Alright, Bad End ID Sinner swap is a common idea in the fandom--especially after Manager Don--and while I'm not comfortable or willing to write a fanfic where we're barely have half of them(and even then G Corp Greg is a bit too dissappointing of a departure compared to his current life). But how would they each end up going into Limbus and what would their Canto be about?
Wracking my head a bit I've come up that instead of a wish I think each of the Sinners will literally have 'Sinned' in whatever their definition would be and since almost every bad end ID is a snapshot just after or before their choices catch up to them.
NClair is said by Carmen to end up dying pitifully, so he'll be picked up by Limbus after Kromer/NFaust leave him for dead after he tried to bite moew than he can chew and the last thing he sees is the dissappointed glare from Kromer/Nfaust because he failed at being the next The One Who Grips. Could even be that it was just a purge operation against a more powerful augmented force so it wasn't even entirely his fault, just structural over-confidence. Maybe even saved by Demian, realizing how he threw away his potential, and try to
Ahabmael is funnily enough, can share things with her canon self by being shipwrecked. Also inspired by canon Ahab's defeat, my first idea is that the Pequod gets fucking murked by the Crimson Whale and she's madly screaming trying to kill it even all alone, delusionally calling out to her dead crew.... and then she sees the Indigo Elder row himself to it, and one shots(or have an actual fight instead of being withered to uselessness) her obsession. So she's left drifting at sea, muttering to herself as guilt suddenly wracks through her until Limbus picks her up.
Manager Don's most likely will lead the Bloodfiends into a suicidal hunt for Bari, and while likely to kill her too(remember that Bari herself said that if the entire Manchegan fight--whether or not that include Dadqui is a bit ambiguous--her she'd lose) they are relatively bloodstarved and have just helped with filial impety so they're a wreck mentally. However, I'd prefer if we move past this and have Sancho, who's already cynical about the whole Blood thing considering her voicelines, be the head of the Manchegans for the past 200 years and them becoming outcasts also to Bloodfiends due to committing impiety suffer a slow detoriation over the two centuries. This leads her to slowly be unable to even justify killing OG Don and here comes Limbus with a promise that they can help her 'redeem herself'
Wild Hunt unlike all the other ones above, can literally just be Erlking himself, realizing his foolosh decision to commit Multiversal suicide-murder.
No idea what to do with Spicebush(Or maybe even going for RingSang)
Wracking my head a bit I've come up that instead of a wish I think each of the Sinners will literally have 'Sinned' in whatever their definition would be and since almost every bad end ID is a snapshot just after or before their choices catch up to them.
NClair is said by Carmen to end up dying pitifully, so he'll be picked up by Limbus after Kromer/NFaust leave him for dead after he tried to bite moew than he can chew and the last thing he sees is the dissappointed glare from Kromer/Nfaust because he failed at being the next The One Who Grips. Could even be that it was just a purge operation against a more powerful augmented force so it wasn't even entirely his fault, just structural over-confidence. Maybe even saved by Demian, realizing how he threw away his potential, and try to
Ahabmael is funnily enough, can share things with her canon self by being shipwrecked. Also inspired by canon Ahab's defeat, my first idea is that the Pequod gets fucking murked by the Crimson Whale and she's madly screaming trying to kill it even all alone, delusionally calling out to her dead crew.... and then she sees the Indigo Elder row himself to it, and one shots(or have an actual fight instead of being withered to uselessness) her obsession. So she's left drifting at sea, muttering to herself as guilt suddenly wracks through her until Limbus picks her up.
Manager Don's most likely will lead the Bloodfiends into a suicidal hunt for Bari, and while likely to kill her too(remember that Bari herself said that if the entire Manchegan fight--whether or not that include Dadqui is a bit ambiguous--her she'd lose) they are relatively bloodstarved and have just helped with filial impety so they're a wreck mentally. However, I'd prefer if we move past this and have Sancho, who's already cynical about the whole Blood thing considering her voicelines, be the head of the Manchegans for the past 200 years and them becoming outcasts also to Bloodfiends due to committing impiety suffer a slow detoriation over the two centuries. This leads her to slowly be unable to even justify killing OG Don and here comes Limbus with a promise that they can help her 'redeem herself'
Wild Hunt unlike all the other ones above, can literally just be Erlking himself, realizing his foolosh decision to commit Multiversal suicide-murder.
No idea what to do with Spicebush(Or maybe even going for RingSang)
