enthroned in his ornate chair, flanked by Professor Goodwitch and General Ironwood who stood on either side and just behind him, like courtiers waiting to whisper counsel – or poison – into the monarch's ear. Before the desk, standing a little to the right-hand side of the room, stood Rainbow Dash and Twilight Sparkle; where Sunset and Pyrrha had come in their field garb, the two Atlesians were wearing the white and grey uniform of Atlas Academy. Rainbow Dash, standing at ease with her hands clasped behind her back, nodded to the two Beacon students while Twilight, standing more informally, offered a slightly hesitant wave.

Sunset might have said something to greet them both, but – as she and Pyrrha advanced into the room and reached a point roughly level with the two Atlesians – Professor Ozpin spoke before she could get a word out. "Miss Shimmer, Miss Nikos, thank you for coming at such short notice," he said. "Miss Dash, Miss Sparkle, I apologise for keeping you waiting, but now that all four of you have arrived, we can begin."

"Twilight," General Ironwood said, taking a step forward so that he now stood level with, rather than behind, Professor Ozpin. "What have you found so far going through the CCT servers?"

"A worm, sir," Twilight said. "And a sophisticated one, from what I could tell. It was dormant, waiting for some kind of trigger or activation signal to wake it up. I decided to prioritise elimination over analysis, but I think if it had been left in place, then they – whoever set it, that is – could have gotten into all our systems that are linked to the CCT network."

"Which is most of them," Ironwood finished for her. "Force deployments, logistical data, the IFF on our automated systems; we'd have been completely exposed. Is it dealt with?"

"I think so, sir," Twilight murmured. "I'll need to run another full diagnostic to make sure it's completely cleared."

Ironwood nodded. "Do it." He smiled in an avuncular manner, like a fond or favourite uncle. "Good work, Twilight."

"Thank you, General," Twilight said. She hesitated. "But, with respect, I don't think you called Rainbow, Sunset, and Pyrrha up here so that they could hear my report on the situation with the computers."

"No," Ironwood admitted. "You've all been gathered here for another reason."

"Before we get down to business," Professor Ozpin said, leaning forwards and resting his elbows on his desk, "I want you all to understand that the information I am about to share with you is of the most confidential nature. I am taking a great risk in telling you any of this, and I want your assurances that you will be most discreet in how you handle what you are about to learn once you leave this office."

Rainbow looked not to Professor Ozpin, but to General Ironwood. "You don't trust us, sir?"

"I trust you," Ironwood said, with a certain emphasis upon his own self that suggested that perhaps Professor Ozpin was not so trusting. "You wouldn't be here if you didn't both enjoy my absolute confidence. But this goes beyond classified, beyond state secrets; not even Councillor Cadenza knows what we're about to tell you, and she cannot know. No one can."

"But, General," Twilight spoke in a voice that was soft and small, faintly bewildered as though the world no longer made as much sense to her as it had done a moment ago. "Why are you keeping secrets from the Council?"

"Because he is a servant with two masters," Sunset muttered, without judgement in her voice. Her eyes flickered to Ozpin. The way he sat, the way they stood… courtiers beside the throne of the king, of course that was how it was. "Isn't that right, Professor? Or should I call you something else? 'My lord'? Or would you prefer 'Your Majesty'?"

"Sunset?" Pyrrha asked quietly. "What are you talking about?"

Professor Ozpin smiled. "Very perceptive, Miss Shimmer; but Professor will do just fine."

Rainbow frowned, her brow crinkling. "What's she talking about, sir, what's going on? What is this?"

It was to the general that she had spoken, but it was Ozpin who answered. "Tell me, Miss Dash, why do you fight?"

Rainbow's magenta eyes flickered to Professor Ozpin. "I fight for the three Fs."

Professor Ozpin's eyebrows rose. "The three Fs, Miss Dash?"

"Flag. Fleet. Friends," Rainbow declared.

"Ah. I see. Very concisely put, Miss Dash." Professor Ozpin said, nodding his head in acceptance if not agreement. "And who or what are you fighting against?"

"The creatures of grimm."

"Is that all?"

"The White Fang," Rainbow growled.

"And what of Cinder Fall?" Professor Ozpin asked.

"I fought her too," Rainbow said.

"But why?"

"Because she tried to kill Twilight!"

Professor Ozpin waved away that response. "You misunderstand, Miss Dash. The question more rightly applies to Miss Fall: not a faunus, not a grimm, but an enemy nonetheless. But why an enemy? In what cause? The same question might be asked of her human accomplices, Miss Sustral and Mister Black, or of Roman Torchwick who currently languishes in silence aboard an Atlesian warship."

"Roman Torchwick is a criminal," Pyrrha said.

"A criminal working with the White Fang, who are themselves working with or possibly even under the command of a human, probably Miss Fall herself," Ozpin said. "Does that not seem strange?"

"Yes," Sunset admitted. "But it probably isn't to you, is it, Professor? That's why we're here: because you're the man with all the answers, and you've decided to share a few of them with us."

Silence reigned in the office for a few moments. Professor Ozpin's face was still, set like a plaster cast. Or a death mask like the ones on the walls of the Nikos mansion. Silently, he got up from his chair and walked to the emerald-tinted windows, looking across the grounds of Beacon and the city of Vale that lay beyond and far below. His cane tapped on the floor.

"Is that true?" Rainbow asked. "You know who Cinder is?"

"We don't know the specifics of her background," Professor Goodwitch said, prompting Pyrrha to glance briefly at Sunset – who did know, of course, but wasn't ready to reveal it in this company; she was grateful to Pyrrha for not forcing her to do so. Professor Goodwitch continued, "But we understand the cause in which she acted."

"And I guess she wasn't just a Mistralian agent then?" Rainbow asked.

"No," Ironwood said. "This war goes far beyond Mistral, Atlas, or Vale."

"'War'?" Pyrrha said. "What war?"

"The war of light against darkness, Miss Nikos," Professor Ozpin said, without looking round. "The war of life against death. The true war. The only war that really matters."

"The fight against the grimm," Pyrrha murmured.

Professor Ozpin sighed. "I am afraid this goes far beyond the creatures of grimm, Miss Nikos." He turned around, sweeping his gaze across the four of them in turn. "Tell me, are any of you girls religious? Do you believe in any god or gods? Do you have faith?"

There was another momentary silence before Twilight raised a tentative hand. "I, uh, I believe in… in the paranormal? Does that count?"

Professor Ozpin smiled. "Do you mean that you believe in magic, Miss Sparkle?"

Twilight bowed her head. "Yes, Professor."

Ozpin seemed to find that terribly amusing. "Fascinating. But do you believe in a higher power? Or rather, do you believe in a higher being, greater than mankind? Do any of you?"

"I… I would not describe myself as religious," Pyrrha answered tremulously. "At least, no more than culturally so; I observe the practices because it is expected, but… I have stood in the Temple of Victory, and I have felt something there, though I am not sure I would call it a god."

"Nevertheless, that is more than many would say upon the subject," Professor Ozpin declared. "In one time, a time long past, the world crawled with cults and faiths; they seemed to spring out of the ground, more of them each day… but the advancement of science made them obsolete – or seemed to – and as the world has become more libertarian in attitudes, so have people come to resent any restriction placed upon the practice of their lifestyle. Nowadays, only a handful of faiths remain, clinging to life with ever-diminished numbers of believers."

"Perhaps it wasn't science or social attitudes that hurt them most," Sunset said. "Perhaps it was when all of their prophets disappeared." Disappeared or turned into Red Queens; now what might you know about that, Professor?

Professor Ozpin looked at her for a moment, his face inscrutable. Neither Professor Goodwitch nor General Ironwood gave anything away on that front either.

Which didn't mean that there was nothing to get out of them, just that it wasn't going to be so easy as making them blanch with a well-placed word or phrase.

"There have been many religions," Professor Goodwitch said, apparently deciding that the best response to Sunset's remark was to pay it no heed. "And dozens of gods and goddesses. But, while many of those faiths had some basis in fact, the truth – as we understand it – is that there have only been two true gods in Remnant."

"Two brothers," Professor Ozpin said. "The God of Light, and the God of Darkness, who ruled over this world in the days long gone."

"Two brothers," Pyrrha murmured. "As in the Tale of the Two Brothers?"

"Exactly, Miss Nikos," Professor Ozpin said. "There is more truth in fairy tales than many people recognise."

"You're talking about real truth, aren't you, Professor?" Sunset asked. "Not metaphorical truth, not emotional or spiritual truth, but real facts about things that really happened-"

"To real people who were just like that," Professor Ozpin finished, a slight smile playing upon his face. "Indeed, Miss Shimmer, that is precisely what I mean. The Two Brothers the tale speaks of are as real as I am."

Sunset's tail twitched. And how many other tales are true, Professor? The Infinite Man? The Shallow Sea? Poppy and Oak?

Professor Ozpin went on. "The God of Light, the elder brother, gloried in creation: he brought forth much that was green and growing and beautiful upon the surface of the earth and saw that it was good, but the God of Darkness, the younger brother, looked upon light and life with horror and with loathing; he desired only to return the world to lifelessness, and he worked tirelessly to consume all that his brother had made and turn all life to death and dust. But he never succeeded. The light was too bright, his brother too powerful, and while much that the elder brother wrought in the light was destroyed or corrupted in the darkness, always, the light would return once again and drive away the darkness, just as life would drive away the stench of death and decay. The elder brother even wrought a mirror in the sky, the moon, that the light might shine on Remnant even in the deepest darkness, and with that light, he might continue to work even in the dominion of his younger brother.

"Filled with resentment, the younger brother saw that this was not a battle he could win alone, and so he set aside for a moment the power of destruction and turned instead to the power that he had always scorned as the domain of his hated elder brother: the power of creation. But into that creation, the God of Darkness poured all of his malice, all of his hatred of life and light, and all of his desire to snuff out both completely."

If Cinder is serving the God of Darkness, then they are well matched, it seems.

"The grimm," Pyrrha murmured. "That's what you mean, isn't it, Professor? The God of Darkness brought forth the creatures of grimm."

"But grimm don't prey on all life," Rainbow protested. "They only attack humans; everyone knows that."

"Now, yes," Professor Ozpin conceded. "But it was not always so. Once, the creatures of grimm were ravenous; they would devour any and all living creatures: beasts, birds, they would even consume plants and trees, anything that grew upon the surface of Remnant. No lion, wolf, or bear could compete with them; no horse or deer could outrun them; their numbers were legion and their appetites insatiable. They would have swallowed the world.

"The elder brother perceived that the destruction of all that he had wrought was imminent, and so, just as his younger brother had embraced the power of creation, so too did the elder embrace the power of destruction to defend the works of his mind and his hands.

"We do not know how long they fought – or exactly how, but considering the combatants, the struggle must have been long and brutal – but when the fighting was over, the elder brother stood victorious, and in his victory, he offered his younger brother a truce. He proposed that they should cease their struggle and work together on one final creation: a perfect being, empowered both to create and to destroy, gifted with knowledge and blessed with the ability to choose to what end he would put his knowledge and his skill. And that creation was, as I'm sure that you've guessed by now, mankind."

"That… that's a cool story and all, Professor," Rainbow said. "But I don't get why it has to be kept a secret, and I don't get why you wanted to tell it to us, and I really don't get what it has to do with Cinder and the White Fang."

"Because we have the power to choose," Pyrrha said. "To choose light or darkness, life or death, creation or destruction. Cinder has chosen darkness and destruction."

"Indeed, Miss Nikos," Professor Ozpin said, sounding almost proud of her. "Miss Fall has made her choice, and we have asked you here to offer you the… the opportunity to make yours."

"Then… then it is the God of Darkness that Cinder serves?" Twilight asked quietly.

"No, thank goodness, things are not quite so dire as that," Professor Ozpin murmured. "Having created mankind, the two gods departed Remnant many ages ago, content to watch from a distance and see what choices men would make without gods to guide or to control them. But they left behind them certain artefacts, containing what we might call remnants of their power. Relics, if you will, of the four aspects of divinity once passed to man: creation, destruction, knowledge… and choice, the most precious and powerful gift of all."

"Is that where the stories of magical objects come from?" Twilight asked. "Caliburn, the sword that could never be defeated; the staff of Diomed that enabled him to grant boons to his subjects out of nothing; the crown of King Paul of Vale that gave him his wisdom?"

"And many others, Miss Sparkle," Professor Ozpin agreed. "Yes. For some time, the relics roamed free in the world, and although their true origin was unknown, their powers were well understood and appreciated."

"Then what changed?" Sunset asked. Why has everything wondrous disappeared out of the world? Why has everything been hidden?

"The relics were too powerful," Ozpin said. "It was better that the temptation for men to use them against their enemies was removed. And besides, although the God of Darkness has departed from the world, there is another who has proven more than willing to take up his mantle."

"What do you mean?" Pyrrha asked.

"Her name is Salem," General Ironwood said. "We don't know exactly who she is or where she comes from; we don't even know if she was ever human or if she has always been… something else. But we do know that she dwells on the continent of Drachyra."

Twilight gasped. "The signal relay."

General Ironwood nodded. "Precisely."

"And Cinder," Sunset said. "She… she serves this Salem?"

"Salem is at the root of all our troubles," Ozpin declared. "The mistress of the grimm, the inheritor of the powers of darkness, the indefatigable enemy of light, of life… and of mankind. Ageless, cunning, and filled with malice, she sends out her grimm to prey upon men wherever they are unprotected and longs for the opportunity to launch a full assault upon these, the four kingdoms and the havens of humanity. And all the while, she gathers to her side all those who are discontented, the outcast and the unclean, those who have – rightly or wrongly – been rejected by the civilised world, and she moulds them into weapons to send against us. Weapons like Miss Fall."

"And we let her get away with this?" Rainbow demanded. "We know that she's the one sending the grimm, we know where she lives? And we just… what? We let this happen? We stand here and talk about gods and fairytales while the bad guys are out there sharpening their knives for us?"

"It isn't that simple, Miss Dash," Professor Goodwitch said.

"The hell it isn't!" Rainbow snapped. "General, sir, you… you know what we've lost. You know what's been taken from us, from all of us." Rainbow looked at General Ironwood, and in Rainbow's eyes, Sunset could see a desperate desire for him to offer her an explanation that would enable her to keep believing in him, to tell her that he wasn't just a monster sending good soldiers and huntsmen to their deaths while he had the power to end the war but would not use it.

Sunset could sympathise; although she hadn't lost any friends to the grimm – or even to the White Fang, who Salem was also standing behind through the intermediary of Cinder Fall, if what she was hearing was correct – the thought that she might preyed upon her mind like a grimm in its own right. She had told Luna that she might be content if she could combine the safety of Equestria with her friends of Remnant, and if that world was within their grasp, if all they had to do was to defeat Salem, then… then why hadn't they done it yet? This was Pyrrha's dream, the one that they had shared on the rooftop after their fight: the grimm defeated, mankind triumphant and free to spread to every corner of the world. At the time, Sunset had thought it a fantasy, but if it wasn't… if the grimm could be defeated through the defeat of Salem, then why hadn't anybody beaten Salem?

Sunset was no great fan of Professor Ozpin, she didn't hold him up as a paragon, he didn't command her uncritical admiration and respect, but in this moment, even she wanted him to offer some kind of explanation, some answer to the big question that now hung over everything that he had just told them or might tell them. This was a war between light and darkness, Ozpin said, a war between life and death; Sunset wanted to know he wasn't actually indifferent to the merits of the two sides.

It was General Ironwood who spoke, his words falling from his mouth with the weight of lead. "I'm aware of our losses, Dash."

"Then why, sir?" Rainbow demanded, "If we know who she is and where she is, then let's bring the big hammer down on her and show her how Atlas takes care of business! Let's end this."

General Ironwood looked physically pained as he said, "We can't."

"Why not?"

"Because we'd lose," General Ironwood said. He didn't shout, he didn't snap or snarl, but he might as well have done, because both Rainbow and Twilight reacted as though he had. They both recoiled from him, looking as though he'd struck them or threatened to do so.

"Believe me, I asked exactly the same questions when I was first read into this," Ironwood continued. "I wanted to know why we couldn't strike back, finish this, finish her. But we can't. She's too powerful; she surrounds herself with too many grimm. We can't even get close to her, and if we could…"

Rainbow shook her head. "I never thought I'd hear you underestimate us, sir."

"This isn't a fight you can win if you just have enough guts, Dash!" Ironwood snapped.

"Maybe not, sir, but we've got guts and weapons, so I think we're in with a shot."

"I understand your frustrations, Miss Dash-"

"Do you?" Rainbow snapped. "Do you really?"

"Yes," Professor Ozpin replied, his voice as calm as ever it sounded, utterly failing to rise to the bait of Rainbow's anger. There was no blood in it, no blood at all. The only tone in the headmaster's voice was weariness. "If Salem could be so easily defeated, then I would do it. Even if it were not easy, I would do it anyway, no matter the cost. But it is no use. Salem… cannot be destroyed. She has existed since time immemorial, and she will go on existing long after our bones are dust. All the weapons in the arsenal of Atlas could rain down upon her head, and it would trouble her no more than an April shower. I thought that there might be a way to… to contain her with a particular power wielded by one very gifted student, but… but it affected her not at all."

Sunset's eyes narrowed. "You're talking about Summer Rose, aren't you, Professor?"

Professor Ozpin looked at her, his face yielding nothing. "An interesting speculation, Miss Shimmer."

"I know what makes Ruby so special, Professor," Sunset declared. "I know that it made her mother special too; we all know." She was willing to give up this particular nugget of information in exchange for something resembling a straight answer out of him.

If he really wants me to know the truth for whatever reason, he's hardly likely to kick me out over the diary.

It had to be said, however, that Professor Goodwitch didn't appear to feel the same way. She scowled. "And how did you come by this information, Miss Shimmer?"

"That hardly seems relevant now, Glynda," Professor Ozpin murmured. "You are correct, Miss Shimmer, in all but one respect."

Sunset's tail curled upwards. "And what's that, Professor?"

"What makes Miss Rose special is her valour," Professor Ozpin said. "Her courage in the face of danger, her commitment to defending life, the ways in which she models the behaviour of a huntress so perfectly. It is spirit, more than any advantages of her birth, which make her extraordinary." He looked down at his desk. "Nevertheless, you are right that her mother made a gallant attempt to… contain Salem. She failed, as I should have known she would, which is to say that I failed her first through my arrogance. Salem cannot be vanquished in the field… but she can be withstood."

"How?" Pyrrha asked. "If she is so powerful, if none of our weapons or techniques are sufficient to harm her, if she could just walk into Beacon and kill us all and we wouldn't be able to do a thing to stop her, then… then why doesn't she? Why hasn't she?"

"Because she is…" Sunset licked her lips, her tail swishing back and forth behind her. "She is a princess," she said in the end, because it was the word that was buried in her mind, the only word that she could think of, the word that made the most sense to use, even as it felt like a betrayal to give it voice. "She does not go forth to fight in her own cause, but sends out…" But sends out her faithful students to do her work. "But sends out others to act on her behalf."

"Quite so, Miss Shimmer," Professor Ozpin agreed. "And therein lies our hope, for while Salem herself may be immortal and invincible, those who work in her name and for her purposes are not. That is why, many generations ago, our predecessors founded a secret order to resist Salem and to keep the sacred relics out of her hands. For if she were ever to obtain the relics and combine them, the power that she would wield would be sufficient to change the world as we know it."

"The group they founded has existed down to the present," Professor Goodwitch said. "We, along with the headmasters of Haven and Vacuo academies and… one or two other individuals, make up the current membership."

"And we're telling you this because we believe that you are the right people to carry our sacred charge into the future," Ironwood said.

"But… why?" Rainbow asked. "Why me, sir? I mean, Twi, sure I get that, but… I mean… I'm just a girl who punches things."

"Remnant needs wisdom and intelligence, true," Ironwood said. "But it also needs a brave defender, and I can't think of anyone braver than you."

"But why is any of this necessary?" Pyrrha asked, sounding as though her voice was on the verge of breaking. "Why not tell people about this? Why keep it a secret?"

"Because if people knew the relics existed, they would be tempted to use them for their own power and prestige," Professor Ozpin said, and as he said that, he looked at Sunset, who felt an uncomfortable shiver down her spine as though the headmaster – or whatever he really was – was looking right into her soul. "Because if people knew that the grimm were more than mindless beasts, if they knew the scale of the threat we truly face, then there would be mass panic of the sort that would attract the grimm for certain; because people deserve the chance to live their lives free from the threat of Salem hanging over their every waking moment. I ask you again, Miss Dash, why do you fight?"

Rainbow shifted uncomfortably. "I fight so that my friends don't have to fight."

"You take that burden on yourself, that they may be spared the weight of it," Professor Ozpin said. "Just as we take this great burden upon ourselves that the rest of the world may be spared it."

You make it sound so noble, don't you? Sunset thought. And maybe it was noble, every bit as noble as he was making it sound… or maybe he wanted it to sound like that to cover up how convenient it was that this state of affairs left him with all of the knowledge, including knowledge of four incredibly powerful objects that he was keeping to himself – for the good of the world, obviously. Maybe Sunset was being too hard on him; she wasn't entirely sure what she thought about all of this yet; so much information dropped on her head at once was leaving her feeling a little stunned as thoughts whirled about her mind this way and that. But here was what she knew: Professor Ozpin had recruited Summer Rose and her team the same way that he was recruiting the four of them now, and Summer Rose had died. Yes, the life of a huntress was an inherently hazardous one, and yes, correlation doesn't necessarily equal causation, but sometimes it does, and in this case… Sunset looked to her left, where Pyrrha stood looking shocked at all that she had learnt; Rainbow and Twilight looked equally amazed. Sunset didn't know about them, but she was under no illusions that they were going to be equal partners in this secret order if they decided to join it – if they were being given a choice, one might argue that they knew too much to turn back now. On the one side, the headmaster, his right hand and the commander of the Atlesian forces; on the other side, four students. One side was going to be given the orders, and the other side was going to be taking them, and it didn't take a genius to work out which was which. Professor Ozpin would use them as he had used Team STRQ; at least, he would use Sunset and Pyrrha; perhaps General Ironwood would take some care of Rainbow and Twilight – he seemed fond of them, although it was hard to tell how much of that was an act. But Sunset and Pyrrha, he would use for certain: they would run his errands and fight his battles and fend off Salem's strokes while he sat in this tower as remote from where the metal met as any king… as remote as Princess Celestia in Canterlot, sending Twilight Sparkle and the Elements of Harmony to save the world while she sipped tea in her shining tower.

That was probably very unfair to Princess Celestia; whatever might be said about her, her ways, her secrecy, or her plans, it couldn't be denied that she had shared much knowledge with Sunset, taught her a great deal of magic and presumably had done the same for Twilight. And she was kind and generous, and she won the loyalty that she demanded of her students through love that Sunset, for one, had found maternal. She had no doubt that if she were to write to Twilight and ask why that she did all that she did, ran all the risks on Celestia's behalf, the answer would include – perhaps amidst a lot of noble sentiments – the fact that Twilight loved Celestia and would do anything the princess asked of her.

What did Professor Ozpin offer in exchange for the loyalty he demanded of his secret servants: the honour of duty done and the glory of integrity of principle? Perhaps he would say it was for the good of mankind as he sent them out to fight, and perhaps, one day, when they were older, Pyrrha and Sunset would be admitted into the decision-making circle… if they lived that long. If they didn't end up as dead as Summer Rose.

I won't let that happen. Sunset's loyalty was not to Professor Ozpin, his society, or his cause; her loyalty was not to the Kingdom of Vale, nor to humanity at large; Sunset's loyalty was to Team SAPR, to Blake, to RSPT as well a bit. Pyrrha seemed to feel a little differently about Professor Ozpin than she had before she had found all of this out, but ultimately, she was still Pyrrha Nikos and just the kind of person to throw herself into harm's way if she thought it was the right thing to do. Ruby was just the same, and even Jaune too.

I won't let that happen. She would keep them safe, all of them, from Salem and from Professor Ozpin if she had to.

And, as much as she appreciated knowing who they were really up against, Sunset couldn't help but notice that Professor Ozpin hadn't mentioned magic at all during this, even when Sunset had offered him the opportunity to do so.

Just as I thought; you ladle out truth according to your own measure, and I reckon there's still some stew left in that particular pot.

It might have been harsh, it might have been personal, but Sunset couldn't bring herself to trust Professor Ozpin.

It was for that reason that – if there was any choice being offered to them in the matter at all – she meant to take him up on his offer.

It wasn't just that he was offering her a share – however menial it might be at first – of power and influence; although Sunset couldn't deny that if he'd told her this a little sooner, she would have been filled with desire for the relics of the gods. She could still feel the alluring desire to be a part of something bigger than herself, to influence the world, to leave her mark on Remnant in some way. She would win no glory from it, being a secret and all, but a few people at least would know and recognise her worth, and perhaps she could be content with that; perhaps that was her destiny, to be a Celestia unsung, to wield the power without the crown, to be a princess in the shadows of the world. Not what she had expected when she set out… but at the same time, it was far from nothing.

More importantly, if she refused Professor Ozpin's offer – if she was even allowed or afforded the opportunity to refuse – then she would be shut out for good and lose all chance not only to influence the things this organisation did, but also to protect her friends from the inside. The fact that she couldn't bring herself to trust Professor Ozpin made it more, not less, imperative that she know all that he knew and know as much as she could know what he was thinking, what he was planning to do with Pyrrha, Jaune, Ruby, Blake.

She would work with him, for him… the better to work against him if she had to.

"You need not decide right away what you will do next, now that you have seen what so few others have seen and know what so few others know," Professor Ozpin said. "Take some time. Consider what you have learned and the great odds that are against us. I freely confess that it was General Ironwood's idea to tell you this, but at the same time, I must also admit that I could use your help."

"Only our help?" Sunset asked. "Professor, how discreet do you expect us to be with this? Are we supposed to keep this from Ruby and Jaune?"

Professor Ozpin, at last, resumed his seat. "You must do what you think best, Miss Shimmer, but I must remind you all that what you have heard today is highly confidential."

"Of course, Professor," Sunset said, with a smile which she hoped was convincing.

Although judging by the way that Professor Ozpin was looking at her, Sunset had her doubts.

"Pyrrha Nikos, Sunset Shimmer," he said. "Rainbow Dash, Twilight Sparkle; you have been chosen because we believe that you possess the courage, wisdom, loyalty, and compassion that elevate humanity above the run of mere beasts: the qualities, one might say, of the divine. But be under no illusions: the survival of our kingdoms, of our very race, hangs by a thread. Our decisions, our actions or inactions, determine the difference between survival and peace for millions… or the death and destruction of all that we hold dear. One day, if you choose to accept some part of this heavy burden that we bear, the fate of Remnant may lie in your hands. I urge you… I beg you to think long and hard about what that means and make your decision with the greatest care." He was silent for a moment. "That will be all."

"Dismissed," Ironwood said.

Rainbow saluted, as much on reflex as anything else, before she turned to go. Twilight cast one last look at the general before she too turned to follow in Rainbow's footsteps. Pyrrha's feet dragged a little as she started towards the elevator. Sunset remained in place, still, unmoving. She stared at Professor Ozpin. He stared back at her.

"Thank you, Professor," she said.

Professor Ozpin blinked. "For what, Miss Shimmer."

"For being so honest with us," Sunset said.

Professor Ozpin smiled. "Of course, Miss Shimmer, although perhaps you should not be quite so swift to thank me. I think we both know that some secrets are best left untold."

Sunset's eyebrows rose. And what is it that you think you know about me? Was it possible that he… how could he know that, how could he know anything about Equestria? Had the knowledge been passed down to him by his predecessors in this secret organisation?

He certainly knows something – or he thinks he does – and he's letting me know it too. To be honest, Sunset was left rather disappointed. Did he really think that she would throw her team to the beowolves in response to a little crude blackmail? Please. Sunset Shimmer had her faults, but she was better than that.

"Maybe, Professor," she said. "But equally, some secrets really are best out in the open, where people can make up their own minds."

She turned away, joining Pyrrha, Rainbow, and Twilight in waiting for the elevator.

XxXxX​

Ozpin watched silently as the door to the lift slid shut, enclosing the four students within it before beginning its descent.

"They didn't take that too well," Glynda said.

"Neither did you, when you first found out the truth," Ozpin reminded her with a trace of amusement in his voice. "I… may have taken a little convincing, but now that the moment has arrived, I'm confident they'll all make the right choice."

"You didn't tell them about the Maidens," James said.

"No, I didn't."

"Why not?" James pressed.

"Because, as much as I think you disagree nowadays, James, I'm not a cruel or heartless man," Ozpin said, a quick glance at James confirmed that he had hit the mark. "They don't need to know everything at once, and we don't need to force that choice upon Miss Nikos just yet. Let them live, for just a little while longer."

Glynda said, "Do you really believe that they will keep this a secret from their teammates?"

"I'd be disappointed if they did," Ozpin replied, allowing a touch of wry amusement to enter his voice. But the ease – or otherwise – with which they disobeyed his instructions would tell him something about their attitude and what he could expect from them going forward. Just as Miss Shimmer's reaction to his threatening to reveal her secret was intended not as a leash around her neck, but to gauge how she would react to the idea that he was attempting to muzzle her.

As Ozpin pulled out his scroll and turned on the security camera footage in the elevator, he thought that his decision to see only half of each team might well be justified by what he was about to witness.

XxXxX​

They rode the elevator down in silence for a moment, each girl lost in their own contemplations, with only the sound of the lift grinding downwards to accompany their thoughts.

And what they had to think about. Even leaving aside any questions of Professor Ozpin's motives, good or bad, Sunset would still have had whirling thoughts. The grimm had a leader, a queen or something in that line. An enemy, a face to put to the constant menace that threatened to submerge the kingdoms beneath its malice. An enemy who wasn't content with her hordes of grimm but who constantly gathered hopeless, wounded people like Cinder to her cause and sent them out to fight against their fellow men.

I suppose that whatever I might think about Professor Ozpin, he at least sends other people out to die for a good cause.

Salem. The name didn't conjure up anything in Sunset's mind; all the talk of gods of darkness beforehand meant that she was kind of imagining an evil alicorn with a colour palette of blacks and blues. That wasn't right, obviously, but it was the best her imagination could do without anything concrete to go on.

It ought to have made things easier. One person pulling the strings of the grimm and the White Fang alike, one person behind everything. Cinder standing behind Torchwick and the Fang, Salem standing behind Cinder, and the grimm all taking her commands as well. One enemy to whom they could take the fight.

Except they couldn't. They couldn't fight her. The silver eyes of Summer Rose couldn't stand against her; the strength of Atlas and its army couldn't bring her down; all that they could do was hold her off, hold the line and pass the torch onto the next generation when all was said and done.

Sunset wasn't sure how to feel about that. It felt bleak, it felt really bleak, but… she couldn't have really said why. After all, from a purely logical perspective, it was no bleaker than the situation had been yesterday when – Pyrrha's quixotic ambitions aside – there had seemed no real hope of defeating the grimm and bringing their menace to an end; all that they could hope to do was – you guessed it – hold the line and pass the torch to the next generation. But it felt different now. Learning that the grimm were not mindless beasts who could be driven off but were controlled by some diabolical entity seemed to render even the victories that they could win against them less meaningful; all the glory that Sunset could achieve here, all the fame that might be hers… it all paled in insignificance when faced with the reality of an immortal godlike figure who had all the time in the world to recover from any setback as she plotted the destruction of mankind, a destruction that she was likely to achieve with or without possession of the relics.

And that was without the question of why the relics weren't being used against the grimm if they were all that. Professor Ozpin's group had really shackled themselves with their insistence on keeping everything a secret.

Rainbow punched her right fist into her left palm. "This sucks. This really… gah! One thing I hate worse than getting screwed with is when I have to bend over and take it! At least when Cinder was the worst thing we had to worry about, I could tell myself I'd kick her ass next time! But this… we're fighting someone we can't even beat!"

"It seems that way," Sunset said.

"'It seems that way'?" Rainbow repeated. "It seems that way because it is that way!"

"Like I said," Sunset said. "It seems that way. But how do we know that this Salem can't be beaten?"

"Because General Ironwood told us," Twilight murmured.

"And Professor Ozpin told him that, I'm sure," Sunset said. "But Professor Ozpin didn't tell us everything, which means that there's at least some chance he didn't tell Ironwood everything either, which means that there could be something he left out, something he isn't saying. Some way that this can be ended."

"Why?" Pyrrha asked. "Why would Professor Ozpin lie about something like that?"

Sunset hesitated. "I… I don't know, honestly. I admit it doesn't make perfect sense. I don't know, maybe I just want it to be true because I'd like a way to win this."

"I'd like that too," Rainbow said. "I just don't know if I can see it."

"I'm not certain I can either," Sunset admitted, although she was curious as to what would happen to Salem if she were to run into Equestrian magic. "Maybe I just want to hope, but… there's something that I have to do, someone that I want to talk to, before we meet up with the others to tell them all this."

"We weren't supposed to tell the others," Pyrrha reminded her.

Sunset twisted around to look at her teammate where she stood behind her. "Maybe not, but we're going to, right? You don't actually want to keep this a secret from Jaune or Ruby?"

Pyrrha looked down at the elevator floor. "I… maybe they're better off not knowing."

"I don't believe that," Sunset said. "And I don't believe that you believe that."

"We just found out that everything we thought we knew about the creatures of grimm, about the world, about why we're fighting, is a lie!" Pyrrha cried, her eyes wide. "We just found out that there is no victory, not even the possibility of it, ever! How can we put that burden on Ruby or Jaune?" She closed her eyes and scowled. "I thought that maybe we could win. I knew that it wasn't a great possibility, but I thought that maybe, if we all worked together and fought with everything we had, then maybe… but we can't." She opened her eyes, and though those emerald eyes were filled with resolution, they were also devoid of hope in a way that frightened Sunset a little. "If all that we can do is fight, then I'm ready to fight. If some of us must die to protect humanity, then I'm prepared to die. But Jaune… and Ruby… Jaune wanted to be a hero like his family, Ruby wants to protect the world… how can we tell them the truth about all of this? Shouldn't we take this burden on ourselves to spare them the weight?"

Sunset stared at her for a moment, before she glanced at the other occupants of the elevator car.

With a short, sharp gesture, she slammed one fist into the emergency stop button, bringing the lift to a halt. The lights dimmed in the car.

"I hope no one's claustrophobic," Sunset muttered.

"What are you doing?" Twilight said.

"I'm not Ruby, so this inspirational speech is probably going to be a bit awkward, but here goes: I'm not ready to give up just yet," Sunset said. "And you shouldn't be willing to give up either, any of you.

"Sure, we've just learned a lot of new stuff. Some of what we've learned is a little depressing if it's true. If it's true. But I'm not taking that for granted yet, and you know why? Because people have been telling me that I couldn't do things for my whole life and I have made it my business to always, always prove them wrong. I never let it stop me before, and I certainly don't intend to start now. So we are going to tell Ruby, and Jaune, and Blake-"

"And Ciel," Rainbow said.

"Yeah, and Penny too if you like, and we are going to work this out and find a way to beat this, because that's who we are!" Sunset said. "We go beyond our limits, and we dare defiance of anyone who would set them on us. We're going to screw the rules and reach for the destiny that is waiting for us. Who's with me?"

"Absolutely," Rainbow said.

Sunset nodded. "Pyrrha?"

Pyrrha hesitated. "And what… what if you're wrong?" she asked. "What if Professor Ozpin and the others are right. What if there is no beating Salem?"

"Then we'll set her plans back over a hundred years trying," Sunset said. "And I'd rather burn brightly in futile glorious effort than spend my whole life sputtering like a candle in the wind." Her face and tone became a little more serious. "Listen, even if you don't think that there's anything we can do to change this situation… if we accept Professor Ozpin's offer – and I for one intend to – then we're going to be sent out on missions, and Jaune and Ruby will be going with us. Don't you think they should know what they're in for and have a chance to tell us no if they want no part in this?"

Pyrrha considered it. "I… you're right. It wouldn't be fair to keep this from them."

"So," Rainbow said. "You're gonna tell the professor that you're in?"

"I'd rather be on the inside than pressing my face against the glass," Sunset said. "You?"

Rainbow hesitated. "I still can't believe General Ironwood's involved in this… but maybe, since he's involved in this, it's better than it seems." She ran one hand through her multi-coloured hair. "Hey, Twi, what do you think Rarity's doing right now?"

Twilight checked the time on her scroll. "Today's Wednesday, so… I'm guessing that she'll be at work right now."

"And Pinkie will be taking the morning bake out of the oven," Rainbow mused, with a fond smile on her face. "Scootaloo will be in school, with Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle."

"Rainbow Dash?" Twilight asked.

"I told the professor that I fought for my friends," Rainbow said. "And I meant it. Whoever she is, whatever she is, if Salem wants to kill my friends – if she wants Atlas – then she's gonna have to go through me first. I'm in." She looked at Twilight. "Twi… if you don't want to have anything to do with this… nobody's going to hold it against you."

Twilight looked down. She pushed her spectacles up the bridge of her nose. "When I heard that Cadance didn't know… keeping secrets from the Council, is that even legal? But that doesn't really matter, does it? If General Ironwood's right, then all of Remnant's in jeopardy, and we… we can do something about it.

"I don't know what you think Professor Ozpin isn't saying, but I still trust General Ironwood. I still remember all the times he came round to our house when I was little. When he put me on this team, he made sure that you were my team leader so that I'd have a friendly face to make me feel comfortable. If he says that it's so, and that it has to be so, then I believe him. Maybe Sunset's right, and there is a way to beat Salem, but until then… I know that I'm not a fighter, but if I can help Remnant by being an egghead, then I'll be the very best egghead that Remnant has ever seen. I'm in."

Rainbow clapped her on the shoulder. "Glad to have you, Twi."

Sunset hit the emergency button again, and the elevator resumed its descent. "The library is probably a little too open for this, so why don't we meet at the SAPR garage in…two hours, with our teams and Blake, and we can share everything we found out and see what we all think about… all of this?"

"Two hours?" Rainbow said. "Why wait so long?"

"Like I said, there's somebody I need to talk to first," Sunset said. "Someone who's advice I need."

What is Celestia going to have to say about all this?
 
Chapter 87 - Celestial Advice
Celestial Advice​



So, there it is. It's been Sunset stopped and sucked on the tip of her pen while she worked out exactly how she wanted to…no, it wasn't even about how she might want to describe all of this madness; it was more about how she could. She scribbled It's been an eventful couple of days.

I cannot disagree with you. came the reply from her old mentor, because Sunset had felt the need of Celestia's wisdom, the wisdom that came with many years and many perils faced and overcome. Twilight was there too, because this was a situation where… well, Sunset could do with some advice from both sides of the divide about this business with Ozpin. At the moment, however, Twilight seemed content to let Celestia do the talking, and honestly, Sunset was content with that as well. I have to tell you, Sunset, that the more you tell me, the more I would do anything to whisk you away from such a dangerous place as you have found yourself.

Sunset felt herself squirming in her seat in the library, as though Celestia were there in person, looking down at her with that gaze that could see through all of her deceptions. It's not so bad.

After all that you have told me – after what you have just finished telling me – I hope very much that you don't have such a low opinion of my intelligence as to expect me to believe that.

Sunset couldn't help but chuckle wryly, just a little bit, before she wrote back. Okay, Remnant has its problems; sure, there are monsters who want to eat everyone, and they're being directed by some kind of demigod who also wants to kill everyone, and she's convinced someone that I wanted to call friend – who I might still call friend, which might be even worse – to serve her in that same cause, and sure, there are a lot of people who think I'm an animal because of the way I look, and the guy leading our fate against the aforementioned demigod might send me out to die just to advance his plans a little bit, but apart from all of that, it's really not so bad.

Celestia did not reply for a moment, so Sunset wrote a little more. I can see your arched eyebrow in my mind's eye, Princess.

Perhaps you can also answer the obvious question?

I can't come back to Equestria.

I don't understand why you would not want to. Luna told me that you had had a nightmare that she found especially terrible, and it took all of my restraint to respect your privacy and not write to you to find out if you were all right. Why would you want to stay in a world that does that to you, that pains and traumatises you, when you could return to Equestria where it is safe?

This isn't about what I want, Princess. I do want to come back to Equestria, and if Princess Luna talked to you about my nightmare, then you must know that. I miss Canterlot, I miss the streets and the shops, I miss my room. I miss the safety and security of a world and a land at peace. I miss being able to lie down in the knowledge that everything was fine and was going to stay fine. I miss Sunset hesitated for a moment, the pen shaking a little in her hands. I miss you. I miss you so much. I miss the feeling of your coat against mine, I miss the feel of your feathers, I miss knowing that you were watching over me, keeping me safe.

I miss being able to sleep like I did back then, when I was a filly, to sleep without needing to be able to wake up in an instant and be ready to fight because the monsters are coming. I miss that.

I didn't realise until I absorbed all of Cinder's hatred just how tired I am from not being able to sleep like that. But I can't come back.

Why not? Why can't you come home? What is keeping you in that place?


It's your friends, isn't it?

And the Princess of Friendship gets it in one. There are other things that I could tell you are keeping me here, and they would be real things: like what would I do in Equestria now, be a second string Twilight Sparkle? I have a chance to make a difference here in Remnant, to be something, to mean something; you know what I just got offered from Professor Ozpin, a chance to stand in the circle that decides the fate of the world.

But I'm not sure how much any of that would matter if it wasn't for them. They need me, if that doesn't sound too arrogant. I can't just abandon them all to run off home because things here are less than perfect. Ruby, Pyrrha, Blake, Jaune; Rainbow Dash, the other Twilight; they don't have another world to go back to. This is the only world they have, and they have to fight for it; they have no other choice. And so, even though I do have a choice, I'm going to fight for it with them because they're my friends. And honestly, when I say this world isn't so bad, they're a lot of what I'm talking about. Sure, Remnant has grimm and racism, and apparently, it has this creature Salem too, but it's also got my friends in it, which makes it bearable. In fact, I will go further than that and say it makes it pretty good.


Some things change, but friendship is always magic.

Sunset looked at that statement for a second before she wrote back. Uh, yeah, I suppose.

Sunset, there are times when I feel as though my heart is going to burst with worry for you, and there are other times when I feel so proud of how far you've come since leaving Canterlot, and I am honestly not sure which I feel more at this moment.

Thank you, Princess Celestia, but I didn't write to you so you or Twilight could feed my ego. I did it because I need your advice. Both of you, if you've got any.

No offence, Sunset, but where are we supposed to start? With your new magic?

Technically, it's not magic; it's called a semblance, and it She stopped. You know what, never mind, let's just call it magic. I did explain semblances by saying 'they're a lot like cutie marks except you can't see them,' so I've got no one to blame but myself for Twilight having jumped to the association with magic.

Should we talk about that? Or the fact that you absorbed someone's hatred and then someone else's love? Or how about the fact that you've been invited to join a conspiracy that maybe runs the world or something? Or that you're fighting a war against someone who can't be beaten? Couldn't you have spaced all this out a little bit for our sakes? This is a lot to take in.

You think that you have it all dropped on you at once, try being the one it actually happened to.

There was a moment of pause on the other end of the journal.

How do you feel, Little Sunbeam?

Sunset hesitated. How did she feel? After last night, after today, after everything that had happened to her and everything that she had learned, how did she feel?

Better now than I was. Between Cinder's hatred and Ruby's love, I've kind of ended up back at an equilibrium for now. But I have to say, so far, this new power really sucks. Even when I learn to control it – and I will, count on that – I still don't know what good it's going to be. I can learn stuff about other people, I suppose, but only if I can get close enough to touch them and only at the cost of feeling the way that they feel. If Blake hadn't

If Ruby hadn't

If I had gone back to the dorm last night


How much did Princess Luna tell you about my nightmare last night?


Only that it was painful. Other than that, she kept your confidence, as she always does.

I thought I'd hurt them. Her hand shook a little as she made the admission. That was my nightmare. I was hurting them the way that Cinder wants to hurt them.

Those feelings are not yours.

But the actions would have been mine if I had let those feelings control me. And that's the point. I got past Cinder's hate with the help of Blake and Ruby but what if, next time, I can't get through it? What if I do something that isn't me? What good are powers that make me do their bidding instead of the other way around?

Do you know that it will always be that way? How do you know that, once you learn to control the powers, you won't also learn to control the side effects of those powers?

I don't know for sure, but what if it isn't like that?

This is not Equestrian magic, so I fear that Twilight and I can offer you only very limited advice in this regard. All I can tell you is that nobody can force you to use any part of your power, and if you dislike any part of your abilities, if you fear this gift that has been given to you, then you need not make use of it.

I do not pretend that this is the best advice, but it is all that I can offer you in this.


Sunset wrote back quickly. Don't worry, Princess, I don't expect you to solve all of my problems. And honestly, 'don't use my semblance if I don't want to' is far from being bad advice. Once I can control it, I won't have to use it at all if I don't want to, and with Pyrrha's help, I'm sure I'll get a handle on it pretty quickly.

Sunset paused and rubbed between her brows with her free hand. Princess Celestia, Twilight, do you think that people are born evil, or are they simply made evil by the world and times they live in?

You're talking about this Cinder Fall, aren't you?

You are not her, Sunset; you are not this monster that you now oppose.

But I could have been. Isn't that why you threw me out? Isn't that why you expelled me from the palace, because you could see that I was becoming a monster? If I had run into Salem and Cinder had run into Ruby and Pyrrha, then she'd be here, and I'd be the one on the run while I plotted to wreak great havoc and destruction upon all things.

No, you wouldn't.

How can you be so sure?

Because Cinder did run into Pyrrha; you told me that when you explained all the memories you got from her.

Sunset knew what Twilight was referring to at once, but couldn't help but feel stupid that she hadn't made the connection that Twilight had apparently made so quickly and without even the lived experience of this place that Sunset had. Just because she's the Princess of Friendship doesn't mean that she has to be that much better than me at this stuff, does it? Cinder saw Pyrrha once at a party, but

And that only made her hate Pyrrha more, that's what you said.

But I hated Pyrrha too, and for the same reasons.

And then you didn't anymore. You were able to look past your own jealousy and get to know the real Pyrrha. Even then, you were able to start opening your heart to friendship. Cinder had that chance, when she met you in Mistral, when she came to Beacon. She could have gotten to know the real Pyrrha just like you did, but she preferred to stew in her own anger and hate the idea of Pyrrha that she'd built up in her head. That's the difference between the two of you; more than things that Cinder's done and the things that you've done. Because nobody is born evil, and we all have some darkness within us, but what makes the difference more than anything else is that we're willing to change and accept that others can change. That's what separates you and Cinder; that – the fact that you were able to welcome friendship into your life, even more than friendship itself – is what means that you're not a monster, even if she is.

Sunset rested her elbow on the table and her cheek upon her propped-up hand. She toyed with the pen, twirling it between her fingers as it spun before her eyes. She didn't know…but if anyone would react well to what she was about to put down it would be Twilight and Celestia.

Twilight, you know how I feel about Adam.

Yes.

Maybe it makes me a massive hypocrite – in fact, I'm pretty sure it does – but I can't hate Cinder the same way that I hate him. Even though there isn't that much difference between the two of them in terms of what they've done, and in fact, I could even see the logic in the argument that Cinder's worse than Adam. Maybe if things were different, then I'd actually make that argument.

Sunset stopped for a moment, not because she wanted a response from either Twilight or Celestia, but because she was thinking over her next words.

She couldn't have told this to anyone else, not to any of her Remnant friends. Pyrrha, Ruby, or Jaune probably wouldn't have understood; Blake probably would have been actively upset by it; only Twilight and Celestia, safely removed from all of this in Equestria and with no personal connection to anyone involved in any of this but her, would let her lay it out like this without judging her for it.

She hoped they wouldn't judge her for it anyway; she hoped that Celestia, at least, would be able to overlook the logical fallacies involved this once in order to tell her… in order to tell her what she wanted to hear at this moment.

Maybe it's just the fact that I know what Cinder went through and felt what she felt; maybe it's just the fact that I liked Cinder before I knew what she was, while I never liked Adam. I don't know; all I know is that I don't hate her the way that I hate him. I almost

Sunset hesitated again, her words teetering on the edge of falling into an abyss from which there would be no recall. Once she set this down, there could be no taking it back. It would remain as a statement of intent before the princesses, and even if she burned the journal immediately afterward, she wouldn't be able to burn the words from the princesses' minds.

I almost want to help her, even though that sounds stupid.

Stupid, Sunset Shimmer? And why in Equestria or Remnant would you think that? Has this world and its cruelty so corrupted you that the very quality of mercy seems foolish to you now?

The idea that Remnant had in some way corrupted Sunset Shimmer, when it – or at least its inhabitants – had rather proved themselves to be her salvation, caused Sunset to let out a little bark of laughter. No, Princess Celestia, it hasn't corrupted me. The opposite, more like. I suppose

Sunset hesitated, then crossed out the beginning of that sentence. You don't think it sounds stupid at all, do you?

I am afraid it worries me a little that you do. Although not as much as it gladdens me that you wish to help this Cinder Fall in spite of all that she is or has done.

In spite of it? But she's evil. She tried to kill the other Twilight, she hurt Rainbow Dash; she's working for Salem, and while I don't know exactly what she wants, I'm pretty sure it's nothing good. And yet I want to offer her a hand to help her up. Isn't that weak of me?

I prefer to say it shows compassion in you. And compassion should never be seen as a weakness to shamefully hide away from the world, still less from yourself.

I don't even know if Cinder would want my compassion.

That does not mean that it should not be offered. After Twilight and her friends used the Elements of Harmony on Luna, I offered her once again the hoof of friendship that she had refused a thousand years ago. I had no way of knowing that she would not refuse it a second time. But with my sister lying, nearly helpless, on the ground before me, I could do nothing else.

I had no way of knowing that she would accept my love, but I could not have lived with myself after if I had not offered it, whatever her response.


But how did you know that she deserved your mercy, just because you loved her?

No one deserves mercy, Sunset, and yet, everyone does. The quality of mercy is not strained, and it speaks more to the heart of she who offers it than she to whom it is offered. Forgiveness is not always easy, any more than understanding, but that does not mean that they should not be offered freely, no matter how difficult it might be to offer such or how we might feel about the person to whom we offer it.

Sunset frowned. Are we talking about Ozpin now?

I think that you're being a little harsh in your judgement of him.

Sunset's frown deepened as she thought about Professor Ozpin. He uses others as his weapons.

There was a pause, as there was no response from the other side of the book. Sunset waited, wondering if a response would be forthcoming or if she had written too harshly and too hastily; had Celestia decided to let it lie there, to reply with silence in order to best show how she felt about Sunset's words?

She was about to write something else, something to let Celestia know that she hadn't meant anything by it, when words in the slightly cramped script that Sunset recognised as Twilight's telekinetic-writing appeared on the page.

If you could see the look on her face right now, you wouldn't have written that. Or at least I hope you wouldn't.

It's quite alright, Twilight; I can speak for myself. You chide me well and cut me to the quick.

Sunset swallowed. Princess, you must know that was never my intent. I only

Spoke from the heart. There is no shame in that. But do not be too swift to judge Professor Ozpin, still yet condemn him. He merely does as do all who rule, or why do I sit here in the midst of this high-vaulted palace, sending even one who is dear as daughter to me forth to battle the darkness of the world in my stead?

Don't talk like that; you're nothing like him.

Really? In what way are we un-alike? In that I am older than he is by far? In that you have affection for me that you do not feel for him?

Affection? Is that all you call it, affection?

You know that I meant

Yes, I do, I'm sorry if that seemed like an overreaction. I just meant that

Sunset stopped, because she wasn't really at all sure what she had just meant. She had overreacted, and now, she had to find some way to take it back. She hastily scribbled something down before Celestia or Twilight could write something themselves. She was mishandling this, she knew that, but… perhaps it was simply because she didn't want to admit that she was wrong about this, but she wanted to make them understand, to see Ozpin as she saw him, to open their eyes.

Perhaps if I can do it for them, then I can do it for my friends here.

Princess, would you ever ask Twilight to do something that you thought was beyond her abilities?

I always have every confidence in Twilight and her ability to fulfil every challenge that I have set for her with the support of her friends.

With all due respect, that's not what I asked. Would you ever set Twilight a task that you knew, for all your faith in her, that she could not accomplish?

No, of course not.

And it would grieve you if she fell in some endeavour you had set her.

How can you ask something like that?!

Twilight, please, it is a fair question. There was a moment of nothing written, and when Celestia's writing resumed once again, Sunset could feel the weight of each word as Celestia set it down. Yes, it would grieve me sorely to lose Twilight.

I cannot say the same of Professor Ozpin; he might set us a task beyond our abilities – considerable though those abilities are – if only because he had no one else to send. And I do not believe that he would grieve for us if he caused our deaths.

And how would you know if he did or not?

Sunset stared down at the question in a kind of disbelief. How could Celestia even ask something like that? Wasn't it obvious? Because if he felt anything, then he'd show it.

Oh, Sunset; would that it were so.

I do not know your Professor Ozpin as you do, but I know what it is to rule. I know what it is to be elevated so far above those whom you rule that all meaningful connection to their hearts is lost, all understanding of their lives reduced to the abstract; I know what it is like to long to descend to their level and yet to be bound by chains of duty to your lonely sphere. I was fortunate that first you and then Twilight came into my life, touching my heart as – due to my age and my position – few others can. I know what it is like to make decisions touching the lives of thousands, tens of thousands, knowing that even the smallest mistake will bring great misery and maybe worse down upon them.

And I know what it is like to belong to others more than to yourself, to force your emotions down inside of you so that you may be, in the eyes of the world, ever the serene princess that they wish to see. The mask that Professor Ozpin wears in public may not please you, but I have no doubt that it is what he feels is expected of him by those around him.


Sunset stared down at the words written before her, words that were so controlled in script but so heartfelt in emotion. I didn't realise.

I would be a poor princess if you did. It is a great burden that we bear, who make the great and momentous decisions. We forget our triumphs all too swiftly, while our mistakes stay with us forever. I doubt that Professor Ozpin regrets any error as much as I regret those which led to my sister's madness – at least, I hope he does not – but I am sure that he regrets his own mistakes more greatly than he ever considers his successes. You think that poor Ruby's mother died in his service?

I think it likely.

You may be assured that if it is so, then the death of Summer Rose will haunt Ozpin every day of his life, for all that he can never show that fact.

But she's still dead. Even if I'm completely wrong about Professor Ozpin and he has an ocean of tears within that he can never shed, even if he loved Summer Rose like his own daughter, even if he loves us all as you loved me once and love me still, Summer Rose is still dead. As Pyrrha could die, as Ruby could die, as Jaune or Blake or any of them could die, and however much it pains him, they'll still be dead.

Well, that's where you come in, isn't it?

Sunset blinked. What?

I can't imagine what you're signing yourself up for; a war without end? Against an enemy who can't be beaten? I can't conceive of what you're letting yourself in for. But I can understand why you want to stay, and I respect that: you want to help your friends, protect them. If that means keeping them safe in situations where Professor Ozpin has sent you into danger, then isn't that just what you were going to do anyway?

Sunset huffed, unable to deny that Twilight had a point there, but at the same time… at the same time, not really wanting to admit it. Well yes, but

Sunset trailed off, because there wasn't really anything after the 'but' at all. There was just a 'but' and her feeling like a bit of an ass.

Would you really be okay with this if you were me? Even if you knew he wasn't telling you everything?

I'm not Celestia; I don't really have anything to do as a princess yet. I don't rule people, I don't give orders, I just… anyway. But I know what it's like to have friends who I'd do anything for, and I know what it's like to face danger, even if not as often as you do. All I can say is that if Equestria were threatened again, it wouldn't matter whether Celestia asked me to step in or not; if there was something that I could to keep the world safe, then I'd do it, and I know that each and every one of my friends would say the same thing.

Sunset snorted and smiled at the same time. My Twilight said something similar, and my Rainbow Dash something not too far away. Sunset let out a long, slow sigh. Sunset: I'm not sure if I can ever like him.

All I can ask is that you try and understand.

Sunset nodded, for all that Celestia couldn't see it. For you, Princess, I will make the attempt. Any advice for me in my new situation?

Don't underestimate the magic of friendship. Although Salem may seem unbeatable, if you stick together and grow the bond that connects each of your hearts, then who knows what might happen?

And even if all you can do is delay this Salem's progress, remember that you and your friends are here because of the efforts of those who came before you to delay her, and if you fight against evil with all the strength at your command, then the world will survive long enough for you to pass the baton on to those who will come after you. So long as there is always someone willing to take up the torch and keep the fire burning, then no matter how hard it tries, evil will never triumph.

Sunset couldn't help but smile a little. I suppose that I should be satisfied if that is my epitaph. Doesn't stop me wanting something grander, though. Thank you, both of you. I needed this.

Whenever you need me, Sunset, here I am.

Here we are. Maybe, next time, try and pace the onslaught of revelations a little more?

Sunset shook her head. I'll try my best. She closed the book and put it away in her satchel.

She was about to get up from her seat in the library when her scroll began to buzz.

Sunset got it out, opening the device to see that she had an incoming call from a number that she didn't recognise.

Nevertheless, in spite of that – or perhaps a little because of it – she answered.

The face of Cinder Fall appeared on her screen.
 
Scheduling Change
If I had a penny for every time I've said 'when SAPR isn't consuming all of my writing time, I'd like to write a fic in which Cinder and Pyrrha are raised as sisters/write a fic in which Pyrrha may have come back to live or Jaune is deluding himself/finish My Brave Pony: The Heart of the World/reboot my Cinderella fics' I would have a few extra pennies, as they say.

And I've gotten fed up with saying that and I've decided to actually do... some of it, by taking steps to make sure that SAPR isn't consuming all of my writing time. What this means initially is that the number of updates will be dropping to two a week from three, updating Mondays and Fridays, they may drop back again to one update a week after this, but if so it won't be for long. I just need a bit of time to do other things and I hope you all understand.
 
Chapter 88 - Meet Me in Mountain Glenn
Meet Me at Mountain Glenn​



Sunset fought to keep her expression neutral and even, to conceal the surprise that she felt beneath a mask; she doubted that she succeeded, she could feel her ears pricked up on top of her head. They were always a giveaway of how she was really feeling; she'd never learned to control them. They were worse than her tail.

She could, at least, control the tone of her voice, keeping it calm and cool as she said, "Cinder, I wasn't expecting to get a call from you today… or any other day, come to that."

"Well, I had nothing else to do," Cinder said idly. "So I thought that I'd call you up and see how you were doing." Her smile didn't reach her eyes, which meant that Cinder probably meant to look insincere.

"Thanks," Sunset muttered dryly. She looked past Cinder to what she could see behind her: the countryside, verdant green fields and some trees beyond. No identifying markers, but it seemed fair to say that Cinder wasn't in Vale anymore.

"You're welcome," Cinder assured her. "So, how was your night?"

Sunset was silent for a moment. "I thought about you," she said, which was not quite a lie, even if what it implied was not quite truth, either. "Cinder, I… I'm so-"

"Stop," Cinder said, her voice firm and suddenly drained of all pretence, all playfulness. "Stop, before you say something that we will both regret."

Of course. Cinder didn't want pity. Sunset hadn't wanted pity either. Cinder was too proud, too afraid of weakness, to accept the pity even of a friend.

"You're right," Sunset murmured. "I didn't mean to insult you."

"And you didn't," Cinder said, her tone brightening. "You stopped yourself just in time, and you only needed a little reminder to do it. Because you didn't want it either, did you?"

"No," Sunset admitted. "But I've learned-"

"What?" Cinder demanded. "What have you learned? What have your friends taught you?"

"That it's okay to need other people," Sunset ventured. "That it's okay to be vulnerable-"

"No," Cinder declared. "It isn't. They say it is because they have never been truly vulnerable in their lives. Do you think Pyrrha Nikos understands vulnerability? When has she ever been truly vulnerable in her entire life? If you are vulnerable, then you are weak – no, you're worse than weak. Weak people can feign strength if they have the skill, but the vulnerable announce their weakness to the world; they draw jackals to themselves like carrion meat left rotting on the plain. You know that, don't you?"

"I know that I never sought to make myself vulnerable, but the jackals came all the same," Sunset replied.

"That can happen," Cinder allowed. "Sometimes, the greatest pretence of strength convinces no one, or not enough. But it is better to try and frighten them away than simply curl up and sob and wait for the pain, don't you think?"

"What happened to you was not your fault," Sunset told her.

"I know it wasn't my fault, and I know exactly who's fault it was, but that doesn't mean it wasn't my responsibility!" Cinder cried. "I… I could not control the malice in Phoebe's heart, I could not control my father's choice of wife that landed me with such a stepsister, but I could control myself. I could have fought back, I should have fought back, I should have escaped sooner, I should have… I should have done something. She should have done something. Instead she cried and sobbed and was so very vulnerable. That girl was pathetic. I am something stronger, and I will be neither victim nor vulnerable again."

"I know that's what you think," Sunset said softly. "Blake wants me to use what I saw to have Phoebe punished for what she did to you."

Cinder froze. Only her eyes moved, her smouldering eyes like hot coals that seemed to grow hotter and more intense the longer they stared at Sunset from out of the screen. "You told them?" she whispered. "You… you told them?"

"I-"

"You told them?!" Cinder shrieked. "How could you? How dare you?"

"Cinder-"

"You violated my mind!" Cinder yelled. "Don't you understand, you violated me?! I could forgive you for that because I understood that it was not your intent, but this? You… you told them?"

"I wanted them to understand-"

"I don't need them to understand me; certainly, I do not want it!" Cinder snarled. "That is my truth, Sunset, mine and mine alone. I would rather that they think me a monster than look on me with pity or sympathy." She paused, and when she spoke again, her voice had calmed a little. "Who else did you tell, besides Blake?"

"My teammates," Sunset said quietly.

"Pyrrha?" Cinder whispered. "Pyrrha knows."

"She doesn't remember you."

Cinder laughed bitterly. "Of course she doesn't. Why would she? Why would precious princess Pyrrha Nikos remember me? Why would she have had cause to look down-"

"You do her wrong!" Sunset snapped.

"As all of Mistral did me wrong!" Cinder replied. "What is the difference between Pyrrha and I that she should have been feted and admired and lauded as a prodigy while I suffered in darkness, languished in torment, wept and sobbed and prayed for help that never came. I am as bold in heart as she – bolder, I deem – and in battle, I will match my blades against her Miló and wager that I am just as swift as she is, if not more, just as ferocious, every bit the warrior she is, if not more. And yet, she is acclaimed the Evestar of Mistral while I am… nothing."

"Perhaps you should have entered tournaments," Sunset suggested. "You couldn't have done worse than Phoebe."

Cinder stared blankly up at her for a moment, before a slight smirk creased her features. "Perhaps," she conceded, "but as Pyrrha herself has discovered, the crowns of the arena are but baubles, signifying nothing, conveying nothing of power or of true glory. My destiny is for grander and for more real things by far. Do they know my name?"

Sunset shook her head, very slightly. "No," she murmured. "No, I did not tell them that."

Cinder's nod was as slight as the shake of Sunset's head had been a moment before. "Pyrrha, Jaune, Ruby, Blake. Anyone else?"

"No," Sunset replied. "Not yet."

"Not ever," Cinder hissed. "You will not tell anyone else. Not Rainbow Dash, not Twilight Sparkle, not Ironwood or Ozpin or any of them!"

"But Phoebe-"

"I insist upon the sanctity of my past!" Cinder declared. "I insist upon the sanctity of my truth. Mine, mine to give to whom I choose or no one, mine to hold fast and keep secure. If you are my friend, then you will not deny me this."

"I am your friend?" Sunset repeated. "Are we friends?"

"Can it be doubted?" Cinder asked. "For my part, I am in no doubt at all; I am your friend."

"You tried to blow me up!" Sunset cried.

"That wasn't me," Cinder replied hotly.

"Do you deny that you're connected to the White Fang?"

"The White Fang works for me now, yes."

"The White Fang which tried to blow me up," Sunset said. "Which tried to blow Ruby up."

"Not at my command," Cinder insisted. "Sienna Khan does not like the fact that I have assumed command of a chapter of her organisation, so she sent The Purifier to take charge in Vale, deposing Adam and myself. It was he and his cell who attacked you without reference to me, for which I killed him."

Sunset couldn't keep her eyes widening. "You-"

"I don't like to share the things that are mine, Sunset," Cinder said, and Sunset felt a shiver run down her spine as she thought about how she had said the same thing to Jaune once. "Especially with people who break the toys they play with. I made sure he understood that, before he died." She paused. "I must say that I'm a little insulted. A bomb? I would never do that to you."

"You would never hurt me?"

"Oh no, I'll hurt you if you get in my way," Cinder admitted blithely, casually. "But I will meet you in battle that ennobles warriors, face to face, as the heroes of old did. I will face you like Pyrrha facing Juturna before the walls of Mistral."

Sunset snorted. "Bold of you to assume that you're Pyrrha and not the other way around."

Cinder chuckled. "I have no intention of losing, Sunset, not even to you."

"It seems to me that you already have."

"When you face me alone, with no support coming to assist you, it will be a very different story," Cinder promised. The smile died from her face. "Promise me, Sunset."

Sunset frowned. "Promise you that I won't tell anyone else?"

"Ideally, I'd like you to stop other people from talking too, but I recognise that's a little more difficult," Cinder admitted. "Promise me, Sunset. As my friend."

"As your friend," Sunset murmured. "It wasn't a lie then?"

"No," Cinder whispered. "It was all real."

"Apart from your allegiance?"

"I never told you a lie, Sunset; I merely omitted certain facts," Cinder told her. "Please, Sunset, I have a right to ask this."

"I know," Sunset murmured. She closed her eyes for a moment. Perhaps Cinder was telling her what she wanted to hear, but Sunset… she believed it. She believed what Cinder was saying, that it had been real and not simply a deception. She believed… that they were really friends, for all that they now found themselves on opposite sides. "I give you my word," she vowed. "It will not pass my lips again."

"Thank you," Cinder said, in a voice soft and tender. "Thank you, Sunset, I… thank you."

"Although it seems wrong that Phoebe should be able to get away with everything she did to you," Sunset could not help but add.

"I will deal with Phoebe," Cinder promised. "In my own time, in my own place, at my own choosing."

"You mean you'll kill her."

"Can you deny that she deserves it?"

"No," Sunset admitted. "But this isn't the way."

"What isn't?" Cinder asked, sounding genuinely curious.

"This!" Sunset cried. "Revenge, anger, wrath."

"Oh, really," Cinder said, amusement tickling her voice in a gentle undercurrent. "And what should I do instead?"

"Let law and justice take their course?"

"The law?" Cinder repeated incredulously. "What law, the laws of Mistral? The laws that serve the elite, that protect the powerful? Is that the law that I should seek to wield against Lady Kommenos, last of an old and storied line? Fie on such law! There is only one law that will serve me now."

"What law is that?"

"Nature's law!" Cinder proclaimed. "Did you know that, in days long gone in Mistral, the common people, ground down by their lords, created gods they could appeal to against the injustice of men?"

"It doesn't surprise me," Sunset replied. "Having no hope of punishing their oppressors on Remnant, they consoled themselves with the knowledge that the lords would pay for their crimes in the next world."

"No," Cinder insisted. "These gods walked among them, dealing out the justice that men denied, stalking the sinful in the night, bringing death for their offences."

"Sounds like the grimm," Sunset muttered.

"Perhaps that's where it came from," Cinder conceded. "In many works of today, they are called Furies, the name given to them by the aristocrats on whom they were supposed to prey, but the common people called them Eumenides – or Kindly Ones – for they were all whom the herdsman or the farmer could depend on kindness from."

"Do you think that you are kind?" Sunset asked.

"Have I not been kind to you?" Cinder replied. Her lips twitched. "No. I am not kind. I am full of wrath and seek for vengeance; I am a Fury, as they named them, so be it. I am no good nor evil thing, I am Nature's law, and I will punish-"

"Who?" Sunset demanded. "How many innocents will you punish with the guilty?"

"Innocents?" Cinder repeated. "What innocents? Who is innocent in this world so full of cruelty?"

Sunset thought of Skystar Aris and her tears. "I could name a couple," she murmured. "Others could name more. Cinder, please, this isn't the way."

"So you have said, and so once more, I ask," Cinder replied. "What should I do instead? What should I do, instead of raging? What should I do, if I cannot have justice or revenge? What should I do, Sunset Shimmer, to turn aside from this dark path that is not 'the way'?" She waited a moment, and then another. "Answer me!"

Sunset's mouth felt suddenly very dry. She licked her lips but did not speak.

"Say it," Cinder urged. "You know what comes next."

"I'd hope to avoid reaching for cliché-"

"Say it!" Cinder snapped.

Sunset sighed first, before she said, "Keep moving forward."

"'Keep moving forward,'" Cinder repeated snidely. "'Keep moving forward,' yes, that's what they say, isn't it? That's what they tell us. That is the answer to all things: keep moving forward. I should not be angry that I was hurt, that I was punished without cause, that no one would come to my aid when I was in need, no, I must keep moving forward. I cannot scream or yell or bellow in my fury, no, I must keep silent and bite upon my tongue until it bleeds so badly that I drown in my own blood and keep moving forward! I cannot visit upon my tormentor the only justice she will ever know, no, I must bow my head and bend my back for the lash and keep moving forward!"

"Cinder-"

"This is how they control us," Cinder declared. "Don't you see that? You must realise that. In this, the White Fang and I are one; our grievances are different, but we have seen the lie they tell to keep us on our knees. We cannot grow angry at injustice, we cannot fight to improve our condition, we cannot struggle, we cannot feel. Everything that happens, everything that is done to us, we are supposed to put it behind us as soon as it is done, supposed to let it roll off us like water and keep-"

"I don't think that's what it means," Sunset said. "It's about… Cinder, the wrath that rules you is a poison, you must see that."

"Then let me choke on it," Cinder hissed. "Perhaps I am not healthy in my soul, perhaps I am not in a state of perfect 'wellness,' perhaps I am damaged, perhaps I am broken. Well then, let me be ill, let me be cracked, let me be a shattered mirror to hold up to this world, but I will not cease my raging until I have given back to this world its fill and more of bloodshed."

"At what cost?" Sunset demanded. "At what cost to yourself?"

"At any cost!" Cinder snapped. "I will not move. Not one step." She smiled, if only for a moment. "I'm getting bored with talking about me. Let's talk about you, Sunset. Let's talk about you and where your magic comes from."

"It's not as interesting as what you've got going on right now."

"I disagree," Cinder replied. "I was told that only a handful of people could use magic, and you're not one of them."

"Prophets?"

Cinder chuckled. "If you like. As I said, you're not one of them, and your magic is not as theirs is."

"How do you know?" Sunset asked. "Have you seen any other kind of magic before?"

"I have," Cinder affirmed.

"Where?"

"Wouldn't you like to know?"

"Obviously, I would; that's why I asked," Sunset snapped.

"Where does your magic come from, Sunset?" Cinder repeated.

"Why don't you ask Salem, or doesn't she know either?" Sunset replied. She took a certain amount of glee from the look of surprise on Cinder's face and from letting that glee show on hers. "Yeah, that's right, I know who you're working for. So, you can talk all you want about furies and vengeance and how justified you are in your wrath, but you serve an apostle of the God of Darkness, so you have forfeited any claim to righteousness as far as I'm concerned, no matter what was done to you. You have the sympathy you do not want, but I won't let you win."

Cinder was silent a little while. A slow smile spread across her face. "I see the old man has been talking. I must have spooked him quite severely to get him to open his mouth. How much did Ozpin tell you?"

"Everything," Sunset lied.

Cinder laughed. "I know that isn't true. Do you trust him?"

"Do you trust Salem?"

"She has been good to me," Cinder declared. "She could be good to you too, if you wish."

"I will not join you, Cinder," Sunset said. "I won't abandon my friends."

"Aww, and I thought we were friends."

"You know what I mean," Sunset said sharply. "I won't turn my back on them, not even for you."

"I know," Cinder said. "That's what I'm counting on."

"What do you mean?"

"I mean you think that friendship makes you stronger, but it doesn't," Cinder insisted. "It's what will bring you down, in the end. It's why you'll lose."

"Not with Pyrrha and Blake on my side, I won't," Sunset muttered. "What have you got to compare to them? A lot of grimm? You don't even have anyone to compare to Ruby."

"And you've got Jaune Arc, so stop boasting," Cinder growled. "Nobody likes a braggart."

"I thought you did."

Cinder chuckled. "Did Ozpin tell you that Salem can't be killed? Did he tell you that she is immortal, unchanging, eternal as Remnant itself?"

"Of course."

"There's no 'of course' about it; some of his pawns only learn that through bitter experience."

"I'm no one's pawn," Sunset said.

"You are his pawn, Sunset, and you're too smart not to realise that."

"And what are you?" Sunset asked. "Salem's queen?"

"Indeed," Cinder said, her voice filled with pleasure and delight. "The black queen. The strongest piece on the board, the piece that will deliver victory to Salem."

"What kind of queen runs from a pawn?" Sunset demanded. "The kind that hasn't made it across the board yet, maybe? The kind that is still a pawn with pretensions, hoping to be a queen, yearning for it, dreaming of the day, dressing up in readiness… but still just a pawn on the board."

"At least I still have my dreams; what do you dream of, Sunset?" Cinder demanded. "Where have your ambitions gone? What do you want, except to play happy found families with Ruby and Jaune and Pyrrha? Do you think you'll get immortal glory serving Ozpin?"

"I think I will do deeds-"

"Which no one will know of, and no one will remember," Cinder said.

"My fellows and my successors in the circle will remember what I have done."

"For a generation, or two, perhaps," Cinder conceded. "If it lasts that long. Do you remember when we worked on that essay on The Infinite Man?"

"I remember the Infinite Man was immortal, and he still died."

"He was not Salem," Cinder said. "My mistress does not make his mistakes."

Sunset paused for a moment. "Is that how you see yourself? The warrior who wished to fight a god?"

"I am fighting much more than a god," Cinder said. "I am fighting the world. And I will win."

"Because the huntsmen have become complacent?" Sunset asked, remembering something else that she and Cinder had discussed.

"We'll see, won't we?" Cinder mused. "In the meantime… well, in the meantime, I'm going to have to go soon; I'm afraid if you want to continue this conversation, you'll have to come and see me."

Sunset's eyes narrowed. "Come and see you?"

"Mountain Glenn," Cinder said. "A dismal spot, but the rent is very reasonable. I'm staying there with a few… friends."

"And the horde of grimm infesting the area?" Sunset asked.

"What do I have to fear from the grimm?" Cinder asked with a slight chuckle. "Of course, if you don't want to come, if you're afraid… the choice is up to you. But I'll be waiting." She hung up, without waiting for Sunset to say another word.

For a moment, Sunset stared down at her scroll. Then she folded it up and tossed it down onto the table beside her magical journal.

And to think that I was feeling at peace for a moment there. Sunset sat down and leaned back on her chair, looking up at the ceiling above her. The lights caused multi-coloured blotches to appear in her vision, but Sunset was so lost in thought that she barely noticed.

She had done what Celestia would have wanted her to do and held out the hand to Cinder Fall; she just wished that she could know whether Cinder was open to receiving it in any way or if she was using Sunset's compassion against her in some fashion.

Mountain Glenn, the last great Valish colonisation attempt and the scene of the greatest disaster in modern history. The greatest massacre in modern history, rather; all those people had not simply died of an illness or a fire or an earthquake. They had been slaughtered, by the grimm and by the callous indifference of their own government which had left them all to die.

Why would Cinder want to go to such a place? Possibly, it was the elusive White Fang base – that fit with the 'friends' comment – but why would the White Fang base themselves amongst a horde of grimm? How had they not been devoured by now, just like the settlers?

Because Salem spares them; they survive upon her indulgence.

All the same, surely, there were other places they could have hid out. Other places they could have gone.

There had to be a reason. A reason Sunset might find out, if she decided to go.

If she was allowed to go, because of course she didn't have quite the final say in it all: Professor Ozpin might have something to say about it as headmaster, let alone as… whatever else he styled himself in his other role. And then there was her team…

Yes, her team. Her team whom she'd been about to go and meet anyway before Cinder called. She'd have to tell them about it. No point in sitting here turning it over and over in her mind like a puzzle that she couldn't solve.

Of course, she wished that she could solve it, but since she couldn't on her own… she would offer it up to the others and see if they had any better luck.

Sunset picked her scroll up off the table and shoved it into her pocket; she would drop her journal off in the dorm room, and then it would be time to head for the garage.

Time to break the news to Ruby and Jaune about what kind of a world they really lived in.
 
Back
Top